7 ms·
I really dislike the way in which this article has been written - it reads as the typical piece from the "bro culture" that massively ignores the rest of the wo
by simonebrunozzi 7y ago
I really dislike the way in which this article has been written - it reads as the typical piece from the "bro culture" that massively ignores the rest of the world. Besides this, which is not the point...
1) most restaurants in US and high-end Europe that survive and thrive do so by having big margins on alcohol. Their margins are not single-digits. (edit: just saw other comments mentioning this).
2) Many restaurateurs don't have the skill or knowledge to run a restaurant, and yet they do so because it's often one of the few options left (if you can't land a high-paying job, and don't like a low-pay one).
3) What she describes in the article is very US-centric. Most of Europe, or Japan (where I am currently sheltering before returning to the US soon), have a very different restaurant landscape. Most are small mom-and-pop shop, they have very low ops costs, and can do not too bad in a time like this one. I spoke with a few owners recently (in Italy and Japan) and they all confirmed it. They mostly don't have personnel, or if they do, their relationship is flexible enough that they can quickly react to 2-3 months of 50-70% less business than usual.
4) For the long term, nobody knows what's going to happen. Are we ever going back to pre-covid levels? Don't know. Probably not. Some restaurants will close, sure, as well as car dealers, etc. Good restaurateurs will manage to find a way, IMHO.
- pkaye 7y agoI believe the article is talking about a Canadian restaurant though much of it would apply to the US.
- MattGaiser 7y ago> it reads as the typical piece from the "bro culture" that massively ignores the rest of the world. Why should articles need to be generalized to the world? It certainly fits the Canadian and US markets. You can't have comprehensive coverage of everything and everyone in an article.
- bartread 7y agoTo be honest I thought in many ways it was pretty spot on for the UK as well. The company I work for has a brand tracking product that looks at the casual dining sector[1] from the perspective of consumers: https://savanta.com/product/brandvue-eating-out/ https://savanta.com/product/brandvue-eating-out/. You can easily find problems around a lot of the points raised in this post in our dataset. If you cut too much around areas like food quality and service your NPS is going to slide, and if not turned around it becomes a leading indicator that the end is looming (e.g., Jamie's Italian). We obviously don't track independent restaurants - chains only - but you can certainly see the effects of high rent and absolutely swingeing business rates[2] coupled with heavy downward pressure on prices across the whole sector. [1] This isn't just restaurant chains: it includes pubs, cafes, fast food, etc. [2] These are nothing short of an outrage in many parts of the UK. Local government will often complain about their moribund high streets, but do little to help their cause. The reality is that with costs as high as they are, and the convenience of online and delivery, it's extremely difficult for any kind of outlet to make money on the British high street.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoHigh Street rents are incredibly high. I'm in one of the poorest UK cities, but even here - with (literally) every other shop empty - rents are phenomenal. But then property owners are accruing financial value through property price rises, they don't need to have leasees, they're still making money. I don't understand why the Council isn't super harsh on property maintenance (absent landlords let their properties bring down the appearance of an area); and why the gov. don't levy high taxes for empty commercial properties. IMO high-street properties that are empty should be a heavy loss on landlords.
- darren_ 7y agoWhen their title is "Why Restaurants Are So Fucked" instead of "Why Restaurants In America Are So Fucked" is why.
- renewiltord 7y agoI think one is expected to understand the context oneself or else the first time one's spouse says "There aren't any eggs" one may receive a terrific fright at the thought of the impending doom of all sexual reproduction on the planet.
- darren_ 7y agothe 'context onself' is americans talking about america. got it.
- gladskdks 7y agoThe issue here is that the vast majority of American articles make no effort to convey the fact they are talking about America. The internet is a _global_ space and there's very little effort required to make the distinction. I would argue that the writers of these articles are the ones not understanding the "context of oneself" given how they think their readership is entirely American.
- scarface74 7y agoSo now should every article written in the Atlanta Journal Constitution published on the internet mention that they are talking about Atlanta in the headline?
- mattkrause 7y agoPerhaps because the author (and restaurant) are Canadian?
- superzadeh 7y agoMaybe just adjust to title to avoid generalization. "Why Restaurants Are So Fucked in the US". Showing awareness goes a long way.
- wutbrodo 7y agoNeither the author nor the restaurant are American; even the example they use is Doner Kebab, a term that's not widely in use in America. What awareness exactly would the author be showing by adding a random country's name to her article title?
- Mikeb85 7y ago2) is the correct answer. Most restaurateurs in Canada (and probably the US) are simply unsophisticated. Most of the restaurants I've worked for and/or run are basically money printing machines (I've been lucky and feel I'm pretty good now) while a few crashed and burned hard (and it was always pretty obvious they would). The example in the article has many, many things wrong with it.
- Ntrails 7y agoThe general rule that I've seen in the handful of UK establishments in which I've chef'd, is that food should be priced by ~tripling the cost of the raw ingredients. It's a pretty inexact science for anywhere small ish with a frequently changing menu - but it doesn't matter. Alcohol also has a big markup, don't get me wrong, but it's not alone. And if you want to know the biggest "free profit" in a restaraunt - it's postmix soft drinks and tea/coffee.
- Mikeb85 7y agoSimply 3x-ing COGS might 'work', but you're leaving a lot of money on the table. > And if you want to know the biggest "free profit" in a restaraunt - it's postmix soft drinks and tea/coffee. No, soft drinks lose you money because it's often a replacement for more expensive alcoholic drinks. The typical soft drink here is $3, even a $6 beer will net me more gross profit than the total price of the soft drink. That's why craft sodas, kombuchas, home-made mocktails and the like are de rigueur nowadays... Tea/coffee is 'free profit' in the sense it's usually an addition at the end of the meal and not everyone will order a digestif.
- illumin8 7y ago> The example in the article has many, many things wrong with it. Agreed. The author of the article seems to lack some basic business skills. I realize that if you're making an artisan sandwich at home you might want to use the best possible ingredients (the artisan sourdough she talks about, etc), but you can't expect to build a viable restaurant business where you are spending so much on raw materials. If I was making myself the ultimate burger I might use wagyu beef that cost over $10 a pound and some artisan cheese, pasture-raised bacon, etc, but I wouldn't try to create a fast casual restaurant and expect to make a profit using those ingredients.
- jerome-jh 7y agoHaving a restaurant is like owning your production tool. The invested capital allows you to make a revenue. High margin is not required since there is little investment to do, except refreshing the furniture every 2 years. They do, however, have a serious problem with the pandemic, unless they turn to pick up meals or delivery.
- amelius 7y agoDelivery market is already spoiled by Uber eats etc. which act like gatekeepers and take a huge margin.
- virgilp 7y agoUS restaurants ask me to pay their tax and their personnel separately, and are still expensive. I get it that cheap fastfoods operate on slim margins but I have a very hard time believing the decent restaurants do. I read the article hoping to find what the hell costs 50-70 USD + tax + waiter wages (aka “20% tip that you’re a monster if you don’t pay”), found no such thing.
- jjeaff 7y agoJust because things are itemized on a bill doesn't make the total any higher. In fact, I would argue that I would much prefer an itemized bill to a black box total. It's much easier to sneak in extra charges if everything is rolled into a single total. Perhaps what you mean is that you don't like having to keep in mind that all your prices don't include tax and tip, which is so common in the US, that everyone just instinctively knows it. To the point that if you try to include everything into the price, people will consider your prices too high. It's very difficult to shift public habit.
- virgilp 7y agoYou can say that, but there are enough hints that you'd be wrong: - Tip habits differ a lot; various online debates and movie references show that there are "assholes" that don't tip (or don't tip well enough?). From this pov serving in a restaurant is more akin to playing music in the subway than working a regular job. This is, IMO, not how things should be. - "if you try to include everything into the price, people will consider your prices too high": this right here tells you that people are not as rational as you paint them to be. Theoretically, the bill is the same whether you include & itemize all things, or not. In practice though, because the bills do not include everything, they can get higher than they otherwise would. Humans are strange and not always rational beasts - that's why prices like "$1999" exist. Because (false) impressions matter. So no, it's not easier to sneak in extra charges by presenting full price on the menu - it's quite the opposite.
- willvarfar 7y agoRe point 1, there has been a major change in pubs in the U.K. All are trying to migrate into dining, as the margins on alcohol have fallen. Those that didn’t become restaurants have basically gone bust. There are no longer any normal classic pubs in England! I know a couple that tried to rejuvenate a failing “free house” in a tourist hotspot and failed. Passing the spot recently I saw it is now a pub restaurant like all the rest. I also once talked with the owner bartender of a very trendy micro brewery pub. The beer was their hook but the money came from food and the stables converted into b&b. It doesn’t invalidate your point at all, I’m just adding detail to a very varied landscape.
- andybak 7y ago> There are no longer any normal classic pubs in England! A slight exaggeration, no? Whilst it's uncommon to find a pub that doesn't do food, I can think of several not far from me. (just outside Brighton). And "a pub that does food" is still quite far from being a restaurant. Some only do food on Sundays, some have limited menus run by guest kitchens and some get the food cooked by a nearby takeaway with whom they partner.
- willvarfar 7y ago“Pubs that do food” is the kind of thing I’m talking about! :) It starts with Sunday lunches, and slips into weeknights. It starts with order at the bar, and slips into little “reserved for diners” signs on most of the tables. It starts with the barman working the sandwich toaster and slides into teenagers in white blouses and knee length black skirts with name tags saying “trainee” asking you to wait to be seated as you enter. Pubs used to be adult domains where people went to drink and chat in the evenings. Now pubs put playgrounds and bouncy castles in the car park to bring in families to dine. Of course there might be some classic true pubs left? Perhaps someone should make an app ... arrrgh!
- Symbiote 7y agoWhen I was very young, in the late 1980s, my parents regularly took me to two different pubs. Both had outdoor equipment (slides, climbing frame, sandpit etc) for children. One served food in the "lounge bar". When I visit London, it's not difficult to find a pub with no children and no food. Things have changed, but you are exaggerating it.
- kenneth 7y agoA "bro culture" article written by a female entrepreneur who isn't from Silicon Valley… right. I think you need to check your prejudices. 1) plenty of restaurants don't sell alcohol, including it seems this one. she also had a point about how drinks aren't a great revenue generator given the price you can expect to charge in a fast-casual setting vs. the costs (higher than grocery stores) 2) how is the restauranteur's motivation relevant? 3) her restaurant isn't in the USA so I'm not sure how you can call it US-centric.
- virgilp 7y agoRef 3: 1. Prices in USD 2. Quotes Philly Mag. (Philladelphia?) 3. Mentions how generous tipping is required to help servers survive Yeah, of course one would assume it’s about US. I’m honestly very surprised if it isn’t.
- mprovost 7y agoCanada also uses (their own) dollars. (As do Australia and NZ among others.)
- lowdose 7y agoSome people use this knowledge to weasel out of bets.
- acjacobson 7y agoPrices are in Canadian dollars, but I didn't know this until I looked up the restaurant. $11 felt kinda high for a döner, even a really good one. But that works out to ~7€ which is a little high for Germany, but not that much higher.
- mtrower 7y agoThat definitely explains a lot; I thought $10/lb for the type of meat they were describing was kind of crazy (for someone complaining about margins, anyway). ~$6.30 USD/lb feels far more sane.
- givinguflac 7y agoGood restaurateurs will manage to find a way, IMHO. That’s literally what the article is about. More importantly many restaurants cant sell alcohol. Sounds like you and the article are talking about two very different things.
- scarface74 7y agoIs everyone who writes an article about anything suppose to be an expert from a worldwide perspective?
- aoeu12332 7y ago0) I kind of wonder how anything that reads as a typical piece from a certain culture could not be criticized for massively ignoring the rest of the world. 1) In France most restaurants sell the same desserts that they buy from the same wholesale Metro that's open only to food professionals. They buy it less than a euro and sell it more than five, with a bit of an english cream they buy by liters. 2) Not sure what's your source, but I suppose running a tobacco shop would be far easier. I have yet to know one restaurant owner who has 0 experience as either a waiter or a cook. 3) Basically you're saying that doing 0 business activity is "not too bad", when you still have to pay the rent. Just because you've spoke with a couple of owners in Italy and Japan. 4) You can be good, but paying for a 10k/month rent + furlough and making absolutely 0 business activity after throwing away your stocks can kill your business even if you're a "good restaurateur". But maybe Simone is right: if COVID killed your business then it's because you're not "good enough". I've yet to read such a both senseless and self sufficient comment on hn. Nice culture, nice inclusiveness, maybe one day you grow a heart. Somebody had to say this.
- ric2b 7y ago> But maybe Simone is right: if COVID killed your business then it's because you're not "good enough". Individuals are supposed to save at least 6 months expenses in case they lose their job or there's an unexpected large expense. But for restaurants it's fine to have so little money that you go bankrupt with a month or two of no business? We're not talking about multinationals, there are lots of reasons why you might need to close a restaurant for a significant period of time or pay for expenses.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]