5 ms·
> Another result of Mr Wantchekon’s political past is a preference for empiricism over ideology. A trip to Albania ended his blind affection for socialism. His
by rayiner 6y ago
> Another result of Mr Wantchekon’s political past is a preference for empiricism over ideology. A trip to Albania ended his blind affection for socialism. His school is not part of efforts to “decolonise” the African academy. Any student of politics must read Rousseau and Madison, he argues. The aim is to add to the sum of human knowledge, not subtract from it. “Be angry but also be thoughtful,” he says.
This is something that should be impressed upon all the Americans who throw around the term “decolonization.” What would “decolonizing” say Bangladesh (where I am from) mean? Should we abandon the use of English? Dismantle our Supreme Court, an institution we inherited from the British? Dismantle our legal system built on British common law, or our constitution built on the American constitution and the Magna Carta? Abandon capitalism and free markets (which 80%+ of the population support because it has revolutionized the country)? Abandon western ideas like religious freedom, secularism, feminism, individualism, etc? What would we replace those things with?
- zozbot234 6y ago> What would we replace those things with? Religious freedom is also an Indian idea, not just a Western one. And Indians are also exporting new progressive ideas to the West, such as the animal rights activism struggle of India's cow protection movement.
- jimbob45 6y agoPretty sure PETA already has that covered pretty well.
- fastball 6y agoAh yes, the Hindu model of caring more about cows than untouchables. Definitely ideology worth emulating. https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2016/08/13/489883492/the-caste-formerly-known-as-untouchables-demands-a-new-role-in-india https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2016/08/13/4898834...
- zozbot234 6y ago> Ah yes, the Hindu model of caring more about cows than untouchables. Ah, yes, "the Hindu model". Meanwhile, plenty of high-status Westerners will happily donate and volunteer towards their local animal shelters, seemingly caring more about them than about Indian untouchables and other millions of people in extreme poverty, that they could donate to instead. Why do you assume it's only Hindus who sometimes push their charitable concerns too far?
- fastball 6y agoYes, "Hindu model". Cows being sacred is a facet of Hinduism. It's not some general feeling of good-will towards cows / animals by Indian nationals. It is literally based on the idea that the cow represents one of the deities in the Hindu pantheon. The caste system was (is?) inextricably linked with Hinduism. There is a clear difference between literally valuing animals over people in a direct way (as shown in the article I linked) vs. putting effort to help animals and less into helping humans. The former is zero-sum, in that you are directly disadvantaging humans for the sake of animals. The latter is not, in that you can help both animals and the destitute. Volunteering at an animal shelter does not disadvantage others, even if holier-than-thou types would like to say that world hunger should be solved before helping animals. The perfect is the enemy of the good.
- churchillracist 6y ago> caring more about cows than untouchables. Definitely ideology worth emulating. Replace cows with animals. Replace untouchables with African Americans. What do you get? Perhaps we all need to look in the mirror before throwing stones.
- dang 6y agoPlease do not take HN threads further into flamewar, especially not nationalistic or religious flamewar. This comment breaks the site guidelines in many ways. For starters: "Don't be snarky." "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith." "Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- godelzilla 6y agoWhy not look at decolonization as a step forward instead? Why not collect restitution from the colonial/imperial powers that have been extracting wealth from South Asia for centuries? Why not use natural resources for the local population? https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00472336.2018.1506043?journalCode=rjoc20 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00472336.2018.15... https://www.dandc.eu/en/article/contemporary-bangladeshi-law-still-largely-colonial-nature-well-spirit https://www.dandc.eu/en/article/contemporary-bangladeshi-law...
- rayiner 6y ago“Decolonization” is, as the article observes, usually an attempt to eliminate the influence of western institutions, culture, and thought. That would be a huge step backward. It would be cutting off your nose to spite your face. Restitution is a separate issue. I think it would be fair for the British to return wealth they expropriated, but I’m not holding my breath. More to the point: I wouldn’t trust anyone who advocates “decolonization” to do what’s the best thing for the country going forward. I’ll stick with the British colonial legacy rather than invite a new wave of intellectual colonization from western left-wing universities. If the developed world wants to destroy itself with those ideas, let that be their problem.
- godelzilla 6y ago> "Decolonization" is, as the Economist defines it... FTFY. If you're going to use a colonizer magazine's definition of decolonization, then of course it'll sound bad.
- pinkfoot 6y ago… because in your world it is all factions, no one can make an independent rational assessment of anything, so if they are not on your team you can just dismiss them out of hand?
- SuoDuanDao 6y agoPeople I respect use the term decolonisation so I'm trying to keep an open mind about it, but I'm unclear what it means and suspect there may be a motte-and-bailey strategy at play around it. Could you explain where the dividing line is between decolonisation and cultural segregationism?
- dundarious 6y ago“Decolonize” is a bit of a wishy washy term, but it means to read _more broadly_, not just the Western canon. Also, as mentioned in The Economist’s article, to read with intention, “Be angry but also be thoughtful”. It’s not to just burn down the old, white people institutions. In Ireland, we had to decolonize ourselves to an extent. Race was less of an issue of course. But of course we kept parliamentary democracy and a lot of other good stuff.
- pphysch 6y agoEscaping (neo)colonialism generally means focusing on domestic ownership of domestic infrastructure, labor, markets, and supply chains, and untangling oneself from debt traps like the IMF. It's not some crazy, scary ideological idea, unlike what elite Western propagandists have been saying. Just don't advocate it too strongly or you might get got by paid goons, like Sankara and many other victims of foreign-influenced regime change.
- zozbot234 6y ago> untangling oneself from debt traps like the IMF. If the IMF is involved with your country, you were in a debt trap already and they're working on untangling you from it. See e.g. Greece, which is now working on their debt problem after the late-2000s economic crisis. "Domestic ownership of supply chains" has also been a disaster historically, because it involves closing down your economy to foreign trade and restricting competitive dynamics: it's better to exploit global supply chains by specializing on the parts that you can be best on, and incrementally working your way up the value ladder.
- pphysch 6y agoGoing from domestic ownership of domestic resources to total economic isolationism is a complete non-sequitor, and dangerous misinformation. The IMF has been around for the better part of a century and has done exceedingly little to address global economic inequality. Maybe it has something to do with it being dominated by the representation of wealthy Western interests.
- zozbot234 6y ago> Maybe it has something to do with it being dominated by the representation of wealthy Western interests. The IMF has its biases and is far from perfectly equitable (and this was quite clear already in their response - or sometimes lack thereof - to the 1990s crises) but expecting it to single-handedly do enough to "address global economic inequality" is just not very fair.
- pjc50 6y agoThis is a straw man with an easy answer: you've made up lots of things and called them "decolonization", but you've not actually asked what the people in the countries calling for decolonization want.
- fastball 6y agoWhat do you think the list is then?
- graeme 6y agoI believe their argument is that there is no coherent, practical position that can be described as decolonization in this modern sense. Both the dictionary and wikipedia only define decolonization in a conventional, imperial power withdrawing sense. Are you aware of a clear, practical definition which a society or state could implement? And does it have no overlap with OP’s concerns. Absent there being any clear definition of the concept I am not sure the onus is on OP to define it.
- rayiner 6y agoHere is a good paper by a Bangladeshi art historian: https://www.collegeart.org/pdf/programs/international/haque.pdf https://www.collegeart.org/pdf/programs/international/haque.... > Decolonization, as we call it, is rather a modern phenomenon that has been bubbling up since the late twentieth century. There are calls for decolonizing everything, art history included. > The concept of decolonization is twofold. First, it means the end of colonization—being independent politically and administratively... The more important aspect began after that point, that of countering the influences of colonization that remained in the society and culture. > If that is so, looking for answers in past glory, or only rectifying the purity that was denounced or distorted by the imperialistic process, is not sustainable. We need to create new vocabularies and new understandings, but not running in only one direction, rejecting everything that is Eurocentric. Then there is the question of: where do you stop decolonizing? Before the British there were the Mughals, who introduced much of the basic culture, food, etc. Before that the Sena, who introduced Islam. Before that, the Pala, who where Buddhists.)
- AnimalMuppet 6y ago
- UncleMeat 6y agoHave you had conversations with academics who are interested in decolonizing their fields? People are interested in decolonizing history aren't saying that we should throw away all study of european history. They are saying that we should add more voices. This has been a project for decades, with more voices of women and poc being represented in historical analysis. Necessarily, this means reducing the amount of time spent on "traditional western civilization" in the classroom, since there is only so much time. But go check out a renaissance history course taught by a young faculty member. White men continue to dominate the discourse. We've just added some more voices alongside them.
- marcosdumay 6y agoBrazilian here. Around here, it usually means adding low quality voices to the discussion. Although there are a few pushing for recognition of good local work, those few tends to be attacked from both sides of the discussion.
- UncleMeat 6y agoIf your opinion is that female and poc voices are "low quality" then I don't know what to say... This isn't adding voices for the sake of it. This is adding voices because those voices are an essential part of historical understanding and history suffers if you exclude them.
- marcosdumay 6y agoBad authors are bad, and good authors are good whatever sex and skin color they have. Individual author qualities are much more relevant than the social context they are immersed; if somebody doesn't understand they society they are talking about, reading them is worthless, it doesn't matter if it has an incredibly different and interesting culture. Around here there is plenty (but trending down) of pushing for authors on the basis that they are local, or non-white, or not male, or poor. There is also a lot (and trending up) of pushing for authors on the basis that they are from some "world-class" place/culture. Both approaches are classist/racist/sexist and plain stupid. Labels like "decolonizing" usually come from the first group, and anybody trying to judge local authors based on their own merits is quickly outed from that group with the argument that judging works done by such class/race/sex is classist/racist/sexist, so people using that label are almost never on the actually unprejudiced group. Besides, forcefully changing authors based on prejudice has the double effect of teaching locals that they aren't expected to create high quality work and delegating competent locals to a life of obscurity, because if you can't judge their work, you can't discover that it's any good either. But anyway, that says nothing about the subjects of study. It is always worthy to study the cultures that helped forming one's own.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]