9 ms·
Lots of kids in LA seem to be spending all day skateboarding 20 people deep on the less crowded streets, playing full court basketball and soccer matches with h
by asdff 7y ago
Lots of kids in LA seem to be spending all day skateboarding 20 people deep on the less crowded streets, playing full court basketball and soccer matches with hundreds of spectators at the supposedly closed public parks. Summer break began when LAUSD went online for a lot of kids.
And its no wonder. 15% of students have yet to be in contact with their teachers during this survey period (1). In south central, 16% of students lack basic internet access. It's hard to imagine this perspective for a lot of the HN demographic, where we imagine internet has been ubiquitous in the U.S. for decades, but this is still not the case for low income areas in one of the largest cities in north america.
1.
https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-04-22/getting-free-internet-hard-for-poor-students-despite-provider-promises https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-04-22/getting-...
- kitotik 7y agoAre the parks actually closed? I only saw them closed for Easter weekend.
- asdff 7y agoYup! All parks are closed, but you can't even tell if you drove by say MacArthur park right now. https://www.laparks.org/covid-19 https://www.laparks.org/covid-19
- kitotik 7y ago“Parks still remain open for walking or running” This is what I suspected. I couldn’t imagine parks and rec or LAPD not shooing people away and putting up physical barriers if they were actually closed.
- asdff 7y agoIf social distancing guidelines are maintained, that is. Note the next line about recreational group sports which are my biggest issues with the parks right now. It would take 1 cop to tell everyone playing basketball and soccer to go home, although with the trongs of spectators on bleachers maybe a couple cops on horses would be better.
- _bxg1 7y agoIs this due to people being unable to afford it, or telecoms being unwilling to build infrastructure?
- davidw 7y agoIt's in the middle of a huge city. If nothing else, they could use mobile data hotspots. The school district has been handing those out to kids with no stable internet at home where I live in Oregon, or trying to, at least.
- adamsea 7y agoOregon !== South Central
- drchopchop 7y agoNot everyone has laptops, and the school may not have the resources to provide devices. Zoom is one thing, but doing any serious learning on a phone is difficult - and that's assume the parent is OK with letting the child use theirs for a large part of the day.
- davidw 7y agoYes, you would have to ensure that everyone has a device of some kind.
- asdff 7y ago4G is not very reliable in LA.
- danans 7y agoThe most valuable and scarce resource for many parents right now is time. Even parents who theoretically have "time" due to a recent layoff or furlough are under stress of trying to apply for various benefits while paying the bills somehow, so the task of organizing their kids' home academic schedule is just daunting, leaving aside the issues of lack of internet access or computers. It was challenging for me and my spouse, despite both having jobs that switch to WFH and flexible schedules, plenty of computers, and internet access.
- throw4839 7y agoInternet in US is not "ubiquitous", but joke. Monopoly everywhere, data caps...
- asdff 7y agoYup. I can only get Spectrum in my apartment, the fastest plan available is claimed to be 100mbps and doesn't hit anywhere close to that in reality, throttles aggressively. 4G coverage is pretty shit here in LA too. Crappy coverage, slow, and drops the connection all the time. My options are deal with this, move, or have no internet. Internet provider choices will weigh heavily when I'm apartment hunting after this lease.
- mobilefriendly 7y agoI don't have land-line internet available at my home in greater DC metro. We survive on LTE hotspots. Praying for the success of StarLink!
- bjourne 7y agoWasn't it obvious from the start that that would be the result? The idea that children should study at home during the school closure is ludicrous. I'm almost 40, have a Master's degree and have self-studied my whole life but I often have trouble being efficient when I'm home. So no way children seven to fifteen years old can do it. Maybe children with academic parents will get some home-schooling, but children from poor backgrounds won't. Those are the ones who will be paying the price of the lock down. Two, three months without schooling will significantly hamper their development.
- Loughla 7y agoWhen my state decided to go to 'e-learning' for the rest of the year, those of us who are located in rural, or low-income districts were terrified. The high-income districts couldn't be more excited; they're biggest headache was making sure each of their students' school issued laptops were appropriately tagged before being handed out. This will further bake in the inequities already present in our garbage education system. Those that have, will have more, better experiences due to involved parents (because they have flexible or even just able-to-be-completed remotely jobs). This will be an enrichment period for those students. If I had a high achieving middle schooler at a high income district, this would be amazing for their development. For those that don't have, they're losing 3-6 months of education, at a minimum. For my child, even with two highly educated parents, due to a lack of resources and access to technology, this will be a loss. Source: My career in rural, urban, and suburban education, both k-12 and higher education.
- whatshisface 7y agoIf it's really so great for the high income students, then maybe the schools there should be shut down permanently so the money can be redirected to where they are necessary.
- mattnewton 7y agoThen the dual income parents would have to find another place to put their kids in during the day.
- gedy 7y agoWhile Internet makes life a bit more convenient, there are books and telephones. We can do something vs just "no education is possible!"
- gmfawcett 7y agoFor example, see "school of the air", an Australian rural education program that used to run over radio. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/School_of_the_Air https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/School_of_the_Air Australia has long been a world leader in distance education, likely because they had such a large problem, and a head start on solving it.
- stefan_ 7y agoThe kids will just retreat to their study? At a lot of homes, there are much bigger challenges than just internet access.
- richjdsmith 7y agoYep. Post service is still working. People have been homeschooling their children long before the internet became ubiquitous.
- dorchadas 7y agoOur school barely has enough books to cover three classes, let alone the entire grade. Likewise, I've tried calling students on the numbers their parents listed both on the syllabus and on the official enrollment forms have still have sometimes had it unanswered.
- dorchadas 7y agoI'm a teacher in a low-income rural area in the South and, try as I might, there's still some students I haven't been able to get ahold of. They don't have phones, or just didn't join Remind for whatever reason, and their parents didn't give me an email address. Hell, I've tried calling some on the numbers the school has on file, or that they gave me, to no success. It's quite frustrating from the teacher's perspective too, as I really just wanna make sure they're doing OK and that they get their stuff turned in... Though our administration did pretty much assume to expect nothing once we went to packets/online work, despite how much they threatened to place any students who didn't do it in in-school suspension or even fail them.
- musicale 7y ago> Summer break began when LAUSD went online for a lot of kids Summer vacation is highly beneficial and better than typical schools in so many ways: getting to choose more of what you want to do and pursue your own interests, under your own motivation, without stressful testing and evaluation, at your own pace. You also get more exercise and the chance to play less structured games that aren't organized or controlled by adults. But even if kids sit at home and play video games all day, I'm pretty sure their math, language, and problem solving skills will improve more than they would if they spent the same amount of time in a typical LA classroom.
- UweSchmidt 7y agoI vividly remember 35 years my kindergarden having a leaking roof, and the ensuing 'chaos', with all groups together and all toys spread around, led to a sense of freedom and interaction and play I hadn't had otherwise. Similarly I fondly remember many stretches of extended free time during my school years but also times of pressure, boredom and a sense failure at school. I believe that this sort of exceptional free time does wonder for the psyches of those kids. The sense of "occupying" the public parks that are usually dominiated by grown ups is something kids these days don't often have. Back in the days we still wandered around in groups and had a chance to explore a forest or whatever.
- notacoward 7y agoIf education is a basic right/requirement, then so is internet access.