13 ms·
America has more new spaceships on the way
- thePunisher 6y agoI wonder how much effort it would take to enable Crew Dragon to fly people to the Moon and pull the rug from under Orion's feet? A slightly improved heat-shield and some rad-hard electronics would do it IMHO. That would save NASA another $10 billion or so. I find the statement that there's a public desire for a winged spaceship silly. I haven't heard anyone call out for such a vehicle, certainly no chant from the general public. The dream of an airliner-like space shuttle died when Columbia disintegrated upon reentry.
- baggachipz 6y agoIIRC a Falcon heavy in expendable mode (i.e., no booster recovery/landing) could theoretically get the job done. Apparently there's little desire from NASA to do that right now though. SpaceX is putting all their deep space efforts into Starship.
- est31 6y ago> pull the rug from under Orion's feet? I much prefer multiple alternatives as then SpaceX can't do price hikes. For example, the US has paid russia to send rockets to space since before they cancelled the Space shuttle. But once they did, the prices went up drastically. The more competing options there are, the better.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y ago> before they cancelled the Space shuttle. But once they did, the prices went up drastically. This. Competition.
- m4rtink 6y agoYou would also need more delat-v or a tug to get Dragon to Moon and back. Unlike Orian (or Apollo back then) Dragon actually does not have a real service module - the trunk provides aerodynamic stability at abort and hosts solar panels and radiators - but is otherwise empty. For lunar operations you might need to put fuel tanks inside the trunk & the make the fuel usable to the thrusters in the capsule. Or alternatively put some simple thrusters in/on the trunk. These could have more efficient nozzle compared to what Dracos & Super Dracos have due to capsule aerodynamics constraints (compare the nozzle bell size for Orion and Apollo). On the other hand this would increase complexity quite a bit & you are effectively lugging around duplicate engines.
- mabbo 6y agoIt would be a lot of work, that's certain. Basing this purely on my Kerbal intuition, SpaceX might try something along the lines of: 1- use a falcon heavy to get a tug (Merlin Vacuum rocket, plus big fuel tank plus docking port) into low earth orbit. Very soon afterwards, launch the Dragon to a rendezvous orbit with the tug. Meet, join, head out. Dragon can land itself with Draco thrusters it already has and likely take off as well- if it has enough fuel. The Dragon might need to be modified for extra fuel. Then of course it either needs a thicker heat shield or else more fuel to slow down before they hit atmosphere, whichever is lighter/cheaper to develop. Could be done, but the R&D money for that could instead be put into Starship. Same story as the recovery of falcon second stage.
- CDSlice 6y ago> I wonder how much effort it would take to enable Crew Dragon to fly people to the Moon and pull the rug from under Orion's feet? As an avid Kerbal Space Program player (but not a rocket engineer!), I feel like it shouldn't take that much effort compared to what SpaceX has already done. Given that Falcon Heavy has the capability to get the Lunar Gateway to Lunar orbit (1), one Falcon Heavy should easily be able to get a robotic tug in LEO and another FH launch could get one in orbit around the moon. Then the Crew Dragon could launch on the Falcon 9, rendezvous with the tug in LEO and then go to the moon. To land I expect a special trunk with it's own Super Draco engines and fuel could land the capsule on the moon and take it back to orbit, potentially with help from the capsule Super Dracos as a sort of second stage. The Dragon would then rendezvous with the second tug that takes the capsule back to LEO so that the reentry would be at already certified speeds. This way nothing would have to change for the Crew Dragon itself so it wouldn't have to be recertified. With this plan the only new things SpaceX would have to make would be the robotic tugs using vacuum optimized Merlin engines and a special trunk for the Crew Dragon that would let it land and take off of the moon. I do wonder if the Crew Dragon's life support systems are rated to last this long and out of LEO. It also would be a one shot program like Apollo which seems antithetical to how SpaceX operates, so unless Elon does it for bragging rights as the first purely private moon landing I don't see it happening. (1) https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/05/nasa-planning-to-launch-an-integrated-lunar-gateway-in-2023/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/05/nasa-planning-to-lau...
- aphextron 6y ago>"I find the statement that there's a public desire for a winged spaceship silly." I have to disagree. For all the technological achievements of SpaceX, we still don't have the capabilities lost with the Shuttle. No other spacecraft before or since has had the ability to launch 8 astronauts and return multi-ton cargos from LEO. There was also just something so cool about having a freaking spaceship that capsule designs will never have, and that shouldn't be discounted. I couldn't help but feel somewhat depressed watching the Dragon launch like we have regressed as a society, no longer daring to push the limits and strive for absurdley ambitious things like the Shuttle did.
- maccam94 6y agoUpmass is way more important right now than downmass. If you want more inspiration, know that SpaceX is making a significant profit on these flights despite their price being a small fraction of shuttle flights. And they're pouring it into their next generation rocket, Starship, which they plan to launch around the Moon in a few years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Starship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Starship
- thePunisher 6y agoWe regressed because we found out that winged spaceships are too hazardous. Dream Chaser too is dangerous since in the event of an explosion it will likely tear the wings off, making a safe return infeasible.
- mabbo 6y agoStarship has a real potential to be accelerated beyond the schedule given because of the return to the moon. NASA gave SpaceX a lump of cash a couple of months ago to fully spec out a Moon-lander variant of Starship, along with two other companies. It's outlandishly large compared to its competitors, but SpaceX has this knack for doing things cheaply. Imagine what happens if NASA looks at all three plans and says "They're all equal in terms of meeting our goals, except that Starship has many times the payload capacity and is cheaper than the others". Add in SpaceX's pretty good record for success, and it could make the decision interesting. If they are selected, suddenly there would be a lot more money in SpaceX's hands dedicated to developing Starship even faster. They could blow up 2 prototypes per month instead of just 1.
- loceng 6y agoHis stated goal is to create to start mass producing Starships, he personally wants 1,000 of them with relaunch time of 1 hour for each vehicle, I believe allowing 2-3 launches per vehicle per day.
- thePunisher 6y agoI don't see Starship landing on the Moon. It's just too big and unwieldy and will likely topple upon touchdown.
- dfee 6y agoAre you an aerospace engineer? Because the credibility of your comment hinges on that.
- thePunisher 6y agoNo, but a friend of mine is and he said exactly the same thing.
- LolWolf 6y agoHey, Kerbal Space Program is a perfectly valid alternative to a degree in Aerospace engineering! EDIT: Obviously kidding.
- SeanFerree 6y agoLove it!
- aerophilic 6y agoInteresting they didn’t also include Blue Origin in the mix: https://www.blueorigin.com/ https://www.blueorigin.com/ In my opinion, we should see crewed sub-orbital flights from them within the year, and possibly crewed orbital flights in the 4-8 year time frame... where those crewed orbital flights may have capacity to go all the way to the moon.
- robszumski 6y agoThis might have been punishment for them being too secretive. The press can only talk about your plans if they have enough information.
- valuearb 6y agoThe press can only talk about your accomplishments if you actually have some.
- itsoktocry 6y ago>The press can only talk about your accomplishments if you actually have some. Why is it that Elon Musk fans claim to be about these overarching, prohumanity missions ("Accelerating the transition to renewable energy! Enabling people to live on other planets!"), but then spend half their time hating on competitors with common goals?
- icelancer 6y agoBecause along the way, Elon actually gets things done.
- 51Cards 6y agoI keep wondering if Blue Origin has something up their sleeve. New Shepard has a great track record but only for sub-orbital hops so far and hasn't yet carried human passengers after 12 successful flights. The New Glen concept looks interesting but it has been in the works for a long time with nothing visible yet. They do also have a great engine in development with customers for it. Several years back Blue Origin used to friendly troll SpaceX on who was leading who but now it's not even talked about. I'll be curious to see how complete New Glen is when they roll it out as more competition, more better.
- am_lu 6y agoI would love if we were going to space united. Humans of Terra got new spaceships on the way.
- jeffdavis 6y agoWidely-shared responsibility and widely-shared credit don't have a great track record for accomplishing amazing and bold things.
- skissane 6y agoMost countries don’t invest much in space. As a percentage of GDP, US is second only to Russia in government civilian space funding. (Given US GDP is over 12 times that of Russia, US spending is higher than Russia in absolute terms.) For your dream to come true, other countries have to increase their expenditure. (My own country Australia is among the guiltiest here - the Australian Space Agency’s budget is less than 10 million a year - it should be a hundred times that.)
- vulcan01 6y agoCompeting nationalism can do wonders for technology (that's how the space race got started, and look at all the inventions we benefit from now that came from NASA). On the other hand, competing nationalism leads to war...
- fasteddie31003 6y agoCan someone explain to me why NASA did not use Orion to get crew to the ISS?
- 51Cards 6y agoIn a nutshell it comes down to two things. A. It's not ready to fly yet. And B. it's not really built for that purpose. Sort of like taking an RV to the corner store. You can do it but it's expensive, bulky, and over-built.
- bryanlarsen 6y ago- Orion doesn't have the necessary docking adapter. - Orion costs well over $1 billion per capsule, plus almost another $2 billion for the SLS rocket to ride on. In total that's more than the $2.6B they paid SpaceX for NRE + 6 flights. (NRE on Orion was $20billion and SLS will be even more) - The SLS rocket isn't ready yet. - Boeing can't build more than one SLS per year.
- kanox 6y ago> Orion doesn't have the necessary docking adapter. NASA actually enforced a standard docking systems for all capsules: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_Docking_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_Docking_System . In theory it's androgynous so it might even be possible to dock capsules to each other. Orion is extremely heavy (26 tons fully fueled) so it would need a Falcon Heavy or D4 Heavy. This would make it very expensive. It's also politics: since the early 2010s SLS has been the only "supported" vehicle for Orion thus tying the two programs together.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- twic 6y agoIt's fun to read articles from a few years ago [1]: > With SpaceX projecting a first Falcon Heavy flight in 2015, even with some slippage it seems reasonable to suppose that Falcon Heavy will be at least as “operational” in 2018–19 as the SLS. Both craft should have made at least one flight, allowing mission planners to ground future efforts in reality rather than speculation. My prediction is that the SLS will never fly. Development might not be cancelled for a long time, because it's a jobs programme, but it will never fly. If Orion ever goes to the moon, i think it will start the journey on a SpaceX rocket. If Starship works out, then on that. If not, then on Falcon Heavy with extensive in-orbit assembly before the trip. Or perhaps even some four-booster Falcon Super Heavy, although probably not. [1] https://thespacereview.com/article/2737/1 https://thespacereview.com/article/2737/1
- rbanffy 6y agoCan't a pair of Falcon Heavy rockets send a lander and an Orion separately so they'd dock in Lunar orbit? 22 tons is a lot of hardware.
- martythemaniak 6y agoIt'll definitely fly once, but probably not more than that. The first rocket, scheduled for an unmanned flight in late 2021, is ready-ish. The second flight is currently scheduled for 2023 and I would agree that one will never fly. With both Starship, and to a lesser extent New Glenn flying by then, it would be sheer lunacy to continue with it.