10 ms·
How many people did it take to build the Great Pyramid?
- burlesona 6y agoThis is very cool to see. The main takeaways for me were: 1. It's easy to underestimate what is possible when you limit thinking to a short timescale. I think of the cathedrals, temples, mosques, etc. that have been built all over the world, where the people who started the work knew they wouldn't live to see it finished, but that didn't dissuade them. Or conversely, it's easy to overestimate the difficulty of something if you are too constrained by thinking in terms of finishing it relatively quickly. 2. Building things does make it easier to build things - and conversely, not building things makes it harder. There is a lot of architectural stuff in our world today, particularly fine masonry and woodwork, that is still common because so much of it was made up through the 1930's or so, but which is actually quite difficult to produce today because most of the skilled labor and the industry that supported it is gone. This also reminded me of an article about scientific glasswork, which is similarly dying out[1], and of course more familiar to the HN crowd we know about old technology that was once common and now is difficult to replicate or maintain. Lots to think about. 1: https://www.latimes.com/local/education/la-me-caltech-glassblower-20160613-snap-story.html https://www.latimes.com/local/education/la-me-caltech-glassb...
- mehrdadn 6y ago> I think of the cathedrals, temples, mosques, etc. that have been built all over the world, where the people who started the work knew they wouldn't live to see it finished, but that didn't dissuade them. That's mind-boggling. Why would building a cathedral/mosque/temple take longer than a lifetime (or half)?
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 6y agohttps://history.howstuffworks.com/european-history/notre-dame-cathedral.htm https://history.howstuffworks.com/european-history/notre-dam...
- mehrdadn 6y agoAh, thanks for the pointer! I just Googled and got this explanation: https://www.quora.com/Why-did-it-take-nearly-200-years-to-build-Notre-Dame-when-Hagia-Sophia-took-only-5-years/answer/Pat-Sullivan-32 https://www.quora.com/Why-did-it-take-nearly-200-years-to-bu...
- obastani 6y agoNot an answer to your question, but the Sagrada Famila [1] began construction in 1882, and is projected to be completed around 2030. It's an immense (and beautiful) structure. Just want to point out that it's not just a matter of the buildings being built a long time ago; this kind of long-term construction is still happening today.
- mehrdadn 6y agoI... just can't wrap my head around this. Is it that they actually take that long with enough people, or they have too few people working on them?
- readams 6y agoThey're specifically using old-style techniques to build it, and doing a sort of fund-as-you-go structure where donations finance the construction. This is combined with the fact that the building is really complicated and every block has to be custom-carved into a unique shape. There's also likely an element of not really wanting it to be done since the construction itself is a big part of the draw of the building for tourism.
- close04 6y agoAnd yet the author of the present article would simply judge it by weight and say "with certainty" it must have taken only a fraction of the time.
- teruakohatu 6y agoFunding but also they are to an extent a giant work of art, adding more people does not produce a better work of art.
- ALittleLight 6y agoI hadn't heard of it, it seen pictures, until we went to see it in Spain. The building is absolutely mind boggling. The sort of thing that makes you proud to be a human. When you see it, the timeline starts to make sense.
- fouc 6y agoYou might enjoy Ken Follet's novel "The Pillars of the Earth", it touches on the notion of spending a lifetime to build a cathedral.
- smabie 6y agoI mean, look at Petra. Some of that stuff must have taken centuries.
- goto11 6y agoSome cathedrals took centuries to complete, but mostly because of long gaps in active work due to lack of funds or interest. Furthermore cathedrals were often build iteratively - e.g. someone finances a new tower to add to an existing centuries old building.
- watwut 6y agoYou run out of money, wars happen, corruption happen, things get finished later.
- est31 6y agoThere is a star trek episode where they encounter a civilization which has built a benevolent AI a long time ago and has since lost capabilities to do much more than give commands to the AI. Our society has managed to write down some things like math for example so our knowledge as species won't be lost if mathematicians suddenly died. But it's harder to find permanent storage for the more skills based human activities like the woodworking you mention. To give another example, the Saturn V rockets were built by a generation of metalworkers who had honed their skills in the manufacturing plants of world war 2. The plans for the rocket engines are still preserved but back then a plan was just a rough guideline. In the details, each single engine was hand-tailored to the individual rocket. Nowadays, stuff is far more automated and plans are highly precise. Thus Nasa couldn't just get the plans out of the cabinet and build new Saturn V rockets or even just put their engines into new rockets. I wonder if we are better in preserving our heritage than we used to be. Which information about the manufacturing process of one of today's cars will be usable in 100 years? Will they be able to build computer chips like we did?
- soperj 6y agoSometimes writing it down means very little. Like Perelman's Poincaré conjecture solution. It took some of the best mathematicians years to even prove it being correct.
- blackrock 6y agoDidn’t the Egyptians write it down? But we still have no idea how to understand their hieroglyphics. Or how they even figured out their math.
- rrmm 6y agoSome light info on it: https://www.storyofmathematics.com/egyptian.html https://www.storyofmathematics.com/egyptian.html
- bingerman 6y agoI don't think they proved the correctness, just read it very thoroughly and were convinced by Perelman's reasoning.
- downerending 6y agoNot the same kind of scientific glasswork, but there were a couple (?) of guys at Harvard that produced a large number of educational models of various biological things, using glass. Worth visiting if you ever go there. https://hmnh.harvard.edu/glass-flowers https://hmnh.harvard.edu/glass-flowers
- necubi 6y agoThis is echoed in a fascinating r/AskHistorians comment I read recently [0]. The question was about how the Romans forgot how to make concrete in the late empire. I highly recommend reading the whole thing, but the gist is: as the empire became poorer, demand for huge building projects (typically funded by the state) declined. Eventually, after a couple hundreds years, the tradition was lost entirely. Losing knowledge like this was much easier in earlier eras when fewer people were literate. Trade knowledge would be passed down via apprenticeships and rarely written down. So it only takes one generation of the apprenticeship system breaking down for the knowledge to be lost entirely. (Also, for anybody unfamiliar with r/AskHistorians, it's one of the best corners of the internet! Professional historians provide in-depth answers to random questions about history.) [0] https://old.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/gntlr8/how_did_the_late_romans_just_forget_how_to_make/frc9cc9/ https://old.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/gntlr8/how_d...
- ssivark 6y ago> Losing knowledge like this was much easier in earlier eras when fewer people were literate. The thing is, there are many aspects to doing things which can’t be written down. So even today, the one generation concept is meaningful. There is a deep “use it or lose it” spirit in biological systems. We might think of ourselves in primarily literate/rational terms, but that’s far from the truth.
- Mirioron 6y agoNowadays we have video which can cover a large part of things that can't be written down. It doesn't cover all of it though, but it can get pretty close.
- nullc 6y agoIf you can manage to preserve access to the video. "Sorry, we lost all knowledge of how to build those during the great content-id wars of 2029."
- 6y ago
- pvg 6y agoI think of the cathedrals, temples, mosques, etc. that have been built all over the world, where the people who started the work knew they wouldn't live to see it finished, but that didn't dissuade them. I wonder whether that's not really more the exception rather than the rule - some famous cathedrals just took a long time. But lots of huge projects were completed in one or two decades or less - the pyramids, the Coliseum, the Taj Mahal, the Pantheon, Hagia Sophia, etc.
- Aeolun 6y agoKind of makes sense, since the person that commissions these things generally wants to see them completed in their lifetime.
- quxbar 6y agoThis is great! Begs the next question - how efficiently did the Egyptian government organize labor?
- Fjolsvith 6y agoThey hadn't invented unions at that time.
- rrmm 6y agoThat's a bit of an understatement.
- ncmncm 6y agoThey had only just invented onions, give them time.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoWas Moses the first recorded union rep? A plague of frogs is one up on work-to-rule.
- Fjolsvith 6y agoI don't think so. The pyramids were built between 2589 and 2504 BC, while Moses wasn't born until 1393 BC.
- 8bitsrule 6y agoI'd be interested in seeing whether some of the new dating methods could be used to scientifically date the Pyramids. Because there's more than one reason to think it might be -a lot- older than 4,600 years ... an anecdotal number. For one easy reason, you don't just build one from scratch without a lot of experience. A lot of artifacts of that period are -way- too impressive for the same reason. Where's the evidence for prior art of that calibre? And when will the chemistry of the blocks be analyzed? Were they cut (how) or manufactured (how)? I haven't seen the book delineating these studies; if it doesn't exist, how long should the present fairy tales?
- xenadu02 6y agoThere is plenty of evidence for earlier pyramid efforts, including much smaller ones and even some botched efforts. You seem to be implying some kind of "aliens did it" conspiracy theory but there is ample evidence that empires lasting thousands of years are easily able to build such structures. There's nothing all that complicated about it and we don't need aliens to explain it.
- Ozzie_osman 6y agoThe timelines are pretty well-established. https://www.ancient.eu/timeline/pyramid/ https://www.ancient.eu/timeline/pyramid/ It did take decades of years for pyramid-building to improve (possibly longer), but the date of the Great Pyramids is known with pretty high confidence and aligns with particular dynasties and rulers. The big ambiguity is around the actual techniques that were used to transport the material and build the pyramids, not around the timeline.
- AlotOfReading 6y agoArchaeologists realized long ago that there were other methods of dating things and that they corroborate. IEEE isn't exactly a cutting edge archaeology journal, so hopefully we can forgive them for not explaining this in a popsci piece. There's also about a century of prior art demonstrating the evolution of pyramid construction from Djoser through Khufu. It's fine to question popsci narratives, but it seems a bit premature to call them fairy tales before you've looked at the relevant wiki page.
- 6y ago
- blackrock 6y agoIt must’ve been built by aliens. Since we can’t figure out the math behind it. Some inner chambers seems to point at the Osiris star cluster. Kidding.. I wonder if an ancient engineer discovered a more useful purpose for the pyramids. Like channeling salt water into the chambers, to create a battery somehow, in order to create an electric field, which was used to power some kind of light bulb at the top. So the pyramid ended up becoming some type of light tower, to illuminate the darkness. This indeed, would be fascinating stone aged technology, that can last for a few millennia. Note, we can’t find the light bulb at the top, to support this fictional theory, because it got looted at some point in history. Maybe it was a precious diamond or something. LOL..
- Cactus2018 6y agoI recently learned about the highly polished white limestone 'cladding' or 'casing' stones Wikipedia says: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Pyramid_of_Giza#Casing_stones https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Pyramid_of_Giza#Casing_s... > Casing stones > At completion, the Great Pyramid was surfaced with white "casing stones"—slant-faced, but flat-topped, blocks of highly polished white limestone.... Visibly, all that remains is the underlying stepped core structure seen today.[citation needed] In 1303 AD, a massive earthquake loosened many of the outer casing stones, which in 1356 were carted away by Bahri Sultan An-Nasir Nasir-ad-Din al-Hasan to build mosques and fortresses in nearby Cairo.[citation needed] Many more casing stones were removed from the great pyramids by Muhammad Ali Pasha in the early 19th century to build the upper portion of his Alabaster Mosque in Cairo, not far from Giza.[citation needed] ...
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y ago> If a work year consists of 300 days, that would mean almost 18,000 man-years, which, spread over 20 years, implies a workforce of about 900 men. While the analysis is interesting, I think the 300 working days a year is too long. Likely, work on these types of public projects was mostly done during the flood season, which was around 4 months (120 days [0]) so maybe 100 work days at best, so the calculations for required workers should probably be multiplied by 3. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Season_of_the_Inundation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Season_of_the_Inundation
- lorthemar 6y agoTotally agree. I was searching for this comment. It's extremely unlikely that a work year was 300 days thousands of years ago. But I don't think the workers had weekends either. So, might be more than 100 days but still should be roughly 3 times than the article shows.
- onion2k 6y agoI don't think the workers had weekends either. Weekends didn't exist until the Industrial Revolution, which was ~4300 years after the pyramids were finished.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoIsn't the sabbath a "weekend"?
- onion2k 6y agoI think the term 'weekend' has connotations of not being religious, but sure, maybe weekends were invented earlier than the Industrial Revolution if the definition is generalized to 'a day when you don't work at the end of the week'.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- octabond 6y agoYou are assuming optimal efficiency for each human. Don't think that was the case
- SideburnsOfDoom 6y agoRight. Energy analysis is cool, but it places a lower bound on the amount of work needed, that's all. If you're only counting energy needed to raise stones, then you're costing at zero a piece of stone, cut and transported to ground level near the pyramid. But that is hard work.
- Areading314 6y agoThis analysis ignores friction in the calculations for energy/manpower needed to construct the pyramid. I wouldn't put much stock into these results
- umvi 6y agoYeah they just calculate the potential energy as if workers can move limestone blocks with perfect efficiency in frictionless conditions. It wouldn't surprise me if it took 2-4x its potential energy (or more) to move any given block into place.
- idoubtit 6y agoThis analysis ignores many physical constraints and archaeological facts. It's an amusing exercise with little connection to the real world. Archaeologists are accustomed to this "pyramidomania" that almost always forgets to examine the facts before building up theories.
- pedrovhb 6y ago"First, assume all cows are spherical..."
- spyckie2 6y agoI love stuff like this. I've always wanted to find a community that collaborates to determine as much as possible the rough range of the total cost, either in man hours, dollar amount or other metrics, of things we see, know, and interact with every day. I think it is even more interesting if you try to estimate the cost of the research the thing depends on (which greatly scales up the complexity but also the fun of the exercise). For instance, what is the manhour cost of google.com historically? You can approach it in so many different ways - revenue analysis, # of employees in google search team over the years, or just guess at how much you would need to build google.com yourself today. Subreddit suggestions for different styles of this kind of activity: === /r/resetPrice Imagine that the infrastructure of the world has reset to the stone ages but we still retain all modern knowledge. What's the price, in man hours, of rebuilding things that we use every day and take for granted? What is the reset price of google.com? What is the reset price of Seattle? What is the reset price of a mechanical pencil? === /r/CTMH Cost in Total Man Hours What's the CTMH of the NY philharmonic orchestra playing for one evening? What's the CTMH of developing the entire iPhone phone line series, from original to current model? Also similar - /r/ETEB - Estimated total effort to build
- strokirk 6y agoI really hoped those would exist! But they don't. :(
- utopcell 6y agoAhem.. I'm just going to drop this link here on how the pyramids were _really_ built: https://youtu.be/TJcp13hAO3U https://youtu.be/TJcp13hAO3U
- jiggawatts 6y agoThat's rather... imaginative. Certainly, water played a role: much of the stone was shipped from quarries some distance away. It's also imaginable that they used canals to bring the blocks further inland, closer to the pyramid construction site. However, the near-vertical water tower and lock system would be a challenge to build today, let alone with the technology of the era. The pyramids were built before the widespread use of the wheel, and with soft copper tools, not bronze. They predate the invention of nails, as in the type used to join wood. For example, the planks of Khufu's ship were bound together with knotted ropes and its sails were moved without the aid of block and tackle, as this would have required wheels and axles! It's a sight to behold...
- noneeeed 6y agoThat was really interesting. Itr's weird to think of how many mundane technologies actually had to be invented, and how things would have worked before. The idea of a boat built without nails is kind of crazy.
- jiggawatts 6y agoBizarrely, for me, seeing Khufu's ship in person was far more memorable than the pyramids themselves. The pyramids are just... piles of rock. Sure, they're big and impressive, but no more. Without using your imagination, you can't see how they were built, what life was like at the time, or what the technology was like. The ship was incredible, to my eyes at least. My partner wasn't interested, but she never studied engineering! To my eyes it looked almost modern, yet absolutely bizarre to the point of being nearly alien, but only in the details. The joinery. The rope work. Things like that. I liken it to seeing a jumbo jet fly over for the first time. It's huge and impressive, like the pyramids. But to me, seeing an airport was the real wonder. All those planes with the engine nacelle covers open, showing the intricate tubing and turbine housings. The bizarre low trucks and specialised equipment that's used nowhere else. The fuel pump trucks that suck up jet fuel from underground pipes. The strange land of endless concrete. People waving glowing sticks. And so on and so forth. It's an entire "world" that's different from the normal world outside. You get to see the inner workings of the technology up close, not just a superficial end product from a distance. That's what it felt like to see Khufu's ship for me. I felt like I had stepped into the era of the Pharaohs.
- onion-soup 6y agoNow divide total number of blocks by 30 years and you get 1 multi ton block being laid every 9 minutes. The current theories are joke, this numbers don’t add up. Don’t be afraid to challenge the “academic” theories, as you see, there is no math behind them.
- Mirioron 6y agoI hear you! Combining your results with the scientists' we can only conclude that the Ancient Egyptians had some technology available to them that has been lost to time. Even modern cranes can't do that. Therefore the only other option is aliens!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ncmncm 6y agoIf they built the Great Pyramid in the advertised 20 years, that means placing a 2.5-ton block every 4th minute, 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. If they stopped at sundown, it's every 2 minutes. If they broke half the year to farm, that's one each minute. But let's guess they had enough surplus to work year-round; so, 2 minutes. Suppose they took 600 years, instead; then it's one per hour. Which is harder to imagine, cutting, moving, lifting and placing 30 blocks in every waking hour for 20 years, or placing one per waking hour, non-stop, for 600 years? Each seems less possible than the other. I don't know of any firm evidence for when any of the pyramids were built. We can guess that the bent and red pyramids were built first, but they could just as easily be poor copies attempted a thousand years later, or ten. There is a fluorescence technique to discover when a cut limestone face that has been covered for centuries was last exposed to sunlight, but I don't know of it being used on any Great Pyramid block. One would not expect Egyptologists to advocate for such a test, because only two outcomes are possible: they were far enough off to be embarrassed; or not, and it was useless. (Either way, better not.) They built these things with perfectly straight, slanting tunnels a few inches wide running from inner chambers almost to the surface, for no known reason. Some people say they point at certain mythologically important stars on equinoctal days, but I have not been able to get confirmation of that. One thing well established is that none of them were tombs. When somebody finally battered their way into each, maybe 4300+ years later, all the chambers were empty and unmarked. (Except one has an empty stone box in it big enough to be a coffin or bathtub.) There are lots of examples of 20-, 30-, 60-ton basalt boxes cut from living rock with perfect right-angled inside corners, and moved through funerary complex tunnels barely big enough. Take off the (10-ton) lid and they're empty. It's anybody's guess what they were for.
- idoubtit 6y agoParallelization is not a concept that appears around 2010 when low-end computers gained multiple cores. Most of the blocks were at the bottom levels, where it was easy to put them in place. Teams moving hundreds of blocks simultaneously wouldn't be surprising. This addresses the first point, and I don't want to react to what follows, especially the theory that all archaeologists are in a conspiracy to hide the truth.
- stormdennis 6y agoWhen King Edward I, suppressed the NW of Wales he had four large imposing castles built in a short period of time to dominate the region. Two of them were completed in less than a decade and work on the other two was started. They are still there to this day and are probably the most impressive structures in the region
- buro9 6y agohttps://cadw.gov.wales/visit/best-history/castles-and-town-walls-edward-i https://cadw.gov.wales/visit/best-history/castles-and-town-w...
- close04 6y agoThis is almost the literal exemplification of the classic "if 1 woman takes 9 months to give birth to a baby, 9 women will do it in a month". The math is interesting and a fun exercise of imagination. But it ignores so much and oversimplifies that it shouldn't really be seen as anything more than "fun". Which is still fine for an article that took no more than 25 minutes of work based on word count and expected typing speed.
- buran77 6y ago> we can say with some confidence how many people were required to build it When someone claims that "by appealing to simple physics" they can say "with confidence" how many people were involved in a construction from almost 5000 years ago I have to doubt anything that follows is more than pure speculation. The problem is too complex for simple physics to provide any relevant answer. The same simple physics would have us believe 14000 strong men could throw a tiny 1Kg object straight into orbit.
- habosa 6y agoThat was definitely interesting but doesn't feel fully thought out. That's how much energy it takes to move the blocks vertically into their position, ok. What about horizontal movements to bring the blocks from the quarry to a staging area to their final place? Also there doesn't seem to be any consideration of logistics time. Were the 900 men always perfectly positioned to apply their energy to the project? Did they not spend time and energy moving around the building site? Did they ever make a mistake and have to redo a section? This is a good starting estimate. As anyone who's ever worked on any project knows, the estimate is going to be way too optimistic. Also: I've been to Giza. It's hot and dry as all hell. Humans are going to be far from perfect labor machines in that climate.
- Balero 6y ago"Also: I've been to Giza. It's hot and dry as all hell. Humans are going to be far from perfect labor machines in that climate" The climate 4500 years ago was very different in this area, and the world in general. For Egypt and the middle east it was generally a little cooler, but much wetter. When we are looking back into history, even only a couple of hundred years it is important to remember that the climate, and geography was different. Climate shifts, rivers and coastlines move etc.
- close04 6y agoThe analysis is only about the effort to lift one cubic meter of stone to an arbitrary height a number of times until you reach the mathematical equivalent of a "pyramid's worth", and then divide this by the average human work capacity. That's it. No other theoretical or practical aspect was considered. No friction, no logistics, nothing else. The conclusion is that it took 900 men 20 years to lift one 2.6t cubic meter of stone to a specific height again and again. Does anyone considers this to be realistic for any construction project? Like estimating the Mona Lisa took 5s to paint based on the surface of 0.4 square meters. Or the Sistine Chapel ceiling took a couple of days and a really big brush. The fact that someone with such a CV [0] came up with this for the IEEE page as anything more than an exercise of imagination is very surprising for me. [0] https://spectrum.ieee.org/author/vaclav-smil https://spectrum.ieee.org/author/vaclav-smil
- westurner 6y ago> The potential energy of the pyramid—the energy needed to lift the mass above ground level—is simply the product of acceleration due to gravity, mass, and the center of mass, which in a pyramid is one-quarter of its height. The mass cannot be pinpointed because it depends on the specific densities of the Tura limestone and mortar that were used to build the structure; I am assuming a mean of 2.6 metric tons per cubic meter, hence a total mass of about 6.75 million metric tons. That means the pyramid’s potential energy is about 2.4 trillion joules. In "Lost Technologies of the Great Pyramid" (2010) and "The Great Pyramid Prosperity Machine: Why the Great Pyramid was Built!" (2011), Steven Myers contends that the people who built the pyramids were master hydrologists who built a series of locks from the Nile all the way up the sides of the pyramids and pumped water up to a pool of water on the topmost level; where they used buoyancy and mechanical leverage by way of a floating barge crane in order to place blocks. This would explain how and why the pyramids are water tight, why explosive residue has been found in specific chambers, and why boats have been found buried at the bases of the pyramids. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0045Y26CC/ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0045Y26CC/ There are videos: http://www.thepump.org/video-series-2 http://www.thepump.org/video-series-2 https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLt_DvKGJ_QLYvJ3IdVKXUUIZAsX0_QD-4 https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLt_DvKGJ_QLYvJ3IdVKXU... I'm not aware of other explanations for how friction could have been overcome in setting the blocks such that they are watertight (in the later Egyptian pyramids). AFAIU, the pyramids of South America appear to be of different - possibly older - construction methods.