27 ms·
Pinebook Pro longer term usage report
- Havoc 6y agoSo frankly about as expected given pricing and nature of this particular beast. I personally think they aimed a little too low on hardware specs. Sure the price is cool but there is something to be said for just a tiny bit more to boost adoption via credible usage
- Sebb767 6y agoIt's great for 200 USD. Of country it's not going keep up with a 2000 USD MacBook Pro, but I doubt that's what they aimed at and the mid-size laptop market is pretty saturated. > I personally think they aimed a little too low on hardware specs. I don't think so. The problems seem to come from more resource hungry applications (yes, that's slack) and it's not much worse than what we had a few years ago with hdd laptops. If you're poorer or in need of a cheap replacement, it's great and priced exactly right.
- Havoc 6y agoThe target audience is developers though (for now) not poor people. I don’t see developers sticking with it long term (and say contributing fixes) if they get frustrated by everything being annoyingly slow (eg browser tab switching)
- stefan_ 6y agoYes, as a platform to develop. Think of it like a dev board with a permanently attached display and keyboard.
- Havoc 6y agoYeah I get that. To iron out bugs you really want devs using it though. I like the concept. Just think they missed a trick there.
- quaa55 6y agoWhile I do enjoy using my Pinebook Pro I usually grab the iPad or Thinkpad, but the pinebook does get a good amount of use. The pinebook is faster than i figured, but it is slow although not annoying slow. Storage is slow and they have m.2 adapters if you are cool with more power usage. The ultimate number one thing to do with this device is turn off tap to click. With that off the trackpad is okayish but still crap. i actually enjoy tap to click on Apple and Thinkpad trackpads. The keyboard is good enough and better than most laptops. not mechanical keyboard good but good in a 50g sponge-ish way. Display is a typical 1080p matte IPS screen (aka a minimum requirement for display specs for some but still within the range although at the low end.) I will say it is valuable to have as a developer. I find it helpful to work off of a slow device sometimes to test how your widget will work as you might run into issues with timers or other weirdness, and aarch64 is somewhat becoming more common - so it might be good to test on that platform too.
- quaa55 6y agoIn addition to what I mentioned, the pbp is faster than a pi4, so there's that too.
- rjsw 6y agoWhich SoC do you think they should have used ? There are not very many that are more powerful, the one in the RPi is unusual in the amount of RAM that it can address.
- danirod 6y agoI remember being a little too hyped over the Pinebook Pro a few months ago and almost getting one, as it looked like a cheap and promising device I could use to test the state of GNU/Linux desktops again, after switching to macOS 6 years ago. But they went out of stock, and then corona happened, which complicated logistics and made these laptops impossible to get for a few months. I’ve recently come across a few long term reviews like this that conclude that the computer maybe wasn’t that good, due to either specs or quality of the hardware itself (keyboard, screen...). So now, I don’t know what to think. Feels like I’ve dodged a bullet.
- CameronNemo 6y agoKeyboard and screen are great IMO, but I am coming from a Macbook Pro (butterfly keyboard) and Thinkpad T430. The RAM is low, so you will need to take that into account and decide if it is enough for you.
- Synaesthesia 6y agoLooks like a combination of slow CPU and slow storage. EMMC can often be quite a bottleneck, maybe if they could get a faster storage controller like new UFS or smth
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoPineBook Pro can support an NVMe SSD with a cheap adapter that fits inside the case.
- TavsiE9s 6y agoI've got the adapter and an Intel NVMe SSD installed, the eMMC is only being used to boot the system. It works reasonably well for a device in this price range.
- Jerry2 6y ago>The biggest gripe is that everything feels sluggish. Alt-tabbing between Firefox and a terminal takes one second, as does switching between Firefox tabs. Looks like the culprit is the CPU/SoC: Rockchip RK3399. The specs for it do look decent on paper [1] but I guess it's simply too slow and not suited for laptops due to a small cache. It looks like a mobile phone SoC. >The screen size and resolution scream for fractional scaling but Manjaro does not seem to provide it. Scale of 1 is a bit too small and 2 is way too big. The screen is matte, which is totally awesome, but unfortunately the colors are a bit muted and for some reason it seems a bit fuzzy. This may be because I have not used a sub-retina level laptop displays in years. Screen is a deal-breaker for me. I stare at screens for hours on end and if it's not something in the same class as a retina screen on a Macbook or iMac, I just ditch it quickly. As for fuzzy screen and muted colors, well, that's the fault of the matte layer on the LCD panel. It's purpose is to diffuse light and minimize reflections. Personally I don't like to make that trade-off and prefer glass surfaces on my screens. I'll make a shade and make sacrifices as to how I orient myself to enjoy crisp text and proper colors in photos/video. As for scaling, only Cinnamon DE does it right. I've tried almost all DEs over the past 6 months or so and Cinnamon's new fractional scaling and HiDPI support is the best by far. [2] >The trackpad's motion detector is rubbish at slow speeds. None of the non-Macbook trackpads are great. There's a project that's working on a good Linux trackpad driver but it's far in the future. Don't bank on it in the short-term. [3] [1] http://rockchip.wikidot.com/rk3399 http://rockchip.wikidot.com/rk3399 [2] https://www.omgubuntu.co.uk/2020/02/cinnamon-desktop-fractional-scaling-support https://www.omgubuntu.co.uk/2020/02/cinnamon-desktop-fractio... [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23235609 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23235609
- Sebb767 6y ago> Looks like the culprit is the CPU/SoC: Rockchip RK3399. It might also be the storage. Especially the delay when entering a git directory hints at slow storage. I had exactly the sand symptoms when booting an otherwise good server from an USB drive.
- toastal 6y agoI've had this issue running Oh My ZSH on a Chromebook several years ago reading git branch info. Running a leaner config than omzsh would likely have been better, but I decided to just fully switch to fish.
- fastball 6y ago> A laptop without an encrypted disk is not really usable as a laptop as you can't take it out of your house. Really depends on what kinda stuff you store on your computer, no? I don't full-disk encrypt my laptop, but everything that is actually sensitive is stored encrypted at rest.
- hibbelig 6y agoIf someone gets their hands on it, they can install a keylogger, and then they know the password for the encrypted part...
- Legogris 6y agoTBF, this is still possible if the boot partition is unencrypted (which is the only way I've ever seen FDE done on Linux in practice).
- fastball 6y agoI don’t actually think that’s true for my MacBook.
- pizza234 6y agoI think this is not the scenario the parent poster refers to (that is, "three letters agency attack"). The typical scenario is: dev brings the laptop out of home -> laptop is stolen. In this case, encryption at rest spares the owner's sensitive information. Actually, I personally consider any machine at risk even if at home, as burglary is not to so far fetched to be considered unlikely.
- stuaxo 6y agoI'd be willing to bet most people including devs don't bother to encrypt their laptops storage.
- TavsiE9s 6y agoEven with the Manjaro installations you can use systemd-homed to store your home dir in a luks encrypted container. Cue the systemd bashing, it works for me.
- ninjin 6y agoI really appreciate write ups like this. While I had considered taking the Pinebook Pro for a spin, the storage and limited RAM situation is ultimately what broke the deal for me as I could not think of a use-case for me as it would fall short of what I need from a laptop. Hopefully I can muster the energy to write something similar after I get my Pinetab, for which I hopefully have more realistic expectations to use as an e-mail terminal (mutt and Syncthing) and occasional “browser peek” while jumping between meetings where I do not feel like dragging a laptop along. My only concern now is whether I can have it fully encrypted and what state video (not browser video) playback will be in. In closing, I have to say that I really appreciate what Pine64 are doing. Their SoC boards, PineTime, and PinePhone are all great fun and I hope this is just the beginning of a long series of awesome hardware to play around with together with supremely hackable open source software.
- rjsw 6y agoWhat is your issue with storage ? It can take M.2 cards.
- ninjin 6y agoThank you, that was a mistake on my part, it was just the RAM then. The mistake is particularly embarrassing as I am very well aware on the M.2 expansion board for the PineTab, so I really should have remembered. Now if only that expansion board would support both the M.2 and SIM at the same time I would even have hopes for the PineTab to finally drive my cellphone out of my life…
- Hoh6quee 6y agoWell, I can certainly provide an argument against expectations of long term usage as well. I bought a pinebook pro, perfectly knowing the performances limitations this article discusses, and actually _wanting_ to learn to live with a less powerful computer, consuming less electricity. In a era where we're roasting Earth, this sounded almost like a duty to me. But when I received the computer, I had a blocking problem with it : its SD card reader was faulty and would trigger I/O errors after a few writes, and the OS would remount the device as read-only. This is a major problem on that computer because it has very low internal storage space so you're supposed to use a SD card to hold data. I tried various OS, various SD cards, did my due diligence to confirm it was a hardware problem - it was. I wasn't that annoyed at that point because pine64 sells spare parts on their web shop. So I went there to replace the SD card reader, which meant replacing the main board as well, but OK. This was all very fairly priced, so no problem. Except… the spare part was out of stock. So I waited a few weeks, and it was still out of stock. I mailed their support presenting my problem and asking a simple question : will spare parts will ever be available again? They answered by asking me to demonstrate this was a hardware issue, which I did. They did not answer my question, so I asked it again, telling them that I was not wishing to make the device travel the world and back, I just wanted to replace the faulty part. They answered me with the address were I should ship the computer to them. So I asked them again directly : will the spare parts will ever be available again? They dodged the question once again and asked me to send them the computer. I guess asking to ship them a faulty product is totally fair, they want to inspect it. I'm not willing do to that because we fly way enough products around the world as is, and I can do any check they want me to do locally. But fair enough, they want it back to solve my problem. What troubles me, though, and what is relevant here is that while they advertise selling spare parts for their computer, they actually don't, and they're shady when asked if they will again. Which probably means they won't. So yeah, I wouldn't bet on long term usage if you have an experimental device that you can't repair.
- emptysongglass 6y agoI think it's because they're all English-as-second-language support staff. I've had the same issues as you and ultimately gave up trying to send them money for spare parts they offered because we kept talking over each other.
- mrob 6y ago>Video playback on browsers is not really nice. Youtube works in the default size, but fullscreen causes a massive frame rate drop. Fullscreen video playback in e.g. VLC is smooth. On Linux, Firefox uses CPU for video scaling by default. You can enable GPU acceleration by enabling layers.acceleration.force-enabled in about:config
- stefan_ 6y agoLast I checked, there wasn't a single official browser release on Linux that did GPU accelerated video decode, which is the norm on Windows of course. So expect playing a 1080p video to hog two CPUs of a real laptop, or all and then some of this mobile chip. It's not even the scaling, if you are full screen the compositor should do that.
- DCKing 6y agoCheck again: Firefox will do this for you now using VAAPI on Wayland since a couple of weeks. If you have an AMD or Intel GPU it should just work on e.g. Fedora and (not sure about if this is explictly needed) setting a Firefox feature flag. Of course the problem here is that this Rockchip's video decoder has no VAAPI driver.
- pantalaimon 6y ago> Of course the problem here is that this Rockchip's video decoder has no VAAPI driver. That’s also not true, according to [1] it should work with Firefox 76 on Wayland [1] https://forum.pine64.org/showthread.php?tid=9171 https://forum.pine64.org/showthread.php?tid=9171
- DCKing 6y agoAlthough it's great news this is being worked on, that thread strongly suggests that this is still very much in WIP status? The only thing they state is that Firefox supports VAAPI in general since 75/76 (which is what I said), not that the RK3399 can actually use that functionality. > 06-07 libva and libva-v4l2-request are basically broken except fro mpeg2.
- bArray 6y agoPersonally I purchased a PineTab [1]. I hope it doesn't feel as sluggish. I suspect most of the lag is the UI they are running. Apparently it purposely runs at a resolution of 720 as not to tax the GPU too much. The plan is to use the tablet mostly with an external keyboard, I suspect the keyboard I purchased with it will not be so useful outside of some odd occasions. I plan to use it for SSH'ing into more powerful machines, vim, a small amount of compiling, LaTeX, a few tabs, etc. Just a machine to take into the office, into meetings, etc. Not a powerhouse photo/video editing, multimedia viewing, number crunching, compiler building beast. As for dev'ing for the device, I'm working on upgrading wm2 [2] to work with touch devices and to remove some of the cruft that didn't age well, whilst trying to maintain the minimalism. I'm aiming for a < 8MB footprint for the window manager and toolbar collectively. [1] https://www.pine64.org/pinetab/ https://www.pine64.org/pinetab/ [2] www.all-day-breakfast.com/wm2/
- josteink 6y agoI think this guy is having issues because he is using Slack, which is known to kill any machine it is launched on (even high-end developer machines) on a lower end, ultra-cheap ARM laptop. The Pinebook Pro itself is probably reasonable (given its price), once you disregard the use of monstrously bloated things, like Slack. That said, the PineTab has half the ram and a measurably slower CPU[1] (See A64 vs RK3399). It’s basically like a PinePhone with a big screen. So don’t get your expectations too high :) [1] https://gist.github.com/ayufan/ce5dc9e501e1b720c2afc31c3ed51f9d https://gist.github.com/ayufan/ce5dc9e501e1b720c2afc31c3ed51...
- bArray 6y ago> I think this guy is having issues because he is using > Slack, which is known to kill any machine it is launched on > (even high-end developer machines) on a lower end, ultra- > cheap ARM laptop. Their "apps" are essentially small web browsers, no wonder! > That said, the PineTab has half the ram and a measurably > slower CPU[1] (See A64 vs RK3399). It’s basically like a > PinePhone with a big screen. This is why I'm working on a lightweight X11 window manager, there's no reason why a UI should take up so many of the CPU horsepower and RAM.
- heldergg 6y agoTyping this on a PBP, Manjaro 20.07 i3. > Alt-tabbing between Firefox and a terminal takes one second, as does switching between Firefox tabs. This is not my experience at all. I do not notice undue delays switching between applications (do not use slack). > The wifi is not very good, it can't connect reliably to an access point in the next room No problems at all. This weekend I'm at my parents, I am connected to an old wrt54gl all day long. I have problems with my other laptop (XPS 13) on the same network. > The screen size and resolution scream for fractional scaling but Manjaro does not seem to provide it. I've been using this machine since late March, I didn't take notes when I configured it but, from what I remember, I only had to make some small adjustments [1] to get things right. Sure, the PBP is an under-powered machine but, given the right allowances (the software is under development, the trackpad is not the best, suspend is not working correctly, etc), I find it easy to use as a daily driver most of the time. [1] https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/HiDPI https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/HiDPI edit: typo and link
- swiley 6y agoFirefox is definitely slow on some of these smaller machines. Although a delay between app switches sounds like some virtual memory got paged out (either swap or executable pages got evicted to make room for FS cache.) EDIT: apparently they’re shipping with plasma as the DE? Yeah that’s going to be slow.
- hedora 6y agoFirefox is unbearably slow on everything including high-end Xeons if you don’t have a video accelerator (think headless VNC). Perhaps the video driver or compositing is misconfigured? Firefox is my default browser, and I’ve found Firefox to be fine on low end machines as long as it can use the video card properly. Chrome tends to have better compatibility with chomebook-class hardware for obvious reasons.
- swiley 6y agoThe experience is a few years old now but I spent a year in college running Firefox on a celeron netbook with just the EFI framebuffer (anything else would crash on boot) and it was totally usable unless you opened google sheets. On my ryzen desktop that I built during the lockdown (after baking some bread heh) it’s very snappy. IME chrome (on GNU/Linux anyway) is usually much worse than Firefox unless you’re in the habit of opening hundreds (at least) of tabs.
- worble 6y agoFor an alternative view to the article, I bought one of the first batches as well, and I couldn't be happier. I don't know what the stock DE is like, as the first thing I did was install arch and lxqt, since I knew from the get-go it was a low powered machine and Plasma was just going to chug on it. I'm not having any issues with playback in browsers (fullscreen or otherwise using latest FireFox), and I use it in bed quite a lot for watching videos, so I'm not sure if there's some specific configuration issue the guy in the article is having, although this could probably be easily worked around with youtube-dl into mpv if you're having something similar happen. I'm also not seeing the same problems on the terminal. I'm using alacritty as my terminal emulator and elv.sh as my shell, with similar customisations to display git statuses etc, and while I notice the occasional white flash (I'm not sure what this is honestly, something to do with alacritty rendering I'm assuming) there's no sluggishness. The trackpad is admittedly horrible, you really need to buy a bluetooth mouse or seperate trackpad because it really is just frustrating to use, on the other hand the keyboard is really solid, I love the feel of it and it's responsive. The monitor, well I'm probably not the person to ask about that. I personally think it looks pretty good, but I'm really not the kind of person who cares or notices about sub-pixel perfect rendering, so YMMV with that. The battery times are also not great, and although you can technically charge it through the USB-C port, it'll still drain power if it's turned on. This isn't helped by the fact I can't get the default brightness up and down buttons to work and have to type sudo lxqt-backlight_backend --inc / --dec to change the backlight. Yes, it is kind of slow, but you really must've known that going into it considering the price and the specs. Overall, my personal perception is that the pinebook pro is batting well above it's weight (well, mine is anyway), and I honestly expected it to be far slower than it is.
- KozmoNau7 6y ago>since I knew from the get-go it was a low powered machine and Plasma was just going to chug on it. I run openSUSE with KDE on all my machines, and it's responsive and snappy even on the Thinkpad X220i (Sandy Bridge Core i3, upgraded to 8GB RAM + SSD). Firefox is what generally eats resources, but below 15 tabs it's fine. Even on my Raspberry Pi 3, KDE is perfectly fine. It's not fast fast, but still feels responsive and usable. KDE was kind of slow in the KDE4 days. Not so anymore.
- oefrha 6y ago> I have a ZSH prompt that shows the Git status of the current directory. Entering in a directory that has a Git repo freezes the terminal for several seconds. For this specific problem, use a prompt that asynchronously updates git status. https://github.com/sindresorhus/pure https://github.com/sindresorhus/pure is an example, and it contains all the primitives you need to implement your own async prompt. Otherwise good luck working on a huge repo like chromium, even on a faster machine.
- EdwardDiego 6y agoYep agree, I found rather OhMyZsh and ZPresto etc. slowed down significantly in larger repos.
- oefrha 6y agoohmyzsh's git status function is utter garbage and has been that way for at least a decade: https://github.com/ohmyzsh/ohmyzsh/commit/8059c0727a09257dc387aa9ba17dc99d1842aa19 https://github.com/ohmyzsh/ohmyzsh/commit/8059c0727a09257dc3... (committed 2010) the function forks 32 times just to do some pattern matching builtin to the shell! Needless to say any theme using that crap is criminally slow. (Edit: It started out forking only 14 times; the number gradually expanded to 32: https://github.com/ohmyzsh/ohmyzsh/blob/d0d01c0bbf32ffe1dc22a66620ca85669c77e6b8/lib/git.zsh#L140-L189 https://github.com/ohmyzsh/ohmyzsh/blob/d0d01c0bbf32ffe1dc22...) To my surprise, it seems the voice of reason finally prevailed, as that crap has been fixed 20 days ago: https://github.com/ohmyzsh/ohmyzsh/commit/1c58a746af7a67f311ee47f97285a855eaf18b5e https://github.com/ohmyzsh/ohmyzsh/commit/1c58a746af7a67f311... (It's still not remotely close to being well-designed.) Prezto's git primitives are solid, but nothing could help you when git itself is slow on a huge repo. Hence the need for async.
- cevn 6y agoI thought this must be the case. Every time I enable oh my zsh git new terminal opens slow by orders of magnitude.
- timdeve 6y ago
- e12e 6y agoAnyone know if if there's support for Wayland? Fractional scaling works pretty well out of the box for me on Ubuntu 20.04 (and also did on 18.04). As for encryption, I see that Architect has support for zfs, but doesn't appear to support installating with encryption out-of-the box. I suppose, if the live Iso does support encryption, it should be possible to "convert" a zfs install to encrypt most (probably not /boot) filesystems: https://unix.stackexchange.com/questions/532619/encryption-of-existing-dataset-in-zfs-zol-0-8 https://unix.stackexchange.com/questions/532619/encryption-o...
- TulliusCicero 6y agoThought it was odd that the author said it's close to being usable, then lists a large number of huge performance problems. That doesn't really sound all that close, though I suppose you could say, "well they just need to slap in a more powerful chip and it'd be fine".
- raverbashing 6y agoI am not sure, but from what I've heard, ARM has a lot of silicon accelerations but not a lot of software (or compilers) already manage to use it (Chrome being one notable exception) https://phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=Arm-Faster-Chromium https://phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=Arm-Faster-C... I wonder what would be the potential if you had more of the userspace libs optimized or a smarter compiler (I mean, LLVM is pretty smart maybe it just needs some nudging)
- panic 6y ago> The biggest gripe is that everything feels sluggish. Alt-tabbing between Firefox and a terminal takes one second, as does switching between Firefox tabs. As an extreme example switching between channels in Slack takes five to ten seconds. It is unbearably slow. This is a hidden downside of writing code that's only just fast enough to work. It may feel fine for you, but anyone building a new computer will have to match your computer's performance, or everything will feel sluggish. We're raising the bar for new hardware way higher than it needs to be.
- Google234 6y agoI don’t understand your comment. When would taking 1 seconds to switch tabs ever feel normal? Are you saying all computers should be that slow?
- opan 6y agoSoftware should be optimized for weaker machines so that it's not this slow even on machines this cheap.
- paulcole 6y agoWhy bother to support something that 1 in 1,000 people (high estimate) is going to be using?
- saagarjha 6y agoThe same reason you use accessibility in general: there might be 1 in 1,000 people who might permanently need it, but considerably more who may want it at certain times (running a compile job in the background, on a business trip and only have low internet speeds, underclocking to save battery, …) and that can be the difference between "I want to use your software because it always works for me" and "I tried it and it works 90% of the time for me, so it's not reliable enough for me to pick it". Plus there's the usual feel-good "I'm helping more people using my software, even the (often) lesser-privileged" rather than "I shouldn't care about these people".
- rbanffy 6y agoThe performance issues reported suggest the software treats all cores as equal and, with that, when you start multiple processes or threads that need to complete for something to happen, you'll end up waiting for the slowest one. That might be bearable on symmetrical multi-core but is an issue with asymmetrical chips. Does anyone knows whether Linux can migrate processes from slow cores to fast ones if the fast one is idling?
- penagwin 6y agoI've been wondering this too. To my knowledge I don't know of any language/framework threading implementations that let you do certain functions in a "fast core thread" and others in a "slow core thread". I'm guessing this means the kernel is making the decisions, which sucks for application developers.
- freehunter 6y agoHow does Android (Linux) handle big.LITTLE chipsets? From what I understand they’ve had this process for years so there must be some software they’re using to handle what process goes to what core. Is that not something they’ve upstreamed to the main Linux codebase?
- zanny 6y agoDepends on the phone. Most 2015-2019 Qualcomm phones use niceness to determine CPU allocation, whereas Android 10 has more complete cgroup support where different groups are assigned to different cores and the APIs categorize tasks / threads / processes by what they are doing into different execution profiles. Pre 10 had some fixed cgroups available but it wasn't as comprehensive.
- gentleman11 6y ago> Eventually I gave up and switched to the default Manjaro. Its installer does not support an encrypted root file system I am using manjaro with an encrypted file system. It was relatively easy to set up and even the boot loader is encrypted. Does pinebook ship with a different version?
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoI'm all in for Pinebook Pro, other open-source hardware projects and ARM ecosystem in general (I even run my production application on an ARM server). But at the same time, we need to be cognizant of the need for software optimisations in ARM running pure Linux operating systems. Much of the complaints levelled against Pinebook can be said for any other similar spec ARM SBC for GUI applications. Some performance tuning could be made at user end such as bloat free Arch ARM, SSD, Btrfs, Zswap etc.[1] but still performance gap with similar spec X86_64 are clearly visible. I have a Acer Chromebook 11 N7, running fan less intel celeron N3060, 4GB RAM, MIL-STD 810G which retailed for $250 (but Google sent one for free to me)[2]. The performance enhancements Google has made with Chromium/ChromeOS is very visible, with every update it got better, there's no sluggishness unless we go overboard with memory. I think there's a reason Google ditched ARM for Chromebooks in spite of it being favourable to run android apps. Mozilla & other free software behemoths who build GUI applications should seriously care about ARM ecosystem when we are voting for projects like Pinebook/PinePhone/Librem with our wallet. [1]https://abishekmuthian.com/getting-smoother-desktop-experience-on-raspberry-pi/ https://abishekmuthian.com/getting-smoother-desktop-experien... [2]https://abishekmuthian.com/reviewing-the-chromebook-google-sent-me-for-free-after-2years/ https://abishekmuthian.com/reviewing-the-chromebook-google-s...
- johnklos 6y agoSome elaboration would help. First, it's clear that several of these things are OS / software issues. Debian has issues with the screen and wifi, whereas other distros have better wifi handling on the same hardware? That's the OS. Firefox is slow with Slack? Firefox is slow with Slack on the fastest hardware you can buy, so why state the obvious? Firefox apparently doesn't have hardware video decoding enabled, which is, again, a software issue. Disk operations seem sluggish? Why not say whether you're using a cheap eMMC or possibly even an SD card? Unless you're selling your Pinebook Pro on eBay as-is, you've left out too much information.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- aidenn0 6y agoQuick tip: you can use xinput to disable tap-to-click on most touchpads, though the exact command is different depending on the touchpad driver used. I occasionally run E and it doesn't have a setting for this either.
- aaravchen 6y agoThe review itself speaks volumes about the author's misconfigurations and lack of Linux experience. As everyone has stated, Firefox, and all major browsers at this point, are resource hogs. On a low powered system, trying to run a huge and inefficient webpage like Slack will always bog down the system. It will frequently cause my browser to use upwards of 15 GB of additional RAM on my 64GB workstations, regardless of the browser and OS involved. However it sounds like it's especially bad on the author's system because he doesn't have any swap enabled (more on that later). HiDPI is a known weakness in Linux for all versions of Linux. The complaint here seems to be that the screen is too good, and the author is slightly uncomfortable with how small 1x scaling is. There is a solution in XWindows that can partially solve that (see other comments), but no version of Linux solutions using XWindows really exist for it that don't murder your CPU. The console problem with zsh being slow is straight out of the beginner's zsh configuration problems "handbook". Every beginner starting to play with their prompts loads up the add ons and bogs it down. Not adding asynchronous plugins, especially for git, makes the prompt on all systems slow, but is especially noticeable on low-RAM systems that can't keep the entire git folder cached for faster lookups. This is obviously exacerbated by the fact that the author has swap disabled. In his first step of the clang build, he says to enable swap. On a low-RAM system, swap is especially important since you're going to run out of space in RAM very frequently. Swap is how you help mitigate that problem, by allowing some of your disk to be used as ultra-low-speed volatile storage. If the author manually disabled his swap (which would be required if he actually used the default install configurations claimed), it's no wonder the system is slow to respond and slow for resource intensive tasks. It's only been recently with the very high memory volumes available that there's been discussions about disabling swap completely. Related, I'm not sure if the sleep mechanism problems from the Pinebook Pro are driver problems, but if your don't have swap configured then virtually none of the Linux sleep mechanisms work. When the device sleeps, it stores the RAM contents in swap. If you don't have swap, you can't sleep. Slow build speeds are pretty much expected. Builds of large codebases are one of the most taxing things you can do to a system. Having a slower CPU and small RAM are the worst things for build times because CPU is frequently a bottleneck on even the most powerful systems, and disk io (the other major bottleneck) is usually mitigated by RAM caching. If the project is C++ you also get crushed by the linking process on large projects, which can require huge amounts of RAM. It's no wonder the author said to add swap since a lack of swap and small RAM can cause a literal crash during linking due to failure to provide minimum required volatile storage. The complaints about the "lack of support for..." are really trite too. It's Manjaro, even a cursory look up on it tells you it's a more stable and slightly more user friendly version of Arch. Both still require you to be comfortable with configuring your system manually, it doesn't come perfectly configured out of the box, that's part of it's draw. Something like disk encryption is a good example where they user is expected to configure their own system. Similarly, Manjaro will perform more poorly than other distros on some hardware if you don't configure it, because unconfigured systems are always less performant than configured systems. tl;dr The author seems to have wiped and reinstalled the Manjaro OS, skipped configuring it or explicitly configured it in a way that makes it perform worse, then complains about the low-spec device performing badly.
- Labo333 6y agoI have used the Pinebook Pro as a main driver for nearly 6 months because my main died before isolation. > Alt-tabbing between Firefox and a terminal takes one second, as does switching between Firefox tabs. Using the OpenGL compositor (which should be the default in latests versions of Manjaro) is a lifesaver! Web apps are and will still be slow sometimes (I don't use slack but messenger can be sluggish). > Video playback on browsers is not really nice. Depends, YouTube is indeed quite slow (I think it became slower after some YouTube update), but if YouTube was optimized for speed there wouldn't be all those adds, right? I like to listen to YouTube music in the background, I use https://github.com/mps-youtube/mps-youtube https://github.com/mps-youtube/mps-youtube for that and it works like a charm, uses 10% CPU and a few MB of RAM. I don't use mpsyt for video but I guess it would also improve your experience. Other websites (kissanime) work like a charm, even in 1080p. > Manjaro does not provide a way to disable tap-to-click True, but installing `xf86-input-synaptics` (although it's deprecated) provides such an option. Also, I use ctrl+F7 to disable the touchpad while I type large chunks of text. From the specs, one could think that the RAM is the problem but zram totally solves that (I have dozens of tabs open in Firefox, including heavy apps like Messenger, Trello and Overleaf). The slow CPU is a larger issue, with Gmail being so slow to load it's almost unusable (loading my mailbox takes 20s and creating a new email takes 3s). Overall, I find the machine very much usable though. I only have two complaints: - static noises - under "heavy" load (eg html5 games with compilation in the background), the alimentation is less powerful than what the machine consumes, which leads to the battery discharging. I wrote a guide on my setup that includes other tricks. Shameless plug: https://louisabraham.github.io/articles/pinebook-pro-setup.html https://louisabraham.github.io/articles/pinebook-pro-setup.h...
- dasb 6y agoSlack is unusably slow on any machine, so there's nothing new about that.
- jancsika 6y ago> I bought a Pinebook Pro in the first batch, and have been using it on and off for several months now. Me, too. > Some people I know wanted to know if it is usable as a daily main laptop. I've successfully used it as my only laptop. > I originally wanted to use stock Debian but at some point the Panfrost driver broke and the laptop could not start X. Only in FLOSS world would someone complain about a first-time-out laptop with very early (reverse-engineered) FLOSS driver support not working on the arbitrary, non-default OS the author happened to install on it. The Pinebook Pro ships with some kind of hybrid Debian Stretch-- it appeared to have Chrome specifically compiled for this board, and probably some other custom things (probably keyboard/touchpad driver, etc.). There's an icon in the taskbar to update this "Debianstein" using "MrFixit's repo." This is the official way to update the laptop-- it asks for your root password, downloads stuff from the repo and then runs scripts. Super shady. That aside-- if the Pine devs weren't shipping with stock Debian when author and I bought it, there is probably a very good reason why. And we see one piece of evidence as the author tries to run "stock Debian" on the Pinebook-- shit broke! > Alt-tabbing between Firefox and a terminal takes one second, as does switching between Firefox tabs. Again, on the operating system which Pine ships with the Pinebook Pro, task-switching between Firefox and the terminal (mate terminal?) is immediate. It's weird to feel I have to defend a laptop that has the shittiest touchpad I've used in a decade. But if you're going to do a serious review of a fledgling laptop like this, either use the default software or know what the heck you're doing wrt drivers/firmware. Otherwise it feels like the point is to get me to sympathize with Apple's "stock OS or it's a brick" strategy.
- seba_dos1 6y agoRunning various distributions and having mainline support was part of Pinebook Pro's value proposition, so while it's worth pointing out I wouldn't blame the author for it that much. There are plenty of people who got or considered getting Pinebook Pro to run things like "stock Debian" on it and aren't interested much in such "Debiansteins".
- wtallis 6y agoWhen it comes to hardware purchasing decisions, I don't really consider a device to be open-source friendly unless the drivers are upstreamed. Out-of-tree drivers that aren't at least on track for upstreaming in the near future will in the long run be just as much of a hassle as proprietary drivers.
- reddotX 6y agouse Ubuntu...
- sukilot 6y agoWho makes Pinebook? Why do they seem to be maintaining anonymity? They go to great lengths to hide their identity or the existence of their native language, even having an About Us page that says nothing about Us. https://store.pine64.org/about-us/ https://store.pine64.org/about-us/ It reminds me of how MSG manufacturers claim they only sell "flavor enhancers".