12 ms·
Coronavirus will end the golden age for college towns
- jakeogh 7y agoRisk of coronavirus spreading in schools is 'extremely low' study finds: https://www.yahoo.com/news/risk-coronavirus-spreading-schools-extremely-194143983.html https://www.yahoo.com/news/risk-coronavirus-spreading-school...
- arcticbull 7y agoTo be fair that's high schools and elementary schools. They're a different risk category, yet lower than colleges. College are really low risk too, though I haven't seen anything to indicate spread would be slow in a college setting.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- trianglem 7y agoThat makes no sense. All the kids are in very close proximity.
- jansan 7y agoClose proximity does not have to the the only factor, although all the world ist currently fixed on social distancing. How about children being less contagious? After all they are developing no symptoms at all in most cases.
- sideshowb 7y agoAnd to paraphrase a post doing the rounds in the uk, elementary school kids are great at social distancing and never randomly lick you
- dr-detroit 7y agoKids don't show symptoms and the testing isnt there to disprove the conspiracy theory
- MattGaiser 7y agoThe STEM grad student numbers are both astonishing and not when you remember how little they are paid.
- MattGaiser 7y ago> It will be impossible for engineering departments to replace many of these lost researchers. That in turn will force many labs to shutter or scale back, making college towns a less attractive investment destination for private companies. This part made me curious. Is grad school not all that competitive to get into?
- d-sc 7y agoWell, it’s hard to find capable people for grad school. It’s not just a selection to pick some form of the best. To succeed as a grad school you need people that can make discoveries and play the academic game.
- throwaway713 7y ago> Even before coronavirus, President Donald Trump's administration had been working to decrease the inflow of students from overseas Sometimes I wonder if the U.S. is purposefully trying to move down in world rankings... I'm not sure why anyone would think it's a good idea to intentionally limit the opportunities to the best and hardest working people in the world; those opportunities will just spring up elsewhere instead. I have a theory that a society cannot maintain leading world standings without also leading in science and technology, and it's not long before the U.S. loses this (if it hasn't already). Most of the greatest recent technological advances are already driven by people born outside the U.S. that work within the country; it wouldn't surprise me if they decide that coming to the U.S. is just no longer worth the hassle.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoSome Americans definitely argue that the US should invest less time and effort into maintaining its international image.
- WillPostForFood 7y agoOr they think it is ultimately better for the US international image to educate its own people.
- renewiltord 7y agoInternational students are a funding source for US universities. They're a net positive if your objective is to educate your own people.
- jerrya 7y agoI'm all for international students but when you say they are a net positive, are they competing with US students for admission slots? If they are, that would seem to put pressure on prices US students have to pay as well as make admission that much harder.
- jerrya 7y ago> The highly successful model of using tax and tuition dollars to subsidize and plant the seeds for thriving local economies is getting hit from all directions at once. Maybe schools can pay competitive wages to their researchers while state schools focus admissions on state students?
- MattGaiser 7y agoThat would mean a decline in revenues and an increase in costs. Where does the money come from?
- pkaye 7y agoGet rid of the excessive high paid administrators.
- michaelbrave 7y agoFootball coaches have a rather large salary.
- exclusiv 7y agoFor many schools, football subsidizes all sports, even after paying the coaches and staff. And for a lot of schools, football pays for scholastics. You'd be hard pressed to find a school that pays a coach out of line financially.
- take_a_breath 7y agoI keep reading these same talking points without any data to support it. Can you provide any details on “many schools” or “a lot of schools”? My alma mater, Miami University in Oxford, Ohio, pays their coach $533k/year. That is half-a-million dollars for a mid-tier team in a mid-tier conference. They also built a $13 million indoor sports practice facility a few years ago. https://miamiredhawks.com/sports/2018/6/7/facilities-indoor-sports-center-15-html.aspx https://miamiredhawks.com/sports/2018/6/7/facilities-indoor-...
- Simulacra 7y agoIt always bugged me that both universities I graduated from took in large numbers of high paying international students, in order to prop up huge salaries for administrators.
- bilbo0s 7y agoJust to point out what may not be so obvious, the vast majority of the non instructional staff are not what many of us would consider to be "administrators". For instance, at the University of Wisconsin, there is an VERY large, extremely expensive bureaucracy called DoIT. It stands for "Division of Information Technology". Basically, it's the department for all of the IT people at the University. It's enormously expensive because of the nature of the work they do. And that's just one of the operations level bureaucracies required to pull off something like a University of Wisconsin. There's Facilities. There's Campus Police, which are very important at a place like UW these days. Student Housing. Health Services. The list goes on and on. These sorts of costs are not cheap, but they are necessary. (Or were necessary prior to covid, now? who knows?) Be that as it may, honest people can debate whether or not operational arms like DoIT are functioning as efficiently as they could be. My main point here was only to shed light on operational costs that many universities have which tend to be overlooked in conversations like these. Especially as those expenses are most likely the key contributors to the overall cost structure being discussed. At Wisconsin, due to a multi year campaign of cuts we have gotten the ratio of academic staff to non academic staff down to about 1:8 at one point. But at most large universities you'll find it in the range of 1:12 - 1:20. Just pointing out that if you want to bring costs under control, getting rid of some dean and a professor is not gonna get you there when you have 20 or 30 systems analysts, programmers, db admins, or campus cops on that same payroll.
- JamesBarney 7y ago> These sorts of costs are not cheap, but they are necessary. If tomorrow the government decided that every university would have to fund itself on half its current budget would universities cease to exist or would they just be different. I'd say the latter. I'd agree they're necessary to how a college functions today, but not necessary to what we think of as the core functions that make a university a university.
- tnecniv 7y agoThe graduate student analysis doesn't seem right. I don't think the article understands the incentives of graduate students. Yes, there are lots of foreign graduate students, especially masters students. One big motivator for them studying in the US is that they want to work for a US company and / or immigrate. Moreover, the ones that want to pursue a PhD often choose institutions based on potential advisors. It seems very unlikely that these things are going to change in the next year or so. Schools might miss out on prospective students with a time table, but I'd be surprised if the situation in 2025 is significantly different from today. I do see academic towns really hurting from the lack of undergrads. That's a big decrease in population, and even if most businesses are allowed to open in the fall, lots of universities will take conservative measures and not let undergrads back on campus --- dorms etc. being an ideal transmission environment.
- addicted 7y agoThose things have already changed though. Students graduating this year will not be able to remain and work in the US because the US has stopped processing work visas and are explicitly preventing immigrants from getting new jobs. This is in addition to the fact that international student numbers had already dropped over the past couple of years thanks to US hostility towards immigrants.
- unishark 7y ago> Students graduating this year will not be able to remain and work in the US because the US has stopped processing work visas and are explicitly preventing immigrants from getting new jobs. What story are you referring to? I've seen stories around the edges of this kind of thing for H1B's, but nothing so definite. A student graduating now wouldn't need one yet anyone because they get two years of OPT if they were in STEM.
- btown 7y agoSeems still in early stages but very plausible: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/05/republicans-urge-trump-halt-immigrant-work-visas-200507145156444.html https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/05/republicans-urge-trum...
- StillBored 7y agoI think both Austin and Raleigh have grown large enough that the "college town" effect is in the noise. In both cases the underlying economy is doing more to drive itself than the college is at this point. In those cases 40 years ago it would have made a big difference, but today better examples would have been places like College Station TX, or Gainsville FL, where the college remains the primary employer. UT Austin is the 10th largest employer in a town with a pretty self reinforcing tech economy, and a very long tail of national brand SMBs. https://www.austinchamber.com/economic-development/austin-profile/major-employers https://www.austinchamber.com/economic-development/austin-pr...
- ramraj07 7y agoBryan/College Station is already growing beyond A&M for sure, even outsourcing companies like Cognizant are opening offices there, not to mention the oil (that might be a big if now of course) jobs around.
- vuldin 7y agoI don't see this at all. Bryan/College Station exist entirely because of A&M, and these towns would do the same as almost every other small town in that area if it weren't for A&M.
- gbpz 7y agoWhat he's saying is that BCS is in it's infancy stages as a city. It's starting to draw in more jobs.
- lsiebert 7y agoAren't Austin and Raleigh state capitals too?
- ashtonkem 7y agoSometimes state capitals aren’t economically that powerful. Denver and Columbus are certainly positive cases, but Springfield and Albany are pretty middling compared to the biggest cities in the same state.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoEven if remote learning MAY (it may not) become the norm for higher education, parents who can afford it will still send their children someplace where children who engage in higher educationing congegrate. Probably college towns.
- rvz 7y agoThe generation from the swine flu pandemic of 2009 would like to have a word with this author.
- buf 7y agoZoom and YouTube weren't as big, mate.
- gerland 7y agoThis is a very hard situation for the affected, but I cannot look at it any other way than a positive change. My own opinion is that modern universities are a mix of ponzi scheme with stockholm syndrom. It's a bubble that should have burst a long time ago. From institutions of education and widening of perspecitve they morphed into thought-culling money making machines. I think we underestiumate just how many things changed for the better thanks to the virus.
- saiya-jin 7y agoYou can't bag all higher education just because you don't like some narrow part of it (ie IT-related). Any white collar job with legal responsibility, or doctors have some good reasons to be as they are (maybe not in ideal state, but that's another topic). Would you trust an architect who aced some online course with a building that you will live in? Or doctor to perform your surgery?
- drunkpotato 7y ago> From institutions of education and widening of perspecitve (sic) they morphed into thought-culling money making machines. How did you come to that conclusion? I would agree on the money-making machine part, but I had rather a different and mostly positive college experience on the education side, both in undergrad and graduate school.
- gerland 7y agoI cannot really asses the situation in US, but observing things like the Evergreen situation makes me believe that it's similar to what happened in Europe (at least to what I've seen). Most probles stem from standarization and degradation of dorm experience. It was pretty obvious when I was doing my Masters that in the lower years if you do not run with the crowd, then you will be ostracized. It was always like that in some degree, but I could not imagine few years before that there would be people protesting against leting in some conservative speakers on the campus. I was traveling a bit later and it seems that this is prevalent in most modern western universiteis. If you are not part of the rainbow crowd, then you have to be very careful where and to whom you voice your opinions. Maybe some people enjoy the Stasi experience, but I actually prefered the camraderie feeling of old - I will listen to you no matter what your opinions are.
- thrower123 7y agoIt's really just accelerating what was going to happen in a decade or so anyway when the demographic bulge passed. Colleges are to some extent wildly overprovisioned, as well as overextended, and many were starting to fail before SHTF.
- EGreg 7y agoPeople are thinking about this the wrong way. Masks reduce R0 so much that in Austria the infection rate plummeted after Apr 6 when masks were required. The lockdowns are a last resort, the result of a public policy failure to contain the virus. The entire US establishment including the CDC, Fauci even Mike Pence said until mid March not to wear or buy masks. Mind you, not even the cheap surgical ones that are 50 in a box. I have pamphlets in NYC written by the city’s health agency Feb 26th that insist there are no confirmed cases in NYC and the risk to new yorkers remains low. NO ONE was willing to get ahead of this thing and look silly requiring masks when there was no emergency. So the outbreaks were swift and led to exactly the lockdowns we were in now. We will face this situation again as we emerge from the lockdowns. We can’t rely on government to create a clear framework for businesses to follow. We need businesses to step up and sell a standardized solution. At Qbix we are doing our part. Contact me if you want to help in your community. Even the most staunch libertarian can’t say no when a private building enforces a mask policy in their lobby and in public areas like elevators. No amount of social distancing will help in elevators - only masks can. But the stupid attitude is “a mask can’t protect me, so why bother?” No!! The masks are to prevent everyone from spewing virus particulates into the air. Seriously this is the 21st century and several months after China got the epidemic, the richest countries in the world are still complaining about not enough masks. Meanwhile in Taiwan the buildings are handing them out and you can drop them off. That’s how it should be.
- gruez 7y ago>NO ONE was willing to get ahead of this thing and look silly requiring masks when there was no emergency. AFAIK it was because there was a mask shortage and giving masks to healthcare workers provided greater utility than giving them to everyone else.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tech-historian 7y agoAccording to the chart in the article, >75% of grad students in EE and computer science at American colleges are international students. That is a shocking number to me. Entire grad programs are in serious jeopardy if the worst case scenario plays out.
- nine_zeros 7y ago> That is a shocking number to me. Entire grad programs are in serious jeopardy if the worst case scenario plays out. Wait till you realize how much young engineering and sciences talent would remain outside the US and how much investment they will attract.
- JPKab 7y agoThose grad programs are too large. The main draw for international students is often the visa, and the universities treat them as cash cows, often providing poor quality product. A friend of mine in a graduate physics program recently told me that he felt that 90 percent of the students lacked the aptitude to capitalize on the program at all, but that the university was financially incentivized to keep them in. Obviously, this applies to both foreign and domestic students, but the point is that these programs are grossly inflated.
- ecopoesis 7y agoThis so much. I live in Boston so I end up interviewing a lot of new Northeastern grads. Foreign Masters students are the absolute worst cohort of candidates I deal with. The vast majority cannot write fizz buzz without help. A Northeastern Masters in CS seems to be nothing more then a way to buy a visa. This is doubly sad because Northeastern BS in CS grads are probably the most successful group I interview and hire.
- tech-historian 7y agoFWIW, I've interviewed tons of CS Masters grads myself, US and international. Northeastern is not alone in awful coding skills. Makes me wonder what the typical curriculum is in a CS masters degree? How can so many people get a Masters without actually knowing fundamental programming skills? Not a great analogy perhaps, but you can't get a Masters in French without speaking the language right?
- sneeuwpopsneeuw 7y agoSide Note: Can we all appreciated that this website requires 112 of its 349 requests to load javascript from 47 different domains.
- leonroy 7y agoGood grief, you weren't kidding. Page size is 11.64MB without any ad blocking and 3.91MB with. For a 3 image article with ~600 words 3.91MB is still a bit much.
- blaser-waffle 7y ago"appreciate"
- dkryptr 7y agoI'm not familiar with website development to know whether you're being sarcastic or not. Is it actually a good thing?
- stjo 7y agoNot at all. You can design a beautiful “modern” site with orders of magnitude less resource requirements with ease.
- tomatotomato37 7y agoI find news sites to be consistently horrid in terms of bloat. One of the reasons I switched from NoScript to uMatrix is the latter has a scrollbar because using NoScript on CNN would end up with the menu literally blowing past the bottom of my screen.
- alpineidyll3 7y agoThese articles claiming new normal ignore the fact that having a pandemic per century is normal. America of four months ago is an America after many pandemics, and that includes college towns. Journalists just want things to say they think people might read.