21 ms·
Valve's Proton Has Brought 6000 Windows Games to Linux So Far
- StavrosK 7y agoHow can I tell if a game is playable via Proton versus being natively supported?
- everdrive 7y agoI believe natively supported games still receive the "Steamplay" icon, whereas proton-supported games will show the Windows icon, but will install and run on Linux. (assuming proton is configure)
- albertzeyer 7y agoSo how do you know if a game with only the Windows icon is supported (via Proton)?
- Zhyl 7y agowww.protondb.com
- mrighele 7y agoLast time I checked by default only a limited number of verified titles is playable with Proton, so if it appears in your list, it should work well. You can enable Proton for all your games, although then I think there is no way to distinguish a verified title from the others.
- coldpie 7y agoThe official whitelist lives here, https://steamdb.info/app/891390/info/ https://steamdb.info/app/891390/info/ about halfway down in the "SteamPlay App Mappings" section. It has very stringent requirements and is not often updated. ProtonDB may be a better place to get an idea if a game is "playable," as opposed to the "perfect" that the whitelist is aiming for.
- Zhyl 7y agoYou can check for individual games or run a check against your whole steam library (by authenticating with Steam) at ProtonDB [1]. [1] www.protondb.com
- StavrosK 7y agoThat's very useful, thank you. EDIT: Clickable: https://www.protondb.com https://www.protondb.com
- ekianjo 7y agoCheck protondb.com as well
- 0xdeadbeee 7y agoProton has been a game changer for me: after many years on Linux only I ended up building a gaming rig a few years ago as I wanted to get back into gaming.The plan was to dual boot and only use Windows for gaming, but in practice rebooting all the time is just too much of a pain so I was using Windows almost exclusively there, with all the related frustrations. About 6 months ago I got myself a new SSD and made a fresh install of Linux with steam and Proton and I've been amazed a the performance and game support. Of course not all games work out of the box (and some not at all), but I haven't had to boot to Windows in months. And for the games I play the frame rate is at least as good as what I used to have on Windows (on a couple of games I do get occasional drops, but nothing too distracting). I play a lot of Assetto Corsa Competizione and my G27 steering wheel even worked out of the box!
- augusto-moura 7y agoIn other discussion someone pointed out about passing a gpu to a windows kvm[1] and getting the output back to linux[2]. I never tried but seems really promising, might try it someday [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22905390#22906984 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22905390#22906984 [2] https://looking-glass.hostfission.com https://looking-glass.hostfission.com
- tgb 7y agoI hadn't heard of Proton before and the article doesn't explain. Here's what the GitHub repo for it says [1]: > Proton is a tool for use with the Steam client which allows games which are exclusive to Windows to run on the Linux operating system. It uses Wine to facilitate this. My question is, what's the "secret sauce"? If this is in fact that much more successful than Wine, what's different? Is Valve putting lots of dev time into it? Or is it just pre-configured for ease of use? [1] https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Proton https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Proton
- chipperyman573 7y agoIt's valve putting a lot of dev time into it. Part of that dev time was spent on making it pre-configured for ease of use
- joerickard 7y agoYes, it will also use a known good version of wine for a particular game. Switching versions manually to find one that worked for old or newer games had been a headache; that work is now done by proton.
- m4rtink 7y agoTo me it seems like a kind of Wine staging, with patches not ready to be merged into the Wine mainline, yet could make some game run or run better. Over time as the code is proven in production and/or is cleaned up to upstream standards, it can be merged to upstream Wine, reducing the difference. Also IIRC there are some other pieces that are not (yet?) part of Wine, that are distributed with it, such as the various DirectX->Vulkan translation layers.
- ekianjo 7y agoIt's Wine + DXVK (including D9VK since they merged together) + ESync with a different Wine environment for each game. Valve also helped Codeweavers developers to implement controllers support thru Wine.
- 7y ago
- danielscrubs 7y agoThe only things these things teach me is that "Platinum - It runs perfectly" is that ProtonDB creators clearly have a different view on perfect. "Doom Eternal runs perfectly - it just have some pink flickering every minute!" "runs perfectly - it just closes when you try to start it." "runs perfectly - multiplayer doesn't work though." Microsoft can change DirectX whenever they want, that goalpost is always going to change to suit them, so why even play them at their game? Create a standard, ask Unity and Unreal Engine to support it, take a smaller cut when buying the Linux version on Steam.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hutzlibu 7y agoI share your criticism, but just "Create a standard" is maybe a bit hard to do. Game devs need a market. The linux market is not really the biggest one, neither in numbers, nor in money. It only became a bit relevant, because Valve used linux, to threaten Microsoft, as they tried to get a big cut of game sales, with their own market. So good for linux, yes, but the normal linux game market is still quite uninteresting (mildly put) for publishers.
- lawl 7y ago> I share your criticism, but just "Create a standard" is maybe a bit hard to do. The linux market is not really the biggest one, neither in numbers, nor in money. I know of at least one game that's regularly in the Steam top 10 (Path of Exile) that is doing a port from DirectX to such a standard, Vulkan. Not to support Linux, but because Vulkan is cross-platform, allowing them to reuse their code base for a mobile game, and also to be able to potentially support things such as Stadia. They also said this will lead to a mac port and may lead to a Linux port. So there might actually be incentives already for game devs to use cross-platform tech, which could lower the barrier for Linux ports significantly and make it worthwile.
- hutzlibu 7y ago
- chaorace 7y agoProton has been fantastic for me, it finally gave me what I needed to reclaim my Windows partition and go full-on Arch! In some cases, running the Windows version inside Proton has actually worked out better for me than the native port (Dead Cells, for example. The native port crashes the Steam overlay and lacks Steam Controller support, but running the Windows version in Proton is seamless) I highly encourage you guys to check out the tech making this possible: DXVK. It's incredible what you can do with these lower level APIs. I'm not sure if this is the right word, but "meta shader pipelines" like this are absolutely the way of the future in emulation. See also: Dolphin Ubershaders. Ubershaders: https://dolphin-emu.org/blog/2017/07/30/ubershaders/ https://dolphin-emu.org/blog/2017/07/30/ubershaders/
- ekianjo 7y agoDXVK also works on Windows, to translate DX11 calls to Vulkan and pipe them thru the graphics card's own Vulkan driver. Video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FVYprONeDtY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FVYprONeDtY
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> In some cases, running the Windows version inside Proton has actually worked out better for me than the native port I, for one, am not surprised. Windows userland APIs are more stable, consistent, and well documented than their Linux equivalents.
- elteto 7y agoThe implication from the comment was that Wine is better at running old Windows games than Windows itself. I’m not sure where this Linux vs. Windows comparison is coming from.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoI don't believe that is correct. > (Dead Cells, for example. The native port crashes the Steam overlay and lacks Steam Controller support, but running the Windows version in Proton is seamless) Suggests the comment is about running the Windows version under Proton being a better experience than running the native Linux version.
- bsharitt 7y agoI don't have a lot of of super current AAA titles, so most of my games that didn't already work on Linux(most of what I buy) already worked on Wine. But with the Proton integration, I do appreciate that I don't have to run a separate Wine instance of steam and instead running my Windows games is far more transparent. I guess the only minor downside is that since the whole process is so transparent it makes it a bit more jarring when I do come across a game that doesn't work.
- Lewton 7y agoProton worked decently for VR last I tried 6 months ago. But I started it up again recently and everything is broken now, partially due to steam updates and partially due to updates to Unity. The entire reason I moved to Linux was because I loathe forced updates >:(
- dsego 7y agoFor me it worked better than Windows for the Bioshock remastered series. On Win 10 the games would crash every few times during saving. I tried every workaround I could find but nothing helped. On Ubuntu the games worked fine.
- chungus 7y agoAmazing, you can buy a triple A title and have it just work out of the box. I'm so happy with Valve's support for linux. And of course the thousands of hours of work that have gone into Wine. It's becoming a more reliable experience to play old windows games using wine than trying to run them on windows 10.
- carlio 7y agoI wonder if you can install Wine under WSL? :evil laugh:
- mmm_grayons 7y agoBetter still, use VcXsrv or similar to run proton.
- freeone3000 7y agoYou want mobaxterm here - vcxsrv is amazingly slow with GLX workloads.
- semi-extrinsic 7y agoDoes it work with VNC and VirtualGL? If yes, this is my new favourite Windows thing.
- beernutz 7y agoIt does work with VNC. Not sure about VirtualGL though. It IS very comlete however, so it has a high likelihood I think.
- phonon 7y agohttps://reddragdiva.dreamwidth.org/607714.html https://reddragdiva.dreamwidth.org/607714.html
- recursive 7y ago
- w0utert 7y agoIs anyone using Linux + Proton for in-home streaming? I'm seriously considering to completely ditch Windows 10 and move my gaming to PS4/5 + Linux/Proton, but I still want to be able to stream games from the game PC to the steam link in the living room. Does this work just as well with Linux/Proton as Windows?
- Tyr42 7y agoI've streamed native linux games no problem. I'm not sure if I was streaming proton.
- ekianjo 7y agoIt works well, yes. However I can't compare with Windows since I don't have any Windows install anymore, so probably you need to get a comment from someone who dual boots! By the way you can also stream PS4 games to your Linux Desktop with Chiaki: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Afc_V73_3w&feature=emb_logo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Afc_V73_3w&feature=emb_logo
- narcolepsy 7y agoYeah I've had it running and streaming! Have run a few games this was - ARMA3, GTAV, South Park: Stick of Truth. All worked well. Have also tried running the windows steam client in WINE and had a few more issues, but as ever YMMV. The performance isn't quite as good (very close to windows perf levels), but quite a few anti-cheat systems will not work in Proton (even less so in WINE).
- dmos62 7y ago> quite a few anti-cheat systems will not work in Proton A lot of interesting "hacks" (sorry for calling gaming on Linux a hack) are made impractical by this. Another is that you can buy a miner's GPU (no video output, but much cheaper) and modify the drivers to route video through integrated graphics VO. Or, modify drivers to support SLI on any nvidia card. These driver modifications require running Windows in a special mode, which triggers anti-cheats. Maybe there's a way around that. Haven't heard of it being attempted on Linux. By the way, these driver modifications are just removing artificial restrictions.
- everdrive 7y agoI've had a great experience with Proton. Glad it's getting some exposure.
- ressetera 7y agoPorting games seems pretty hard IMO. Why isn't there an intensive to port the latest Adobe CC software [1] too? I know a few designers & video editors who use passthrough to run Adobe software on their beefy workstations, which I would also prefer as I'd rather not use multiarch on my linux system. [1] https://appdb.winehq.org/objectManager.php?sClass=version&iId=38516 https://appdb.winehq.org/objectManager.php?sClass=version&iI...
- coldpie 7y agoTo be blunt, funding. No one is paying to improve Adobe CC in Wine.
- dannyw 7y agoSteam has an important reason for growing alternatives to Windows gaming: stop Microsoft from being able to extinguish non-Microsoft PC gaming. Just imagine if DirectX 13 was XboxTM Game Store exclusive...
- jannes 7y agoExactly. And to be fair, I doubt Valve is making a lot of money off of Proton on Linux. I consider it more of a philantropy project from Gabe Newell.
- clarry 7y agoMaybe they're not breaking bank but for a company whose revenue is measured in billions, moving the needle by .1% is worth millions.. I know many Linux users who have abandoned competitors (GOG..) for Steam due Linux support.
- blihp 7y agoWhile I do appreciate Valve's support of Linux, it's hardly altruism: it gives them some room to negotiate with/pressure Microsoft. (i.e. while it would be painful to push even a fraction of their users over to it, it is an option Valve has) Compare that to the situation app developers on mobile platforms find themselves in these days. So it's smart strategically even if it doesn't translate into big $$$ currently.
- papermachete 7y agoDo nvidia profile inspector and reshade work in Linux?
- GormHouj 7y agoWhile proton works wonderfully, I've found that most of the time the anticheat systems do not run at all. So multi-player is usually disabled, even if the game runs flawlessly as a port. The Halo collection let me log into Xbox live, but then fails to run anticheat, so you are left with campaign. Same with PUBG. So many games run extremely well that it's not a deal breaker for me. My last gaming rig was on Zorin Ultimate.
- gpm 7y agoYesterday I played civ6 with 4 people on 3 operating systems. The Mac user couldn't fullscreen the game and had weird rendering artifacts. One of the windows users had the game take 10x as long to load as it should have (commparing to mac/Linux/windows on vaguely similar hardware) The other windows user kept dropping. Note that we were all sitting at the same kitchen table, with reasonably good wifi. Linux worked flawlessly. I'm sure there was some luck involved, but Linux gaming has truly come a long way from being the most finicky platform.
- wayneftw 7y agoAnd yet, I still have trouble running normal software that was built for Linux, on Linux. Every set of updates might cause a problem that I've never seen on Windows or a Mac. I had an Ubuntu machine that only lasted 2 weeks before it wouldn't boot one day after an update. Never figured that one out - it was an experiment to see how much easier Manjaro was to setup and add software to than Ubuntu. (The answer: it's much, much easier.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Topgamer7 7y agoI run Manjaro too. Having up to date versions of software is nice instead of having to wait until ppa's are updated. Also there is a community version that includes just i3 the tiling window manager out of the box.
- xrendan 7y agoWhat distro are you using for Linux? Civ 6 is literally the only reason I keep my Windows partition and I can't get civ 6 to work with Proton.
- gpm 7y ago
- philzook 7y agoIt seems superfluous when we already have the greatest game ever made available right in your package manager: TuxRacer.
- moneysake 7y agoI think the main problem with playing games on linux is that the anticheats for the games can't run properly on linux
- snarfy 7y agoSadly, a lot of the games I want to play have anti-cheat crap
- recursive 7y agoYou may feel it's crap only because you aren't able to run it. Players whose games cheaters are being excluded from are more likely to be glad for it.
- flohofwoe 7y agoIMHO "emulating" the (fairly small) subset of the traditional Win32 and DirectX APIs required for typical games might even make sense on Windows itself, should Microsoft one day decide to deprecate Win32 in favour of something more "modern" (heavy air-quotes). The window creation and input event handling of Win32, together with D3D9 and D3D11 (the really popular versions of D3D), and whatever is the current audio API on Windows (this seems to be the least stable area) have proven to be quite fantastic for games, maybe the best set of low-level APIs needed by games outside of actual gaming console. Porting those APIs to other platforms, instead of porting the games doesn't seem such a bad idea at all in hindsight.
- qplex 7y ago>"emulating" the (fairly small) subset of the traditional Win32 and DirectX APIs required for typical games might even make sense on Windows itself, should Microsoft one day decide to deprecate I recently tried to run some WinXP-era games on modern hardware, and had absolutely no luck on Windows 10. However some of the games ran fine on Wine (and 64-bit Linux). The only downside I see to emulation is latency, but for many games this doesn't matter, and it's worthy to keep them runnable like this.
- outworlder 7y ago> The only downside I see to emulation is latency There shouldn't be significant latency issues, unless there is large amounts of (CPU) work that's required to make large data structures compatible(for a silly example, imagine that the texture formats are different and you need to convert between them). Or if you need to simulate a single function call in a tight loop with several calls. But the overhead is usually not much more significant than what you get when you import a library to call OS functions on your behalf, versus calling them yourself.
- runjake 7y agoNow, the kickers behind the headlines (that nobody told me up front): 1. The majority of the games do not support multiplayer on Linux, due to dependency on Windows-specific anticheat software. 2. Many, many of the games themselves aren't totally stable on Linux. So, expect a crash or two at critical gameplay moments. That said, Proton is a great effort and it's great they're pushing Linux forward.
- shazow 7y ago> The majority of the games do not support multiplayer on Linux, due to dependency on Windows-specific anticheat software. Definitely not majority. Maybe majority of the top 10-20 most popular/most cheated games? The very long tail of games works with multiplayer splendidly There have been reports that Valve is collaborating with EAC to improve Proton support: https://www.gamingonlinux.com/articles/apparently-valve-are-working-with-easy-anti-cheat-to-get-support-in-steam-play.13573 https://www.gamingonlinux.com/articles/apparently-valve-are-... > Many, many of the games themselves aren't totally stable on Linux. https://www.protondb.com/ https://www.protondb.com/ is a great database to check on the stability of games. Many, many games are very stable. Games that I happen to play regularly are more stable than Windows (especially with alt-tab and such).
- dx87 7y agoI wouldn't oversell protondb since it's based on user submitted reports. I've tried multiple games that were rated platinum, but wouldn't launch or had other graphical issues that made them unplayable. Luckily the issues usually present themselves before you reach the 2 hour refund time limit.
- blaser-waffle 7y ago> 1. The majority of the games do not support multiplayer on Linux, due to dependency on Windows-specific anticheat software. Not even anti-cheat, just different implementations of things in the Linux and Windows versions. IIRC Paradox games don't have any strong anti-cheat, but Linux and Windows users can't play due to how their systems handle network time synchronization. > 2. Many, many of the games themselves aren't totally stable on Linux. So, expect a crash or two at critical gameplay moments. Many, many of the games themselves aren't totally stable on Windows, either. Bethesda games (Fallout, Skyrim) come to mind -- desktop Skyrim had all sorts of bugs and crashes on Windows. And why would it crash only at critical gameplay moments? Sounds like FUD.
- Insanity 7y agoAdding to the anecdata, but steam Proton has been great for me under Debian. I've been gaming on linux on and off for about a decade (mostly with wine before or the few games that did support linux). Proton has been a perfect experience for me.
- eximius 7y agoI don't know what rock I was living under, but I finally tried it yesterday after a misadventure forced me to upgrade to Windows 10 to support a new nvme drive. Tabletop Simulator, The Witcher 3, Endless Legend, all play perfectly. Haven't had the chance to try more. Definitely a fantastic effort by Valve and Wine.
- shrimp_emoji 7y agohttps://www.protondb.com/ https://www.protondb.com/ is a crucial companion, letting you generally know whether stuff runs. Mentally-downgrade ratings by one, as a rule of thumb. Also, tfw the native Linux port runs worse than the Proton version PepeHands
- lugermorph 7y agoThe day Adobe apps get ported to Linux is the day I fully switch to Linux. Sorry GIMP, but you kinda suck.
- BubRoss 7y agoI would say that what is already available for linux is far better than what adobe has for image editing and video editing. Nuke and Houdini are much better for editing images than photoshop. Davinci Resolve is a much better video editor than premiere. Painting and vector illustrations are where Linux doesn't have good alternatives as far as I know. At this point there are multiple web based image editors that are far better than the low bar that Gimp sets. Gimp is a relic that most people would be better off forgetting about.
- Topgamer7 7y agoKrita is wonderful for painting and other applications like that. But isn't a full photoshop replacement. It is pretty heavily focused on digital painting.
- nihil75 7y agoHate to be that guy but nobody mentioned it - Lets not forget Proton is a wrapper for Wine, and we're here today thanks to many many years of community effort.
- jfkebwjsbx 7y agoNot just Wine. Mainly DXVK and related projects are what enabled the latest boom.
- paines 7y agoAnd, at least for the early version for Proton, out-of-the-box controller support. You simply do not want to mess around with this manually on wine.
- nihil75 7y agoYes, Vulkan is awesome, but its biggest benefit apart for performance is DX11+ support. Wine had DX9/10 for ages now, and many Proton games don't depend on Vulkan to run.
- jfkebwjsbx 7y agoD3D10 and D3D11 are very similar (I remember DXVK claiming that, which is why the supported both at once). I don't think we had usable D3D10 support before DXVK, but I may be wrong.
- bmorbach 7y agoAnnoyingly, games that use Valve's own DRM/encryption scheme CEG don't work: https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Proton/issues/753 https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Proton/issues/753
- lordleft 7y agoAny issue with nvidia cards?
- mouldysammich 7y agoI never had any issues with my nvidia card when i was using it
- nihil75 7y agoHonorable mentions: WineTricks, and its successor - Lutris. If you can't get it to run on Proton (or not a Steam game), try those.
- 0x1ch 7y agoI remember when proton was literally a pipe dream, and that was only only a few years ago. The improvement across linux drivers for GPUs as well as these technologies is great.
- antjanus 7y agoYep! I'm running Final Fantasy III without a single issue which is just astounding.
- gldev3 7y agoOne just can't thank enought the contributors for ther incredible work and effort.
- prince005 7y agoIf Cyberpunk 2077 runs on linux, I'll remove windows today itself..
- mongol 7y agoIs Microsoft Flight Simulator running on Linux? It used to be the gold standard for "PC compatibility" early in the PC era.
- blopp99 7y agoI was a ubuntu only user for the last 3 or 4 years. Even though part of what I did on my computer was gaming, there was a side of 3d design which I was put in a bad position when I started to get more hardcore. I decided to buy windows and try it. No regrets W10 is good and universal. I would consider going back if Linux has more cad programs compatibily. In the time being I'm just gonna miss Ubuntu remembering to mute if my earphones are plugged in.
- zelphirkalt 7y agoWell, of course all of that would not have been possible, without the long hard work and experiences of all the people involved with creating WINE in the first place. That said, I think it's great that Valve contributes. It might be naive though, to believe, that they'd do any such thing, if the license did not force them to. I am quite sure, that they'd see some kind of advantage to take, if those contributions could be limited to only their own platform.
- outworlder 7y agoI was actually pleasantly surprised by the number of games that my steam library listed as linux-compatible. VR games are a large omission.
- coldpie 7y agoVR is supported by Proton. Not all games work, of course, but it's not in itself a blocker.
- pengaru 7y agoValve should ship the Steam Client native for ARM/Raspberry Pi Linux users. It's a fairly large underserved community when it comes to gaming, and they're practically all Linux boxes, and the latest gens are perfectly capable of modern 3D gaming, if not all the AAA titles.
- Narishma 7y agoHow many Steam games work on ARM?
- pengaru 7y agoFewer than there would be if Steam actually shipped ARM support to those who wanted it. It's a classic chicken-egg problem. I have a game on Steam, it builds and runs on ARM/RPi just fine, but there's no ARM in the list of architectures on Steamworks because the client doesn't support it. So I don't bother shipping the ARM build despite having one here and one of my artists using an RPi4 as their primary desktop with a functioning build of the game for testing. We're talking about commercial interests here. If a game has been ported to native linux/SteamOS, it's likely just a recompile away from having ARM support. If the Steam client were made available to Pi users the demand would appear on the store for more ARM-compatible games and we'd all immediately jump on the opportunity for more sales from practically zero effort.
- divs1210 7y agoI have been playing exclusively on Wine + Mac for a long time now. It takes some minor fiddling, but works for the most part.
- barbs 7y agoI've only discovered Proton recently and I'm very impressed. I'm no stranger to using Wine to get games running in Linux, but Proton makes the whole process so easy. And Wine itself has come a long way even in the past few years. GTA V was the reason I kept a Windows partition when I played it a few years ago, and now it works amazingly with the latest version of Wine/Proton.
- acomjean 7y agoI’m confused. Is steam selling linux games with proton as Linux games? Or do you have to buy the windows version and run it with proton. I got black Mesa on Linux from steam (works great), but is that a proton game? Last time I browsed Linux games on steam most seemed like they were indie with very few aaa titles.. I do feel Linux has arrived.
- account42 7y agoNo, games marked as Linux on the Steam store do not use Proton (by default) but are native (either ported or in some cases wrapped with Wine/whatever by the developer). Black Mesa uses the Source engine for which Valve created their own ToGL wrapper but it's compile-time and much smaller than Wine.
- wdb 7y agoWhat about macOS?
- iszomer 7y agoProtonDB is a good place to check for compatibility. I still have trouble trying to get Elite Dangerous to work on my Linux machine at home.
- RedBeetDeadpool 7y agoOh thank god. The more I use windows the more I just want to pull my hair out.
- mikewang 7y agoI love games and linux. But never play one in linux.