7 ms·
I hate URL fights. I give little extra value to people providing links with their clams. I largely given up providing links to information when called out as
by duxup 6y ago
I hate URL fights.
I give little extra value to people providing links with their clams.
I largely given up providing links to information when called out as well. It's not worth the time.
Discussion on the internet is broken in most places (HN is less broken than most). I find little value providing URLs. Much of the time I provide them, few folks seem to read it, fewer actually want to read it in an intellectually honest way and usually they respond with some bonkers links of their own that don't say what they think they're saying.
Much (not all) of the time I've given up providing links to basic information it doesn't change the conversation in any meaningful way. It's usually just an argument where folks who feel like URLs are some sort of scoring device.
I get the idea put forward here, but I don't know if it makes sense in an age where you can find an URL that says anything and discussion on the internet is so bad that nobody is really reading them anyway.
- DangitBobby 6y agoI frequently visit the links found in comments here. But in these instances I am reading someone else's "URL fight."
- duxup 6y agoHN is certainly an exception I'll make for providing / reading links.
- the_duke 6y ago> Much of the time I provide them, few folks seem to read it I wouldn't be so pessimistic. Only a small fraction of people that read comments will respond. Plenty of viewers will probably check out the link and derive value from it, but won't have anything valuable to contribute to the discussion. Antagonistic viewers that already strongly disagree will be much more likely to respond (and without reading the link), skewing your perception.
- hinkley 6y agoIt helps me sometimes to remember that my conversation has an audience, and just because my opponent didn't learn anything doesn't mean that I wasted my breath.
- Legogris 6y agoI think it’s very worthwhile; it allows readers to judge the legitimacy and relevance of sources for claims made.
- im3w1l 6y agoA big gripe I have about youtube links: I can't learn anything about the video from the link. Once in a blue moon a youtube source is actually good. But the odds are so low that I often wont even bother clicking.
- vkou 6y agoI completely ignore YouTube links, if they are secondary, or tertiary sources. (They can be pretty good as primary sources. If someone claims that an event happened, and then links to a YouTube video of that event, that citation is often quite conclusive as to the validity of that claim.) They are unsearchable, unskimmable, and require way too long to get through. And if someone links them with a particular timestamp in mind, because some fifty-second segment is the salient part of the link, then, at best, they are an appeal to authority.
- hinkley 6y agoYou can't maintain an asynchronous conversation with a youtube video in the middle. With a link I can scan for support of your position and mine. With the video the conversation just stops for 20 minutes while I watch a stupid video. And then I can't cite anything from it unless I'm a transcriptionist.
- duxup 6y agoAgreed. YouTube links are automatic ignore for me. Video that isn't a sound byte or "here is that thing happening exactly" is a horrible way to consume information related to a discussion.
- adsjhdashkj 6y agoGood point. I derive a lot of value as a reader from the ability to verify someones claims.
- 082349872349872 6y agoPage 58 of "The Art of Conversing With Men" (an 1805 translation of a 1788 work by Knigge) shows that trolls were a thing in the eighteenth century: > "There are people who pretend to know every thing better than others, contradict every one, frequently against their own conviction, merely for the sake of disputing. There are others who are fond of speaking in parodoxes, and accustomed to maintain assertions which no sensible man can take seriously in the sense in which they utter them, from no other motive than to provoke contradiction; there are finally others whom the French call querelleurs (wranglers,) that studiously seek opportunities to engage in personal disputes..." After saying "Don't Feed The Trolls", a phrase on page 59 shows that eighteenth century mores did differ from twenty-first: "...it is extremely wrong to use against a wrangler any other weapon than contempt, or at most a cane, if he carry his impudence too far..." https://books.google.ch/books?id=PtQGAAAAcAAJ&printsec=frontcover&hl=fr&source=gbs_ge_summary_r&cad=0#v=onepage&q&f=false https://books.google.ch/books?id=PtQGAAAAcAAJ&printsec=front... original available at https://www.projekt-gutenberg.org/knigge/umgang/chap005.html https://www.projekt-gutenberg.org/knigge/umgang/chap005.html §8 > "Es gibt Menschen, die alles besser wissen wollen, allem widersprechen, was man vorbringt, oft gegen eigne Überzeugung widersprechen, um nur das Vergnügen zu haben, disputieren zu können; andre setzen eine Ehre darin, Paradoxa zu sprechen, Dinge zu behaupten, die kein Vernünftiger irgend ernstlich also meinen kann, bloß damit man mit ihnen streiten solle; endlich noch andre, die man Querelleurs, Stänker nennt, suchen vorsätzlich Gelegenheit zu persönlichem Zanke" > "...und der hat doppelt unrecht, der gegen einen sogenannten Stänker mit andern Waffen als mit Verachtung, oder, wenn es ihm gar zu nahe gelegt wird, anders als mit einem geschmeidigen spanischen Rohre kämpft..."
- zentiggr 6y agoIt is a bit of an art to separate those who are discussing a point for sake of clarity or persuasion, from these bastards whose only goal is to get a rise out of you or consume your time with their own amusement. Disengaging from those conversations is easier though. Don't answer, walk away, just stop playing their game. Although there is a part of me that wants to shout them down and ridicule them, that plays right into their bs as well. Sigh. Hell is other people.
- 6y ago
- moultano 6y agoArguments are for the spectators.
- awinter-py 6y agoonline arguments are for spectators now because we don't have effective moderation and because our formats don't promote this kind of exchange philip tetlock claims that constructive arguments happen in relatively small high-trust communities where people are incentivized to get the truth, accountable for being wrong, and don't know the alignment of their audience.
- severine 6y agoThanks for the mention of Philip Tetlock, I found and just read this recent interview with Tyler Cowen and it's very interesting: https://conversationswithtyler.com/episodes/philip-e-tetlock/ https://conversationswithtyler.com/episodes/philip-e-tetlock... (audio & transcription)
- duxup 6y agoYeah that's the truth. More and more often as a sort of puritanism takes over replies have near 0 to do with me. I'll put forth an idea X, and someone will maybe think (sometimes reasonably, sometimes less so...) it also supports another idea Y. I'll be all "oh man no not Y". And I'll get a diatribe about how I support Y ... despite explicitly saying that we both agree that Y is bad... It sometimes feels like in most places nobody believes anyone is honest and just is looking to riff off some tangential thing and yell at people.
- SkyBelow 6y ago>I largely given up providing links to information when called out as well. It's not worth the time. Demanding citations you don't plan to read, to either waste a person's time or to make them look unreliable, is a tactic I've seen used so often I normally don't care to provide links. Instead, I'll just point out some 'so you agree with my argument but doubt data backs it up?' at which point, if they respond, it'll be a negative indicating a link wasn't relevant except to waste my time. Edit: To clarify, I mean discussions in other sites.
- AnHonestComment 6y agoAs someone who gets censored for wrongthink routinely, I’ve taken up having GitHub repos of links so it’s easy to support my point. Case in point: I’m “banned” on HN because @dang thinks my genuine view, calmly stated is inherently a flame war and I shouldn’t be allowed to join the conversation.
- tomrod 6y agoFlame wars aren't always launched or avoided due to the level-headedness of rhetorical delivery
- AnHonestComment 6y agoOkay. Censoring some views because people can’t control themselves in response to those views calmly stated is a classic example of ideology censorship. I just wish @dang would be honest that HN engages in discrimination based on ideology.
- herbstein 6y agoI don't know which view it is you're talking about, but what @dang did isn't universally wrong. If the view is something that is as close as possible to objectively wrong, in the moral sense, as something could be, I'd say it's justified. An example of this could be genuinely stating "Hitler did nothing wrong" or "black people deserve slavery". You know, reprehensible stuff. There's no reasonable way to have that discussion. How do you debate whether a large minority is inherently sub-human? Like, I'm sure a Neo-Nazi would be able to calmly explain their views without attacking me (a white man) personally, verbally, or physically. But their view is inherently an attack on the humanity of other people. To be clear, I'm not saying you are actually a Neo-Nazi or a racist. They're just very, very clear-cut examples of the point I'm trying to make. Another example could be that someone stating that every LISP programmer is a child molester. There's no flamewar in the comment itself, but it's a view that can't be expressed without inciting one. Yet another example could be thinking that every person earning more than $50k is a capitalist pig and deserve the guillotine. Again, calmly stated as a matter of fact. But it's also calling for the execution of a large part of this site's audience. It would inherently cause a flamewar too. All of these examples are extreme, but I think the point that some views inherently having a piggybacking flamewar has been made. Where @dang decides to draw the line between controversial point with legitimate room for discussion, and views so abhorrent or nonsensical that it's easier to simply ban users perpetuating them is up to their discretion. I also don't think @dang bans people because of a single comment, but rather someone continually pushing the view that inherently leads to flamewars.
- scoutt 6y ago> providing links ... when called out People got so used to seeing links up to the point a fight might end in a "URL request": you have to sustain your claims by bringing a link to the discussion, and if you fail to do so, you are wrong. Like if every research and every paper, study or whatever is publicly accessible and indexed. If am I wrong, please provide a link to a study which demonstrates it.
- tonmoy 6y agoI claim there is a tea pot in orbit around the sun. I can’t sustain my claims by bringing a link, you need to provide reference to prove that I am wrong.
- cblackthornekc 6y agoI mean I have a teapot on my stove. It's orbiting the sun. So you're correct. *I know what reference you're making, I just like to be a pain. :)
- pinopinopino 6y agoBut there are many tea pots orbiting the sun, the path they follow is a bit weird though ^_^
- scoutt 6y agoIf you made the claim then the burden of proof is on you. The thing I was talking about is that I can automatically win the fight by asking you to provide a link. Edit to add: a link that I know for sure you won't be able (or will be very difficult for you) to provide.
- NoSorryCannot 6y agoWhile difficult for me to characterize, I feel that there is a middle ground for more casual interactions that doesn't call for maximum rigor so as to fend off the most radical claims. In practice, we can just dismiss them without engaging.
- johngalt 6y agoThe challenge with the link fights is often about the difference between data and conclusions. For example, if I claim that "marriage has a positive impact on men" then cite a bunch of data showing that married men live longer and make more money on average etc... Have I truly proven my conclusion that marriage benefits men? Or does the same data show that healthy men with jobs are more likely to get married? Yet, I will stubbornly say that citation makes the conclusion unequivocal. 9/10 times the disagreement isn't data/citations but conclusions or criteria.
- duxup 6y agoAgreed. What the article actually means / we should think about it is a big part of it. For a while there were some accounts on reddit (and even HN) posting the same collection of links with regards to a particular topic. The links even came in the same order each time ;) It always came up with regard to a particular nation and a specific topic. (for the record they're long since gone, at least with those links) Anyway one of the articles was a US university professor who said something about some other countries actions and so forth. To the astroturfers that was supposed to mean something, X. What it really meant was a university professor said that if the data supplied by that country is true that it means that they maybe did Y. The article was was miles and miles away from X. Granted those were astroturfers, but I see the same issues with folks who honestly believe a rando quote means something significant. I often find myself asking people about their links "What do you feel that article means?"
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> 9/10 times the disagreement isn't data/citations but conclusions or criteria. Or assumptions behind the cited data, and effect size. What I've seen very often (particularly around sketchy nutrition discussions about "natural" things and "evil chemicals") is that quoted research seems to support a given conclusion, but under assumptions that do not apply to the argument at all, or significance is so low as to make the result useless. Some study showing that a bunch of mice got cancer after getting injected with more artificial sweetener than you'd drink in a year does not show that artificial sweetener causes cancer in men. A study that says you get 0.003% greater chance of cancer from eating red meat every day has an effect size so small it's probably bullshit, but even if, 0.003% increase is not something worth caring about at all.
- clairity 6y agofurthermore, calling for citations is primarily an expression of disbelief, not a furthering of discussion. either the argument was indeed faulty, in which case the responder should call out the weakness directly, or the responder has no specific objection but wants simply to object. it's lazy and should be discouraged (e.g., downvoted). another lazy response is providing links without summarizing the linked content, but i digress. citations can buttress but never make an argument. this of course is different from the memes that the author seems to be targeting, which don't make sound arguments in the first place, and no citation will make them rational. it's best to simply ignore those.
- brlewis 6y agoWhy is expressing disbelief less furthering of discussion than citation-free expression of belief?
- clairity 6y agobecause in the first instance, all you're saying is "prove it", implying that the prior reasoning was deficient without specifying the insufficiency. that's vague, lazy, and ultimately unproductive/stifling. at least point out the deficiency, thus furthering the discussion. the counter is not a non-furthering "citation-free expression of belief", but rather a rationale, a chain of observations leading to a reasonable conclusion, which can largely stand on its own and also furthers the discussion.
- brlewis 6y agoA full rationale is a nice ideal, but if you don't have time to research and compose a full rationale, silence is not always the best alternative.
- clairity 6y agoagreed, no one expects footnoted essays in discussion forums, but just saying "prove it" is lazy and no rationale at all. folks have to put some effort in to further the discussion. they shouldn't expect a response otherwise.
- DharmaPolice 6y agoOne of the chief benefits I find to providing links when in a discussion is - I get to realise I'm wrong before I've posted. I'll have some half-remembered quote or statistic in my head and I want to provide a link to evidence it. But after finding a decent source I find that I've misremembered something - usually it's a minor detail but sometimes not and sometimes it undermines the point I was going to make. That kind of self-fact checking is enormously useful since i) I look less of a fool and much more importantly ii) Less bullshit is propagated overall. I'm not sure how you can know that "nobody is really reading [your links]" - on most forums the number of people reading a thread will heavily outnumber the people participating. Who knows how many people are reading your links, perhaps months later? Even when not in a discussion/debate I think providing a link is just good manners. Searching for something might only take 2-3 minutes but why should every single one of your readers have to do that? Isn't it more efficient that I do it once and provide the link? This is especially true when there are multiple versions/editions of (for example) videos with very similar titles but different quality or subtly different content. A URL helps to say "This is the specific thing I was talking about".
- duxup 6y agoThat's a really good point. That does happen to me when I go looking and find I misremembered some details and it turns out... yeah I'm wrong.
- brabel 6y agoI find it useful to provide sources even to just make sure I don't misrepresent something myself. Many times when I felt like posting an outraged comment to disagree with someone, after looking for sources for my points, I just gave up because apparently, I was wrong. Sometimes you just misremember things... sometimes you're just ignorant on a topic and what you've heard is all secondhand (and wrong). Providing sources is not something you do only for others, you should do for yourself.
- hinkley 6y agoThere are a lot of documented rhetorical devices that can deflect your opponent, and one of them is sometimes called "assigning homework". A URI that is a 3 minute read is fine. But you'll see people say they won't even entertain a discussion with a person until they have read a book, and that is not a road to dialog.
- jimbokun 6y agoThis seems to be more an argument for avoiding internet discussion altogether.
- aflag 6y agoI think it makes sense to put links for those who read. I disconsider a lot of stuff because I can't be bothered checking. If your goal is having a great discussion, then the links may have little effect. However, if your goal is to inform (including all the people who will not reply), then providing links is great.