5 ms·
I always argue caution about revolution to help the poor, as there are plenty of examples where revolution killed as many poor people as it did aristocrats. Po
by ashtonkem 7y ago
I always argue caution about revolution to help the poor, as there are plenty of examples where revolution killed as many poor people as it did aristocrats.
Possibly the least flame war worthy example is the French Revolution. While the popular image is of the great terror killing off nobles, the reality is that most of the killings in Paris were either politicians or unfortunate merchants who refused to sell their goods at state mandated prices (at a loss) and were denounced.
And that’s not even including the 160,000 mostly poor soldiers killed in the Vendée after peasants revolted against forced conscription, nor the extra 40,000 civilians killed in the brutal reprisals after the war was over.
And the kicker? Not only did France eventually get a different king, but most nobles were able re-buy their old estates, and the government even went deeper into debt to compensate various nobles for their confiscated land.
- Supermancho 7y ago> I always argue caution about revolution to help the poor, as there are plenty of examples where revolution killed as many poor people as it did aristocrats. Std pareto curve. population of 100. 10 are aristocratic. 90 lower class. if you net equal losses, population 80 and you have increased equality. This is a simplification.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoRight, but they didn't net equal losses. The vast majority of people killed in the French Revolution were from the Third Estate.
- Supermancho 7y agoIt doesnt have to be equal, just outside the existing curve. Again, conceptually, 1:9 from 100 is an improvement for some abstract measure of equality.
- BobbyJo 7y agoGiven the fact that everyone ended up worse off after, this is kind of a pointless thing to attempt to point out.
- OldFatCactus 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Revolution#Long-term_impact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Revolution#Long-term_im... Just skimming this, it seems the french and the entire world was left better-off actually
- BobbyJo 7y agoFair enough, but I think we could both agree that the revolution was only beneficial because it changed the old system into something more malleable and predictable. The throne is an unstable thing, as is the man in it, and only subject to change on unpredictable whims. If you already exist in a system that is pliable, like a democracy, revolution really wouldn't bring you any of the benefits the French revolution did in the centuries that followed. You'd really only get the downsides. Let's not forget the context of the conversation here an talk about completely different circumstances.
- OldFatCactus 7y agoI don't follow what you mean about context, you brought up a bad example and you're moving goal-posts. There have been numerous revolutions with positive benefits to the world at large as well as to the society/culture in which they took place. I would chance to say that the majority were net-positive. If you find yourself scared of revolution, you should maybe take an introspective moment and ponder why the poor and downtrodden of the world (or just in your own country) would consider you their enemy.
- BobbyJo 7y agoI'm pointing out that the long-term gain from a revolution is not a by product of the revolution itself, but from the pre and post conditions. The revolution was necessary to effect those changes, but it was the difference in condition that lead to the benefit. Unless you are planning to massively alter the political (IE not have a democracy anymore) or economic system (IE not have capitalism anymore), a revolution does more harm than good, because you are only getting the short-term byproducts which are predominately bad. If the political and economic system remains largely the same, then a revolution is just a period of time where people are committing violence or protesting instead of making things.
- BurningFrog 7y agoI'd say it's very hard to find any violent revolutions that improved a society. It's pretty much a long line of tragedies. I count throwing out a foreign oppressor, like the American revolution or the Czech "velvet revolution" as a separate category. Those can be good.
- TomMarius 7y agoThe central point of the Velvet revolution was that it was non violent; also it was not about foreign oppresor primarily, we were oppresing ourselves very well without much help needed.
- BurningFrog 7y agoMy impression is that once it was clear the Soviet Union would not rescue the regime, it had lost it's power base, and was doomed.
- TomMarius 7y agoYes, but that was the last resort, after the regime's own army and secret police got overwhelmed.
- ciceryadam 7y agoBy the time the Velvet Revolution started, Poland was already after it's semi-free election, Hungary dismantled the heavily protected border with Austria, and the Berlin wall fell. But still, part of the local communist army had a contingency plan, 2 MiG-29 jets going supersonic, as low as they could, above the 300000+ protesters in Letna park. Thank god they didn't go through with it. Sources in Czech: https://www.seznamzpravy.cz/clanek/stacil-by-prelet-stihacky-nad-letnou-a-byli-by-mrtvi-vzpomina-na-listopad-prominentni-estebak-82837 https://www.seznamzpravy.cz/clanek/stacil-by-prelet-stihacky... https://www.parlamentnilisty.cz/zpravy/Havel-vzpominal-Stacily-dve-stihacky-A-revoluce-by-byla-krvava-218079 https://www.parlamentnilisty.cz/zpravy/Havel-vzpominal-Staci...
- HaloZero 7y ago
- C1sc0cat 7y agoIn the French revolution every one think it was mainly the aristos that went to the Guillotine. In fact most of the deaths happened out in the countryside, Infernal Columns, Revolutionary Weddings (masss drownings of clergy) and the Revolt in the Vendee.
- JamesBarney 7y agoObviously revolution is terrible because of the enormous amounts of human suffering. But if we're trying to compare the impact on rich vs poor we should probably use per capita numbers because there are far more poor than rich.