21 ms·
Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017)
- charliebrownau 6y agoIf you want to find out the REAL BIAS .. Check out - DULUTH MODEL , women globally get a pussy pass and ethnic straight native men are treated guilty before innocence
- wenc 6y agoReally hate to be the overanalyzer here, but just wondering how is physical attractiveness defined in these studies? And was charisma considered as a variable? (I'm just thinking of the courtroom scene in "My Cousin Vinny". Joe Pesci is not conventionally good looking but has a personality that is very persuasive)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 1996 6y agoThere are many scientific studies. For all the variables, check table 1 of the following for "Zero-order Pearson’s correlations between facial appearance and health, with the corresponding p-values and sample sizes": https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5290736/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5290736/ If you want more example for a given variable, for example the effect of adiposity (we know it's quadratic), read one of the original papers: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6308207/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6308207/ All this is well known now, as the first study was about 22 years ago: Perrett, D. I., Lee, K. J., Penton-Voak, I., Rowland, D., Yoshikawa, S., Burt, D. M., … Akamatsu, S. (1998). Effects of sexual dimorphism on facial attractiveness. Nature, 394(6696), 884–887. doi:10.1038/29772
- HenryKissinger 6y agoWhat about tech? Are physically attractive software engineers more likely to receive jobs and promotions than engineers of equivalent skills and experience?
- jpxw 6y agoAlmost certainly yes, unless tech is different from the job market at large. An interesting point on attractiveness in the job market is that people who are extremely unattractive tend to also perform very well. It’s mildly unattractive people who do the worst. My pet theory is extremely unattractive people have to work their asses off to make enough money to be sexually competitive in any way.
- biggestdecision 6y agoExceptions stand out from the crowd, good and bad. If you are a competent dev, nobody cares about that if no one notices you. If people notice you, they'll next notice if you are competent or not.
- afuchs 6y agoThis carries the assumption that competence is something that is purely objective. I find it more likely that what is perceived as competence is still subject to bias.
- sukilot 6y agoHow do you know the perform very well? I'd guess extremely unattractive people don't find sexual mates regardless of wealth.
- typingmonkey 6y agoGood questions, I would like to see some data for that. I assume it is like a reverse bias where someone who looks like garbage is expected to be a good programmer.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mc32 6y agoHonestly I don’t see a profession where people considered attractive in that location would do worse than their unattractive peers, all other things being equal.
- modeless 6y agoWow, a huge effect on sentencing (fine amounts, prison term lengths) but no effect on conviction rate? That seems hard to believe. If true, it means that this bias could be fairly straightforward to correct in theory, though in practice I doubt people would accept the necessity or fairness of such corrections.
- TallGuyShort 6y agoI'm surprised too, but conviction does seem to be the more objective part. Sentencing can vary on the attitude, etc. and is inherently more subjective in practice IMO.
- tristor 6y agoWith the exception of mandatory minimums, sentencing usually is broadly subjective with judges having significant leeway. In contrast, convictions are based on juries who are provided strict instructions on how they must arrive at a verdict. Swaying the judge can you get you lighter sentencing but has no impact on the verdict.
- modeless 6y agoOf course that's how it works in theory. I'm just surprised (and encouraged) to find that it appears to be true in practice.
- happytoexplain 6y agoI'm aware of this distinction, and yet I too am a little surprised, only because I'm so used to seeing people manage to convince themselves against fairly objective truths in the name of following their emotions.
- sukilot 6y agoBut why aren't juries swayed by the lawyers and defendants? I'd guess it's because conviction is binary, so there's very little signal for "guilty vs very guilty", "innocent vs maybe innocent"
- montenegrohugo 6y agoThis is an unfortunate reality in most aspects of life. Physical attractiveness _does_ matter, and has many advantages. Whether in job interviews, relationships (non-romantic ones too!), performance assessments or even the judiciary system: attractive people are seen more favorably.
- YetAnotherNick 6y agoAsk any girl and they will say that people who wants to be friends with them greatly depends on the current attractiveness of her. I think it is less true for males, but nonetheless I feel like there is correlation.
- joncrane 6y agoI think males are subjected to the same appearance biases, but it's not necessarily pure attractiveness. Height and size, for example.
- YetAnotherNick 6y agoI still think the effect of attractiveness on female-female friendship is much much more than male-male friendship. I don't know if there is some known theory or reason for it, but you can see in a group of female friends, the attractiveness level is in similar range more often than not(of course speaking from anecdotes, nothing to prove).
- sukilot 6y agoWomen notice it more because women have much higher day to day variance in current attractiveness, due to makeup and fashion.
- jtsiskin 6y agoI would love to see a double blind study on attractiveness and job interviews, but this would be pretty hard to do (facial prosthetics?) Response rate of identical resumes with different portrait photos attached would be interesting. Can we make attractiveness a protected class?
- echelon 6y agoPhysical bias is inherent in everything. All human interaction. Being "beautiful" or "ugly" can be a pro, it can be a con, it can lead to jealousy. Awkwardness, feeling low self-esteem, confidence, tension, etc. A lot of it is subjective. We're animals, and we often forget that fact. We try to normalize as much as possible to remove these biases (thankfully), but it's completely impossible to remove outright. I'm waiting for the day we have Matrix-like capabilities and can change our avatar on a whim. :)
- amelius 6y agoTotally true, but physical bias should not be a factor in the legal system.
- echelon 6y agoThe only way to completely remove it is to present and rule on cases blind. But even then, a lot depends on judges' and juries' emotional variance throughout the day. Did they have a meal that gave them indigestion? It's imperfect.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- benhoyt 6y agoI was interested to see the section, "A lawyer's physical attractiveness" -- it reminded me of a few years ago when my wife was supporting a friend during a messy divorce by being present in court with her. Both parties' lawyers were women, but the husband (who had a lot more money) had hired a very sharp, very expensive, dressed-to-the-nines Manhattan lawyer. But the wife's lawyer was a relatively inexpensive lawyer from Long Island, comparatively unattractive and frumpily dressed. Obviously it helped that the Manhattan lawyer was very quick on her feet, but my wife commented at the time that "even from the way she was dressed, the Long Island lawyer didn't have a chance". It makes me sad how much of an influence money and appearances are in the justice system. Maybe all the lawyers and jurors should be literally blindfolded, like Lady Justice.
- thegjp210 6y agoI would imagine there's a strong causal link between competence and being "dressed-to-the-nines"/"very sharp". Maybe signals of fitness and fitness here are to an extent the same thing.
- drchickensalad 6y agoI have seen a strong inverse correlation in my (anecdotal and quite brief) professional life :|
- kbenson 6y agoI imagine it's probably fairly dependent on the expectations of the people you interact with. If there's no or very little expectation to dress professionally, those doing so might be doing it because they want to, or are trying to compensate for something else, or are trying to signal some other group (e.g. management). If the expectation of everyone is that you will put effort into it (even if it's because it's self-perpetuating by them making negative assumptions about you if you don't), then it can actually mean people that don't either are trying to make a statement, or can't make that happen, which can signal something all its own.
- solveit 6y ago
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoA huge confounding factor is that socio-economic status and life history can significantly affect attractiveness. For example, in the US at least, a lot of people consider having nice, straight teeth attractive. But getting there requires good dental care and perhaps orthodontics such as braces which can be expensive. Thus, not only are straight teeth attractive, they can be a signal of socio-economic status. Another thing is that life situations alter attractiveness. For example, I have seen people who were attractive once, but after a few years of using meth, they would not be described as attractive by a lot of people. Also, in at least one of the studies, photos of the criminal were used to judge attractiveness. These may have been mugshots. However, how someone looks on mugshots can be significantly different if one has been living on the street for sometime vs living in a wealthy home, and their lawyer arranged their client to turn themselves in to the police.
- mikece 6y agoThis reminds me of a study of cases where judges pre-screened cases looking at the evidence and charges without ever seeing the defendant or demographics about them and predicted the outcome. Their expected verdicts and sentencing was far more uniform and accurate (taking appeals into account) than the in-person trials that followed.
- ekianjo 6y agoThe bias does not exist only in the legal system...
- site-packages1 6y agoNo one made the claim that it did exist only in the legal system. This article is just about bias in the legal system.
- gamegoblin 6y ago"Liking What You See: A Documentary" is an excellent short story by Ted Chiang (these days best known for the story behind the film "Arrival") about this topic. In the story, a highly-targeted brain treatment exists that can make it so that one is unable to perceive physical attractiveness. The story explores the ethics of such a treatment. Here is a pdf, but if you like it, I highly recommend supporting the author and getting both of his collections, "Stories of Your Life and Others" and "Exhalation". You won't regret it. https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:vSPLnvgBqIgJ:https://canvas.wayne.edu/courses/102861/files/3959556/download%3Fdownload_frd%3D1+&cd=7&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us&client=firefox-b-1-d https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:vSPLnv...
- fossuser 6y agoI love this short story, I think it's probably my favorite of his first collection. I think he does a great job of making realistic and compelling arguments for both positions and really exploring the details.
- loosetypes 6y agoThanks for noting this. I enjoyed Exhalation but was not aware of the other collection.
- greggman3 6y agoSomeone should write a story about speakism, judging a message based on how it's said instead of the content of the message. They can posit some AI that extracts the facts from each person's message and removes how it was expressed. This would be see to help people who are not proficient in the local language, people who have accents that are perceived as less intelligent/trustworthy, people who deliver their message in harsh ways (Linus was apparently an example)
- gamegoblin 6y agoThat exact topic actually comes up in the story I linked. SPOILERS BELOW (though knowing doesn't really detract from the story) In the story, one of the central discussions is the debate to make the procedure mandatory for students at a college campus. The procedure is non-invasive and reversible, similar tot an MRI or something. Fearing that this sort of public debate will spread, a cosmetics lobbying firm (who wants to maintain the status quo) publishes a video with a persuasive counter-argument. It is later revealed that the video had been manipulated by software "capable of fine-tuning paralinguistic cues in order to maximize the emotional response evoked in viewers. This dramatically increases the effectiveness of recorded presentations." Some people get a further brain tweak to mitigate this effect.
- aminozuur 6y agoThis reminds me of another study that showed that "90% of CEOs are of above average height." (source below) I also wonder if the WFH revolution will reduce the advantage a tall, handsome guy has over a more productive, short guy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Height_discrimination https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Height_discrimination
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoInterestingly if you account for height discrimination, it causes women to be over-represented in management roles, implying that what's normally ascribed to sex discrimination is really height discrimination and the sex discrimination, if anything, goes the other way. A 5'6" man is less likely to be in management than a 5'6" woman. It also implies that if we solved height discrimination there would be a lot more female CEOs.
- jariel 6y ago" A 5'6" man is less likely to be in management than a 5'6" woman." Maybe a better way to put it, an 'average height female is more likely to be in management than a below-average height male'.
- darkerside 6y agoA different way to put it. Not a better one. Both are valid points to make, but you seem to be missing parent poster's.
- jariel 6y agoI'm accounting for the OP because it's not correct to say that 'height' is what matters, it's relative height, among gender.
- darkerside 6y agoCorrect in what sense? Both statements are borne out by the evidence. You are each choosing to select different representations of those facts as the most salient.
- ve55 6y agoThis reminds me when I once remarked that Elon Musk's various procedures to change his appearance likely were an ROI of >1,000x for him and have probably increased his net worth by billions if not tens of billions of dollars, just by making him seem more attractive. It's unfortunate that appearances are always so important, but it's definitely ingrained deeply into reality. Also see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halo_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halo_effect
- 1996 6y ago> It's unfortunate Saying that is normative, not descriptive, especially if you recognize the phenomenon is real. Anyway, what is it unfortunate? Hackers hack. Finding an investment with a 1,000x ROI is a great hack.
- ve55 6y agoI was referring to the general concept (e.g. think of OP's link), not Musk in particular. Edited for clarification, thanks
- stevewodil 6y agoSteve Jobs wasn't really conventionally attractive (and to my knowledge didn't get any cosmetic surgeries) and still managed to make billions and a massive impact on the world. Additionally I wonder what bald Elon looks like. Jeff Bezos put on some muscle and looks a lot better afterwards despite losing his hair
- elmomle 6y agoI'd beg to differ--I'd say he was maybe _the_ original sexy young tech startup founder, and his appearance was integral to his success as a marketer, leader, etc.. A lot of his early publicity shots are smoldering, e.g.: https://manwithoutqualities.files.wordpress.com/2014/05/steve-jobs-walter-isaacson.jpg https://manwithoutqualities.files.wordpress.com/2014/05/stev... He was also 6'2".
- 6y ago
- ilyagr 6y agoI find it surprising that, according to the article, attractiveness affects the severity of the sentence, but not whether someone is judged innocent or guilty. If the former is true, the latter seems too good to be true. If both are true, it's fascinating. We should then research the mechanism that makes judgements more fair, and see if we can't change the way the sentence is determined to match that.
- t-writescode 6y agoMy bet is that they didn’t test for that.
- jariel 6y agoIt is fascinating because the notion of guilt may be difficult to apprehend. It could be that the investigation of guilt is very carefully pursued, with a lot of rules, a lot of evidence. It could also be that for 'most cases' the outcome is actually fairly straight foward? Also, once someone is found to be 'guilty' - then we are free to 'loathe and pity then'. Whereas guilt/innocence is mostly a black and white affair, subject to objective guidance ... the sentencing may not be, which is to say, it's maybe hard to reference 'what is a little and what is a lot' in any given scenario, so are bias are more likely to run free.
- sukilot 6y agoRemember that by the time a case gets past indictment and plea bargain, almost every case is a conviction. Prosecutors aren't dumb. Variation in conviction is pre trial or even pre arrest, not at trial.
- Hokusai 6y ago> Generally, attractive people are perceived as more intelligent, more socially skilled, more appealing personalities, more moral , more altruistic, more likely to succeed, more hirable as managers, and more competent. I am always astonished by how much we humans mix how moral is someone and how horny that someone makes us. And it works both ways. To tell someone that you are not attracted to them is perceived as a judgement of their value in society and morality. When we actually decide if we are horny for someone in just 1 second from a picture and zero knowledge about that person. Many years ago, I worked for a company that hired the hot one instead of the competent one. And it was amazing to see the twisted justification. But, I believe that the hiring manager was not aware and was convinced that the decision was based on the bogus conclusions. > Some researchers are skeptical that real jurors will have the same biases as the studies in simulated juries. I would expect even worse bias when you do not feel observed and you are not a student that may have knowledge about the concept of biased decisions.
- dlivingston 6y agoBeing a human means that we are constantly at battle between the calm logic of our neocortex and the chaos of our primate origins. It's all too common for people to forget that we are still very much sub-Saharan apes underneath our Calvin Klein suits.
- Aerroon 6y agoThis got me wondering whether there is an opposite effect too. Do people that are very moral appear physically more attractive to us?
- sukilot 6y agoPeople those personality you like become more attractive to you. This is well studied as well as common sense (see every happy marriage).
- BurningFrog 6y agoI believe the science is, unfair as it might be, that more attractive people are, on average, more intelligent, more socially skilled, more etc than the opposite. What we find attractive has formed through eons of evolution, and we retain the preferences of those who managed to leave more descendants. That's not the same as being more intelligent etc, but it's not completely unrelated either.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mindvirus 6y agoTed Chiang (wonderfully talented sci-fi author, wrote the story Arrival was based on) wrote this great short story "Liking What You See: A Documentary" that explores a device that causes people not to see physical attractiveness, by inducing something like prosopagnosia (a medical condition where people can't recognize faces) in the wearers. It's written in short snippets of people arguing for or against device and whether it should be mandatory. It didn't consider the legal system angle though!
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 6y agoPDF: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:vSPLnvgBqIgJ:https://canvas.wayne.edu/courses/102861/files/3959556/download%3Fdownload_frd%3D1+&cd=7&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us&client=firefox-b-1-d https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:vSPLnv...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- MaximumYComb 6y agoThis should be obvious to anyone who isn't gifted with top ~10% looks. Not just in the legal system but in the way the really attractive just have things easier. The person who just smiles and avoids trouble, etc.
- aduitsis 6y agoIt is amazing how complete is the delusion that beauty is goodness. - Leo Tolstoy
- nabla9 6y agoAnother think that affects justice system is blood sugar. Court rulings depend partly on when the judge last had a snack https://www.economist.com/science-and-technology/2011/04/14/i-think-its-time-we-broke-for-lunch https://www.economist.com/science-and-technology/2011/04/14/... The paper: Extraneous factors in judicial decisions www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1018033108
- viburnum 6y agoI think that one was debunked, cases weren't scheduled randomly.
- spyder 6y agoYes: https://www.pnas.org/content/108/42/E833 https://www.pnas.org/content/108/42/E833 https://daniellakens.blogspot.com/2017/07/impossibly-hungry-judges.html https://daniellakens.blogspot.com/2017/07/impossibly-hungry-...
- BbzzbB 6y agoDisclaimer: I've only read the 'Key takeaways' in the article. Should we consider a system where the judge and jury do not see the defendant (and suer if applicable) in the pursuit of objectivity? I think the bias towards attractive people is quite obvious in so many spheres of life. For employment, for the way people treat you as a customer, colleague or day-to-day, for housing, etc. We are actively fighting many -ism in (rational) societies, but "unattractivism" is more taboo. I am not sure what the solution would be at societal level. My feeling is that a societal movement for this inclusion is more unlikely than the other ones, but that would require to acknowledge an implicit scale of attractiveness which is divisive in the first place (as opposed to gender, sexual orientation, ethicity, religion, etc which are either obvious or self-decided). But I could be misreading the situation obviously. The judicial system is different, and with radically impactful consequences, you do not have to eliminate human bias (which probably isn't even possible), you just have to make the decision-maker blind just like peer-reviewed papers. While we can't really hide identity for employment or housing, but a judge and juree do not need to know the name or see the person. To go further, please could be read by impartial narrator which would also take care of emotional bias (should a good actor have a more lenient sentence?). In a way, the justice system should seek ultimate objectivity for the sake of fairness. On the flipside however, it would have a dehumanizing effect on the deciders to have zero connection with the convicted and perhaps lead to an increase in sentencing lengths, which I'm not particularly in favor of.
- joncrane 6y agoI think lawyers are subject to the biases, as well. Defense lawyers probably work harder for attractive people, prosecutors are probably less cutthroat. It's an intractable problem.
- BbzzbB 6y agoBut judge and juree make the final decisions, and the lawyer issues run much deeper in terms of inequalities. I don't think lawyer perception of client attractiveness is the core issue in this case, they'll (naturally) mostly care about their compensation. Prosecutors having a bias plays into the other -isms as well, perhaps a blinding system could be helpful as well, although harder to enforce.
- DC-3 6y agoIt's funny, in a society with an intellectual obsession with recognising and deconstructing systems of privilege, we largely overlook what is possibly the single most powerful inborn advantage one can have - attractiveness. It's rightly considered abhorrent that people could be treated unequally based on their race or gender, but I think that we are on some level accepting of the fact that attractive people have it easier in almost every field of endeavor.
- at_a_remove 6y agoSomeone, I think Sonja Starr, did a series of studies on racial bias on sentencing. Unsurprisingly, it existed. Here's the shocker: the male versus female bias on sentencing was enormous by comparison, using the same methodology. I remember a very left forum in which someone bemoaned that one out of four homeless are women, and that's why we should care about homelessness. Overall, I have begun to look at which privileges are examined and which are ignored as the real three card monte.
- sukilot 6y ago> I remember a very left forum in which someone bemoaned that one out of four homeless are women That sounds like an extreme mischaracterization. The concern about homeless women is the extra suffering the endure at the hands (and other parts) of homeless (and other) men. Much worse is the horrific (and never retracted) Washington Post article fretting that murder at work is a female epidemic because even though men are murdered _more_ often than women at work, men die so much in other ways that murders of men aren't important*. It was absolutely gobsmacking to read the utter disregard for men's lives. "more men are murdered on the job than women. But that's because [450%] more men are killed on the job overall." https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/08/27/murder-is-second-most-likely-way-for-women-to-die-at-work/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/08/27/murde...
- at_a_remove 6y agoNope. That was the thrust of their argument: we should care about the homeless because some of them were women. I've seen it elsewhere, there's even some handy samples on imgur if you search for them.
- refurb 6y agoHmmmm... physical attractiveness is highly subjective. What was the methodology for determining it? I didn't see it in the article. And physical attractiveness can vary by setting. Dressing business professional helps attractiveness in a court room, but if you were dressed like a stripper, you might still be highly attractive, but cause a negative perception in the court room.
- huge87 6y ago> physical attractiveness is highly subjective There's always sociocultural dependencies and personal preferences, but beauty can certainly be quantified. Facial symmetry, body proportions, etc. Of course beauty is in the eye of the beholder, but only up to a point. There are some markers that, when you increase or improve them, objectively increase beauty. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physical_attractiveness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physical_attractiveness
- refurb 6y agoThere are trends in what is considered attractive, but I would imagine you're looking at a +/- 30% variability. Would love to know how these studies measured it.
- WatchDog 6y agoIt's not massively subjective. FTA: > They gathered a group of police officers and students to rate the attractiveness of over 2000 criminals. A scale of 1 - 5 was used and their ratings were mostly similar.
- jariel 6y agoWelcome to the real world? This is in everything. That said, you don't want to be too attractive - rather, nice symmetry, good proportions, healthy looking, but generally not attractive like a model. Height and even girth for men, but only height for women as weight is a negative for them (I'm loathed to find the source for this, sorry). One of the only fields where 'well turned out' folks are naturally viewed with scepticism ironically is software! Either by way of reason (ie nobody who spends that much time looking good has spent enough time on algorithms!) or by jealousy (ie it's unfair that this attractive person is as smart as me!) I think we tend to love 'true geek' flair. It's probably mostly a healthy bias ... Edit: I should add 'nice teeth'. Seriously, 'nice teeth' are the ultimate mark of class in an ostensibly classless society. Like in the UK, the oddly huge variety of accents immediately projects one's origin (and thus class, however totally unfair it seems to be that way, at very least subconsciously), 'perfect teeth' are generally uncommon in nature, more likely it means one's parents could afford the $5K in braces etc. for their kids, which is still not entirely widespread. It's not something I think we think of consciously, but my gosh 'nice teeth' make a really 'nice smile' and it has such a big social impact without us ever really realising it.
- 11thEarlOfMar 6y agoThe article mentions that felonies did not produce a sentencing bias. Perhaps this is because sentencing guidelines for more severe crimes are also more closely defined by the points of the case and judges have less latitude in sentencing. If so, could other forms of bias be mitigated by providing additional guidelines for sentencing in those cases? Do they simply suffer from lack of attention to the guidelines?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 23f23ffe 6y agoHumans are pathetic. All judges should be fired and replaced by an AI system.
- tyingq 6y agoI wonder how much of it is the DA team as opposed to the judge.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tus88 6y agoCorrelation is not causation.
- blueblimp 6y agoThe only section I needed to read was "causation". Essentially, there's no evidence that this is a causal effect of attractiveness on sentencing, and there are many alternative explanations available. So do an RCT please.
- cheerlessbog 6y agoIf you lead a tough life of crime or had an abusive childhood that led you to crime, etc - I would expect it to be hard on your body - and looks. Whenever I see correlation assumed to be causation I like to wonder why they excluded causation in the other direction. In this case, maybe sentencing someone heavily is hard on their looks, and we know once you go to jail you’re likely to reoffend, and that continues, until you have the correlation you observe, perhaps?
- elchief 6y agoIf you want more science of attractiveness, see https://www.reddit.com/r/BlackPillScience/top/?sort=top&t=all https://www.reddit.com/r/BlackPillScience/top/?sort=top&t=al... (warning: might ruin your day)
- rogerdickey 6y agoWonder if this controls for severity of the crime? It could be the case that attractive people don't tend to commit crimes as serious (within each category, ie misdemeanor)
- triggercut 6y agoNot sure how this was done but this needs a 2017 tag. Old paper.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoMakes me think of this SNL sketch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uvgBKO7CGzY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uvgBKO7CGzY
- PlugTunin 6y agoThis got me thinking of the connection to ageism. Sure, a younger person might be hired over an older candidate for reasons that are legitimate: maybe the more senior person wants too much money, or maybe the hiring powers-that-be want to bring in someone who can "grow with the company". But occasionally, I suspect these reasons become convenient excuses to go with the younger, more attractive, reasonably-qualified candidate.
- bambax 6y agoIt's kind of funny that the article, and most, if not all of the comments imply that basing sentencing on physical attractiveness is "unfair". Yet our current society tends to consider it completely fair that success should be a function of IQ. IQ is no less a given than face symmetry. Grit too. Nothing's "fair".
- riwsky 6y agoThe argument isn’t that basing sentencing on physical attractiveness is unfair because attractiveness is randomly distributed (“less a given”), it’s that it’s irrelevant a priori; accordingly your argument misses the point. In contrast: IQ and grit are by definition supposed to measure those traits which are relevant to success; fwiw they are NOT considered completely fair, but that is because of the extent to which many instruments end up measuring “belonging to a certain cultural group” instead of those relevant traits.
- arthens 6y agoThat's a weird comparison. Yes life is unfair and everyone of us is born with some genetic privileges or disadvantages. But IQ and beauty hardly sit on the same bench. IQ has a pretty strong correlation with the quality of the work you can produce. Higher IQ is generally beneficial to the solution of any task. If you are trying to go to Mars or find a vaccine for COVID-19, you probably want very smart people in the room. Hell, you want smart people even if you are building yet another ecommerce website. The same is hardly true for beauty. Excluding beauty-specific jobs, skills and experience should always prevail over look. IQ: unfair to the individual, justified by society well being Beauty: unfair to the individual, no particular advantage for society
- oblio 6y agoThis is under the assumption that that IQ is used for a noble cause :-)
- collegeburner 6y agoGiving an IQ test for a job is illegal.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- andredz 6y agoLooking for something unrelated (retcons), I somehow ended up in this TV Tropes article that contains quite a few examples relevant to this topic: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/BeautyEqualsGoodness https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/BeautyEqualsGood...
- irrational 6y agoA coworker came back from jury duty. She said, “He was totally guilty.” “How do you know?” “Because his lawyer had greasy hair and shifty eyes.” “So he was guilty because his lawyer looked untrustworthy?” “Yes” “Okay...”
- waterhouse 6y ago"Attractive people tend to have better physical health, better mental health, better dating experiences, earn more money, obtain higher career positions, chosen for jobs more often, promoted more often, receive better job evaluations, and chosen as business partners more often, than unattractive people." Could some of those correlate with things relevant in court? Prior criminal history, for example? (That explicitly and deliberately does factor into sentencing, where the main difference is reported.) Are they controlled for? The article doesn't use the word "control" or "history". I only see a couple of studies about mock juries, where the subjects are merely given a photograph and a packet to read, which does control for everything (except for details that the subject's imagination is left to fill in).
- dang 6y agoIf curious see also this similar thread from 3 weeks ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23821125 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23821125
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- collegeburner 6y agoWow, after all the professional, personal, and legal information that's been related here, I feel pretty badly. Is it really that important to go get plastic surgery? I exercise and take care of myself, but have an exceptionally asymmetric face, so might it improve my prospects personally and professionally?
- misanthropian00 6y agoUnfortunately plastic surgery cannot usually fix things like asymmetry. Surgery is really very primitive and people like to overestimate its power. It rarely ever makes a person more attractive in reality.
- jdm2212 6y agoIgnore the studies and anecdata. Attractiveness is substantially a reflection of personality, so it's hard to disentangle them in studies and anecdotes. Being unattractive can be superficial, or point to deeper issues. In general it'll hold you back to the degree that it points to deeper issues, because people mostly won't care if your face is a bit asymmetrical if they can depend on you and you are pleasant to be with.
- kingkawn 6y agoIt’s wack as hell to go along with this kind of judgment and then just shrug and say “that’s how it is!”
- sytelus 6y agoThese are eye opening results: minimum 2X to almost 4X increase in fine for unattractive people! In a way attractiveness plays out everywhere starting from college admissions to careers to finding mate. We don't want to admit it but then we are fighting against biology and evolution. I guess it doesn't matter what other attributes one has in long run. Evolution doesn't care anything but propagating the best genes which apparently attractiveness is a statistical proxy. Another irony: Virtually every object of value in modern world is made by scientists and engineers but guess who is million times more worshiped, popular, paid, followed, protected and cared about: actors! Most actors simply act out a scene someone else designed, someone else shot, someone else wrote, someone else directed. None of the behind the scene people matter much or even get fraction of a credit because they are often not as attractive as these puppets to put on the screen. That's humanity for you in its raw form.
- cyberdrunk 6y ago> Most actors simply act out a scene someone else designed, someone else shot, someone else wrote, someone else directed. I can imagine myself designing, writing and shooting a scene, but I can't imagine acting it well (let's say on Antony Hopkins level). I have maybe the 5-10% of the expression range necessary for that. It's a talent and a skill, possibly more rare than the ones which "just" require lots of brains and an eye for aesthetics.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Virtually every object of value in modern world is made by scientists and engineers but guess who is million times more worshiped, popular, paid, followed, protected and cared about: actors! Not really. It just seems that way because of the a tiny, highly visible slice at the top of the field. The 2018 median pay for an actor was $20.43/hr, there were only 64,500 of them working in 2018, and there's about 1% projected 10 year growth in the field. https://www.bls.gov/ooh/entertainment-and-sports/mobile/actors.htm https://www.bls.gov/ooh/entertainment-and-sports/mobile/acto... The median pay for a software developer in 2018 was $50.77/hr, there's almost 1.4 million of them, and there's 21% projected 10 year growth in the field. https://www.bls.gov/ooh/computer-and-information-technology/mobile/software-developers.htm https://www.bls.gov/ooh/computer-and-information-technology/... > None of the behind the scene people matter much or even get fraction of a credit because they are often not as attractive as these puppets to put on the screen. Directors, Producers, Screenwriters, and Composers, among others, often are as prominently, or nearly so, credited as stars, paid quite well, and quite well known; definitely moreso than non-star actors. And star actors very often have a much bigger impact on productions than just presenting what others have written, actively shaping their characters and often other parts of the production.
- keiferski 6y ago“Clothes make the man. Naked people have little or no influence on society.“ - Mark Twain Mostly a joke, but also completely true. We are physical beings in a visual world. The way you present yourself matters.
- stevebmark 6y agoEventually we'll have an equality movement for the very real effects attractiveness / unattractiveness have on things like job performance. It will be a more subtle equality movement than civil rights, gay rights, trans rights, but it will happen.
- hedberg10 6y agoAlready happened. Kurt Vonnegut described it in Harrison Bergeron.
- miki123211 6y agoMy opinions are quite controversial, but I think that for most jobs, interviews should be conducted fully in text, through a platform that doesn't reveal anything about the interviewed. This is the only way to combat this kind of bias in recruitment, where it exists too. Teaching people not to discriminate is just the beginning. Changing the system to make discrimination impossible is much, much more important.
- TomMarius 6y agoHow do you see cultural match and the person's mentality that way? Many brilliant engineers simply wouldn't fit into my team and would be a net negative. Most of the time it's obvious to the person being interviewed too, but how would we know if we don't talk about non-technical things or don't even see each other or talk at all?
- mwcampbell 6y agoWould it help if the work itself were also done fully remotely using only text? I'm with miki123211 on this.
- TomMarius 6y agoHowever it is not, at least not if we are talking about (agile) software engineering and related disciplines that other team members do.
- bloak 6y agoSo many people in this discussion seem to think that "attractiveness" is a scalar value. This makes no sense to me. Quite apart from this being highly subjective (different people having different opinions) I couldn't even state my own opinion on something so vague. If you asked me which of two people is most "attractive", I wouldn't know what's meant. If you asked me which looks more intelligent, or more friendly, or more trustworthy, or more healthy, or more fun, I could perhaps give some kind of answer, but, seriously, what is "attractive" supposed to mean?
- misanthropian00 6y agoIt sounds like you have a kind of impairment in this regard. Most of us don't need anyone else to define 'attractive' for us. It is something we all feel when we see a face that represents certain ideals of aesthetics. For me it is a small round flat doll-like face with large widely spaced and elongated and ideally slightly upturned eyes close to the edge of her face. When a girl has a face like that I feel a kind automatic love for her. I think that is what it really is: a kind of aesthetically based instant love. Every time you find someone attractive it is a variant of love at first sight differing only in degree.
- notSupplied 6y agoIf you haven't read "Liking What You See", a short story by Ted Chiang, do yourself a favor and check it out. It is one of the most interesting works of fiction focused entirely on this subject. It is part of the book "Stories of Your Life and Others".