9 ms·
Australia is doubling fees for arts degrees
- totetsu 6y agoDon't want any of those pesky political science or public policy majors around to scrutinize the government. History? who needs it, it's better to just not look at Australian history, incase anyone wants another costly apology.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rexreed 6y agoI actually think this is a clever idea. While getting an advanced degree in humanities is a possibly laudable goal, the truth is that the vast majority of undergraduates with history majors or art majors will never enter into further studies in those fields. Rather, they will get underpaying jobs doing menial tasks. Getting a degree simply to get a degree is one of the failings of our higher educational system and the high cost of tuition doesn't usually justify those degrees. The perverse disincentive of doubling tuition for degrees with expected low workforce value might reduce the number of undergraduates who have such deemed unnecessary degrees in the workplace, but what then do you do with those post-secondary school students who feel that a college degree is useful, regardless of what that degree is in? I think we need a renewal of trade schools, apprenticeship programs, and a movement to more practical degrees. Of course if you truly want to study advanced art or literature or history or theater, there should be a path for that, but the future for those in those fields are not in high paying jobs, which means that the tuition will very rarely be returned to the student in the form of wages.
- jclulow 6y agoI think it's a pretty rubbish idea if you don't believe the point of life is to maximise your earnings. What if the point is to lead a good life that you enjoy on some level, and society is a system in which we perhaps try and facilitate that for everyone?
- pb7 6y agoI don’t see anything wrong with that but then tax payers shouldn’t need to subsidize your particular goals in life. No one is stopping you from getting that arts degree, it’s still there for you.
- tacomonstrous 6y agoIf I'm not mistaken this comment misses the main point the parent is making: if the goal of society is to ensure that everyone gets to live a good, fulfilling life, then this is precisely the kind of thing taxpayers should subsidize.
- pb7 6y agoI imagine they’re only taking action because they’re currently heading down the wrong path. But even still, it’s hard for me to agree that society should subsidize things that it democratically decided it doesn’t need as much of. Will someone pay me to watch TV all day because I’m really into movies? Probably not. You have to draw the line somewhere. I would be fully onboard your side of thinking if they were planning on getting rid of the arts in schools altogether but coincidentally, it’s more favorable for the schools to fund those fields because they get more money from the few that choose to pursue them. Let’s also not forget that formal education is not the only or even the best way to explore your interests in these things.
- NamTaf 6y agoAs an Aussie, I'm pretty happy to subsidise any of my fellow citizens getting higher education if they want to, because I believe the pursuit of life goals and in particular life goals in education leads to a societal betterment overall. Written differently, if someone wants to go and study philosophy even if they don't believe they'll ever work in the field, I'm happy that my tax helps to support that because I think that the process of higher education in itself is a valuable learning experience that helps produce better citizens within their communities. Higher education - even without directly leading to a career - can be a very powerful way of lifting people out of generational poverty traps. You say that no one is stopping someone getting said degree, however often without subsidy/support it can be prohibitively expensive and that stops them. No one person may be stopping them, but systems doing so are no better. Naturally, that comes with limits, since we are not yet able to function in a fully automated society where scarcity is abolished. Hence why the Aussie system caps the subsidised loans you may receive. edit to add: I also support reducing the societal pressure that a university degree is the only path to success. I'd like to see much more support and emphasis placed on practical tertiary education, such as trades and the like. I think it's all too often an option that people dismiss because they're sold the lie that university guarantees success.
- triceratops 6y agoIt's actually idiotic and anti-market. If art history majors get low-paying jobs, it makes no sense to have their degrees cost more. They should actually be increasing cost of the high-paying majors and reducing the cost of the low-paying majors, in order to correctly reflect the market value of those degrees.
- throwaway69123 6y agoI think your calculating market value wrong.
- triceratops 6y agoWhen selling a product, it's pretty standard to provide more value to the customer than the price you charge. If art degrees are already low value, increasing their price is stupid.
- throwaway69123 6y agoThe customer isnt paying so the anology doesnt hold. The tax payer is largely footing the bill for these degrees that provide little economic uplift.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> It's actually idiotic and anti-market. It’s not anti-market for a subsidizer to cut subsidies for things that don't produce things the subsidizer wants as effectively as other alternatives, so the direction of both the fee effects and the funding changes is sensible. The relative size of the two changes (the subsidy changes being larger than the fee changes), which means that the university gets less for the job-ready degrees and more for the less-useful ones, however, is silly.
- triceratops 6y agoThe job-ready stuff makes no sense to me. People want jobs - that's why they go to college. And when they do they try to find a major that has maximum overlap between their strengths, interests and earning potential. You aren't going to make engineering any more attractive to someone by making it cheaper, if the salaries weren't already doing it.
- pdr2020 6y agoI agree wholeheartedly. As an arts/law graduate, who has since moved into a senior, highly technical IT role, I can honestly say that had I not moved into the IT field, my existing and already large university tuition debt would never have been repaid within my lifetime. There is such a huge glut of humanities graduates in Australia now, that unless you are graduating within the very very top percentile, you are guaranteed to have wasted both time and money for no return.
- aaomidi 6y agoThis is such a bad view on education that we don't even realize is so based around a broken system of economy. I hope for a better future where education isnt a commodity and isn't merely a way to prepare you to join a company that takes away most of the value you produce as profit for themselves.
- rexreed 6y agoUnfortunately the whole K-12 education system and higher education system has been optimized for wage-earning jobs and not the pursuit of educational goals. This is how it has been for the past many decades. I wish it was otherwise but it's not. Higher education is a business in itself. And the whole system has optimized for goals that we might not agree with, but this is how it is.
- eric4smith 6y agoSounds like a great idea. Increase liberal arts fees and decrease STEM fees. What could be the consequences good or bad? Less women doing college - but it's already empirically proven that women don't really push for STEM (and no, it's not only due to sexism). Less degrees overall. This is maybe a good thing, since people are going to college without thinking what they really want to do (not having a plan). More people doing vocational education, since it's not so easy to go to college for that arts and humanities degree that you'll be sure to pass. Finally, waking up people to the fact that it's not so necessary to get a college degree for most professions on earth anyway.
- tropdrop 6y agoThis "job-ready" talk is a classic example of technology developing a life of its own (in the widest sense of the word "technology"), corrupting education specifically to suit its own needs of self-replication. [1] The lede is a bit buried (and the financial restructuring "very complicated"), but here's the key insight to how Australia's implementing this: The reforms redistribute these subsidies and changes the amount of funding that different subjects receive. For subjects like law and the humanities, the increase in student fees exceeds the decrease in government subsidies, meaning universities end up with higher fees overall. This is not the case in “job-ready subjects”, where universities are forced to absorb a shortfall since the government subsidies do not offset the drop in student fees. This, higher education professionals argue, means lower per-capita student funding that will not give universities the resources they need to produce more ‘job-ready’ graduates – and could even back-fire. I personally concur with this: “I think the idea that you can persuade the student who is interested in philosophy to go and become an engineer is just not how this is going to work,” says Joel Barnes, a public history researcher at University of Technology Sydney. Of course, spending any time around a college undergraduate quickly shows you that most students take awhile to understand what their "philosophy" is. This, in my opinion, is the strength of America's (higher) education system - it is so flexible that one can decide to switch to philosophy/programming halfway through their training, once they discover that really is what they liked to do all along but had just never tried it. This Australian system would, instead, lock you into a cheaper major regardless of how miserable you are. Sounds to me like a recipe for a lot of incompetent engineers. 1 - https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2019/08/rotten-stem-how-technology-corrupts-education/ https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2019/08/rotten-stem-how-t...
- pankajdoharey 6y agoI think it actually might work, if enough number of people who think they are interested in Philosophy go ahead and study Engineering, every now and then you might have enough engineers to fulfil the demand. In software this is a recurring trend people from all walks of life with different professional backgrounds musicians, artists , lawyers regularly produce great software. And I think this is how things are in real life, explicit specialisation is a mistake, we need people with diverse backgrounds who can think laterally, such engineers will enrich the engineering experience, we need all kinds of people not just straight A math students. Because different people also bring along different ways of thinking and different ways of problem solving. After all Philosophy is as much as intellectual pursuit as engineering if no less. Though I am kind of a semi socialist in for education, I would prefer Education to be free for all as long as you can qualify the entrance you should be free to pursue anything. I believe job market will eventually dictate what people study, if there are no jobs for humanities people in the market people might stop studying those things.
- dirtyid 6y agoSo humanities and the power to dictate culture will be further reserved for the wealthy and privileged? Alternatively, humanity degrees fees should be quadrupled, but 3/4 of slots should be reserved for average income households who gets to attend for free.
- zamfi 6y agoExactly. One way to think about this is as a "disincentive to study job-relevant fields". But another way to look at this is further entrenching the reality that only the wealthy and privileged can afford to be less vocational in their thinking about college. I'm not sure the outcome here is great.
- lopmotr 6y ago> only the wealthy and privileged can afford to be less vocational in their thinking about college. Isn't that perfectly reasonable? If you have the means to study as a hobby, then you should be able to enjoy that. If you haven't yet got the means for that, then earn it and maybe your children can do an arts degree off the back of your engineer's salary or you can do it yourself when you retire. The whole point of the government subsidizing education is to create useful workers that give more back to society with their useful work. Not to indulge people's pseudo-intellectual pleasures. It's not as if arts degrees make people somehow superior at understanding society and arts and culture. Those are things anybody can pick up even with no formal education. Understanding the scientific method, statistics and critical thinking would go further in making well rounded useful thinkers than knowing what some ancient person's opinion about his local society was or training to become an activist who refuses to allow themselves to think objectively.
- totetsu 6y agoSociety is like a big discussion that takes place in many different communities, groups, institutions, some using being specialists, using special language, some having more influence than others. If you can't take part in that discussion, your interests wont be represented. If many of the specialist, influential discussions can only be taken part in by people with wealth, then the interests of people without it will become marginalised. Generally people know what they need for themselves better anyone else. Not being able to voice needs leads to society not working for those people, and barriers to them gaining wealth, and doing work that is useful for themselves and all society. The humanities is not for the pursuit of the life of the mind, it is important for a functioning society. Many topics in maths and engineering are very intuitive to pick without formal education. To understand Humanities requires discussion with others. Writing and getting feed back on a lot of essays, listening to and explaining ideas in seminars, testing out an idea in a lecture. It can take a decade to start to understand someone like Foucault. It's hard to find a community of specialised discussion outside of formal education. Just picking up humanities from a few youtube videos or whatever is what I am convinced has led us to the kind of unobjective activism that is reacted against so much recently.
- eindiran 6y agoBeyond just the perverse incentives for university administrations discussed in the article, this would be quite disappointing. The constant push towards specialization has led to most undergraduate programs losing any liberal arts rounding, which has some obviously negative impacts (eg the perennially-absent ethics and history courses for engineers). With a further reduction in the number of students in the arts and humanities, I imagine this trend would be pushed significantly further (eg the vast majority of voters having last taken a history class in secondary school/never having taken a political science class, school districts following this lead and cutting the already-paltry funding of the arts and humanities for primary and secondary schools). Hopefully the lawmakers see that investing in STEM doesn't need to be at the expense of the arts and humanities.
- quantumwannabe 6y agoMany engineering programs require an ethics class already, and many STEM degrees require TWO YEARS of "liberal arts rounding" classes. I learned nothing in those classes that I couldn't teach myself, but I sure as hell paid a lot of money for them. Additionally, every single university student has had 13 YEARS worth of liberal arts education before they've taken their first university-level class. If 13 years wasn't enough to "round out" a student, then what good will another few years do?
- freeone3000 6y agoThe "13 years" of compulsory education are foundational, but cannot adequately address topics in any depth, at all. A student who has taken "13 years" of math might be able to solve for x and y in a system of equations and calculate compound interest. Two additional years would grant them an understanding of set theory, Bayesian statistics, or calculus. Nearly no ethics or civics is taught during the compulsory period. No philosophy, very little critical reasoning. What we could do with just a little bit there.
- pansa2 6y ago> many STEM degrees require TWO YEARS of "liberal arts rounding" classes. Is that true in Australia? I assumed universities in Australia would be similar to the UK, where all classes are in the chosen subject only?
- foobar1962 6y agoI overheard some students at a uni talking, one said they were doing a photography degree. They later qualified that they are studying the history of photography. So they weren’t learning how to do something, they were learning about other people doing that something in the past. I wondered about their future earning potential, and where they would work.
- zaaakk 6y agoYou sound like a bugman who lets earning potential and capital drive all his life decisions.
- erklik 6y agoWhere did you hear this? I study at an Australian University. I have never heard of these sort of degrees in my entire study career and I have been here about 5 or so years. The Univeristy I study has the following sort of degrees under the Bachelor of Arts : Anthropology and Sociology, Archaeology, Architecture A & B, Chinese Studies, Classics and Ancient History, Communication and Media Studies, Criminology, English and Literary Studies, European Studies, Fine Arts, French Studies, German Studies, History, Human Geography and Planning, Linguistics, Music Studies, Philosophy, Political Science and International Relations, Psychology All of which, at the very least, seem to be very worthy things to learn.
- triceratops 6y agoAre you sure "history of photography" was the degree, rather than about a single subject or course? If you were studying for a photography degree, I could see you needing to study history of photography for a semester.
- giantDinosaur 6y agoLet's be honest: the quality of humanities degrees in Australia is bad. Could they be good, and challenging, and actually useful? Of course - but I doubt you get this anywhere in Australia for undergrad. The bad thing here isn't the doubling of fees for mostly useless (and I mean intellectually useless - I couldn't care less if something isn't really directly relevant to a job) majors - it's the state of those majors in the first place. It pains me to see the lack of real rigorous and critical thinking present in undergrad classes, and the assessments are often a joke.
- christophilus 6y ago> It pains me to see the lack of real rigorous and critical thinking present in undergrad classes This is not a new phenomenon. I went to university in the US 20 years ago. Very few students ever thought to question the narrative they were hearing. Critical thinking was not taught where I went to school unless you were in a hard science. And from what I see around me today, it’s still not being taught.
- garbagetime 6y agoHow good is the critical thinking that's taught in the hard sciences? My assumption would be that it's quite limited there, too - present only to the extent that it absolutely has to be for good science to be carried out. It seems that critical thinking is generally seen (by whatever system is in charge) as an ugly thing, which, in some cases, must unfortunately be allowed to rear its head, so that progress can be made. Critical thinking is really quite a natural thing for humans to do, but it is for the above reason that it is largely stamped out of us by the school system.
- DomenicoMazza 6y agoWow what a false generalisation. As an academic across communication design and IT (i.e. humanities v science) I will say you are wrong. I have seen disengaged students across both major areas. It's not discipline specific and it not just the quality of degrees. Consider the readiness of students. I completed a year long TAFE (TAFE is technical school, 5 days a week) like foundation course prior to studying communication design at university because I originally began a degree I quit after two weeks and it was too late to restart another degree. Myself (and other students) that competed this foundation year had a major advantage. We already learned the basic tools we would need and practiced concept development so university for us was a better space for us to learn an experiment. Considering teaching contact hours a year in a TAFE is like two in a uni. Guess what! This foundation course which ran for more than 20 years lost its public funding. Furthermore, the degree I had to apply a portfolio to enter now takes in much more students with no portfolio and more or less similar amount of full-time staff with casuals picking up the rest. The problem is multi-faceted. The honest truth is any coalition government (this is the Aus Liberal Party for U.S. folk reading) is ideologically hell bent on removing public support of anything they can. On top of that they load other ideologies about the humanities being less important than the sciences. I'd start by not commodifying tertiary education and giving students the opportunity to explore and discover their flair with smaller and richer courses before going to uni.
- throwaway69123 6y agoWhen these degrees are tax payer funded the cost of said degrees should be index'd proportional to the historic rate of payback from past people doing these degrees. Hear countless anecdotes of people saying they used their arts degree to get a professional job, so this sort of indexation shouldnt be a problem
- aaron695 6y agoI think one shouldn't confuse the destructive nature of the humanities currently with the schadenfreude of making people pay more to study them. It's really hard to know how this will play out. The higher fees for instance is an argument the faculties should get more money and because Australian students can defer all payments of fees only on CPI it might not change numbers much.
- hogFeast 6y agoSky-high wages and low immigration were probably big factors here. Either way, there are alternatives: Give kids more vocational stuff to do at school. Most children grow up with almost no understanding of the world of work. Improve the humanities courses. Suggesting that they offer no workplace skills is nonsense. If you go to a good uni, you get skills that are useful in business. Simple. Make university low-cost - why does it need to take so long? why does it need to cost so much? Make it more expensive really helps no-one. If you made a bad choice, you are now more fucked. The price mechanism doesn't work with education (ironically, this may have been clear if policy-makers had more STEM education...or is economics a social science? Who knows?). Most of these effects are because humanities courses matriculate way more students than STEM, entrance to STEM is often controlled by trade bodies, the students have different goals, and more lower quality institutions do more degrees with more students that get thrown into humanities. University is not the be-all...if you study history, that shouldn't really limit your career in any way. There are countries that turn out masses of STEM grads and haven't taken over the world (India, China's "engineer mindset" amongst its political leaders is also infamous). I am in the UK, and most people who do STEM degrees end up doing something non-STEM related to actually make money (either CS or finance)...most STEM jobs here actually pay poorly (most engineers earn the average salary, staying in academia in a STEM field is career suicide). It is great headline but I suspect it will achieve little.
- deecewan 6y agoLow cost, low quality university is often the reason why the masses of STEM grads from India haven't taken over the world (as well as a healthy touch of racism). This is in Australia, where not only do you get tax free (but indexed) loans for university, but the government also provides a "Commonwealth Supported Place" - they cover half the fees, and then you get your tax-free loan for the other half. This is entirely just trying to maximise ROI for the government. If people want to do an arts degree, they are able to, and will still get the tax-free loan. But the loan will be higher, because the government is less willing to subsidize degrees that have a lower likelihood of high income.
- tamrix 6y agoThis is somewhat inaccurate. The government pays for half the cost of a degree for Australian citizens. Then you pay back the other half in tax, interest free but with inflation but only when you earn over a certain amount of money. The cost isn't doubling. The government isn't covering half the cost of the degree.
- sandoooo 6y agoFar as I can tell, the government has several levers that they are pulling/not pulling here (somebody correct me if I'm wrong, I'm just getting this out of news articles, not primary sources): - they are partially directly subsidizing the cost of degrees for domestic students. The extent of subsidy has not changed in the new policy. (questions: is the direct subsidy the same for all degrees? do arts currently get more or less than STEM?) - they set the fees that universities are allowed to charge students. In the new policy, the allowed fees for humanities have doubled, the allowed fees for STEM has decreased. - also, there is HECS/HELP, which is a scheme where all domestic students (not PR/exchange) are allowed an interest-free, CPI-indexed loan that is only paid back slowly when the student's wages go beyond a certain threshold. This is for the full cost of the entire degree, and is a big part of why students tend to be price-insensitive. - fees for international students are roughly 5x domestic students, and they don't get HECS/HELP. They are basically subsidizing the entire system. The covid situation has dried up this revenue stream and now the unis (who have not been financially prudent during the fat years) are deep in the red, with rumors of bankruptcy starting to circulate. editorializing: 1. Arts and humanities are bad choices if you're already poor. If you're from a rich family it's actually pretty great - light course load, personal growth, better male/female ratio, etc. If you're poor and you do arts, you will have trouble getting a job. People should be allowed to choose whatever degree they want, but the government shouldn't subsidize bad choices. 2. The government seems to be implementing this in a suboptimal way. It seems that there is a fee increase but no decrease in subsidy (or there's a mismatch). I would just lower the subsidy for arts/humanities and allow a fee increase that matches exactly. 3. I doubt this will produce worse engineers. The engineering degrees in good unis are heavily sought-after and difficult to get in, and this just increases the number of applicants, while the number of available places won't change much. I think the largest effect is unis will spend more on marketing their arts degrees, since these will be more profitable going forward. If it leads to the arts departments upping their game to attract students, it's probably a net plus.
- chadcmulligan 6y agoThe annoying part is that most of the politicians have humanities degrees and are of an age where their degree was probably free in Australia. $40K is a lot for an arts degree. Surely a better solution is to provide lots of incentives to get a STEM degree - more carrot less stick. I suspect their motivations if their stated goal is to get more STEM graduates, then this is not the best solution.
- pb7 6y ago> $40K is a lot for an arts degree. Working as intended. Lower cost for a STEM degree = lower risk in the event that you don’t find a job. Existing higher relative compensations = bigger carrot.
- chadcmulligan 6y agoHumanities is also valuable - history, economics, traditional liberal arts are all valuable knowledge. I have one of each (B.Sc / B.A.) and a lot of the stuff I learnt in the BA is very useful, for one thing it gives you the skills to argue with politicians who are, in the main, lawyers and professional arguers. As others in this thread have said, this will reserve humanities degrees for those that can afford them, i.e. the rich, who will become the lawyers and managers. Many managers have humanities degrees. And on a lighter note, where will our baristas come from if there's no arts graduates? It would be a poor society that doesn't have people educated in the arts.
- pb7 6y agoHumanities won’t go away. At some point, equilibrium will be reached and there will be an appropriate number of people going into each. Only the foolish think that liberal arts are completely worthless — but there are too many people that go into them with no special talent to give them an edge in a very limited employment market. I know from experience how common it is for people to decide to go to college because that’s the thing to do, and oh, well I guess I have to decide on a field to proceed with this so might as well choose something that my friends are doing. The thinking is backwards. First you have to decide what you want to do in life, calculate how that will provide for you financially, then figure out what education you need to get there. Who knows, maybe there is in fact a B.A. in Gender Studies requirement at my local coffee shop I don’t know about. ;)
- kevindong 6y agoYou can see the actual brackets/tiers on pages 17 and 18 here: https://www.dese.gov.au/system/files/doc/other/job_ready_graduates_discussion_paper_1.pdf https://www.dese.gov.au/system/files/doc/other/job_ready_gra...
- abiogenesis 6y ago> A cheaper degree in an area where there’s a job is a win-win for students Uh, it also means a lose-lose for other students.
- unexaminedlife 6y agoThe article says they're increasing tuition for "courses seen as less vital to the economy". I have certainly not met all computer scientists obviously. But what I can say is almost every single arts / humanities graduate that I've ever met who decided to pursue a career in computers / programming were on average more qualified for the job than their computer science degree counterparts. YMMV...
- Jedd 6y agoAustralian tertiary education system is a bit of a mess. Rather than saying 'the government provides subsidies / loans' -- it's preferable to think of this as the population does this, with the government merely administrating. In theory the government should reflect the will and interests of the population, but in Australia that's not the case on most important issues (climate change, fossil fuel usage, renewables, health, etc) and there's no evidence to suggest they've got it right with this decision. Trying to guess what the job market will look like in 10-30 years from now, and fiddling with deferred monetary incentives today, sounds like hubris. HECS - university fees - came (back) in around 1990, initially a flat rate of A$1800 per student per degree. Naturally this number has risen steeply over the last three decades. Interestingly many of our politicians obtained their qualifications when tertiary education was effectively free (1974-1990). This, along with considering breakdown of what subjects our politicians actually studied at university [1], should be considered as they blithely toy with the long term social and economic effects of coaxing people into career pigeon holes. [1] https://www.torrens.edu.au/blog/business/what-degrees-do-ministers-in-australia-have-and-why-it-matters-guess-the-top-3 https://www.torrens.edu.au/blog/business/what-degrees-do-min...
- austinl 6y ago> "Rather than saying 'the government provides subsidies / loans' -- it's preferable to think of this as the population does this, with the government merely administrating." I think this is true of all public spending in some sense. Governments don't have money. Rather, the population does, and via taxation, the government is able to administer it how it chooses, for better or worse. Hopefully for the better, of course.
- Jedd 6y agoYes, absolutely. In some cases the distinction's less compelling, say defence, where individually I'm unlikely to notice the budget allocation, let alone how that expenditure is sliced up. It's still fair to say that it's the collective's money, but government budgeting for it is just not scrutinised in the same way. Also, with education it's fundamentally different as almost everyone goes through some part of the education sector at some point in their lives. In Straya we have about 1.5 million people in tertiary (university, colleges, etc) education today. This is a large chunk out of of the 25m population. Consider also that we have 13.5m tax payers, and about 17m eligible voters (and voting is compulsory here). I feel that 'the government spends this money' distracts us from the provenance and accountability for these crucial and significant social decisions.
- Gatsky 6y agoThe Government has a somewhat anti-University agenda. This isn't necessarily a bad thing. Universities in Australia have drastically grown in size over the last 20 years, funded by international students. The other trend seems to be a lot of lightly employed people doing graduate degrees which are pretty lucrative for the Unis. Almost everyone I know is doing some kind of diploma, MBA, masters, PHD etc etc. I think in at least a non-trivial proportion of these cases, they do it because they can't get a good enough job or enough hours of work. It feels like everyone is over-educated and underemployed. Not clear any of this over-training leads to better job prospects. Feels like an example of the meritocratic trap [1]. They make ends meet because Australia has free healthcare, and the previous generation is very wealthy and can support them. This only lasts one generation of course. There seems to be a dearth of opportunity for young professionals. On the one hand you have people in their 60s - 70s working longer, because they earn a LOT (eg > $300K a year as well established doctors, lawyers, accountants). The pay scales in government jobs also mean senior people can earn huge amounts just by virtue of being around for a long time (ie close to double what someone 20 years younger would earn for doing essentially the same thing). On the other hand you have young professionals who can't get a decent job, with ever more candidates piling up behind them. I am not sure about the idea of a STEM shortage in Australia. Is this broadly true? The last mechanical engineer I spoke to quit to become a java programmer because he couldn't get a job. On the other hand a guy I know in Fintech hired out the whole team from overseas, there wasn't anyone with .NET experience locally. Boeing has a software shop and they used to hire a lot of engineers, not sure what they do now. It's puzzling. I suspect there are some social effects at play that are restricting labour market mobility and also that universities are not well aligned with the labour market. One thing I definitely notice - there is a real lack of highly technical startups here. Apparently venture capitalists in Australia are not the best. 'I wouldn't piss on them if they were on fire' was one comment I heard about local VCs. [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2019/09/meritocracys-miserable-winners/594760/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2019/09/meritoc...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- LaundroMat 6y agoIt reminds me of Reagan who spoke of "certain intellectual luxuries we can do without" and that taxpayers should not be asked "to subsidize intellectual curiosity". Where I'm from (Belgium), there's also a tendency to focus more on educating for jobs instead of stimulating human curiosity and knowledge. It's the same type of people who advocate progress and innovation, and just don't see how moulding people's education to an existing situation is counter-productive to their hopes for progress. It's also the type of people who pay lip service to agile development methods, but cannot stand the insecurity of not knowing what the outcome will be. We're living in times where many people fear being unproductive or producing something only to discover that is has no immediate value. Instead of moving us forward, such fears bring us to a standstill.
- bobthechef 6y agoTwo points: 1. The "job emphasis" of higher education is out of control. That is not the primary purpose of higher education. The proper end of education is the education of the human person, not the production of a workforce. We are savages with a pinch of technical savvy perhaps, but nonetheless savages. Of course, savages make good slaves, even when they're rebelling. Of course, one must know the end of human life to be able to know the end of education. From this observation, we are led to, the second point... 2. Sadly, most universities are wholly incapable of implementing a sound curriculum . Sure, the humanities are being measured by their industrial utility, but the humanities aren't blameless. If you thought the amount of garbage the STEM fields put out is jaw-dropping (it is), then I invite your to meet the humanities. The humanities have been slipping into decadence for some time and have become victims of ideological corruption.