14 ms·
TSMC officially begins 5 nm production
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoSo Intel has lost the price and performance war against the latest Ryzen architecture and has also lost the fab war against TSMC and if the rumors of Apple moving to their own ARM based arch on TSMC node next year come true, then I expect Intel stock to take a serious tank. That being said, I'm not too worried about Intel, they have such a diverse silicon portfolio(FPGAs, Optane, etc.) that I'm sure they'll be fine in the end. My $0.02.
- tyingq 6y agoThere are some new dynamics in play for Intel that didn't used to be there. For example, most of the server CPUs used to be bought by conservative data center owners at stodgy companies. Change didn't happen quickly. Now, you have huge entities like AWS that can, for example, move things like ALB, RDS, SQS, or Aurora off of Intel on little more than a whim. Basically, the leverage on the customer side is consolidated now, and the barrier to leave you is lower.
- an_opabinia 6y agoDatacenters are the highest-binned parts, and therefore the highest margins. Whom is Amazon going to sell low-bin Gravitons to? It isn't cost effective to run them, just like it's not cost effective to use low-binned Intel or AMD chips in datacenters. It's intrinsic to the way all chips are manufactured. Making your own low performance chips makes clear economic sense, as the producer and consumer of all output. But there have been decades of people trying to make their own high-performance chips as both consumer and producer, and they inevitably fail. And it's not super black and white, whose "subsidizing" whom, in the chip business - datacenter purchasers get cheaper chips because Intel can sell lower-binned parts to enthusiasts, while enthusiasts get cheaper parts because datacenters pay more. Same thing is observed for GPUs, product segmentation in chips is a real synergy and not zero sum. Who knows if that will succeed, for the idiosyncratic reason of the foundry business being separate from the IP business. Did it really just take a corporate reorg? Maybe AMD was right.
- tyingq 6y agoThe question about where low-binned Gravitons go to is an interesting one. But my point on how easy it is now, as compared to the past, for large swaths of customers to move away from Intel, stands. Moving to AMD or some 3rd party ARM provider are options outside of Graviton that can be done quickly.
- SergeAx 6y agoA lot of datacenter running cost lays in power and cooling (which requires more power). Maybe Gravitons are not that space effective, but they are definitely power effective, so there is a possibility to get a better margin in the long run.
- rckoepke 6y agoSome people predict that feature shrinking may end around 2025 with an inability to go below 2nm. If that's the case, Intel (and everyone else) will get time to "catch up" to the latest technology standards around 2030. TSMC may not be able to hold a lead forever, if there is a physics wall that stops additional shrinking. There will be additional efficiencies to be found, and TSMC may continue to have an edge on a business-process level, but if shrinking stops, I'd expect the market to become as competitive as vehicle manufacturing currently is, by 2040.
- pantulis 6y agoAlso, being the first doesnt mean you necessarilly win: smaller node size will give poorer wafer yields, giving Intel time to milk older node processes while playing catchup with TSMC.
- erichocean 6y agoTSMC also has older process nodes running, there's literally no advantage to Intel failing to execute on their product roadmap; it's all downside.
- noir_lord 6y agoOlder and at this point mature 7nm processes which is behind I suspect the new XT processors from AMD, yields improved enough to bin higher.
- noir_lord 6y agoIntel has been milking those 14nm++++++ processors for so long now that TSMC went screaming past dragging AMD and Apple with them, I'm not seeing an upside for Intel out of any of this and that's before Meltdown. I'm still smarting about that dropping 3 weeks after we rolled new servers out at work.
- bilalhusain 6y agoIntel's roadmap (from last year) is suspected to target 1.4nm in 2029 https://www.anandtech.com/show/15217/intels-manufacturing-roadmap-from-2019-to-2029 https://www.anandtech.com/show/15217/intels-manufacturing-ro...
- agumonkey 6y agoI pity Intel a tiny bit because even though they probably got a bit too comfy on price/feature ratio, I think they took the 1st runner blow by being the first to try sub 14nm at a time when no clear path was on sight, and by the time they got knee deep in their failing strategy, other caught up and now everybody is gliding (seemingly) easily toward 7nm. Times of crisis are also interesting, maybe intel will have to find new ideas to get his status back.
- The_rationalist 6y agoeverybody? 7nm has beaten globalfoundries
- AgloeDreams 6y ago> Apple moving to their own ARM based arch on TSMC node next year Nice timing.
- szatkus 6y agoTSMC 7nm and Intel 7nm are completely different things. At this point it's unknown how Intel's 7nm process is going to better/worse than TSMC counter-part. For sure 10nm was a disaster, but the next one doesn't have to be. Recently TSMC uses names like N7 and N5 for their processes, because they're no more related to actual nanometers on chips. Same for Intel, but they stick to their traditional naming.
- dehrmann 6y agoI'm starting to treat process nodes as about as meaningful as clock speed.
- imtringued 6y agoIt's kind of like rating composite armor by how thick a steel plate would have to be to achieve equal protection except in this case every manufacturer decided to use a different type of steel which makes the entire idea pointless.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y ago> they have such a diverse silicon portfolio That had a diverse portfolio 25 years ago. They sold all of it off and now only have a handful of money makers.
- Traster 6y agoI wouldn't look to FPGAs or Optane to save Intel's bacon. The issue Intel have is that the x86 is their cash cow - since Intel's primary way of selling FPGAs and Optane is bundling it with their CPU. It's all about pricing the full package of products and using their CPU dominance as leverage.
- lowmemcpu 6y agoWhat changed to enable this? I was told a decade ago by my professor that chip makers were facing an issue with electrons jumping across these tiny circuits, and couldn't go much smaller. I'm continuously surprised.
- pulse7 6y ago5 nm in reality is not a 5 nm, but just a marketing name suggesting further optimizations by about 20-40%.
- marcosdumay 6y agoExcess electrons and holes in silicon spread through spaces on the order of 10nm. Any smaller features will get mixed up. But that's not really what is happening here. The first thing is that those are feature size, not the size of the dopant region. They are like the size of the pixels on a screen, where the transistors get drawn. The second thing is that this limit is for silicon crystals, and top of line chips are now built in 3D with mixed materials, so you can have an entire crystal that is smaller (at least in one dimension) than that limit.
- imtringued 6y agoYou need to look at the physical dimensions of the transistor instead of the marketing.
- x87678r 6y agoI've been looking at Huawei gear, Samsung memory as well and its getting a bit scary about how far USA is behind Asian countries in high tech. Meanwhile all undergrads understand FANG companies pay best, it seems crazy.
- 11thEarlOfMar 6y agoWould be interested in a specific technology that the USA is behind Asian countries in.
- ipsum2 6y agoManufacturing chips, which is the subject of the article.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 11thEarlOfMar 6y agoChips are manufactured using equipment that is not made in Taiwan or China. It's primarily made in the USA, Japan and Europe. That same equipment is available to Intel. In the last 12 months, Intel's net profit was $21,000,000,000. I don't work for Intel so I don't know, but I'd wager that any chip node that TSMC can produce, Intel can produce as well. Intel has access to the same equipment and plenty of profit to work with. They either choose not to, or, they simply choose not to advertise the capability. For TSMC, as a foundry, their manufacturing capability is a selling point. For Intel, it is a strategic advantage. It makes sense for TSMC to announce what node they are capable of. It does not make sense for Intel to do so. Intel sells chips based on the chips' capabilities. Not on Intel's manufacturing capabilities.
- ipsum2 6y agoThere are reports that Intel is using TSMC for manufacturing their GPU. If they could replicate what TSMC is doing easily, I doubt they would have done so. https://wccftech.com/intel-abandoning-10nm-after-dg1-planning-to-use-tsmcs-6nm-and-3nm-for-next-generation-xe-gpus/ https://wccftech.com/intel-abandoning-10nm-after-dg1-plannin... Also in the article: > Interestingly, however, Intel's CFO has previously admitted that 10nm yields aren't great and will actually be lower in profitability than their older 22nm process
- SomeoneFromCA 6y agoSingle-thread performance it tied to clock frequency, which cannot go above 5Ghz, so the only thing we'll see is more cores. It is actually blessing in disguise, this is exactly why ancient Core Duos, made in 2007 are still perfectly usable for office applications and even lightweight development.
- mywittyname 6y agoWhere do you get this idea? Single-threaded performance has improved substantially in the past several generations of Intel processors. Single-threaded performance and clock speeds have not been correlated outside of same generation for a while now - like over a decade. https://www.cpubenchmark.net/singleThread.html https://www.cpubenchmark.net/singleThread.html There's are 2.8GHz processors at the top of that benchmark with a 3100 score and one near the bottom with a 539 score, as well as everywhere in between.
- szatkus 6y agoProbably he based his opinion on speed of progress. In 2006 you could buy Core 2 Duo at 3.0GHz. Modern processor at 4.5GHz would be maybe just 3 times faster in normal, every day, single thread use which seems like a lot, but isn't too much if you think that CPUs 14 years before Core 2 Duo were clocked at 33MHz and IPC slightly below 1. My dad uses a computer with C2Q CPU and it's still fast enough for everyday use. Edit: to be clear, he's still wrong, we had quite untrivial IPC increase during all these years. I just wanted to point out that he's comment probably was based on empirical data.
- WizardAustralis 6y agoOne of my desktops is a C2Q and I swear I could get another decade out of it yet.
- qes 6y ago5% increase per gen for most of the past decade vs. 50% increase per gen when clock speeds were increasing in lock step along with transistor count, but sure. I've got a 13 year old laptop that runs today's OS's and development software a little slow but ultimately just fine, and if it weren't for a low limit on installed RAM it would be more than "ultimately" just fine. That would've been absolutely laughable even 10 years ago, much less 20. You'd be lucky to be able to run a then-current OS on 2-3 year old hardware in the 90's through early 2000's.
- fizixer 6y agoMoore's law is dead. First, Intel and the semiconductor consortium started the garbage definition of a technology node about 10 years ago, when pitch levels stopped following Moore's law. Now TSMC and all Intel competitors straight up started lying through their teeth. I'm sure what TSMC is calling '5nm' is a complete joke even in face of the horrible redefinition 10 years ago. Don't believe me? See for yourself: - nVidia GeForce GTX 1080 Ti was announced in 2016. base clock 1481 MHz, 11.34 TeraFLOPs FP32, on a 471 mm2 die [1]. - Four years later, RTX 3080 Ti, base clock 1905 MHz, 21.1 TeraFLOPs FP32, on a 700 mm2 die [2]. - 21.1 / 11.34 = 1.86x improvement in raw TeraFLOPs. - 700 / 471 = 1.486x die size increase - 1905 / 1481 = 1.286x base clock increase - 1.486 * 1.286 = 1.91x Conclusion: nVidia could use the bigger die size and the higher base clock to deliver 1.91x the performance using the same 16nm technology node (theoretically). But instead, using the 7nm node, they're delivering even less of a performance bump, 1.86x, when in reality it should've been 7.64x (= 4x * 1.91x, considering two node jumps, and the die-size and base-clock bump). [1] https://www.techpowerup.com/gpu-specs/geforce-gtx-1080-ti.c2877 https://www.techpowerup.com/gpu-specs/geforce-gtx-1080-ti.c2... [2] https://www.techpowerup.com/gpu-specs/geforce-rtx-3080-ti.c3581 https://www.techpowerup.com/gpu-specs/geforce-rtx-3080-ti.c3...
- AtHeartEngineer 6y agoId be interested to see the wattage per teraflop difference between the two.
- stagger87 6y ago> Moore's law is dead. GTX 1080 - 11b transistors (2016) RTX 3080 - 45b transistors (2020) From Wikipedia "Moore's law is the observation that the number of transistors in a dense integrated circuit doubles about every two years."
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AnimalMuppet 6y ago> RTX 3080 - 45b transistors (2020) That's just... insane. That's five transistors for every person on the planet. In 700 mm2.
- wolf550e 6y agohttps://en.wikichip.org/wiki/5_nm_lithography_process https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/5_nm_lithography_process Note that the marketing name is meaningless, has nothing to do with feature sizes. Also note that "Intel 10nm" is denser than "TSMC 7nm" and Intel's planned "7nm" should be denser than "TSMC 5nm".
- Lind5 6y agoSeveral foundries are ramping up their new 5nm processes in the market, but now customers must decide whether to design their next chips around the current transistor type or move to a different one at 3nm and beyond https://semiengineering.com/5-3nm-wars-begin/ https://semiengineering.com/5-3nm-wars-begin/
- wetpaws 6y agoGentle reminder that 5nm is a meaningless marketing number that does not represent neither the transistor size no element density, and it does not correlate in any way with all other Xnm production of other companies.
- ceo_tim_crook 6y agoIntel on suicide watch
- blackrock 6y agoWhat ever happened to clock speed? Nobody ever talks about that anymore.
- imtringued 6y agoIncreasing clock speed will require a different technology than silicon. It's not impossible to think that graphene or carbon nano tubes could allow higher clock speeds.
- redis_mlc 6y agoAs you increase clock speed, temperatures approach the surface of the sun. Besides being hard to cool, it causes chemical, delamination and other changes to the chip, eroding it. "In 2001, Pat Gelsinger—then Intel‘s CTO—predicted that within a decade the energy density of chips would be equivalent to the surface the sun if nothing was done." https://semiengineering.com/thermal-damage-to-chips-widens/ https://semiengineering.com/thermal-damage-to-chips-widens/