15 ms·
China’s new plan to seize the world’s tech crown from the U.S
- ideals 7y agohttps://outline.com/pXuSZG https://outline.com/pXuSZG
- Arbalest 7y ago"...echoing objectives set forth previously in the Made in China 2025 program" In other words, this isn't a suprise, just that this is the latest push to fulfil the existing plan.
- magicsmoke 7y agoThis is going to answer a very important question for the future. Is American tech dominance the result of some magic cultural mojo born from American values that can't be replicated in a different cultural sphere, or is it something that can be replicated if you pump enough money into the right educational, institutional, and industrial structures while completely divorced from American culture. Since the fall of the USSR, the global zeitgeist has been that if you want to be a developed country, adopting American values in some form is necessary sooner or later. China is challenging this assumption and many developing countries will be watching the outcome.
- Hydraulix989 7y agoWhat do you mean by American values? Specific examples?
- magicsmoke 7y agoDemocracy naturally leads to competent and benevolent government, there are no circumstances under which human rights violations are ever acceptable, freedom of the individual takes priority over total benefit to the group, all individuals have the same intrinsic value regardless of their economic/social status, etc.
- wahern 7y ago> Democracy naturally leads to competent and benevolent government That hasn't been an American value for quite awhile, assuming it ever was.[1] Thus Reagan's famous quote: "The nine most terrifying words in the English language are 'I'm from the government, and I'm here to help'. [1] I'm willing to accept that it was for relatively brief but important periods, such as the 2-3 decades after WWII. The U.S. would still be a backwater were it not for moments where pragmatism and a shared sense of responsibility trumped cynicism and a reflexive fear of authority.
- magicsmoke 7y agoPerhaps I should have worded it as Democracy is the most tolerable form of government. No matter the disillusionment with Democracy in America today, the idea of adopting China's government is completely outside the Overton window in America. In other parts of the world, I'm not so sure.
- emiliobumachar 7y agoDisobedience. http://www.paulgraham.com/gba.html http://www.paulgraham.com/gba.html "Those in authority tend to be annoyed by hackers' general attitude of disobedience. But that disobedience is a byproduct of the qualities that make them good programmers. They may laugh at the CEO when he talks in generic corporate newspeech, but they also laugh at someone who tells them a certain problem can't be solved. Suppress one, and you suppress the other."
- mywittyname 7y agoThis is more of a young person thing, and only for specific personality types. And America is much less forgiving of disobedience today than it was, even just 20 years ago. Unless you come from a privileged group, run-ins with the authorities are not pleasant.
- fakedang 7y agoMaybe that's why you see China catching up - because America is falling back and suppressing disobedience.
- mac01021 7y ago> America is much less forgiving of disobedience today than it was, even just 20 years ago. Do you have any examples of this? I've always been american, but I was only 15 years old 20 years ago.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- blackrock 7y agoNo, that is the illusion. The primary thing you need is capital. Money, and lots of it. Then a service and manufacturing economy to support and sustain it. But the most important ingredient, is to be sovereign. And not get invaded for a hundred years, while you build out your economy and institutions. The last major war on American soil was the Civil War. You can achieve a lot of momentum, when war and invasion is not happening on your territory. Basically, don’t be poor. And have a lot of nuclear weapons to F! up your opponents, if they dare attempt to invade you. If you have all that, then everything else will fall into place.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI'm not sure this makes sense as an explanation of tech dominance. Tech is one of the least capital-intensive industries around. The capital required to build Twitter, or Facebook, or Google, arguably even the Internet, was available in many contemporary countries.
- sp527 7y agoEach of those companies solved hard tech problems to scale and also only managed to achieve that scale because of venture capital subsidization (prior to monetization). They also benefited from major human capital involvement. Looked at the right way, they were extremely capital-intensive endeavors. It just came into more play going from “1 to n” than “0 to 1”. In fact, I’m willing to bet that you’ll find lots of examples of 0 to 1s similar to Facebook and Twitter that preceded them but lacked the capital necessary to get to the same scale.
- ponker 7y agoTo have $2 billion available to invest in Facebook you need to have $200 billion laying around to invest in all the Webvans you find while looking for the next Facebook.
- flukus 7y ago> Is American tech dominance the result of some magic cultural mojo born from American values that can't be replicated in a different cultural sphere To an extent I think it was, nothing inherently American but openness and a certain amount of cowboyness has been a key differentiator in what tech thrives and what dies and authoritarian cultures/governments/organizations don't tend to favor openness. Look at the web verse what it could have been though something like minitel or AOL, look at linux vs commercial operating systems, unix itself and windows fostered a cowboy culture where everyone could write there own programs, bring there own hardware and generally and do what they want. For the most part I think American tech is abandoning those values anyway, walled gardens are becoming more common and getting more restrictive, open standards are yielding to proprietary services, users are being restricted in how they operate their own machines. That's something China can compete with and win, you wouldn't get IRC out of china but you would get slack, you wouldn't get Linux but you would get apple.
- Barrin92 7y ago>Is American tech dominance the result of some magic cultural mojo born from American values that can't be replicated in a different cultural sphere I'd question if that's even the case inside the US. America was industrialised on the back of the American System and Silicon Valley was built on top of defense contracts. Napoleon brought the first civil code to France and Germany's national education system is a result of Prussian militarism. In many countries that tell a story of some sort of Western transparency and laissez-faire culture it was arguably authoritarian structures that initiated reform not unlike those you find in Singapore or China today. There's this popular narrative today championed by people like Acemoglu of "extractive" and "inclusive" institutions with the latter leading to progress and the former being bad, but even in Western nations a significant amoung of progress was built by the former and inherited by the latter.
- zozbot234 7y agoLinux came from Finland, not the U.S. And there's quite a lot of underground "cowboy culture" in Chinese tech, though people will disagree as to whether that promotes good quality.
- 4cao 7y agoAmerica attracts top talent from all around the world. China has a lot of domestic talent but struggles to put it to good use, and does not really have a compelling proposition for anybody coming from the outside. This I think is the biggest differentiator and unlikely to change for the time being. American tech dominance is also predicated upon having a huge domestic market that is relatively uniform in terms of the business environment and easy to navigate. Start here and you have access to 330M potential customers. This is something that the EU/EEA is only struggling to become: it's mostly still separate national markets there. China has the same advantage America had as well, and an even larger population to start with. America has well-oiled financial markets that are good at allocating capital. In China it's the government doing the allocation, and the results have often been abysmal, e.g. technology investment funds being used to further inflate the property bubble in disguise. However, historically, many of the biggest technological breakthroughs in the US were associated with government-funded military projects. No reason why China could not replicate this in principle. Not sure where the "American values" fit here, it depends what you mean by that. If you meant entrepreneurial spirit and individualism then the Chinese are entrepreneurial and individualist too. If you mean liberty/freedom then these aren't only American values but more broadly the values of the European Enlightenment, and this is indeed another differentiator between China and the cultural West. Would be interesting to know what values you had in mind.
- klipt 7y ago> America attracts top talent from all around the world. The current administration seems to be trying hard to change this via travel bans etc. The one actually good idea that Trump floated in his campaign was meritocratic points based immigration ala Canada, but it seems that topic got dropped in favor of more attention drawing stunts like the border wall. > technology investment funds being used to further inflate the property bubble in disguise Same thing in Silicon Valley, and to a lesser extent many other US cities with good tech jobs.
- malandrew 7y ago> meritocratic points based immigration this is one of the main ideas that Ted Cruz has promoted.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 7y agoNo, it's not a matter of magic cultural mojo. Japanese tech was ascendant for a long time in the 1970s and 1980s, and arguably even today beats the pants off American tech in many areas like automobiles (until Tesla came along, at least). And while Japan has adopted/had some American values rammed down its throat post-WW2, it remains very different culturally: there's very little in common between a Silicon Valley startup and a Japanese megacorp.
- Dirak 7y agoPost WWII, Japan was able to differentiate itself from other developing nations in becoming a major economic center precisely because it was the first to adopt American ideas such as the free market and free enterprise. A free market and a lack of regulations is what enables America today to be center for innovation when it comes to technology. Likewise, an uptick in regulation explains why car manufacturing is a stagnant industry in the US. Just to drive the point, the downfall of Detroit coincides timeline-wise closely with the city becoming a union town.
- dannyw 7y agoThe example of Tesla being forced to stay closed is another one.
- winrid 7y agoJapanese automobiles are still much higher quality than Tesla's. But yes, Tesla is pushing boundaries.
- toast0 7y agoI don't think you can separate the educational etc structures from the culture. Another poster mentioned cowboyism, which I think is apt. The US culture reveres the rugged individual ideal, and the structures allow or encourage it. All the big US tech companies have an origin story with one or two people, often without traditional credentials, who turned a small idea into a big idea and a huge company. Usually not a lot of group glory, unless it's the five or ten people who left after building a big company and made their own bigger companies (see the traitorous eight that formed Fairchild and went onto form others companies; or the many video game companies starting with A formed by Atari employees such as Activision) You don't get innovation by doing what everyone else is doing. You get it by doing stuff that seems crazy and turning out right.
- unishark 7y ago> Since the fall of the USSR, the global zeitgeist has been that if you want to be a developed country, adopting American values in some form is necessary sooner or later. China is challenging this assumption and many developing countries will be watching the outcome. Imitating the leader is just common sense if you want to emulate their success. China has been doing it bigtime also. Central planners can do a fine job of catching up once the path is obvious. Train people with these skills and have them build these products. Just watch the news to learn how. But even if they take over their targeted fields, US tech will move on to new ones. To lead means to figure out what to do next, before it's the biggest thing in SV already.
- blackrock 7y agoIt is much easier, when you have a lot of money, and available capital. And especially the ability to print money. It also helps a lot, if your country got that initial seed capital, from ill-gotten gains, and spoils of war.
- oillio 7y agoAlternative answer: America's geography makes all the important things easy, leaving us the resources to take risks and innovate. We have some of the best farmland in the world. With a river system to feed it water and easily transport goods. As well as a relatively flat landmass to facilitate transportation of people and goods. Add to that the largest energy deposits in the world, and nearly every other natural resource needed to run a modern economy. We have it pretty easy. A highly inclusive democratic society is just the cherry on top that pulls it all together. And BTW- Chinda does not come out very well on any of those metrics. They are a massive net importer of food and energy, for instance. That makes it much harder for them to come out ahead in a global economic shock. Say one brought on by a global pandemic.
- raducu 7y agoBy no means trying to be racist or dismiss the natives, but the geography of North America surely did not change since white man came. Which clearly shows culture is probably just as important as geography.
- oillio 7y agoThe pre-industrial world was a very different place than where we live now. Back then, technology and information gave you a massive advantage. Nowadays information moves relatively freely. Also, there were some extenuating circumstances. An epidemic that wipes out 90% of your population makes it pretty hard to compete.
- readarticle 7y agoIn the sense that “being exposed to the literal rest of humanity’s innovations” is culture, yes. Anything and everything had to be independently developed in the Americas prior to contact due to isolation, the white man backwater of Europe got to ride the coattails of R&D across the entire Eurasiafrican supercontinent for millennia, as a comparison. For a concept like a wheel to spread from, say, Northern China to Southern Spain, they could literally just roll on over.
- enaaem 7y ago
- OnlineCourage 7y agoJared Diamond, who is much more researched than anyone else commenting here, has written a lot on this topic, and briefly stated - it has more to do with a society's capacity to receive and process outside ideas. It's less about American culture and more about the fact that America has been for the most part an open society, but more so American metropolitan society and not America as a whole.
- blackrock 7y agoA crisis is the best time to spend a ton of money. Fascinating. If they succeed, then China will advance into a high tech economy full of computer programmers and electrical engineers, and AI Computer Scientists. They want to build out the future digital city, so their citizen can live and interact in it.
- anthony_doan 7y ago> They want to build out the future digital city, so their citizen can live and interact in it. When they started Golden Shield Project they built it for monitor and surveillance iirc. Forgive me if I'm skeptical of your view. I do welcome more competitions between companies/countries which will hopefully lead to consumers enjoying the benefits.
- blackrock 7y agoWell, if you want to take that angle, then are you aware that you’re already being actively monitored by the Patriot Act, and the NSA, and a host of other unknown government programs out there? Are you complaining about these, or out there protesting against them?
- jjcon 7y agoWith all that false equivalence and whataboutism you must be real fun at parties.
- Proven 7y agoChina government has a much bigger problem: where their manufacturers can sell that stuff. It's highly unlikely that developed countries will continue to welcome subsidized products, some (I'm being generous) of them based on stolen intellectual property.
- robert2020 7y agoFinally, a Great Leap Forward!
- godzillabrennus 7y agoI wonder how much democide this will result in.
- panaffa 7y agoI think it's totally going to happen because China has the talent and scale to pull it off.I do think it'll be inferior to the open global tech ecosystem that benefits from open idea sharing
- cvaidya1986 7y agoNah
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- redis_mlc 7y agoPG wrote an essay on this in 2006: http://paulgraham.com/siliconvalley.html http://paulgraham.com/siliconvalley.html I think the summary is that SV is a unique confluence of education, freedom, commerce, funding, population, laissez-fair business, military and worker rights. The closest I've seen to this is Toronto, though startup investment is on a miniscule scale compared to SV. Toronto may have an advantage in the future because health care is free there. (Israel also, and the town where Skype came from in Estonia?) For those outside SV, you can talk investors into funding years of development and marketing based on just an idea. At first it seems crazy, but if the market is there, it works.
- oillio 7y agoYeah, SV had a lot of factors that needed to be just right for it to be successful. But we only need one SV. Once the model is proved out, it will naturally spread the seeds of startup culture to other cities. Like VC's drifting in the wind. The socio-economic soil of the transplants doesn't need to be nearly as fertile as the first location. It is taking a while, but the model is definitely spreading. Most every major city has a startup scene these days, and a government looking to nurture it.
- redis_mlc 7y agoWe're not seeing that for various reasons, often insurmountable ones. The Boston area has draconian employee IP ownership agreements, so that gives California a huge advantage. Some European countries require pre-payment of pensions, preventing start-ups from even forming. PG's essay was published 14 years ago, yet no city council seems to have adopted it as a checklist.
- scarmig 7y agoIn some ways, the tier one cities in China are more advanced than their Western counterparts. E.g. mobile payment platforms are ubiquitous, app-mediated delivery of food is profitable and sustainable, taxi companies and bikes are more accessible. The last time I was in a cafe, all I had to do was scan a QR code, select some items on a menu, and press a button to pay and have it delivered to my table. The tech ecosystem has evolved in a very different way than the US, but not at all in an obviously worse way: I'd expect Tencent and Alibaba to outperform the US tech giants over the next ten years. It's mostly insularity that makes Americans think that China is massively backwards technologically. The biggest issue moving into the future is the national government's hostility toward foreigners, even foreign professionals. Even then, though, a billion people gives you a lot to work with.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- winrid 7y agoYou had to scan a QR code?? :) When I was in China this year there were places where you paid just by scanning your face (this was for street food....)
- gruez 7y agoI doubt it's used as a primary means of identification. Apple's faceid has trouble identifying some siblings and twins. I can't imagine how many impossible-to-discern faces there are in a country with a billion people.
- eunos 7y agoI saw already on TikTok someone utilized Alipay face payment while wearing a mask. So I assume the Computer Vision is quite good.
- gruez 7y agoI'm not sure whether that proves anything or not. It could be a tech demo or publicity stunt, for instance. If anything, if the first time you're hearing about it is through a tiktok video, rather than some sort of press release or news story, makes me think it's not a real production system.
- neonate 7y agohttps://archive.md/eEzUa https://archive.md/eEzUa
- slumpt_ 7y agoUnder their present government? lol
- edwinyzh 7y agoIf the goal ever reached (personally I'm confident in the long run, but not sure about the time frame), it must be the present government. Why, because CCP represents the majority of the people, not the capitalists.
- slumpt_ 7y agoI don’t agree that the CCP represents the majority of the people. I think it actively handicaps a large subset too. The world won’t forget the Uighurs. The world won’t forget Li Wenliang. Some of the people are wising up. We’ll see.
- intopieces 7y agoChina takes the precise opposite path to the US. While the US pumps trillions into private hands to keep private enterprise afloat, China spends an equal amount on infrastructure, largely financed through debt. This is a smart move because your countries economy could collapse but the nation's financiers aren't able to repossess poured concrete, AI knowledge or wireless access points.
- raducu 7y agoThe problem never was repossessing debt. Fiat money, unlike gold, is all about direct resource allocation. Pouring trillions in bad corpoarate debt is just as bad as pouring trillions in inflating the housing market -- resources are poorly allocated and capital markets are bypassed. Bad debt is bad debt, it is equally destructive in the end.
- oillio 7y agoYou would be surprised as to how creative the repo man can get ;)
- OnlineCourage 7y agoConcrete has poor liquidity though both literally and figuratively so when it turns out you spent way too much money on concrete instead of agricultural development you are screwed. Also, US financiers are bondholders, meaning the public. The public reposessing corporations would mean nationalization, which...Chinas economy is already far more nationalized than the US.
- blackrock 7y agoApparently you’re not following the news lately. The Fed is buying up all the corporate junk bonds. And with all the impending bankruptcies, they’re probably a few steps away from buying company stock outright. You can sugar coat this all you want, but it is effectively nationalization.
- badrabbit 7y agoIt comes down to which country people prefer to live in. I suspect a lot of of foreign money will be leaving China soon, if they can keep peace and prosper without depending on the west,they stand a solid chance against the US. Make no mistake,the CCP has no intention of being self-contained, if you are not with them,you are against them. Their intention is hostile. The dramatic slow collapse of the US is what enables their success. Americans and foreigners no longer think it is the land of opportunities. Fears,divisions,mistrust,avoidable tragedies all over. In China they'll just suppress anything negative. They've already positioned themselves well for internal subversion of american government and society. I just hope things remain peaceful.
- scarmig 7y agoOne interesting thing is how much of a foil the US is to China and how it acts as a legitimizer. Whatever failings the CPC has, they can point to American government and make plausible claims that at least they aren't that incompetent. And no one's heard of any evidence to the contrary.
- baybal2 7y ago> I suspect a lot of of foreign money will be leaving China soon I do to, a giant portion of China's current account is operational capital of big multinationals. When they will start withdrawing money, Yuan will fall through the floor for a year, or two before rebalancing. This will give a great boost to China's exporters.
- badrabbit 7y agoBut can anything replace the west's unending consumer appetite? As big as they are, can their own people consume enough? I think a lot also depends on US elections.
- baybal2 7y agoThat's the question. Either China tries to grow more itself, or it will seek to boost trade with whomever is left in the non-aligned camp. Boosting own consumption didn't work much for China in the past Selling more to the few of its allies will not work either for the sane reason. China's only option is to do a Marshall Plan 2.0 in the developing world, and hope to dramatically reshape their economies, in hopes of them actually making these money, and just borrowing to buy Chinese trinkets.
- throwaway517365 7y agoI'm surprised nobody has mentioned interviews as a possible problem here. If you buy into the notion that coding interviews generate a lot of false negatives then there is a lot of talent that's underemployed. If that's the case, it wouldn't matter at the company level because they can afford false negatives, but it would matter a lot at the national level if there are a lot of people that are capable of much more than they are placed at. And even if it doesn't generate false negatives, the current hiring practices encourage people to not switch to newer roles: - Practicing leetcode takes a long time and you have to brush up on it every time you look for a new job - Coding projects often take a long time, 4-8+ hours - Multiple whiteboard interviews with the coding projects - Getting ghosted after submitting coding projects leading to burnout - Exclusively hiring people that know some very specific libraries or languages. It might only take a week or two to get up to speed on these. This encourages devs to devote a ton of their free time into learning new libraries that they might not even use just to land a job All of these could also discourage smart people from joining tech, since the high salaries aren't as high as they look when you factor in all of the extra time involved here, and some people don't want to sacrifice their leisure time for higher pay. From what I understand, the tech scene in Europe is bad exactly because they're way underpaid, so Europe has trouble attracting talent and getting people to enter into tech. China might have the same problems here, I'm not sure, but if these assumptions are true then just finding better ways to match people to jobs they'd perform the best at would give whatever nation a competitive edge.
- dirtyid 7y agoPentagon jargon filled interview discussing the future of optimizing the allocation human resources. I mean interviews. It hits on many of your points. https://warontherocks.com/2020/05/scoping-the-future-of-education-in-national-security-in-beyond/ https://warontherocks.com/2020/05/scoping-the-future-of-educ...
- LargoLasskhyfv 7y agoI can haz transcript? Channel capacity insufficient.
- bitxbit 7y agoChina can’t reach full potential with CCP in place.
- kilroy123 7y agoI've always felt the same way. If China were to adopt Democracy, the US would rapidly fall behind them.
- keiferski 7y agoThese discussions never seem to mention cultural soft power. Even if China were technologically superior to the US, they simply don’t have the cultural production that the US (and broadly, English-language media) has. American television and movies are known the world over, whereas I can’t name more than a handful of (non-Hong Kong) Chinese books/movies with global reach. I also don’t see Mandarin replacing English as the global default trade language. China would need to make its own NYC and Hollywood to begin to compete with this. Why is this relevant to tech? Because I think one could argue that many tech companies are built upon this cultural capital; it’s hard to imagine YouTube being successful globally without being the source of a ton of American-made video content.
- claudeganon 7y agoTikTok would like a word.
- keiferski 7y agoI seriously question the idea of comparing TikTok to the entirety of the American film and media industry. A better comparison would be to SnapChat.
- papeda 7y agoSerious question: is it a soft power win for China if most non-Chinese users don't think of it as a Chinese product?
- claudeganon 7y agoI would say so. For me (in the US), the amount of TikTok reposts on platforms like Twitter and Instagram seems to grow by the day and I rarely, if ever, see the concern about it being a Chinese app raised.
- papeda 7y agoMaybe there are two type of soft power. The first type is where a company makes a globally popular product. The second type is where a company makes a globally popular product that is recognizably "of its country". TikTok is the first, McDonalds/Hollywood/NBA is the second?
- lazylizard 7y agoWhat is it that china still cant do? 1. Metallurgy? Or just engines? Of all types.. Petrol diesel jet gas turbine steam turbine rocket etc 2. X86 or general computing cisc chips, maybe fpga n asics too. Maybe fab process tech as well. Or is it all silicon? Theres only licensed designs and last gen fab? 3. glass? Canon L, nikkor ed, any leica or zeiss.. 4. watches? Selitta miyota ronda.. We're not even talking a lange&sohne 5. Maybe some materials that dow dupont basf bayer akzo nobel are producing? Roche novartis sanofi? 6. ???
- SomeoneFromCA 7y agoThe only "Chinese" factory worth talking about is TSMC. And it is not on CCP's side of China.
- janekm 7y ago1. Apparently China can now make the balls for ballpoint pens (a metallurgical milestone, supposedly?): https://www.businessinsider.com/china-has-finally-figured-out-how-to-make-ballpoint-pens-2017-1?r=US&IR=T https://www.businessinsider.com/china-has-finally-figured-ou... 2. Fab process tech is pretty firmly in Dutch/Swiss/Japanese hands I think? In terms of fabs, SMIC is planning to start 7nm process this year, so about 3 years behind: https://www.tomshardware.com/uk/news/chinese-fab-smic-to-start-7nm-production-in-the-fourth-quarter-report https://www.tomshardware.com/uk/news/chinese-fab-smic-to-sta... 3. Anecdotally I visited an optics tradeshow in Shenzhen and it was pretty impressive what was available in advanced lenses for process control. But I'm no expert. Consumer camera lenses from China have been getting better and better. 4. It's not really hard to make mechanical watches if you have great CNC machines. Which are still dominated by Switzerland (Tornos), Germany (Kern), Japan (many, including Tsugami). Seagull have been making decent mechanical watches for >60 years... 5. China is pushing heavily on gene therapy which may turn out to be a big part of future medicine
- baybal2 7y ago> 3. glass? Canon L, nikkor ed, any leica or zeiss.. A big part of lenses in lithography steppers come from China, where they managed to beat Zeiss on cost/quality n-fold. The biggest, and most expensive lenses are still Zeiss' speciality.
- SomeoneFromCA 7y agoThis is not serious. US has lots and lots of aces in its sleeve: first - top quality universities, second - military research, thirdly - with moving TSMC factories in into US and probably asking/forcing Taiwan to not accept Chinese orders etc, US will keep its dominance for long.
- person_of_color 7y agoHow does one go long on China if they believe this?
- baybal2 7y ago> This is going to answer a very important question for the future. Is American tech dominance the result of some magic cultural mojo born from American values that can't be replicated in a different cultural sphere, or is it something that can be replicated if you pump enough money into the right educational, institutional, and industrial structures while completely divorced from American culture. My American comrades, I find you sounding rather alarmist. While American culture has little to do with it, China doesn't benefit a single bit from that. What matters is: 1. Rich, and talented people can afford to vote with their feet. China is not a nice place to live if you are one (and to be fair, not safe either.) 2. Deng Xiaoping has catastrophically undermined China on demography. The impact of 1 child police will be felt for many decades to come even if China will abolish demographic controls completely. 3. All rich, famous, and talented people I know in China are set to move out "someday," taking their capital, and brainshare with them. The USA is still the No. 1 destination for many Chinese.
- cannabis_sam 7y agoI’m far from an expert on China, but I’ve been under the impression that Deng Xiaoping was a generally positive influence from an economic perspective. I’ve kinda understood him as the one that stepped away from the planned economy of Mao (but I’m not really knowledgeable on the subject) What am I missing here?
- BeeBoBub 7y agobaybal doesn’t contradict you. Deng radically westernized parts of the Chinese economy, but he also enforced the one child policy. The economic effects of a small young generation supporting a large aging population is witnessed in Japan: a slow in growth if nothing else
- cannabis_sam 7y agoThanks! I wasn’t aware
- Fluid_Mechanics 7y ago
- mark_l_watson 7y agoGood article, a good call to arms. In my fields of interest (General AI, NLP, machine learning), Chinese research papers even just 20 years ago did not impress me much. Now, it worries me that some of the best published research from China gets translated too slowly. As a US citizen, I think that our ability vs. China’s ability to market high tech to places like Europe and the upcoming countries in Africa and elsewhere will be all important. I don’t think that President Trump’s approach is correct, BTW. We should invest more in education, research and infrastructure. He is right to push back, but much more moderately than he is doing. If our economic and tech “war” with China badly inconveniences other countries, then there will be blowback.
- yorwba 7y ago> some of the best published research from China gets translated too slowly. Could you give some examples of research where you had to wait a while for a translation to appear? I was under the impression that Chinese researchers still try to get their research published in international venues if they can, which means writing in English. Do they publish in Chinese somewhere else first? (Where?)