8 ms·
For the cases given as examples in the article, from Georgia and Texas, even if they got prompt test results both those states are doing badly at contact tracin
by tzs 6y ago
For the cases given as examples in the article, from Georgia and Texas, even if they got prompt test results both those states are doing badly at contact tracing which further exacerbates the situation.
Georgia is currently tracing just 7% of contacts. They were in the 7-9% range from mid May to early June, then fell slowly to about 4%, then briefly in late June got up to 19%, and then immediately went into decline back down to 7%.
Texas is doing 6%. They were at 19% in mid May, rising to 42% near the end of May, fell to 25% in early to mid June, jumped to 33% by June 11, and then have been on a decline down to the current 6%.
Experts say this needs to be 90% withing 48 hours of infection.
California peaked at 39% in mid May and has followed roughly a declining sawtooth since then, currently at 22%.
Florida is just 3%. They peaked at 40% at the start of June and went steadily down hill since then. They curve looks like a capacitor discharge curve.
The only states that currently either have enough contact tracers or have planned expansions that will get them enough are: Alaska, Hawaii, South Dakota, and everything north or east of Pennsylvania except for Rhode Island, .
Of those, all but New Jersey, Massachusetts, Alaska, and Hawaii currently have sufficient contact tracers on hand.
The remaining ~40 states do not have enough and do not plan to get enough.
A state needs 5-15 tracers per daily positive test. Georgia has 0.33, Texas 0.31, California 1.07, and Florida 0.15. Compare to New York at 13.75. (Missouri and Alabama are tied for the worst here, at a paltry 0.08).
Reading between the lines, I think that several states hired enough to handle the load near the end of lockdown, with perhaps some room to spare for a minor raise as they reopened. When the rise was faster than they anticipated, they failed to slow down reopening or to boost their budget for contract tracing.
Above data from https://testandtrace.com/ https://testandtrace.com/ and https://covidactnow.org/ https://covidactnow.org/
- makomk 6y agoNo amount of budget-boosting would be enough to keep up with exponential growth. If they hired enough people to cope with the contact tracing load near the end of lockdown plus a little bit of an increase, and then the increase was faster than expected, that sounds like a pretty clear sign that contact tracing is not a workable solution. (Which is, as I understand it, pretty much what we'd expect. Contact tracing has not conventionally been seen as even remotely viable for a respiratory disease like this one.)
- irrational 6y agoI thought contact tracing was exactly how countries like South Korea kept their numbers so low?
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoIt's unclear. Rates in South Korea are rising, and they've generally used somewhat broad shutdowns in addition to contact tracing. (For example, when there were positive cases found in Seoul bars, they closed all the bars in the city for weeks.)
- on_and_off 6y agocontact tracing + massive testing. It is unclear to me why this wasn't doable in more countries but this has been one of the very few winning strategies. (not trying to be malicious here, I admit that I don't know the logistics of large scale testing and why it wasn't applicable to more countries).
- usaar333 6y agoWell, that and an actually effective isolation program.
- maxerickson 6y agoAbsolutely not viable as the sole mitigation, but when rates are very low it is a useful tool in keeping them low.
- lostlogin 6y agoWith minimal budget and used in isolation, this is what you get. It is viable when used with other (strict) measures.
- trhway 6y agoit seems that it is viable up to a specific scale, and we're already past that scale. Honestly, my imagination fails to come up with a remotely plausible math model of containment, say in CA, of further spread from the current 400K (4M after the CDC 10x multiplier with the most being unaware of being a carrier) cases in 40M population.
- dehrmann 6y ago> Reading between the lines, I think that several states hired enough to handle the load near the end of lockdown Government being government, I understand why this doesn't work, but states literally have a list of people without jobs and their occupations that they're already paying. If the health department could/would just talk to the unemployment department...
- cma 6y agoThere were some recent fixes to it, but we've allowed our phone system to be completely overrun by scams and spam. So we don't even have a trusted line of communication between government and citizens other than mail, which is too slow. Most people have had to just block all unknown numbers. The only reason for it was because offering spam blocking service was a cash cow for phone companies, so hey lobbied against any effective governance to stop it (finally some was passed in late 2019). If people have an interest in something, the government is barely responsive, it took years and years. Special interests that can pay to lobby for it get their way right away unless there is pretty huge backlash.
- Spooky23 6y agoThat’s an unfair statement. The powers that be need to be motivated and stuff gets done. Northeast states like NY, NJ, CT, Mass were able to mobilize after the initial crisis and rapidly hired and got systems in place to do contact tracing. In the south, you have the conflict between municipal and county authorities managing the crisis on the ground while the obsequious governors are busy sucking up. It’s depressing that the tragedy of what happened in April didn’t result in more intelligent actions in other places based in the lessons learned.
- arrosenberg 6y agoIt seems to me that it's probably a money issue. States can't run deficits and the Federal government hasn't stepped up to backstop municipalities, just private corporations. Extend the states an unlimited line of credit from the Treasury for contact tracing and most of the states would probably ramp up.
- 6y ago
- jakear 6y ago> Experts say this needs to be 90% withing 48 hours of infection. Statements like this always bother me. Which experts? What happens if the value isn’t reached? How did they even arrive at these numbers? The statement makes it seem totally made up on the spot, which isn’t helpful in a time when so much of the “expert advice” is already disregarded (often for good reason! Remember when “experts said” that masks were ineffective at reducing transmission of this disease that has very few asymptomatic carriers?)
- paulryanrogers 6y agoDid experts actually say masks were ineffective at reducing transmission? I recall it was more about not buying up masks so that healthcare workers had enough. And that masks may not help stop contracting it oneself.
- Herodotus38 6y agoUnfortunately yes they did. Even in my hospital I remember when the recommendations were that masks were unnecessary unless in a covid room. I’ve been treating covid pts since April. Edit: maybe for clarity I should add that I don’t remember anyone saying it was ineffective, just unnecessary. I witnessed several physicians wearing their own masks be told by higher ups to stop though. I’ll have to look through old emails, things have changed on a weekly basis.
- kemotep 6y agoMore or less the message was, you don't need a mask because you shouldn't be out in public anyway.
- orangecat 6y agoRight, the abstinence-only approach. Which worked exactly as well as you'd expect.
- odshoifsdhfs 6y agoI can't say for US, but yes, both WHO and local government health figures were spouting that masks don't work. LAter they recanted that the reason they said that was because there weren't enough, but the initial dialog was they were ineffective. (from a previous discussion, I think France was the same)
- pmiller2 6y agoYou’re right, but, at the same time this is an extremely puzzling phenomenon. We have millions of people out of work whom we could be paying to do contact tracing, and, yet, we don’t. Even if the states are low on funds, the federal government could either subsidize or fully fund such programs. Doing so would be a huge step toward dealing with COVID-19, as well as providing a partial solution to all the unemployment that’s been created by the lockdowns. Why don’t we do this? It’s a jobs program, not an entitlement, so, theoretically, Republicans should eat it up. And, I don’t see Democrats opposing it, either. Instead, we’re pointing fingers, calling it the “China flu,” or the “Trump virus,” while over 130k have died, and many more get infected by superspreaders who could easily have been identified and isolated were there enough contact tracing in place. Even California, which I thought was handling the crisis well at first, has faltered by prematurely reopening sectors of the economy. I’d like to say it’s a lack of leadership, but I think it’s more that our leaders are serving interests that are not ours. This is a nonpartisan statement — Trump is to blame for a lot of it, but Democratic governors and mayors, by and large, haven’t stepped up, either. It’s time to ask cui bono? It’s time to really drain the swamp, instead of continuing to vote for the mosquitoes who suck the life out of the American people.
- liuliu 6y agoYou cannot have massive job program without state financial going into red. And states have to balance their book every year.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoIs there not a website, either state or federal, where one can go and report contacts? Why does the roll need to be performed by boots on the ground (exclusively?). I could just be ill-informed here. We have one active case in hospital quarantine here is Tasmania who is a resident returning from Victoria, and I’m not really paying much attention so.
- fspeech 6y agoThe state aggregated data for California doesn't make much sense. San Diego county is still contact tracing at 90% (was 98% earlier) https://www.sandiegocounty.gov/content/dam/sdc/hhsa/programs/phs/Epidemiology/COVID-19_Daily_Status_Update.pdf https://www.sandiegocounty.gov/content/dam/sdc/hhsa/programs... Since this stat is monitored state wide as a reopenning criterion other populous counties should be comparable.
- cptskippy 6y agoWhich is weird because Carlsbad's latest report said they were at 7% and their goal was 12%.