4 ms·
> Drinks for instance cost us more than at the grocery store — but we can’t exactly go get 20 cases of pop per day, so we don’t have much choice. I didn't unde
by triceratops 7y ago
> Drinks for instance cost us more than at the grocery store — but we can’t exactly go get 20 cases of pop per day, so we don’t have much choice.
I didn't understand this. It may not be feasible to buy 100 cases of pop at a regular grocery store, but isn't Costco/Sam's Club set up for that?
I do think it comes down ultimately to real estate prices. Major metros in North America have gradually become unaffordable for the middle-class over the past 20 years. It's not surprising that it's the same story for small businesses such as restaurants. Businesses have to pay workers more (because housing is expensive) and they have to pay their landlord more (because commercial rents are high). All that profit margin is ending up in landlords' pockets.
- dehrmann 7y ago> real estate prices For older, less popular restaurants, maybe, but a salad at Sweetgreen is, what, $10-$15? And that's fast casual. Clearly overhead is being passed on to customers.
- Digory 7y agoAnd yet I'm not sure it's a smart deal to be a commercial landlord. These "Retail space per capita" graphs have been eye-popping for awhile.[0] The landlords that win seem to be the landlords who play the political subsidy and tax games, not just good developers. [0]
- mark-r 7y agoMy favorite is the landlords that refuse to lower their rents to attract tenants. They got a loan to buy the property, and the loan is backed by the revenue potential of the property. If rents decrease, the revenue potential also decreases and the lenders require the property owners to make up the difference. It produces a huge incentive for a property to go unrented at a high price rather than rented at a low price.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- JackFr 7y agoI’m familiar with the argument but I think people overstate the importance of unrented high price to refinancing. Banks (and CMBS investors) don’t simply look at market rent levels in isolation. They also look at percent vacant and length of tenancy. Except over the very short term, no one is being deceived.
- mdtusz 7y agoI can't say that it's specifically the case, but in Montreal, there's been an ever increasing number of vacant commercial spaces - seemingly because they know that "eventually" some BigCo will come along and be willing to pay the extremely high rent. As anecdata, there's a corner space on the ground floor of Duluth and St. Laurent that's been vacant for well over a year - maybe even two. It's pricing out smaller businesses, and even though the space is available and empty, it's just unaffordable and priced far above the true market value. We don't want more A&W's and Starbucks, but that's what eventually happens here. The only places that survive are bars.
- mark-r 7y agoRefinancing isn't the answer, because the borrowers will need to make up the difference between the old value and new value in cash. That's what makes this such a strong incentive, where it's worth it to leave a property unrented for a long time. If there's no refinancing, there's no reevaluation and no big lump of cash to be produced - everything just continues on as it did before.
- tomatocracy 7y agoLarge landlords who own an entire street/area in upmarket or aspiring parts of a city also worry about low end tenants dragging the rest down. Completely rationally they'd rather have 60% occupancy at 2x the average rent than 95% at 1x and they know that high end retailers will pay a lot less (if anything) for a site next to a McDonald's (for example) than for a site next to another high end retailer.
- mark-r 7y agoLandlords, like any other business, are out to maximize their profits. Their goal is to capture 100% of the profit of businesses that rent from them. Given that the mechanisms for doing this are very crude, there's a chance that they could be getting 101% or more and that spells death for your business.
- IAmGraydon 7y agoA landlord’s goal is to capture 100% of their tenants profits? That’s quite a misinformed statement. Their goal is to create sustainable, long term income on their investments. Taking everything they can from their tenants would not foster sustainability. I’m also really curious about your last sentence. Can you elaborate?
- mark-r 7y agoThe goal is to maximize income, and the maximum you can get sustainably is 100% of your lesee's profits. If you take less then you're leaving money on the table. If you take more than that (e.g. 101%) they will inevitably go out of business. If you guess wrong and drive a place out of business, your hope is that the next tenant is more profitable and can handle the overhead. Chain restaurants are typically pretty good about this because they know their revenue potential accurately ahead of time.
- opo 7y ago>...The goal is to maximize income, and the maximum you can get sustainably is 100% of your lesee's profits. If you hypothetically take 100% of the profits of the renter, they won't be in business long term. There likely will be a gap between when they stop paying rent and you are able to evict them. There will also likely be a gap between that point and when you get a new renter, particularly when your rent is so high. I agree that the goal is to maximize income, but trying to take 100% of the profits of the renter is not a way to maximize long term income.
- chii 7y ago> the maximum you can get sustainably is 100% of your lesee's profits. only if there's a monopoly on real estate. I find that unlikely.
- RandallBrown 7y agoI'm not sure why you couldn't buy 20 cases of pop per day at a big grocery store. There's more than 20 cases of each flavor at my local grocery store and there's lots of other grocery stores nearby that have the same selection. Also, you're right. Costco exists too.
- gladskdks 7y agoA few reasons: One: the shop often wouldn't let you buy up their whole supply Two: there are likely other restaurants in the area, so that's 20*N boxes a day Three: lots of countries have resale laws that prevent this Four: that's a lot of time to spend every day when you can get a single delivery every week / two weeks instead Five: the delivery often includes the collection of the used bottles (when using glass) and that otherwise can cost a lot
- Dylan16807 7y ago> One: the shop often wouldn't let you buy up their whole supply Any half-sane shop would love the giant piles of money you're spending and negotiate a way to get you a nice big supply with an even easier pickup process than filling a cart. > Two: there are likely other restaurants in the area, so that's 20N boxes a day Even better. Imagine a shop saying they don't* want to ramp up to selling ten times as much product out of aisle seven with no extra work beyond staying in stock. > Three: lots of countries have resale laws that prevent this If you buy a shelf-stable food, you can't resell it? Why would a law like this ever exist? > Four: that's a lot of time to spend every day when you can get a single delivery every week / two weeks instead This is a better reason, but you'd think the huge volume of the sale would get you at least a mild price improvement. > Five: the delivery often includes the collection of the used bottles (when using glass) and that otherwise can cost a lot If it costs money to set things out for recycling, the local government is doing a bad job.
- WalterBright 7y ago> All that profit margin is ending up in landlords' pockets. The landlord's costs go up, too.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoNot nearly as much. If at all. This is what killed retail in the UK. Amazon certainly made a difference, but given a choice, some people actually enjoy mall shopping and eating. But between huge hikes in business rates (commercial operating taxes) and rent increases, retail simply isn't as profitable as it was in the 90s. The rent increases are pure greed and predatory extraction. There certainly hasn't been any correspondingly huge explosion of costs for landlords.
- WalterBright 7y ago> Not nearly as much. If at all. Have you looked over their books? Landlords have to pay: 1. taxes 2. maintenance 3. insurance 4. mortgage costs (they're usually leveraged) 5. legal and lawyer fees for contracts and disputes 6. costs of unrented space 7. accounting costs 8. costs of just keeping track of all the changing laws 9. depreciation In Seattle, landlords are considered an unlimited source of funds for social programs by the City Council. For example, if the spouse of a tenant damages the apartment, the landlord has to pay for the damage, not the tenant.
- jlokier 7y ago>> [Cost have not risen] nearly as much. If at all. Your counterargument: > Have you looked over their books? > Landlords have to pay: > 1. taxes 2. maintenance 3. insurance 4. mortgage costs (they're usually leveraged) 5. legal and lawyer fees for contracts and disputes 6. costs of unrented space 7. accounting costs 8. costs of just keeping track of all the changing laws 9. depreciation I think your argument is "there are lots of costs", which is true and people don't appreciate that a landlord can have a hard time. But it doesn't work as an argument about how much costs have risen or fallen. Most of the costs you listed have either stayed the same or gone down in recent years, so it doesn't appear to support your side of that argument. Mortgage costs in particular have gone down a lot in recent years. Mortgages are great if you can get them, because they are so cheap now. 6 has gone up but that one is cheating. It's like saying landlord's income is lower than the amount it "should" have gone up, which does not work as an argument that landlords actually have to pay out more. If 6 has gone up due to longer voids, those voids (until recently) are usually due to raising the rent, their own decision, so again do not constitute landlords paying out more. 9 is an interesting mixed bag, as depreciation is only relevant as a true outgoing cost if you're going to sell the property someday, in which case you should only be counting the interest component of the mortgage, which has gone down, as well as the change in property price, which has probably gone up by more than depreciation (until recently).
- Rebelgecko 7y agoThat part seemed strange to me. According to people I know that have worked in food/beverage industry, the most expensive part of a cup of Coke at a movie theater or fast food restaurant is the actual cup itself. The liquid inside the cup costs pennies.
- wiredfool 7y agoMy first boss said the ice was the most expensive part. But that just may have been his occasionally flakey ice machine.
- runxel 7y agoPossibly because the machine costs a bit, the constant running costs, and maintaining of course as well. Also maybe because you don't want to use tap water...
- veggieburglar 7y agoAs with my examples above (linen and dishwashing) ice machines are also notoriously difficult/expensive. They most certainly have to be cleaned & serviced regularly. When the Board of Health comes in, the ice machine is one the first places they look as it’s basically a invitation to a mold party without diligent cleaning.
- mtrower 7y agoSyrup is cheap, water is cheap, C02 is cheap... for a fountain drink, you are indeed correct. The margins here are crazy. I assumed this vendor was selling bottled or canned soft drinks. Why that is, I couldn't say (just as I couldn't say why they're renting a dishwasher, why they're paying a linen cleaning service rather than purchasing a washing machine, etc...).
- veggieburglar 7y agoIt’s very common to rent a dishwasher. High volume dishwashers break down all the time and need very regular servicing and cleaning. At every establishment I have been associated with (wine industry) I’ve been on a first name basis with my dishwasher service rep. With linen, when you go through a big volume, it is infinitely easier to use a linen company than to do it yourself on site. You’d have to buy industrial washers, pay rent on space to keep them, know how to service them, pay staff to operate them, etc... If you’re a large chain, perhaps you could bring those operations in house. If you’re tiny, you could do it yourself. But if you’re seeing over 100 guests a day, there’s no reason not to use service companies for these two examples.
- Aeolun 7y agoThis doesn't make sense in the first place. Don't suppliers charge lower rates to restaurants exactly because they'd otherwise just go to the supermarket?