13 ms·
Wakaresaseya: private agents hired to end relationships
- watwut 6y agoWhen sociopaths enter relationships, but are two shy to end them.
- djohnston 6y agothis reminds me of something i recently read about the parents of the first Qin emperor, who were embroiled in a similar scandal, albeit without passionate murder.
- grumpitron 6y agoI recently listened to a series of podcasts where this was mentioned on Our Fake History, though my recollection was that he seemed to think the story's accuracy was questionable.
- djohnston 6y agointeresting, i didn't dig too deep, but it seems totally plausible that a 2200 y.o. story of sexual intrigue could be fabricated
- vstm 6y agoThat's nothing. I can sabotage my relationships before they even start.
- sergiomattei 6y agoThis comment made my morning.
- mcraiha 6y agoHave you given your TED talk already?
- ineedasername 6y agoGiving a TED talk, replete with vague and over-simplified solutions to complex problems all with a palpable sense of smug superiority... that by itself can be enough to sabotage a relationship: "Oh no, no no no-- I will absolutely break up with you if you give a TED talk about how a carbon tax is the obviously perfect solution to racial injustice."
- abnercoimbre 6y agoIt really makes one wonder what is said between TED talk staff and the presenter behind the curtain. Or did the first presenter ever simply did it one way and now everyone copies it?
- KONAir 6y agoHe was going to but it got cancelled by a series of unfortunate events.
- csomar 6y agoHe sabotaged his own TED talk. Guy is specialized in this and knows what he is doing.
- peteretep 6y agoIt’s a TEDx talk but the social media photos (and captions) all crop out the x
- raxxorrax 6y agoMarriage counseling is an honest profession.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y ago> Marriage counseling is an honest profession. I'm genuinely curious how many of these relationships could actually be salvaged by good counseling, once they've reached the point where someone is willing to hire a saboteur.
- vmception 6y ago> once they've reached the point where someone is willing to hire a saboteur they probably haven't reached that point, compared to other societies, their law just makes evidence a requirement if the divorce is contested. so the incentives are misaligned for different behavior.
- mratsim 6y agoTalking face-to-face is contrary to Japanese culture.
- raxxorrax 6y agoI wouldn't believe every stereotype you hear about a culture. For instance, I always thought that Canadians are nice but an American saved me from this prejudice and told me that they are just polite. Trying to prevent people from making the same mistake is what real nicety is.
- itronitron 6y agocan confirm
- Razengan 6y agoNo, it’s not.
- S_A_P 6y agoCan someone give more context here? Is there some burden of proof required to divorce in Japan? From the article it looks like most are attached to private detective agencies as well. Is this because without evidence of infidelity you have to pay alimony/some other spousal support? Or is there no equivalent of 'we just don't like each other anymore'?
- sersi 6y agoIn Japan, divorce is relatively easy in case of mutual consent but in case when the spouse doesn't want to divorce it quickly becomes very complicated... The first step is mediation with a court appointed mediator which can take a long time... If mediation doesn't work, the next step is to go to court in which case having some dirt on the spouse that doesn't want to divorce is crucial in influencing the judge deciding the case.
- sukilot 6y agoUnless you have children, right?
- ArekDymalski 6y agoFrom the article: "Isohata’s husband used these photographs as evidence for a divorce. (Such evidence is needed when a Japanese divorce is contested.)"
- laurieg 6y agoIf both parties agree then divorce is very simple. However, if one party refuses things can be drawn out for years (an old boss of mine came into the office literally singing and dancing after the divorce was finalised). Bare in mind that Japan has no legal joint custody. Also, culturally it's normal for one parent to have zero contact with children after divorce. Here is an account of the divorce process[1]. I do not know if all the information is still relevant today. [1]http://www.debito.org/thedivorce.html http://www.debito.org/thedivorce.html
- stupidcar 6y agoThe UK too has only just introduced the concept of "no-fault divorce": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-fault_divorce#United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-fault_divorce#United_Kingdo... Previously couples had to apportion blame for the marriage breakdown, which encouraged it to be an adversarial and rancorous process.
- keiferski 6y agoIronically this industry seems to only have come under scrutiny because the hired gun wasn't professional enough and/or took his job far too seriously, depending on your perspective. In 2010, Takeshi Kuwabara was sentenced for the murder of his lover, Rie Isohata. What captured the world’s imagination was not the tragedy itself, but the fact that Kuwabara was a wakaresaseya – a professional hired by Isohata’s husband to break up their marriage. Once Isohata learned of the deception, she angrily attempted to break off the relationship with Kuwabara. Unwilling to let her go, he strangled her with a piece of string. The following year, he was sentenced to 15 years in prison. There is definitely a dark rom-com movie script to be made from this story. Edit: I just remembered, there is an old Italian film which has a similar plot. It's called Divorce, Italian Style and is about a man who wants to divorce his wife, but can't due to the local laws. He spends the movie trying to get his wife to take a lover, so that he can shoot her "in a rage of jealousy" and get a reduced sentence for manslaughter. It's pretty funny, I highly recommend it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Divorce_Italian_Style https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Divorce_Italian_Style
- nolok 6y agoI can't help but think that at the other end of that spectrum lies the british infiltrated cop that once he got his mark arrested left the girl he was with undercover and the kid they had together, without any support, and with his former associates fully knowing, with the british court saying she didn't deserve any child support or anything. I don't know where the line is or how it should be done, but I know as much as I know anything that it's not the proper solution if it ends with "and some innocent bystander live was (temporarily) ruined in the process". (I used that exemple because it's the one I always remember as the court case marked my mind, but I'm sure most countries have an equivalent)
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoWonder if the companies are sometimes hired by a third party wanting to break up someone else's marriage or would that be outside the realm of possibility in Japanese culture?
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoApparently in the US there's a couple of companies that will hire an attractive woman to take you to a bar, get you drunk and attempt to get you to take them home in your car so you get a DUI and makes it easier for divorces not to go your way. If you're getting divorced, wait until it finalizes no matter how hot she is.
- ineedasername 6y agoI wonder how many marriages have been saved by Uber.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoIn this example, it would be an attractive woman approaching you at a bar after the paperwork is filed. Once you have the DUI on your record, you're now too dangerous to take care of our kids...
- greiskul 6y agoWell, I know this might be a bit extreme for Americans, but one of the easiest ways to prevent DUI's is: don't drive your car to a bar?
- ineedasername 6y agoI understand the concept, I meant the target could avoid the DUI by calling an Uber instead of driving their own car.
- sukilot 6y agoIn many states you can get a legal separation before you divorce.
- Hitton 6y agoSimilar services exist even in Europe. I remember reading about it some time ago and managed to find it. https://www.alibinamieru.sk/ https://www.alibinamieru.sk/ They provide multiple of services including: fake alibi for cheaters, testing fidelity of your partner, breaking up relationship by seducing someone (either lover of cheating partner when you want to end their relationship or directly the partner when for instance parents of the second partner want to prove that the chosen one is no good etc.) It's hard to say how popular the service really is though.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y ago> It's hard to say how popular the service really is though. If it was popular, wouldn't they try to hide how popular it is? ;)
- xutopia 6y agoFor the life of me I would think that this should be illegal somehow.
- Sebb767 6y agoWhy? As far as I can see, they don't force anything on anyone. One could also make the argument that if a partner falls for this (or hires them), the relationship is already on rocky ground, so they don't do much harm either.
- king07828 6y agoOne can argue that the conduct is detrimental to the victim's interests and that the conduct constitutes common law fraud [1] because (1) the saboteur tells the victim "I like you", (2) the saboteur knows this is false or reckless, (3) the saboteur intends for the victim to leave the victim's current relationship, and (4) the victim left his or her current relationship. I am not your lawyer. This is not legal advice. If your partner is actively sabotaging your relationship, it may not be a good idea to stay with that person. [1] in Texas: In order to prove fraud, a plaintiff must show that (1) the defendant made a material representation that was false, (2) the defendant knew the representation was false or made it recklessly as a positive assertion without any knowledge of its truth, (3) the defendant intended to induce the plaintiff to act upon the representation, and (4) the plaintiff actually and justifiably relied on the representation, which caused the injury. Ernst & Young, L.L.P. v. Pac. Mut. Life Ins. Co., 51 S.W.3d 573, 577 (Tex. 2001).
- Sebb767 6y agoI'd compare it more to the law of entrapment: You need to show that you did the action because it was an officer convincing you; the fact that you were convinced/talked into doing something is not enough. Which seems parallel to our case: The spouse in question was open to cheating; the fact that it was a detective (or fraudster) on the other side seems irrelevant. But I see your point, it feels fraudulent since you prove one side is bad by doing something (possibly) equally as bad, but only one thing is regarded in court. Though it will probably look bad if it's found out. > I am not your lawyer. This is not legal advice. Me neither, but I think it's an interesting topic. > If your partner is actively sabotaging your relationship, it may not be a good idea to stay with that person. Of course. But that was the point all along, I guess ;)
- xyst 6y agoTIL: murder in Japan is not a life sentence
- kerkeslager 6y agoIt's frequently not a life sentence in the US, and a "life sentence" in the US is actually not a life sentence, as people can get out on parole in under two decades (exact time varies by jurisdiction).
- zelos 6y agoIt is a "life sentence" really, as the offender is only released on parole and is on licence for the rest of their life, so can be required to abide by license conditions or be recalled to prison at any point. (assuming US law is similar to the UK)
- kerkeslager 6y agoThat's a semantic argument. I think when most people hear "life sentence" they think the person will spend the rest of their life behind bars, so the phrase "life sentence" doesn't clearly communicate what actually happens.
- christiansakai 6y agoRead about Junko Furuta murder case, and you'll get even more mad.
- sneak 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Junko_Furuta https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Junko_Furuta
- 14 6y agoI started reading and could not finish. This is a horrible story. It will hurt your mind for a long time to come. Please read with caution as the story is very graphic in the horrible things the girl suffered
- ff2f332 6y agoCarnivorous plant produces very nice smell for insects. Once insect lands on the plaint, it cannot move away and will be eaten by the plaint. Relationships are working the same way. Women will take away everything you have or earns and you will end up homeless & broken on the street.
- nikol_w 6y agoThis is an article describing exactly what (a certain type of) private detectives do in Japan, Europe, North America, and other places, and using a word in a different language, 'wakaresaseya' in order to depict it as a strange and novel 'Japanese phenomenon'.
- bluedevil2k 6y agoI don't think there's anything like this in the United States. In Europe, I have no idea. There's private investigators, but nothing of the sort of forming a months-long flirtation/affair in preparation of divorce. But there article is very fair...there are LOTS of strange and novel Japanese phenomenon that fascinates people in other countries. Even in this article, they describe hiring actors to appear as family members at events. That certainly doesn't exist in the United States.
- DarkWiiPlayer 6y agoIronically, I would have found it weirder if it hadn't been Japan. There's lots of japanese constructs that seem really weird to us on the outside (Hell, there's an anime airing right now about renting a girlfriend), so it's easy to get used to it as Japanese culture just working a bit differently.
- elliekelly 6y agoI can’t believe how little it costs for all the effort involved. Four people and four months to sabotage a relationship for <$15,000?
- bluedevil2k 6y agoThis was exactly my reaction as well. They tease the price by saying it's only for rich people and then give us a price that seems far too cheap for the effort involved, and affordable by most middle-class families in Japan. In the United States I can't help but think that would cost $100k or more.
- sukilot 6y agoIt's not 4 months of full time work. It can be one email per day.
- giaour 6y agoThere’s a great Taika Waititi movie about a relationship sabotage agency in New Zealand: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt6728096/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt6728096/
- castevictim 6y agoThis is quite common in India, but the twist being they are not hired by those in relationship but their parents! Usually due to caste differences. Here is an interview of one such agency by Niel Patel in his Indian startup show, where she(founder) proudly claims to end relationships on behalf of clients(parents). If you thought that was awful, wait till she tells at the end 'There are no regulations for Private Investigative Agencies in India' ! (Neil just laughs it off). [0]https://www.indianstartupshow.com/episodes/akriti https://www.indianstartupshow.com/episodes/akriti
- zw123456 6y agoAnother really good way to ruin a relationship is to join a start up :)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jccc 6y agoKinda seems like the real purpose of this saboteur service isn't so much to engineer the end of your relationship so you don't have to, or just to acquire legal proof so the law will let you two divorce, but rather to engineer the end in such a way that it financially advantages the employer of the saboteur. She cheated on me, so I get to keep the house. The headline and framing of the story hides the greed/selfishness/manipulation/exploitation. (Of course, the bigger part of the actual event is the murder, but the story minimizes that too.)
- toxik 6y agoThat is a good point, the end game is maximizing the separation cash out. Not entirely unlike bosses who give employees they want to fire impossible tasks until they quit of their own volition.
- SkyBelow 6y agoSeems similar to a police sting operation. Providing the opportunity to commit a crime but not forcing them to, so when they do it is used against them. In this case it isn't an actual crime, but an action that is disadvantageous in divorce. But given the comparison, if someone is okay with police stings should they also be okay with this?
- philwelch 6y agoIn cultures without no-fault divorce, manufacturing fault like this is sometimes necessary for the divorce to happen at all, regardless of the eventual settlements.
- flexie 6y agoThis business is only relevant due to tragic laws making divorce difficult. In Denmark, you can divorce by electronic signature and without any reason. If both spouses agree, they can be divorced immediately. Immediate divorce is also possible in case of - adultery, - two year physical separation due to disagreements violence, - sexual assault, - bigamy, - child abduction. Otherwise, a 6 months separation period is needed. In most divorce cases, no law suits are needed.
- xxpor 6y ago>If both spouses agree, they can be divorced immediately. Does this include an agreement on alimony/child support/custody? Or are there automatic arrangements for that in Denmark? That seems to be where things get nasty in the US for the most part. It's not the literal divorce but the second order effects due to it.
- amscanne 6y agoThe article indicates that most cases are actually relating to ending an affair, rather than initiating a divorce. E.g. someone is hired to seduce a husband’s mistress, and cause the mistress in turn to end the affair. Seems like a crazy amount of deception and effort to avoid confrontation, but perhaps that also hints at the root cause? The article also notes that the marriage can’t be terminated easily if contested, which suggests to me that it can also be easily terminated if both parties agree.
- jessriedel 6y ago> If both spouses agree, they can be divorced immediately. Immediate divorce is also possible in case of...adultery, According to the article, that is also the case in Japan. It is only contested divorces that require proof of adultery. Now, it may further be the case that contested divorces without something like adultery are easier in Denmark, and that might be the better system, but avoiding outlier cases like this hardly seems like the reason.
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoI'm baffled that marriage laws are so weird, obtuse, and outdated, pretty much in most of the world. In particular, but not limited to, property and wealth subdivision.
- petters 6y ago> Fees can go as high as 20 million yen (£145,000) if a client is a politician or a celebrity, requiring the highest level of secrecy. Still seems very cheap?
- burtonator 6y ago> Meanwhile, a colleague of Kuwabara’s photographed them in a love hotel, and Isohata’s husband used these photographs as evidence for a divorce. (Such evidence is needed when a Japanese divorce is contested.) unintended consequences... policy decisions have real world implications. Marriage should not be a slave contract.
- dhosek 6y agoThe classic Astaire-Rogers film, The Gay Divorcee, turns on a not-that-different practice that was common in England in order to get a divorce where a professional co-respondent would be hired to enable a divorce on the grounds of adultery. I turned up this article on non-fictional uses of co-respondents: http://www.queensilver.org/gstory2.htm http://www.queensilver.org/gstory2.htm
- drummer 6y ago> The continuing existence of the wakaresaseya industry suggests that money and deception may be uncomfortably threaded into relationships more often than people recognise Really? They needed a wakaresaseya industry to know that? Isn't it obvious that in most societies around the world a man can't get pussy unless he has money and can lie? Don't 99% of women lie about their appearance with fake nails, hair etc?
- dest 6y agoFrench movie on a similar topic: L'Arnacœur https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1465487/?ref_=nm_flmg_act_20 https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1465487/?ref_=nm_flmg_act_20
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 01100011 6y agoHow about a service which will marry an ex spouse? I'd gladly pay $40,000 to anyone who successfully marries my ex and terminates my alimony payments.
- blaser-waffle 6y agoBut then how will they get out of alimony later? Hire another one?
- phendrenad2 6y agoWow, how much are you paying per year?
- 01100011 6y agoAbout $40k. That's based on my previous income of about $146k/year. I took a high pressure job in the valley and now make double that, but my initial agreement expires in January and I've been told I will potentially pay more since I make more money. Granted, the alimony is tax deductible, but it still removes something like $2k from my budget after taxes every month. This is for a long term CA marriage with no kids and a wife with a history of working.
- boojums 6y ago> and I've been told I will potentially pay more since I make more money. On the surface this strikes me as insane, but from the perspective of the opposite situation it sort of makes sense (e.g. if the poster's income fell it makes sense they would pay less in alimony). It might be a bias against alimony in general, but it seems strange that alimony would increase post-divorce.
- grillvogel 6y agosounds like a sidequest from the Yakuza video games
- known 6y agoIt's all about money + hegemony