31 ms·
Microsoft is shutting down Mixer and partnering with Facebook Gaming
- i_rawr_u 6y agohttps://www.theverge.com/2020/6/22/21298963/ninja-shroud-mixer-facebook-gaming-twitch https://www.theverge.com/2020/6/22/21298963/ninja-shroud-mix... I'm wondering how these contracts for the the Mixer exclusives will pay out.
- tinodotim 6y agoRemarkable if Microsoft really thought they could just buy two big streamers (and a couple of smaller ones) to get Mixer going and that Twitch market share - without making much change to the platform and its community. "A typical Microsoft" I guess? Big pay day for Ninja & Shroud though if they're really just free to join Twitch again, their returns will be huge.
- sohamsankaran 6y agoI wonder what happens to folks like Ninja with big exclusive deals.
- bdz 6y ago>stars like Tyler “Ninja” Blevins, Cory “King Gothalion” Michael, and Michael “Shroud” Grzesiek — will be released from their contracts, and Microsoft says it’s up to them where they decide to go. >“It’s up to them and their priorities,” says Vivek Sharma, the head of Facebook Gaming, meaning the platform isn’t actively pursuing exclusive agreements with any of Mixer’s biggest names. https://www.theverge.com/2020/6/22/21298963/ninja-shroud-mixer-facebook-gaming-twitch https://www.theverge.com/2020/6/22/21298963/ninja-shroud-mix...
- rauchp 6y agoReally surprising move, considering that's the main thing Mixer had going for it. Facebook got the short end of the stick on this deal, considering they'll have to negotiate again with these Twitch streamers. Now that these streamers have an idea how much engagement and money they'll be losing from switching platforms, they'll probably demand more from FB Gaming for an exclusivity contract. I haven't heard people talk about Mixer being a better platform or experience for streaming, so I'm not sure what FB gets out of this considering Mixer's talent was its most valuable asset.
- fsociety 6y agoIt’d be very unfair to the streamers if they were forced over to FB Gaming. Good on Mixer and Facebook for making sure that didn’t happen.
- karthikshan 6y agoDoes this mean they don't get paid out for the remainder of their contract? These streamers took a massive brand hit by leaving twitch for so long...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cjbprime 6y agoThey do get paid out -- I think I read that Ninja receives $30M and can now go back to Twitch.
- Wafje 6y agoIt seems like they do. https://twitter.com/RLewisReports/status/1275139749716480000 https://twitter.com/RLewisReports/status/1275139749716480000
- hobofan 6y ago$30M for not even a full year, and not even a gigantic brand hit (they seemed to retain their fanbase pretty well, and did well with Youtube clips) sounds like a great deal.
- kevindong 6y agoI'm curious about what the contracts the big streamers signed have to say about contract termination fees.
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoThey were all paid in full because their contracts were bound to the Mixer platform specifically.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoWell, if they were paid in full, it's because that's how Ninja/Shroud and their lawyers were able to negotiate the contract. It's arbitrary. The contract could also have just been "contract terminated if Mixer ends".
- corobo 6y ago“No I’m not signing that” is the magic spell to make that line disappear
- seaish 6y agoApparently Ninja and Shroud were paid in full: $30M and $10M respectively. https://twitter.com/Slasher/status/1275145243478892544 https://twitter.com/Slasher/status/1275145243478892544
- maps7 6y agoThis amount of money is crazy to me. Are these guys really that big of a draw? Are they just so good at the games they play or are they funny/entertaining?
- kungato 6y agoThey are entertaining enough to a big group of people and they managed to build and sustain their audience. It's like asking is Robert Downey Junior the best actor in the world. If you don't see the value that just means you aren't the target audience
- maps7 6y agoYou've read my comment wrong
- nimos 6y ago2 summers ago when Ninja was really popular I did a back of the envelop calculation on total viewer hours over a year and it was roughly the same as a season of the Big Bang Theory. Obviously not comparable for a variety of reasons (viewer quality, syndication, youtube clips) but that show was spending 100+ million on just the main cast.
- gempir 6y agoNinja is really marketable. He has merchandise sitting in Walmart, was on big tv shows like Ellen or hosting a NYC New Years Event. He's the face of gaming for all the non-gamers right now. Shroud is just a very good gamer and has a big audience, he's not that marketable compared but still worth a decent penny I guess. He's probably considered the best FPS streamer out there whenever a new game comes out. He's the go to for many.
- dvt 6y agoInterestingly, this indicates that the streaming market is saturated, and Mixer simply had no room to grow. The analysts probably didn't realize their gamble was a zero-sum game. Ninja & Shroud weren't enough to tip the scales and Mixer had zero traction. Of course they will be fine, but it sucks for the smaller streamers that hitched their wagons to Mixer and are now left to hold the proverbial bag. Even more telling is that Microsoft is burying this news under WWDC20, probably embarrassed about the entire snafu.
- noodle 6y agoWell, lots of streamers really don't like Twitch. But Mixer was a downgrade for most people in terms of features and functionality. Same situation with YouTube - a lot of content creators aren't happy with it, but everything else out there is just a worse version of YT. The bigger, older platforms have a lot of momentum.
- legohead 6y agoIt's okay to copy a product. You just have to do it better. And Mixer wasn't even close. I actually liked Mixer's video quality more than Twitch, but that's not what makes Twitch fun for users...
- detaro 6y agoMixer did have comparatively low latency and interaction features, that was a unique point at least back then. Apparently not enough though.
- theklub 6y agoI’m pretty sure mixer had a ton of features twitch didn’t have at one point but I could be wrong. I just remember watching kabby in the height of the pubg craze and he had a ton of cool stuff no one on twitch had.
- noodle 6y agoThey have some better and different features; but also lacking in some features people considered essential. For me as a viewer, an easy example is that taking clips of streams is relatively new to Mixer, and you can't even sort/filter them. Clips helped build a lot of Twitch streamers' popularity by making things bite-sized and shareable.
- aboringusername 6y agoI find it intriguing that generally speaking, people have issue with monopolies. Yet, as much as everyone claims there's a free market, MS has failed with both a mobile OS and a streaming service, and essentially gives it over to the giant. FB didn't even need to do anything, just their existence and networking abilities is enough to make alternatives unviable. I do wonder what we will do in the long term as most places are centralized. Google and Apple for a mobile OS, FB (or FB properties) for social networking, there's Twitch for streaming, YouTube for video hosting. These days, the chances of competition are (IMO) impossible due to the sheer size and influence (and power) of these mega giants.
- earthtobishop 6y agoAccording to the most recent Streamlabs report: YouTube Gaming Live accounted for 22.1% market share for 2019 in terms of hours watched while Twitch market share accounts for 75.1% and Mixer market share accounted for is 2.7%. Youtube Gaming is also growing extremely fast since they have rolled out their new creative suite. https://newzoo.com/insights/articles/streamlabs-newzoo-q4-year-in-review-live-streaming-industry-report/#:~:text=With%20a%2046%25%20increase%20in,share%20accounted%20for%20is%202.7%25 https://newzoo.com/insights/articles/streamlabs-newzoo-q4-ye.... Facebook Gaming hardly has any market share so I don't understand why you are saying their existence and networking abilities is enough to make alternativeS unviable. The streaming industry seems to be one of the most competitive markets out there.
- huhuhuhuhuh 6y agoA more recent report: https://blog.streamlabs.com/streamlabs-stream-hatchet-q1-2020-live-streaming-industry-report-9630bc3e0e1e https://blog.streamlabs.com/streamlabs-stream-hatchet-q1-202... facebook gaming is catching up really fast. it went from 'hardly any market share' to 11% of hours watched.
- jorams 6y ago> I find it intriguing that generally speaking, people have issue with monopolies. Yet, as much as everyone claims there's a free market, MS has failed with both a mobile OS and a streaming service, and essentially gives it over to the giant. When people take issue with monopolies, they are not asking for a company like MS to break that up. They are asking for smaller, independent players.
- detaro 6y agoMixer had (pre-Microsoft) some neat tech, but wasn't enough in the end. The few streamers I knew moved there have all long moved back.
- thorum 6y agoMixer had potential as a streaming platform, they completely failed to create a culture anything like what Twitch has. Any streamer who wanted to move to Mixer would have to sacrifice being part of that Twitch community.
- asebold 6y agoBy courting big names like Ninja and Shroud though, I feel like Mixer wasn't interested in "creating" a culture, they wanted to flat out "buy" twitch's. Safe to say it wasn't successful within the past year, but I'd expect it to take much longer than that anyways. Why would they give up right after dumping a huge amount of time and money into it?
- TheAdamAndChe 6y agoTheir culture is 100% why they failed. They were technically far superior to Twitch. Their video quality was much better with lower CPU utilization, their latency was extremely low, and their UI was intuitive and butter smooth. Their culture though... Before Shroud and Ninja joined, there were rules that you couldn't tell people your age. They had rules on how wide your shirt straps could be, and just generally seemed like if you had any opinions on other people, you would be chastised. They valued explicit political correctness, but that's not so good when you're making a place designed for just chilling and hanging out... At least, not when you're trying to grow.
- Goronmon 6y agoThey valued explicit political correctness, but that's not so good when you're making a place designed for just chilling and hanging out... At least, not when you're trying to grow. Another way to word it is that the online gaming community is extremely toxic and you have to accept a decent chunk of that toxicity to grow a community in the gaming space.
- TheAdamAndChe 6y agoWhat I am about to say, I mean with absolutely no disrespect. What you consider non-toxic is considered uptight and overly sensitive by many... Whether you think that's right or not is beside the point. I understand the need for political correctness and politicing at work. It keeps conflicts from arising and it avoids hurt feelings. It's not as valued by many people outside of work. That can affect the growth of sites like this. Put in another way: each stream is an individual community. By making such explicit rules, they are policing culture and suppressing certain identities. That is counter to the environment needed for growth.
- haunter 6y agoUnfortunately Twitch is buffering for me all the time. 4K streaming on Mixer was flawless, I can't even do 720p 60fps most of the time on Twitch :/
- lwansbrough 6y agoCould be throttling. Have you tried watching through a VPN?
- haunter 6y agoYeah VPN works perfectly but I'm not a big fan of it I have to use it all the time just to watch Twitch
- user5994461 6y agoCan you drop the 60FPS to 30FPS ? That would cut the bandwidth requirement in half.
- haunter 6y agoOh I'm talking about watching not streaming non affilite/non partnered streamers don't have quality selection and if they stream 720p 60fps I have to watch that. I honestly don't even know what's the problem because I can even stream on Twitch easily pretty much up to 10000kbps. But once I start watching almost any stream heavy buffering starts.
- tech-historian 6y agoMixer joins its brethren in Microsoft's list of discontinued products. https://www.versionmuseum.com/history-of/discontinued-microsoft-products https://www.versionmuseum.com/history-of/discontinued-micros...
- s9w 6y agoWow that came out of nowhere. Mixer could be so great but they're massively mismanaged with what I guess is out of touch management. They had such a big budget and still failed. Like many couldn't get used to the bad site and never used is. But competition for twitch would have been nice. The internet can be weird.
- kawfey 6y agoThis comes at no surprise to the game streaming community. A number of popular gaming stream helpers, namely Harris Heller from Alpha Gaming [0], have kept streamers away from Mixer to focus on Twitch and hosting VOD/highlights on YouTube in order to best grow a community. Facebook is a large enough platform that this might cause some trouble for Twitch, but we'll see. I think the gaming community is deeply seated around Twitch/YT. Since Facebook has already lost tons of younger users, and rejects anonymity, and doesn't have dark mode, I don't think this will turn out very good for Facebook. [0] https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCATWC1JSlhzmYeDbjnS8WwA/search?query=mixer https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCATWC1JSlhzmYeDbjnS8WwA/sea...
- jitl 6y agoNit: Facebook has dark mode
- brogrammernot 6y agoOne word why I think this will work out well: money. I can see FB/MS tapping into deep pockets to offer some top streamers a great deal to move platforms. If they get enough of them to move and the service is stable, intuitive and fun to be on then I can see FB doing well. FB knows how to build communities, they know how to build engaging content and how to run that type of business. I would bet on them figuring out how to leverage their subject matter expertise on that side house to bring a very good product offering in this new vertical. There’s an ecosystem there that they can tap into as well, marketplace, pages, etc that if they can pull it off, could make it a very lucrative all-in-one solution for the streamers.
- aerovistae 6y agoNo way. This is literally exactly what Microsoft just did, and here we have the results. Facebook can try it, and they'll fail too. There is absolutely _zero_ chance of younger demographics moving to facebook. I'm in my 20s and know many gamers in their 20s/teens and we all avoid facebook like the plague. There's no chance. We've seen it again and again and again-- you can't just steal away a successful business by throwing money at the problem and copying it. Look at zune, look at tidal, look at google+, look at bing, look at mixer. All either outright failed or stole at best a tiny fraction of market share. There's so many examples of corporations trying and failing at this strategy that it's just a comic act by now.
- throw_m239339 6y agoHow long did Mixer exist again? For the people here who think GitHub is too big too fail under Microsoft… and let's not forget that MS used to have its own code repository website before shutting it down...
- MaximumMadness 6y agoIf I'm Twitch the #1 thing I'm thinking about right now is how to extend the olive branch to all of these creators. Favorable partner terms, sponsorship, resources etc. This is a market share growth opportunity that comes around very infrequently
- v7p1Qbt1im 6y agoSame for YT and FB. It’s just 3 players now.
- bena 6y agoReally? Why? Twitch is already over 70% of the streaming market. Let's say that both of them go to YouTube. Let's also say that Ninja and Shroud accounted for all of Mixer's market share.. That would give YouTube roughly 20% of the market, up from about 17%. Twitch is still 70% of the market. Twitch should be looking for ways to make it easier for streamers to stream and get noticed. Find the next Ninja.
- 0xCMP 6y agoThey're still important and it builds good will which helps them gain more loyalty from the viewers. E.g. Facebook spies on you while Twitch supports the creators I like.
- bena 6y agoIf you have 70% of something, I would think you have a decent amount of goodwill and loyalty already. And I'm not saying the value of acquiring them is zero. I'm saying the value of acquiring them may not be worth it.
- 013a 6y agoYou would think that, and you'd be wrong. Many streamers dislike Twitch, in the same way many YouTubers dislike YouTube for their policies. Most stick around, because they saw what happened to Ninja, and he represented the best of what could be possible; your viewers by-and-large wont follow you, your community is on Twitch, they're not your community, they're Twitch's community. Twitch could be a lot worse, and they'll probably get a lot worse now losing their only decent competition. The general murmur around the Twitch exclusivity deals was that they 10x'd in value and quantity after Microsoft put a price on Ninja. Unless YouTube gets serious, the same level of serious that Twitch and Mixer were, Twitch has no reason to add value to these streamers. The streamers wont leave; they can't. And we all know YouTube won't do the right thing by their content creators, because they already don't. This is a very dark day for content creators. Mixer failed, but it at least represented literally the only threat on Twitch's radar; there was always the question of "well what if Mixer blows up" guiding biz-dev at Twitch. Unless streamers band together and unionize, Amazon is going to crush them.
- saltedonion 6y agoWhat’s preventing streamers from streaming to multiple platforms at once. Is it against he Eula or something ?
- hexmiles 6y agonot sure about others, but for twitch if you become a partner, required for most (all? don't remember) monetization you can't stream to other platform.
- sdan 6y agoYes. Applies to YouTube, Twitch, and other afaik.
- WesleyLivesay 6y agoMonetization. The platforms require Affiliate/Partner streamers (so people with Subscribe buttons) to be exclusive streamers on their platform.
- ehsankia 6y agoWhat if you're not a partner on the other platforms, can you still stream to Facebook, Youtube, Twitch, all at the same time? Smaller streams rely heavily on chat and interactions, but 1000+ viewer streams generally don't so you don't need to read 3 different chats. You can still receive donations and maybe ad money?
- WesleyLivesay 6y agoYou can, but you will not get ad money (which requires Affiliate/partner).
- detaro 6y agothen you can do it, and some streamers do.
- rosywoozlechan 6y agoThe streamer known as Destiny and Giant Bomb sort of do this. They stream on Twitch but they accept monetization through alternative means. Destiny is actually exclusive to Twitch, he just hosts his streams on his own website and accepts subscriptions and donations there in addition to Twitch, all of his chat is on his own website though. Giant Bomb is not monetized through Twitch, it's monetized through CBS Interactive and hosted on their own site, but the stream is a Twitch stream. So they're not on multiple platforms, but they've not tied themselves to Twitch's monetization.
- totaldude87 6y agoDidnt ninja and Shroud bag a lucrative deal with Mixer this year?! guess they will go back to twitch after all https://www.dexerto.com/entertainment/ninja-shroud-could-return-to-twitch-after-mixer-joins-facebook-gaming-1383085 https://www.dexerto.com/entertainment/ninja-shroud-could-ret...
- Operyl 6y agoAnd likely keep all the money too, assuming the contract is void and is not transferred to Facebook. Double dipping!
- ehsankia 6y agoRumors are they were offered double the initial offer to come to Facebook, but they both declined and forced Mixer to cash them out.
- minimaxir 6y ago> Sources: Facebook offered an insane offer at almost double for the original Mixer contracts of Ninja and Shroud but Loaded/Ninja/Shroud said no and forced Mixer to buy them out. Ninja made ~$30M from Mixer, and Shroud made ~$10M > Ninja and Shroud are now free agents https://twitter.com/Slasher/status/1275145243478892544 https://twitter.com/Slasher/status/1275145243478892544
- apacheCamel 6y agoMan, getting paid to switch just to have the service go bunk anyway. Probably one of the easiest $30M ever. I really wonder if he lost any sort of revenue over those months that he switched? I can't imagine it coming anywhere close to the $30M he made just for the time.
- EastSmith 6y agoNinja had 80-100k viewers when he switched to Mixer, and now on Mixer he has 2-5k. Each sub on twitch was making him $3-4/month (do not know how many subs he had, but I can imagine 10-30k). So, he lost $30-$120k on Twitch subs alone per month. Then an Ad on Twitch in front of 100k viewers is different than an Ad on Mixer (not really sure if they have Ads on Mixer). With Ninja's viewership on Twitch 60 second Ad, can probably bring him more than $10k. Not sure if he had used Ads though (may streamers chose not to use them).
- KaoruAoiShiho 6y agoI thought Mixer would've been a home run if they integrate it into the new xbox's dashboard. Guess it's company infighting that killed it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ohyeshedid 6y agoMy concern is how FB Gaming will be installed/embedded into the Xbox dash. If it's like the current FB SDK, does that mean that FB will be siphoning data off xbox users that don't use FB?
- jitl 6y agoA closer partnership with Facebook is going to loose Microsoft the coming console generation just like their focus on “TV is the new water cooler” lost them the last one. Gamers don’t want Facebook. They don’t want TV. Gamers want games.
- TremendousJudge 6y ago>Gamers don’t want Facebook. They don’t want TV. Gamers want games. Yeah, the fact that the PS2 could play DVDs had absolutely nothing to do with its tremendous success.
- twalla 6y agoThis is how I convinced my parents to buy both a PS2 and PS3 - the PS3 was one of the most affordable blu-ray players when introduced, it just happened to have a game console attached to it.
- jdofaz 6y agoIt was a much better player than most dedicated bluray players at the time too.
- vertex-four 6y agoThe difference is that everyone (to some approximation) who is likely to buy a PS5 has a computer of some description that is perfectly capable of streaming media - you're not thinking "oh, I need to get that console so I can watch Facebook Gaming".
- jimmaswell 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Yhippa 6y agoBummer. Streaming from the Xbox was easy and fun. You could stream a multiplayer game with your friends! Friction was reduced to stream and you didn't need to mess with stream keys or overlays. Sad.
- koheripbal 6y agoThat will almost certainly still be possible to do via FB.
- Yhippa 6y agoMaybe. It's interesting that Sony removed FB integration from their OS for the PS4.
- superbaconman 6y agoNot sure why you're getting downvoted. This was a very nice Xbox feature. They had it for PC on their Xbox bar for a while; You could stream any window or your desktop to the same mixer account as your gamertag. Then one day it just disappeared. I guess that should have been a sign they were having issues.
- Yhippa 6y agoI was wondering where that that went and thought it was a bug or something.
- alexbanks 6y agoHappy that Shroud and Ninja get to come back to Twitch
- apazzolini 6y agoMy solution to a streamer moving to Facebook Gaming is simply going to be watching a different streamer.
- jonny_eh 6y agoStreamers really are a dime a dozen. No offense to streamers here.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- JoshGlazebrook 6y agoThe only thing I don't like about Twitch is they got rid of their Roku app. I assume it's Amazon's doing, but it still eliminates a large portion of users who want to watch gamers on Twitch.
- alibert 6y agoMixer has a nice streaming tech. I used to stream to a friend who could interact (voice chat) with me with almost no stream delay (<500ms). I don't think Twitch offers a latency as low as Mixer. Last time I tried (some weeks ago), it was still 2+ secs.
- HacklesRaised 6y agoCaffeine.tv offer similar latency. (Full disclosure, I used to work there)
- reggieband 6y agoI'm very surprised that MS has quit this quickly. I didn't expect them to win in the short-term against Twitch and I doubt they did either. This suggests that Mixer didn't just do poorly (which could have been assumed) but it must have been a deep catastrophe that showed no signs of turning around. I think the problem with video, and the monopolies it continues to create, is the massive expense of data transfer. I'm guessing Mixer had hundreds/thousands of streamers active at any given time. I assume this was a massive cost and the revenue to support it (even ignoring their deals with streamers like Ninja/Shroud) just wasn't there. It makes me doubt the profitability of Twitch, although you can be sure they are breathing a sigh of relief today.
- the_duke 6y agoThey tried to integrate with XBox. They pumped millions and millions into exclusivity deals with streamers like Ninja and Shroud, only saw small growth and then completely stalled. Even during the recent lockdowns they remained almost flat, while others had big viewership spikes. At some point you just have to call it quits. The new competition besides Twitch is FB Gaming and YouTube, which can leverage existing platforms with a huge userbase. An isolated platform that offers no value over Twitch has no chance in this environment.
- ihumanable 6y agoI think your analysis is dead on, the only thing I'm surprised by is that Facebook has some sort of FB Gaming streaming platform. I don't really use Facebook, but I watch a fair number of twitch streamers and let's plays and whatnot on YouTube and I've never once heard anyone mention FB Gaming.
- butler14 6y agoThis seems super out of no where and way too soon to throw the towel in. Thinking there was some break clauses in Ninja and Shroud’s contracts that incentivised MS’s early exit.
- errantspark 6y agoIt's kind of sad to see Mixer/Beam go, they did have a couple unique features I made good use of. - FTL protocol, a streaming protocol based on UDP which had sub 1 second delay times, far far superior to what Twitch is capable of. - User interaction, I was able to quite quickly set up buttons on my page that let my stream viewers control the RGB lighting in my room in interesting ways, and it was a lot of fun for me as a streamer to get that realtime interaction with my viewers
- uncoder0 6y agoI'm very familiar with Mixer my company does interactive streaming and I really liked Mixer/Beam they had a great team. Their mobile interactivity is next to their low latency as the high marks of the platform. I do think their audience acquisition strategy with large streamers was lopsided. Maybe if they went farther down the longtail and involved a lot more content creators they could have carved out a whole community. Really sad to see them go. Shameless plug warning but, if you're moving over to Twitch there are a lot of great extensions and you can always easily build one on your own with our tools at Muxy.
- willcipriano 6y ago> FTL protocol, a streaming protocol based on UDP which had sub 1 second delay times, far far superior to what Twitch is capable of. I don't use/watch any of these platforms but I heard the delay is a feature of Twitch to prevent people from "screen peeking" players when they play online.
- detaro 6y agoYou can always add artificial delay if that's what you want, but if you don't want to delay to interact with your audience/have them interact with the game, you want something that can do low-latency.
- zapzupnz 6y agoTotally. Avoiding screen sniping should be up to the streamer — in OBS, for instance, one could set up a scene with one source item, an instance of another scene, then add a delay filter to it. Then one can freely switch between the live scene and the delayed scene. Simple.
- Lorin 6y ago9 year gaming/esports industry insider here. I don't understand why Mixer, after failing to penetrate the game streaming market - didn't pivot to a tech/coder oriented streaming service. It would have better integrated with Microsoft's other products (GitHub, Teams, etc), and trivialized finding marketing/ad-fill partners. Twitch has a 'science & technology' channel grouping which is nice, but there's a demographic mismatch and thus it has less than 10k viewers on average. This niche would have been a shoe-in for a Microsoft service. I also wonder what would have happened in a parallel universe where Beam wasn't acquired by Microsoft.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- slightwinder 6y ago> I don't understand why Mixer, after failing to penetrate the game streaming market - didn't pivot to a tech/coder oriented streaming service. It would have better integrated with Microsoft's other products (GitHub, Teams, etc), and trivialized finding marketing/ad-fill partners. Because this doesn't make money, has a very low market and doesn't need all the expensive technology they invested into. > Twitch has a 'science & technology' channel grouping which is nice Exactly, and it sucks. I'm a dev, I occasionally watch there, but it's just not very good. Technology is just not good content for this medium. And a good streamer has the kind of personality which is hard to find with technology-affine people. > but there's a demographic mismatch Not true. There are many coders and people working in IT on twitch. They probably even make the biggest group outside of gamers. Though, it's also true that Twitch does not sell this category well. There are many stuff outside of gaming which could be sold better. Creative-Categories have this problem too.
- WorldMaker 6y agoIt's a relatively smaller niche than gaming/esports, so such a pivot was unlikely. Microsoft did admit there is a smarter pivot on the tech side, at least. Mixer's claim to fame over Twitch et al was lower latency streaming and Microsoft admitted they are already working to move the technical teams at Mixer to work on Teams. > I also wonder what would have happened in a parallel universe where Beam wasn't acquired by Microsoft. Best guess: something very similar. Beam would likely have also failed to break much of a second place against entrenched competitor Twitch and likely failed to find a solution to the network effects battles when Facebook Gaming or YouTube gaming started up. Best case for them would likely have been an acquihire by Facebook or YouTube rather than Microsoft in that scenario where Microsoft didn't acquire them.
- Sleaker 6y agois FB gaming even a platform that people want ? I just get annoyed and skip past stuff that shows up on my feed cause that's not how I want to use FB ever.. If I wanted to watch someone streaming I'd go use a site specifically for that, but maybe my internet use is dissimilar to how most people expect content to be delivered?
- lawik 6y agoMicrosoft has done so much to improve their reputation. I think this is a risk and a mistake.
- mxscho 6y agohttps://www.streamhatchet.com/pdf/report2019.pdf https://www.streamhatchet.com/pdf/report2019.pdf Some 2019 streaming numbers from pre-Corona era which I found interesting at that time. Mixer declined in hours watched after summer of 2019. Also interesting to see that Facebook "Gaming"'s top games only feature mobile games. Being a gamer myself I therefore find it difficult to really view them as a serious competitor to the game streaming market of YouTube and Twitch. Maybe this will change with Mixer's user base.
- remir 6y agoI never heard of Facebook Gaming. Is it a serious competitor to Twitch?
- esturk 6y agoI'll give credit to Mixer for 1 thing they did do well, you will only expect proper gaming channels. Nowadays, Twitch is filled with "Just Chatting" which you have people doing illegal watch parties of copyrighted content or girls showing just enough skin to not get banned. Twitch is slowly becoming a degenerate platform.
- spoopyskelly 6y ago> Twitch is slowly becoming a degenerate platform. Are you 80?
- thejynxed 6y agoNo, but I can fully understand their viewpoint, especially if they have kids to monitor. People forget part of the reason YT has been cracking down heavily on the behavior and content within streams and static video is complaints from parents and politicians, not just advertisers or nebulous "social justice" groups. What we may see as perfectly acceptable is not the same as the parents of a young teenager trying to prevent their kid getting bombed with Rule 34 content because they were suggested a Fortnite stream.
- pochamago 6y agoI always hoped Mixer would do better, I really liked watching E3 conferences on it over Twitch and YouTube. Its latency really was way better than them, and it seemed like Microsoft had better infrastructure overall.
- numlock86 6y ago>dead streaming is shutting down and partnering with dead streaming The only real alternative to Twitch is streaming live on YouTube. Not a competitor, but an alternative. And that's only because they have a massive viewership already. A lot of those probably never heard about Mixer or even Twitch at all. You'd think it's the same with Facebook, but that's like a different target audience. You don't usually go to Facebook to binge videos. Just like it would make no sense to stream live on Twitter.