40 ms·
Huawei builds up 2-year reserve of 'most important' US chips
- drevil-v2 6y agoInteresting comment in the article from one of their sources > It (Huawei) is preparing stocks for wartime Strange word/terminology to use for something they have apparently been doing since end-2018
- TazeTSchnitzel 6y agoWhich is about when the US started getting really aggressive about Huawei?
- christophilus 6y agoThe US and China have been in a Cold War for longer than 3 years. This didn’t start with Trump, and it won’t end with him. Trump is just an inarticulate accelerant in an already unfolding geopolitical catastrophe.
- logicchains 6y agoThis sounds like a great opportunity for organised crime. I imagine China'd be willing to pay at least as much for smuggled chips as drug consumers in many places pay for smuggled drugs, so it represents a huge opportunity for US-law-nonabiding middlemen.
- thePunisher 6y agoI'm somewhat surprised this loophole is allowed to exist at all. More likely companies involved in this trade will be put on a blacklist as well.
- sfmike 6y agoreminds me of the departed where they're doing a deal for the chips. quite the foreshadowing.
- mayama 6y agoMore of a target for espionage or cyber espionage. These lithography, semicon machines are low in number and expensive. Companies can't run gray batch for these and hide the profits, especially when they have good backlog of orders. So, these are good target for espionage, like it already is.
- thcleaner999 6y agoGood for them intel processors hasn’t changed last 2 years
- redis_mlc 6y agoSounds like they're working around a US embargo, which got Huawei CFO Meng Wanzhou detained.
- pinkfoot 6y agoOut of curiosity, in which legal system, is legally buying up stock months BEFORE an embargo is announced considered a crime? Retrospective law does not exist in civilised societies.
- redis_mlc 6y agoThe embargo started in May, 2019, so I guess we'll find out in 12 months. :)
- trhway 6y agoThis [1] sounds like an embargo workaround which can get people to prison [IANAL] (for example those Russian immigrants [2] got arrested for doing similar thing with Xilinx chips few years ago) [1] "... Huawei has not been able to directly buy chips from American companies without special approval since last May. However, it has been able to continue building its inventory of American chips through other available channels -- such as local chip distributors and traders, or even asking its own suppliers to buy the chips for it, sources familiar with the matter said. Huawei has been willing to pay far higher prices than normal for the chips, despite the fact the company can only secure "off-the-shelf" versions without customization or technical support, they said." [2] https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndca/pr/san-francisco-man-and-company-indicted-smuggling-sophisticated-electrical-components https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndca/pr/san-francisco-man-and-c...
- dntbnmpls 6y ago> Retrospective law does not exist in civilised societies. They exist in "civilized" societies when it suits their interests. The most famous being the nuremburg trials. Edit: In case the downvoter truly didn't know ... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuremberg_trials#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuremberg_trials#Criticism
- chvid 6y agoAs I understand it the big challenge is to replicate the chip manufacturing done by TSMC today. From what I have read mainland China is still years away from doing that.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoThey are. What is happening has probably made catching up one of their top priorities, and thus this will, ironically, shorten the time it will take for them to rise in that industry. That will also diminish Taiwan's strategic importance, which some might argue can increase the probability of forceful reunification.
- ahmedalsudani 6y agoChina already had the “Made in China 2025” initiative, and I imagine they’re putting a lot more money into similar efforts right now. They will likely 1. Close the gap at a faster rate 2. Make life difficult for Taiwan unless Taiwan relents We’re probably entering into a rough patch of human history for a lot of people.
- thePunisher 6y agoTheir biggest problem is procuring EUV machines from ASML. Setting up a factory with these machines is no big hurdle for them if they are able to buy the machines. The U.S. is pressuring the Dutch government to prohibit their sale, with some success. More likely China will now try to steal ASML's secrets and manufacture or duplicate the machines. ASML is known to have a large number of foreign contractors, and there are sure to be a few Chinese among them. If I where them, I'd quietly ban al ethnic Chinese from working at their company.
- banifo 6y agoDidn't it took ASML ages to be able to build EUV Machines? I don't think you can just replicate something like a EUV machine from them in any way. You probably need highly specialized workshops for tons of different components and all of those workshops have to go through the same innovation cycle.
- 082349872349872 6y agoSince 2018? Plenty of time to have run some Westlaw/LexisNexis searches in between. According to the Phase-1 agreement, China should buy at least USD 68B of US services in 2020. If they were to spend most of it on counsel, that'd be a lot of nastygrams, even at common-law billing rates.
- Barrin92 6y agoI think this decoupling attempt is unwise and will cost the US a lot of cash long term. There's too much at stake for China to ever back down, and it won't take them long to catch up in chip production. It's going to hurt them for a while but at the end of the day the US will have thrown a gigantic market away it could have comfortably owned. The strategic sector for Huawei is 5G, and it can trivially get enough chips for that. It will hurt their smartphone sector but the government can jump in if necessary to dampen the impact. Same with the Google Play Store embargo on Android. It just robs American companies of a market where they had a lead while it accelerates China's ambitions.
- jorblumesea 6y agoI see this argument all the time and just don't get it. China is basically stealing everything from source code, hardware schematics, materials science research. It might accelerate this a bit, but China already had its sights on a domestic semiconductor solutions years ago. The idea that they were going to ever let the US just "have the market" isn't how China does things. One way or another, China is going to copy everything the US does. It's just kicking the can down the road another 5 years or so. It's not a solution.
- liuliu 6y agoThere is no path for backing down for China. There is no clear actionable demand from the current U.S. administration. All players are waiting for the November result to pursuit a more strategically-oriented outcome.
- DiogenesKynikos 6y agoThe US is trying to block China's access to EUV lithography devices as well, which are required to fabricate chips at the 7nm scale and below. The lithography machines that Chinese companies (in particular, SMIC) want to buy are produced by a Dutch company, ASML. The US government recently pressured the Dutch government into blocking a sale of such machines by ASML to SMIC.[1] The US government has identified EUV lithography as a bottleneck in the semiconductor industry, and is trying to keep that bottleneck in place, as a pressure point that can be used against China in the future. The Brookings Institution has laid out the strategy.[2] Of course, that means that the Chinese government will now probably invest heavily in domestic lithography companies. The Brookings Institution thinks that the US can shut China out of high-end semiconductor production indefinitely. That seems like a pretty foolish conception to me. 1. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-asml-holding-usa-china-insight/trump-administration-pressed-dutch-hard-to-cancel-china-chip-equipment-sale-sources-idUSKBN1Z50HN https://www.reuters.com/article/us-asml-holding-usa-china-in... 2. https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/FP_20200427_computer_chips_khan_flynn.pdf https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/FP_2020...
- rfoo 6y agoThat's not foolish. Modern lithography technology (and in general high-end semiconductor production) is complicated enough that neither US nor China may catch up in reasonable time, if they are targeting a domestic supply chain. That said, the caveat here is the "neither US nor China" part, why would ASML, a Dutch company, align itself with US?
- DiogenesKynikos 6y agoWhat I mean by "foolish" is that in the long run (a decade), it will not work, and the entire policy of trying to stunt China's economic development will lead to conflict sooner or later. ASML didn't have a choice in the matter. The US government pressured the Dutch government to withdraw the export license. That's at the diplomatic level, way above the heads of company executives. The Netherlands is part of NATO and is more closely aligned with the US than with China. But the Netherlands could at some point decide that it just wants to do business with everyone.
- loyukfai 6y agoPersonally I feel that the probability of a major conflict between China and the US has increased substantially since the beginning of the 2020. We live in interesting time. Cheers.
- dragonsh 6y agoSuch conflict will be disaster for the whole humanity, so the probability of such conflict is not that great except some small skirmish here and there. I will not count on difficulty of technology to stop a country progress for long. China mastered bullet trains and surpassed the original designs from German, French and Japanese designs, so given time and resolve they will be able to solve given, at present USA closing doors and China opening doors for educated immigrants. I hope the world instead of focusing on differences, focus on collaboration, USA and its system has its own pros and cons so is China’s system. Also in general I believe no meaning in forcing Chinese to accept what’s right for them based on US ideas, let them have their own freedom to choose and work or change their system. As US has black minorities and Puerto Rico (overseas territory), so does China (Hong Kong and Taiwan). Let them figure out in their own way how to work out between their majority and minority. This is what US or any sovereign country irrespective of system will expect. If China tries to teach USA how to treat and respect its minorities and overseas territory they won’t agree, same is China.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI tend to agree. If the world’s fine with China engaging in a little soft genocide, I don’t think there’s much China would do on the international stage to actually provoke a war. The CCP does seem to be legitimately uninterested in the kind of violent foreign policy that would drag it unintentionally into conflicts.
- gdy 6y agoYep, China has already figured out how to work with its Muslim minority.
- dragonsh 6y ago
- purmac 6y agoEDA tools are possessed by US companies. It is not easy to close the gap i think.
- raverbashing 6y agoI wouldn't be worried about those. I'm sure China can easily find "alternative sourcing" for them (also the version they have right now is probably sufficient for some time)
- antpls 6y agoThere could be a revolution regarding EDA thanks to ML : https://ai.googleblog.com/2020/04/chip-design-with-deep-reinforcement.html?m=1 https://ai.googleblog.com/2020/04/chip-design-with-deep-rein... Google publicized about it, is China at the same level?
- Nokinside 6y agoIf Huawei is still blocked after stockpiles runs out, they have to start buying standard components from MediaTek or Samsung. There is no good non-American substitute for Xilinx. MediaTek’s flagship Dimensity 1000 5G Chipset is fine, so is Exynos 990. They are just slightly behind Snapdragon 855+ and A13 Edit: in case it's not clear, FPGA's are used in wireless base-stations.
- curiousgal 6y agoAs if A13 was even purchasable by anyone.
- zxcmx 6y agoInteresting to speculate on the engineering workarounds if all FPGAs disappeared tomorrow. I'm not sure there's a big long-term impact. Maybe more shift to more to DSP, make low volume ASICs on older nodes cheaper and cycle faster, put up with more card swaps since you can't update certain things in firmware so easily. You can still do all the things but maybe the design takes longer or you sacrifice some performance (designer gets to choose the tradeoff). My guess is the main "real" impact is cycle times, design retooling and having to pause and rework existing designs suffering from supply chain disruption. Potentially all problems you can fix scalably by throwing enough bodies at them since the money is clearly there. Would be interested in perspectives from anyone working in a related area.
- xupybd 6y agoHas the US disclosed why they are cracking down so hard on this one company. I know they are seen as a security threat and a puppet of the Chinese government but has there been a statement explaining what's going on here?
- londons_explore 6y agoIt's the first non-west-friendly provider of core bits of network infrastructure. It's also cheaper and better, which means it's selling quickly. Having network infrastructure with your designs installed on every network interconnection worldwide is very useful if you want to, say, have access to tap any conversation anywhere in the world... The funny thing is the US has missed the boat... Hearts and minds is what matters far more than network infrastructure, and tiktok has won there...
- giantrobot 6y agoThey resell a bunch of stolen Cisco and Nortel technology. So it's cheaper because they didn't develop it and better is a very subjective statement.
- harpratap 6y agoTheir 5G antennas are novel tech and only Nokia and Ericcson can compete with them. Cisco and Nortel provide just software layers on top of it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- londons_explore 6y agoStealing two bits of good tech, and combining them to make the best tech, might be against lots of IP laws in the US, but still results in the cheapest and best product on the market.
- TazeTSchnitzel 6y ago
- thePunisher 6y agoThose stocks will run out eventually. Huawei is probably betting on the sanctions being resolved through negotiations and the Chinese government making concessions on trade. However, I wouldn't count on this happening since the U.S. knows very well the power of being able to spy on adversaries and allies using network and telecom equipment. I don't believe Trump will back down on Huwawei no matter what the Chinese government offers.
- temac 6y agoSMIC already produces at 14nm. You can cover lots of things with that.
- thePunisher 6y agoApparently not enough as Huawei seems pretty nervous about it. If your competition is using 7nm and 5nm parts and you're stuck in the past with 14nm your market share will erode very quickly, especially in the smartphone business. Mind you that other Chinese smartphone makers do not (as of yet) face the same restrictions and are able to purchase the newest parts. What chance does Huawei stand against them, even in the Chinese market? I'd say very little.
- logicchains 6y ago>I don't believe Trump will back down on Huwawei no matter what the Chinese government offers. It's not a foregone conclusion that Trump will still be president in a year's time.
- KCUOJJQJ 6y agoIf people cared about spying, there would be end-to-end-encryption in 5G. Maybe it'll come with 6G.
- thePunisher 6y ago5G is a transmission technology so end-to-end encryption isn't useful there. You need end-to-end encryption at the application level.
- 0xFFC 6y agoExcuse my ignorance, why Huawei just does not ditch snapdragon and only improve/use HiSilicon Kirin?
- ogre_codes 6y agoSeems to me that buying a 2 year supply of CPUs is not a great strategic measure since 2 years out your competitors will have faster chips or paying far less than you in 2 years for the chips sitting in your inventory. Obviously if the alternative is to not have CPUs, it's the only choice they have, but its going to put them in a rough place competitively.
- notatoad 6y agothere's still a ton of new phones shipping with two-year-old chips in them. obviously, for new designs they won't choose to integrate chips that they can't source, but having a supply of chips they can no longer source means they can continue to manufacture their current models.
- andarleen 6y agoI yet have to understand why Chinese companies are not getting the same treatment in the US as US companies get in china. In the EU i understand - germans need to sell cars there, but in the US it is beyond me given the POTUS is “against” China.
- qihqi 6y agoThe US need to sale the iPhones?
- wwarner 6y agoI think it's important that the next big advances in computing are developed in the West. That's why the proposed NSF Technology Directorate [1] is so important. [1] https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2020/05/us-lawmakers-unveil-bold-100-billion-plan-remake-nsf https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2020/05/us-lawmakers-unveil-...
- cheez 6y agoThat first sentence is vague enough to lose hope.