12 ms·
Colleges are reopening in fall, but many professors won’t be present
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- outoftheabyss 6y agoI’m doing a distance data science degree at a fraction of the cost and I would imagine I’m getting much more out of it than this September intake will. There’s been a revolution in remote working, will education follow?
- ketanmaheshwari 6y agoCould you post the link to the degree that you're taking.
- blackrock 6y agoI hope the education is free. Because without the human presence, paying $250,000 USD for a university education sounds like a ripoff.
- brighton36 6y agoEven with the human presence. There's so much unneeded bundling - these campuses have turned into prestige factories.
- watwut 6y agoAs opposed to which exactly the year and country?
- brighton36 6y agoAs opposed to which... What? Colleges used to manufacture knowledge.
- watwut 6y agoThey still do manufacture knowledge. This part was always by employees.
- brighton36 6y agoThen, the prestige it sells, is probably not all that legitimate.
- chrisseaton 6y agoIs anyone genuinely paying a quarter of a million dollars for a degree? That seems extreme even for a non-scholarship medical doctorate degree, let alone a simple data-science degree.
- DreadY2K 6y agoI'm a current college student, and my school costs about $80k per year, counting tuition, room & board, supplies, etc., before financial aid. That would be $320k for 4 years, well over a quarter of a million. I'm personally getting a significant amount of financial aid, so that it will end up costing much less than that for me, but I know people who are paying full price. EDIT: I'm an undergrad at a 4-year university.
- chrisseaton 6y agoObviously I believe you if you're saying that, but I've heard that nobody really pays these full sticker-prices and everyone's really getting some kind of aid unless they're literally a billionaire - is that not the case?
- HaloZero 6y agoI don't think so? I did a lot of tax work for VITA and met a lot of parents. Mostly low income and low-middle income got full scholarships and grants but if you're middle class it highly depends on the institution. The larger schools with huge private endowment do cover a lot but a public school like any in the UC system? Nah. It's basically all loans which have to be paid back. *My knowledge is limited to California in the United States. I know there exists programs in Georgia and other places that do cover full rides but I think they are anomalous and not the rule.
- drfuchs 6y agoTypically, in the Ivy League / Stanford, a one-child family with annual income of over $150k to $200k (depending on the school) will pay full tuition. Really. And incomes of less than $65k-ish get you a free ride. Details vary.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- atemerev 6y agoI am a researcher and a lecturer in a Swiss university. Switzerland is famous for being expensive, and the reputation is well deserved. However, the price of education for our students is about $1200/year. Which includes famous schools like EPFL (where Scala was born and still developed) and ETH (which contributions to computer science are too many to mention here). The students can e.g. collaborate with CERN researchers as part of their projects. For $1200/year. Available for everyone regardless of their nationality. The best part is that for many master degrees and some bachelor degrees you can study remotely while living in your own country, only coming to Switzerland once or twice a year. I don’t know why there are so few American students studying outside the US. (We do have some Canadian and Australian students though).
- mdorazio 6y agoBe careful in your assumptions here. Online degrees still carry a huge negative stigma with them (which is interesting given that all students in the current cohorts at normal universities will have had several semesters of remote learning). Signalling of the college brand is also largely underappreciated by online students. You're getting a degree for a fraction of the cost of an in-person one, but it may or may not also carry a fraction of the job market value. Note: I do not know which school you are referring to. It might be Berkeley's $70k+ degree or one of the many lower-tier schools, so YMMV.
- ckdarby 6y agoI believe they're specifically talking about data science and fields related? I'm a prior software development manager and degrees in general in this kind of field don't carry much weight outside of academic hires and very select companies. While some companies or hiring managers might frown upon this it doesn't matter if there is an active hiring group that doesn't put any weight on them. I guess one could argue that the ones who frown upon the degree pay more competitive but I've only found the opposite to be true with my experience. (I'm ignoring FAANG because they're so unique that they're an exception to everything in the "real world")
- mdorazio 6y agoI'm specifically talking about data science as well. My experience has been pretty much the opposite of yours. Data science boot camps and online programs have been cranking out grads for a few years now, so the base credential isn't all that valuable anymore. The big companies I work with are specifically looking for traditional degrees from Top 20ish colleges. On the other hand, it's probably quite different with smaller companies and especially non-unicorn startups.
- bllguo 6y agowow, berkeley has a $70k online DS program?? Does your comment change re: stigma if OP was in fact talking about said berkeley degree?
- generationP 6y ago> What [the students] might not expect: a lack of professors in the classroom. Maybe they might not expect it, but will they mind it?
- 1996 6y agoCollege currently sell an "experience" with clubs, restaurants, football teams, fraternities, housing, a nice campus with trees and lakes, etc. This isn't free. It has pushed up the price of education. If education turns remote, I would expect prices to fall (and layoffs for the administrative staff), unless a similar experience part can be replicated online (which I strongly doubt) This is the exact opposite of work vs remote work: if WFH becomes the default, I would expect wages to rise, as the most "experience" provided in the workplace (with nice offices, nice chairs, window view, in a nice campus with amenities like catering etc) will be footed by the employee in a WFH setting
- walterbell 6y ago> most "experience" provided in the workplace (with nice offices, nice chairs, window view, in a nice campus with amenities like catering etc) will be footed by the employee in a WFH setting Will these expenses be as tax deductible for WFH employees as they are for business? Is live/work zoning common?
- nradov 6y agoIf working from home becomes the default then wages will fall because employers will be able to select employees who live anywhere. Working in a physical office constrains the labor supply to workers who live nearby (or are able to relocate).
- deathcalibur 6y agoThis could work both ways. Workers have more options for employment meaning they can jump to a higher paying job without having to uproot their life.
- ativzzz 6y agoIt will fall for people living in high cost areas like SF and NYC, but it will rise for people living in low and mid cost areas like Dallas or Cleveland because now companies in SF can easily hire the best developers in Dallas cheaper than average developers in SF by paying them more than the average Dallas rates.
- gbronner 6y agoThis is looking more and more like an extinction event for academia. Elite institutions can charge whatever they want for their brand name and selectivity, and for the environment of other equally motivated high potential students. Other schools combine a school with a resort/cruise ship experience. Insofar as the school is no better than a bunch of videos, and the resort is mostly shut down, so long as employers don't care, it will be hard to justify spending 10x on a residential experience. With live teaching going the way of life musicians 100 years ago, we can expect similar effects- fewer better teachers, and better access to them.
- dredmorbius 6y agoI'm leaning more strongly to "major impact / selection event / paradigm shift" than extinction. Education generally, and universities specifically, are highly durable institutions which have undergone massive changes over time, whilst retaining recognizable elements from their origins. Specific universities are remarkably durable, with the oldest (Bologna, Oxford, Salamanca, Cambridge) dating to the 11th and 12th centuries (Bologna will be 1,000 years old in 2088, within the lifetime of some now reading this). (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_oldest_universities_in_continuous_operation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_oldest_universities_in...) Curricula, degrees conferred, methods, organisation, associated attached sport and medical industries, and defence and research programmes ... are largely newer. Starting with the Humboldtian reforms in Germany in the early 19th century, much of what we now think of as the modern universiy started taking shape (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Humboldtian_model_of_higher_education https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Humboldtian_model_of_higher_ed...) In-place instruction of both explicit and tacit knowledge, remains the most effective method attained. Mediated education, whether through old low-tech such as books, or high, such VR headsets, may have their affordances, but simply cannot match the full immersion of simultaneous group presence. More so for tacit knowledge in which simply ingesting words is not sufficient, where hands-on experience is required, and equipment, facilities, and materials needed. There are several fundamental functions of the universiy which seem unlikely to vanish. Education; credentialling; open research; establishing curricula and pedagogy; relations with culture, industry, and government, document archival, basic research; keeping aging academics off the streets; and serving as transition institutions four young adults entering the world, all remain. No doubt individual campuses or systems will collapse, and many revered traditions will be abandoned, at least temporarily. How this is accomplished given a few months, or years, or decades, of endemic disease, is a challenge. The institution's seen worse.
- ThA0x2 6y agoI wonder what this will do to the huge amount of dead weight in University administration. I imagine the demand for useless positions like "head of diversity and inclusion" will dry up, further driving the costs down.
- sumoboy 6y agoSo many of these teachers have become unqualified to teach remote classes since they can't adapt to virtual engagement to help students succeed. They don't answer emails, don't chat, leaving students lost. You get more from a youtube video in many cases. Remote teaching has made these teachers lazy IMO.
- jasonv 6y agoI agree, based on this: My high-school aged son was taking two in-person community college classes this last semester. When the SIP hit, his Spanish class just "ended". Nothing online, nothing from his teacher, it was just over. His math teacher worked diligently to keep things going, and I could see the adaptations the math teacher attempted to evolve his efforts with the unexpected conditions. If the CC is only online in the fall, we'll find something else for him. I don't think v1.0 of online CC is worth spending my money on, based on the v0.9 beta.
- oarsinsync 6y agoI’m not sure it’s fair to characterise a change in circumstances as severe as what we’ve just been through, and the results of remote work, as a v0.9 beta. MVP feels fairer, and even that feels like a stretch for a lot of places.
- jasonv 6y agoPossibly -- but where a CC has a lot of adjunct profs, not staff, I'm not sure they're going to solve a lot of their issues over the summer. Perhaps at a University, where tenured staff.. and those in the tenure-track, are likely to take the changed circumstances as a mandate to adjust and adapt. One consideration we've had is signing him up for classes, and making a determination pretty quickly about how online-instruction ready the instructors he ends up with are. If we can drop enrollment for no, or little, $ outlay, we may give it a shot. But our alternative -- returning to a tutor we used some time ago -- could be a more secure option, unless he's booked full. Which could be the case.
- coronadisaster 6y ago
- mtgp1000 6y agoThis is good. I think the commoditization of college had profound negative effects on society. Historic trust in the academic system was abused in order to, at best, sell degrees to people who were unqualified for them, and at worst, to indoctrinate two generations of children (anything outside of STEM is heavily politically slanted - it's the long march through the institutions that the infamous Weather Underground spoke of). If intelligence (and general ability) is truly normally distributed then you cannot award degrees to the majority of the population without lowering historic standards.
- analbumcover 6y agoYou make a lot of good points here. What is expected of students in University these days is a joke compared to historical standards. Ironic given the more demanding job market expectations.
- acwan93 6y agoScott Galloway of NYU called it, and has been increasingly louder about it. Like he says, it seems like this is the turning point for many middle-tier universities. Once you start viewing colleges as brands and luxury goods, especially the Stanfords and Harvards, it becomes clear there’s a massive revenue shortfall for them. >This fall, I’m scheduled to teach MKTG-GB.2365 (Brand Strategy) in KMC 2-60 Tuesday nights at 6-9pm. It’s not going to happen. The room would normally be filled with 170 full- and part-time MBAs looking to garner the skills to build economic security for themselves and their families, and improve the world. Mostly the former. However, a room full of 170 NYT subscribers, sitting elbow to elbow, spells one thing — recurrence. So, while Liberty University will likely welcome kids back to campus, I speculate we, and anybody else that does not have their head up their a, will not. https://www.profgalloway.com/post-corona-higher-ed https://www.profgalloway.com/post-corona-higher-ed
- sys_64738 6y agoOnline classes simply don't have the value that in person classes have. Extend that to degrees and that's the stigma you have to deal with when trying to get a job. Telling an employer you got your degree remotely V the in class person, who are you gonna hire?
- unishark 6y ago> Online classes simply don't have the value that in person classes have. I certainly agree with this (people aren't that stupid). But schools like Stanford and USC have been doing online MS programs for decades. As far as I know they are are just as valuable to your resume as an in-person MS from the same school. The value is in the fact that your average student simply doesn't have the self-motivation to do fully-online classes (we certainly have been seeing this problem in the last few months). This is why they primarily have been for working professions part-time in the past, that's a group and mode of learning where people actually get it done.
- pyuser583 6y agoI’ve benefited immensely from online education, but it’s not a substitute for an in person liberal arts education.
- scarface74 6y agoIf you tell someone you got the online masters from Georgia Tech, no one would look down on it. I can’t speak for other online masters. https://omscs.gatech.edu/ https://omscs.gatech.edu/
- noir_lord 6y agoI’ve been in a position that was involved in hiring. I’d count an open university degree as equal or better than most universities. Anyone who can work full time, study for a degree and often manage family life is worth a good look all other things been equal.
- OminousWeapons 6y ago> Online classes simply don't have the value that in person classes have. I think one question worth asking is what would happen if we blended both? Would it be possible to have a community college charge community college prices but work off of other peoples' excellent material? Imagine a CS 101 course where the lectures, problem sets, and tests were from MIT's Open Courseware, TAs were on site to hold sessions and help you, and a domain expert or professor was providing supplementary material and answering questions during recorded lectures. Sure it wouldn't be a stand in for MIT for many reasons, but it would probably give you a better education than most schools for a fraction of typical mid tier school pricing.
- dicomdan 6y agoLet the students network and collaborate with each other. Classes and office hours can be done online. Value of universities is primarily in peer interactions.
- vgchh 6y agoFor universities to fully crumble and education to become significantly cheaper, in addition to all the advancements that have occurred in last decade, I believe we need a credible way to certify students online. Imagine if someone sitting in Tibet or slums of Bombay could prove to Googles of the world that he/she (and not some hired help) successfully completed a highly ranked test online, it could be transformative. If online testing could vouch for a person in the same way that universities do, it could open the doors to world-class opportunities for the entire world, cheaply.
- wongarsu 6y agoOnline tests are wide open to cheating if they aren't taken in person. Hybrids exist (take online test in a testing center, e.g. AWS certifications), but aren't all that useful for the slums of Bombay. And in a way Google is already doing this in person with their interview process: they ask obscure questions aimed at knowlege gained in a computer science degree (or by good test preparation).
- vsskanth 6y agotaking tests in a testing center is actually pretty viable and scales well. This is primarily how all those international students from developing countries write GRE, TOEFL and end up coming to study in the US.
- crimsonalucard5 6y ago>they ask obscure questions aimed at knowlege gained in a computer science degree (or by good test preparation). I don't think this is the focus of their questions. Their questions are more like IQ tests with a CS spin. The knowledge itself is trivial, it's how you use that knowledge to solve problems.
- jki275 6y agoProctortrak. It’s not a perfect solution (and I despise it), but it does resolve a lot of those issues.
- creato 6y ago
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/D6RKy https://archive.is/D6RKy
- gruglife 6y agoI’m an adjunct prof at a middle tier college. We have a couple classes planned to be in person for fall. I highly doubt it. Plus a majority of the student body is foreign and can’t even travel to the USA. Essentially I’m sayin RIP to middle of the road universities. Guess I need to start looking for another side hustle.
- ghaff 6y agoNot everyone is in a position to do it. And I don't know what the position of universities in deferring will be at this point. And obviously gap year options that are constructive/interesting are way limited at the moment. But I'd have to seriously consider if it makes sense to enter a university as a freshman in September. Especially given a non-trivial possibility of things blowing up mid-semester with all sorts of attendant costs. Obviously a really really tough decision. And this will probably result in a lot of students not entering or completing college which, despite some of the common wisdom in tech, will probably lead to some pretty severe downgrades to lifetime career opportunities and income to many.
- davesque 6y agoAs a full-time resident of Boulder, CO (college town), this seems like an impossible situation. I can well imagine that the university here is under heavy pressure from local government to hold classes in the fall. This is because going a semester without all the students/faculty will be disastrous for the town's economy. On the other hand, the increase in coronavirus cases will also be disastrous. I don't have an answer. But, as a person who recently bought their first home in the area, I'm pretty bummed at the prospect of the local economy collapsing.
- kleinsch 6y agoWe’re moving to Boulder next month. With houses starting at $800K and larger houses going for $1.5M+, it seems like the local economy must be driven as much by the tech companies that flocked to Boulder bc of the school as by the school itself.
- davesque 6y agoI've lived here for about 30 years and I really doubt Boulder would last long without the university. And when I said "home", I meant condo, not house. The average tech employee in Boulder is still a long way away from house ownership in town. The real estate prices are not primarily explained by the tech scene.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xenonite 6y agoUsually, the tech companies in college cities are driven by university graduates. It is not hard to guess what happens after a while.
- ashtonkem 6y agoBoulder at least is relatively well to do and has close economic ties to Denver, a lot of other college towns would be economically worse off if college stayed close. Lafayette Indiana (Purdue) and Athens Ohio (OU) come to mind, although there are others.
- gumby 6y agoI suspect there will evolve a hybrid model: - a small number of elite institutions will offer largely the same product they do today, possibly in lower volume but even higher price. Some lectures will be online, combined with in person recitation, lab etc. - these same institutions’ lectures will be available online, perhaps for free or paid. Why get a lecture from state U when you can get the MIT lecture? - local third parties will offer the recitation, lab etc. Perhaps you’ll go to a completely independent one, perhaps you’ll attend one that has licensed the GAtech name or has some sort of reciprocity deal in order to proctor exams and such. - the networking value of school attendance will vanish except at the elite places. - a few professors, the ones actually presenting the lecture, will earn a living wage, or perhaps even a significant wage. Everybody else student-facing in this ecosystem will earn adjunct/ post doc barely-living wage. - even the recitations could be conducted online, perhaps by third parties in India who can explain the material just as well or better than someone local. You could be getting 1:1 instruction his way.
- ckdarby 6y agoThis is the con of universities. The only way to justify the tuition is face-to-face teaching and to have access to all those amenities. Once you remove those students would be asking for price reduction.
- tw1912112 6y agoRecently I read a post about education that was quite resonating. Universities have historically been "hard to enter, but easy to exit", meaning it's really difficult to get in but about the only thing that matter is getting in and no one really cares what your grades are if you are from Stanford/Harvard et.al. On the flip side, med school or west point are less about getting in but more about exit value. It's not really that important as to whether you got in but whether you graduated from West Point. West Point / Navy Seals can essentially double the class size without losing any credibility. I think higher education is going in similar direction.
- qserasera 6y agoAdministrative bloat and lax student standards should be geared up for older students and retraining during structural changes happening in the economy (right fucking now) Sadly administrators have no skills to retrain people.
- _Understated_ 6y agoI find it odd that even now, after all that's happened in recent months, and with the reserves of cash that some of the elite establishments (in the US at least) are not taking advantage of online degrees. To give you an example. I am planning on starting a degree in October. I'm 45. It will be through the Open University. It will cost about £6000 to complete the degree. I looked at a ton of Universities in the UK and their online offerings are abysmal. there are some in Europe that look ok but the US ones are in the $30k+ price range... If I thought that Yale, Harvard etc. would do an online degree for a fraction of what an actual degree currently costs in person, I would jump at the chance... who wouldn't want that on their CV? With the resources they have they could easily extend their degree programme to the rest of the world via online learning. Same lecturers, same material. Instead, they're sitting on their hands while their entire foundation burns... I agree with one of the other comments that this could be the beginning of the end for the bricks and mortar universities
- Google234 6y agoA big part of the brand/prestige of Yale and Harvard is the exclusivity.
- _Understated_ 6y agoValid point but there are hundreds of other institutions that don't have that exclusivity that have very little to offer when it comes to online learning. From what I can see, the OU is miles ahead.
- jgalt212 6y agoFull professorships, irrespective of institution eliteness, are a tough job to get. If I were the provost, I'd just sack the folks who refuse to show up to work this fail. Most of them would be very easy replace (certainly if you value teaching skills over research skills). Furthermore, the health risk to professors is much lower than it is to primary school teachers. 20 year olds can wear* masks for 45-90 minutes at a clip, 2nd graders won't be able to do that for six hours straight. * or legally forced to, as they are adults.
- nr2x 6y agoAs recent weeks have shown 20 year olds will be going to bars and parties and seeding new waves of infections. The vast majority of people in their age group have negligible mortality risk, and high incentives to socialize after being stuck at home with parents for months on end. The faculty on the other hand are in the demographic where COVID is a death sentence.
- jlokier 6y agoAnd when they don't die, it can ruin their academic & intellectual lives by making them long-term ill & disabled, including neurologically. Some of the lingering symptoms are nasty.
- hiidrew 6y agoI’ve thought about this quite a bit, really interesting what will happen to higher-ed. I’m currently a graduate student at a public research uni, which I imagine are the type of uni’s that may struggle (cause it’s not like ivy tech or other elite schools, may struggle to tract people if they start competing online only). Another interesting factor are the increasing amount of bootcamps like Lambda and others offering technical education for the low. I wonder if companies like those will try to expand to other less technical subjects. Think future higher-ed will be up to the experience and faculty, also makes you kind of worry about these public research institutions if tuition starts drying up.
- jake_morrison 6y agoI have two daughters in college. My older daughter just graduated in mathematics / machine learning from UCLA. Online classes were mostly ok, though there were some comical situations where the professor taught the whole class with his microphone on mute. Her exams were really rough, though. The math professors were unwilling to make any accommodation for the virus. While in quarantine with demonstrations and national guard soldiers literally across the street, she was taking exams. Everyone had 24 hours to take the exams, so they made them extra hard. They graded on a curve, because taking that away would be sacrilegious. So you have a choice, either spend as much of 24 hours as possible on the test, cheat (like some groups of students did), or get a bad grade. And then she had three exams in the same 24 hour period. The goal of testing should be to ensure that you know the material, not this competition shit. My younger daughter is studying at USC. She came back to Taiwan last semester, so she hasn't needed to deal with the virus. Online classes have been pretty chaotic, though. Watching async videos has actually been a plus, but the mandatory discussion sections at 3 AM have been rough. It would be nice if they would just open one up in Asia timezone. Especially because students from China are now blocked from going back to the US. USC was planning to have everyone come back on campus next semester, but just canceled because their opening plan was rejected by LA government. I am happy that she will be safe. Universities are really worried about their business model, and are willing to have people die to preserve it.