26 ms·
Young U.S. men having a lot less sex in the 21st century, study shows
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Natsu 6y agoThis is part of how many stable societies evolved into some approximation of monogamy, because having a sufficiently large group of sexually frustrated men tends to create instability (like incels).
- lordleft 6y agoThe conservative political commentator (and never-Trumper) David Frum has commented about this and the general decline in coupling between the sexes among young people. He believes that part of the reason comes from the economic hurdles facing many millennials; it's harder to get your own place or have a sense of financial confidence, so starting a family or embarking on a relationship may seem more daunting. He also thinks that this will make gender an even greater political and social fault-line, as men and women will spend less time knowing and understanding each other.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoI wrote a comment that dives into this a bit ~3 months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22407388 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22407388 If you don't want to read the whole thing (it's brief though, so consider it, and includes citations that I don't want to pollute this thread with), the high level TLDR is (based on the data) men are content to date down, women are not, and economically disadvantaged men (which there are more of due to globalization and other macro factors) are exiting the dating marketplace, creating a market imbalance. Toss in data showing men online target ~20-25 years old for a partner, while women prefer to date around their age as they age (+-5 years), and here we are. Edit: Regardless of the political leanings of the person you reference, I would agree with that thesis (economic hurdles and a lack of empathy and societal/community cohesion will cause existing rifts to widen).
- mellosouls 6y agomen are content to date down, women are not This misses a fundamental point that has been made clear since the advent of Tinder and the like. The terrible experience and loneliness of men not in the top 20% on those apps is because the women on them are not content to date on their level, or even below several rungs above them. Let alone "date down". I've seen this happen with multiple friends of mine, decent (not nerds but not alpha) guys who have to swipe hundreds for a single match. It's absurd. This is the great unsayable (in correct society) that has actually been said loudly for years in masculinist fora, most viciously and notoriously by the incels. The adage is that in environments like dating apps, 80% of women go for 20% of men. Exaggeration or no, there is real truth there that society needs to wake up to if it has any care at all for the mental and emotional health of men.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoSociety can't "wake up", this is what it wanted. Women being equal, but not interested in "lesser" partners, causes a natural imbalance. You can't "fix" the imbalance without removing free will from market participants.
- mellosouls 6y agoThe history of social constructs and law has been about constraining and enabling "market" participants. Free will doesn't come into it unless you live in an anarchy. Sometimes those social changes have good results, sometimes bad. Here there is a clear social ill that has been dismissed for years whenever it is raised in edge fora - perhaps with studies like this being publicised in respectable publications we will begin to look at what we can do to improve the lot of a significant marginalised group.
- newguy1234 6y agoI think the problem (from my experience as a 30 year old man) is that young men absolutely struggle to find women that are in their age range. Young women often go after older men, with established careers and incomes. If young women do date their age group then they go after men that have better looks, money, popularity and so on. So the end result is the vast majority of young men are completely dateless. I remember when I was a young man, I absolutely struggled to get a date even though I tried very hard. I was always rejected. Women didn't even want to talk to me! If I small chatted with them they would always find some reason to get out of the conversation. When I did actually manage to get a date it was because the woman specifically went after me. I had a small relationship with her but it mostly fizzled out over time. I spent most of my youth simply working and getting my degree. Now I am 30 years old, have a solid career and excellent financials. I have a spouse now and I don't bother with these young entitled women anymore. I think all men should do the same. Work hard, get a good career and then find a woman who is also financially successful.
- luckylion 6y ago> economic hurdles facing many millennials This would affect men and women equally, but it doesn't, so that seems not to be it.
- pacija 6y agoBack in a day, quite some time ago, I started screwing around when I was 16. Most of the parents were quite conservative so they didn't allow kids to do it at their places where we, kids, lived, at least not to their knowledge. But we used every occasion to do it while they were at work. Or at birthdays and other home parties. In parks. At the graveyards. On roofs. In basements. Any place where we could get half an hour without people passing by. I think I never had as much sex as when I didn't have my own apartment. The decline started after I finally got it, in my late twenties :) So while I understand that not having your own place or financial stability can affect people's will to start a family, I tink it's too early to start to worry about it before at least late twenties. Until then, if people don't screw around on a daily, or at least best-effort basis, something is screwed with their chemistry.
- inamberclad 6y agoThat's the thing, you're talking about 'back in your day', but this article suggests a major demographic shift.
- watwut 6y agoThe thing that primary predicts less teenage sex is sexual education. Which is better then used to be. The conservativism of parents where you lived likely contributed to kids having sax in the park hoping nobody will arrest them and charge them with public sex. And honestly, I never witnessed what you described here and I am kinda happy I did not.
- pacija 6y agoDid I understand your point correctly, that you think that having less teen sex is a good thing? Also that it is ok to ruin young people's lives for having sex outside of apartments or hotel rooms?
- watwut 6y agoGiven that teenage pregnancies are also down and so are std and so is drug taking, yes. And given how much of effort was put into making teenagers have less sex and use dammit condom, yes. Because side effect of that period were teenage pregnancies that had quite destructive effects for the rest of those kids lives. And side effect of sexual education are safer sex practices. On the second point, that is actual risk involved. I would not made those laws, but I can't change them. Third thought, it is also not comfortable to lie in park without things like blanked under your body with guy focused on finishing as fast as possible. I don't know how to tell it differently, but in average case the girl won't have that much fun in those quick minutes as guy who has fun until he finished. Which means less drinking and drug taking must be factor in drop of those encounters too, because one of partners would be more likely to refuse the activity.
- acwan93 6y agoThe Atlantic covered this recently too: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/12/the-sex-recession/573949/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/12/the-sex... >I was told it might be a consequence of the hookup culture, of crushing economic pressures, of surging anxiety rates, of psychological frailty, of widespread antidepressant use, of streaming television, of environmental estrogens leaked by plastics, of dropping testosterone levels, of digital porn, of the vibrator’s golden age, of dating apps, of option paralysis, of helicopter parents, of careerism, of smartphones, of the news cycle, of information overload generally, of sleep deprivation, of obesity. Name a modern blight, and someone, somewhere, is ready to blame it for messing with the modern libido.
- mc32 6y agoSo it’s really really a problem in Japan and to a lesser extent Singapore and SKorea, but there is a whole generation of guys who’re just not getting any and have little interest in getting any at all. And at least in Japan there is a weird subculture of something I’d call “adult play dates” where you pay for someone to feign interest in you —I don’t even know what the purpose of that is.
- troughway 6y ago>And at least in Japan there is a weird subculture of something I’d call “adult play dates” where you pay for someone to feign interest in you —I don’t even know what the purpose of that is. Welcome to OnlyFans.
- mc32 6y agoTrue, true, but these play dates are in person. It’s kind of like a strip club but without the nudity. It’s implied that the person you pay will show fake interest and you set up subsequent dates knowing there is no real interest. So it’s kind of like a strip-club + wannabe shrink + palm reader mashup.
- tenebrisalietum 6y agoNot sure this is about libido so much as about access to another partner.
- mpfundstein 6y agoare we really surprised? last year a woman called me a sexist because i said 'ladies firsr' on the coffee machine. a friend got problems with hr becahse apparently he stared at some titties in the elevator lol. luckily i am married and had my fair share of partners. but nowadays i would be scared as hell to even take the first step in the club. i mean, i might easily become a toxic male sexual predator exposed on social media trying to drug a victim by offering to buy a drink :-)
- wilg 6y agoBased on your comment, you probably have some work to do to on how you treat women.
- mpfundstein 6y agoask that my wife. she is quite happy. or she is the best liar i've ever met
- rootusrootus 6y agoI agree with your assessment, but I do think it would be fair to say that a negative reaction to a man saying "ladies first" is an overreaction. I can't imagine it happens that often, though, but there are exceptions to everything.
- thehappypm 6y agoNever thought I’d see the word “titties” here.
- monocasa 6y agoI think the modern idea isn't that there's no longer a space for dating and sexual encounters; it's that this space isn't work. Work is for work, not finding a wife or mistress or staring at breasts. The club and dating apps is where you go for that. If you and someone you work with both swipe right, then it's fair game. But there's an affirmative, out of work step to getting there.
- 6y ago
- fuddlecarrion 6y agoIs it a problem? People don't need to be having sex. As long as people are happy.
- rootusrootus 6y agoI think you answered your own question. If not, go visit a forum for incels and see how happy they are.
- vzidex 6y agoAt the same time, people definitely can be happy without sex - various religious factions have been doing it for ages with vows of celibacy, and today there's a non-negligible "volcel" (voluntarily celibate) movement.
- TallGuyShort 6y agoIt can be done and result in happy people. It can also turn out that years later you have decades of sexual abuse victims coming forward years later.
- foepys 6y agoI have never heard about vocel. Only about Men Going Their Own Way (MGTOW), which, at least on reddit, were a women hating incel community.
- thelean12 6y agoBut this isn't useful to this discussion. In aggregate, less sex may be a bad thing. In aggregate, more sex may be a good thing. That's what's being discussed. Individuals and anecdotes just distract from the discussion.
- luckylion 6y ago> At the same time, people definitely can be happy without sex Yeah, but that's really like saying "but people can be happy while they are fasting" to somebody that is being starved. Something being voluntary often makes the difference between it being considered harmful or even torture and a weird thing.
- winrid 6y agoProbably because you can now play counterstrike in the browser. :)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pwdisswordfish2 6y agoI’ll bet the causation is more like the inverse. (This is the best construction I could come up with. Native English speakers enlighten me please.)
- jchallis 6y agoFrom a native English speaker: You have confused cause and effect.
- selimthegrim 6y agoI doubt monks wrote that code.
- ficklepickle 6y agoThere are English idioms that express that concept, but I don't think there is anything wrong with the way you wrote it. The fact that you didn't use a common phrase made me read it more carefully. The simplest phrase that comes to mind is "the other way around". Or you could say "cause and effect are reversed".
- tangjurine 6y agoI'd just say: more like the inverse.
- newguy1234 6y agoYou have a point
- kelvin0 6y agoI wonder how much of an impact the pervasive availability of digital pornography has on this.
- rubicon33 6y agoPorn, Video Games, lack of a "tribe" / strong community, low socioeconomic status... All are factors (IMO). Porn - Relieves the sexual desire temporarily. Video Games - Distracts and occupies the mind Lack of tribe - Depresses, and isolates the individual Low Socioeconomic Status - Lowers ability to attract opposite sex, lowers confidence, etc.
- antidaily 6y agoPorn on the internet has existed since the internet has existed.
- slothtrop 6y agoIt wasn't always so easily accessible and in such vast quantities. Downstream was slow, there was that wild west time of p2p in the late 90s-00s where you never really knew what you'd get. Now it's ridiculously pervasive.
- antidaily 6y agoIt was always easily accessible and downloaded fast enough. But ok, let's say it took a minute to download a 150kb image of porn. Did that stop anyone? No. But I do think a comment you made above is correct -- people are more sedentary. Especially young men. So they possibly seek porn out more often just out of boredom.
- slothtrop 6y agoYou used an image as an example, but this is far less stimulating than video.
- jcims 6y ago
- tharne 6y agoThey buried the lede here. > Sexual activity was largely unchanged among unmarried women, along with no notable decline among gay men, researchers reported. Basically sex is following the pattern of wealth. Men as a group aren't having less sex, instead there's a winner take all effect where a small number of men are having a lot of sex with a lot of women while a large number of men are having little to no sex. It'll be interesting to see what happens in 5-10 years as the individuals in this cohort begin to settle down and marry and have children. Given the push to eliminate virtually all traditional norms associated with sexual activity, I wouldn't be surprised to see a serious push for legalized polygamy in a few years.
- buboard 6y agohttps://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2018/10/sexual-partners-and-marital-happiness/573493/ https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2018/10/sexual-pa...
- vzidex 6y ago> instead there's a winner take all effect where a small number of men are having a lot of sex with a lot of women If true, I wonder how much of that is due to self-selection by men who aren't having sex. Having once upon a time been lonely and bitter, I know that men often end up in positive feedback loops that strengthen their not having sexual partners - due to the attitudes they develop towards women.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 6y ago
- monsieur_h 6y agoIt's a fact... that in societies like ours sex truly represents a second system of differentiation, completely independent of money; and as a system of differentiation it functions just as mercilessly. The effects of these two systems are, furthermore, strictly equivalent. Just like unrestrained economic liberalism, and for similar reasons, sexual liberalism produces phenomena of absolute pauperization. Some men make love every day; others five or six times in their life, or never. Some make love with dozens of women; others with none. It's what's known as 'the law of the market'... Economic liberalism is an extension of the domain of the struggle, its extension to all ages and all classes of society. Sexual liberalism is likewise an extension of the domain of the struggle, its extension to all ages and all classes of society. ― Michel Houellebecq, Extension du domaine de la lutte
- RIMR 6y ago"The survey found that from 2000 to 2018, nearly one in three U.S. men aged 18 to 24 reported no sexual activity in the past year." I'm not sure I understand what they are measuring. This sentence is hard to parse. Did they ask people who were those ages during those years if they had gone an entire year without sex during that period? Did they ask people of that age slowly over the course of those 18 years and recorded the answers relative to the time in which they were asked?
- war1025 6y agoI believe the correct interpretation is: They ran the study periodically from 2000 to 2018. At each point, they surveyed groups, of which, one bracket was "men aged 18 to 24". Within that bracket, one third of those surveyed reported no sexual activity in the past year. This was roughly consistent over the entire 18 year period.
- maxerickson 6y agoHere's the source article: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2767066 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle... So it's like the other reply states, ~1/3 respondents to various surveys reported no sexual activity in the year preceding the survey.
- nroets 6y agoOver the study period, pornography became really easy to obtain. Isn't that the cause ? Men (we) no longer need to groom themselves, dress up, spend money on dates and deal with all the complications of relationships. They (we) now have instant simulation within a few taps on their phones.
- inamberclad 6y agoFrom the JAMA article that all this data comes from: > Use of pornographic material was associated with a lower likelihood of sexual inactivity among both men and women.
- Vysero 6y agoIt's become harder to approach women. Based on my experience, they are far more likely this day in age to reject you than ever before. That coupled with the constant barrage men receive on the sexual misconduct front coupled with the notion that women only want exceedingly wealthy, attractive, muscular men makes it very easy for men to slink away into their rooms after work, and play video games all night rather than face the reality's of dating. Why shouldn't their standards be high? Women that is.. I mean women are enjoying more financial success, and independence than ever before. Marriage is becoming a notion of the past. Children are being seen as to large of a burden, and relationships are being sent by the way side as a result. If you ask me, kids are just starting to open their eyes is all. EDIT: After thinking about this I would like to offer up some optimism. I think the lack of confidence in men that we see when approaching women will inevitable lead to women becoming less reluctant to approach men then it has historically been. Optimistically, I believe this will start to reverse some the effects we are noticing among single males.
- shuntress 6y agoPlease consider the varied cultural pressures that dissuade women from enjoying the same games that men "slink away" to play. There is a reason that the social spaces these (presumably) undesirable men inhabit tend to have low numbers of approachable women.
- joelbluminator 6y agoMost women are people just like you, they want a real relationship and want love. I know it's shocking, but they're not all after sleeping with muscular wealthy men any more than you are with sleeping with an 18 year old blonde with huge breasts. Stop being so superficial and start looking at women as real people.
- Vysero 6y agoWhat makes you think I am not interested in sleeping with an 18 year old blonde with huge breasts? That's EXACTLY who I am interested in sleeping with... personally, I am not interested in a relationship at all nor am I attacking women here so I am not sure where you are coming from.
- codingslave 6y agoThis is a widespread societal change that I think most people are completely unaware of. The majority of women are sleeping with the top 10% of men, sometimes only the top 3-5%, with the rest barely getting any at all. the sexual revolution was never about free love or sexual freedom, it was about womens rights to sleep with the few men they are all attracted to. The lower 80% of men instead saw their sexual freedom diminish drastically. Even the men not getting any do not realize how easily other guys are getting sex. Its like they live in separate universes. Whats more, eventually these women need to settle down, often with men who are their "equals". But they do not see them as equals, as they have been having casual sex with men way out of their league for years. This is a deep societal problem and one that surely adds to unrest among the population. How do I know all of this? I lived in NYC for five years and ran in circles where we were usually the best looking guys at the bar. The ease with which some friends got women was shocking. Especially in contrast with other circles that I ran in, specifically nerdier programmers working at FAANG. If I said the above out in the open I would lose my job. But its reality. EDIT: I agree that women should be free and any opinion other than that is heinous. But I am going to add a bit about the sexual revolution part, because I think it is critical. Monogamy is about stability in society. Half of the reason for pushing for sexual restrictions and monogamy was because it stopped uprisings and stabilized relations. It has been a cornerstone of western society. All of these restrictions from the past had a purpose and stood the test of time, they were not random. When we remove those restrictions and societal opinions of sexual conservatism, we throw out thousands of years of hard learned rules across societies.
- eranima 6y agoYou would lose your job because that is some serious incel shit.
- codingslave 6y agoThe trick is I'm not an incel. I'm the opposite. I've seen this with my own two eyes for years and am completely shocked by it.
- 6y ago
- seppel 6y agoThis article awkwardly dances around reasons why young men have less sex. First it is "social media and electronic gaming", then the reasons "may also include stress of juggling work and intimate relationships, as well as the prevalence of other forms of solo entertainment." But then, they notice that "[s]exual activity was largely unchanged among unmarried women, along with no notable decline among gay men, researchers reported." So everything said before seems kind of void anyway. Obviously, the reasons must lie somewhere else. However, this is not explicitly stated. Now they continue with huge jump: From sexual activities to relationships: "Given a preference for men of higher socioeconomic status and the larger number of college-educated women than men, some young men may find it difficult to form heterosexual relationships" Well, maybe. But how does that connect to the first part?
- throw51319 6y agoThe mainstream thought/media is probably 5-10 years behind certain spheres of thought on the web, and it's hilarious.
- zlast 6y agoNot sure if this is what you meant, but I'd correct it to "what is allowed to be said" is probably 5-10 years behind certain spheres of thought. Reuters certainly wouldn't want to alienate readers with something controversial - hence the lack of strong analysis.
- throw51319 6y agoYeah good point. I actually use Reuters as my go-to for that reason, and the ability to get what matters quick and efficiently.
- sebwi 6y agoWell, I guess they theorize that in stable relationships, men are more likely to have sex. If forming relationships gets more difficult, the majority of men have less sex. I'm not sure if the argument is actually valid but from a historical perspective I can understand the thought process.
- vowelless 6y agoI would like to see marriage rates by age over time. Overwhelming amount of sex happens in marriage. If people are marrying less or marrying later, then I think that will explain this trend almost completely. If marriage rates are falling, I doubt it’s because of economic hardship (hundred years ago we had much worse financial outcome for people).
- sosuke 6y agoJust curious; do you have the reference for most sex happening in marriage?
- s5300 6y agoHoly crap haha. You're blind and living in a nice little bubble.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> If marriage rates are falling, I doubt it’s because of economic hardship (hundred years ago we had much worse financial outcome for people). Absolute levels of economic hardship are not relevant. What matters is the lifestyle people are comparing themselves to, usually a minimum set to the quality of life that they had. With more volatility in labor market, and dual income households being a necessity to attain that minimum quality of life, I can certainly see a reason to not get into a relationship. I would opt against kids (and marriage as a result) if I didn’t think I could close to 100% provide for them and their healthcare/shelter/education in good areas.
- dstaley 6y agoIs there a link to the study? I'm curious if there was some sort of selection bias.
- doorstar 6y agoThis is easily the most depressing thread I've ever encountered on HN. Women aren't sleeping with men because we know this is what you all really think of us. I'm not interested in someone with such levels of disdain for my entire gender.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Buttons840 6y ago> Women aren't sleeping with men because... The data showed that women are sleeping with men. It says: "Sexual activity was largely unchanged among unmarried women".
- doorstar 6y agoI correct myself - women aren't sleeping with men to the degree that men would prefer. And if most of the 300 comments in this thread are to be believed, it's because women will only throw themselves wantonly at high earners. Men just need wait long enough so that women's biology will force them to lower their standards. You guys really don't like us do you?
- newguy1234 6y agoMost men are going for the 18-25 year old group simply as a matter of preference. We aren't interested in women that are "waiting to lower their standards". So as a man, you figure out what that age group wants and then you try to get it.
- doorstar 6y ago> Most men are going for the 18-25 year old group simply as a matter of preference. Yes, that's why we don't want to sleep with them. We have a inexplicable dislike for men who are interested in our age first and everything else second. > We aren't interested in women that are "waiting to lower their standards" Good because they only exist in men's minds as a sad excuse. > So as a man, you figure out what that age group wants and then you try to get it. No one in any age group wants you.
- rurabe 6y agohypotheses (not in any order) 1. economic concerns 1.a. not having a job is not an ideal situation for attracting potential partners 1.b. having less disposable income means less ability to take people on dates 1.b.i covid has made this much harder 1.c. much harder to live alone 1.c.i. you might have roommates and feel it awkward to have sex with them in the house 1.c.ii. you might live with family and feel it awkward to have sex with them in the house 1.d. hard to pay for sex regularly 1.e. might not feel ready for even the chance of having a child 1.e.i might not feel like you can afford a child 1.e.ii having a child might have detrimental effects on careers (especially for women) i.e.iii you would think that increased birth control efficacy would reduce this? 2. health concerns 2.a increased awareness and fear of stds in the post aids era 2.b. more recently, covid 3. social issues 3.a. social media has provided an alternative and to varying degrees replaced some in-person interaction 3.b. porn is free and incredibly prevalent 3.c. slut shaming 3.d. fear of stigma of teen pregnancy 3.e. abstinence education 3.e.i but hasn't this always been the case? 3.f. video games are a lot of fun and less work 3.g. tinder 3.g.i must be attractive on looks (and profile wit) alone 3.g.ii winner take all dynamics
- dimitar 6y agoIsn't the best way to have regular sex is to be in a committed relationship, either a marriage or living with a partner? These are on a decline. Statistically women date/marry and live with older men, so I think it would be expected that they are having more sex in the ages of 18-24.
- jgwil2 6y agoSo many of the comments on here seem to be making an implicit and flawed assumption that people are only having sex within their age cohort.
- sct202 6y agoFor all the people who want to read the actual stats, the inactive sexual % for men who earn more than $50k is only 7%. Here is the study that article's commentary was refering to https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2767066 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle... Some of the people here are making it sound like no one but male models are having sex.
- sacred_numbers 6y agoThank you so much for posting the source! I don't understand why so many reporters write an entire story about a survey or scientific paper and don't link to it or even mention the title of the paper.
- Bjorkbat 6y agoReminds me of this take I read on Quilette about Vox's Explaining Monogamy https://quillette.com/2018/06/07/explaining-monogamy-vox/ https://quillette.com/2018/06/07/explaining-monogamy-vox/ The show itself seemed to suggest that since our closest primate relatives engage in polyamorous free love it's likely that we do as well. This can be further supported by observation of hunter-gatherer tribes, or so they argued. The author had a different take. He didn't necessarily suggest that monogamy was necessarily the norm nor was it natural. However, he also didn't believe that humans naturally gravitate towards egalitarian polyamorous societies. Instead, the norm tends to be polygeny, societies where the upper echelons of men have more wives, while the lower-rung of men simply don't marry or are forced to share. Indeed, a good way of garnering loyalty if you're a higher-status male was to share your wives with your inferiors. Many of the very hunter-gatherer tribes mentioned in the Vox video were themselves polygynous rather than egalitarian polyamorous societies, and frankly quite misogynistic. To be clear, wife-sharing isn't polyandrous (one wife many husbands). The difference is that the wife doesn't get the final say and probably doesn't even have a choice. These societies are polygynous. Polyandry is rare and often occurs in certain environments, or so the author suggests. Monogamy came about likely because those societies that embraced it had less sexual competition. They were less violent. More cooperative. Societies that didn't embrace it were easily subjugated by the societies that did. Progress is not the norm in polygynous societies. Frankly, between a polygynous future where you're either being stabbed in the back or doing the back-stabbing, or a future where a software glitch causes a world-ending exchange of nuclear weapons, I'd pick the nuclear exchange. At least the latter is over in an instant.
- malcolmgreaves 6y agoA lot of guys are complaining in the thread, with undertones of an expectation of sex Most likely reason I see that would cause this data: the immense social pressure applied to straight women has lessened in the 21st century. A straight woman won't be ostricized at 25 if they don't "have a man." The data suggests that young straight men aren't having as much sex. I postulate that the only reason is that straight men need to work harder to impress empowered straight women. And that the overwhelming majority aren't even trying.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thewarrior 6y agoBut the data also shows that for women the figure is unchanged.
- malcolmgreaves 6y agoPrecisely illustrates my point: most men are still operating under an outdated expectation of sex and romance. That merely existing suffices for being a good partner. When in reality, standards have been vastly increased any only a few men have gotten with the times.
- thewarrior 6y agoAnd what are the standards exactly ? Plenty of people who have good jobs, average bodies and decent personalities absolutely struggle. If that’s not enough ...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bjl 6y agoBecause the men that are willing to put in the effort are still having sex. Its not hard for a man to become attractive: eat right, exercise often, groom regularly, dress well, develop a compelling personality, cultivate relationships with interesting people. The fact that people who don't even try aren't able to have sex doesn't seem surprising (or bad).
- throwaway219491 6y agoI think the cause is very obvious, and I assume other people do to, but it's the kind of thing I would never actually say in the real world. Before the internet women didn't get hit on by thousands of men before their 21st birthday. Now that they do, they can be more picky in choosing partners, so fewer (hopefully higher quality) men are having sex.
- tootahe45 6y agoSocial media has led to a huge amount of female worship and has certainly put women them on a pedestal. The average 20-year-old (my age group) woman thinks she can land a Jeff Bezos, while the average 20-year-old male has little confidence he can get anything at all.
- cosmodisk 6y agoThe answer to all this: Porn and ever increasing consumption of it.
- npiit 6y agoIncels have contributed to civilization more than the rest of the human race. Newton, Nietzsche, me, Schopenhauer are a few examples. It's the path for greatness :)
- werber 6y agoI find myself fatigued by making the right choice to the point of not making choice in the current gay app climate. I’m actually bored by hook ups, but unable to find a partner who is, but also equally open to being persecutive, together. It feels like the algorithm is just harder now. Or I’m just difficult.
- tonystubblebine 6y agoThere are two coaching perspectives that I think are useful for single men. We don't have many dating coaches in the coaching community I run, but I've been in long conversations with coaches outside that community whose job it is to help men date. One perspective is that it's almost always faster to focus on being more interested rather than more interesting. That means focusing on status and alpha male activities is typically a loser in terms of strategy despite all the anecdotes you hear to the contrary. Whereas treating women like people, looking them in the eyes, listening, being curious, trying to find ways to relate--these can be very effective. There's a lot to unpack there, but maybe the easiest is just to give women credit that they know when they are being manipulated. But human connection can be rare and a huge number of male daters are not approaching dating in a way that allows for that connection. To do this authentically, you have to be crystal clear that there is a difference between "I'm laughing at her jokes because I hope that will make her sleep with me." and "I'm laughing at her jokes because she's funny." This be more interested approach has an unfortunate counter narrative about getting friend zoned, as if that is a bad thing. You talked to a woman and ended up with a friend, what's so awful about that? And on this, I like the perspective of one of our sales coaches. Her perspective is that sales is a lot more about sorting than it is about convincing. If you approach dating as an exercise in convincing then you are basically implying that you can point at a woman and then rely on some set of male seduction skills that will convince her to sleep with you. What if you gave up just that fantasy of being able to pick any person and make them like you. And instead treated dating as a sorting activity--who do you like that also likes you back? An exercise anyone could do to see some of the wisdom above is to ask their female friends to show you the worst profiles and come-ons that they've received on Tinder. I think that will help you see that a lot of what is preventing men from finding matches has little to do with status and a lot to do with being weird and self-centered.
- quasarj 6y agoI'm glad you brought up the friend-zone thing. I feel like I'm extremely good at all the things you listed before that, and I have a ton of female friends (which I love, don't get me wrong). I just have no idea to turn that into sex.
- abeppu 6y agoPeople in this thread are talking a lot about the availability of non-sex ways to spend attention (porn, social media, netflix), and of loosely power-law effects where a small number of men can have a lot of sex because of good looks and money. What about the other economic factors? - aren't more young people in living situations with greater sharing and less privacy than 20 years ago? - given the relative stagnation of wage increases over those intervening years, aren't more young people having to work more hours to keep that room in a shared apartment? - maybe the crushing stress of student debt is sometimes a turnoff? (edited for spacing)
- cheonic729 6y ago> What about the other economic factors? This would be true if women also demonstrated a decline in sex. However, women are having sex at the same rate as men. The problem is not economic. It's winner-take-all as the top comments mention. The causal reason cannot apply to men and women equality (eg, economic). It must overwhelmingly affect men.
- Nav_Panel 6y agoYes. I think many people are missing the point, which is that all these failures of intimacy are downstream from failures of community, of sociality in general (cf. "Bowling Alone"). Our culture has shifted further toward valuing the individual over the group, which means that many individuals no longer have recourse to a group in order to find partners, friends, etc. Men are not just "not having sex", they are lonely, in a rather unprecedented way.
- Gibbon1 6y agoThis is the comment I most agree with. We've created a world where there aren't many neutral venues for men and women to get to rub elbows with each other and get to know each other. Combine that with the US's culture of fear and here we are.
- walls 6y agoThis is pure nonsense, there's never been more things to do and places to go to meet people. There are hundreds to thousands of meetups on any given week for any given interest or hobby. If you're not aware of any of these things happening, it's possible that you need to find some interests or hobbies.
- doorstar 6y ago> The survey found that from 2000 to 2018, nearly one in three U.S. men aged 18 to 24 reported no sexual activity in the past year. > Sexual activity was largely unchanged among unmarried women The first reason that occurs to me is that women are showing more of preference for monogamous relationships. Perhaps the 'hookup' culture is starting to lose it's appeal. I find it a bit stomach-churning that we are presented below with > Given a preference for men of higher socioeconomic status Which has no references and feeds into a very unpleasant stereotype. Particularly with the followup > larger number of college-educated women than men Why not say that women prefer men with a matching socioeconomic status? It moves the implication from "gold-digger" to "seeking equal partner". > The trend is concerning as sexual relationships are important for well-being and health, researchers note. Sexual relationships also have a lot of downsides and negative impacts on well-being and health. If this outcome of this study was "men are having fewer healthy relationships" it might be more useful. Without that distinction, you could conclude men need more one night stands. That may be true - but if ( many ) women aren't interested then it is what it is.
- koheripbal 6y ago> women are showing more of preference for monogamous relationships. The data suggests exactly the opposite. If the same number of women are having sex, but a record number of men are having no sex, then there is a lot less monogamy going on.
- jungletime 6y agoObesity kills sex drive for both sexes, in many different ways. Most people don't like snoring whales in their bedroom with heart problems. I also suspect the typical advice of hitting the gym, for men, results in bulking, and is not that attractive to women either. Since it doesn't result in tall and slender, a typical preference, most of the time. What does work, just from comparing to Europe, is consistently walking everyday for long distances and dressing nice.
- ravenstine 6y agoWith the obesity rate going up, I imagine there's a proportional decrease in overall attraction which could explain some of what we're seeing. (obviously not all of it)
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoMost men who go to the gym are not getting too muscular for women. It's hard to get that big if you aren't juicing.
- tartoran 6y agoI think the ubuquity in porn is a big one here. If men got horny and didn’t have a way to get off they’d quicly find a partner, even if that means lowering of the perceived standard in a potential sex partner. Also, the fact that we’re communicating less in person may have some impact as well. As someone suggested that affluent men get everything and the rest don’t get anything has some truth to it but it doesn’t explain the whole picture. There are women who are not attracted to wealth and who seek a genuine connection - a connection they refuse to have to someone playing video games for 8 hours a day. No disrespect for avid gamers but i think they’re missing a big part of life
- Coutured 6y agoI’m a young US man and I find sex (and close human contact in general) mildly disgusting. Yet, I also feel so much pressure from my peers to be dating and having sex. The culture basically says sex and drugs are the only things worth doing. I spend my time on dating apps going on dates I don’t enjoy in the hopes of having sex that I don’t enjoy. Don’t get me wrong, I’m attracted to women and enjoy spending time with them. I just don’t like sex. I like the idea of sex but my desire to have sex with someone decreases significantly the closer they are to me (disgust is inverse-square with proximity). At least I can find humor in the absurdity. It feels like I can trace all the problems in my life back to my uncomfortableness with sex. Why am I so uncomfortable? That might take another long unpleasant post. Its tempting to think that I should find some peace in not having sex or find a partner who doesn’t like sex either. That’s a good suggestion. Its really a war in my mind between feelings of disgust from having sex and feelings of disgust from not having sex. My therapist and I agree that its best for me to “get out there” and date.
- RodgerTheGreat 6y agoYou may be asexual. There's nothing wrong with that. Do some research; choosing to identify with the label could make you feel more comfortable in your own skin. Some dating apps allow you to specify your orientation as asexual and search for potential partners who feel the same. Sexual orientation is only one small factor in overall compatibility, but if it's something causing you anxiety while trying to find a partner, being up-front can't hurt; you will only filter out people who would have been a poor match anyway.
- Coutured 6y agoYou can call it asexual or you can call it “sexually traumatized straight” but I’m not sure which is more accurate. One has nothing wrong with it and another has a lot wrong with it. To tell you the truth I’d not be particularly happy with either.
- akvadrako 6y agoI think it’s quite normal to find sex a bit disgusting - human bodies are pretty gross, at least with modern sensibilities. Sex is enjoyable when I’ve been looking forward to it for weeks with someone who I am comfortable with. But hookups are not worth it.
- lifeisstillgood 6y agoTo be honest, sex has to be the one shining example of how much things don't change as civilisation evolves. As much as we might like to think apps like Tinder change the game, sex is very very location based - always has been always will be. And a crowded bar and admiring glances act pretty much the same way as swiping left or right or whatever does. There is always competition for desirable resources.
- troughway 6y agoThis has always been the case; it's just that the internet has facilitated dissemination of this knowledge very rapidly. Read "The Game" by Neil Strauss and the whole alt.seduction.fast thing - this was happening in the early/mid/late 90s long before the advent of online dating. This is old knowledge coming to surface. Nothing has fundamentally changed in the behavior/logic of men or women.
- nvr219 6y agoJust gonna say a lot of the comments in this thread make it sound like the commenters believe this is women's fault or good looking guys' fault. Hopefully I misunderstood your comments...
- wcoenen 6y ago8000 years ago, 17 women reproduced for every one man. This is based on analysis of DNA that is exclusively passed on by males (Y chromosome) and females (mitochondrial DNA). https://psmag.com/.amp/environment/17-to-1-reproductive-success https://psmag.com/.amp/environment/17-to-1-reproductive-succ...
- Nav_Panel 6y agoThere was a lot more raping and pillaging back then, I assume. What's your point?
- wcoenen 6y agoThe biological reason for having males and females is ultimately game-theoretical: males spend less energy on reproduction. Females spend more energy (pregnancy), but compensate by demanding higher evolutionary fitness from the males. The male strategy is high risk / high reward. During times of rapidly changing evolutionary pressure, there is a "winner takes all" effect. Perhaps we're going through such a period right now, just like 8000 years ago.
- cmdshiftf4 6y agoThis is one aspect of my belief that Western society, especially that in North America, is crumbling before our very eyes and yet with each piece that hits the ground, instead of seeing concern we're hearing "PROGRESS!". As part of a couple now considering bringing children into the world, the absolute shitshow that I predict the West to be constantly embroiled in 20 years from now when they would be adults is something that's weighing heavily on my mind.
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoShouldn't people like you be having more children? If society is really crumbling, we need more people who have the right ideas about how to rebuild it. I'm not being sarcastic by the way. I imagine we have similar concerns about Western civilization.
- cmdshiftf4 6y agoAbsolutely. On the one hand, having a comparatively large family (3 kids) and raising them well would be one very strong thing one could look at on one's deathbed and be comforted by knowing you did your part to help. On the other hand, there's something morally uneasy about bringing children into something you know to be broken. As we correctly recognize, children won't fix a damned relationship and bringing them into one can harm them long term. It sort of feels like that but on the macro scale. All that being said, we are leaning on the side of having a large (as above) family, but it doesn't come with an uneasy feeling.
- inv13 6y agoI surprised how the article or any of the comments did not address pornography. Having been given up on it years from now, so I can talk out of experience. The number and clarity of with which women kept and keep on signifying to me to have sex with them, or just they interested in me, are just crazy. Usually when I start a friendly chat, it takes 2 minutes without me trying anything to make them come closer to me and make em do their shit, whatever they do when they are into you and willing to show it to you. I don't want to go into story telling, because you can have your own research and read some other peoples experiences about this. Search for nofap in google. There is of course a lot more to than just not doing something, but it is a really huge leap towards the correct road. (which is in this case getting more sex :))
- danlugo92 6y agoYou're just attractive I guess? Are you implying they can smell nofap on you wtf.
- war1025 6y agoPheromones. They underlie a lot of primal behavior.
- deathgrips 6y agoPlease search for nopoo. It's like nofap but you don't take a shit more than once every three days. Your body expends a lot of energy with excretion. If you train your body to conserve this energy it becomes easier to concentrate and you exude attractive pheromones.
- verst 6y agoHere is the primary data source used by this study. GSS General Social Survey https://gss.norc.org/ https://gss.norc.org/ Specifically of interest as it related to this article: Number of sex partners in last year (by year): https://gssdataexplorer.norc.org/variables/5049/vshow https://gssdataexplorer.norc.org/variables/5049/vshow Frequency of sex in last year (by year): https://gssdataexplorer.norc.org/variables/5057/vshow https://gssdataexplorer.norc.org/variables/5057/vshow
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Frost1x 6y agoI can't help but notice the irony of this thread blowing up in popularity given that it's a Friday afternoon across most the US and during a pandemic with a lot of isolation, for an audience where the industry is largely populated by US males. Also quite humorous how it was removed from the front page shortly after even though much of the discussion was civil. Let's not discuss the hard problems folks, thats how we solve real problems, right?
- ratww 6y agoIt was probably removed from the front page because the number of comments is bigger than the number of votes, to avoid flamewars. I've seen this pattern happening over and over.
- chrisjarvis 6y agoA lot commenters here are blaming the sexual revolution for this trend, and I don't think that's the case (and its obviously a good thing women have more autonomy). I look at the men I'm surrounded by in my life, generally intelligent people who are financially comfortable in their mid or late 20s and think to myself, "I wouldn't fuck any of these losers, either." The men of my generation are absolutely consumed by the drugs of the modern world; video games, porn, binge-watching low quality media, childish crap, unhealthy diets, etc. The great companies of the world benefit from this becoming the majority, a consumer who will never question the world around him. Reject this nonsense, humans weren't designed to live in boxes, eating garbage and consuming media for 80 years. You don't need to fight in a war for your life to have purpose, there are battles to be fought and WON every day of your life. You, sitting there, are the product of millennia of genetic success, you have the tools to be great and I, personally, really want you to be. Never get discourage! Always believe in yourself! And don't be afraid to ask for help!
- thrwaway69 6y agoI actually love this trend. Overpopulation is a disease. Hopefully more countries follow this.
- troughway 6y agoI agree with you here, but there are a number of other posts in this thread that are basically saying to "pull yourself up by the bootstraps", which we know works oh-so-well for those who are in poverty.
- chrisjarvis 6y agoya that's a good point that I didn't even realize, my messaging was more geared towards people who are in no danger of starving/poverty but who still live unhealthy, unfulfilling lives. I didn't even stop to think that there are people who don't have the ability to lives of excess, let alone needing to actively work on not living this way.
- buboard 6y agowhiny comments whenever one more study like this comes out. This is a trend that is well known and discussed for at least 10 years. A french novelist wrote about it 25 years ago: the free sexual market leads to inequality , which means pauperization for a lot of men. Now, instead of chest thumping and whining, it is better to accept the trend for the fact that it is, and work with the consequences. These changes reflect free and deliberate choices by people that are going to be respected because most people like progress and aren't going to go back to traditionalism or authoritarianism. Such trends can indeed have society-changing effects, since access to sex and family is one of the cornerstones of organized society, and society doesnt form spontaneously in nature. The foundational myth of ancient Rome included the abduction of the Sabine women. In ancient Athens, lawmaker Solon instituted state brothels with cheap prices for everyone. Marriage, and access to family for most men has been holding together societies for millenia. It's only natural that men will not want to "give back" to society if they don't feel they get any benefit. What may follow from here? Perhaps if men still want sex they could seek more gay sex - they do seem to be having a lot more fun as a group. Or perhaps men might just not be interested in sex anymore - after all there is very clear evidence that testosterone and sperm motility have seen huge drops in the past 4 decades. Americans (with their relatively macho culture) are even lagging behind in this trend away from sex -- it's likely more advanced in many other countries. In societal terms this may undermine social solidarity or lead to mass exodus to new enclaves that have yet to be built. There's also the prospect of biotechnology: we can already almost design babies, and maybe we are not very far from an artificial uterus which at least can provide access to family for most men. I think as societies we should not be hiding these issues under the rug (or purposely removing topics from the frontpages) but realize that these are solid, future trends that deserve being discussed reasonably and dispassionately
- mD5pPxMcS6fVWKE 6y agoMass castration, as done to domestic animals, could solve a problem. Genetic test can help decide today if a male baby is going to be less than 6ft tall in adulthood, and thus warrant castration to prevent future disappointment in life.
- 6y ago
- bluekite2000 6y agoAny tech dev/company in Bay Area want to set up shop in Vietnam? And live a more balanced life (in terms of dating, traveling, eating good food, etc)? I can help be your local point of contact.
- rv-de 6y agoIs this some incel subreddit, or what? Guys, chill, you can and you will meet women if you finally start to use your brains for this matter - and maybe pull yourself together every once in a while - it's not _just_ about genetically predisposed features. Having said that - I mean, meeting anybody these days is a bit of a challenge anyway.
- mydongle 6y agoIt's partly an American culture problem. I'm sure the dating game in some other countries are a bit healthier than ours. There's simply so many mixed signals now on what you are and are not allowed to do. Is it okay to go up and talk to a girl you think is cute anymore? No one is really sure. Depends on who you ask. Go up to the wrong girl and you might end up in jail or maybe shamed by her and her friends online somewhere for being creepy. There's also the question about consent. Having to whip out a contract for the girl to sign, confirming her legal consent to have sex is not too attractive. Not to mention the fact she can take away her consent post-sex and then you become a rapist. Girls on average find the less consensual, proactive way more sexy, but that's not something anyone would admit. But that's a cultural taboo now, so yeah.
- giardini 6y agoThat is OK: leaves more of it for us old U.S. guys!8-)) BTW I'm seeing a lot about marriage and sex in these postings. But it is quite possible to be married and not have much, or any, sex. In fact IIRC there was an older study that said only a small percentage of married people had what both partners termed a good sex life. The facts that men (in their youth) usually desire sex more than women and that women mostly acquire a desire for sex usually in their later years ensures that there is only a brief period where both "agree" on how much sex is satisfactory.
- cbruns 6y agoI didn't realize how much of HN overlapped the incel 'community'. Really an eye-opening and depressing thread. Do so many young men really think this way?
- luminaobscura 6y agoIt shouldn't be surprising. It's established that IQ correlates with less sex. especially in west.
- nazgulnarsil 6y agoTalking in percentages encourages relative rank reasoning and ignores population level changes. 70% of men are overweight. This was not true in the past.