8 ms·
Yes. I've pointed out before that the enthusiasm for micropayments is from people who want to collect them, not those who want to pay them. Unlike credit cards
by Animats 7y ago
Yes.
I've pointed out before that the enthusiasm for micropayments is from people who want to collect them, not those who want to pay them. Unlike credit cards, which, when introduced, were easy to sell to buyers but hard to sell to merchants, since the merchant pays fees.
Cryptocurrencies are not a magic bullet here. The technology for preventing double-spending is incredibly inefficient and slow. Transaction costs are high. Right now, a Bitcoin transaction costs at least US$5. It's been as high as $20.
- robcohen 7y agoHave you seen how much a lightning transaction costs?
- EGreg 7y agoHave you? Can you get to the point?
- xur17 7y agoI have. For small payments, something like $0.0001 - $0.0005 is reasonable to expect.
- lawn 7y agoHave you seen how much opening a lightning channel cost? And opening a second channel, if you cannot find a route to your merchant? How about refilling your channel? Or how to close it, if a malicious node wants to steal your funds? That's right, it will all cost the same as a Bitcoin transaction. And how about receiving a lightning payment? Well... The merchant need to have a balance so he can accept your payment(!) Yes, that's another Bitcoin transaction right there. Or if you're lucky you can find someone who'll give you liquidity (for a fee of course). It's debatable if micropayments will ever take off, but lightning never will.
- BubRoss 7y agoEvery crytocurrency works well except for bitcoin, because its throughput was crippled to try to sell a centralized second layer owned by the company that weaseled their way into controlling the github and subreddit. I don't think any of them make micro payments easy right now, but throughput is not a real problem until transaction volume goes WAY up.
- zozbot234 7y agoExpanding throughput comes with severe tradeoffs: it increases the resource requirements for storing full blockchain history, and makes provision of mining services inherently more centralized in other ways as well. All things considered, a "second layer" with weaker trust guarantees may well be a preferable solution.
- BubRoss 7y agoAt the current scales, that is like saying a 128x128 jpg has big implications over a 64x64 jpg. Anyone who can watch a 240p youtube video can sync with bitcoin's limited blockchain. Not only that but most people don't need to and don't want to. What is bitcoin's throughput? 2MB every -10 minutes-? That's less than 3KB/s. Let's not do this whole dance where the real numbers never come up in all the fear mongering.
- TylerE 7y ago2MB every 10 minutes is 9GB/month.
- BubRoss 7y agoPlayStation games need to download more than that to install. Many steam games push updates bigger than that. A single 10TB hard drive would take over -92 YEARS- to fill up at that rate. And again, most people don't ever need to sync with the chain, they let servers do it for them. What is your point?
- 7y ago
- CalmStorm 7y agoSince it is a micropayment, it is possible (or acceptable) to accept payment with zero confirmation (in less than 10 seconds), as pointed out by Satoshi in the "Bitcoin snack machine" post: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=423.msg3819#msg3819 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=423.msg3819#msg3819 Yes, there is a risk of double-spending, but since this is a small amount, the cost of the attack may be higher than the benefit. The payment processor can also deploy more full nodes in different geographic locations to monitor and detect potential double-spending transactions in the transaction memory pool.
- fxtentacle 7y agoSince all you need is the software to generate your fake transaction with the right technical format, the cost of the attack can be zero. And then a million fraudulent microtransactions will add up. Of course, that would never happen in practice, because the Blockchain cannot handle a million transactions in any reasonable time frame.
- CalmStorm 7y agoIn case there are multiple conflicting transactions (for double-spending purpose), the network will only accept the first one and reject the rest. So the micropayment processor needs to wait for a few seconds when it receives the first transaction in the mempool. If no other conflicting transactions arrive, the first transaction will be acccepted. These few seconds give the first transaction big advantage over the double-spending ones, as it will most likely be included in the block. If the attacker sends the legit transaction and double-spending one at the same time, it will be detected due to the few seconds wait by the payment processor.
- paulmd 7y agothere's no protocol-level guarantee of that, both transactions are perfectly valid, signed transactions and it's purely dependent on the good behavior of node operators to reject these and in fact it is quite common to accept "double-spending" since that is really the only way to increase fees to push through a "stuck" transaction. Otherwise you have to wait an indeterminate (potentially forever) period of time until it exits the mempool of all network participants
- toohotatopic 7y ago>but hard to sell to merchants, since the merchant pays fees. There is a nice article which hopefully somebody can link that explains that visa was a success because merchants reduced their costs, too. They had to do informal credit accounting for all their clients who only paid for the purchased goods once a month. With visa, that accounting position, which could be a full-time employee, wasn't needed any more. Furthermore, they reduced their risk of clients defaulting on those micro loans.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 7y agoThe other thing credit cards did is reduce the risk of employee theft and even armed robbery. There is also a time savings. You don’t need employees counting and recounting the cash with witnesses when the cashier changes. Cash needs to be physically secured. A cash register full of credit card receipts is pretty worthless.
- mdszy 7y agoWhat? Cash didn't immediately disappear the moment credit cards came around.
- Jach 7y agoAs https://bitcoinfees.earn.com/ https://bitcoinfees.earn.com/ shows it's only $5 if you want your transaction confirmed the fastest (next block) for the cheapest. If you're willing to wait longer, you can still pay as little as 2-4 cents. And the average fee will probably go down again, the complete history is here: https://www.blockchain.com/charts/fees-usd-per-transaction https://www.blockchain.com/charts/fees-usd-per-transaction You're right about crypto not being a magic bullet though.
- nerdbaggy 7y agoBitcoin wants it to be expensive which is the problem
- core-questions 7y agoWhy would they want it to be expensive? Who gets the money?
- nerdbaggy 7y agoThe people running the miners. The higher the price the more money they make.
- thinkmassive 7y agoWhich means they’ll invest more to produce it, providing greater security to the network by making it more expensive to conduct a successful double spend attack. The users also want it to be secure. It’s a great alignment of incentives.
- nerdbaggy 7y agoYeah it just shows that there is incentive for prices to remain higher than lower
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kasey_junk 7y agoThe bigger issues for payments has nothing to do with the mechanics of moving money it’s the compliance, fraud, risk & customer support burden. None of those get easier with micropayments. If anything they get more difficult.
- mehrdadn 7y ago> I've pointed out before that the enthusiasm for micropayments is from people who want to collect them, not those who want to pay them. It might be just out of my ignorance for what the downsides are, but quite often I do wish I had a way to make micropayments, and I feel like lots of others do feel similarly.
- dn2k 7y agolighting network is perfect for micropayments
- paulmd 7y agolightning is really only cheap if you use a single centralized node as a payment provider, in which case you lose the benefits of decentralization. Otherwise you have to frequently open new channels as they become depleted of funds, which becomes quite expensive. and if you just leave one big channel with lots of money in it, then you end up with this fun situation! Hope you don't have a power outage... ever. https://coinspice.io/news/bitcoiners-warn-after-user-documents-losing-32000-in-btc-lightning-network-is-high-risk/ https://coinspice.io/news/bitcoiners-warn-after-user-documen...
- dpc_pw 7y agoYou can replenish channels, even multiple all at once, either through someone just paying you, or an on-chain payment through a "loop". And trading some decentralization for "performance" when dealing with small frequent payments is still better than other choices.
- knocte 7y agoEven if you use a centralized node, this kind of centralization in LN is not as bad as the typical "centralization problem" often referred to in cryptocurrency, because it doesn't mean counterparty risk. The worst thing that could happen is that you have to wait some time to get your money back. BTW a follow-up to the story you link is this one: https://cointelegraph.com/news/guy-who-lost-4-bitcoin-has-recovered-most-funds-a-month-later https://cointelegraph.com/news/guy-who-lost-4-bitcoin-has-re...
- api 7y agoI would pay them if it meant no ads and better content.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> not those who want to pay them Sample size of one, but I do! I frequently come across paywall'd articles I'd like to read. I'm not willing to add more subscriptions to my life, but it would be great if I could pay 25¢ just for access to the one article. If the payment process was easy, I'd use it a lot!
- thinkmassive 7y agoWhy try to use the base layer for micro payments? Lightning Network allows amounts down to the msat (millisatoshi).
- earthtolazlo 7y agoAnd it’s only eighteen months away!
- vinniejames 7y agoIt should get here just before cold fusion and AGI!
- knocte 7y agoIt works today.
- ChainOfFools 7y agolast I checked LN channels must be pre-loaded with funds, which would seem to kill the incentive to use them for spontaneous one-off BTC transactions between otherwise unaffiliated parties, which would be most of the transactions taking place. Who wants to put up $100 just to transact $10?
- thinkmassive 7y agoSounds like a good opportunity for a hub to connect micropayments merchants and consumers. Consumers can open a $10 channel, merchants open larger channels based on volume, and the hub provides rebalancing services for a tiny fee.
- ChainOfFools 7y agowell sure, why not. this decentralization thing is mostly a fiction anyway, might as well re-centralize our superficially p2p money network back into a p2h2p model, since that actually works.
- TACIXAT 7y agoI am incredibly excited about micropaymemts from a consumer perspective. I would pay 5 cents for every article I read. I won't pay a $5 subscription.
- enraged_camel 7y agoThe thing is -- and I realize the flaws in this argument before I even make it -- I would want to pay 5 cents for every article not to access it, but after I have read it. And it would have to be my decision: if I think it was a high quality article, well researched and reasoned about, perfect. If it turns out to be garbage though? I wouldn't want to pay.
- TACIXAT 7y agoI used to think that, then I realized I have also thrown change on the ground rather than carry it. If the article sucks that just hurts my chances of purchasing again from that author or publication.
- lazyjones 7y ago> If the article sucks that just hurts my chances of purchasing again from that author or publication. And this is why most publishers will use subscriptions for their normal content, except some dubious ones who will use clickbait headlines to attract one-time buyers.
- rhizome 7y agoI don't think postpaying is a necessary model, there could be a popup saying you don't have a subscription and to read the (full, probably) article is $0.05, would you like to pay this? I would almost certainly click "yes" on a lot of the stuff I don't wind up getting much value out of, and hey, 5c is naturally not that much so it balances out! And maybe that Isaac Chotiner or Bill Simmons (stay with me) 8,000 word'er will be $1. Package deals are easy. In fact, what with d-u-m-b cookie settings, email begs, and rest of the stack of "first 5 seconds" mandatory interactions, right now would be a great time to pop up a less-annoying payment dialog: "[Yes] [Account] [Sign Up] [No]"
- nine_k 7y agoWho in their right mind would need micropayments like this? Of course, any reasonable solution would take, say, $10 from you, and allow you to just press "pay" anywhere a paywall is encountered. Of course it would just auto-pay for articles on sites you put in a whitelist, within a limit you set. All the clearing is done in non-micro amounts, say, monthly. Such solutions do exist. The problem, of course, is the buy-in from site owners. I suspect that running better ads just has a higher ROI.
- threwe34234 7y agoIndia seems to get away with it - with UPI sending around Rs 1 (~ 1.5c) for 'verification' etc. is routine, and as with any UPI transaction it's all free. The only thing lacking with UPI is proper integration with merchants; large retailers rely on weird locked in services like PhonePe etc. for integration with their billing systems, but the rest seem to use a QR code and manual verification of payment.
- quantummkv 7y ago> The only thing lacking with UPI is proper integration with merchants; large retailers rely on weird locked in services like PhonePe etc. for integration with their billing systems My local grocery store (a small mom and pop operation) uses a QR code system with a speaker the recites out loud any new transaction so that both the merchant and the customer can verify it easily. And besides, integration with merchants is not the job of UPI. It's the job of the application implementing UPI.
- kelnos 7y ago> I've pointed out before that the enthusiasm for micropayments is from people who want to collect them, not those who want to pay them. Consider me one of the mythical latter people. I really really really want to support quality journalism, but I don't spend enough time on any one news site to justify a monthly subscription (most of which are fairly expensive). I would be totally fine spending sub-$1 per article read, though, if that were an option. I understand why it is not an option, but that's not really the point. If it were, I'd do it. Hell, I'd pay 50c per article just to avoid the annoyance of finding a paywall workaround.
- rb808 7y ago> Cryptocurrencies are not a magic bullet here. Many CCs are great for micropayments, its just bitcoin that sucks - it shouldn't be that popular.
- BurningFrog 7y agoIf both Credit Cards and CryptoCurrencies have the acronym CC, payment transaction discourse is doomed.
- lawn 7y agoMandatory note that Bitcoin is not representative for cryptocurrencies, and transaction costs are only high because it's been artificially hindered. 0-conf is also reasonably safe for small amounts. We must always remember that credit cards are perfectly acceptable, despite them only being "confirmed" after several months (so they cannot be reversed any longer).
- _Kristijan_ 7y ago> The technology for preventing double-spending is incredibly inefficient and slow. Transaction costs are high. Right now, a Bitcoin This is true of bitcoin. There are better cryptocurrencies which have already solved these problems completely. Have a taste on https://nanospeed.live/ https://nanospeed.live/ to do a fee-less live transaction in milliseconds.