22 ms·
How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion
- maxfan8 6y agoI can’t seem to load this page (getting infinite redirects from https://www.economist.com/books-and-arts/2020/07/15/how-objectivity-in-journalism-became-a-matter-of-opinion https://www.economist.com/books-and-arts/2020/07/15/how-obje... <-> https://www.economist.com/books-and-arts/2020/07/16/how-objectivity-in-journalism-became-a-matter-of-opinion https://www.economist.com/books-and-arts/2020/07/16/how-obje...) Also looks like Wayback Machine is experiencing these redirects as well: http://web.archive.org/web/20200716120005/https://www.economist.com/books-and-arts/2020/07/15/how-objectivity-in-journalism-became-a-matter-of-opinion http://web.archive.org/web/20200716120005/https://www.econom... http://web.archive.org/web/20200716120005/https://www.economist.com/books-and-arts/2020/07/15/how-objectivity-in-journalism-became-a-matter-of-opinion http://web.archive.org/web/20200716120005/https://www.econom...
- wazoox 6y agoWorks for me, see http://archive.is/3Nn1P http://archive.is/3Nn1P
- ameister14 6y agoI think it's an adblock issue
- tclancy 6y agoIt worked for me until I logged in, which is depressing.
- tomp 6y agothis works: http://archive.is/0Vyx0 http://archive.is/0Vyx0
- Digit-Al 6y agoAlso: https://outline.com/btGuzC https://outline.com/btGuzC
- benlumen 6y agoIn my opinion, once-objective mainstream journalism is now about writing content to please target audiences and catch trending topics on social media, as well as keep fast cycles going to appease the algorithms on news aggregation sites and search engines. The names of once-trusted news companies has stayed the same, but it's about the only thing about them that has. I believe the tipping point was smartphones, and find it very ironic that Steve Jobs showed off iPhone's ability to load up The New York Times in its reveal keynote in 2007. This was the exact topic of my first substack piece on Monday if anyone is interested. https://benlumen.substack.com/p/thank-god-i-never-went-into-journalism https://benlumen.substack.com/p/thank-god-i-never-went-into-... I did feel a little vindicated reading Bari Weiss' NYT resignation letter the next day saying that "Twitter has become its ultimate editor".
- batty_alex 6y ago> In my opinion, once-objective mainstream journalism is now about writing content to please target audiences and catch trending topics on social media, as well as keep fast cycles going to appease the algorithms on news aggregation sites and search engines. That’s an awfully cynical take when all you have to ask is how these publications could stay afloat without drawing readers in. They’re in a tough spot when people are opting for their Facebook feed over paying for articles from proper journalists.
- benlumen 6y agoI'm not suggesting they had a choice - I believe they had to do it to survive. But there is now a void for the objective journalism of old. It's why I'm excited about the resurgence of the newsletter model - if journalists don't need to catch passing trade and can instead rely on being delivered direct, perhaps the incentives that have skewed their writing so much can be mitigated.
- bilbo0s 6y ago"But there is now a void for the objective journalism of old." I don't know man? Many have tried, all have failed. Even newsletters, in the end, write what readers want to hear. Some of the most radical and extremist information out there, is disseminated by newsletters. I think OP hit on the crux of the issue, technology, or "the smartphone" if you want to pin it on that, has changed not only methods of consumption, but consumption behavior and expectations on a fundamental level. And I think that applies to all media, not only news. The seeming efficiency of information and media delivery on a smartphone just makes us think differently about the value of information and media. We start wanting the information we want, and we start blocking the information we don't want. After a while, information and media we don't want won't even show up for us. It's massively efficient customer service on a global scale. I'm not sure what can reasonably be done about it?
- mlthoughts2018 6y ago> “ Over 500 at the Washington Post endorsed demands for “combating racism and discrimination” at the paper.“ I’ve always viewed journalism as a career as something very, very similar to a hated defense attorney. A defense attorney’s job is to set aside all personal beliefs, moral points of view on racism, violence, inequality, whatever, and execute the best possible legal defense for a client. The attorney may utterly hate rapists, but may also be highly skilled at defending them in court because the civic function of requiring evidence and due process to lead to a legal standard of a guilty verdict is an even greater moral requirement for society than punishing someone accused of crimes which elicit outrage. It’s similar for a journalist. Your job is to set aside all beliefs about what’s right or wrong and do the best job of executing a record of eye witness observations, quotations and facts that give a holistic view of every story. If any component of your own preferences for social movements or causes has come through, you’ve failed badly. But it seems like society is pressuring for journalism to go the other way, and largely academia too. You cannot dispassionately pursue analysis of facts and observations. You must color them with a definitive edge or stance that injects an active agenda based on the prevailing moral opinions of whatever in-group your employer belongs to (usually left vs right in America). Journalists have some extreme self-aggrandizing view that their function is to carry out missions of morality or causes and to “do good” with their journalism. It leads to editorializing both what is newsworthy in the first place and also what discourse is allowed to be had about it. I personally think it’s really frightening. If journalists at our most major institutions believe their work should pursue an agenda like combating racism, that’s horrific. Racism is deplorable and despicable. Journalism ceasing to be an unglamorous job about executing observatory faculties to let others draw conclusions for themselves is cosmically worse, in the exact same way that rape is deplorable and despicable, but a situation where defense attorneys view it as their job to railroad people accused of rape without executing their best possible legal defense is cosmically, immeasurably far worse.
- nkozyra 6y agoJournalism - good journalism, anyway - is constrained by rules and best practices to do exactly what you describe. And many journalists consider that alone to be "doing good." And I agree. Bias is inevitable, even given the constraints. Resource allocation to stories, physical space and dealing constraints, advertisers ... so many parts of the business and reality of producing journalism make the ideal unachievable. The goal is to be as close as possible. The BIGGEST problem is journalists are now highly visible social media presences. Their casual pseudo personal accounts give an eye into the thoughts, preferences and opinions of journalists. And that brings their potential biases to the forefront
- drtillberg 6y agoIn practice, newspapers just have different thought leaders now. Once, reporters parroted "a government spokesman confirmed that" -- this was treated as pure fact. It wasn't perfect, but in the U.S. context it generally didn't seem far off the mark. Now the narrative is provided by the opaque party apparatus of the DNC and GOP. This leads to one result-- factual inaccuracy. Media coverage of key issues thus has become little better than the political propaganda from non-free global rivals in the 20th century. Quite a fall.
- phkahler 6y ago>> Now the narrative is provided by the opaque party apparatus of the DNC and GOP. No. I still get the NYT daily email briefing and it shows a clear bias and agenda every day. Which reminds me, I need to cancel that.
- yetanta 6y agoYou are seeing one of the parties opaque view. The DNC seems to have a better handle on their operatives than the GOP. That resignation letter from a few days ago for that particular organization shows a very toxic place to work at. Where if you do not toe the line you are attacked daily. Fear and intimidation and loss of group are proven ways to make your point the loudest. Mr. Bernays should be proud of the monster he set loose upon us.
- cyberlurker 6y agoI don't disagree, I see something that looks like a bias too. But on some of the issues (wearing a mask, climate change) the GOP is so off the mark how can the NYT not come across (appearing) biased? I've also noticed the past few months they now make an even greater effort to call out racism by some politicians. Is this an agenda or just factual observations? There are a lot of discussions on race right now and a lot of dog whistles. I go back and forth, but for the most part I think the NYT does a better job than most. Their opinion section is atrocious.
- watwut 6y ago
- tgv 6y agoAnd like that, an unholy alliance between left-wing and right-wing agitators and ad-buyers puts objectivity in the press at stake, and with it the future of democracy.
- Miner49er 6y agoObjectivity is impossible in journalism. Even if you only report facts, what facts you choose as important enough to cover or not will introduce a bias.
- andi999 6y agoTrue. Although I found that the financial times is pretty neutral and the articles have a very high quality. You do not have to have Gell Mann amnesia to read it. Maybe it is the target audience. If you want to make money, you do not want your information to be politically biased.
- rsynnott 6y agoI think probably the problem there is, what is bias anyway? In the UK, Brexiters have been complaining for years that the FT is massively biased, because it isn't sufficiently complimentary of Brexit. A lot of people seem to define media bias as not being 'in the middle'; in the Brexit case, facts have a remain bias, so many people perceive the FT's largely factual reporting on Brexit as bias. The only way to produce Brexit reporting that would satisfy the 'in the middle' people would be, frankly, either to not print most of the news about Brexit, or to outright make stuff up.
- newen 6y ago> facts have a remain bias ... Or, FT could actually acknowledge that the remain folks have legitimate arguments.
- rsynnott 6y agoSure, and they do. But some people interpret that as bias, because it isn't occupying a largely imaginary position equidistantly between remain and leave. When the average person talks about media bias, they do _not_ actually mean 'factual reporting', or 'independent editorial policy', or anything like that; they mean either 'agrees with me' or 'occupies a weird artificial center position'. Some (usually public) broadcasters actually have 'equal-time' rules, which can produce fairly bizarre results.
- lordnacho 6y agoI think the issue is really whether people can make up their own minds. Early on it seems there was this idea that you could simply give people the facts, and they could decide for themselves what to think. This seems to not be the case. Both in the sense of whether people can think for themselves, and whether anyone thinks they can. How often do you see a comment that blames public opinion on the media? For me, it's all the time. Now that everyone thinks that people will just think what they're told, you have a paternal class of writers who feel they need to be very vocal in what they direct people's opinions towards. It's clear that if you think people can't think for themselves, persuading them of one opinion or another is going to look very different from if you thought they were rational agents that just looked at evidence.
- dfxm12 6y agoEarly on it seems there was this idea that you could simply give people the facts, and they could decide for themselves what to think. This seems to not be the case. Yeah, people say they want objectivity, that they want facts, but then they'll complain about bias when they read that their opinion on something is objectively not based in fact. As an example, how many people are complaining about objectivity, while also refusing to even entertain the idea that someone who says "COVID-19 is a hoax" is a liar?
- rodiger 6y agoFacts without the corresponding counter are incredibly powerful at being "accurate" but still swaying opinion towards a bad take. Modern media abuses this. There are facts to support most viewpoints, but most can also be readily attributed to other factors. However, when presented in certain lenses it's near impossible to tell who is correct (without going off and doing independent research).
- makomk 6y agoCareful use of facts can even convince people of things that are out-and-out untrue. For example, at least for a while everyone on HN seemed convinced that the US coronavirus testing program must obviously have been sabotaged because we couldn't even catch up with South Korea in tests per capita - people kept on pointing to that one specific fact, even though it wasn't true and hadn't been in a good while. This was the result of hard, deliberate work by the American media. It started when America genuinely was behind South Korea and the media pointed to this as the reason they'd supposedly contained the coronavirus without locking down (they hadn't, of course). Then when the US started catching up with South Korea, passing them in both total tests and testing rate per capita, all the usual publications ran fact checks insisting it was false to claim that the US was testing more people for coronavirus because they'd tested less people per capita. When even that was passed, the media carefully avoided mentioning it, using other comparisons such as test positivity rate to argue that the US coronavirus testing was still behind South Korea. (In reality this wasn't actually measuring the scale of coronavirus testing at all - South Korea had reached that low positivity rate by using a partial lockdown to drop the number of cases and were coming to the end of that lockdown.) Anyone Googling for information on the false claim would find only the outdated fact checks, which even their authors must've known weren't going to be true for long given the trajectory back then. Not only that, when Trump pointed out in a press conference that in reality the US had passed South Korea in this, the New York Times even ran a news headline claiming he was lying... and if you read the article, their basis for claiming this was that there were still a few other countries carrying out more coronavirus tests per capita than the US. (Which was technically true but irrelevant, particularly since most of the larger ones also had worse coronavirus outbreaks than the US so it clearly wasn't doing them much good.)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- henvic 6y agoWas the mainstream media ever objective or impartial? I find it appalling how people believe there is such a thing as unopinionated journalism. There's not, especially in a world where much media outlet income and even access to information comes from its association with state actors. In some - if not most - parts of the world, there are even supposedly impartial media outlets whose most income comes from advertisings for state campaigns and politicians' agendas. Exclusive perks and access to state authorities for journalists is also another problem. While many people might say that it's essential for them to have close access to presidents, governors, and lawmakers to inform the general public, no one can argue that this doesn't have implications in behavior. You get reporters traveling alongside politicians in taxpayer-paid aircraft, bypassing immigration protocols, getting celebrities associated with authority, and their integrity is likely going to mold even if it is hard to see.
- rsynnott 6y ago> In some - if not most - parts of the world, there are even supposedly impartial media outlets whose most income comes from advertisings for state campaigns and politicians' agendas. Some, but probably not most; most developed democracies _severely_ limit spending on political campaigning. The US is something of an oddity there.
- benlumen 6y ago> Was the mainstream media ever objective or impartial? It depends where you are - I'm in the UK where TV news still has objectivity regulation. I know that's been gone in the US for a long time. In general though I think when there were fewer publications and delivery channels that we had to share together (the newspaper stand), journalists had to appeal to a wider audience than they do now. Personal devices mean they have a direct route to you, on an article-by-article basis. So they can write whatever lands in a niche.
- rsynnott 6y ago> I'm in the UK where TV news still has objectivity regulation That's only for the BBC, as far as I know. And one could, er, definitely question how well it worked in the last election.
- Guy2020 6y agoWhen journalism is paid for primarily by corporate sponsors, the premise of "objective journalism" is absurd. People have to pay for their news if they wish to have the slightest hope of it being objective, but with the ubiquity of free content, paying for journalism now seems like an unwelcome deviation from the norm in the eyes of many. Ad sponsored journalism, and media in general, has poisoned the well. When you are used to getting something for free, it feels wrong when you have to pay for it. This cripples alternative media that isn't reliant on corporate sponsors...thus the ecosystem for "objective journalism" is weak. The current environment, with respect to the aforementioned incentives, makes objectivity difficult -- not to mention the political/economic instability which adds tons of fuel on this fire.
- xamuel 6y agoI sometimes wonder what the authors of the U.S. constitution would think about the modern "press". I wonder whether in some alternate universe the constitution could have been interpreted in such a way that special protections for the "press" only apply to the LITERAL press, i.e., to those who physically print news onto paper with a printing press. The world could be a lot different today if that's how our interpretation of the constitution had turned out (such a world would be better in some ways, maybe worse in others). A physical newspaper has a natural tendency to incentivize payment models where the reader pays for the paper; a physical newspaper is much harder to alter after-the-fact; and a physical newspaper lends itself to a daily news cycle which gives writers time to think more carefully about what they write (with "Extra" editions being reserved for truly rare occasions like war breaking out or presidential assassinations).
- Guy2020 6y agoI suppose we would have to reason about the intention/function of the press. As far as I understand, freedom of the press was about the dissemination of ideas. In a democratic republic, the people must have a means of circulating information about various issues so that voters can cast informed votes. It could be argued that the modern press spreads confusion and is less about the dissemination of ideas for the purpose of informing the voting public; however, the history of the press is not a glorious one. The press has always been a mess. Nonetheless, I think, as you say, the "slow press" is more in line with the idea of informing the public. The "continuous press" is more about pushing propaganda and conditioning the public...in my view.
- marcusverus 6y agoObjectivity has been dead for half a decade. Sure, the explicit statement of opinion has been (mostly) relegated to the Op-Ed section. But journalists are experts in spin. You can spin an article in a million ways without explicitly stating an opinion. 1) Bury the lede. Make your argument above the fold, hold the counter arguments near the end. 2) Use sneaky language instead of numbers/statistics, unless the statistics support your position. 3) Misinform the public, then use polling of the misinformed public to push lies (one egregious example[0]) 4) Misrepresent a situation with technical truths that leave out pertinent behavior. 50 million USD in property damage in Minneapolis becomes 'some destruction of property by a small minority of protesters'. 5) Selectively fact-check 6) When mentioning a person you dislike, remind the reader of past controversies. 7) Use loaded language. A person you like 'punches back' a person you dislike 'lashes out'. A person you like 'gives an impassioned speech', while a person you dislike 'goes on a rant'. Someone you don't like is trustworthy "Person A says [yada yada]". Someone you don't like is suspect "Person A, without evidence, claims [yada yada]" 8) Editorialize the headline, include snark in headline. 9) People you like are described by their allies. People you dislike are described by their opponents. 10) Find anonymous 'sources' with convenient 'inside information' that always seem to support your biases. 11) Make statements as fact about the state of mindset of your opponents. You can say what they fear, when they're anxious, etc, with impunity. [0]https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/meet-the-press/majority-americans-say-they-expect-their-taxes-stay-same-or-n991416 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/meet-the-press/majority-ame...
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago>Objectivity has been dead for half a decade. Half a decade? 5 years?
- matt_s 6y agoThere is bias in selection of what news to print/air as well, I think that is more of a problem than objectivity inside of articles. Balance should come from covering sides of an issue, presenting facts, but from maybe multiple angles. Social media has brought about a factor of being first. First to report that so-and-so athlete signed with a team will trend better than an in depth or behind the scenes analysis on what happened. Maybe news companies should form a scoring system of sorts that they will hold themselves and each other to regarding journalistic integrity/objectivity. A certification of some kind. They could offer that to social media companies as a way to filter the un-certified junk. Some people might pay for that.
- Rochus 6y agoPublishing opinions and assumptions has always been cheaper than proper research. Obviously a large part of the content is also a "reuse" of other content (in plain language "copied"). The peak of this development is, in my opinion, when journalists even interview each other (instead of the actual sources). I no longer read the newspapers for this reason. The trees could be saved for better things.
- mvanga 6y agoNot entirely related to the article, but rather why I think we're seeing all these problems in journalism of late. The rise of the internet gatekeepers (Google, Facebook, Twitter) has forever destroyed the old business model for journalism. Today, in order to have any success at building an audience on these platforms, one needs to appease the algorithms that these gatekeepers employ. Unfortunately, their algorithms are designed to bring out the sinister side of human nature; tribalism, extremes of opinion, polarization. I suspect anyone that tries to stay on the neutral side of journalism will eventually be forced to pick a side to stay afloat. Not because of the gatekeepers themselves anymore, but because the gatekeepers have amplified qualities in all of us that have irreversibly changed individual behavior itself. I'm not sure of what can be done to ebb the tide. The problem is you can no longer look to fixing the gatekeepers. The real problem is how to turn back the clock on individual behavior en masse.
- Nasrudith 6y agoThe algorithms are a scapegoat for them sucking at their job. The news media was already a rotten corpse who couldn't even compete with bloggers in accuracy and fact checking. Rainbow parties, breathlessly publishing grudge slang made up wholecloth, and satanic ritual panic for one. Compounding that they were blind enough to use the youth and their hobbies as punching bags while getting the most basic details wrong. Then wonder why their demographics keep drifting older.
- cowpig 6y agoThis article is really interesting, but I think an important part of this that it didn't discuss is misinformation. The Chinese[1] and Russian[2] governments are known to be engaging in misinformation at a scale never seen before, and across geographic boundaries. Many other misinformation operations are also in force. Meanwhile, the primary source of news for a significant portion of the globe does little to combat it[3]. In fact it has an explicit policy of treating falsehoods the same as truth. That was never possible before the age of information, and I think it changes the landscape of news enough that it merits a place in this discussion. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party [2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2018/world/national-security/russian-propaganda-skripal-salisbury/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2018/world/national-... [3] https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/akz7qa/facebook-finally-agreed-to-a-civil-rights-audit-and-surprise-surprise-it-failed https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/akz7qa/facebook-finally-a...
- the-dude 6y agoWhy are you targetting China and Russia in particular? We have had Radio Free Europe, Iraqi Weapons of Mass-Destruction and smearing of Huawei. I know that is whataboutism, but what about it?
- cowpig 6y agoalways interested to learn about other misinformation machines, but your comment lacks sources
- Aunche 6y agoIt's ironic that you listed the Wikipedia entry as evidence the 50 cent army is engaging in disinformation at an international scale. The only cited source for this describes a Huffington Post commenter disagreeing with an article and the author claiming that the commenter is a paid Chinese shill.
- cowpig 6y agoHere are some more sources: https://www.propublica.org/article/how-china-built-a-twitter-propaganda-machine-then-let-it-loose-on-coronavirus https://www.propublica.org/article/how-china-built-a-twitter... https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/a-wuhan-writers-life-during-the-outbreak-censorship-misinformation-and-anger/2020/07/01/f2919df6-ab4a-11ea-9063-e69bd6520940_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/a-wuhan-writers-life-... https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/23/world/asia/china-hong-kong-propaganda.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/23/world/asia/china-hong-kon... https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2016/05/19/the-chinese-government-fakes-nearly-450-million-social-media-comments-a-year-this-is-why/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2016/05/1... https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-twitter-disinformation/twitter-takes-down-beijing-backed-influence-operation-pushing-coronavirus-messages-idUSKBN23I3A3 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-twitter-disinformat...
- martincmartin 6y agoThis exact same URL was submitted 13 hours earlier here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23853239 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23853239 Why wasn't the second submission redirected to the first? There's something about Hacker News submissions I don't understand. :(
- raxxorrax 6y ago> but to many the distinction between right and wrong now seems obvious. A new generation of journalists is questioning whether, in a hyper-partisan, digital world, objectivity is even desirable. They are part of the polarization because they profit from it and I think they are entertainers instead of journalists. They know how to channel the hysteria and lust to condemn. Maybe not by experience, but their metrics certainly would show it. Some moderately serious youtube channels are more in line with facts and many online articles became profoundly lacking. Granted, it was the users that clicked them. And certain topics were clicked by all political factions. Racism and sexism are popular topics here. Having an opinion doesn't need any qualification, so those topics can reach anyone. Engagement shows these articles are much more popular than boring politics. Of course the more left or libertarian inclined journalists deliver the better content than their conservative contemporaries with few exceptions. But I think it is the older generation that created that image. > American view-from-nowhere, ‘objectivity’-obsessed, both-sides journalism is a failed experiment,” tweeted Wesley Lowery, a Pulitzer-winning 30-year-old now at CBS News This price is probably given by click rate. So the most outrageous claim wins. Again, I can name bloggers that could compete... no, that are vastly more poignant to the matter at hand. Seriously, read the articles, they aren't really good, but judge yourself. > unconscious bias gas-lighting, original sin or completely useless information. It is like discussing free will where the quality of the wine is important, not the result. I think to have bias is completely fine, but I can still separate my perception of facts from my opinion. That isn't actually too hard. Won't ever be perfect, but beating online journalism isn't hard. > One is Donald Trump’s rise and the challenges it has posed to traditional reporting. I think the press is vastly responsible here too. It may actually be a good idea to vote a president the "4th estate" is critical of. An angle I would think is beyond Pulitzer price winners of today. > Objectivity has been “turned into a cartoon”, he said. Better to aim for values such as fairness, independence and empathy. Sure, here bias wouldn't matter... A few journalists still try at least. They often don't have large twitter followings but you are always shown a new perspective if you read their editorials, which indeed do give context to their articles. The perspective of the conventional journalist is utterly mundane in contrast. > Amid more diverse recruitment More racist recruitment is the objective description. Because race matters here. For most people it doesn't. > The final reason for the turn against objectivity is commercial Back to the start. Why did some journalists condemn Fox News for being a scam? Ah yes, none of you are in a position to do so anymore...
- rjkennedy98 6y agoOf course we have to get rid of objectivity, otherwise people couldn't claim obviously false assertions like publishing an op-ed “puts black @nytimes staff in danger.” In the spirit of the new AP guidelines which say “Do not use racially charged or similar terms as euphemisms for racist or racism when the latter terms are truly applicable,” let's have the same criteria for "Stalinism". What's going on is pure Stalinism.
- pnw_hazor 6y agoThe concept of objectivity is being attacked as being of white-supremacy culture or whiteness. https://nypost.com/2019/05/20/richard-carranza-held-doe-white-supremacy-culture-training/ https://nypost.com/2019/05/20/richard-carranza-held-doe-whit...
- beepboopbeep 6y agoThis is going to be a dumpster fire of opinions.
- trabant00 6y agoWhat is up with this nihilism? Ofc there is no such thing as perfect objectivity, democracy, justice, etc. But it's critical to strive for all these things! "Media has never been objective or impartial so might as well go for my political/moral stance and destroy everything else." Fight wrong with wrong, eh? No wrong tactics only wrong targets? This is progressive and "on the right side of history"? Don't go down that path, this is not what US ideals stand for. And yes, they are ideals, dreams, I know, but they make a huge difference when compared to what I lived under communism in eastern EU. The world is watching and copying everything it sees in the US. What you do matters more than you think.
- seneca 6y agoIt died in a wave of post-modernist thought crashing on the west. Post-modernists genuinely believe that objectivity is impossible. You'll see it in this very comment section, I'm sure. And, interestingly, at the core of it they're right. It's impossible for a human being to be truly objective. The value is in the pursuit of that ideal though, like many others, not in expecting to perfectly attain it. People seem to have lost that idea.
- shkkmo 6y agoAre you saying that the impossibility of objective truth is objectively true but effectively useless?
- seneca 6y agoI don't think I said anything objective truth, if it read that way I did a poor job. I am pretty far from believing that there is no objective truth. I was simply saying that there is merit to the idea that human beings themselves can not communicate objectively. Wittgenstein talked about it in a way I tend to agree with. Post-modernism runs wild with his ideas and ends up at things like "there is no objective truth".
- hirundo 6y agoIt's not new that news outlets aren't very objective. It is new that so many no longer aspire to be so. That aspiration has a lot of value, particularly where we fail to attain it. Two other areas where the same is true: color blindness and meritocracy. These things are worth striving for, especially where we fail at them. The recent trend of dismissing these things even as worthy goals is damaging to our collective pursuit of virtue.
- rdtwo 6y agoI wonder how we’re going to teach kids about goods sources. When the real news comes from blogs and tweets and the garbage comes from “news” agencies. I don’t think it’s really possible to filter out what’s real and what’s fake -perhaps it never was.
- simonkafan 6y agoNot sure if anyone here has heared about the case Claas Relotius before. Relotius was a German journalist mainly working for "Der Spiegel" and well known for his remarkable, well-written articles. He wrote primarily about civil war, refugee children, racism, often with a pillorying undertone about the heartbreaking cruel world we live in. His view of the world (which he incorporated subliminally into his articles) was well received in his circles; he was awarded over 19 prizes. Long story short: In 2018 was revealed that most of his articles were fake or embellished. He got away with it for so long because everyone _wanted_ the world to be the way he portrayed it, almost nobody looked closer. I think this is symptomatic of modern journalism: Many journalists are only interested in getting recognition in their circles, so they do whatever is necessary to get it, even if it means bending facts. This is also problematic because it casts a bad light on reputable journalists who reflect the events of the "boring" world correctly and not through lies or Hollywood stories.
- GenericsMotors 6y agoOne of the last drops in the bucket for him was his story about a town that voted for Trump: https://medium.com/@micheleanderson/der-spiegel-journalist-messed-with-the-wrong-small-town-d92f3e0e01a7 https://medium.com/@micheleanderson/der-spiegel-journalist-m... What made all this worse was the fact that Der Spiegel was looked up to for (supposedly) having a solid team of fact-checkers. As the medium post shows (and the magazine's own investigation afterwards) was that not even basic and publicly available info was checked, such as the percentage of pro-Trump voters, let alone the rest of the original article's hilariously ridiculous claims. Another Der Spiegel reporter who was suspicious of Relotius tried raising his concerns with the management after he did some digging of his own, which almost cost him his job and reputation: https://english.elpais.com/elpais/2019/02/26/inenglish/1551176169_246969.html https://english.elpais.com/elpais/2019/02/26/inenglish/15511... Der Spiegel enjoyed the profits of Relotius' fiction and peddled literal fake news to the world for years, and the magazine's readers lapped it all up because it reinforced their biases.
- CM30 6y ago> because everyone _wanted_ the world to be the way he portrayed it, almost nobody looked closer. This is definitely the real issue a lot of news sites/sources have now. They have an audience in mind, they and that audience have some ideas about what the world is like, and anything that conforms to that view isn't properly fact checked at all. If you want to get a hoax past any news outlet, make it a story that shows their ideological opponents in a bad light.
- belorn 6y agoI find it odd talking about objectivity in journalism without addressing the issue of narratives that create facts rather than facts creating a narrative. When a narrative is allowed to create facts what usually happens are lies which represent bias of the author and publication (which is supposed to fact check). The article talk both about alternative facts and value loaded language, but outside of intended bias where news paper are directly involved with a political party, narrative generated facts are likely the culprit for most alternative facts. Looking at old news papers I think I see much less of narrative designed articles. It might still be biased for all I know, but they seems to be less about trying to tell me a coherent narrative that will draw me in and more about writing up what happened and who said what. The stories seems to generally lack narrative structure, and maybe that allows the author to avoid falling into the trap of filling in facts which does not exist.
- pcmaffey 6y agoPeople mistake a desire for politically moderate journalism with objective journalism. How do you objectify atrocities, corruption, lying etc without coming across as politically opposite the perpetrators? The simple act of reporting becomes political.
- m1aw 6y agoI have been search for quite a while for a service that I could subscribe (pay) to get a list of high quality, information dense, writing, about current world events. I haven't yet found anything that I would be satisfied with. I looked at Substack but most journalist there seem to be basically running blogs.
- crazygringo 6y agoI mean, that's the Economist, literally the publication this article is from. There's literally no other English-language news publication for a general educated readership that is higher quality, denser, and focused on the whole world rather than any single country.
- yosito 6y agoI stopped getting my news from social media, and started subscribing to The Economist and the Financial Times.
- m1aw 6y agoI read the Economist from time to time, never subscribed, but always seems to be a bit longer, trying to give some sort of opinion even if very politically unbiased then I would want. I straight up just want to get a list of things that happened and some context information. I can do research on the topic if I find worth the time.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoReuters doesn't make you pay, but it's pretty good. I'm not sure how it is for UK news, but for world and US news it seems to be pretty straight.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Digit-Al 6y agoI've thought a lot about the plight of newspapers, but still struggle to get my thoughts into black and white. I apologise if this ends up overly wordy and/or makes no sense at all. The way I see it the newspapers are now facing an existential crisis, and I personally see no easy way forward for them. Print sales have been on the decline for the last 20 years and with it a decline in their ability to sell valuable advertising. I think we all know that newspaper prices are subsidised by advertising, so falling advertising sales, will inevitably lead to a rise in newspaper prices. With online advertising dominated by the big internet companies that leaves a small slice of the pie for the newspaper publishers, and correspondingly a need to chase the algorithms to try to get clicks. This, inevitably, is leading to a race to the bottom to chase every last penny of advertising. The only way to save themselves is to get people to pay for journalism, but this presents many obstacles. Nobody wants to pay for anything on the internet - we have all been trained to expect everything for free. Even those of us who are willing (and financially able) to pay for journalism now have an expectation of being able to access a variety of sources and won't necessarily want to pay for subscriptions to a variety of publications. Far too expensive. Unfortunately, a paid news aggregation site seems like a pipe dream right now. No publication wants to lose their brand under someone else's banner; and you can't really blame them for that. Even if you could find a way, no one would be able to agree how payment should work. A payment per article click would just lead to a similar situation to today, with click-bait headlines designed to draw you into clicking on poor quality articles. We all know that micro-payments haven't managed to make any kind of traction. So we have the current situation where those publications that do have quality journalism have a hard time getting reader attention away from a deluge of click-bait articles designed to stir base emotions so they will be shared widely by incensed readers, thus earning more money. Those that can are having a hard time finding funding, usually relying on a mixture of advertising, begging for reader donations, and paywalls. Meanwhile, the industry as a whole is on a slow death spiral whilst readers are begging for ways to get articles from a wide variety of sources at a fair price, but no one can think of any feasible way to offer this. That's my own personal, probably biased and non-objective, view on the situation. What do you all think? Am I right? Wrong? A complete idiot? I'd love some feedback. Something else I'd love to know: how many of you out there have subscriptions to one or more news publications or make donations to a small news publication?
- iagovar 6y agoHm, I expected more of the article. I did my thesis for my bachelors degree about the agenda-setting theory, with nothing really remarkable, but learned a lot in the process. So here are my takes. > A new generation of journalists is questioning whether, in a hyper-partisan, digital world, objectivity is even desirable. Journalists that use their position as a way of aggressively pushing an agenda are not outliers nowadays. I'm not sure about the US, but in Spain this people reads Gramsci & Laclau and similar people, or it's familiar with their theory. When I stumble upon news that smell like propaganda I always do the same, see who wrote the piece, look at his name in social media, and 99,9% of the times is someone who's actually very partisan of his particular ideas. I've donde this with Spanish and US news with similar success, not so much with Portuguese and French (maybe cos I have a lower understanding of the environment), but still. This people is not even trying. You could argue that everyone defaults to his biases and we do a very good job of tricking ourselves but IMO there seems to be a conscious effort of framing and priming information, and as a broad patter of behavior in journalism. In my particular case, when I watch or read mainstream news, I do it almost as an anthropologic exercise, what they want people to think about? How they want people to think about it? There are so many instances of propaganda that it's not worth to filter any more. I just go to some finance, niche blogs or specialized publications when available. > And so objectivity became journalism’s new lodestar. As Lippmann put it, the journalist should “remain clear and free of his irrational, his unexamined, his unacknowledged prejudgments in observing, understanding and presenting the news.” And > A study for the API in 2018 found that 75% of Americans could easily tell news from opinion in their favoured outlet, but only 43% could on Twitter or Facebook. The problem is that people in newsrooms are perfectly aware on how news are consumed today, so they mix information and opinion in their pieces and their opt-in channels which is typically social media.
- JanneVee 6y ago> The final reason for the turn against objectivity is commercial. The shift away from partisanship a century ago was driven partly by advertisers. Today, as ad revenues leak away to search engines and social networks, newspapers have come to rely more on paying readers. Unlike advertisers, readers love opinion. Readers love opinion? How do they know this? Is it because Ezra Klein said so in the following sentences, that people want to be coddled by their media?
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoIt seems obvious. Hannity, Carlson, and Ingraham are the top rated “news” programs. All are opinion shows, not straight news.
- JanneVee 6y agoJust because some opinion shows "top rated" it doesn't necessarily mean that "news reader" audience like to be treated the same way. Right? Somewhere I would like to have a little more qualification to that a "reading audience likes to read opinions".
- cik 6y agoThe increasing integration of the news cycle and social media serves to opinionize objectivity. If the notion of social media is tribes, and tribal adherence/management/connectivity managed by upvotes and downvotes one can logically assume "engagement" on social media if tracked by upvotes just exacerbates this example. It would be more interesting if engagement on the newsroom side were met by the combination of actions (i.e up, down, retweet, reads, etc). At the same time that ultimately means that articles are now aiming for engagement - at the very least confrontational opinions and thoughts would be measured as "interesting". This is dangerous thought control popularized.
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/0Vyx0 https://archive.is/0Vyx0
- jacquesm 6y agoSocial media disrupted journalism in a way that can only be described as a net negative. Tbh it was headed that way with news cycles getting ever shorter. Twitter and other sites like it (including this one) have shortened that to the minimum we can achieve today given the tech available. Within minutes any idiot with a megaphone can make themselves heard with a voice that is just as loud as a carefully researched piece of work, and quite possibly reach more people if the right trigger buttons are pushed. Democracy has survived quite a few assaults, let's hope that if the 5th estate dies it will manage to hang on. I get a lot of mileage out of social media but it isn't without its problems and they're hard to solve. But TV and before it radio (and before that print) were quite disruptive in their own right and depending on who you ask the outcome was fine.
- gHosts 6y agoSupposedly https://www.britishpathe.com/ https://www.britishpathe.com/ was an icon of journalistic objectivity in it's day. Today it looks like an icon of British Imperialist jingoism.