16 ms·
Invasive, secretive “bossware” tracking workers
- PeterStuer 6y agoI'd be interested in a tool or list of reliable detection methods for the presence of these programs. Do regular antivirus programs that can be user added detect these by default? I woud assume the one supplied in the company configuration has these whitelisted.
- daenz 6y agoI'm almost inspired enough to create an open source "killer" of these background programs. "Bossware" is one of the most infuriating things I've seen wrt employment in a little while.
- dreamcompiler 6y agoIf you do so, please design it such that it feeds a constant steam of innocuous data to the boss so they can't tell the bossware isn't working. Any employer who chooses to engage in technological warfare against their own employees deserves warfare in return.
- supercollision 6y agoHad a teammate do something similar but much simpler in the past (think limiting execution and FS permissions). This is unlikely to end with management appreciating your initiative.
- gen220 6y agoDepending on your definition of bossware, this may or may not be practically impossible. If you consider carbon black to be bossware, you would have to exploit the operating system vuln to get around it. Every once in a blue moon, our security team runs a p99-latency scan on my laptop, that basically bricks it. I’ve tried and failed to kill it, but I’m open to suggestions!
- novok 6y agoIf you have admin on your machine, turn unload the kernel extensions and turn it off. One dirty secret is that many IT departments wont notice or wont care.
- PeterStuer 6y agoUnlike HN readers, most employees do not have admin on their work computer, and for good reason. Doesn't mean they should suffer 'bossware' and most certainly not without informed and explicit consent.
- PeterStuer 6y agoI would start with presence detection. Removal might be in this specific cases better handled through a process that forces the company to remove it based on rules and regulations if possible. Most employees will not just want to start a tech war with the company admins.
- koheripbal 6y agoMany companies that monitor also prevent running ad-hoc excutables.
- abstrct 6y agoDon’t use the company device for personal use. It’s just not appropriate, for so many reasons.
- monocasa 6y agoI've increasingly heard of places requiring that you put it on your personal phone for working class jobs. BYOD gone horribly wrong. The same app will also be the only way to get your timesheets, clock in, or trade shifts, etc.
- abstrct 6y agoThen to me, this is the real issue. Businesses aren’t providing the right tools to help employees separate their personal lives with the business. BYOD has indeed been a curse.
- monocasa 6y agoI think a lot of middle managers for working class jobs see the inability to separate work life from personal as a critical feature. The ability to peer into their employees' lives gives them new levels of power over the employer/employee relationship. If the app did give the employees the tools to separate their lives, the employer would churn to another app.
- rantwasp 6y agothat a no for me. my phone is my phone. i am betting this is grounds for a class-action lawsuit if you indeed have no other option than to install crapware on you PERSONAL phone
- monocasa 6y agoI hope that it's grounds for a class action given how abhorrent of a practice it is, but I bet as long as there's relevant language in your employment contract, it's kosher.
- 6y ago
- MintelIE 6y agoIntel ME can be used to monitor employees without the OS ever becoming aware of anything. The only way to detect it would be to sniff the network.
- SheinhardtWigCo 6y agoDoes this really happen, or would it ever? Seems like a contrived scenario for employees to have enough access and knowledge to detect and defeat a userspace or kernel-resident solution that doesn’t want to be found. Plus, if you’re going that far, you’d want to make sure it wasn’t easily detectable by analyzing network traffic. I’m sure such a thing is out there, but I doubt it’s being used by employers to spy on workers. More like governments spying on workers with access to sensitive IP.
- nitrogen 6y agoYes https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Active_Management_Technology https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Active_Management_Tech... Plus the laptop "anti-theft" BIOSes that phone home whose name I cannot recall.
- bob1029 6y agoComputrace?
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoThat'd be it. My Thinkpads let me permanently disable it.
- MintelIE 6y agoThat's what the BIOS claims anyway...
- Spooky23 6y agoNope. It’s all over. Absolute Computrace starts at $29 and is resident in most every OEM BIOS manufactured in the last 20-25 years.
- yepthatsreality 6y agoIf your employees are so unaccountable and the work they do is so untraceable and often neglected, then there’s a management problem.
- dagav 6y agoYep, of course their solution to that problem is equally terrible
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- koheripbal 6y agoThese software help management deal with that problem by providing transparency and auditability to the work performed.
- raxxorrax 6y agoThe better managers I know are pretty critical of quantifying every work metric possible. Either you get it or you don't but perhaps that separates good managers from bad ones. If you cannot define a goal that people can work towards aside from a most uncreative KPI, it is always a management problem. At least in engineering. It is a work culture thing, but if you have a constructive one established, these tools can do much damage.
- threatofrain 6y agoSame discussion at same link. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23717964 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23717964
- tyxodiwktis 6y agoI used to work at a company that hired temps off Craigslist to do fairly sensitive healthcare work. The economics and extreme seasonality made that the only viable approach. Software like this was absolutely critical to limiting what people could do and preventing things like identity theft etc. Strong deterrent effect too- during orientation they would show people exactly what they could see. Not great in a general work environment with FTEs but these tools have legitimate uses.
- pphysch 6y agoHIPAA compliance requires these sort of measures to be taken anywhere, not just at home. This is rather unrelated to general-propose "bossware".
- snuxoll 6y agoI work for a HIPAA covered entity - software such as this is not even close to required to meet our compliance obligations. If I found we were trying to deploy it I would fight tooth and nail to protect the dignity of my coworkers and myself, and if they failed you better believe I would have a new position lined up within a week. “Bossware” like this is not a security tool, it’s a way for micro-managers and ass-in-seat bosses to be more effective in their misguided management styles.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- novok 6y agoAt least they are transparent about what they can do. Many if not most companies are surreptitious about it, including the FANGs.
- temporaryvector 6y agoI've always been a bit curious, do these types of programs make any attempt to identify whether they're running in a VM?
- 6y ago
- skylarchunk 6y agoPerhaps the ethical qualms could be settled if the tracing of workers were handled by a neutral third party. Being tracked by parties you are affiliated with opens a whole can of worms.
- Sophistifunk 6y agoNo, the harm is inherent in the surveillance.
- gentleman11 6y agoThat third party will be incentivized to monetize the data they collect after “anonymizing” it
- jodrellblank 6y agoHow can they be a neutral third party when they're paid by, and report to, the employers and not the employees? Their incentive would be to find problems, because that makes their service look worthwhile.
- Shared404 6y agoI'm going to play devils advocate here... They could make the data for all levels of the organization public within the organization. Doing this would allow for time tracking to be had for the scared middle management, but also give any employees the chance to view any unfair treatment. Of course this would never happen, but honestly, I would probably be ok with it.
- m3kw9 6y agoBoss ware vs Boss screen
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoMany years ago I spied on employees (of my client). Specifically, there were always few sales guys who'd spend hours a day lost in games, dating sites, etc. Who hasn't gotten lost on the internet? However, these guys were at it every day. From my perspective, they were caught in a trap that wasn't good for them or the company. I wanted was to help them find their way back to doing what they were good at. I setup a squid proxy, got good at regex & category blocking. After hitting my proxy, the sales guys would get a little frustrated but they invariably redirected themselves and that'd be the end of it. No need to involve management. Non-stupid employers know that what employees need are duties they can care about & opportunities to make something better. What employees don't need, to excel at their jobs, is to be surveilled, micromanaged or tightly restricted. (Granted, a few might hit a dark patch & need some guidance. A rare few might be beyond guiding and have to be let go.) tl;dr: Don't be a crapty employer & you won't have an imaginary need to spy on your employees.
- ianmcgowan 6y agoI worked at a small company and got sick of the monitoring/time-wasting complaints from managers. Installed a squid proxy and published the daily reports on an internal intranet page that everyone in the company could view. There was an explicit "internet is for work use only" policy, so there was no expectation of privacy, and I gave everyone in the company a lot of notice that it was happening. Our #1 user was very into Days-of-our-lives forum sites, and the sales guys still went to porn sites, but at least I wasn't the internet police any more.
- to11mtm 6y agoI worked at a place once that had a similar policy. The head of IT had a background in mind-games. So, he had fun with it. Blocked websites would get you a nastygram page, along with a warning that repeated attempts would result in an email to your manager. If you tried to use one of those 'proxy' sites that would try to get around blockers, You got an extra-special-nastygram. Told you that an email was immediately sent to your boss, and his boss, and the Director of IT. Well, I tripped -that- warning once, (trying to do a task at my manager's request,) so I let him know I couldn't and he was going to get an e-mail about it. "What? I don't see one... Go talk to IT and tell them we need it." I pondered this as I walked to the IT office. Thankfully I had a great rapport with them, so as they went to put in an exception I asked. "So, does anyone really get an email?" smirk
- rhacker 6y agoMy worry is that companies like Zoom will start offering enterprises higher paid plans that effectively install this software. So think about the next time you join a meeting you may be installing something like this. And... what if you join some of those meetings on your personal laptop?
- judge2020 6y agoZoom already basically did this, but they removed it: https://support.zoom.us/hc/en-us/articles/115000538083-Attendee-attention-tracking https://support.zoom.us/hc/en-us/articles/115000538083-Atten... Archive: https://web.archive.org/web/20200401215500/https://support.zoom.us/hc/en-us/articles/115000538083-Attendee-attention-tracking https://web.archive.org/web/20200401215500/https://support.z... Very old blog post on it: https://blog.zoom.us/zoom-tips-for-educators-attendee-attention-tracking/ https://blog.zoom.us/zoom-tips-for-educators-attendee-attent...
- TuringNYC 6y agoAttention trackers sound like they would be difficult to get right. For example, I have three monitors and one is on zoom. During the zoom conf, i've got full view of the screen, etc. But the focus is on another screen, where I continue slack/messaging/typing/coding/etc. Would an attention tracker be smart enough to realize that -- despite not being focused on the Zoom window -- that I indeed am listening and viewing it?
- degenerate 6y agoGotomeeting has an "attention" metric and it's completely, utterly useless. It works by seeing if the gotomeeting window has focus. Not even attempting to track visibility, but actual window focus. It's the laziest crap imaginable, yet unchanged for years now.
- underwater 6y agoPaying attention during a meeting is pretty binary. Either you're engaged or your checking emails/Slack/etc. I've yet to meet anyone who successfully multitasks in Zoom calls.
- iamleppert 6y agoI worked at a company that made software that could record employee phone calls and the video of their screens. It was a source of great fun to watch some of the videos where the employees got busted watching porn. One guy even used a customer credit card to order a bed off Amazon. If you’re dealing with hourly employees that are bottom of the barrel, this kind of monitoring is absolutely necessary to keep them in line.
- Shared404 6y agoAs a recently ex-hourly "bottom of the barrel" employee, I would ask you to reconsider your position. We are people too. If you have good management, you really don't need to worry about it. Also, anything useful that you described, sans credit card fraud, could be accomplished by network logging, without any need to invade the privacy of your employees. In the case of the guy who used the customer CC to order a bed, you would have been alerted whenever they were sued for credit card fraud, unless I'm deeply misunderstanding the system here. edits: Remove personal attack and increase clarity. Although I still feel justified, I appreciate the quality of discussion on HN to much to risk polluting it.
- discordance 6y agoBottom of the barrel performance for bottom of the barrel organizations like yours seems an appropriate response
- spiritplumber 6y agohttps://marshallbrain.com/manna1.htm https://marshallbrain.com/manna1.htm
- hrhrhrd 6y agoSounds exactly like an Amazon warehouse or Uber. The gig economy is Manna.
- mjayhn 6y agoI learned that Teams has idle reporting recently. Now I don't trust any of these collaboration apps.
- jedieaston 6y agoSkype for Business, Lync, and in the dark ages Office Communicator even had it. If you left IM open and your PC unlocked but you weren't using it, after a user set delay your status would turn to idle. You can't set the timeout in Teams anymore, IIRC. Does Slack not have this? I'm 99% sure Zoom does as well.
- mjayhn 6y agoI admined slack long long before it had any Enterprise bolts so I'm sure it has stuff like that now. Teams makes it front and center so you can track your employees interactions and chats, calls (not emails like I thought). https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoftteams/teams-activity-reports https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoftteams/teams-activi...
- discordance 6y agoGot a source on that? - I can only find the following: - Display name is the display name of the user. You can click the display name to go to the user's setting page in the Microsoft Teams admin center. - 1:1 calls is the number of 1:1 calls that the user participated in during the specified time period. - Channel messages is the number of unique messages that the user posted in a team chat during the specified time period. - Reply messages is the number of unique reply messages that the user posted in a team channel during the specified time period. - Post messages is the number of unique post messages that the user posted in a team channel during the specified time period. - Meetings organized is the number of scheduled meetings a user organized during the specified time period. - Meetings participated is the number of scheduled meetings a user participated in during the specified time period. - Chat messages is the number of unique messages that the user posted in a private chat during the specified time period. - Urgent messages is the number of urgent messages that the user posted in a chat during the specified time period. - Group Calls is the number of group calls that the user participated in during the specified time period. - Audio time is the total audio time that the user participated in during the specified time period. - Video time is the total video time that the user participated in during the specified time period. - Screen Share time is the total screen share time that the user participated in during the specified time period. - Last activity is the last date (UTC) that the user participated in a Teams activity. From https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoftteams/teams-analytics-and-reports/user-activity-report https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoftteams/teams-analyt...
- non-entity 6y agoOne of my coworkers at my last job was involved on writing a piece of such "bossware" (although nothing as extreme as the examples in the article). It used some WMI interfaces to track what users were doing. He seemed to express at least some level of uncomfort with it, but ultimately wrote it anyway.
- emersonrsantos 6y agoMicromanagement is a bad habit of insecurity that rots leadership, it affects the company health so much. One more source of emotional distress that makes good people leave. Accountability (AKA delivery, outcome) is the best metric for me.
- koheripbal 6y agoWhat makes you think this software is used for micromanagement? In most cases, it's used for auditing. If someone is suspected of abandoning their job, or stealing, or working a 2nd job, or etc... then the logs are reviewed.
- to11mtm 6y agoPossibly because they've experienced their data being used in the past for Micromanagement. Source: Been Micromanaged in the past and seen scenarios where said micromanagers used such data on others.
- crmrc114 6y agoLegal Problem; the moment you log this crap as a company... It's discoverable. That sexual harassment lawsuit that just came up? You are legally required to now do data hold on all these keylogs and screenshots you took. Oh and now you have to explain to a jury how you don't fall into the common charge of "could have or should have known" that abuse was occuring. I mean, you had all these logs and you still let this go on!? Any corporation that collects these logs is asking for danger. Give a good law firm that much data, they will nail you. Not to mention if you fire someone for burning time and they sue for wrongful termination and you get an e discovery request..to see if you applied that surveillance to everyone equally. Let's request a random selection of logs from 10 staff members in the same or related roles. This level of monitoring can get you in some huge problems.
- gruez 6y ago>Legal Problem; the moment you log this crap as a company... It's discoverable "Sure, here are the logs for the past 3 days, in accordance with our retention policy which is also 3 days"
- crmrc114 6y agoSo you had screenshots and keystrokes? Our client has printed emails where her boss made unwelcome sexual advances. Did you design this data retention policy to hide systematic sexual harassment in your company? Also anything less than 90days is likely to raise some eyebrows. Also your not the one pulling data in all cases. In some events the court will order your cooperation with a neutral third party for ediscovery. They will come in an perform data forensics on the assets in question.
- gruez 6y ago>So you had screenshots and keystrokes? Our client has printed emails where her boss made unwelcome sexual advances. Did you design this data retention policy to hide systematic sexual harassment in your company? Also anything less than 90days is likely to raise some eyebrows. Would this be enough to convince a judge/jury? AFAIK a lot of companies/govt agencies have short retention windows specifically to frustrate discovery, so it has to be working?. Granted, they're not as low as 3 days. Is 90 days the magic period where it's long enough to plausibly say you're not doing to frustrate discovery? >Also your not the one pulling data in all cases. In some events the court will order your cooperation with a neutral third party for ediscovery. They will come in an perform data forensics on the assets in question. That probably isn't an issue if your third party shreds the data after the retention policy. For "security purposes", of course.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- analog31 6y agoIs there something like pi-hole, that could block this stuff by interfering with the internet connection?
- hirundo 6y agoMy boss has us using a bossware SaaS app that tracks our work with exquisite detail. It's called GitHub. The tracking consists of our trail of commits to various repos. (Along with the resulting error logs and tickets.) He can see exactly what we're doing for the project and when. In fact he has a team that "peer reviews" the tracking data line by line and are not shy about pointing out deficiencies. To track other things, like time on task or web surfing habits, would not even be redundant, just superfluous.
- mobiledev2014 6y agoEvery morning I rebase my local changes from the previous day and push them at roughly the same time. I suggest everyone do the same! I might switch to doing it once a sprint :)
- choward 6y agoWhy not at the end of the day in case something happens to your computer?
- mobiledev2014 6y agoSounds like my employer's problem. ...but also because I'm a weird night owl and don't like my employer to see me slacking off all day then doing work at 1am.
- looperhacks 6y agoDoesn't the author date stay unchanged by a rebase?
- gen220 6y agoYou can doctor author dates pretty trivially. git commit --date=
- onion2k 6y agoYou can modify both the author date and the commit date on a commit if you need to. Git log is not trustworthy spying tool.
- tjbiddle 6y agoI'll share my experience, even though it's on the pro-monitoring side: I run a small e-commerce company. It's myself, and two customer service/operations team members that I have hired out of the Philippines. I live in Indonesia (I'm American) and my company serves those in the US. I made my first hire back in November 2019, and originally just had her paid salary and an expectation of 40/hours a week. After a while, she started occasionally disappearing for a day or two at a time. Always having some excuse - which I try to understand. But when I'm running a business on US-hours and my only person working in that timezone disappears, it gets hectic quick. She was doing phenomenal work, but these gaps caused me extreme stress and were affecting my business. I also felt my trust for her disappearing every time left and then came back with an excuse, that sounded legitimate enough, but nevertheless - it was becoming unacceptable. I felt like my payment was not being justified, and that I also was beginning to resent her as my business would suffer and my own mental health was deteriorating. I couldn't rely on her. We had multiple discussions, but when there's an excuse - it's hard to debate that. In addition, I was finding that some tasks that I could complete very quickly myself - would take her forever or be incomplete. But I also wanted to be understanding - I wanted to give the benefit of the doubt, and assume her excuses were legitimate. So I had a two-fold plan: 1) Setup time-tracking software and switch her pay to hourly. I gave a small raise, as well as paid vacation time based on hours worked, as an incentive. I wanted to make the switch, but still make it fair - and if anything, for her to come out ahead. 2) Begin to make headway on hiring a second person so that when these legitimate use-cases pop up, that we're still covered. I ended up choosing HubStaff - which looking at the chart on the article, appears the least invasive - which makes me happy with my decision. I have it configured to track applications and websites monitored, screenshoot every 5 minutes or so, and logs keyboard and mouse activity levels, but not actual data. 99% of what I use it for is just the time-tracking, but sometimes when things aren't completed on time - I can take a quick peak and see that yes, it does appear she was busy all day (Or enough - I don't expect people to hammer out 100% productivity - her activity levels usually hang between 30-60%) and was being honest. In addition, now that I've hired a second employee - I can compare their activity levels together to get a better idea on what's normal. And as for my original experience of her disappearing. She still does that on occasion. But now, since she's not logging in - she's not getting paid, so I can assume it's legitimate. And I have another employee logging on later during the day to ensure there's not a backlog. I guess my point here is that the tools are only as nefarious as your employer. I'm not looking to infringe on privacy, or micromanage. I very rarely even bother looking at the information it tracks - but it's a reassurance I'm not getting cheated when something awry pops up.
- vyshane 6y agoThis article resonates with me. I feel very strongly about spyware (Bossware is too kind). Views expressed here are my own, not those of my employer. I work for a company that makes an automated time tracking product (WiseTime [1]). We migrated our infrastructure to EU/Germany because we wanted to fall under a jurisdiction that is one of the strictest when it comes to privacy. This is how we think about the problem. - Many professionals (lawyers, contractors, ...) get paid for the time that they bill their clients - Manual time tracking (start/stop stopwatch) sucks - Automated time tracking is an order of magnitude more convenient - If you are going to automate the problem away, make sure that the system cannot be abused to spy on people - Otherwise no one will want to use it! We view privacy as one of our most important features, and our systems were designed from the ground up to protect it. - Your activity is captured into a private timeline that only you can see - To make your time available to your team, you must select the activities that you want to share, and explicitly post them to the team. It's like sending an email. Your draft is private, but once you send it off, then your recipient has a copy of it. - We allow you to anonymise your posted activity data when you leave a team - We allow you to specify filters around what activities should and shouldn't be captured. Of course you can delete anything you want off of your private timeline. - We provide user-level and team-level data retention settings. We automatically purge data that falls outside of your desired retention period. - We silo our data layer so that we don't store any personal information with user activity data. User activity data is siloed away from posted team data, and so on. - We take GDPR seriously and we even have automated processes to purge data from our Sales team's CRM We are a remote-first team, and we wanted to build a system that we personally dogfood without any qualms. [1]: https://wisetime.com https://wisetime.com
- umvi 6y agoI often find myself thinking about problems in the shower or out on walks, and that's also when I have big breakthroughs. How does WiseTime ensure I'm paid for that time too, not just when my butt is in my seat?
- vyshane 6y agoThat's a tough one to automate. Right now, it involves logging a manual time entry to your timeline (then posting it). If you walk away from your computer and come back, WiseTime will ask whether you want to log the time (or part of it). If you wake up in the morning, jump into the shower, solve a problem there, and hop onto your computer, WiseTime will then offer to log the last several hours including your sleep time. Edit down to 10 minutes (or however long your shower was) and log it. A bit contrived, but that's the best I got at this time. It's a tough problem to solve ;)
- tjpnz 6y agoI've heard a few stories about how Japanese companies are using these. There's one company which deployed a webcam app on their employees laptop to "track attentiveness" and dock pay for periods of time where they take their eyes off the screen. Another company is asking employees to wear a device (with camera and sensors) around their necks in order to track their overall "happiness". Stuff right out of 1984. The fact there are people in my profession working on such things troubles me.
- ddrt 6y agoHmm when I was visiting Japan they had a serious problem with work exhaustion related suicides. The workload and pressure to perform at higher and higher levels was too much so they ended it. That was just a few years ago. So, to hear that there is a new level of control for this already judgemental and “honor” based society is just appalling.
- koheripbal 6y agoWe just use it to make sure people are working. We discovered one person who, while "working from home" logged in at 9am, wrote one email, then again at 5pm, and did nothing in between. We suspected as much, but the surveillance software allowed us to provide the evidence for that person's dismissal.
- tjpnz 6y agoCouldn't you also solve this through better management? If someone isn't hitting their targets I don't think you need that kind of evidence to begin the dismissal process.
- blackrock 6y agoBut most of my important work is done off screen. Like, staring off into space. Like, I’m stuck on solving a problem. I look and I look. I can’t find it. I walk away, thinking about it. Still nothing. I drive home, then, I get my a-hah! moment. I solve the problem. And it was a one liner, to fix the problem.
- teddyh 6y agohttps://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?project=Macintosh&story=Negative_2000_Lines_Of_Code.txt https://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?project=Macintosh&stor...
- toto444 6y agoI remember reading a commenter on HN saying that most problems are solved going to the toilets. I hope no one installs bossware there as well.
- b34r 6y agoI deleted my org’s off my computer since I have root privs. They asked to put it back and I’ve been ignoring them. I signed an NDA, if that’s not good enough... idk what to tell you.
- gorgoiler 6y agoIn a contract between two parties, no party has any kind of legally elevated position over the other. Many employment contracts are written by employers though, so this culture that the employer is some kind of gentle but strict super entity pervades through the language of employment contracts. The company is just another Joe, and you have just as much right to dictate the terms of your employment as they do, just as you have equal standing in any contract you enter into with your mom, your husband, or your church. One thing that helps pick apart the engrained culture of faux company superiority is to imagine they are a church instead. Quoting the following part of EFF’s article makes me feel like they are still toeing the line. > [the state] must also establish protections for churchgoers: surveillance of parishioners should be necessary and proportionate [and] parishioners should have the right to know what exactly their priests are collecting.
- thescriptkiddie 6y agoIn practice, the employer holds most of the power in the relationship. Yes, even if you are a Rock Star™. They'll just fire you and find someone else. The only way for employees to actually negotiate their contracts is through collective bargaining.
- rocqua 6y agoJust because two parties are legally at the same position doesn't mean there isn't a power imbalance. Without collective bargaining, any employment negotiation is going to be lopsided, since not having a job hurts a worker a lot more than having one employee fewer hurts an employer. I think I am pretty good at my job. I get great feedback from all sides and complete my work on time and with high quality. We are also looking hard for more people because we have too much work. Getting people up to speed also is a big issue, so my employer invested a decent amount in me. In all, I have a dang good bargaining position. And yet if I were to quit my job, that would hurt me a lot more than it would hurt my employer. I would lose 100% of my income, which is essentially catastrophic. I would run massive risk in needing to find another decent job, would probably have to move, and wouldn't know whether I would like my new job. Meanwhile, for my employer, a few projects would be slightly delayed, and we'd have to be more held-back in accepting new work. Nothing really impactful. Hence my employer holds a lot more bargaining power than I do.
- mark567g 6y agocan this type of software be installed remotely via cisco anyconnect?
- confounded 6y agoAnyone have a method/script to detect these via ps or similar? In a previous job I had an alias to monitor for and kill Tanium, though now I don’t even know what I’m looking for.
- 6c696e7578 6y agoWith a key/screen logger on your personal, or corporate device, what happens to your gmail login (assuming you're permitted personal email at work)? The company where I work permits a small amount of time for personal affairs, checking bank/email if required, I've never personally done this as I'm fully aware of a MITM proxy. All that aside, if you were to log into your personal bank account, or personal email, what are the restrictions around where the data is logged, or who has access to the data. This should extend to the disk storage replacement, if a disk is upgraded, or becomes faulty, where does the data centre remote hands put the faulty/old disk once popped from the tray? Lets hope that gmail account didn't provide MFA for another site login. Should this type of software be announced in employment terms?
- posedge 6y agoThe thought that apparently some employers think it is a good idea to spy on their employees on such an invasive and unethical level makes me sick. Not to mention that the lack of trust in such a company has probably eroded productivity a long time ago.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- NumberCruncher 6y ago> Let’s be clear: this software is specifically designed to help employers read workers’ private messages without their knowledge or consent. By any measure, this is unnecessary and unethical. I am too European to understand how this can be legal.
- aloisdg 6y agoThe more I read, the more I think that the US is a nightmare for worker.
- caymanjim 6y agoIt's likely not legal, but hasn't been tested by the courts.
- koheripbal 6y agoIn the US and Canada, this has been upheld in court as legal numerous times. Any activity done on the company equipment/software is considered work product and is accessible for audit/reviews. In our case, we only open these logs if a manager has an issue with an employee (either a complain against their conduct, or drop in attendance/work product). Often, the metrics show that the employee is just doing other work that the manager isn't aware of, but sometimes it's clear that the employee has either abandoned their job entirely and is just doing nothing - and the logs give us legal grounds for termination. We tell everyone that the system is monitored - we're very transparent about that, and remind them that person comms should be done from their phones. I honestly don't understand the controversy. This transparency has saved good employees, highlighted bad managers, and helped us remove bad apples.
- joann56 6y agoI just can’t thank him enough,he gave my son free scholarship into the college,all i had to do was to settle the bills for the tools on the job,i used $500 to get a job of over $5000 done all thanks to Eaglespyhacker At Gmail Dot Com,he saved me from all my troubles,sharing this is how i can show gratitude in return for all he has done for me and my family.