12 ms·
Pentagon official: FCC decision on 5G threatens GPS, national security
- herdodoodo 7y ago>U.S. Space Force Gen. John Raymond told the Senate Armed Service Committee >U.S. Space Force Gen. I know it's unrelated, but it is very strange seeing this title actually written out.
- zrail 7y ago"the Fourteenth Air Force/Air Forces Strategic was redesignated as Space Operations Command (SpOC)." Because of course the Space Force would have something named Spoc(k). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Space_Force https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Space_Force
- briandear 7y agoThis is being framed as a military issue, but the reality is that this would cause havoc with aviation as well, especially precision GPS approaches. Reminds me of a similar issue from 2012: https://www.gps.gov/news/2012/02/lightsquared/ https://www.gps.gov/news/2012/02/lightsquared/
- powellizer 7y agoAppears to be the same company: https://ligado.com/press/ligado-networks-launches-with-goal-to-expand-delivery-of-next-generation-mobile-connectivity/ https://ligado.com/press/ligado-networks-launches-with-goal-...
- neltnerb 7y agoI'm a little worried that GPS is so vulnerable that these satellites could cause such disruption to be honest. This is satellite based, any country could be approving this plan and the impact on GPS would still be present since orbits go everywhere. I guess I'd rather they just... not... I don't really even think the trade-off in increased seemingly real health risk is worth making the cell network even faster. It's going to happen though, if there's no mitigation that makes GPS more invulnerable to interference it will inevitably fail when actually needed.
- sasasassy 7y agoLet me just point out that satellites don't necessarily orbit around the world. They can be geostationary, and in fact they usually are I think. That is why you will find most US GPS satellites over the US, most Russian satellites over Russia, etc. Also, signal disruption is already very common as a necessary precaution at sensitive times and places. I think many military bases and other sensitive places, like the Kremlin, have signal interference so they are very imprecise to target with GPS-guided weapons.
- marcosdumay 7y agoGPS satellites are not on geostationary orbits[1]. And if you are using "GPS" as a common name, I still doubt you'll find any. Geostationary orbits are very far away, what leads to horrible timing properties, and all in a single plane. They are almost useless for positioning. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Positioning_System#Space_segment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Positioning_System#Spac...
- duskwuff 7y agoGNSS satellites (GPS, Galileo, GLONASS, Beidou, etc) are not in geostationary orbits. Being in a geostationary orbit would put them in fixed "locations" in the sky, making them easily blocked by terrain and entirely unusable at high latitudes. GPS satellites are in MEO, at ~20 km MSL. Other GNSS satellites use similar orbits.
- duskwuff 7y ago(Just noticed a minor error: GNSS orbits are roughly 20k km, not 20 km!)
- Rebelgecko 7y agoGPS wouldn't really work in a geostationary orbit (there'd be no way to tell if your latitude is North or South)
- unethical_ban 7y agoI have not read up on it - I am no expert. However, this is the second technology (first being weather radar) that 5G is reported to have significant, negative effects on. As a layman, I do wish we banned 5G entirely, assuming these assertions are correct. There is a greater public interest than even faster cell connectivity. The wiki on 5G isn't bad - I now get that it is a tri-band negotiation, and I assume it is the "high" band that causes the issues.[1] How does Wifi 6 use the same spectrum as 5G mid, but get such higher throughput? And if the point of 5G is also to give higher speeds and capacity in dense urban environments, with denser antenna coverage, why couldn't they adapt the existing 2-6 GHz range instead of going up toward millimeter? [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/5G https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/5G meta-edit: So, I put forward assertions, admitted humility and lack of expert knowledge, asked questions and linked to a wiki that I found to talk about the subject. If the person/people who downvoted me for the original content sees this, please note that the downvote button is not a disagree button. If you have substantive issue with the post, rebut it.
- pavon 7y agoThe problem has nothing to do with 5G inherently, and the vast majority of the bands it is approved to operate on will have no interference issues. The problem is that the current FCC has been very bullish on opening up more bands for mobile use even if there are legitimate interference concerns. > And if the point of 5G is also to give higher speeds and capacity in dense urban environments, with denser antenna coverage, why couldn't they adapt the existing 2-6 GHz range instead of going up toward millimeter? They are. Eventually all the bands currently used for 4G will be migrated to 5G. If you see T-mobiles ads about the largest 5G network in the country, that is all deployed on existing bands that were also approved for 4G. On these bands 5G will be a minor upgrade. The millimeter bands are intended to significantly increase the number of concurrent users, but the places where it can be effectively deployed are very limited. It won't pass through buildings, and has short range. As an example, Verizon couldn't even cover a full sports stadium with a single tower, and that's a prototypical case of where millimeter is supposed to be valuable. This latest issue is completely separate. It is entirely about a single company, Ligado, that bought spectrum adjacent to GPS at a discount deal because it came with strict restrictions on how that spectrum could be used to avoid interference with GPS. For years they have been trying to get the FCC to relax those restrictions for various different purposes, and this FCC finally approved. For previous requests there was tons of hard data filed showing that the proposed use would absolutely cause interference, and the requests were rejected. The latest approval does stipulate much wider guard bands and other measures to decrease interference. I don't know whether these measures are sufficient. The FCC commissioners unanimously think they are, while the DoD brass is insistent that they aren't.
- kryogen1c 7y agoI don't understand this. Is the DoD not subject to FCC regulation? Are there multiple bands that different types of GPS signals use (civilian vs military)? My understanding of GPS was that it is used in _civilization critical_ applications like satellite synchronization and plane/ship navigation. How could any sane human approve an interference with this traffic?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- inetknght 7y ago> How could any sane human approve an interference with this traffic? I think your assumption that people in charge at the top of the United States are sane isn't a valid assumption.
- WillPostForFood 7y agoFWIW, it was a unanimous 5-0 vote by the FCC. There is probably a sane a rationale for approval, even if one disagrees with it.
- dang 7y agoPlease keep this sort of flamebait off HN. Maybe you don't owe the people in charge better, but you owe this community better if you're posting here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- syshum 7y ago>>Is the DoD not subject to FCC regulation? That is complex, but most likely no. Like the FAA they largely respect the civilian agencies but ultimately they exist outside of that civilian regulation >>Are there multiple bands that different types of GPS signals use (civilian vs military)? Yes the military GPS is different from the Civilian GPS, the US DOD has the ability in a time of war to cut off Civilian access to the GPS Network where only US military (and approved Allies) receivers will work. This is one (of many) reasons the EU, Russia and China all have their own GPS systems >>How could any sane human approve an interference with this traffic? While I do not know if I agree (have not read enough on the interference to form a definitive opinion) the supporters of the new network claim there will not be any meaningful interference, that the DoD is over reacting and if there is Interference they will be required to replace the equipment..
- mLuby 7y agoDo they ever not say that? News would be "Pentagon official admits that <thing> doesn't actually threaten national security of largest military on the planet."
- MR4D 7y agoAn interesting threat vector arises here for Huawei... Ignore all the stuff about backdoors and such for a minute. I wonder if the administration fears that Huawai could simply attenuate their cell tower signals at a high wattage to disrupt all sorts of things. I never thought of that before - "5G as a weapon". Definitely a weird world. I need to start reading Judge Dredd again to start getting caught up on the future.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoIIRC: In the late-2019 BBC Click interview with GCHQ on the subject of Huawei, 5G, and security the spokesperson said information security wasn't an issue as we have end-to-end to handle that, the greatest risk was remote shutdown of the network. I assumed they're alluding to "in a time of war", falling back to non-5G wouldn't seem to be a big problem ... but then lots of our comms send to run on Huawei hardware already. Personally I don't think that risk is worth avoiding Huawei over. But then I'd be happy to maintain the top level of infrastructure we already have in the UK and work on bringing breadth to the networks using 3G&4G and taking an upgrade-hiatus. I'm not convinced the average person will get much from 5G except more infringement of civil liberties ...?
- 3pt14159 7y agoColour me skeptical. I've seen enough to know that MITM gives you enough information or threat vectors. That said, I agree with you about Huawei and non-5G. We shouldn't be talking about banning them on 5G, we should be talking about banning them (and anyone outside of the western alliance, really) from selling gear in our countries period. National security takes precedent. China doesn't even let reporters from the NYT in their country ffs. But whatever. Politicians are reactive and don't understand cybersecurity and the few that do don't have the sway or incentives to really push for this. Though I will say one thing, in a cyberwar we'd brick China just as badly as they would brick us, so at least we have MAD working for us.
- nxc18 7y agoShould the Europeans ban American equipment? We know the NSA intercepts shipments and tampers with network equipment, on top of everything else they do. We also know a foreign agent (with considerable Chinese debt who was elected with the help of Russian intelligence) is now in the White House. I know it’s fashionable to shit on China (China China China), but it’s not like they’re doing something new and unique. How can you count on the US, or any other country, to be a reliable partner? The POTUS is openly inviting Russian interference in US affairs ffs.
- brenden2 7y agoIt's in the military's interest to limit the freedom and empowerment of the public as much as possible. I would take their opinions with a grain of salt. With that said, this seems like something that can be easily solved with technology improvements.
- souterrain 7y agoExcepting in this case where the military operates a critical, life-safety infrastructure used by civilians. I'm frankly more concerned with the FCC acting as a taxpayer-funded telecoms industry cheerleader. Dear FCC: You're regulators. You're supposed to be regulating. This is what you get for being public servants.
- brenden2 7y agoMeh, the military engages in far more life terminating than life saving.
- kube-system 7y agoDeterrence is hard to measure, but US military superiority correlates with a period of relatively low global conflict.
- brenden2 7y agoMaybe so, but the evidence is weak at best. Some wars (like Iraq, Korea, Vietnam) were a sham. I'd feel more comfortable knowing nobody had nuclear weapons.
- kube-system 7y agoYou'd feel more comfortable, but is that the same as actually being safer?
- brenden2 7y ago
- Negitivefrags 7y agoIs this even actually directly related to 5G? I mean a mobile phone can’t connect directly to space satellite right? The article says “Would allow telecom companies to deploy 5G networks”. Is this satellite network for doing connnections between cell sites maybe? If that’s the case, it feels like 5G is only tangentially related and only included in story for click bait given that people seem to want to get mad about 5G recently.
- dralley 7y agoYou're right, although Ligado's intent seems to be to develop 5G networks on this piece of spectrum. It doesn't have much relation to the current 5G ecosystem however.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoIndeed, the issue here is a company, Ligado, that plans to use the L-band spectrum. As this is the part of the spectrum that GPS uses, the Pentagon worries about interferences. This has nothing to do with 5G, the cellular standard, per se, and even even less with Huawei or China. Edit: In fact, cellular networks like 4G and 5G ones rely on GPS for correct synchronisation and interfering with GPS could have an impact on them. Just to illustrates that this is a really a spectrum allocation issue regarding potential interferences, this is not a 5G issue.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- icegreentea2 7y agoLigado (ex-lightsquare) product is a hybrid satellite terrestrial network. The specific component that people are concerned about is their terrestrial network which is very much a 5G creature (in so much at Ligado is marketing themselves and this approval as a step forward for 5G and IoT).
- mytailorisrich 7y agoIt's not a 5G issue, it's a spectrum allocation issue.
- tracer4201 7y agoIs it correct to say that this impacts GPS not only for the American civilian and military but also the rest of the world? What are other country’s thoughts? It would be interesting to learn what led the FCC to make the decision they did... how did they deem the safety or consequences of this decision, etc. hopefully it’s not driven purely by profit incentives that put lives at stake. Disclaimer: I have no background on GPS, whichever wave “band” the issue impacts, or much of any technical understanding of the topic at all. Casual observer.
- reubenmorais 7y agoThe company wants to build a 5G network in the US, so it would affect GPS in the US. It's interference at the receiver, not at the GPS satellites themselves.
- kevindqc 7y agoMy understanding of this is that the company wants to use L band, which is the designation for the range of frequencies in the radio spectrum from 1 to 2 gigahertz (GHz) Doesn't 5G use higher frequency than that? Is the company, a satellite company, trying to use their satellites to provide 5G or something? So if the interference starts at the satellites, it could affect other parts of the world? >“We have presented to the FCC a proposal to utilize our terrestrial midband spectrum as a greenfield opportunity that is aligned with the commission’s stated goals of providing the foundation of the 5G future,” explained Doug Smith, Ligado president and CEO. “By deploying 40 megahertz of smart capacity on midband spectrum, we can create a model of at least a partial 5G network — a next-generation, hybrid satellite-terrestrial network — that will enable 5G use cases and mobile applications that require ultra-reliable, highly secure and pervasive connectivity.”
- madengr 7y ago5G is a very broad term, which is supposed to offer 10x performance in all metrics over 4G. This seems to be the same issue when they were called Light Squared. The L-band was to be used for terrestrial base stations with very high power transmitters. The issue is that, even though several MHz away, from the GPS carrier, the transmissions will compress the LNA on GPS receivers with poor or little filtering, desensitizing the GPS receiver. Most civilian stuff now has decent filtering prior to the LNA so it can co-exist with all the other wireless crap crammed in your phone. I’m an RF EE and do a lot with GPS.
- jrockway 7y agoI don't think there's enough detail here to decide whether or not to be mad. The L band is huge, 1000MHz-2000MHz. GPS uses a few tiny slices of this band. Cell phones, amateur radio, weather radar (though not precipitation-detection radar), ADS-B, and a ton of other non-military things are in that band. Adding 5G may or may not have any negative effect on GPS. I doubt they are proposing to run their 5G network on top of the GPS frequencies, after all, because everyone knows that would break GPS (which already operate well below the noise floor). One time when we were working on testing Wifi interference, we tried to buy every possible 2.4GHz device to see what they did to our routers. We found these TV extenders (connect camera to one end, connect TV to the other) that claimed to be 2.4GHz but didn't interfere at all. We looked more closely with a spectrum analyzer and they were actually 1.3GHz and completely stepped all over the GPS frequencies. Did the FCC stop Amazon from importing these things? Nope. I guess my point is... the threat is real, but someone going out of their way to request permission from the government (as is legally required) is probably not going to cause many problems.
- core-questions 7y ago>everyone knows that would break GPS (which already operate well below the noise floor). Can you explain the noise floor bit?
- Junk_Collector 7y agoThere exists a fundamental level of electrical noise at all frequencies typically controlled by the background temperature that sets the minimum level of signal you can resolve before it gets washed out in noise. GPS uses multiple coherent (noise being random instead of coherent does not combine at the same rate) copies of the signal that can be recombined to increase their effective signal, so even though they are transmitted below the universal noise floor, they are above it once recombined. *edited for spelling
- core-questions 7y agoThanks, that's very interesting. Appreciated.
- kyrra 7y agoFYI, Mark Esper (U.S. secretary of defense) has a commentary piece in today's edition of the WSJ about this, titled: "The FCC’s Decision Puts GPS at Risk" https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-fccs-decision-puts-gps-at-risk-11588719423 https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-fccs-decision-puts-gps-at-r...
- _bxg1 7y agoI have yet to hear anyone who's not a telecom CEO or a politician say they actually want 5G
- starpilot 7y agoI want 5g.
- sl1ck731 7y agoI mean, I'm sure a lot of people want it if it improves their mobile experience. It isn't really something that the average person is going to celebrate on Facebook.
- _bxg1 7y agoExcept: - It's shorter-range, so coverage will be spotty for a long time - It doesn't go through buildings, so even the urban centers most likely to get the first towers will have spotty coverage - It will require buying a new device, which OEMs love but the average person won't - That device will take a hit in battery life And all of this for ludicrously-fast new speeds on mobile devices that we'll use for... what exactly? We can already stream HD video over 4G. What experience is 5G, assuming you actually have access to it, going to improve? I'm sure we can contrive some use-cases like streaming VR video or whatever (even though all current phone-based VR platforms have been sunsetted), but I'm extremely skeptical that it will do anything to make the average user's mobile experience better in any meaningful way.
- Mo3 7y agoRegarding your first point, I'm not sure if that's true, I think they use low frequency spectrum around 900MHz (just like LTE) as well, not just the 2000MHz+ to GHz spectrum in densely populated or visited places. Also, as far as I'm concerned, the latency gains are much more interesting as the ludicrous speed, and then not even exclusively for phones and new types of apps, but for IoT as well
- apcragg 7y ago
- Causality1 7y agoI struggle to see the point of 5G existing at all when I can already burn through the 22 GB data cap on my "unlimited" plan in an hour with 4G.
- apcragg 7y agoThe new standard supports more concurrent users by using the available spectrum more efficiently. There are new modulation and timing "modes" that enable better coverage at cell edges and in dense urban environments. There is better support for multi-antenna systems which means better coverage and more efficient spectrum usage. End-to-end latency has been dramtically reduced and the next 5G NR iteration (rel 17) will add a super low-latency mode. There is now a mode for IoT that enbales low-power communication. Most of these changes aren't going to give you 1Gbps downlink speeds but they represent huge improvements over even LTE-A.
- skoskie 7y ago> ... and to repair or replace at Ligado’s cost any government device shown to be susceptible to harmful interference. Boy, if that’s the actual text (it isn’t) of the contract, they need new lawyers.
- beams_of_light 7y agoWhile sometimes considered controversial for decisions made on intangible things like net neutrality, I expect the FCC would have a much better understanding of the electromagnetic spectrum than the military, and having all of them approve this tells me they see no threat to GPS from Ligado's spectrum use. Makes me wonder what the politics are behind this, especially when I see someone like Jim Inhofe involved.
- finnthehuman 7y ago>I expect the FCC would have a much better understanding of the electromagnetic spectrum than the military Why? The FCC is concerned with coordinating peaceful use of commercial RF products (and experimentation that could lead to new commercial products). The military operates in hostile RF environments, conducts Signals Intelligence, and has to mitigate signal intelligence conducted against them. The demand for the absolute cutting edge of RF expertise is all on the military side.
- thoraway1010 7y agoThe history of lightsquared, the company involved, is horrendous. They bought spectrum with a SPECIFIC restriction on it to avoid GPS interference - then proceeded to get a proposal approved that violates that restriction. The amount of bad faith dealing by this company was eye opening. I thought Garmin / Trimble and basically every GPS company had sued them because of how terrible their proposals and behavior has been. This is not traditional 5G, it's basically misusing satellite spectrum.
- thoraway1010 7y agoFor those not in all the details - the spectrum was for earth to space communication. They bought it and said they would use it to do earth based broadcast. First - if this spectrum was usable for earth broadcast LOTS more people would have bid on it and used it. Second - almost all their proposals were totally and obviously disastrous for other existing users of the spectrum. With enough venture funding and sticking around for 10 years until you find a compliant FCC you can be rewarded for your bad behavior (and yes, they did finally change some of their proposals - but why this company gets to repurpose sat freqs at no extra cost for terrestrial use is ridiculous). .
- upofadown 7y agoIt's more or less the same process where a developer buys land cheap and then with the help of a corrupt government rezones that land to something more valuable.
- thoraway1010 7y agoNot totally the same - its worse. The FCC licenses bandwidth, no one owns it. The FCC can rezone, they generally then run an auction, keep lots of $$ for the govt, and kick some back to others if needed especially if they force folks like TV stations to move their station broadcasts. Lightsquared 100% lied when they said they would use the spectrum to serve 100% of users with a sat service. That was a necessary process for the original transfer (like for like use). And the value they are getting is huge. 40MHz of nationwide bandwidth. Easily worth 10Billion plus. Be totally fine for FCC to rezone using a normal process, auction to normal business at fair market value, protecting or compensating existing users.
- tonyztan 7y agoThere also seems to be concerns that 5G may interfere with weather satellites: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-03609-x https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-03609-x
- niftich 7y agoSee document FCC-20-48 [1] for full text. Some quotes: "Our decision authorizes Ligado to deploy a low-power terrestrial nationwide network in the 1526-1536 MHz, 1627.5-1637.5 MHz, and 1646.5-1656.5 MHz band (...)" "Our action provides regulatory certainty to Ligado, ensures adjacent band operations, including Global Positioning System (GPS), are sufficiently protected from harmful interference (...)" "Ligado's amended license modification applications significantly reduce the power levels of its operations from its earlier proposals and commit Ligado to providing a significant guard-band in the MSS spectrum to further separate its terrestrial transmissions from neighboring operations in the Radionavigation-Satellite Service (RNSS) allocation. Based on the extensive record, we conclude that Ligado's latest proposal—combined with the stringent conditions we adopt today—addresses harmful interference concerns with respect to GPS operating in the adjacent RNSS allocation, as well as concerns with respect to MSS licensees' operations in the L-band." Read section "II. Background" for more technical info and changes since the LightSquared proposals. [1] (PDF) https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/FCC-20-48A1.pdf https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/FCC-20-48A1.pdf
- mirimir 7y agoCouldn't the FCC just rescind approval if there's interference with GPS? Or at least, with DoD GPS?