29 ms·
Apple, Google ban location tracking in apps using their contact-tracing system
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cratermoon 7y agoSo GPS for me but not thee? "Privacy experts have warned that any cache of location data related to health issues could make businesses and individuals vulnerable to being ostracized if the data is exposed." Apple and Google already have that data in-house, it's just as vulnerable as any data. How is this not an absurd stance?
- Spivak 7y agoIt’s only absurd when you assume that access implies blanket authorization. Apple Maps is allowed to use my location for the purpose of providing me directions. Sure privacy policies are usually overly broad but for sure “to allow Mark in accounting to track his ex’s” aren’t part of it. I don’t see a contradiction in two large players refusing to cooperate with governments that want to slurp up people’s location data. They might lose the court case and be forced to allow it but I see no absurdity in the fight.
- cratermoon 7y agoIt's the reasoning they give -- that it might be compromised and used for bad ends. That's already possible, Anyone genuinely thinks that the partitioning of data for different purposes provides any real privacy protections, I've got a LifeLock subscription to sell them.
- londons_explore 7y agoIn terms of technical competence, I trust Google and Apple 10x more than I trust most governments.
- cratermoon 7y agoLemme guess, libertarian? Or at least "fiscally conservative, socially liberal"? Blind faith in the Free Market Fairy (https://bitworking.org/news/2008/01/The-Free-Market-Fairy https://bitworking.org/news/2008/01/The-Free-Market-Fairy) is a big part of how we got here. As Einstein said, "We can't solve problems by using the same kind of thinking we used when we created them".
- ghshephard 7y agoI can't speak for Google, but I know that Apple goes out of their way not to have any clue where your are. For example, when you do mapping directions, you get issues multiple single-use codes, that are refreshed during the trip, so not only does Apple not know what directions you asked for, they can't even associate the trip with a single entity. When you say, "Apple has the data in-house" - what are you referring to?
- viraptor 7y ago> they can't even associate the trip That's assuming the single-use codes are not persisted on the other side. Maybe they aren't. "Apple has the ability to have the data in-house" / "Apple promises not to have the data in-house" would be more precise. The rest relies on the current behaviour and T&C.
- AJRF 7y agoI've been wondering about the UK contact tracing app because they seem to be deliberately misleading saying that data is secure on the phone, yet it's a centralised model, and they are using bullshit terms like "clinically secure algorithm" to describe the one-time codes; Is the source code of these apps something that could be FOI requested from NHSx seeing as it is publicly funded by the tax payer? Also they've already started moving the goal posts; https://www.theregister.co.uk/2020/05/04/uk_covid_app_human_rights_parliament/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2020/05/04/uk_covid_app_human_... This* came from NCSC - that image about the NHS version worries me greatly. * https://www.ncsc.gov.uk/blog-post/security-behind-nhs-contact-tracing-app https://www.ncsc.gov.uk/blog-post/security-behind-nhs-contac...
- jjgreen 7y agoGiven that Palantir is involved, I'd not touch it with a long stick https://tech.newstatesman.com/coronavirus/palantir-covid19-datastore-coronavirus https://tech.newstatesman.com/coronavirus/palantir-covid19-d...
- AJRF 7y agoOh wow I had no idea Palintir was involved, I feel like I've finally turned in to the paranoid old fool that people laugh at, but this really upsets me to think of the millions of people who are going to install this without so much as a thought.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- uoaei 7y agoThe thing about those paranoid old fools is that some of them are right. But where they are stuck at the level of trying to convince others to just "look with your eyes, see the truth right in front of you!" those with actual experience with praxis know it's much more fruitful to put your efforts toward political campaigns. Grassroots is a thing but it's always some weird combination of coercion and rhetoric about morals and ethics, because most people don't care so you have to make them care before the movement picks up steam.
- sbhn 7y agoSounds like a cartel
- three_seagrass 7y agoI mean, imagine the repercussions of allowing third party apps to do this. It's tragedy of the commons for health info. i.e. A crappy mobile app that spams notifications when you're around someone who was in contact with Covid infected. One which doesn't have any oversight and motivation other than mobile ad views.
- jimmaswell 7y agoThe repurcussion is.. you know someone near you was in contact with covid (a good thing to know) and it has ads (devs need to eat too)?
- three_seagrass 7y agoIt means scammy apps will spam contact notifications without proof just to get eyeballs, and that's on top of the ones using covid fears to phish for info. Bad actors will exploit this.
- lazyeye 7y agoDoes anyone else find this a little ironic given Google is a company that has been logging peoples location to a very fine detail for years
- cm2187 7y agoAnd Apple.
- gruez 7y agoApple logs location history? Other than the wifi location log from ios4 and the significant locations feature (opt in, device only), I don't know how apple is logging locations.
- cm2187 7y agoNot only it does but I even remember a story of a crime that was solved in Germany a few years ago just by requesting from Apple the history of the locations.
- jeromegv 7y ago"I remember a story that is the entire opposite of what you said". If you have an argument to make based on a specific event, you're going to have to do better and provide some sources. "I remember a story", are we going to throw the full privacy history of Apple away based on your "history" that you remember? Please provide sources or do some research before you comment.
- slg 7y agoOn your iPhone you can go to Settings -> Privacy -> Location Services -> System Services -> Significant Locations and you will see that Apple does keep track of at least some of your location history and tries to analyze it if you don't actively turn it off.
- angott 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ramshorns 7y agoSure. It's maybe a bit unsettling to see a global corporate monopoly telling countries what they're allowed to do, but in this case it's the right thing.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- fancyfredbot 7y agoI trust a democratically elected government above a duopoly personally, and I'm not convinced the decision of how far to trade off privacy concerns against public health is one those corporations are competent to make.
- fooey 7y agoYeah, in this case, I think it's clear that if GPS data was attached, user adoption would be ruined. The most important thing is to get absolutely as many people possible using the technology. Besides, for their own selfish reasons, neither Google or Apple want to be so blatantly attached to something that could be so easily abused.
- thelittleone 7y agoOk so devils advocate here. Google and Apple need to advocate privacy for reasons. But they also want to help the government (PRISM example). So they carefully craft a bug that only government knows about and that allows the extraction of location data. If ever discovered it was not intentional. The NSA backdoor at RSA is an example [1]. [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-security-nsa-rsa/exclusive-nsa-infiltrated-rsa-security-more-deeply-than-thought-study-idUSBREA2U0TY20140331 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-security-nsa-rsa/excl...
- Spivak 7y agoI think it’s unsettling that were so used to companies and people with actual power doing fuck all to stand up to government abuses that it’s weird when it actually happens.
- karambir 7y agoWill be interesting to see if they can ban Indian govt. app[1] which needs full location access(clarified)[3]. A lot of people like this app(including me) but also know government does not have good track record in securing private data. Previously Apple were made to bend their rules when India threatened to ban Apple devices if they don't allow TRAI Do Not Disturb app in 2018.[2] [1] https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=nic.goi.aarogyasetu https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=nic.goi.aarogy... [2] https://9to5mac.com/2018/11/30/apple-approves-india-dnd-app/ https://9to5mac.com/2018/11/30/apple-approves-india-dnd-app/ [3] https://paste.gg/p/anonymous/b7c95d3967514e78a652840b5b666d50 https://paste.gg/p/anonymous/b7c95d3967514e78a652840b5b666d5...
- Karupan 7y agoDoes the Indian app use the contact tracing API? I was under the assumption that it used the regular location/Bluetooth APIs in android.
- searchableguy 7y agoIf they ban it, my next phone will be an iPhone.
- mynameisvlad 7y agoApple is known for being far more heavy-handed with its banning of apps in their store, so I wish you luck on that endeavour.
- Fiveplus 7y agoWhat is the status of contact tracing apps in the United States?
- skybrian 7y agoNot launched yet.
- skybrian 7y agoWe probably shouldn't call them "contact tracing" apps since what they plan to do is so different than manual contact tracing. "Exposure notification" is a better term. Nothing prevents anyone from using their phone's location history to remember what to tell the contact tracing people.
- azinman2 7y agoWhat exactly is the difference?
- paxswill 7y agoSay Alice tests positive. Contact tracing: Alice is able to say, “I was in contact with Bill and Carol.” Then authorities can talk to Bill and Carol, and have them trigger their phones to see who they’ve been near. But because that’s slow, most plans would upload the lists of who’s been near who to a central server. Then the authorities can do a simple query to see who’s been near who. Exposure notification: Alice enters a code that she got with her positive test result in to the app. The app has been continually broadcasting rotating, random identifiers which it then uploads to the central service. The code she entered verifies to the central service that she has a legitimate positive result. Bob and Carol’s phones periodically check with the central server for the list of positive IDs. Their phones stored one of the IDs from Alice’s phone when they were near each other earlier. Once they get the latest list of infected IDs, their phones will alert them that they have been exposed and should be tested. In CT, the central service has all the data, and you can trace contacts without the knowledge of the users. In EN, the service has a list of infected people, and everyone needs to check that list periodically. Pretty sure there’s some subtlety with the IDs being a cryptographic sequence or something so there isn’t a gigantic list of IDs everybody is constantly pulling down, but this is the gist of it. ETA: The FAQ from Apple+Google is a pretty quick rundown of where exactly each part of the data is stored and when it leaves your device. https://blog.google/documents/73/Exposure_Notification_-_FAQ_v1.1.pdf https://blog.google/documents/73/Exposure_Notification_-_FAQ...
- xkyscore 7y agoGoogle have flat out banned any apps that have anything to do with combating COVID-19 if they aren't either funded by their government or are a registered health company. I tried releasing a symptom tracker app before Zoe released theirs and it was rejected for this reason.
- cwhiz 7y agoThey will ban and flag your account if your app just mentions the word Covid. It is absolutely absurd. Only Google is allowed to make a Covid app.
- jedberg 7y agoIt may be a bit harsh, but it makes sense. Too many people are trying to take advantage of the situation to pull scams. It's a lot easier for Google to operate on a whitelist model than a blacklist model.
- PaulKeeble 7y agoThen Google would be building a whitelist. They aren't doing that, they are using a position of power to isolate the market for themselves. That is a monopoly.
- jedberg 7y agoThey are building a whitelist. They even made the criteria public. You have to be a government or health entity to publish a Covid related app.
- PaulKeeble 7y agoThat isn't a whitelist, there is no way on it with a legitimate app when the entry criteria is being a state.
- 7y ago
- kristianc 7y agoSomewhat inevitable that the briefing will begin tomorrow against Apple and Google that American big tech firms are deliberately frustrating attempts to fight COVID and wouldn’t it be better if we just taxed them out of existence. Shame, as a UK citizen I’m entirely supportive of the stance Apple and Google are taking.
- tomatocracy 7y agoI'm not so sure that this type of framing will work so well in the UK. I suspect a lot of the press will jump straight to "it's because Dominic Cummings wants to benefit his mates who do dodgy data mining". Even if that's demonstrably totally untrue, enough people will believe that narrative for it to become mainstream. The fact that there are plenty of other countries who are content to go with the Google/Apple API will also neutralize a lot of this type of criticism.
- PaulKeeble 7y agoI have no idea how to predict the UK public anymore. When it comes to the snoopers charter it went by with barely a whisper from the populace and yet when it comes to the 18+ filter on broadband something like 93% of people had opted out on their home broadband. It's exceptionally rare to find so many people do the opposite of default. I can't work out if the Uk public do or do not care about privacy and their security or what but they surprise me with their actions at times.
- williesleg 7y agoThey want to control it themselves. Everybody's got an agenda https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JEGEnKPtx6M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JEGEnKPtx6M
- smallstepforman 7y agoI’m genuinely suprised that an implementation came out so quickly ... one would think the pandemia must have been advanced before the government even considered doing this ... and here we are with Android and iOS approved apps, with bluetooth and permission solutions made by a team of available engineers, implementing goverment documented requirements ... hmmm
- Slartie 7y agoThere is not a single app using this API in "approved" state, let alone active use. The API is kept very simple, its implementation has just entered a beta stage, and the Bluetooth tech it uses is almost a decade old already. And the entire idea of contact tracing via BT has been discussed for months already by several teams worldwide and already been implemented a few times in various ways, so it's not exactly new either. But don't worry, just go on with your demonstrative "critical thinking"...
- tobyhinloopen 7y agoInteresting. I wonder if countries will try to force them to re-enable it
- ufo 7y agoDoes anyone know if the original statements from Apple and/or Google are available online?
- hashemian 7y agoI believe it comes from here: https://blog.google/documents/72/Exposure_Notifications_Service_Additional_Terms.pdf https://blog.google/documents/72/Exposure_Notifications_Serv... Section 3.c.i
- ufo 7y agoThanks. It sounds like this only applies to Google's own exposure notification service and would not apply to standalone contact-tracing apps such as the one being proposed by the UK government.
- flipgimble 7y agoIts interesting that they call this a "Contact Tracing app" even after changing the naming to ExposureNotification.framework I think these restrictions are meant to win confidence with a somewhat skeptical public. This will also confine the apps to be single purpose for contact tracing only.
- notyourday 7y ago"We have established the person over there has been exposed to Bad Ideas on May 22 2020. Let us find all those people that were exposed to him. We trigger the exposure event via ExposureNotification.framework"
- azinman2 7y agoWhat is interesting about that?
- finnthehuman 7y agoWhy would Reuters follow Apple's branding?
- buboard 7y agocovid19 has become a buzzword factory. Politicians popularize terms like "herd immunity" , "crush the curve", "testing", "ventilators", "PPE" etc to appear to be doing something. "Tracing" is the next in line, but it's a total sham. No country has been able to contain the epidemic with bluetooth. And all the countries that manage the epidemic have first waited until they have very few cases , which can be traced manually, and they did isolation well. As long as there is a high number of active cases, tracing won't work. So, it's good that apple+google are banning those apps because they would be useless and a damn spying vector.
- artursapek 7y agoYou seem to agree with Schneier! I'm with you, the whole premise is utterly useless. https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2020/05/me_on_covad-19_.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2020/05/me_on_covad-1...
- chimprich 7y agoSchneier's a security expert, not an epidemiology expert. I don't think I'm going to put much weight in his opinion. The UK's epidemiology and behavioural teams have some confidence that this app will have an effect. It doesn't need to be perfectly effective to be useful. Even a small reduction in R is very helpful.
- DanBC 7y agoTo be clear: Sage thinks it will work, but we're not told who is on Sage not which of them think this will work. For all we know this is Cummings not understanding any of the science.
- chimprich 7y agoFor what it's worth, I was thinking of developing an app on similar principles a couple of months ago and I talked to at one of the Sage people. They were enthusiastic about it. There have also been papers modelling the effect. I don't like Cummings' politics but he is a smart guy. I think he'd follow the science.
- swirepe 7y agoThey have to protect their valuable behavioral surplus.
- mrfusion 7y agoI’m so confused. Can you opt out of this?
- djrogers 7y agoCan you opt out of installing an app? Is that actually what you're asking here? If so, yes..
- mrfusion 7y agoIf Apple wanted to they could force your phone to install an Unremovable app or just add in the software in an update.
- AlexMoffat 7y agoThis is not just a straw man it's a straw giant.
- aaron695 7y agoCan anyone show me an app in the wild that uses Bluetooth like or close to what the Covid apps wants to? Why isn't HN talking about the technical side at all? We know Bluetooth on phones can't do what the governments says it can. We've all gone through the stage of, what if we used Bluetooth to track people indoors and do cool stuff! Then we realise you can't. The best we see is advertising maybe doing low quality beacons. It like we think C19 makes the impossible possible.
- ObsoleteNerd 7y agoThe Australian one seems to follow the spec pretty will. Uses rolling random IDs and BT RSSI to check for proximity to infected people. “Infected” is declared by the patients getting the hospital to input a private key when they’re diagnosed, which then uploads their last x days of random IDs to declare them as infected. Source code is public and has been shared/audited on twitter etc but no formal audits that I’ve seen yet.
- shakna 7y ago> Source code is public and has been shared/audited on twitter etc but no formal audits that I’ve seen yet. I don't believe that's true. There is certainly decompiled code floating around, but release of the code has been delayed whilst the Signals Directorate investigate the app. [0] Worth noting that decompiling the app to see if it actually does what it says it does is a crime under the legislation backing it. > Agreed. The PIA and source code will be released subject to consultation with the Australian Signals Directorate’s Australian Cyber Security Centre. [0] https://www.health.gov.au/sites/default/files/documents/2020/04/covidsafe-application-privacy-impact-assessment-agency-response.pdf https://www.health.gov.au/sites/default/files/documents/2020...
- aaron695 7y agoI've decompiled the app for android and had a look over the source and what you say isn't true. The rolling ID doesn't work so 3rd parties can track you. Source code has not been released at all. It does not work in iOS I think is a fair statement. It won't until Apple do the update. It does not check the 'proximity to infected people'. All data processing is done by a human. The app just dumps all your info. All interactions with other phones with the app to a human. Then then work out times and if the person was 'close' So this is why I've asked the question. Surely someone on HN has made an android/iOS app and can comment. It would have to be around a phone Bluetoothing to a phone.
- HABytes 7y agoAwesome but not yet launched.!
- alkibiades 7y agoeven without location tracking it’s creepy. what happens when the govt contact traces a man with his mistress and then blackmails him?
- sjwright 7y agoI laugh at conspiracy theories which revolve around the Government paying special attention to normal individuals. Dude, Governments have the power to tax millions of people. They don’t need your piddling bribery money. It’s too much work for too little reward.
- macinjosh 7y agoIt’s not about the money and it’s not about “normal individuals”, whatever that means. Law enforcement and intelligence agencies find this sort of information useful to further their agendas.
- sjwright 7y agoThen (in your absurd hypothetical scenario) those agencies are being incredibly stupid, they're wasting their time on on high risk / low reward strategies. Oh wait, you're probably talking about the United States? It's scary how fucked up that place is just millimetres below the surface.
- alkibiades 7y agoi’m talking about what they did to mlk jr. even if it doesn’t affect me it still matters. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FBI%E2%80%93King_suicide_letter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FBI%E2%80%93King_suicide_lette...
- ghuntley 7y agoSee https://twitter.com/GeoffreyHuntley/status/1256124427781062656?s=19 https://twitter.com/GeoffreyHuntley/status/12561244277810626... for Australia.
- shakna 7y agoWhere are the bug bounty programs? That's easy. It's a crime to see how any of the app is running. Reporting a security flaw would likely see you receive a $5000 fine, and potential jail time atop of that. They didn't bother to get the servers running before pushing out a gigantic advertising campaign shaming anyone for not using it. ... Despite it having obvious flaws from day one, that showed it was mostly a cut 'n paste of Singapore's GPL app. (Though you can't access the source. National security trumps freedom of information and promises.)
- viraptor 7y ago> It's a crime to see how any of the app is running. Have you got something supporting this? Here's a panel of Australian-based security people decompiling and discussion the details of the app: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U3dN99ljgD4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U3dN99ljgD4 Are you saying they've all publicly admitted to committing a crime and are unaware of those laws? Are all editors here https://docs.google.com/document/d/17GuApb1fG3Bn0_DVgDQgrtnd_QO3foBl7NVb8vaWeKc/preview# https://docs.google.com/document/d/17GuApb1fG3Bn0_DVgDQgrtnd... criminals? The only serious analysis I can find is in http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/journals/JlLawInfoSci/2003/2.html#Heading337 http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/journals/JlLawInfoSci/2003/2.ht... and it's "kinda depends why you're doing it, but either way it's largely untested".
- shakna 7y agoIt isn't actually a law yet - that happens later this month. Instead, we've received a determination by the minister [0], which will act as a kind of back-date for when those laws are passed. > A person must not decrypt encrypted COVID app data that is stored on a mobile telecommunications device. That video shows them looking into how the data bundle is assembled, but I don't believe they actually touch it or run it in an emulator, which would very much breach the determination - because unless you're one of the exceptions, you're not legally allowed to run the software outside of tracing. Exceptions are given for those in employ of the health department, or other government bodies. Whilst that might vaguely not mean decompiling the app, the minister's own press conference is clearer on the intent [1]: > It cannot leave the country, it cannot be accessed by anybody other than a state public health official, it cannot be used for any purpose other than the provision of data for the purposes of finding people with whom you have been in close contact, and it is punishable by jail if there is a breach of that. Decompiling the app steps outside the provisions for looking at the data, and yes, you don't have permission to look at your own data. [0] https://www.legislation.gov.au/Details/F2020L00480/Html/Text https://www.legislation.gov.au/Details/F2020L00480/Html/Text [1] https://www.health.gov.au/ministers/the-hon-greg-hunt-mp/media/press-conference-about-the-covidsafe-app-launch https://www.health.gov.au/ministers/the-hon-greg-hunt-mp/med...
- baybal2 7y agoWill they boot existing contact tracing apps with GPS from the App Market?
- jb775 7y agoThe title says "ban use of location tracking", but the article says "will not allow use of GPS data". There are many ways to extrapolate a user's precise location from non-GPS data.
- crowbahr 7y agoAs an app developer that sounds like disallowing precise location but allowing general location.
- tinus_hn 7y agoThat kind of data, for instance visible access points or cell towers, is not available for apps on iOS. If you disagree, could you please list ways you think this can be done?
- cat199 7y agoif the goal is 'privacy', I'd think contract tracing is every bit if not more more of a privacy concern than is location
- azinman2 7y agoHow so? You're an anonymous identifier in this system.
- estebarb 7y agoThe GPS data couldn't be "rounded" to have less precision, depending on population density?
- smeyer 7y agoWouldn't that sort of defeat the point here? Contact tracing apps want to use location data to know when I might have been in contact with someone. If you do something like round the data to a suburban neighborhood or a densely populated city block in Manhattan, you can't effectively contact trace. Any granularity of data that is useful for contact tracing would seemingly raise the same concerns that are leading to them banning this.
- adfjlkjwezv 7y agofuck the liberal google and apple PM's sitting at home, smoking weed thinking this crazy shit up they should be sued and fired and then thrown in jail!
- Someone 7y agoThe title of this article is incorrect. FTA: “Apple […] and […] Google on Monday said they would ban the use of location tracking in apps that use a new contact tracing system the two are building”. So, contact tracing apps that don’t use that system, such as the one from the UK (https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-52441428 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-52441428) still would be allowed to do location tracking.
- dang 7y agoOk, I've tried to fit that in the title above.
- grey-area 7y agoBut will anyone use them? I wouldn't trust an app which has been outsourced and feeds data to palantir: https://eandt.theiet.org/content/articles/2020/04/nhs-opts-for-centralised-contact-tracing-app/ https://eandt.theiet.org/content/articles/2020/04/nhs-opts-f... https://www.hsj.co.uk/technology-and-innovation/exclusive-wobbly-tracing-app-failed-clinical-safety-and-cyber-security-tests/7027564.article https://www.hsj.co.uk/technology-and-innovation/exclusive-wo... The Apple/Google solution sounds much better to me - no central datastore.
- Traster 7y agoOh the UK government has got a great plan for that - they're going to stick the NHS logo on it. That way people will incorrectly think it's trustworthy, and when they find out it wasn't it'll damage the reputation of the NHS - which is a key goal of the current government.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- miguelrochefort 7y agoI can't imagine that working out in China. EDIT: Nevermind. Looks like this only applies to apps using their new contact-tracing framework.
- jaimex2 7y agoHere in Australia our Covid tracing app is already out. It uses Bluetooth proximity logs and local storage unless you test positive and are asked to upload. I had a look at whats in the apps DB and it seems it just keeps a log of unique ids it bumps into. When you test positive and upload I'm guessing it publishes those unique ids if the logs show over 15 minutes of contact. The government already have our locations via cell towers so they just have to match the data if they really wanted to.
- crushthecurve 7y agoA misunderstanding is that this system results in instantaneous contact notification and isolation (which is what one of the original papers on digital contact tracing efficacy assumes). The reality is the entire 'human in the loop' contact tracing process is still manual. Health staff working in state contact tracing teams still need to call and interview every contact to determine whether they could be considered a close contact from an epidemiological perspective. Also consider that close contacts include anyone you've spent more than 2 hours in an enclosed room with. So that immediately limits the utility of any bluetooth proximity app: you still need an entirely manual process for home, work, social gatherings - any situation where you are in an enclosed room. We've taken a deeper look at the assumptions and expert opinion, both from individuals and institutions, which appear to discount this kind of system from providing significant value. Even the product lead of Singapore's TraceTogether app, as a natural advocate for this kind of initiative, admits the technology is oversold and is only an additional tool (due to the significant potential for false positives / negatives): https://blog.gds-gov.tech/automated-contact-tracing-is-not-a-coronavirus-panacea-57fb3ce61d98 https://blog.gds-gov.tech/automated-contact-tracing-is-not-a...
- jaimex2 7y agoThanks for the insight. Why wouldn't they just auto-alert anyone who came in adequate proximity to get tested though? Surely there is some benefit to letting people know they need to be extra careful now and get tested ASAP. All the manual human work can continue as normal.
- Gollapalli 7y agoYes. I believe them. Totally. The borg has my best interests at heart. My big brothers Apple and Google will look after me.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- McTossOut 7y agoAll hail Apple, Google the kings of the apps. Welcome to a world where: -everyone else must be worse.
- crushthecurve 7y agoWe've been looking at digital contact tracing from the perspective of Australia, as we see a huge push for the COVIDSafe app, based on Singapore's TraceTogether app. It seems the sensible order of questions is: 1) Do we have a contact tracing problem? 2) Does digital contact tracing generally solve it? 3) Is the specific app / implementation useful / safe / privacy-respecting? It appears the national conversation almost entirely skips thinking about 1) and 2) and gets lost in the limited analysis of 3). We had a deeper look at 2) in this recent piece: https://blog.crushthecurve.today/why-should-you-install-the-covidsafe-app-part-2/ https://blog.crushthecurve.today/why-should-you-install-the-...
- viraptor 7y agoThe post has a very city-specific view. (and it may have good points about that environment) Compare it to a regional town: minimal public transport, few/no dense residential buildings, no large offices. For me the app is literally a "does anyone I stood next to in the shop / petrol station test positive" indicator.
- crushthecurve 7y agoIn a regional context a bluetooth proximity app offers even less theoretical value. A contact is only registered after 15 minutes of time spent within an estimated proximity of 1.5 metres (itself a primitive model of infectious disease transmission based on a 1942 paper). Note other countries set the distance at 2 metres. As outlined in other comments in this thread, close contact rules include anyone in a room for more than 2 hours, so even though all close contacts have to be manually interviewed (there is no instantaneous notification and isolation) for most social situations close contacts won't be registered through crude estimates of proximity: home, family / friends, work all require thinking about and providing contacts. When you strip out all the situations that aren't beneficial, that starts to leave public transport in major metro situations where commutes are greater than 15 minutes. Keep in mind that also implies the end of any social distancing (as otherwise no contacts are registered). That seems obvious, as public transport becomes overwhelmed if capacity is significantly reduced.
- goindeep 7y agoHorrible.
- azinman2 7y agoI have to say, working at Apple and knowing all the hard work that goes into this and making sure your data stays private while also being able to combat this disease, it's very frustrating to read a lot of the comments here. I can understand why the public is skeptical, but I feel like as a society we've swung so far away from institutional trust that now nothing good can actually emerge. The anti-vax movement is a perfect example where the collective work of thousands of people over decades to save millions of lives just gets tossed aside because some celebrity 'feels' like there's a connection that isn't there, and in the process, the level of public harm becomes severe. Note: All opinions (in this comment and all of mine on HN) are my own.
- droopyEyelids 7y agoShow me any institution that has maintained trustworthiness for all of history, and I'll consider trusting Apple/Google/our govt. with the ability to tell where every citizen is and who they associate with for the rest of the future.
- selectodude 7y agoI'm just not sure why we're more trusting of our wireless service providers who have explicitly given personal location data away to not only the government, but also to advertisers, than we are of Apple who would love to sell us another $1200 phone.
- dvtrn 7y agoConvenience. Convenience always wins.
- rconti 7y agoorrrrr don't install it at all, or delete the app when Covid-19 is no longer a threat like I plan to do.
- plerpin 7y agoRead the fine specification.
- spicyramen 7y agoLocation information, political preferences, socioeconomic status, photos, emails, search locations, to name a few. Is very dangerous that they are openly monopolizing access to everybody's life without regulations in place. I personally believe that Engineering teams do their best to anonimize individuals but reality is that other products teams such as Ads or growth don't do it
- nitinreddy88 7y agoGood luck implementing it in other side of the world (India). You can't refuse if Govt mandates it. So what's the point in Apple and Google wants to control Privacy. I can trust Govt more than Greedy Private companies.
- ksml 7y agoJust curious: why do you feel you trust your government more than "greedy" private companies?
- dingo_bat 7y agoThe result of this move will be that most contact tracing apps will use their own system, thus bypassing the location restriction.
- known 7y agoUnder the cover of coronavirus, governments punish adversaries and reward friends https://archive.vn/Ea2qr https://archive.vn/Ea2qr
- alkonaut 7y agoIf you don't trust Google and Apple when they say their API does what they say it does, then you can't use an iPhone or Android phone. I understand that people are conscious about these things but what I don't understand is how people say "oh I'd never run an app using an API from google/apple, they have a horrible track record" and then carry a phone in their pocket with an OS from either Google or Apple, where those companies can basically do whatever they want. If you carry such a phone you already trust them. If this API does what it says it does (basically exchange random numbers) then how is that worse than what you already trust your phone to do?
- mellow2020 7y ago> If you carry such a phone you already trust them. I don't. But not because I think my dumbphone isn't also basically a mic I carry around, but because mobile devices are a joke, one and all. It's like moving back to communicating with infant sounds after I learned how to walk, form sentences and use tools -- why would I? Because so many people do, that they already assume everybody does? I don't need e.g. Whatsapp to stay in contact with people I care about and who care about me, if I was only reachable by mail they'd send me letters. Anyone incapable of that I would surely dislike for dozens of other reasons already, so the question of "how to stay in contact even though I don't have a smartphone" literally didn't come up once since Apple "changed the world" in 2007, heh. This stuff is just a very recent blip in our evolution as a species, and the phase we're in is about as impressive as the lies people told each other once they invented writing. It too shall pass.
- redlorryyellow 7y agoif I was only reachable by mail they'd send me letters. Based on your comments above, I'd bet a lot of money that they wouldn't...
- mellow2020 7y agoBecause something you can't even specify rubbed you the wrong way, no person in the world loves me? That's just wishful thinking on your part.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- brevityism 7y agoI am sure most people would agree life > privacy any day. Edit: But then again, if there was an option to opt out that would be great too. Got to give people options!
- dkraft 7y agoSo if you are in jail, youre set free because of the virus. If you are free, you are put in jail because of the virus. Got it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ComodoHacker 7y agoI have two questions. 1. Why are location data needed? What difference could it make vs just contacts? 2. Couldn't this ban be easily circumvented by telling people to install another app that shares location data?
- cja 7y agoContact tracing with location tracking must surely be more effective than contract tracing without location tracking. I'd quite like my government to decide how contact tracing should work in my country, instead of two companies making that decision. I cannot vote against Apple or Google if I don't like what they do. Also, I'd like to leave my home without worrying about catching a dangerous and possible fatal disease, and if I have to sacrifice some privacy to do this then that's ok. Privacy is important, and it's lovely that IT people care so much about it, but all the people on zero-hour contracts and with underlying health conditions would probably rather that we prioritise the most effective approach to eliminating the virus.
- elisharobinson 7y agothis is a text book cluster fack
- frankzen 7y agoThe idea that this won't be abused is nuts after seeing what's already been done by the likes of Facebook, Zoom, Microsoft and others. Privacy is privacy. No one has the right to take that away.