11 ms·
Portland protesters say federal officers in unmarked vans are detaining them
- Bostonian 6y agoMany cities choose not to control their rioters, arsonists, and looters. In such cases, the Federal government may need to step in. It's my civil right to not have my business looted, and when local authorities do not protect civil rights, others should.
- ianleeclark 6y ago> the Federal government may need to step in. Not quite sure unmarked people kidnapping people into civilian-grade minivans is the best way to quell insurrection.
- whb07 6y agoGot a source they are "unmarked" ? The pictures I've seen are regular fatigues with patches marking and other symbols marking who they are with.
- krapp 6y agoApparently the vehicles are unmarked, and any patches or other worn identifiers are generic or nonspecific.
- ianleeclark 6y agoThe first paragraph says that there are only generic "police," patches on their fatigues. No badge numbers, nothing indicating where from, or anything beyond that patch. I know someone might say that's technically marked, but, when you're being pushed into a minivan, that's pretty vague. I know damn near any american reading this will have been told as a child not to go along with a stranger just because they said they were police.
- entropea 6y agohttps://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_nkw=police+patch https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_nkw=police+patch There are the generic "POLICE" rectangle badges in there too. They are essentially unidentified.
- kyleee 6y agoare they wearing any other agency/organization patches?
- pandaman 6y agoThey appear to. Even on the video[1], which was obviously shot on a potato (or Twitter compressed the shit out of it) you can see there is a round emblem on the left arm. You can see at multiple times, for example at 15 seconds. 1. https://twitter.com/matcha_chai/status/1283328232033411072 https://twitter.com/matcha_chai/status/1283328232033411072
- agentdrtran 6y agothe vehicles are rentals
- dekhn 6y agoOnly a single anecdotal observation in this article, and not speaking directly about the vans: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/17/us/portland-protests.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/17/us/portland-protests.html """One of the people detained, Mark Pettibone, said in an interview that an unmarked vehicle stopped right in front of him around 2 a.m. on Wednesday and four people in camouflage jumped out. Given the lack of markings or identification, he had no idea who they were. One of the officers said, ‘It’s OK, it’s OK,’ and just grabbed me and threw me into the van. Another officer pulled my beanie down, so I couldn’t see,” Mr. Pettibone said. Mr. Pettibone said he was terrified and that at no point was he told why he was arrested or detained, or what agency the officers were with. He said he was ultimately held for about two hours before being released.'"" Most articles I've found are citing statements from one or two individuals (Pettingbone): https://www.opb.org/news/article/federal-law-enforcement-unmarked-vehicles-portland-protesters/#.XxD9y_CwH4w.twitter\ https://www.opb.org/news/article/federal-law-enforcement-unm... I haven't seen enough authoritative evidence to truly say that there are "unmarked vans driving around portland kidnapping protestors"; if the federal government is doing that to nonviolent protestors who are obeying orders, they put themselves directly at risk of being sued for civil rights violations. I've noticed that WaPo is especially prone to rumormongering/anecdote amplification in a way that makes it sound like the problem is far worse than it really is. I find it necessary to read a wider range of news to get a fully informed view.
- fapjacks 6y agoI think this is happening in order to identify specific people who can be demonstrated to have some sort of link to other, unidentified instigators that the feds are after (e.g. linked via drone or bodycam or other footage showing interaction). So they pull somebody off the street in this manner, conclusively identify the person, and then pull and add that person's metadata to the Palantir graphs, in order to identify the people they can't find, or people they suspect are running the instigator show. That this is happening in Portland in particular does not surprise me at all, given the history of the city and the level of organization at protests and riots there in the past (something I have personal experience with and know a bit about). I strongly suspect that local law enforcement is fully supporting these operations, even if they are not doing so outwardly, or even denying it.
- rudolph9 6y agoI live in downtown Portland. A few bad apples breaking some windows does not justify the federal government overstepping their bounds and surprising political activism. Things were drastically improving until the Federal government showed up in full camouflage uniforms and started antagonizing people.
- alexfromapex 6y agoThis isn’t breaking windows, there have been people murdered and millions of dollars in damages. What was improving?
- snogaraleal 6y agoWhat's funny is that it doesn't matter whether it was improving or not. Law is law. You don't stop chasing criminals just because criminality is down.
- thecolorblue 6y ago> You don't stop chasing criminals just because criminality is down. The process of arresting and charging those who have broken the law should not change either.
- snogaraleal 6y agoYet it seems to have changed nation-wide in order to accommodate those who are "protesting". You can't get it both ways.
- mnm1 6y agoWhy let innocence get in the way of chasing people down? That's the argument police unions have been making for years. Whenever society wants to improve and decriminalize something, it can't because the fucking cops want to have easy arrest targets. Fuck them. At least now we can stop pretending we don't live in a police state.
- ta17711771 6y ago> It's my civil right to not have my business looted This is the only part I don't strongly agree with.
- marcusverus 6y agoThis article offers scant evidence that this occurred. A man claims that he was arrested "as he was walking home from a peaceful protest" and taken to the courthouse in an unmarked vehicle. This strikes me as unlikely to be the full story, but it is presented as the gospel truth. The entire thing is based on the word of this guy. What did the Washington Post do to verify the truth of this story? Anything? The WaPo article refrences Oregon Public Broadcasting as a source, and their article[0] contains more allegations: > Federal law enforcement officers have been using unmarked vehicles to drive around downtown Portland and detain protesters since at least July 14. and > Personal accounts and multiple videos posted online show the officers driving up to people, detaining individuals with no explanation of why they are being arrested, and driving off. Neither article links to these videos. So, in terms of supporting evidence, we're left with the word of one man and a perfectly credulous article written in a local publication. Has anyone seen one of these videos? [0]https://www.opb.org/news/article/federal-law-enforcement-unmarked-vehicles-portland-protesters/ https://www.opb.org/news/article/federal-law-enforcement-unm...
- ianleeclark 6y ago> Has anyone seen any of these videos? https://twitter.com/matcha_chai/status/1283328232033411072 https://twitter.com/matcha_chai/status/1283328232033411072 Is the one I've seen going around
- woopwoop 6y agoHere's one: https://www.reddit.com/r/PublicFreakout/comments/hry8db/armed_troops_in_portland_oregon_are_taking_people/ https://www.reddit.com/r/PublicFreakout/comments/hry8db/arme...
- dTal 6y agoMany of the comments note a number of highly suspicious irregularities which point towards this being some kind of asset extraction, as opposed to a genuine arrest.
- marcusverus 6y agoThank you for the link. That's some scary stuff.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- disposition2 6y agoIt is nice to see this finally getting the attention of national media. It was a week or so ago I saw videos of some guy get shot in the face while holding up a sign and another being kidnapped and dragged in to an unmarked car by unidentified individuals for an unexplained reason.
- Avshalom 6y agojust a reminder of the dress rehearsal from Standing Rock https://theintercept.com/2017/05/27/leaked-documents-reveal-security-firms-counterterrorism-tactics-at-standing-rock-to-defeat-pipeline-insurgencies/ https://theintercept.com/2017/05/27/leaked-documents-reveal-...
- hirundo 6y agoHow can you have the right of habeaus corpus when nobody knows which agency seized your corpus? We urgently need a federal statute to require that armed federal agents wear prominent identification. Even just a number that we can lookup for the details. Cops with no accountability are how we got in this mess and this anonymity amounts to more of the same.
- LorenPechtel 6y agoYup. What I would like to see: Normally, to act as a law enforcement official you must have clearly displayed identity. Without this identity you are not considered to be an agent of the state and have no powers a passerby would not have. The identity may be pseudoanonymous but the agency must be able to link it back to the individuals. I would make exceptions for undercover officers who are discovered or who choose to break cover, and I would make exceptions for circumstances beyond their control. (You don't cease to be a cop because someone destroyed your identification in the incident etc.) Likewise, I would like to see their powers go away if they aren't filming, likewise with an exception for something that happened during the incident. (But turning off one's camera is voluntary, it doesn't count unless you did it under duress.)
- entropea 6y agoI've heard some talk that the NDAA allows overriding habeus corpus, but I'm not a lawyer so I don't know if it's entirely true. Source: https://m.huffpost.com/us/entry/us_57c9b648e4b06c750dd9cd6f https://m.huffpost.com/us/entry/us_57c9b648e4b06c750dd9cd6f
- hirundo 6y agoIf it's legal then there's even less prospect of accountability, so it's worse.
- thephyber 6y agoThe John Yoo interpretations of existing law during the early Bush 43 administration already did that. NDAA and subsequent updates weren't required, but I wouldn't doubt if they solidified some of the weaknesses of just having White House / NSC council interpretations. Also, in practice, law is very subjective and frequently doesn't supply any prior constraint against government actors, only recourse after-the-fact.
- erentz 6y agoThis has been going on for a while. It started with using unidentified units at the DC protests. Then the clearing of protestors for the photo op. Now they're roaming the streets in unmarked rentals in Portland abducting people. This is against the wishes of the Governor and the Mayor. The DHS secretary visited Portland yesterday, this is what he saw that has prompted him to send in these forces: pictures of graffiti [1]. For that he labeled these are violent extremists and violent anarchists. And he has labeled these unidentified units abducting people as our valiant men and women in uniform and patriots. This is war on terror language used in our country, on our streets. On Wednesday Trump, with AG Barr next to him named other "blue cities" in addition to Portland: Seattle, Minneapolis, and Chicago. If this chills you and you don't want to see it progress, call your representatives and ask them to intervene to stop this. [1] https://twitter.com/DHS_Wolf/status/1284095525122453504 https://twitter.com/DHS_Wolf/status/1284095525122453504
- erentz 6y agoLegit curious about the down voting. If we're going to allow news like this to be posted, then what about my comment is not adding facts or to the conversation? Is it because of this line: "If this chills you and you don't want to see it progress, call your representatives and ask them to intervene to stop this."?
- philipkglass 6y agoI tried to upvote your parent comment earlier today but the action did nothing. Your karma did not increase. I was able to upvote it just now, though it's still in the gray. I have noticed that a minority of comments seem to be "locked" against voting for a certain period of time. I have previously found unvotable comments like yours, spotted them again hours later, and found that voting worked again. I haven't been able to spot any common patterns in these temporarily unvotable comments. I wonder if there is some sort of cooldown timer on voting for comments that have received heavy voting in both directions. I'm not entirely satisfied with that guess, because IIRC some unvotable comments I have encountered in the past appear to be anodyne and unlikely to have attracted prior vote controversy. There's also a limit on how frequently your votes will affect another user, but I hadn't voted on any of your other comments in the past day.
- solarkraft 6y agoSo what happens if you manage to shoot these (quasi- or even actual) kidnappers in self-defense?
- EForEndeavour 6y agoAlong those lines, aren't situations like these precisely why the Second Amendment exists?
- fzeroracer 6y agoYou'd think so, but yet I see the same people who are ardent defenders of the Second Amendment and supposedly hate government tyranny come out to defend what is essentially unnamed federal officers in unmarked vehicles grabbing people off the streets. You'd think that the same people that are incredibly pro-freedom would see this as a massive assault on someone's rights and yet, well.
- yeetawayhn 6y agoSince when is officers arresting people tyranny? That sounds like a "sovereign citizen" kind of position.
- Sohcahtoa82 6y agoIt's tyranny when the people being arrested have not committed any crimes. Half the country has forgotten that peacefully protests aren't just legal, but protected by the first amendment. I know the knee-jerk reaction to this statement is that rioting isn't peaceful protest, and you'd be absolutely right. But the media (especially on the right) has blown the number and severity of riots completely out of proportion, because riots are sensational. They're exciting and get a lot of eyeballs watching their broadcasts and reading their articles. They've successfully convinced half the country that the riots significantly outnumber the peaceful protests. This focus has made it impossible for any change to occur, because they defend the unjust actions of the police. You can point to this massive list of over 200 videos showing police brutality during the protests [0], and they will respond with "BUT THE RIOTS!", as if that excuses any of it. [0] https://twitter.com/greg_doucette/status/1266751520055459847 https://twitter.com/greg_doucette/status/1266751520055459847
- AlleyTrotter 6y agoHow did he know they were federal?
- kyleee 6y agoI think they have patches and stuff on their uniforms, a bit hard to tell in video but looks like it
- Avshalom 6y agoThe feds have said they're there. Not what they're doing exactly but they haven't been hiding their presence. If you know they aren't local PD because you've been there long enough to know what swat-ass PPD look like the choice is vigilante cosplays or Fed, and Occam says fed.
- exabrial 6y agoFor everyone wondering what's happening, here's my theory. They're likely using CCTV footage, either drone or fixed, to identify people in the crowd. Most likely these are instigators that are inciting violence or destroying property. They're waiting until the people are separated from the crowd, to make sure that things don't escalate, then arresting them. We need to follow up with the arrests and make sure due process is being followed. If you're inciting violence or destroying property, you need to face justice. If you're assembling peacefully, we need to monitore for/end the abuse of power.
- aedocw 6y agoNice theory, except they are not being arrested. They are being detained, and then released with no charges, and no apparent record of having been captured.
- exabrial 6y agoHave a source? I don't think that's true. This is what I'm seeing. https://www.portlandoregon.gov/police/news/read.cfm?id=250994&ec=2 https://www.portlandoregon.gov/police/news/read.cfm?id=25099...
- cosmiccatnap 6y agoHello fellow cop
- cameldrv 6y agoOregon law seems straightforward: ORS 162.367: (1) A person commits the crime of criminal impersonation of a peace officer if the person, with the intent to obtain a benefit or to injure or defraud another person, uses false law enforcement identification or wears a law enforcement uniform to give the impression that the person is a peace officer and does an act in that assumed character. (2) Criminal impersonation of a peace officer is a Class C felony. ... (3) As used in this section: ... Law enforcement uniform” means clothing bearing words such as “police,” “sheriff,” “state trooper” or “law enforcement,” or clothing that is an official uniform or substantially similar to an official uniform of a law enforcement unit that would make it reasonably likely that a person would believe that the wearer is a peace officer. [1993 c.243 §2; 2005 c.259 §1] ORS 133.005: (3) “Peace officer” means: (a) A member of the Oregon State Police; (b) A sheriff, constable, marshal, municipal police officer or reserve officer or a police officer commissioned by a university under ORS 352.121 (University police departments and officers) or 353.125 (Creation of police department and commission of police officers); (c) An investigator of a district attorney’s office if the investigator is or has been certified as a peace officer in this or any other state; (d) An investigator of the Criminal Justice Division of the Department of Justice of the State of Oregon; (e) A humane special agent as defined in ORS 181A.345 (Humane special agents to enforce animal welfare laws under direction of law enforcement agency); (f) A regulatory specialist exercising authority described in ORS 471.775 (Service of subpoenas) (2); (g) An authorized tribal police officer as defined in ORS 181A.680 (Definitions for ORS 181A.680 to 181A.692); or (h) A judicial marshal appointed under ORS 1.177 (State plan for security, emergency preparedness and business continuity for court facilities) who is trained pursuant to ORS 181A.540 (Certification of judicial marshals). There is a separate definition of "Federal Officer." A Federal Officer is not allowed to wear clothing bearing the word "Police", because they are not a police officer. Impersonating a police officer is a class C felony, carrying a maximum sentence of five years in prison.
- pandaman 6y agoIANAL so I don't quite understand why would be a state law (Oregon in this case) applicable to federal agents executing the federal law. Seeing that internet is full of pictures of federal agents with "police" insignia (usually together with the agency name, but not always) it appears that the federal law allows this type of identification and, because of the Supremacy Clause, the state law has no effect. Am I missing something here?
- theknocker 6y agoThat's so unjust how democrats can't just incite riots and let them burn uncontrolled without the federal government stepping in.
- lumberingjack 6y agoThis was happening in Cincinnati about 20 years ago and nobody believed me the neighborhood I lived in was so bad with gang violence anytime you called the police they showed up an unmarked clothing wearing masks in unmarked police cars white and black
- 0max 6y agoThis play is straight outta Vladislav Surkov's book. He's starting to look like Putin's Kissinger. Look up the "little green men" in Ukraine.