20 ms·
Zoom Acknowledges It Suspended Activists' Accounts at China's Request
- amrrs 6y ago> The company said it would no longer block accounts outside of mainland China at Beijing's request, but did not say outright how it would handle such requests that affect users within mainland China. Instead, Zoom said, it would develop technology to block users based on geography. Funny how these kind of statements are thrown around wherever something is blown up about Zoom. I'm one of those who had goodwill on Zoom but looking at the amount of issues popped up recently and their "Yeah this was intentional but I'm sorry next it it won't happen' response Pattern indicates that the company is aimed at only one thing - Growth at any cost
- ciarannolan 6y agoIt's the Facebook playbook of doing something illegal/immoral, getting caught, saying 'gee sorry, that was an accident', then doing it all over again.
- ct520 6y agoLOL for real. I will cry no tears for FB when they get what’s coming to them. Will be the MySpace of my kids time.(if it’s not already is)
- lotsofpulp 6y agoFB has had solid revenue and net income for many years, so much that it’s one of the most valuable companies in the world. It’s not comparable to MySpace, and definitely isn’t going anywhere anytime soon.
- DeusExMachina 6y agoWhile Facebook and MySpace are different in many ways, the average lifespan of a S&P 500 company is below 20 years. Facebook could very well be an outlier. If it isn't, it could definitely go away in the coming years. In any case, that shows that its revenue/income is not a predictor of anything. When a company spirals down, it does so at an accelerating rate and can quickly burn through any amount of cash.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoFacebook is very far from an average SP500 company, as are the rest of the big tech companies. They drive the market indices with how much investors think they are worth and will be worth. And they have levels of cash that tech (or any) companies in decades past could only dream of.
- ct520 6y agoUh - ok
- echelon 6y agoAs bad as Facebook is, it's being supplanted by the CCP-controlled TikTok. That's almost certainly worse for freedom.
- noirbot 6y agoI'm not sure supplanted is right here. TikTok right now feels more like it's taking the role of Snapchat/Vine/Instagram. Part of the never-ending rollover of new apps for that sort of thing. Time will tell, but it doesn't feel like it will kill Facebook.
- thedragonbabe 6y agoExactly
- polemic 6y agoHard disagree. Until extremely recently Zoom was a mature enterprise video conference solution. It's a B2B product that has suddenly exploded in general consumer usage, and suddenly product and commercial decisions made in that context are at odds with their new market. They don't sell ads or your personal data, they're not interested in your private life, and their users are their customer. In other words, they lack the nefarious motive of the Facebooks of the world. They're changing - rapidly - and I believe we can take their efforts to change at face value.
- reaperducer 6y agothey lack the nefarious motive of the Facebooks of the world No. It lacks the obvious, commercial nefarious motives of the Facebooks of the world. As many have pointed out, Zoom is believed to be CCP-controlled at some level. That's as nefarious as it gets.
- giantDinosaur 6y agoI'm surprised they don't implement particular forms of shadow banning, such as degrading connections and causing dropouts for particular accounts. That'd be much harder to prove than account termination. Frustrate instead of infuriate, like aspects of the GFW.
- duxup 6y agoI feel like they would get caught and China doesn't want "just bother these people"....
- giantDinosaur 6y agoYes, it's probably unworkable in terms of getting away with it.
- dsalzman 6y agoVote with your wallet.
- duxup 6y ago"Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere. We are caught in an inescapable network of mutuality, tied in a single garment of destiny. Whatever affects one directly, affects all indirectly.” -Martin Luther King Jr.
- draw_down 6y agoAlso: “[Capitalism] started out with a noble and high motive… but like most human systems it fell victim to the very thing it was revolting against. So today capitalism has out-lived its usefulness.“
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dehrmann 6y agoIf I were a company using Zoom, I'd be a little worried. Zoom already proved security isn't part of it's culture; now, likely because of it's dev office in China, it's doing at least some of what China asks. I'm suspicious of their end-to-end encryption claims (and implementation), and it's in the realm of possibility that the Chinese government is spying on Zoom calls.
- runawaybottle 6y agoDoes anyone know if Zoom is built on any open source video streaming tech? I’m have a hard time believing their product isn’t going to meet massive amounts of competition very soon. Edit: After some Googling - https://webrtchacks.com/zoom-avoids-using-webrtc/ https://webrtchacks.com/zoom-avoids-using-webrtc/
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoNo, it’s a custom solution.
- bigphishy 6y agoThey were former employees of webex and may have taken a lot software design from that product.
- jdm2212 6y agoGiven that purely from the standpoint of product quality, WebEx is a gigantic dumpster fire and Zoom is fantastic, it seems likely that they learned mostly what not to do from WebEx.
- dehrmann 6y ago> I’m have a hard time believing their product isn’t going to meet massive amounts of competition very soon. There have been several vendors doing this for years. Google Hangouts, Skype, BlueJeans, Webex. Zoom just did it better. Except for security; Zoom doesn't understand security.
- ridewinter 6y agoPaul Graham tweeted the other day about the opportunity to supplant Zoom with something better. Zoom doesn't seem to have much of a moat, right? Most users aren't even logged in.
- dehrmann 6y agoIts only moat is a better experience than competitors. This shouldn't be much of a moat, but having used competitors' products, it somehow is.
- montroser 6y agoSome quality "indie" zoom alternatives: https://whereby.com https://whereby.com https://team.video https://team.video
- fossuser 6y ago“The reality is Zoom operates in more than 80 countries and continues to expand, which requires compliance with local laws even as Zoom seeks to promote the open exchange of ideas.“ This kind of rationalization isn’t just a problem with Zoom, Apple does the same thing - blocking podcasts and other apps in the Chinese market (also the Taiwan flag emoji). This is wrong. What’s legal and what’s right are not the same thing, Zoom’s PR about the promotion of an “open exchange of ideas” is nonsense and both Zoom and the CCP know it. Companies that work to suppress the rights of citizens are complicit in that suppression and its legality is irrelevant. When Zoom is requested to send over names and videos of political dissidents to authoritarian leaders will they comply? I’m sure those killed will be pleased to know Zoom was operating within the legal framework of their country. Legality should be the bare minimum standard - and in countries with bad laws (Middle East, China) it shouldn’t even be that.
- f00_ 6y agothey have a lot of staff in china proper right? I mean, it's likely like every other business trying to operate in china (including google) bow down to the government to get the money what can you expect, just use open source
- barry-cotter 6y agoAlmost all their engineering staff are in China. > In January 2020, Zoom had over 2,500 employees, 1,396 are in the United States and 1,136 are in their international locations.[69] Although 700 employees within a subsidiary work in China and develop Zoom software. ... Zoom's product development team is largely based in China, where an average entry-level tech salary is one-third of American salaries, which is a key driver of its profitability. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoom_Video_Communications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoom_Video_Communications
- monocasa 6y agoAlso, as absolutely reprehensible Apple's similar actions are, Zoom canceled _a US based account_ because of a Chinese request. It's one thing to be all "we comply with local laws", and another to enforce one country's geopolitical aspirations across international borders. Like, I think companies should take a stand and both aren't acceptable, but Zoom takes new, additional steps here.
- refurb 6y agoWhat I'm shocked about is that a group of senior leader at Zoom thought this was a good decision. Maybe they thought they could get away with it and things would blow over?
- BadassFractal 6y agoOr they knew this would blow up on Twitter, but that they would get in trouble in China for refusing the government request of their own volition. So they did what the govt wanted, waited for the uproar, and now they can CYA by blaming the Western mob on the forced change of heart. Zoom ends up doing the right thing, and the execs don't end up in a gulag somewhere.
- dirtyid 6y agoPretty much what I speculated [1]. Chinese companies / companies with large Chinese footprints are going global, many are exploring ways to disassociate from Chinese influence as controversies crop up. It's an uphill battle, at least for some western markets. US will object the loudest and has the domestic alternatives to shift the balance. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23484028 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23484028 Speculation: Chinese zoom users were required to switch to Chinese version of Zoom last September. There were probably mainland users using international version + VPN to participate in the event, probably some sort of local regulation that prevents users in CN from interacting with international meets, especially on no-no subjects. From 2nd link below: >>Intensifying international tensions and the country’s upcoming 70th anniversary are cited as reasons for the block, according to Chinese media. Some old articles: Zoom suspends Chinese individuals users from hosting meetings due to ‘regulatory demand’ https://technode.com/2020/05/15/zoom-suspends-chinese-individuals-users-from-hosting-meetings-due-to-regulatory-demand/ https://technode.com/2020/05/15/zoom-suspends-chinese-indivi... China’s Zoom users switch to local version after blockage https://technode.com/2019/09/19/chinas-zoom-users-switch-to-local-version-after-blockage/ https://technode.com/2019/09/19/chinas-zoom-users-switch-to-... China blocks US video-conferencing tool Zoom https://technode.com/2019/09/09/china-blocks-us-video-conferencing-tool-zoom/ https://technode.com/2019/09/09/china-blocks-us-video-confer...
- baybal2 6y agoThe thing is, this is the model how many US dotcoms wanted to operate in China, where Chinese legal requests would have no impact outside of China. And another thing is that it has totally set off Chinese government. On one side, they are very unhappy that this completely works around the very much intended action to shut up their opposition's voice abroad, but on other side this precludes further action China can do while still formally claiming it follows legal process, and not claiming extraterritorial jurisdiction explicitly. This is why they pushed out such de-jure compliant, but not de-facto incompliant Western companies with equally silly, passive aggressive tactics, like closing companies offices for months on end under pretext of fire safety violations.
- joyfulmantis 6y agothe offical blog post is at: https://blog.zoom.us/wordpress/2020/06/11/improving-our-policies-as-we-continue-to-enable-global-collaboration/ https://blog.zoom.us/wordpress/2020/06/11/improving-our-poli... Was it wrong to suspend accounts outside of mainland china? Ultimately yes, but as they stress these were accounts that were holding meetings with mostly mainland chinese participants in it. Any company operating globally needs to follow all the local laws where they operate in. Zoom's decision to develop technology to ban participants from specific countries joining meetings seems to be a good solution to this problem.
- yingw787 6y agoI'm not sure I agree with Zoom's strategy here. Adtech can get away with compromising user's privacy because users aren't customers, they're eyeballs for advertisers. Zoom by contrast does primarily B2B sales, and calls do need to have some semblance of privacy. If a Western-based multinational corporation competes with a China-based company, Zoom suddenly looks a lot scarier. People sometimes say nothing came of the Snowden revelations. I think they're wrong. When the NSA mentioned connections between datacenters were tapped, I believe FAANG immediately end-to-end encrypted links between datacenters, because otherwise your business secrets depend on how cozy you are with the government. I'd even say it may have played a role in Google Fiber. I don't know about Google laying its own fiber because it wants to be nice or because it wants to roll in the mud with Comcast. But if Google was suspicious that ISPs could get Google data by tapping end users, then it makes sense to keep up the pressure, and less sense after getting everybody to use HTTPS. Timing seems to work out. Might be a load of conspiracy hogwash, but it fits the laws of power.
- KerrickStaley 6y ago> When the NSA mentioned connections between datacenters were tapped, I believe FAANG immediately end-to-end encrypted links between datacenters... This is correct, at least for Google. I worked at Google when the Snowden leaks happened and there was an immediate company-wide push to encrypt all server-to-server traffic.
- koheripbal 6y ago... but wouldn't all DC to DC traffic be over an encrypted site-to-site VPN anyway?
- ciguy 6y agoGoogle and Amazon have their own dedicated fiber between DC sites, but there was evidence that the NSA was still tapping it at some points. So they added encryption between the sites as an extra safeguard.
- lmz 6y agoI don't see why this is such a big deal. Company with operations in China gets order from Chinese government to suspend accounts of people the Chinese government don't like. Company with operations in the US gets order not to trade with people from US embargoed countries [1]. What's the difference? [1]: e.g. https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2018/07/19/gcp-move-update/ https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2018/07/19/gcp-move-update/
- 082349872349872 6y agoIn the old days, this game used to be played with passports and visas[1]. I was surprised to hear a recording of Paul Robeson singing "Old Man River" in Moscow, with the lines Show a little grit And you land in jail Someone must've narced on him for showing a little grit: he didn't land in jail, but his economic livelihood (from touring internationally) was effectively destroyed when his passport was pulled. "Yes, Minister" introduced me to conjugations of the form: I am an activist You are a troll He is a bot To be perfectly clear: I am in favor of free exchange of ideas (what day of Eternal September[2] is today?); just trying to point out that repression at the hands of the state can take many forms, some more obvious than others. [1] why do US visa authorities harvest VK and Youku accounts, anyway? [2] that was too cynical; we're actually living in one of the easiest times for ordinary people to communicate, with other ordinary people in other cultures, ever. Not only do we have an internet (so timezone is more of a barrier than location), machine translation is no longer "invisible, insane."
- summerlight 6y agoThis case can be framed more like "an american company suspended an american account of an american citizen to comply with Chinese local law." Operating in China doesn't necessarily expand its jurisdiction into the US. What Zoom should have done is blocking participants in China from the meeting created by Zhou and Wang rather than suspending a US citizen's account. For the case of Gitlab, Google and Gitlab are both US based companies so it makes sense to comply with the US law.
- lmz 6y agoDo they not have a local Chinese subsidiary that hires their employees there?
- xster 6y agoI mean our Twitter and Facebook have been shutting down accounts from elected offices of NATO "targets" like Venezuela and Iran for a while now https://thegrayzone.com/2020/01/12/us-pressure-social-media-censoring-suspending-venezuela-iran-syria https://thegrayzone.com/2020/01/12/us-pressure-social-media-.... I don't see people up in arms saying "legality is irrelevant".
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lrem 6y agoTwitter and Facebook are American companies, with the US being part of NATO. Zoom tries to pretend it's not a Chinese company.
- remus 6y agoSimilarly, I don't think we can really hold the US up as some sort of bastion of moral excellence. As a non US citizen you have very little right to privacy and the US government will use this against you (see: forcibly having to unlock your devices so border agents can search them). On balance I think the US is a lot better than China, but there's a lot of room for improvement.
- echlebek 6y agoLuckily, you don't have to hold up the US as a bastion to criticize China. They can both be criticized independently.
- tatersolid 6y ago> They can both be criticized independently. But not inside China. And therein lies the great difference.
- jcytong 6y agoThat's not the right comparison. To use your example, a closer example would be You believe it's unjust to have those FB/Twitter accounts shutdown and you host a Zoom call to build a campaign to voice out. Your local government ask Zoom to shut you down. Zoom then deletes your account as well as those of your allies in Vanezuela and Iran. On top of that, the local law requires Zoom to give data to identify you at which point your life is at risk or a jail term without a trial. That's what those people face in China.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- joyfulmantis 6y agoFollowing the local laws of countries where a company operates in is a fundamental condition necessary for globalization. The idea that the americans know best and don't need to follow local laws is really just another form of imperialism.
- waheoo 6y agoYup, even google does the best thing it can here. https://youtu.be/P_UVPTdjxC0 https://youtu.be/P_UVPTdjxC0 I find it incredibly hypocritical for any american to compalin about china, ya'll fucking made it what it is today.
- rayiner 6y agoIt depends on the law. At a certain point local laws transgress international norms and it’s justified for countries and companies that have the power to get away with it to flout them: https://www.chicagotribune.com/business/ct-xpm-2013-12-15-ct-biz-1215-outside-opinion-20131215-story.html https://www.chicagotribune.com/business/ct-xpm-2013-12-15-ct.... More broadly, it’s akin to how courts in the US will generally enforce judgments of foreign courts, but not if those judgments are based on laws that deviate too far what US courts consider to be the basic norms. > Many companies adopted the Sullivan Principles, prepared by the Rev. Leon Sullivan, a board member of General Motors. The Sullivan Principles asked its signatories to treat all workers equally, in effect calling on U.S. corporations to violate South African law, but only a few acted. > IBM became the first company in South Africa to appoint a black as a supervisor of white employees. On the other hand, IBM's largest client was the South African government, and its computers were used primarily by the military.
- joyfulmantis 6y agoFree speech is a concept even the west is struggling with -- Twitter hiding Donald Trump's tweets for example, or New Zealand banning the terrorists manifesto. If even the bastion of free speech is starting to have second doubts about it, how can you claim the moral high ground when a third country wants to restrict free speech?
- NotSammyHagar 6y agoHuman rights are more important than corporate rights. But where does that leave us in the situation, whereas others have said Apple cuts off apps like the one in Hong Kong, and they use the excuse of local laws. Apple and zoom both need to stop enforcing Chinese law, or stop seeing the benefits of being an American company. The ability to complain about your government, to point out injustice, it's a human right, not an American right. I'm safe and sound in the US so I'm not subject to this. But the people of the world should not have their right to public expression taken away by profit driven American companies.
- jatone 6y agoamerica should be cutting ties with china and encouraging our allies to do the same. enough of this shit. china is a bad actor and should be treated as such on the world stage (same with russia). there is 0 reason to do business with china beyond cheap labor and there are other options for labor.
- zo1 6y agoThe big downside to going too-far down that road too-quickly is that it might put China in a corner financially. I don't think anyone wants it to get to that point because isolating them quickly will definitely escalate tensions and maybe even war. Rather: Determined and solid pressure should be put on any expansionist and growth policies that China may have. Reduce and starve them of critical imports, slowly make their businesses un-competitive with tariffs and increasing regulatory requirements for companies that want to do business with China. Of course, the response to those sorts of suggestions is that they'll buy ill-will from the Chinese people and grown division even further. Agreed, but at this point, that's guaranteed and no matter what we do it'll grow. E.g. Leave it alone and China's authoritarian and technocratic social policies will increase Chinese peoples' division from the West if not downright hatred. But if you intervene, then you're being unfair to the Chinese people that want access to the West in various forms. What is constant is that China is big threat to global stability and we should be reducing their power so that the eventual conflict is lessened. I don't think we can hope for a "the Chinese people love the world and want peace enough to go against their government" scenario. We're way passed that I would argue. I'm sure a lot if not almost all of the German people wanted peace and weren't anti-semitic, but that didn't stop an authoritarian government from steam-rolling their dissent and turning it into blind compliance. And that was without any large-scale technocratic indoctrination and control mechanisms, just plain propaganda.
- kenneth 6y agoPerhaps the US needs a law that states that a company cannot discriminate against users based in the US at the request of foreign governments or to abide by foreign laws.
- joyfulmantis 6y agoSo are you saying that companies operating in New Zealand shouldn't follow New Zealand law to ban the Christchurch shooter's manifesto?
- fossuser 6y agoNo, I’m saying that there isn’t an immediate answer to any of these questions and companies need to evaluate it themselves when deciding. The country’s own legal framework isn’t enough to decide for you. I think your moral relativism is lame, both here and in your other comments. It might feel good to offload that responsibility, but if you do, and you operate in a country that has problematic laws, then your self-assured relativism can get others killed.
- threatofrain 6y agoYou're basically saying that different nations can't develop their own moral and legal conversations fast enough, and thus an international intelligentsia needs to pick up the slack; a bit of noblesse oblige. Not a very reliable mechanism, and kind of a story of a ticking time bomb.
- fossuser 6y agoI'm saying that we all have responsibility for the software we put out into the world, and we're complicit in how it's used. It's wrong to offload that ethical responsibility entirely to others. Things get better because we want them to be better, as people that build these things we have to care.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoSurely it doesn’t come as a surprise to you that there exist in this world who no only don’t think like you... There are people in this world who are happy to write cigs than can be weaponised against those they disagree with. So in that sense, I’d suggest you’re wrong. Software Developers are not a homogeneous while who do or should think like you. Whether or not we agree that way of being is reprehensible is a different matter, in which I tend to agree it is.
- zamalek 6y ago> which requires compliance with local laws even as Zoom seeks to promote the open exchange of ideas. That's as good as saying "we will kill puppies if local laws require it as Zoom seeks to promote fair treatment of animals." They aren't promoting "open exchange of ideas" and likely never will. Zoom have continuously proven to be profit driven. This is perfectly fine, so long as they don't lie about it (they lie like they breath). Furthermore, if you are an activist and are using Zoom, you have none of my pity. They have proven their beliefs at every possible opportunity, and then some, for months. You really have to start questioning your belief patterns and critical thinking if you are sharing anything remotely confidential or private on Zoom. Using Zoom for basically anything is the equivalent of "not being able to program the video tape recorder." It's not applying enough thought to the trivial problem at hand, and subjecting yourself to turmoil due to that. We don't need legal structures for this. Just stop using stupid products, Zoom being one of the best examples.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoIt is troubling, but, as others have mentioned, Zoom is not alone here. What I do not really get is why? Is the Chinese market really that important to Zoom ( especially given nascent anti Chinese sentiment in US )?
- jcytong 6y agoChina's the second largest economy and growing which will make them the largest in the foreseeable future. Wall street is pretty indifferent when it comes to people being locked up/killed in a foreign country (heck probably in their own country). Where as Zoom CEO, your stock price determines your bonus, your continued employment, but probably most importantly your employees employment and well being. Given a lot of Zoom staff are in China, there is a non-zero risk of their well being at play. Obviously, they care about their public image too in the US. But China's market is very enticing. :(
- astatine 6y agoThese skirmishes (Zoom now, TikTok earlier and the ongoing Huawei one) make for interesting shows, for those outside China and the US. China uses nationalism as the excuse for censorship. As long as you don't criticize China you are free to do anything you want. The US uses morality as the excuse for censorship. As long as you don't do anything that violates that particular notion of morality (the American way of life?), you are free to do anything you want. Wonder which will be easier for the 80% of people outside these 2 countries.
- chii 6y agoThe american way of life is easier. Because it's demonstrably better so far.
- hrktb 6y agoFeels like the current events aren’t really going in that direction. And it’s sad because we’d really need to have decent govs and leadership where the power concentrated.
- grishka 6y ago> Wonder which will be easier for the 80% of people outside these 2 countries. I'm Russian. Neither. We have our own Facebook that doesn't moderate as much and explicitly allows adult content as long as it's marked such.
- totalZero 6y agoWould you please give me an example of something that the US government is currently censoring based on morality?
- idrios 6y agoI think he's talking about the conversation going on about FB, Youtube, Twitter removing posts that are hate speech, inciting violence, spreading misinformation, etc.
- est 6y agoFrom earlier news: https://www.axios.com/zoom-closes-chinese-user-account-tiananmen-square-f218fed1-69af-4bdd-aac4-7eaf67f34084.html https://www.axios.com/zoom-closes-chinese-user-account-tiana... > Zhou and other organizers told Axios in a statement. "As the most commercially popular meeting software worldwide, Zoom is essential as an unbanned outreach to Chinese audiences remembering and commemorating Tiananmen Massacre during the coronavirus pandemic."
- MintelIE 6y agoMost Universities and companies really don’t care, it seems. Zoom is one of the many shady Chinese companies (yes I am aware of Zoom’s recent change in status here) who we just do business with no matter HOW harmful it could potentially be. Recently there was concern about how certain anti-cheat software included with Chinese games is an effective root kit as well. And several large American firms have been help China build out their surveillance infrastructure which is used to send people to death camps.
- dehrmann 6y agoUniversities, I get--there isn't much of an espionage risk with course content--but companies should be worried. China has a reputation for corporate espionage, and while Zoom is nominally an American company, headlines like this remind us it's also very Chinese (dev office, data centers).
- MintelIE 6y agoThe recent arrest of Charles Lieber and other professors shows that academia is a big target for the Chinese.
- throwaway0613 6y agoBear in mind that Zoom is a Chinese company — the founding team is Chinese; the core engineering and ops teams are largely in Suzhou and Hangzhou. So, while they are incorporated in the US and have significant presence in their HQ, their ties to China are stronger than the more-commonly-discussed outsourced-engineering sort of relationship.
- koheripbal 6y agoWe are rapidly devolving into separate internets.
- Infinitesimus 6y agoI think that is inevitable as long as the top N companies enforce their morals and standards on consumers all over the world. If the world could agree, we can legistlate these companies to be neutral and grant then protection from some state lawsuits if they don't enforce standards that aren't globally agreed upon (by the UN for instance). It will be tricky because that means admitting that internet companies are their own independent states and many countries will not be happy with that.
- koheripbal 6y agoI think of it a little differently. I think as long as their is a potential to exert political power via the internet, then governments will strong-arm companies into doing their bidding.
- crazygringo 6y agoWhen will this meme die? Zoom is NOT a Chinese company. It is incorporated in and headquartered in the US. Like any American company ever, it follows US laws in the US, and local laws in other companies where it operates. End of story. Yes their culture certainly has stronger cultural internal ties to China, due to the number of Chinese employees, but what has that got to do with anything? At the end of the day, they're a public, profit-driven corporation trying to make lots of money across the entire world. It's not like they're secretly and nefariously doing the CCP's bidding, which seems to be the veiled suggestion people keep making. Seriously, every time someone brings up that Zoom is "really" a Chinese company, it comes across as borderline racism or conspiracy-mongering or both. And while I'd usually never comment on someone using a throwaway account, in this case when you're pushing these kinds of shady "stronger than the more-commonly-discussed" insituations, I think using a throwaway here is representative of exactly the kind of astroturfing that spreads malicious rumors without evidence.
- malka 6y agoZoom is a blatant CCP trojan horse. It is very clear where Eric Yuan's loyalty is. And it is not toward the USA.
- cammil 6y agoIts easy to blame zoom and Apple and other companies, but if our own elected governments can't stand up to oppressive regimes, why should we expect a private company to?
- gorgoiler 6y agoPiffle! At least they only had to suspend an account! Imagine the outrage if Zoom had been complicit in adding backdoors, or conducting surveillance at the implicit or explicit demands of the state. (I think Snowden even once claimed Apple’s iOS has an NSA backdoor?)
- ridewinter 6y agoWho here doesn't think that China has similar things and much much worse added to Tiktok, Zoom, etc?
- villgax 6y agoSo we killed America's Skype & got China's variant.
- cheesecracker 6y agoGermany mandates by law that social networks like Facebook or Twitter censor people on government request. I have yet to see the global outrage over it.
- paulcarroty 6y agoI'm not surprised. Zoom isn't the one and only service used by China to censor free speech globally: * https://www.reddit.com/r/HongKong/comments/dfg1ce/list_of_companies_under_chinas_censorship_orders/ https://www.reddit.com/r/HongKong/comments/dfg1ce/list_of_co... * https://time.com/5557951/china-interference-global-media/ https://time.com/5557951/china-interference-global-media/ So if you're an activist and still use Reddit, Discord or services from the list above - prepare to be banned. Also check twice any China-affiliated service/products before using.
- Proven 6y agoCCP Bootlickers.
- notsag-hn 6y agoI struggle to understand how people work hard to build they dream technology, they are also lucky enough for it to take off like zoom in this case, and then they go ahead to do nasty stuff and to fuck up their users! I hope one day we'll really condemn and stop using apps/social media for things like this.
- chii 6y agoif you switched 'Zoom' with 'Google' in the above, would you have made a different argument?
- notsag-hn 6y agoI would put Google there for sure! Google is nasty at other scales anyways. As search engine I use Duckduckgo, but sometimes we don't have much of an option with Google, do we? Mainly on mobile, which the option is Apple, not great.
- ngcc_hk 6y ago2 problems. let us agree china law has issue, can zoom block any account traffic to china. But you note google and Apple has no such issue. More problematic and deeper issue is how the overall game work for chinese market access and free world market access. As only China sanctioned account can communicate with china but you can use the channel for most, it has an advantage move others have. The market access to billion. As there is no equivalent they will take over a significant percentage of the market with sanction and freedom of speech as a cost. If it connects with india ... Have to stop that kind of WHO and world trade chinese model, otherwise the free world would be in trouble.
- boraoztunc 6y agoSiding with governments, instead of people is wrong. Not a surprise though, Zoom can do anything for money and its position. It is my wrong though, to wait for some kind of soul from corporates.
- ryuukk_ 6y agoNOBODY care less bad than Microsoft backdoors and Facebook/Twitter spying tools
- techgiant_guy 6y agoWhatsApp is addressing 20 person video calls to compete with Zoom & Google Meets. Ref - https://l1n.com/whatsapp-is-addressing-20-person-video-calls-to-compete-with-zoom-google-meets/ https://l1n.com/whatsapp-is-addressing-20-person-video-calls...
- IgorPartola 6y agoRemember when Zoom bought Keybase last month and some of us were raising concerns that Zoom is beholden to the CCP and most of the HN discussion thread was defending the company saying how just because they employ a lot of people in China doesn’t mean they will do anything like this? Pepperidge Farm remembers.
- ngcc_hk 6y agoChinese firm can go into USA, build a firm and control USA media but not USA firm. It is asymmetrical warfare. War? USA firm are not party and national related. Chinese firm all are. USA is naive for a long time to look the other way and that china will change to better. So what I treat you fairly but not the other way round meant ok. Good luck but luck is running out. They do not need to be successful, but once like editing gene of baby. You lost. If they fail to control their virus handling from low tech like bat eating to virus testing in their 44 p3 lab and the p4 Wuhan one. Just once. Or maybe twice. Humanity lost. Or done with. To be fair if all are equal. But if china is more equal than USA in market access. Good luck again
- newbie578 6y agoI am amazed yet again how willing are people here to defend Zoom and China, even daring to compare USA to China lol. While the U.S. might not be perfect and it does have its share of problems, it cannot compare to a fraction of China's problems. Zoom is China's shill, while representing itself as a U.S. company, which should be publicly condemned.
- remotists 6y agoI stopped using Zoom right after the privacy and the Facebook data sharing issues propped up. Using Skype and Google Meets at the moment, hopefully these guys don't violate my privacy.
- dcanelhas 6y agoIf the tool isn't free, why would one expect freedom using it?
- dreamcompiler 6y agoZoom is not a Chinese company in the same way that Huawei is not an arm of Chinese intelligence.
- natestemen 6y agoI know this website has a penchant for anti-China everything, but it's funny because every terms of service I've ever read has something in it about complying with law enforcement about giving up data and terminating service. If you're against zoom doing this, I would expect you to be against every other company having this clause in their TOS.
- m3kw9 6y agoWith China requests it’s a landline for all US based tech companies that needs to operate in China.
- beefman 6y agoIs this supposed to be worse than Congress telling Facebook to delete thousands of accounts a quarter that belong to Eastern Europeans who have posted about US politics?
- eblanshey 6y agoThis demonstrates the issue with an internet designed for centralized services. Zoom is in the position of A) bending to china and not losing their business, or B) ignoring China's request and lose all of China's business. With a properly-designed decentralized internet, this decision wouldn't even exist. Data and services wouldn't be centralized to a company's servers, and there wouldn't be a way to take down anyone's service. I really wish projects like MaidSafe and other similar ones would take off, but it's a difficult problem to tackle.
- a13n 6y agoThis seems like capitalism at work. - Zoom wants to build as big of a business as possible. - Therefore, Zoom wants to retain access to the Chinese market. - Therefore, Zoom must work with the Chinese government, to avoid getting banned. Is this "legal"? Probably, yes. Is this "required by law"? Probably not, no. Is this "right"? Depends who you ask, but probably not. I feel like this summarizes one of the core issues with capitalism. Companies make immoral decisions because they can and it makes them more money.
- WeNeedDemocracy 6y agoIs Eric Yuan Chinese? I sometimes wonder if Chinese entrepreneurs could be hedging to make sure that the Chinese government would have mercy over them in a time where China overtakes USA.
- HashThis 6y agoZoom sells out citizens to China. US Congress would protect US citizens affected, except US Congress sells out to corporations (zoom). US Congress -> Sells out -> Zoom -> Sells out -> China
- sadsadsadsad 6y agoZoom really is taking the "any publicity is good publicity" saying quite literally huh?