12 ms·
How to Safely and Ethically Film Police Misconduct
- tmsh 6y agoCan I just say - the sources for good, actionable news are sometimes the strangest of places these days. I've started just reading: http://reddit.com/r/news http://reddit.com/r/news instead of newspaper websites and it's nice - some affiliate tv news stations (the Minneapolis newspapers...not so much) or student newspapers (I see you Crimson reporting on the anthropology department) are getting it done and sometimes more consistently than major news organizations. Crowd-sourced news is coming of age.
- xapata 6y agoTeen Vogue has been surprisingly adult in a time when adults ... aren't.
- dmurray 6y agoIt's also very reasonable with ads. For me the page has 3 or 4 ads that interrupt the content, but don't masquerade as content, and they're all for other brands owned by the same publisher (so hopefully not on a third-party ad network). If all sites were like that I wouldn't feel the need for an adblocker.
- afturner 6y agoTo be fair, ad blockers block more than just advertisements
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoIt has been quite refreshing. I find it unfortunate that the adult version hasn't followed suit.
- terramex 6y agoI use https://legiblenews.com https://legiblenews.com to keep up with most important things happening in the world.
- samizdis 6y agoThat seems to be a timed snap-shotted version of Wikipedia's current events page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portal:Current_events https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portal:Current_events
- HomeDeLaPot 6y agoYep, there's an attribution at the bottom of the page that credits "Wikipedia contributors"
- jasonjayr 6y agoSomeone mentioned SPIDR on HN a while back, and it's seems to have a wide range of headlines + viewpoints: https://spidr.today/ https://spidr.today/ The comments are useless though..
- jbeam 6y agoI like Memeorandum: https://www.memeorandum.com/m/ https://www.memeorandum.com/m/ It gives you exposure to whatever people happen to be talking about at the time, but also other takes on the issue. Completely automated.
- Mirioron 6y agoA word of caution: /r/news is quite partisan (so be skeptical). Not as bad as /r/politics, but not too far either. I do agree though that having a variety of what seems to be unusual news sources is pretty good.
- joejerryronnie 6y agoIt is becoming harder and harder to find non-partisan sources of news these days. Even CNN (who I always considered impartial) pretty blatantly wears their politics on their sleeves now. I’ve resorted to reading multiple center-left & center-right sources and trying to reconcile the truth somewhere in the middle.
- cycomanic 6y agoThis is a discussion that comes up again and again. How do you go from the news is partisan to the truth must lie somewhere in the middle. Truth does not care about political leanings. Moreover this assumption has caused a pretty extreme drift to the right in the US, all driven by the republican party & fox news moving more and more to the extreme right, but moderates still thinking the truth must be in the middle.
- joejerryronnie 6y agoI make a case by case determination based on what info is out there, what I am able to observe, and the sum total of my life experiences. What I believe is true about an individual topic does not always fall directly in the center. But I guarantee you the left spins their stories just as much as the right does.
- cycomanic 6y agoThis has simply not been the case in recent years in the US, where there has been a concentrated and deliberate attack on the truth exclusively from the right, just look at any analysis on the unprecedented number of false statements (dare I say lies) from Trump. The whole argument also completely ignores the fact that pretty much everything of US politics is far right from the perspective of most other countries. So if the truth is in the middle, which middle is it?
- Mirioron 6y ago>The whole argument also completely ignores the fact that pretty much everything of US politics is far right from the perspective of most other countries. I don't really mean to offend, but I think you've drunk so much of the leftwing coolaid in the US that you don't notice it anymore and consider it normal. Just try to analyze people like Don Lemon. The few clips I've seen of him are very partisan politics. Look at Time Magazine when they talked about border detention. The images used were there to paint a narrative. The US hasn't moved to the right politically at all recently. You're getting more government spending on social programs and you're getting a more liberal stance on many social issues such as gay marriage. If you still don't see it, then ask yourself this: how much has the religious right influenced politics recently? Because Bush cited religion as one of the reasons for war. It's clearly losing ground.
- dntbnmpls 6y ago> Crowd-sourced news is coming of age. That's what people thought around 2010, then we got censorship and control. If you like r/news now, then you would have loved it 10 years ago when it was more "crowd-sourced" with less censorship. r/news is now no different from other major subs, mod propaganda. Also, append "old" to reddit.com for a better user experience - http://old.reddit.com/r/news http://old.reddit.com/r/news
- danielfoster 6y agoIt's great to see younger people get much-needed information on how to keep the police accountable in a democratic society. I'm impressed with this article's level of detail. I was most impressed that the article emphasizes sticking to the facts. The goal should always be good citizen journalism, not creating the next WorldstarHipHop sensation.
- ipython 6y agoOverall there have been a lot of great content from teen vogue especially over the past five years, despite the connotations associated with the name.
- lordnacho 6y agoWhy do I not see more drones in the protest videos? You'd think that would be a safe way to film things, plus it's a little harder to confiscate than your phone.
- notahacker 6y agoI assume consumer drones are not particularly difficult to shoot down, with rubber bullets or otherwise
- snovv_crash 6y agoRacing drones are much sturdier and harder to hit, lots of videos of people on YouTube with paintball guns trying to shoot drones.
- tonyarkles 6y agoIn Canada, at least, a drone (even a consumer drone) is considered an aircraft. Shooting at an aircraft is not, legally, a very good idea. We're admittedly talking about a group of cops that don't seem to hold the law in very high regard, but intentionally shooting at an aircraft is likely to get some investigation from people a little higher up into the food chain. Airspace is federally regulated and the regulatory agencies (Transport Canada, FAA) don't generally like other agencies on their turf, shooting at things :)
- PeterStuer 6y agoFlying over groups of people is not allowed.
- tonyarkles 6y agoThere's nuance to that, at least in Canada. First, you can fly over people if you have an Advanced license and are using a unit with an appropriate Safety Assurance declaration (https://www.tc.gc.ca/en/services/aviation/drone-safety/choosing-right-drone.html https://www.tc.gc.ca/en/services/aviation/drone-safety/choos...), you can fly over people. Second, if your drone is under 250 grams, the rules are pretty much "don't put people in harms way" and "don't put aircraft in harm's way". The DJI Mavic Mini was designed pretty much to squeeze under that limit, coming in at 249g. I don't know if the FAA has a similar rule (a quick Google search suggested the answer is "maybe").
- scarface74 6y agoAlways share the video on social media. Don’t trust the cops or any part of the justice system to do the right thing.
- IanCal 6y agoEven if the victims don't want that?
- x86_64Ubuntu 6y agoHow often does that occur in police misconduct incidences?
- jedimastert 6y agoIt's usually because of fear of police retribution.
- threatofrain 6y agoIn a large scale protest, surveillance and military drones are the end game IMO.
- germinalphrase 6y agoI’ve been hearing from people I know who have been participating in nighttime protests/property protection that social media posts on Snapchat/Facebook/reddit are disappearing or seeing significant posting delays. I can’t confirm it personally, but the social media chatter last night was significantly lower than previous nights (though - to be fair - the Minneapolis streets did start clearing out around 11-12).
- StellarTabi 6y agoIt's always ethical to film police misconduct, in fact what's unethical is that they're not already filming themselves. Safety is important, protesters (and even journalists...) have been livestreaming themselves innocently doing nothing (in contrast to other media's hyper-focusing on "looting") then getting shot with rubber bullets. One of them reportedly has permanent blindness in the left eye as a result. Police brutality in response to a protest against police brutality is truly disturbing.
- samdamsamm 6y agoTonight I witnessed a young girl get knocked out cold by a tear gas canister shot into her face from about a 40 ft. range. She was holding her hands up. There was nothing but peaceful protesters standing around, not blocking traffic. No vandalism anywhere in sight. This was in Louisville, KY. The police fired rubber bullets at the group of people carrying her away to a place on the other side of the line of humvees blocking the street to where the ambulance could reach her. Everything most middle-income Americans think about our police forces is wrong.
- scarface74 6y agoMiddle America knows that police target minorities - they just don’t care.
- seaknoll 6y agoI think that's an extremely unhelpful oversimplification. There isn't some subset of humans (as a high enough percentage of the population to be considered) that's simply missing empathy. At least in their own minds they are good people, so that's where they have to be met. So IMO we need to start by assuming that they DO care, but they have different assumptions about the difficulty and danger of police work. They live in safe communities and go into cities and see poverty and homelessness, mental illness on the streets, read about the gun crime, and think that it's scary. They're not entirely wrong. Where they ARE wrong is in failing to realize how often police officers are the ones to create violent situations. Why did they use force over a counterfeit bill? Why would they bust into someone's apartment in the middle of the night over a drug charge? Unless there is an in-the-moment violent situation going on, they should not be entitled to use force. They should be required to wait, plan, and deescalate. The last thing they should be allowed to do is play out their masturbatory fantasy on the public. If that makes police work more boring, so be it.
- ncmncm 6y agoI keep seeing indications that Teen Vogue editors are more aware of their responsibilities than one might expect.
- obblekk 6y agoI find it fascinating that teen vogue is running content like this. I wonder what it says about our society that this is in vogue for teens. Probably that we both have matured and have needed to mature. Reminds me of hongkong students.
- pmorici 6y agoThere is quite a bit of anecdotal information floating around suggesting that a large portion of the 'loot & riot' crowd are young people not necessarily from the city coming into the city to cause trouble and are separate and apart in their intentions and motivations from the protest crowd made up of people who live in the area and have a direct interest in it.
- aurizon 6y agoDo not wear a 'shoot me' sign. Live hidden video, (2 cams, one points front and one points rear placed behind a plastic grommet it can see through - but is not alone, or buttonhole - make sure cam can not be seen and can not be blocked as you move, and blends in to clothing) stream to a friend-monitored cloud(that the friend can view, but not erase in case the friend is also grabbed). This will give you video your cloud keeps, even if you are frisked flat on a wall. Google how to hide a cam with a grommet or other peephole. Facing away you are nota threat. Learn the ways you hidden cam points and stores video. Wide angle is good, but loses resolution in dimmer light. Use best resolution, 4K etc. Make sure your video cloud is pass-worded and you do not carry the PW in ur pocket. Battery life may be shortened, so an added battery pack pluged into the phone will help. You may be able to encrypt?? You can also use a tiny 4K cam instead of a phone because phones can be detected via some police hand scanners and some forces have been caught using stingrays that can detect and divert your video away from your cloud to their cloud. (I am not sure how well stingrays can do this in the USA, in some foreign places the police own this tech in depth - so be wary of risks and be able to silence your emissions of the police forces seem to be manually scanning people with sensing batons - again, this tech is costly and not universal, but it is out there. Only the paranoid.....
- gruez 6y agoIf your threat model includes police stingrays, the could also jam all cellphone traffic which makes cloud backups irrelevant.
- aurizon 6y agoThat is true. With enough tech, even a WiFi or other radio link could be blocked. A cam with it's own transmitter to a receiver off the cell bands - few would have it? Not sure how to solve this unless you have a hidden flat pack receiver in a hidden pocket with a good sized battery, flat enough to be hard to pat down?
- yummypaint 6y agoThis wouldnt be possible in the US, the police don't have the authority to override federal legislation. The FCC has historically been extremely agressive and successful in prosecuting use of jamming devices. I think it's more likely that stingrays would be used to inventory who is at a protest etc and put people on a list for individual targeting.
- Sevaris 6y agoAt this point people should be wearing helmets and goggles to protect their heads and eyes from rubber bullets and canisters of tear gas. It's crazy that the police can get away with severely injuring people. We've seen them directly aiming and shooting at cameras at eye level, and aiming at peoples' heads without any regard for safety.
- jungletime 6y agoLong zoom lens is probably safest. Something like nikon p900 has a zoom of x83 and is about $500 on ebay. Having just seen some videos of store owners getting whacked with 2x4s by looters. Need a follow up article, how to safely and ethically deal with looters. https://twitter.com/WHAM1180/status/1267031930308104197 https://twitter.com/WHAM1180/status/1267031930308104197
- RickJWagner 6y agoI'm starting to wonder if we need some formal role for communities in this. Bad cops must be held accountable. But also there must be some way to compel a belligerent person to go along with police (i.e. not resist arrest). Maybe there should be 'community liaisons' or something that would be called out when there is a troublesome situation.
- bilbo0s 6y agoIn fairness, part of the idea of using professional cops and not soldiers, was originally that professional cops were from the community and would be better able to interact, or "liaise" with community members. It's just that over the centuries we kind of forgot about that part. In the US we moved to the current system where many of the police may not even live in the communities they serve. Heck, they may not even live in the municipality at all. It's a better idea to try to make the cops community liaisons by going back to hiring your police from among the people who live in your municipality. You would get more familiar faces out there, and I think you'd get rid of the weekend warrior types from the suburbs or whatever. But there must be some reason they don't do that because that idea is just way too obvious. Maybe they have data that shows more corruption if the police are from the municipality being served? Or actually probably, the police unions don't allow it? Or something. There's probably a reason.
- shigawire 6y agoThere are rules like this in Chicago but you just get police and fireman enclaves right at the edge of city limits. Also walking beats is less common so there is no familiarity
- wintermutestwin 6y agoMaybe it is because (where you live ≠ community) anymore.
- vsareto 6y ago>In the US we moved to the current system where many of the police may not even live in the communities they serve. Heck, they may not even live in the municipality at all. Some will take out-of-state applicants as well. This is when they need bodies over liasons. And the hiring standards adjust accordingly, too.
- jasonv 6y agoI’ve wondered for years whether there has been an effort within police forces to congregate at a national level and work out improvements in their own processes, standards and relationship to issues seen with police practices. Arresting people for filming police, for instance — is there a national body that exists to align things across police forces? Are they all really acting independently and without any coordination wrt improvements?
- mitchtbaum 6y agoAuditors need auditing too.
- drdeadringer 6y agoI recently found out about an app from the ACLU specifically for recording//reporting (abusive) police activities. The app itself, at least the California version, has a section regarding one's rights and safety whilst filming police. https://www.aclu.org/issues/criminal-law-reform/reforming-police/aclu-apps-record-police-conduct https://www.aclu.org/issues/criminal-law-reform/reforming-po... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ACLU_Mobile_Justice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ACLU_Mobile_Justice
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]