20 ms·
Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981)
- sjwright 7y agoAnd the real question is: will history repeat itself with Netflix, et al? HBO demonstrates that it’s still an open question.
- elliekelly 7y agoI’ve recently noticed some Hulu shows that let you know you’ll see ads even if you subscribe to ad-free Hulu.
- zdragnar 7y agoIIRC, the licensing arrangement between Hulu and the network prohibits not showing ads on those shows, or some such nonsense.
- beerandt 7y agoThe networks have always entirely owned Hulu. It's that way because they want it to be. Netflix has no such network licensing problems.
- tzs 7y agoHow quickly does Netflix get those shows? I believe Hulu gets them the day after broadcast. Maybe the network licensing term are different depending on the delay between broadcast and streaming?
- culturestate 7y agoAs far as I know, Netflix negotiates those rights independently so it varies per network. They're doing a new-ish model now, though, where Netflix actually pays to co-produce content with networks in exchange for getting faster and/or exclusive streaming access. The most high-profile example off the top of my head is the new Michael Jordan doc; they split the cost with ESPN, and Netflix gets next-day international rights and accelerated domestic streaming rights (3 months after broadcast, I think).
- rhino369 7y agoNetflix doesn't have the problem because they never had ads. Hulu likely signed a deal with ABC (or the production company who make the shows) for those three shows that still have ads before they had the idea to go commercial free. Changing a deal that had a provision about ads is expensive. Hulu was a joint venture between several networks. There are three old shows that still have commercials due to old contracts that were made before they switched to the new business model. Given TV deals are complicated (for example, the networks likely have revenue deals with production companies), its not worth a huge renegotiation.
- icelancer 7y agoThat's tremendous. That type of brazen not-give-a-shit is impressive to me, as abhorrent as it is.
- scarface74 7y agoThere are three shows with ads on Hulu without ads. https://help.hulu.com/s/article/hulu-no-ads?language=en_US#still-see-ads https://help.hulu.com/s/article/hulu-no-ads?language=en_US#s... The additional shows you can get on demand without Hulu Live TV have ads. But that’s more akin to traditional cable.
- elliekelly 7y agoHow interesting! The list must update with some frequency because I don’t watch any of the shows currently listed in that link yet I’ve encountered the message a handful of times. The three current shows listed are: - Grey’s Anatomy - Marvel’s Agents of SHIELD - How to Get Away with Murder
- rjtobin 7y agoI think there’s a chance it will be different: at least now there is the potential to offer customers an ad-free package for an extra cost. Some services like Hulu already do this (offering cheaper plan with ads and a slightly pricier plan with no ads). I think with cable this would have been difficult or impossible to achieve. One nice thing about this is it makes plain how much the networks make from showing ads to your household. I happily pay a little extra to “outbid” the ad networks.
- dicknuckle 7y agowe actually split Hulu with a friend. we pay the difference between basic and no-ads. it's an auto payment from bank account to bank account every month. life on autopilot.
- 0xff00ffee 7y agoNot true. HULU still shows ads, even with "No Ads" version. From their website: Hulu (No Ads) Get First Month Free then $11.99/month A few excluded shows play with ads. [from here https://signup.hulu.com/plans https://signup.hulu.com/plans] That last line kills me. It's like H2G2, you can't have Tea and No Tea unless you remove your common sense particle.
- dlbucci 7y agoI mean, you're not wrong, but it's only for three shows, and there are no ads during the shows, only before and after. It was 7 when it first launched, so it doesn't seem like any other shows or new content will ever have ads. But hey, if you watch Agents of Shield, Grey's Anatomy, or How to Get Away with Murder, that surely does suck.
- 0xff00ffee 7y agoHuh. Thanks for figuring out what shows have ads! Yeah, I guess that isn't as bad as it seems if there are just a few. I didn't bother to look up what "excluded" meant.
- mavhc 7y agoSelling ads globally seems like it's more expensive, unless you automate it like Google etc do, so they'd rather stick to just having subscriptions and be considered premium content.
- leereeves 7y ago> HBO demonstrates that it’s still an open question. What do you mean? Is HBO or HBO Go adding commercials?
- SubiculumCode 7y agoI assume he means that because HBO does not show ads, it is an open question of whether Netflix would try. Personally, I will not subscribe to services that show commercials. Commercials are for free services, not for paid services. As soon as you allow them to cross that boundary....
- leereeves 7y agoI feel the same way, but not everyone does. With that in mind I was wondering which Hulu plan was most popular. All I could find was the same widely syndicated Reuters article [1] from January 2019 calling the plan with ads "Hulu's most popular plan". I guess there is a market for streaming with ads. 1: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-hulu-prices/hulu-cuts-price-of-most-popular-plan-by-25-percent-idUSKCN1PH229 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-hulu-prices/hulu-cuts-pri...
- bonestamp2 7y agoThey're not selling ads, but they do run a 15-30 second spot before each episode advertising one of their own shows. That doesn't really bother me for now, but it seems like a slippery slope towards showing two spots, or three, or selling those spots to other advertisers. Side note, with all of the streaming subscriptions I have, I'm probably not saving any money compared to when I had traditional cable, but there are fewer commercials and the content is so much better.
- m463 7y agoFor every shitty experience, there is a market opportunity. (I hope. There hasn't been much of a market for privacy)
- qppo 7y agoAs long as I am given the option to purchase content without advertisements I will do so. If I can't watch a piece of content without ads, I'll either wait until I can or pirate it. Usually the former. Frankly I think content is just overvalued and the actual creation of content is extremely inefficient, from a financial point of view. My personal experience has been that Hollywood film/television studios are poorly run businesses with massive losses at each point in the process, but is laden down by individuals who do things because it's the way it's always been done, are hostile to innovation (both technology and in business), and are anti-consumer, anti-viewer, and frankly anti-making-money. It's honestly a terrible industry and needs to be disrupted. Market distortion is the only reason films cost what they do, from production to distribution and consumption. And literally everyone in the pipeline has an incentive to keep the market distorted, except people who watch content. Thank god for piracy.
- akhosravian 7y agoI’d be interested in hearing more about what you mean by market distortion here. A lot of the silliness in things like how much stars are paid seems applicable to software development — tiny incremental value adds become very substantial with a large enough audience.
- qppo 7y agoI don't know what it is off the top of my head but I think actor pay isn't that big a slice of the cost. What I mean by market distortion is really the lack of insight into value creation. How much value is created by whom in the pipeline, essentially. Data driven, direct to consumer enterprises are changing this a bit and that's great. But my experience is that data doesn't change minds of the top stakeholders, and there are incentives to make decisions that are bad for consumers even if the data says that both sides can win.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> My personal experience has been that Hollywood film/television studios are poorly run businesses with massive losses at each point in the process, but is laden down by individuals who do things because it's the way it's always been done, are hostile to innovation (both technology and in business), and are anti-consumer, anti-viewer, and frankly anti-making-money. Is it that, or is the industry mind-controlled by parasites to achieve a different goal than delivering quality entertainment cost-effectively? "Hollywood accounting" is a known term, and it doesn't describe being bad at making money - it describes being very good at making money for yourself by purposefully cheating those who actually brought in that money. (My general heuristic is that, if they're inefficiencies persisting despite competitive pressure, it's because it's these inefficiencies that are the real reason the business is done, and someone is making a good money off them.)
- dylan604 7y agoHBO also demands a higher fee than something like HGTV or A&E. The one that kills me is ESPN. It is the most expensive channel for a cable operator to carry, and it is also known as a must carry.
- scarface74 7y agoHBO is completely different than ESPN. You can choose to pay for HBO. You can’t choose to exclude ESPN.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoESPN (and consequently sports teams and their players) are about to find out how less valuable they are I think. There are so many options for entertainment that I doubt they will be able to command the wide audience they used to.
- jcfields 7y agoI think the difference is that the infrastructure is decoupled from the content now. Cable systems and satellite fleets were both traditionally very high barriers for new competitors to overcome. Granted, consolidated media oligopolies may get us to the same place a different way.
- 0x202020 7y agoI think they are bound to. You don’t think as soon as Disney can they aren’t going to start showing ads for everything Disney related? The worst step back to me from TV -> streaming -> streaming becoming more TV like is content release schedules. The Mandalorian on Disney Plus was a great example, you have all the episodes ready and there isn’t a good reason to keep them sitting behind a time gate. I would be much more likely to subscribe for a month to watch a show in a week than I would be to subscribe for a few months to few one show. Instead you get none of my money
- Talanes 7y agoCatering to the customers least interested in keeping the service isn't a great business strategy. Those who do only want to pay for one month to watch the whole show still have the option of subscribing during the last month of airing. Or any time after that.
- 0x202020 7y agoFor sure. It’s one of those things that my use case is probably a very, very small percent of users but it would be nice to be a bit more viewer friendly from that point of view. Right now since they have limited new content it feels like they are stretching them to keep subscribers as long as possible.
- Talanes 7y agoThat's 100% what they're doing. I imagine most their money is in people who aren't re-evaluating the subscription month to month, and just need some drip of new content to keep justifying inertia.
- hinoki 7y agoThere is no global schedule of programming any more, so there is room to have tiers with and without ads. So maybe it’s more like “Netflix with special offers”
- Animats 7y agoClassic ad, run in theaters, against Pay TV: https://archive.org/details/Drive-inSaveFreeTv https://archive.org/details/Drive-inSaveFreeTv
- tedunangst 7y ago"30-minute toy-store shows." Which arrived in 1984.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- downerending 7y agoIt's like a creeping cancer that cannot be stopped. Back around 1981, advertisers would take a certain percentage of ad pages in each newspaper or magazine and consider it a reasonable deal. These days, they absolutely will not accept this unless they get a lot more space, obnoxious animations, force-play videos, and overlays that you have to click through, and often various registration walls, cross-site tracking, etc. They have only themselves to blame for ad blocking. With ML, eventually this will become pervasive, even into the physical world. (My VR goggles will gray out billboards, etc.)
- judge2020 7y ago> My VR goggles will gray out billboards Only if the billboard doesn't qualify for "acceptable billboard ads" (or you could jailbreak and run a different billboard blocker like a rebel)
- nordsieck 7y ago> With ML, eventually this will become pervasive, even into the physical world. (My VR goggles will gray out billboards, etc.) Will your glasses grey out James Bond's Aston Martin in Goldfinger?
- llukas 7y agoWith style transfer improving a bit they can make it any brand ;P
- jagged-chisel 7y agoNot really necessary unless Bond’s current fling proclaims “This is a truly astonishing automobile, James. From which dealer is it available, and are there any current incentives?”
- celeritascelery 7y agoIf only advertising was so opaque.
- 7y ago
- bovermyer 7y agoIf advertising ever intrudes on streaming the way it did on cable, I'll just transition out of watching TV altogether. I don't care near as much about keeping up with the zeitgeist as I used to. Maybe I'm just getting old.
- etrautmann 7y agoYep, exactly. I refuse. I’m not sitting through any ads.
- pmiller2 7y agoMore importantly, I’m not paying to sit through ads.
- BurningFrog 7y agoThe TV zeitgeist is gone. People used to all watch the same shows at the same time.That made it the thing everyone had in common. Now TV is more like reading books. Everyone does it n their own time. It's still a big things, but it doesn't create a nationwide community. On top of this, you're also getting old :)
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoIf you heard about Game of Thrones or Westworld or Stranger Things, or most recently, Tiger King, you'd realize this is very much still a thing for a large population. Weekly shows of certain types have massive speculation and plot discussion crowds with podcasts and analysis channels. Then there's a second viewership wave created by all the memes. Netflix's just drop the whole season model has cost them a lot in public discussion and hence hype, some of their shows are now released in a weekly format to better capture the hype cycle.
- ygjb 7y agoI that because of the hype cycle, or is that because they have distribution and creative partnerships with other distributors?
- caseysoftware 7y agoIt's amazing how much commercials have crept in. If you watch an "hour long" show from the early 80s, it's roughly 48 minutes. If you watch a similar show from 10-15 years ago, it's closer to 44-45 and in the last few years, it's more like 42 minutes. I assume it's only going to get worse as TV ad revenue drops faster with more alternatives.
- jandrese 7y agoWatch broadcast TV and you'll notice that hour long TV shows are in 1:15 timeslots because they need to pack in an extra 15 minutes of ads. Or the show will have bits cut out like half of the opening, the start and end of some scenes, etc...
- timcederman 7y agoDo you have a citation for this? It's been 42-44 minutes of content for at least the last 20 years in my experience.
- magicalhippo 7y agoChecked some episodes from some shows I had available, first seasons, DVD or Bluray source: Miami Vice (1984): 48m Homicide Life On The Streets (1993): 47m TekWar (1994): 45m Nowhere Man (1995): 45m Battlestar Galactica (2003): 44m Dark Matter (2015): 43m 12 Monkeys (2015): 43m Lucifer (2015): 43m There are exceptions though. Legion (2017) episodes are around 50m, and several of the newer "made for streaming" shows have 50-60m episodes.
- caseysoftware 7y agoThanks. The pattern isn't perfect but the trend is clear. These are Season 1, excluding pilots. A-Team (1983): 49m MacGyver (1985, original): 48m Quantum Leap (1989): 47-48m X-Files (1993): 43-44m Monk (2002): 44m Eureka (2006): 44m MacGyver (2016, remake): 42-43m
- johnbatch 7y agoBig Bang Theory - 18-20 mins https://trakt.tv/shows/the-big-bang-theory/seasons/10 https://trakt.tv/shows/the-big-bang-theory/seasons/10 Brooklyn Nine-Nine - 21 mins https://trakt.tv/shows/brooklyn-nine-nine/seasons/7 https://trakt.tv/shows/brooklyn-nine-nine/seasons/7 The Office - 22 mins https://trakt.tv/shows/the-office/seasons/9 https://trakt.tv/shows/the-office/seasons/9 M.A.S.H - 24 mins https://trakt.tv/shows/m-a-s-h/seasons/10 https://trakt.tv/shows/m-a-s-h/seasons/10 Golden Girls - 24 mins https://trakt.tv/shows/the-golden-girls/seasons/1 https://trakt.tv/shows/the-golden-girls/seasons/1 Cheers - 24 mins https://trakt.tv/shows/cheers/seasons/10 https://trakt.tv/shows/cheers/seasons/10
- sarajevo 7y agoThis promise did not age well: >“We won't break programming at awkward times,'' promises Dick Cox, president of CBS Cable,
- rollingbarreler 7y agoWhat a name to have
- WheelsAtLarge 7y agoI will bet a lot that Netflix is headed this way too. Once Netflix stops growing, it will need to find additional growth, and advertisement will be the way to additional profit.
- janesvilleseo 7y agoPossibly. But with original content it may just be through syndication as well.
- mjrpes 7y agoAlso, in-show product placements.
- missedthecue 7y agoThey already do this
- banana_giraffe 7y agoI've been waiting for the day for shows on Netflix to start replacing in-show things like posters on the wall with recent ads.
- pests 7y agoShows and networks have already been doing this for a very long time. https://www.hypable.com/how-i-met-your-mother-is-inserting-new-ads-into-old-episodes/ https://www.hypable.com/how-i-met-your-mother-is-inserting-n...
- 4ec0755f5522 7y agoIs anyone still doing this? That company (SeamBI) is long dead. (Domain for sale, twitter nonactive since 2012, etc.)
- the_duke 7y ago
- alexmingoia 7y agoThe market is big enough for ad-free options. HBO built a business providing ad-free TV entertainment. The Economist built a business selling ad-free news periodicals. YouTube provides a paid ad-free option. You could look at the Web and say “it’s littered with ads” or you could look at the Web and say “it’s the largest collection of free information on the planet.”
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> YouTube provides a paid ad-free option. It's an "ad-free", with a large disclaimer under asterisk. > you could look at the Web and say “it’s the largest collection of free information on the planet.”* Or you could look at the way advertising influences curation of information, and how the viability of ad-based business models mean there's incentive to create sites with things that promise, but not deliver, information. You could look at that and say that the Internet is the largest collection of free disinformation on the planet. Most places that give reliable information do not show or involve themselves with advertising.
- alexmingoia 7y agoI have a different perspective and experience. Ads have enabled me to access information at little to no cost to me. Ads enable us to search the Internet. I learned to exercise, eat healthy, and much more from watching YouTube. I’ve learned a lot from newspapers and blogs. I’ve learned a lot from people on Twitter. Do I enjoy advertising? No, usually not. But from my perspective it’s a win-win. Companies promote their products and I get to read things for free. Look on the bright side.
- zxcvbn4038 7y agoIm enjoying Hulu/Netflix/Prime Video while I can. My kid has grown up in a household without commercials and where you get points for who can hit “skip” the fastest when one does pop up. Commercials were always annoying but when you aren’t used to seeing them then it really hits home that your seeing the exact same commercial for floor wax sixteen times an hour and the exact same commercial for anti-AIDS drugs sixteen times per hour. You can forgive broadcast TV - someone had money to spend and wanted to hawk floor wax to the ethos excessively. But lets look at YouTube for example - their algorithms are supposed to be so sophisticated but I’m outside every desirable demographic except maybe not dead, I don’t impulse buy, I don’t have any wax able floors, if I did I would switch apartments before waxing them, and I downvote, skip, or just kill the youtube app every time I see a commercial. I should be number one in the lost cause file, but instead they keep showing me the same stuff that I’ve already downloaded, skipped, stopped transferring countless times. How do you explain that in the era of machine learning and no holds barred privacy invasion?
- anpat 7y agoProbably because it still earns them money over not showing you anything! I have come to believe that over a period of time producers and consumers both will realise that the middleman cares more about it’s own cut over either of them. Less cynical thoughts; 1. I don’t know if and what kind of controls/flexibility YouTube allows on demand side, but it could be a “foot meet gun” story. ie advertiser is new to platform and messed up targeting and/or is over-bidding. 2. Advertiser might think 1 cent CPM is worth it, no one else bothers to bid on your data (based on your description) - still kinda ties into cynical view.
- war1025 7y ago> the middleman cares more about it’s own cut over either of them. Rational self interest, as they say.
- jwr 7y agoThey get paid for displaying the ads to you, so that's what they do :-) It's really that simple. And they will continue to do that while advertisers get a return on their ads (it isn't clear if they do, sometimes it can take a while for the market to realize that a certain fad strategy simply does not work). But I'm guessing it does work.
- klausjensen 7y agoI don't pirate because I don't want to pay for content - I pirate because it is the only way I can get a lot of content. I wish there was a global way to subscribe to and pay for content in a market/app-independant way. If you are not in the USA, Canada or UK, your options to pay for the most popular, newest content are very, very limited. And if you are in a very small and/or somewhat impoverished country, forget about it. "Sorry, this content is not available in your region. Please go fuck yourself". Luckily, Netflix has improved this a lot (which is why I happily pay for it), but for a lot of content, it is still impossible to consume in a legal way.
- kinleyd 7y agoComing from a very small and somewhat impoverished country, I agree fully with your comment. I enjoy Netflix now, and am warming up a lot to the NBA and NFL's League Pass subscriptions. These three have nailed it for me price-wise and content-wise, so much so that I'm considering switching from European/UEFA football viewing to the NBA and NFL. Outside of this, my only option is piracy - there isn't any other way.
- nolok 7y ago> I wish there was a global way to subscribe to and pay for content in a market/app-independant way. The socialist party (biggest left wing party at the time, and in power 2012-2016)here in France talked at lengtht about this idea during Sarkozy's implementation of the repressive Hadopi system. Pay a yearly fee, don't get punished for pirating, money gets redistributed. Similar but also vastly different to how we already have a specific contribution for French state medias, and then one to finance French production (movies, music,...). It didn't get past the heavy talk part because no matter how you turn it, the abuse / unfair redistribution / increasing need unrealistic compared to usage is unavoidable.
- RedShift1 7y agoI've argued about this numerous times: ISP's need to provide customers with an opt-in p2p license that adds a small fee to their monthly bill. This monthly fee is transferred to a central authority, the ISP does not make any profit from this fee. The license would allow users to torrent whatever content they want. Torrent trackers would be fully legal, their only legal obligation would be keeping track of torrent popularity and reporting this to the central authority every month or so. The central authority that receives the money from the ISP's then forwards the money to the creators of the content being distributed, divided based on the popularity reported by the trackers. A minimum baseline amount is provided to each creator to subsidize indie and struggling creators. And obviously geoblocking should be illegal but as the media companies would be making more money if they didn't geoblock, it gives them incentive to not do that.
- Jemm 7y agoI don’t understand why people pay upwards of $200 a month for a television service that plays ads every three minutes
- JKCalhoun 7y agoThey crossed the line for me. Someone wiser than me said they'll put as many ads as we will tolerate. Imagine that when "Star Trek" was originally airing, the episodes could be 50 minutes long to allow for commercials in a 60 minute slot. By the time Star Trek was in reruns in the 80's they were cutting a few minutes here and there to allow for the longer commercial time. By the time the cable Sci-Fi (or was it Sy-Fy yet?) aired them "un cut" they had to put them into a 90 minute slot. Sometime before the latter example, I ended up cutting the cord: stopped paying for television. You have to decide where the line is for you and act.
- SamuelAdams 7y ago> ''Propaganda masquerading as information'' is the reaction of Peggy Charren, president of Action for Children's Television, to such proposed programs. Unless there are sufficient safeguards, viewers - especially children - may find it difficult to distinguish between the program and the advertisement, says Mrs. Charren, raising the specter of ''30-minute toy-store shows.'' It's interesting how a generation raised in war (WWII, Vietnam) was very sensitive to propaganda and how it influenced their children. Whereas today, propaganda is spread on TV networks, the internet, and other news sources and yet very few people stop and ask what the intent of the source of information is.
- fdgwhite 7y agoI worked in b2b publishing for a while. Magazines are just ad delivery systems so they need to sell ads. But ad buyers need to sell their product too and and their job is to buy ads. They can’t go back at the end of the year and tell their boss “look at all the money I saved by not advertising“.
- PunksATawnyFill 7y agoFunny how far things have gone. "Basic cable" had ads, but it was "free," as in included with your base-level subscription. But then basic-cable channels like MTV decided to try to charge for their viewership, AND have commercials. So now you're supposed to PAY to watch commercials. But let's face it: The stupidity of the public seems to have no bottom. Look what Apple gets away with.