7 ms·
>> is needed to make the Raptor's super maneuverability a reality. The term is "Supermaneuverability"... all one word. This is characterized as post-stall, so
by sandworm101 6y ago
>> is needed to make the Raptor's super maneuverability a reality.
The term is "Supermaneuverability"... all one word. This is characterized as post-stall, sometimes called "non-aerodynamic" controlled flight. In short, it means the aircraft remains under pilot control even after the flow has separated from the wing (aka a stall).
The 22 is not considered supermaneuverable by many. It can use thrust vectoring and some fly-by-wire tricker to ape supermaneuverability but it pales in comparison to many russian aircraft. The 22's wing becomes very unpredictable in stall, hence the need for all the fly by wire. It was meant for flying fast in a strait line, and for stealth. It was never meant for things like Kobras or Kulbits. That it could eventually do them was an afterthought. The Russian aircraft have wings designed for slow speed/high AOA maneuverability.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kulbit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kulbit
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jks6TTFsglk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jks6TTFsglk
Kulbit / Chakra at about 05:20 and again at 06:20. Note how slow/tight the show is. An f-22 could never perform repeated maneuvers like this in such a confined space.
- scarier 6y agoTo add on, supermaneuverabillity looks really cool and is an impressive technical achievement for sure, but its utility in combat (at least for the time being) is likely low to negative. Among other reasons, the more players in a fight, the less anyone can afford to sell all their energy for a shot opportunity--even if it works, it leaves them extremely vulnerable.
- stouset 6y agoThis 100%. While really cool demonstrations, the utility of these in a fight is virtually nonexistent. Any air-to-air engagements these days are inevitably BVR (beyond visual range) encounters, where aircraft fire missiles at one-another from extreme ranges. This type of maneuverability has no use whatsoever in such a scenario. If all of the long-range missiles fail to neutralize one side of the other and both forces opt to continue the engagement, you get to WVR (within visual range) where infrared missiles and—once those are spent—guns are employed. There could be opportunities here where such a trick might be useful, but only in a 1v1 scenario. For any case where you might have two or more enemies to deal with, such an abrupt loss of energy is suicide. And if you’re on the side with superior numbers, the odds are overwhelmingly in your favor with little chance of you being defensive in the first place. And in the 1v1 scenario, modern infrared missiles like the AIM-9x (which are effective even when launched at frankly ridiculous off-boresight angles) make such a maneuver suicide as well. So it might, might be useful if: both sides empty their long/medium-range radar-guided missiles at one-another, only two combatants remain, neither decides to bug out, the aggressor empties their IR missiles unsuccessfully, and the defensive craft is imminently going to be within the weapon employment zone for the bandit’s cannon… then this might be a Hail Mary to force the aggressor to overshoot so you can turn the tables. But having bled all your energy, you’re going to get at most one shot before you’re back to simply trying to survive.
- Firehawke 6y agoMost fights will inevitably go from BVR to WVR-- ECM is continually in a war of escalation with munitions and ECM is almost always ahead.
- scarier 6y agoThis is a really interesting topic for debate. Possibly the most recent employment of modern air-to-air tactics we've seen in actual combat was in the early '80s (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Mole_Cricket_19 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Mole_Cricket_19). I hope we never have to see an actual large-scale air war between high-end, near-peer competitors, and can continue to armchair debate these kinds of scenarios.
- trhway 6y agoSpeaking about ECM and the Bekaa battle, a kind of similar situation has just happened in the recent months - Turkey found a way for their drones to effectively attack Russian "Pantsir-S1" anti-aircraft system (details aren't clear, seems that in addition to ECM the drone specific aspects like long loitering waiting for opportunity and simultaneous multiple drone attack from different directions played key role), and around 30 Pantsirs have just been lost in Syria and Libya. (Sidenote: Ukraine has recently got those drones from Turkey and successfully tested against Pantsir - Pantsirs are standard air defense of Russian tank battalions and was the main reason Ukraine, who has nor stealth nor high precision standoff, didn't use the air-to-ground attacks against the Russian tank forces when they ventured into Donbass back then in August 2014 and February 2015)
- Diesel555 6y agoIt has very little combat usage, there's a reason the Raptor doesn't do it. Any time you see an aircraft do some high AOA (Angle of Attack) maneuver and provide almost zero line of site (not moving up / down / left / right), you know he's slow and you've won the fight if you have airspeed (assuming gun only). The only benefit would be to get an IR missile off when you've already realized you are losing and he's behind you.
- scarier 6y ago>The only benefit would be to get an IR missile off when you've already realized you are losing and he's behind you. Bummer the Raptor driver doesn't have JHMCS...
- sudosysgen 6y agoJHMCS isn't that useful in such extreme off-axis situations. A missile taking a big turn requires it to expend a lot of energy and drastically hampers its probability to hit the target.
- Diesel555 6y agoI mean for the Russian driver. And yes... bummer... but who can turn their neck that far? Don't forget eyeball gimbals don't count.
- scarier 6y agoMaybe they'll start adding certain neck mobility requirements in the anthropometric screening? It's a brave new world...
- burfog 6y agoA reasonable use would be for checking out a slow little biplane or helicopter, presumably a foolish civilian, who is violating restricted airspace.
- scarier 6y ago
- sudosysgen 6y agoNot necessarily. In a reality where your missiles have a huge delta-v and acceleration advantage against the enemy, while your plane itself is deficient in energy generation and retention, supermaneouvrability might be a logical and effective option. Indeed, if you're a Russian Su-27 that just shot off two R-77 at targets at the cost of its energy, you just forced two of your opponents to disengage and lose all of their useful energy as well as targeting opportunities, and they might even be shot down. Evading a missile is so costly in terms of energy and opportunity that getting a shot off by sacrificing your energy can be viable. After all, if you've got a missile on your tail you're not much of a threat anymore. If there are many enemies, not only are you not much of a threat but you're soon dead.
- scarier 6y agoAre we talking F-pole/A-pole tactics or WVR stuff?
- Diesel555 6y agoHow many fighter pilots lurk hacker news?
- scarier 6y agoI think I've seen a handful here...
- thaeli 6y agoProbably a few actual fighter pilots, and quite a few more simulator enthusiasts who know a lot about the mechanics.
- atlgator 6y agoOr perhaps even those that built the flight simulators that trained the pilots. Now we’ve come full circle.
- sandworm101 6y ago
- TwoBit 6y agoSeems like the classic problem of Russians doing something because it's impressive and not because it's a good idea.
- scarier 6y agoTo be fair, the same systems that enable supermaneuverability typically enhance "normal" maneuverability as well. I don't think the Russian engineers were designing these systems specifically for awesome-looking airshow maneuvers and 1v1 BFM.
- sandworm101 6y agoBFM... a less-than-common phrase online but very common on the DFS.
- KingOfCoders 6y agoHow can an ability be negative? I can always decide to not use it?
- scarier 6y agoIn the sense that the advantages you get from using it could be outweighed by the risks you incur by using it. All else being equal, supermaneuverability is great to have, but when you start looking at design tradeoffs (e.g. canards being great for maneuverability but poor for stealth, the added weight and complecity of TVC) it's not necessarily an advantage.
- burfog 6y agoYou can stall with lots of energy, up in the coffin corner. The U-2 pilots commonly fly there. Going slower or turning too much will produce a stall, but going faster can hit never-exceed speed limits. Supermaneuverabillity would make that portion of the flight envelope much less hazardous.
- scarier 6y agoA supermaneuverable U-2 would be... interesting. I wonder if that would reduce pilot workload or increase it? The engineer in me would suggest a robust automatic flight control system system instead, although considering how insane the procurement process can be, I'm admittedly not all that confident it would save money in the long run.
- jasonwatkinspdx 6y agoI'm not a engineer but it seems infeasible to me to create a U2 variant with wings strong enough for such maneuvering. They shaved every ounce they could off those things.
- Symmetry 6y agoEspecially with the introduction of off-boresight missiles that don't require the plane to be facing the target to launch at them like the AIM-9X.
- benburleson 6y agoI grew up with Top Gun, so I get excited thinking about dog fighting, but in the context of 2020 and cyber warfare, is there really much value in air combat? When is the last time two sides actually engaged fighter jets? I'm probably blissfully unaware how relevant they are, but it just feels like a massive waste of money continuing to build these projects.
- z3phyr 6y ago> When is the last time two sides actually engaged fighter jets? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_India%E2%80%93Pakistan_border_skirmishes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_India%E2%80%93Pakistan_bo...
- Sebb767 6y ago> but in the context of 2020 and cyber warfare, is there really much value in air combat? Technical fights are surely relevant, but in the worst case you can 'simply' unplug your overseas fibres and be done with it. Also, if someone simply marches/flies in and destroys your IXPs, your technical superiority gets irrelevant pretty quick. So, you really need to keep up technically with your possible foes. Additionally, it also serves as a demonstration of strength and industry funding. So fighter jets won't be going anywhere, soon.
- ohazi 6y ago> This is characterized as post-stall, sometimes called "non-aerodynamic" controlled flight. i.e. "Falling with style"
- slim 6y agoplus Sukhois are the most beautiful combat aircrafts ever built
- LoSboccacc 6y ago> Kulbit / Chakra at about 05:20 that was done at an extremely slow speed; if it'd be viable at mach, it'd be interesting, as it could throw off a missile target guidance's prediction, but I seriously doubt the wings could survive it at speed, and as such, it looks mostly like a cool party trick at best and a vestigial requirement from previous wars at worst.
- hn_check 6y agoMost of those Russian jets have thrust vectoring as well. They also have fly by wire. Further, these are airshow maneuvers that would never be used in actual combat, being effectively a novelty. Thrust vectoring is critical for high speed maneuvers as well. "It was meant for flying fast in a strait line, and for stealth." It was meant for air supremacy, and after having seen it performing maneuvers that F15s and F16s could only dream of, this notion that it's somehow some second-rate to Russia jets using precisely the same sneaky tricks (thrust vectoring, fly-by-wire) is absurd nonsense.
- jacobush 6y agoThat’s beautiful, goosebumps all over.
- x86_64Ubuntu 6y agoWould a Kulbit ever be used in combat?
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoWow, that video was so cool, thanks for sharing! Still, echoing the other commenters, I can't see how that has any utility in modern warfare.