15 ms·
Obviously using a throwaway here. Our board members got it into their heads that successful companies must have an AI "play", so they instructed the CEO to inve
by worriedformyjob 6y ago
Obviously using a throwaway here. Our board members got it into their heads that successful companies must have an AI "play", so they instructed the CEO to invest about 10% of our development budget on AI.
We are doing absolutely inane projects that have no hope of succeeding.
We serve a niche industry where certified professionals have to do certain tasks personally, instead of being able to delegate to secretaries. Somehow our CEO has been convinced that AI can be trained to do these tasks, at a reliability level not achievable by other humans.
Team motivation is in a weird space: everyone is relaxed because there is no pressure to succeed - we all know the project will fail unless someone develops well-perfoming, human-level AGI before Q4/2020. Lots of long lunches and checking out early in the afternoon.
At the same time, everyone is worried how terrible the fallout is going to be once the project reaches its inevitable conclusion.
Interesting times, but at least we can now tell investors we are a keen company with an AI play up our sleeve!
- seibelj 6y agoJust pivot to "assisted-AI" where your solution is really bad but it adds "super-powers" to all their existing employees. It may give cover to some other businesses to fire staff under the "force-multiplier" argument that your software adds ("If their software makes every employee 33% better, we can fire 33% of our staff!").
- dctoedt 6y agoAnd of course you're being facetious, because if everyone is 33% better, the company can fire 25% of its staff (right?).
- m463 6y agoThat's hilarious - I can't help but think of this dilbert cartoon on making change: https://dilbert.com/strip/1993-03-20 https://dilbert.com/strip/1993-03-20 (I am not putting you down)
- thaumasiotes 6y agoI would have thought of this one: https://dilbert.com/strip/1998-03-17 https://dilbert.com/strip/1998-03-17 My dad always disliked the strip you cite, because the change Dilbert expects is $5.25, but there's no way to provide $7.14 in a way that couldn't be trivially reduced to $2.14. If the goal is to make things easy for the cashier, he should obviously provide $2.14 and just keep the $5 he already has anyway.
- m463 6y agoYou are right, that is a much much better cartoon as a reply! If it had been in my faulty memory banks... (and I agreee - the first dilbert cartoon is super contrived)
- OJFord 6y agoOh dear. Erroneous 'grossing up' percentages and mis-non-use of percentage points is a pet hate of mine. I didn't realise I was a cartoon!
- emmelaich 6y agoI'm sure that's intended; Dilbert is smart but dumb. Or dumb but smart.
- sukilot 6y agoI'm pretty sure it's just a mistake because Adams wasn't careful.
- rurp 6y agoYears ago I worked at a store with registers that didn't calculate change; myself and the other cashiers would need to calculate the change mentally. Once in a while I would get people like this who threw out convoluted amounts of change. Normally it was fine, but sometimes towards the end of a long day when my brain was tired I wanted to strangle them. The store actually had really great employees overall and I suspect this little factor played a big part in that. Part of the application process was a basic math test and it was funny to see how quickly some applicants recoiled when they found that out. It seemed to be a great filter.
- aledalgrande 6y agoOn the other side you could have this pretty good AI, which can be made amazing just by adding a human step to it.
- reading-at-work 6y ago> we all know the project will fail unless someone develops well-perfoming, human-level AGI before Q4/2020 This is hilarious, and makes me wonder how many similar corporate AI initiatives are under way in the world right now.
- bob33212 6y agoI have had a couple conversations where a business guy starts off with a decent idea then he says something like "the cognitive AI module will fill out your expense report after watching you do it for a couple weeks". What the fuck? If I had the ability to code a cognitive AI module which could do that I would not be building it for you, I would solve self driving and license the software for billions.
- hieunc229 6y agoBusiness guys usually comes together and brag about their works. Quite often, they start to talk about things they heard but don’t understand much. And the other one hear about it, get excited, but also don’t understand much. Then on the meeting, he brought the idea up and convince everyone to do it. The next you know, you’re pulling your hair out trying to understand what is going on
- pm90 6y agoThis happens way too often. They often read a blog that talks about how X was implemented at company Y and mindlessly cite the blog for their own related-but-different-in-important-ways ideas and it’s upto the engineers to fact check the wackiness. It’s not pleasant. This happened to me recently where a PM shared a blog about someone who had built an “all encompassing multi cloud cost calculator” for their org and had blogged about it. The PM was naturally extremely excited but I asked him to find more details about the tool and if/how that can be used. Turns out even though it was supposedly open sourced it wasn’t really available to just anyone but the author promised he would release it in a month. That was over 6 months ago, no word from the author or PM. These blog fueled hype trains are extremely destructive. It makes engineering appear trivial. Building useful tool might be easier now but it’s not trivial. And if a tool sounds too good to be true it probably is.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hedora 6y agoOnce the CEO asked me to build a human level AGI in front of our only customer (small company). I asked them what they wanted to do (it was solvable with keyword search) and told the CEO that I’d be happy to get it into the next version. It took an afternoon or so to implement. Gotta love the PHB effect.
- Robelius 6y agoPHB Effect?
- totetsu 6y agothis maybe? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29214487/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29214487/
- jakear 6y agoCertainly not. But the results they list are interesting - my gut tells me they wouldn’t be reproducible. Can’t seem to find the full text though, pretty messed up that my tax dollars go to finance academia that I can’t even consume.
- eindiran 6y ago"PHB" means "Pointy-Haired Boss": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pointy-haired_Boss https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pointy-haired_Boss The relevant bit: > He is notable for his micromanagement, gross incompetence, obliviousness to his surroundings, and unhelpful buzzword usage; yet somehow retains power in the workplace.
- hedora 6y agoPointy haired boss. (From Dilbert)
- projektfu 6y agohttps://www.dilbert.com/strip/1995-11-17 https://www.dilbert.com/strip/1995-11-17
- noizejoy 6y ago> but at least we can now tell investors we are a keen company with an AI play up our sleeve Obviously I don't know the details of your company situation, but I've experienced myself over the years, that sometimes it can be less overall cost and trouble to give this kind of lip service, rather than fighting an overwhelming fashionable trend until that trend runs its natural course to extinction. > Team motivation is in a weird space: everyone is relaxed because there is no pressure to succeed If I was leading that team, I would try to find (or insert) nuggets of goodness (smaller/non-obvious objectives and tasks) in that project which allow the team members to get some personal longer term benefit out of it. And ideally find (or insert) nuggets of goodness (smaller/non-obvious objectives and tasks) in that project, which have a good chance of becoming useful to the company later - beyond the scope of the official project. And hopefully the team would become excited about doing something meaningful beyond the official project objective. p.s. I'm speaking from experience in this kind of a situation.
- hieunc229 6y agoWell, it sounds so weird but intriguing. Do you mind telling the rest of the story?
- noizejoy 6y agoThe story would probably make little sense to most HN readers, since it's very old and what was very non-obvious back then, became very obvious 5 years later. Around 1994/95 client/server was unassailable in board rooms (much like AI is now). And after initially speaking up against it, I ended up shutting up about my criticism of that architectural approach, since it would have just gotten me fired. So I ended up sneaking some early Internet technologies into a big client/server project I managed. Doing that ended up benefiting those developers in future jobs, and the company, because they didn't have to re-write that part so quickly. :-)
- epberry 6y agoDoesn't this speak more to the board's astounding foresight than inane projects?
- danbmil99 6y agoThink about open-sourcing some of the stuff you're doing. Otherwise it's likely to stay buried in the corporate IP portfolio
- taneq 6y agoIs it really worth doing so if it's as inane as they say?
- danbmil99 6y agoMachine learning requires a lot of nuts and bolts devops type stuff that isn't directly related to the problem you're trying to solve. I think it's a shame that a lot of this stuff gets reinvented at different companies and kept under a cloak of secrecy. Any part of the problem that is not specifically related to the company's vision should be part of a communal effort make machine learning and AI tractable. Companies should compete on their core Mission and cooperate on all the plumbing.
- np_tedious 6y agoWould it be a better (even marginally) play to use AI to detect if they are passing off the work to underlings?
- tootie 6y agoHa. CTO at my last place did something similar. He hired an AI/ML team. I asked him what projects he had in mind and he said once the team was on board they'd find things to do. He also said we needed a voice app because he read an article about the size of the market. I quit before seeing how any of that worked out.
- coredog64 6y agoPrevious employer did something similar. Hired a crazy expensive data scientist, spent truckloads of money on a data swamp, er, lake, and then didn’t really have any goals for what to do with all that capacity. The new hire got lucky, as there was some low hanging fruit (optimizations we all knew about). The obvious solution was implemented and then he ex post facto claimed 100% credit for the revenue enhancement. Since it’s like 10x his salary every year he’s pretty much on autopilot.
- petters 6y agoSo you all knew about optimizations 10x a data scientist salary, but didn't act on them? Actually good that the company hired him then.
- willvarfar 6y ago> So you all knew about optimizations 10x a data scientist salary, but didn't act on them? Sadly, most engineers aren't allowed to pursue that kind of stuff. Normal dev jobs can be stifling.
- lifeisstillgood 6y agoIf you walk into your CEOs office today and say "I can increase revenue from our site by 1 million dollars" (#) you will get a hearing. If three devs on that site do it, with a poc they will get the chance to do it 95% of the time. But the CEO who hires a data scientist is explicitly asking that person to walk into their office and say "I can increase revenue by X" - that is their job. The website dev does not have that job. And there are two views on this problem - the CEO did the right thing by hiring someone to explicitly optimise the site - there are improvements to be made, create the right organisation so that those improvements flow to company. Or there is the other argument, that the organisation is stifling innovation from below, and that the CEO should have been actively soliciting improvements from dev team and elsewhere Generally both are right
- yters 6y agowhat about human augmented ai? that is what successful ai companies use
- uoaei 6y agoYeah exactly, the play here is to make AI assistants to human decision makers.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoIt could be worse... you could be at a company where using such technology is banned... because marketing and sales are scared of the blowback.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoI'm cynical about a lot of 'trends' that have popped up over the year, because oftentimes they're just compromises or marketing to get employees to join them. Notably, in recent years, a LOT of employers / recruiters will stuff "IoT" or "Blockchain" into their job descriptions, knowing full well they do nothing with it - or if they do, it's a couple hours a week they give up on to keep the employees happy, interested and motivated. It's a weird theater. Most of those jobs are generic Java work, but it's hard to find motivated / qualified people to work on just that.
- NalNezumi 6y agoOh boi does this hit hard as a engineer that recently got hired as a part of the AI/automation team on a startup, that few month in got told by the boss that "we need a AI team because we promised the investors. Investors are not interested in tech without AI baked in". Whelp.
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoReplace AI with ______. Some things never change!
- gwbas1c 6y agoI wish I knew the details of the project; getting to mess around with new technologies for a year and no strict deliverables is a great position to be in. Worst case, you got to learn some new tech and pad your resume for your next job.
- Plutonsvea 6y agoAlmost seems like menial work that your CEO might be using to gain a better foothold on gathering external investments. My experience with CEO's says that they aren't complete morons. I hope for your sake there is another valuable reason why he has you all doing this work.
- praptak 6y agoTimes change, patterns stay the same. I remember when Facebook got big, so obviously everybody had to copy them. Imagine working on an accounting application when the CEO suddenly instructs everybody to figure out how accountants could connect with each other and maybe publish their balance sheets instead of cat pictures or whatever. Details changed, but it was that weird.
- m0zg 6y agoTo kind of go against the flow here: _most_ of the projects I worked on seemed to be a waste of time when I worked on them, but ended up making a lot of money many years later, years after I'd moved on. I like the green field stuff, and green field stuff looks like a waste of time most of the time. The first three versions suck ass and don't do much, but without having them you don't get to something that doesn't suck. Both the first and the second project I worked on at MS seemed like horrible waste of time in early aughts, but have likely made tens of billions of dollars for it by now. Then there are projects where I did something ahead of its time (and was ultimately unsuccessful) yet other people did the exact same thing later and made a ton of money. Finally I ran engineering at a startup which spent ~3 years largely wasting time and money, only to be acquired for hundreds of millions of dollars for reasons that are still unclear to me. You never really know. Success is a random, nonlinear process and your effort is but one input to it. I've given up trying to predict if something will be successful if the work that's being done at the front lines is solid from the engineering standpoint. Business is mostly about being very persistent and/or being in the right place at the right time. For all you know your company might be one PhD hire away from absolutely blowing the doors off competition. Or it may get to that point years later because it started thinking about it now. Or having at least some sort of an AI strategy (even if not very successful) might double the acquisition price in some upcoming merger. All of those things would make your work worthwhile in retrospect even if the project fails. You never know such things. These uncertain situations are usually a blessing in disguise: because management has no clue, you can pretend that you have clue, and steer things in the direction that's useful to you. Put some cool things on your resume, if nothing else. Move on, see if you have better luck elsewhere.
- lifeisstillgood 6y agoThank you - it's nice to have a considered view on these things
- jpm_sd 6y agoThis is a great comment. If you're comfortable sharing any more information, I'd love to know just a bit more detail. What were the technologies or strategies that seemed useless at the time, but eventually succeeded?
- dkersten 6y agoIn my own experience, often non-technical people will attribute things as AI that we wouldn’t, eg any basic automation. Really anything that’s in any way intelligent or seems that way. I had a project where people were excited about a feature that was basically just alerting when one value crossed over or under another... I wonder if your team could provide real value to customers providing some smart “AI” feature that isn’t actually machine learning.
- blauditore 6y agoThe line of were AI starts is not well-defined. If you think about it, virtually all software can be considered AI if you put expectations low enough. From the other end, one could argue that once you understand the inner workings of a piece of AI, it just becomes a fancy algorithm to you. In the end, everything is just a piece of software converting input to output. My experience is that people tend to consider things AI whenever it feels like "magic" to them, at least in non-technical circles.
- dkersten 6y agoCompletely agree. If its artificial (all software) and its in some way intelligent p, or appears that way, (a lot of software, or features thereof), then you could argue its artificial intelligence, based on just those two words (ignoring the definition technical people give AI). That’s why machine learning is usually more useful from a technical discussion viewpoint. > From the other end Yeah, using wongarsu’s example of chess: brute forcing chess was once a highlight if AI achievement and now its just a crude search algorithm.
- bigiain 6y agoOn the other hand, actual AI is kinda cut-n-paste accessible now too. I slapped together a POC javascript tinyYolo feature detector demo last weekend (using someone else's code and pre-trained model from their github project), and joked when I showed it around that "And we can tell investors we're running AI, deep learning, and convolutional neural networks in our realtime production workflow!"... (But as we all know, all the _proper_ magic is done by the regexes buried in that Perl module dependency hidden in a deeply nested source code directory that no-one without a grey beard is ever game to peer into...)
- yusi-san 6y agoIt looks exactly like my company, but I am few months ahead. I am now at the time where investors starts to ask for results. The CEO wants to please them and starts to put pressure on our team by changing priorities almost everyday (which impact the project quality). The thing is, everyone knows that the project is doomed to fail.
- rosstex 6y agoIBM?
- alkonaut 6y agoMany of us have been there. I think what struck me was how low the treshold really is for what's accepted as "AI" in most industries. Do this: 1. make something that has some "modern" AI such as deep learning in it, but that doesn't do anything much useful (because that's almost impossible in most cases). E.g. predict something trivial based on a time series, and repoort it. We all know how hard this is, so just take some hello world ML project and change some inputs. 2. Find some easy project that actually makes business sense, and that isn't yet done, and can be done with simple logic or some old school "traditional" ML or constraint solving e.g. a scheduling/optimization problem. 3. Make sure these efforts are "merged" so that the fancy AI tech AND the measurable good outcome is the same project. The "AI" moonshot of the company. 4. You can now say you are doing "AI", you have measurable success.
- aloisdg 6y agoA "friend" of mine is doing exactly that in its disruptive startup. Their AI part is a joke and handle a part that nobody really care about, but hey they are doing it like every other cool kids.
- hjnilsson 6y agoIt cracks me up that on the new LG TVs (I have a C9), it has “AI preview”. Which means: when I hover the Netflix icon in the dashboard it presents a list of the most recently played shows. I think the “Open Recent” menu debuted in 1980s? But now it is AI!
- LoSboccacc 6y agoyeah I've resisted these fake ai project as much as possible, but sometimes the budget is there so you're better off spending it. bet there's something between a full AGI and a set of ifs on the audit log that could help the human experts reduce error rates and fit within the direction constraints
- waltherg 6y agoAny chance at sharing what consulting company put the AI play idea in your CEO's head?
- didymospl 6y agoI used to work at a software house which makes software for few big companies. A few years ago our CEO thought it's time to diversify our income stream by creating some SaaS. He came up with a really then-buzzword-packed(AI, ML, IoT, microservices, Kubernetes, mobile first) product. Quite ambitious, especially for a team of 5 people, regular web devs who had no working experience with any of those. Everyone voiced their concerns but we were told to just use our best efforts. Long story short: after a year or so, our boss decided to scrap our half-baked system and gave up on the idea of creating some internal product entirely.
- kmclean 6y agoI've had a very similar experience. I'm surprised at how little so many managers and investors understand AI. They talk about it like it's some sort of panacea that will make a company automatically grow 10x. Then you ask them what they actually want you to build and... Crickets.
- cm2187 6y agoPerhaps the most significant outcome is that you guys will be peppering your resume with AI buzzwords, which the board may be paying through expensive staff retention.
- vbtemp 6y ago> Interesting times, but at least we can now tell investors we are a keen company with an AI play up our sleeve! To be fair, this is absolutely not unique to you but literally every (software) company in america right now.
- weeboid 6y agoAhh, I see. You misunderstand your true customer. It is not the purchaser. It is the investor — PE. Or, "the market".
- surething123 6y agoI worked on a project that basically was a very simple rules engine, encoding a bunch of domain knowledge in a digestible dashboard format, which happened to use a few predictive models' output as well to drive a few of the rules. The product owner insisted that "AI" be in the name, whereas I was reluctant to put lipstick on that pig. Ultimately (as usually happens if the product owner is your boss) the "AI something something" name stuck, but the whole branding of the endeavor rubbed me the wrong way (even though the product was actually somewhat useful).