10 ms·
Why Sex? Biologists Find New Explanations
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- globular-toast 7y agoThe author fails to mention what is probably the largest downside to sex: an entire half of the population is completely unable to reproduce. The question "why do we have sex?" could be restated as "why do males exist?" Unfortunately the answers to that question trouble some people so it's difficult to establish the truth. The simple answer comes down to the fact that a species has to find a balance between maintaining genetic diversity, which is important for resilience and adaptation, and maintaining a strong breeding population. Males are there to allow some really wacky variations to exist that just wouldn't be viable in females. It only takes a tiny handful of males to take part in reproduction, but it takes essentially all females (especially considering they are only 50% of the population to begin with).
- microcolonel 7y agoEven acknowledging the basic fact that males have more diverse expression is touchy these days on its own, I find; possibly because people are upset that men and women won't simply be hammered into the same form.
- aaron-lebo 7y agoYou guys mind backing up your facts? > The simple answer comes down to the fact that a species has to find a balance between maintaining genetic diversity, which is important for resilience and adaptation, and maintaining a strong breeding population. > the basic fact that males have more diverse expression Not to be a jerk, but you guys are just throwing out this stuff without backing it up and it's not at all self-evident to me. How are males more diverse? Kind of feels like a big reason why this stuff is touchy is cause we're just saying things without having evidence for it, so yeah, there's not a lot of common ground to discuss.
- hi5eyes 7y agomen and women take on equally risky roles to attain wealth, status and attract partners
- microcolonel 7y ago> Not to be a jerk, but you guys are just throwing out this stuff without backing it up and it's not at all self-evident to me. Well as for "you guys", I don't know this guy, I'm just adding my two cents to this dollar. As for it being self-evident: of course it's not self-evident, that's why it's a matter for scientific research. Your answers will be found searching for literature, not impugning the motives of random strangers on Hacker News.
- virgilp 7y agoWould you care to give pointers to a stranger who would be interested in reading said scientific research?
- aaron-lebo 7y agoIt really wasn't a knock at your motives and it wasn't personal. I just feel like if you are going to make statements and even go so far as to label them as fact, it is your job to back it up.
- LifeLiverTransp 7y agoIf i remember, the distribution in men is greater. (https://www.aei.org/carpe-diem/chart-of-the-day-scottish-iq-test-scores-by-gender-reveal-the-greater-variability-of-male-intelligence/ https://www.aei.org/carpe-diem/chart-of-the-day-scottish-iq-...) Also the expression of neuro-diversity is usually more severe (do not have a linke for that one). While we are at it, can we talk about the loop deformation, too? Aka, evolution as a blind machinery, adapting humanity to the cycle of strife, by allowing neuro-diverse speacilizations to exist, which in turn try to propagate the circumstances they thrive in. Thanks to science, we had a nice 90 years of surplus and plenty, basically bribing ourselves out of natures grasp. Now the whole messy affair returns with a vengance, and it will be interesting to see, if leviathan-cybernetics ( aka societal implants (cellphones, self-surveilance etc.)) can reign the forces of the old world in, were wishfull thinking and society regulation mechanisms (religions, rules, etc.)fail.
- msoad 7y agoI feel you didn’t read the entire article. They study single gender and asexual species for exactly that assumption you made
- Spooky23 7y agoI get what you're saying, but I think facts suggest that this isn't downside with significant impact. Populations seem to grow just fine in all sexually reproducing species as long as conditions are ok. Even some of the poorest countries have very high fertility rates, as high as 6-7 births per female, so availability of women is not an issue.
- jedimastert 7y agoThese comments make me sad. I thought the HN community was better than this.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- foobarbecue 7y agoYour comment is at the top now for me... So you might want to be more specific about your complaint.
- throwaway6575 7y agoHN is notoriously bad at anything related to biology, evolution, and genetics. It's a combination of this (https://xkcd.com/1831/ https://xkcd.com/1831/) and this (https://xkcd.com/793/ https://xkcd.com/793/) comic. People there are also fond of finding a bunch of psychology papers that confirms existing biases. There's also a misleading phenomenon where many of the fields whose "experts" chime in on these questions are called evolutionary psychology or behavioral genetics, making you think that these fields are related to biology and enjoy the same methodological standards of rigor as well as the same consensus from biologists. In reality these fields approach the questions from psychology, and that one field is known for having a bunch of practices, biases and motivated reasoning that'd make many a biologist reluctant to touch it with a ten feet pole. It's very elegant to see the sleight of hand in action: someone makes a claim about sex, arguing it's a biological reality, and when challenged backs up their claim with a psych paper from a field that disguises as one from biologists and pretends that his claim enjoys a widespread consensus among actual scientists (as opposed to just psychologists). Hence, the claim isn't ideologically motivated, it's just science. Beautiful
- vikramkr 7y agoThere are at least a few of us on here that are actual biologists- and with the increasing overlap of biotech and hacking, maybe we'll see more of us on here soon? Especially with how much HN seems to enjoy bio related threads, it's nice to see people at least engaging with the subject. And it looks like with time some of the poorer faith comments do get buried, however plentiful they may be.
- itchyjunk 7y agoI like how the article starts but I think it got lost a bit in hypothetical and anecdotes towards the end. Not holding it against the article though. As the article rightly points out, anything involving sex drags in biases as well. I wonder how convergent evolution [0] fits into this? Maybe one form of reproduction leaves a large niche open for another type of reproduction to fill in. Could it be that there was sexual reproduction first and asexual reproduction came later? We always assume the other way around. But maybe conditions were initially always stressful and only after conditions improved (I am thinking of conditions on Earth when these single cells organisms were evolving) did asexual reproduction start. Last question, is meiosis and mitosis the only two way to reproduce? I had never really though about it until now. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convergent_evolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convergent_evolution
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoViruses
- Koshkin 7y agoSexual reproduction is not about injecting a DNA (or RNA) into a host cell for one's own sake.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoOk that sounds a bit pedantic. Reproduction is a technical term, sure. But its also a common term for life copying itself. But ok, sure.
- smilekzs 7y ago> Last question, is meiosis and mitosis the only two way to reproduce? GP answer is a valid example?
- ARandomerDude 7y agoThe problem is you need two complete sets of reproductive organs simultaneously. If either the male or female has a single defective organ, nothing works.
- sharadov 7y agoThis is pretty amazing - the fact that it can be immunity-boosting and slow age-related brain function. This is an area that needs to be explored further.
- known 7y agoSex is good for your heart A hug keeps tension away Sex can be a stress buster Weekly sex might help fend off illness People who have sex feel healthier Loving support reduces risk of angina and ulcer https://www.nhs.uk/live-well/sexual-health/benefits-of-love-sex-relationships/ https://www.nhs.uk/live-well/sexual-health/benefits-of-love-...
- jshevek 7y agoThat quoting style is for code. It is difficult to read on mobile.
- vikramkr 7y agoThe article really highlights that there's likely not one single explanation for sex - increasing diversity, decreasing diversity through gene repairs. Same-sex behaviors potentially being something not just even worth being selected against, highlighting the "good enough" nature of natural selection where not everything needs a reason. A good read on the complexity behind explaining phenomena with natural selection - billions of years or random chance + selection pressures has no requirement to result in clean, neat, and easy explanations for complex phenomena.
- reubenswartz 7y agoI'm not a biologist, but my understanding is that bacteria are much more likely to undergo horizontal gene transfer when undress stress. (Particularly troubling these days for antibiotic resistance.) Seems like it would be a natural next step for single cell eukaryotes to have a similar mechanism to fix bad DNA, especially given the much longer genomes of eukaryotes, which the article discusses without mentioning bacteria. By the time you get to multicellular creatures, this gets even more important and leads to males, who pass on only nuclear DNA, and females, who pass one nuclear and mitochondrial DNA.
- koeng 7y agoEukaryotes don’t really evolve very much on the protein level - their complexity allows them to mostly evolve on the regulatory level (while bacteria often still are on the protein level). Practically, this means that getting proteins from elsewhere isn’t that selected for, while better regulation is. It’s a complicated subject, but that’s partially why there is so much “junk” dna in multicellular eukaryotes (single cellular like yeast are still pretty efficient)
- reubenswartz 7y agoMy primitive understanding is that the bottleneck for bacterial reproduction is DNA replication, so there’s a huge incentive to shed unneeded DNA, especially with mechanisms to get genes back via HGT. Am I right in thinking that the more efficient chromosome replication in eukaryotes doesn’t penalize junk dna the same way, so it can just stick around?
- econcon 7y agoIf same sex attraction exists biologically, not as a social construct than it's possible those genes are select as side effect of smth else that comes with it. For example, my gay friend is godlike attractive and one girl literally begged him to marry him in really sick ways and he's ended up marrying her to make his life easier and also because she was completely attached and attracted to us just because of how he looked. Few months ago, they had a kid. Has there been any studies which can shed some light on this, if gay people are more attractive on average or more intelligent?
- slfnflctd 7y agoThis is really more of a silly and non-scientific anecdotal pursuit of probably very little value. That being said, I have heard many women say, "Oh, he's way too hot to be straight". So I think there is at least some kind of meme-level support for the idea. I have also met lots of very wonderful, very gay, quite-less-than-stereotypically-attractive people who could warm almost any soul with the way their smiles lit up their faces. For whatever any of that is worth.
- jmeister 7y agoWow can we see a picture of this Adonis please?
- tuan 7y ago>> It increases genetic diversity in the pool of offspring. That diversity could then raise the fitness of future generations by making them stronger, faster, more resistant to parasites or otherwise more adaptable Probably off topic, but I didn't know this was not a commonly accepted explanation. When I went to school (maybe middle school) in Vietnam in the early 90s, I was taught this. My biology teacher said this explains why marriage between closed relatives is not recommended because it leads to less diversity, and a bad gene would have chance to manifest.
- Marsymars 7y agoReproduction between close relatives isn't recommended because of the chance of offspring getting multiple recessive genes. That's orthogonal to the genetic diversity benefits from sexual reproduction. (In asexual reproduction, you don't have to worry about offspring inheriting multiple recessive genes.)
- koeng 7y agoC. elegans is a good example of this. They have males and hermaphordites, but interestingly enough, the ratios of those two from lab and wild strains differed by quite a bit. Turns out, in a stable lab environment, hermaphrodites were more efficient. However, once you started changing the environment populations with males could always adapt faster.
- jackcosgrove 7y ago> Nedelcu and her colleagues found that if you alleviate their physiological stress — by providing them with a boost of antioxidants — they don’t have sex. Well that explains a lot. In all seriousness, I find that the idea in the article raises another question. If mating can increase individual fitness by sharing something, how is that explanation of sex different than being a member of a social group? Social species take the idea even further. Is sex simply the building block for social behaviors, and more sophisticated adaptations beyond sex are now available?