11 ms·
Thoughts about the difference between European and American H/W and S/W design
- Causality1 6y agoI think the oversight in this article is the survivor bias regarding American designs. There were plenty of those fast, efficient designs from American developers but they too died in the avalanche of big-team giants.
- willvarfar 6y agoI don't doubt you, I just don't know of many, so some examples please?
- Causality1 6y agoWell, one that springs to mind for me is Palm. Their devices punched well above their weight when it came to performance vs their Windows Mobile PDA competitors with better battery life but couldn't stand up to the corporate demand for buying things with the Microsoft sticker on them. Their later smartphone products were in the same position when Apple debuted the iPhone and was able to bring boatloads of cash from their ipod successes to bear on pushing both Palm and Windows Mobile out of the smartphone market entirely.
- magicalhippo 6y agoI also think it severely underestimates the advantage of having such a large internal market. Having access to a large internal market allows you to grow to a fairly large size while still only serving that internal market. Then, when you want to expand abroad, you're likely in a much better financial position to take on the expenses of dealing with lots various local laws and regulations.
- DoingIsLearning 6y ago> having such a large internal market. ... (I would add to your statement) with a large amount of median disposable income. Adding to this, a large numbers of consumers who have access to consumer credit and are far less reluctant to purchase on credit than other nations. A lot of countries have a large internal market but not all of them actually have the purchase power or the inclination to spend on novel non-established products as much as the US market.
- magicalhippo 6y agoVery good point, thanks. I had that as an implicit assumption.
- dekervin 6y ago"the inclination to spend on novel non-established products" is the key competitive advantage of the american market. Everything else are just compounding factors.
- TulliusCicero 6y ago> or the inclination to spend on novel non-established products as much as the US market. Moving from the west coast to Germany was definitely a fair amount of culture shock there. Americans love trying out shiny new things that are weird or different, my experience has been that Germans are much more cool to that kind of thing. They're simply less interested in novelty for novelty's sake.
- mschuster91 6y ago> And I think a big reason is that Europe was poorer, so product development was all about efficiency, cost-reduction, high performance and sparing use of resources. The result was very fast, efficient products. While Europe is poorer, the issue is not a focus on fast/efficient products... rather that US companies have access to incredible amounts of "dumb money" via pension funds that they can use to simply flatten (or buy up) any European competition. Either via outright price dumping (Uber), via lobbying efforts (Microsoft), by marketing (Apple) or by having access to way more R&D resources than European companies (Apple again).
- theandrewbailey 6y agoThis seems to be a list of things that Europe used to have. Here's some counterpoints that you might be thinking of: The most popular form of UNIX (Linux) got started in Finland. The best selling CPUs (ARM) are ultimately of British origin. The Web was created by a Brit at CERN (Switzerland). Raspberry Pis are quite popular, and British. (Also has an ARM CPU, and often runs Linux, sometimes with a web server. Nifty!)
- Kuinox 6y agoThe web ? We had minitel in France.
- twic 6y agoAnd the first microcomputer: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micral https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micral I only found out about this because its inventor, André Truong, studied at EFREI at around the same time as Pol Pot. Fortunately, Truong was a much better engineer, and did something more constructive with his life.
- msla 6y agoBut not the first personal computer, which was American: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kenbak-1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kenbak-1
- msla 6y agoMinitel wasn't really the same kind of thing as the Internet or the web.
- esperent 6y agoThis article has a huge cultural blind spot. What about Asia? Probably most of the hardware in your phone was designed in Asia. Arm, originally from the UK, is now Japanese owned. ATI is Canadian, which also doesn't get a mention. When it comes to programming languages, C++ and C# were both created by Danes, although they were working in the US at the time. Presumably because that's where the money was. Does that mean the US gets to claim these languages? Personally, I think it just invalidates the whole argument of what is American and what is European. Creation of modern tech is a global effort. If you look inside any modern laptop or smartphone you'll find that most it was manufactured in Asia, and that the software and hardware design was split between many different countries and continents, and that the actual people doing the work are even more diverse.
- creddit 6y ago> Probably most of the hardware in your phone was designed in Asia It doesn’t appear to be true at all for Apple phones: https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/iPhone+11+Pro+Max+Teardown/126000 https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/iPhone+11+Pro+Max+Teardown/1...
- gambiting 6y agoApple devices are a tiny minority on the broader scale. https://www.counterpointresearch.com/global-smartphone-share/ https://www.counterpointresearch.com/global-smartphone-share...
- creddit 6y agoIs it even true for the Asian designed phones that the majority of the hardware is designed in Asia? https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Samsung+Galaxy+S20+Ultra+Teardown/131607 https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Samsung+Galaxy+S20+Ultra+Tea... LOTS of Qualcomm ICs as well as Skyworks, Qorvo and Maxim which are all US companies.
- shard 6y agoIf you consider display/battery/cameras/mechanicals, then by weight/volume/cost, most of the phone is designed in Asia.
- oaiey 6y agoAlso not to forget: American business culture is focused on achieving your yearly bonus, means achieving your goals, means delivering the product you promised. Many European places are focused on quality and feature richness. That produces delays and budget overruns. As a consequence, American products are often first to market, get the attention and the money. And often, they just buy the competition who has not made it (European or not). (and this is not only true for companies but also for managers within the same multi-national company).
- lewis1028282 6y agoI’ve never seen such an incorrect statement in my life — have you ever been to Europe?
- mikorym 6y ago> Ada, the fast type-safe compiled language (French)? Largely dead in the market. Isn't this language used in the Eurofighter Typhoon?
- sgerenser 6y agoI thought Ada was still fairly widely used in aviation software in general. Perhaps not in new designs?
- non-entity 6y agoFrom what I've seen in job descriptions for various defense related positions Ada seems to be written in as a small "nice to have" and makes me imagine most of it is maintenance or being replaced (probably by C++ too lol)
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoNot much Ada was written in the first place. The reason you see it in job requirements is because inertia and it's easier to slap those three letters in there than it is to try to explain to someone that there is no reason to require it on the job postings. Imagine if a bank listed Cobol on every single tech related job posting, that's basically what defense contractors are doing.
- ycombinatorrio 6y agoand some missile guidance system too
- Spearchucker 6y agoWhen focus is quality, quality rises and costs fall. When focus is cost, costs rise and quality falls. William Edwards Deming, an American, said that. Whilst a lot of what Liam wrote rings very very true (I'm not Amercian either) I think it's slightly more nuanced. Windows Phone is a great example. Americans hate on Microsoft and so deprived themselves of the best mobile phone OS of ever. Even today Windows Phone is more usable, faster, more secure and better in almost every metric than Android. But Windows Phone is dead. Same with the Compaq IPaq. It too was American and amazing. I went through the whole tech cycle Liam did (started programming in '84), and felt crushed every time another obviously superior product died. Apart from the iPaq, some highlights in the mobile space alone are the Nokia 9000 Communicator, the Nokia E90, the Nokia N900, and the best device (my opinion) I've ever experienced, the Nokia 1520. Interesting that we as humans so often base our decisions on emotion rather than logic. I now use an Android phone and no longer bother with mobile apps. That sense of awe and wonder has been eviscerated, eaten up and spat back out. Today's tech is throw-away. Watches, thermostats, tablets, light bulbs... Delivered by Amazon this morning, in the trash this afternoon, making space for yet another smart but shitty light bulb tomorrow. I miss that child-like sense of excitement and wonder tech used to instill in me...
- anticristi 6y agoThis. I sometimes turned to my girlfriend while taking off in a plane (back in 2019 :P) and tell her: "OMFG! We realise humanities dream of flying!" More examples from the comedian Louis CK: https://youtu.be/kBLkX2VaQs4 https://youtu.be/kBLkX2VaQs4
- pyentropy 6y agoWhen Android started getting big, a huge community of enthusiasts were making cool proof of concepts. Port busybox, VNC, run Ubuntu on your phone, ROM customization. Beginners started using accelerometers and multitouch to make innovative games. I remember tutorials on how to make algorithms for good gesture detection (gestures were a big thing). Now app stores are worth almost trillion dollars. You can still find niche communities but just like with the Internet, it got too commercialized.
- FpUser 6y ago
- kanobo 6y agoEurope seems to me to have good intentioned laws and norms that stifle computer related companies. 1) Very strong privacy laws and culture that make it difficult for startups to thrive 2) Business and bankruptcy structures that aren't as friendly to investors 3) More sensical valuing of companies and higher risk-aversion
- Uberphallus 6y agoThis thing of running a company into debt while growing userbase until someone figures out how to make money out of it is certainly not part of the culture. That's what gave YouTube an edge over DailyMotion, they were pretty 50/50 in popularity in Europe before Google stepped in to monetize the thing. I certainly remember uploading videos to both platforms.
- bsder 6y ago> That's what gave YouTube an edge over DailyMotion, they were pretty 50/50 in popularity in Europe before Google stepped in to monetize the thing. YouTube was flaming out until the boardroom backscratch between Sequoia and Google bailed them out. YouTube was burning several million dollars a month on bandwidth and was facing down billions in legal fees--both of which were rapidly increasing. It was going to be bankrupt before the buyout. The buyout meant that Google could subsidize YouTube for a very long time. It's also not at all clear that we wouldn't be better off if YouTube had actually gone bankrupt.
- growlist 6y agoI'd suggest that in Europe innovation is stifled by a strange mix of very old vested interests, the class system (certainly here in the UK), socialistic cultural scepticism around capitalism/profit, and a cynical zero-sum mentality. Sadly I can only see the US going the same way what with the combination of ever-concentrated wealth for the lucky few, plus the faux-socialist destruction of the middle class which the Democrats seem to be working extremely hard at bringing about.
- dmm 6y ago> Use the most minimal, close-to-the-metal language that will work. What? Javascript/Electron is super popular, way more popular than close-to-the-metal languages for desktop applications.
- FpUser 6y agoNot sure. I saw a lot of industrial applications and they're all native. No Electron there.
- sriku 6y agoOcaml - France? Erlang? A heartbreaker for me is Mozart/Oz (Germany?) .. wish it was developed/used/taught more .. "pickling" (in python) came from M/Oz.
- catherd 6y agoThere seem to be a lot of supporting arguments (look at all these dead projects he deems to have been fast, elegant, and efficient, also, hey, my current toys are not made for me to play with like I used to be able to, and the battery life sucks). But what is the actual thesis? It seems like he wants hacker toys and is unhappy that everything is built for consumers now. I can't get anything deeper out of it. The EU vs. US/Asia thing just seems like a weird proxy for saying real techies don't like extruded technology product but it's what the market asked for and now we have lots of it.
- jiofih 6y agoWhat makes you think the products he mentions were “hacker toys”? They were consumer products just the same.
- catherd 6y agoSome of them were consumer products. But they lost out (probably) because they were more like something a technical person would want and less like something made for a consumer. Would you frame the reasons they failed differently? If TikTok users and gamers needed long battery life and elegant scripting tools we would have them. But they don't.
- pjc50 6y agoPsion in particular had a huge business following. Mind you, so did Blackberry.
- 4cao 6y agoI think there is an interesting question here but I'm not sure I follow the train of thought. First of all, I doubt that whatever happened relatively recently with regard to certain design choices in hardware and software is related in any way to how different implementations of BASIC fared against one another in the 1980s. Regardless of the conclusions, there are simply too few people involved in making these choices now that also know what the situation was then. As a matter of fact, one of the perpetual problems in the field seems to be that so many already identified problems with certain design choices and solutions to them are being forgotten, and have to be rediscovered again by every new generation of programmers. And I'm not sure how all this can be framed into the Europe vs America debate: most of the big things happen in the US. Arguably, having a huge single market and less regulatory overhead helps but it's also because this is where the financing is. However, there are people from all around the world working on these things, so to what extent the final outcome can be called "American" is debatable. The founder of Commodore himself was a European Holocaust survivor. And we really have to be careful lavishing praise on "elegant" and "efficient" European products lest we forget about whom to hold responsible for monstrosities like Systemd. Could it be just that we tend to remember the most succesful products from the past, and those originating outside the US had to meet a higher bar to become so? Perhaps there is an argument to be made that at some point while stuff in Europe was still being "built to last," American businesses have already been discovering the allure of planned obsolescence. This would pertain to the hardware side of course. As far as the software is concerned, I think everybody just got lazy the moment they could get away with it due to the rapid advancement in hardware performance. So from the era where you could have Jet Set Willy or Dynamite Dan (platform games with dozens of levels) fit in 48 kB, we've now "developed" ourselves into a corner where even winver.exe (a program whose sole purpose is to display the Windows version and an "OK" button) takes more than this (56 kB on my system). While I concur this outcome is not desirable, I can't really agree it happened because of "moving close to the metal." On the contrary, I think this was only possible because of moving away from it, one layer of abstraction away at a time. To paraphrase the quote attributed to Churchill, BASICs of the future will no longer call themselves BASICs but I think if a BASIC was being invented today, it would look like another JS and it would be part of the problem, not the solution.
- lproven 6y ago
- Rochus 6y ago> Ada, the fast type-safe compiled language (French)? Largely dead in the market. Well, Ada was the language of choice of the US DoD from 1983 to about 1994. And it's only dead if you ignore the millions of code lines (old and new) produced in aerospace and defence. > The Pascal/Modula-2/Oberon family, ... Largely dead. Well, Pascal and it's decendants (Delphi, etc.) are still in wide use with good tool support; obviously not in the author's field of sight here either. > Nokia's elegant, long-life, feature-rich devices ... Sunk by an American u-boat in the prime of its life. Asians or Europeans are also behind many so-called American inventions. Anyway, I don't understand what the author is trying to get at.
- masswerk 6y ago> Anyway, I don't understand what the author is trying to get at. It's about paradigms in technology deployment.
- zwieback 6y agoI grew up in Germany during the home computer boom in the 80s and there was a definite anti-computer vibe at the time, my classmates thought I was contributing to the destruction of the high culture that was so superior to the US. Even though there were many cool platforms I think ultimately the pro-tech and pro-business atmosphere in the US drove the smaller competitors in Europe out of business. Which isn't to say that European companies aren't strong in some areas. Here at hp we love STM32 micros (French/Italian), German robotics and automation equipment, optical equipment and of course ARM, which is a direct outgrowth of the pioneering European micro culture.
- pjc50 6y agoI'm surprised and disappointed that was the prevailing culture in Germany, which is famous for its engineering culture; I guess that's limited to mechanical engineering? The British microcomputer boom had a huge boost from a classic "dirigiste" state direction, involving the BBC producing a TV series to educate the public and a matching computer to work along at home with. That led to Sophie Wilson being hired straight out of Cambridge to produce it, and ultimately to ARM.
- wink 6y ago100% - if you look at the landscape now, everything digital is still pretty much new and not working ("Das Internet ist für uns Neuland" in 2013). Broadband is worse than in other countries, government interaction is pretty much non-digital and other things (there recently was a big thread about a government game development grant that was so startup-adverse that the person telling the story was lucky to not have been bankrupted) and it goes on and on. Also remember all the pixelated houses in Google maps? I wanted to look something up yesterday, image was made in 2008 and everything is pixelated. Despite working in tech I don't see Germany in any sort of leading role in anything digital or IT and this won't change.
- AnimalMuppet 6y ago> The Pascal/Modula-2/Oberon family, a fast garbage-collected compiled family Pascal wasn't garbage-collected, was it? At least not in the original form.
- jhoechtl 6y agoThere is much truth told but > Nokia's elegant, long-life, feature-rich devices, the company who popularised first the cellphowe and then the smartphone? Now rebadges Chinese/American kit. As someone who paod a lot for these early smartphones (N80, N800) they were highly inconsistent. Maybe ahead of it's time but when the iPhone hit the market Nokia quickly lost it's share for good reasons.
- nn3 6y agoHis examples have so many mistakes, it's hard to take anything in this seriously. - Ada (French). Ada is not french, it was developed for the US DOD. I also wouldn't call it dead. - Pascal/Modula-2/Oberon: ... garbage collected ...: Neither Pascal nor Modula-2 are garbage collected. Modula-2 and Oberon are probably dead, but Pascal in its modern iterations is very alive and still widely used, apart from having a significant legacy.
- GeorgeTirebiter 6y agoI do have anecdotal evidence for this (probably incendiary, but certainly not intended that way) point of view: Europeans tend to love creating and mastering complexity; Americans at their best despise complexity and produce simple approaches that cover most of the use-cases. (Also, the author doesn't mention the HP 200LX PDA - a full DOS box, CGA on which I have running a C compiler, scheme48, RF design s/w and much more. Still works great. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HP_200LX https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HP_200LX)
- elchin 6y agoA professor in my grad school told me once "In US if you try to create a business and you fail, people will think you're entrepreneurial. In Europe they'll think you're incompetent".