9 ms·
In NY major crime complaints fell when cops stopped ‘proactive policing’ (2017)
- annoyingnoob 6y agoBroken windows policing is why I hate police. My chances of calling police under any circumstance is near zero. Having the cops kick your ass for no reason does not help anyone in our society, it only breeds mistrust. That mistrust can last a life time. Its going to take a generation or more to get past this bullshit. Welcome to the United Police States of America.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI'm not a fan either, but I think we have to acknowledge that it's an attempt to address a real problem. There really are areas where people regularly try to engage in petty crime, and the government has a duty to address that.
- MiroF 6y agoWhy? And what sorts of petty crime? If the solution is more damaging than the problem, (and where I grew up, with jumpout vans driving around to stop and pat down random groups of teenagers, it certainly was) then the solution seems unnecessary. I feel like many commentators here are divorced from what policing on the ground in these places really looks like, there is no finesse or discretion to it.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI agree that the existence of the problem doesn't justify any possible policy, and patting down random groups of teenagers does seem bad. But, I mean, crimes are bad too. Ideally nobody should have to live in a neighborhood where they're afraid of being mugged or having their car broken into, and today a lot of people do.
- MiroF 6y ago> being mugged Mugging is a violent crime and should be policed - but studies also show that people vastly overestimate their risk of being mugged. It definitely happens, but I am very skeptical that "broken window" policing addresses these sorts of violent crimes. A better move would be to de-densify poverty with mixed income housing, provide support resources, and build trust with police so people will report violent crimes. > having their car broken into Cars being broken in to? That's a different matter - I really don't think we have the capacity to police this in any meaningful way, it's a problem endemic to urban neighborhoods and is incredibly hard to police in a way that isn't super disproportionate. Don't leave valuables in your car, don't lock your doors - they'll just open, rifle through, and leave. I've had my car rifled through tens of times and the most they ever got was some quarters I left in there. The utilitarian in me feels like being exposed daily to random patdowns and harassments and having people jump out on you is much worse than that. Nobody should live in a neighborhood where the law enforcement doesn't treat them with dignity, just because of the color of their skin or their class background. You can't cleanly separate what crimes you choose to care about from the policies in place. When voters tell elected officials "decrease car breakins, that's what impacts my vote" that'll translate to these disproportionate policies because the communities being policed do not have the power to sway the policy and it is easy to hide the impact of the policing from the voters.
- mikeappell 6y ago> Don't leave valuables in your car, don't lock your doors - they'll just open, rifle through, and leave. I've had my car rifled through tens of times and the most they ever got was some quarters I left in there. Not sure how much of an issue this still is, but thieves used to steal airbags. That's a lot more expensive and a PITA to replace.
- MiroF 6y agoBased on a quick google, you have about a ~0.01% chance of your airbag being stolen in a given year. How many black people should we stop and frisk to solve that problem, I'm a little rusty on the math?
- rwmj 6y agoIn tourist areas I'd quite like the police to be proactively stopping pickpockets and scam artists.
- MiroF 6y agoAgain - you're discounting the negative secondary effects of the policy when the police start harassing people who "look" like pickpockets. Reminder - more total money is stolen from workers in the form of wage theft than is robbed by a factor of ~3 [0], why don't we focus on policing that? [0]: https://www.epi.org/publication/wage-theft-bigger-problem-forms-theft-workers/ https://www.epi.org/publication/wage-theft-bigger-problem-fo...
- rwmj 6y agoYou target pickpockets by having the police pretend to be a tourist, then arresting anyone who tries to pickpocket them. There's no confusion or profiling going on. And the rest of your comment is pure whataboutery - yes, we should do both.
- MiroF 6y agoIt's not whataboutery in the context of limited policing resources and public attention. Accusations of tu quoque get thrown around way too quickly on the internet.
- skinnymuch 6y agoThere’s limited resources. How is it whataboutism?
- rwmj 6y agoArresting pickpockets may be an overall gain if tourists feel safe to go out and therefore spend. And rampant wage fraud also ought to be tackled, again possibly a net overall gain if that increases tax revenue. If your country cannot fund a police force that could do both these things then you have much bigger problems.
- TuringNYC 6y agoThere are lots of petty crimes on Wall Street too. Check out downtown Manhattan on a Friday night and you'll find plenty of people with illegal drugs...yet...the broken windows theory seems to focus only on select [poor] neighborhoods.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoAnd that's a bad thing, but I'm sure you'd agree the right solution isn't for the police to permit lots of crime in poor neighborhoods.
- LeifCarrotson 6y agoPermitting petty crime would be a better solution than many alternatives. One such worse solution would be, for example, proactive, racially and economically discriminatory policing, ruining fragile, impoverished, limited-opportunity lives and breeding distrust, while simultaneously ignoring white-collar crime in rich neighborhoods.
- JackRabbitSlim 6y agoSo inversely, it is the right solution for police to permit lots of crime in well-off areas. “The law, in its majestic equality, forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal their bread.”
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoPoor people are certainly exposed to bad policing more often, but I don't think they see the entire concept of law enforcement as unequal. Most people across all income groups don't commit or approve of crimes.
- bikezen 6y ago"Permitting crime" and not hassling everyone who looks a certain way or is in a certain area are two VERY different things. People are harassed and delayed for no reason just because of the way they look or where they are coming/going from, even if its their neighborhood. They're also ticketed for minor offenses due to those same "reasons" meanwhile people elsewhere are not having those same offenses punished. You will find plenty of stories from people who lives in neighborhoods where this was applied where you literally have to allow extra time to come and go from your own home because its likely you will be stopped and questioned just going about your daily lives. That would not fly in more affluent communities. "Proactive Policing" allows implicit and other biases of the police force to be acted on directly because there needs to be no crime to stop someone, its entirely on the polices judgement on who to stop and why.
- wavefunction 6y agoCommunity policing is the solution to the problems that broken window policing attempts to and fails at solving. It involves building rapport with the local community so that the community and police can work together to solve the problems in the community.
- stephen_g 6y agoWhat you're basically saying is, "sure, this and various experiences show that this kind of policing might make things worse, but hey, at least they have good intentions". Well, plenty of terrible things have been done with good intentions. This is one of the things I really dislike about a lot of politics, I see it all too often. There's a problem, so we need to do something in the name of fixing it - doesn't matter if it helps or not, we just have to be able to say we're doing something. But maybe we should step back and look at whether there are better ways to deal with the problems.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoWe should step back and look! What concerns me about policing is that a lot of proposals seem to reduce to ignoring the problem; there's a particular famous city a bit north of me where it's just become accepted that the streets should be covered in poop and shattered window glass. So I'm skeptical of alternatives which can't clearly explain how they will stop people from doing crimes.
- craftinator 6y ago> Poop and shattered window glass These are symptoms of wealth inequality. Do you see wealthy people going around defecating on the ground or breaking glass? No. Do you see middle class people doing these actions? No. These are actions taken by homeless people (and teenagers), who have nothing worth while to do with their time, no money for idle entertainment, and awful living conditions.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThis just strikes me as an intensely disrespectful hypothesis. Poor people and teenagers are people just like you and I; the vast majority of them are good citizens who feel no impulse to do crimes or poop on the street.
- pinkfoot 6y agoSingapore has some ideas.
- rmrfstar 6y agoThe US has the highest per-capita incarceration rate in the world [1]. US: 655/100k UK: 135/100K China: 121/100K Germany: 77/100K Iceland: 37/100K It feels like we are consuming just a little too much of the "security" product. Maybe we should try consuming the "justice" product. I hear it's pretty good. [1] https://www.prisonstudies.org/highest-to-lowest/prison_population_rate?field_region_taxonomy_tid=All https://www.prisonstudies.org/highest-to-lowest/prison_popul...
- Zecar 6y agoEvery one of those countries has a high level of social cohesion that is not present in the USA. Don't you think that would be a huge factor?
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI agree, but the question is how to get from here to there. Releasing all the nonviolent drug addicts - which we certainly should do! - still doesn't get us close to those other countries.
- MiroF 6y agoThe problem with the drug war is imprisoning dealers, not addicts - and if we released them it would get us much closer to those other countries.
- danenania 6y agoBy the numbers, our best bet is probably revamping the prison system to focus on rehabilitation instead of punishment, and then drastically reducing the length of sentences. Our goal should be to get someone as close as possible to 0 chance of recidivism in as short a time as possible.
- close04 6y agoEducation is usually another good place to start. Educated people tend to make more informed choices, and informed choices tend to shape better futures.
- SN76477 6y agoI believe that petty crime is the cost of a free society. Strong arm tactics used by police do not stop it. It is simply going to happen. Spending resources to make sure everyone has what they need will drop petty crime rates. this is all my opinion.
- xphilter 6y agoThose areas are everywhere; they’re only selectively enforced in neighborhoods of color. White people don’t smoke weed, for instance? The huge rush of white folks into “legal” weed business suggests that’s not the case. But how many teenage boys in the suburbs are harassed and arrested and need to be bailed out? Imagine if all white people were stopped when they’re out in their neighborhood and actually had all those “petty” crimes enforced. (1) the policy would change overnight and (2) the arrest rate and mistrust of police would skyrocket.
- kspacewalk2 6y agoYou seem to suggest "broken window policing" has to come with abuse of power. But it is in fact the abuse of power that breeds mistrust. The broken window theory itself seems quite sound to me - if you let small crimes slide without appropriate, lawful and proportionate response and punishment, it does indeed breed contempt for the law and does indeed lead to increases in more serious crimes. I think the same is true with upholding traffic laws, for example. My home province of Ontario loves to create rules that sound great (and sometimes overly strict) on paper, and then proceed to not enforce them, ever. Municipal police services have essentially given up on speeding unless it's truly outrageous, like 50kmh over. But what they fail to realize is the causal link between small offences and large ones. Hypocrisy about "small" offences breeds general contempt for rules of all kind.
- mc32 6y agoIndeed. Anyone who lived under Edward I. Koch’s mayorship would agree that the broken window theory has merit. As you say it also requires proportional response with the intention of steering behavior towards a better society rather than looking at it as purely “punishment”.
- vmception 6y ago> Anyone who lived under Edward I. Koch’s mayorship would agree that the broken window theory has merit. There are subsequent studies that suggest it didn't have as much merit as people imagined it did.
- mc32 6y ago“Not as much” doesn’t mean no merit. Even empty storefronts with no broken windows, if they dominate, take out the spirit of a location. Cities could, if they have resources, lease and use them for community centered services to entice some form of vibrance.
- vmception 6y agoWhich is why I wrote not as much instead of no merit. Words.
- apotecaryman 6y agoWhat is your definition of broken windows policing? When I google it, it says: "The broken windows theory is a criminological theory that states that visible signs of crime, anti-social behavior, and civil disorder create an urban environment that encourages further crime and disorder, including serious crimes." Now when you look at a riot such as the one in Minneapolis and in in prior cases such as California 92, how do you not see a further increase in crime and disorder once a subset of the population realizes that something seems to have gone unpunished? Even in smaller cases such as graffiti, an area tends to have a higher rate of graffiti the more graffiti there is in the area. The reason is simple, others came before and managed to do, opportunistic individuals with broken morals will abuse it.
- kaitai 6y agoAs someone from the Twin Cities, the opportunists here include white supremacists and outside agitators as well as local folks who took advantage of this loss of control. We had hockey riots too, & burned cars, in 2003 and 2014; no one made your argument there. We have a strong civic community here, and there are many more protestors taking care of each other, taking care of small businesses, and trying to keep the peace here. Yes, sh*& is going down here. We need change. The arrest of Omar Jimenez of CNN on camera accurately represents the situation for black men in Minneapolis. This is not about broken windows or graffiti. This is about George Floyd, Philando Castile, Jamar Clark, the fact that Devin Chauvin who killed George Floyd has been involved in multiple shootings and has never been prosecuted -- even after killing other people. That's your broken window, hah.
- zaksoup 6y agoIf you had scrolled down a bit on the Wikipedia article you might have found a rather well cited section that shows the causal link you imply here is extremely weak in follow-up studies. Sure you can say intuitively "if people see crimes go unpunished they may be inclined to commit further crimes" but the problem is that policing is an aggregate function of society, not an individual one. Communities rightfully question the efficacy policing petty property crimes with the total value of white collar crime vastly dwarfs the value of property crime. Often these white collar criminals are connected to or directly the cause of economic devastation in these communities, yet the communities themselves are the ones who bear the brunt of over-policing and the violence that causes.
- hedora 6y agoI’ve had no luck calling the police. Certified crazy friend wanted to shoot people at a synagogue. Family, friends, employer and psychiatrist agree he needs to be taken in? Nothing. Witnessed a person hit my car, give them the license plate? Nothing. Multiple burglaries in a remote area, with video footage and time stamps? Do they run a Google location tracking query after I point out they can and should? Of course not. Hand them the address of a repeated trespasser that’s threatened to damage my property, with video footage? They’ll enforce the law ($500 fine next offense, misdemeanor after that) if I spend $10k’s on a civil case, and the court orders them to do so. If I do nothing, they’ll encumber the deed to my property with a prescriptive easement for the jackass. Nightly drug deals in my back yard keep waking me up? They’ll have a patrol car drive by in 5 hours. That time the DMV received, recorded but failed to process my smog check? >$1000 in fines, and two days missed work. Once a black lady ran a light in a car I‘d sold. That was the crime of the century! They tracked me down and threatened to take legal action against me if I didn’t say who she was. I had no idea; it went to an auction house. It took multiple phone calls and two letters to prove I hadn’t had a sex change and somehow switched races. They “resolved” it by saying they’d either drop charges, or they’d assume I waived my right to trial and issue an arrest warrant. They said there was no way for me to tell me which of those things they did. It’s been a few years, and no one’s arrested me. I guess I’m good? Each incident happened in a different city in the SF bay area.
- 8ytecoder 6y agoHere I was thinking police not enforcing pedestrian safety rules and not even moving a finger to find my lost bike was a big deal. I feel you. I have dealt with police in two countries and it’s the same story. There are very few service minded individuals in the department.
- annoyingnoob 6y agoThe DMV is a whole different kind of crazy.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoFor those who would like to learn about the origins of Broken Windows, which the parent mentions - Hidden Brain (NPR) has a great episode on Broken Windows[1]. [1]https://www.npr.org/2016/11/01/500104506/broken-windows-policing-and-the-origins-of-stop-and-frisk-and-how-it-went-wrong https://www.npr.org/2016/11/01/500104506/broken-windows-poli...
- downerending 6y agoI've called the police one time in my life. The arriving officers were a bit wary and perhaps a little dim, but they ultimately helped save my friend's life. I would have been in trouble without them.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoI do not want to sound flippant, but does that mean that crime did not happen, because it sounds like we are now deciding that 'broken window' is not an issue worth pursuing.
- ipnon 6y agoA rather terrifying statistic I remember from investigating crime in Chicago: 50% of homicides are brought to justice in Chicago, but the remaining half are not normally distributed in terms of crimes per criminal. ~50 people are responsible for half of the unsolved homicides in Chicago. I am not going to be able to provide a direct reference for this claim. My point is that the rate of severe crimes can be efficiently diminished by targeting professional criminals and the networks that enable them. Policing minor crimes is counterproductive because the harmful side effects of policing (racial and social injustice, legal costs, adversity between police and citizens) are greater than the benefit to the community of removing misdemeanors like vandalism and drug use. You might say that broken windows policing is not Pareto efficient.
- Gibbon1 6y agoA thought of mine is the police use prosecution of minor crimes and harassment of identifiable groups as a proxy for harder to enforce and more serious crimes. I think it's a fallacy with very negative outcomes.
- foolmeonce 6y agoI think it is entirely different to handle reports of misdemeanors by the public with integrity and to attempt to catch misdemeanors in progress with active surveillance. The first can get you trust needed to identify your major criminals, the second creates an alliance of presumed criminals that shares little with the police.
- j88439h84 6y ago> ~50 people are responsible for half of the unsolved homicides in Chicago. What does this mean? If we know who did them, how are they unsolved?
- yters 6y agoi bet if police stop responding to 911 calls altogether then crime complaints will drop to zero
- minikites 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tsHcLIxg8KA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tsHcLIxg8KA
- gotoeleven 6y agoYeah in fact what they should do is punish the people who report the crimes, that would definitely drop the rate of crime reporting! You get what you optimize for.
- yters 6y agosimplest approach to eliminate crime is to get rid of the law no law = no crime not sure why no one else has ever realized this guess i am a genius
- craftinator 6y ago> Yeah in fact what they should do is punish the people who report the crimes This happens surprisingly often in the USA. I won't bother inundating HN with all the sources that a simple search will turn up, but aside from many reports of this happening, I have first-hand experience. I called the non-emergency police number because my neighbor's large dog had escaped and was kind of freaking out the neighborhood, growling at people it didn't know, barking at people through their house windows, etc... Police showed up 3 hours later, issued me a ticket for being parked 14 inches from the street curb, gave me a verbal warning about "showing more respect" to police when I re-stated the reason for calling them, then left without doing anything about the dog. Protect and Serve.
- thejynxed 6y agoThey pretty much have in parts of Baltimore, Philadelphia, NYC, and San Francisco.
- mikem170 6y ago>So, with the drop in relatively low-level police activity, what happened to serious crime in the city? The scientists found that civilian complaints of major crimes dropped by about 3% to 6% during the slowdown. Is 3-6% a significant enough difference to draw conclusions from? I wonder what is the normal variation in major crime complaints from one six week window to another?
- f00_ 6y agoyeah, it's not like this is a randomized experiment so there might be confounding factors. Observational studies aren't very useful for determining causation in general
- Simulacra 6y agoFollowing the murder of George Floyd, and the violence between citizen and police, I can see the police as a body withdrawing from "policing" period. After Freddy Gray's death, police stopped responding to calls form west Baltimore. We want them to respond to our needs but they're not going to come if people are going to shoot at the squad cars.
- minikites 6y agoYou are badly misunderstanding the issue and why people are up in arms.
- aquilaFiera 6y agoMalcom Gladwell addresses why proactive policing doesn't work at length in his book "Talking to Strangers". He refers to it as Kansas City style policing. Highly recommended.
- Izkata 6y agoI'd like to dub this "the Batman effect", but unfortunately it's already taken. It's a pretty common theme in the various incarnations of Batman that the primary reason Gotham City gets so many crazies is that the existence of Batman either attracts or indirectly/accidentally creates them.
- jmilloy 6y ago> we find that civilian complaints of major crimes (such as burglary, felony assault and grand larceny) decreased during and shortly after sharp reductions in proactive policing This is based on a pay-walled article that would be interesting to read. One major question that is unanswered in the abstract is whether a reduction in complaints is a useful correlate for reduction in crime. That is just something I don't anything about. Another question, that I would bet is answered in the article, is if civilian complaints of petty crimes increased or decreased after reductions in proactive policing. Lastly, the results suggest that proactive policing may not deter major crimes as it is meant to. Do the authers (or others) think this is because proactive policing causes an increase in major crime? Or does it just distract police from major crime? Or is it something else entirely?
- mnm1 6y agoWhen you arrest or kill a drug dealer, many others come in and fight for his place creating more violence. This is known and shown by studies and every cop's experience ever. They know this and yet they still do it, causing more violence and chaos on the streets, more deaths and more imprisonments. They support keeping things criminalized because many would likely be out of a job, or certainly out of an easy, low-risk job in favor of more difficult, actually useful police work. Police knowingly and intentionally increase violence in the communities they police. Until we stop criminalizing normal activities, this won't change. The stupidity of the drug war is now clear for all to see. In Colorado and other states you can peacefully walk into a store and buy weed. In a state like Alabama you might spend years in jail for a joint. The stupidity, inhumanity, and cruelty is glaring and disturbing. And the system of violence that is perpetrated by this situation in non-legal states and as regards to other illicit substances starts and ends with the police. They arrest people for breaking windows or some other such nonsense, then throw them in prison, give them a record, and basically turn them into real criminals since they no longer have a chance to contribute to society. The less involvement the police have, the better off society is. Does it make sense to criminalize jaywalking? We're giving the police a reason to potentially kill someone for crossing the street at the same time. That goes for every petty crime out there. Every single crime that police enforce might require that police use deadly force. Do we want to use deadly force for weed smokers, jaywalkers, and single cigarette sellers? Because that's what the 'broken windows' policy of idiocy advocates. Then we wonder why cops are kneeling on people's necks or choking them out for selling a single cigarette? Because as a society, we condone this and we especially encourage it be done to minorities through the laws we pass, the police we hire, and the rules and procedures we approve for enforcement.