20 ms·
Ubuntu got worse at 18.04. Logging in on desktop now requires "swiping up" with the mouse to get the password box. The "swiping" thing is to avoid problems with
by Animats 7y ago
Ubuntu got worse at 18.04. Logging in on desktop now requires "swiping up" with the mouse to get the password box. The "swiping" thing is to avoid problems with unwanted activation when the device is in your pocket. It's totally inappropriate to desktops.
Then there's icon mania. I've recently converted from Blender 2.79 to Blender 2.82. Lots of new icons. They dim, they change color, they disappear as modes change, and there are at least seven toolbars of icons. Some are resizable. Many icons were moved as part of a redesign of rendering. You can't Google an icon. "Where did ??? go" is a big part of using Blender 2.82. Blender fanboys argue for using keyboard shortcuts instead. The keyboard shortcut guide is 13 pages.
Recently I was using "The Gimp", the GNU replacement for Photoshop, and I couldn't find most of the icons in the toolbar. Turns out that if the toolbar is in the main window (which is optional), and it's too tall to fit, you can't get at the remaining icons. You have to resize the toolbar to give it more space. Can't scroll. There's no visual indication of overflow. It just looks like half the icons are missing.
(I have no idea what's happening in Windows 10 land. I have one remaining Windows machine, running Windows 7.)
- the_af 7y agoIs there a sane mode or config for vanilla Ubuntu 18.04? I'm considering upgrading from my trusty old 16.04 LTS (both home and office laptops) and I dread the usual pointless UI changes that come with all the reasonable bugfixes/improvements.
- rpcope1 7y agoI think Xubuntu is a good alternative. XFCE doesn't have as much eye candy, but it certainly surprises me far less and usually is very pleasant to work with.
- bityard 7y agoI used Xubuntu for a number of years and it's a great lightweight environment overall. The main problems that I experienced with it are that it's handling of hot-plugging multiple displays (especially in between sleep states) has always been poor and crashy. And I like the cohesiveness and integration of GNOME, although I had to do a hell of a lot of customization to mold it into something I could tolerate.
- flyinghamster 7y agoI've also noticed that XFCE's handling of hotplug monitors leaves much to be desired, and it also cheerfully ignores my preference of not suspending when I close the laptop lid (so I can use only the external monitor and an external keyboard when I have it plugged into my TV). Close the lid under XFCE and "BEEP!" it goes into suspend mode instead of doing nothing. Fortunately, Cinnamon is just an apt-get away, handles both monitor hotplugging and closing the laptop lid sanely, and works the way I expect a desktop to work. I've settled on Xubuntu+Cinnamon as my go-to when setting up a desktop or laptop.
- bityard 7y agoCan you elaborate on Xubuntu+Cinnamon? That sounds interesting. I also just noticed that there's an Ubuntu Cinnamon which might be right up my alley as well.
- flyinghamster 7y agoThe setup I did was to just install Xubuntu, then: apt install cinnamon Once installed, I logged out, and then picked Cinnamon from the session selection menu (the little gear near the upper right corner). It comes right up, though it won't pick up your preferences from XFCE. I hadn't realized there was now a Cinnamon spin - is that still in testing? It's not on Ubuntu's list of flavors.
- Figs 7y agoNo, or at least I haven't found one. I was recently forced to upgrade from 14.04 and tried the default configuration in 18.04 (clean install) for a while before I gave up and installed Unity -- which, thankfully, is in the package manager. That at least got me back to the point where I could configure things critical to my workflow like having a 3x3 workspace switcher. The system has fought me every step of the way though -- especially with things like global hotkeys which have about half a dozen different places they can be configured and it's completely inconsistent what works where. I've literally spent weeks trying to get back to the level of usability I had on my 14.04 setup -- compiling old/patched versions of software from source because the "improved" versions removed features I depend on or otherwise fucked up the interface (I cannot understand why anyone thought removing typeahead from Nautilus was a good idea!), trying every damned thing I can think of to debug the global hotkey problems (still can't get IME switching to work right reliably... it works for a while after I fiddle with it then just stops working and I have no clue why), and just generally having a bad time.
- worik 7y agoDo not upgrade. Switch. A lot of Ubuntu software is now (Version 19.xx) only available with "snaps". They make some sense for IoT machinery (the user does not control updates, so they are deploy and forget) but I do not want to loose control. Final straw for me. I am test driving Arch now....
- tfleming 7y agoDid you install Arch from scratch or are you using Manjaro, etc? I love Arch but I've never installed from scratch. It's on a my bucket list. I'm currently using Endeavour OS, which is easy-install Arch Linux with way less bloat than Manjaro. It's awesome. I'll never install a *buntu type system again.
- worik 7y agoHa ha. From scratch I think. My aptitude is no use with pacman
- imhoguy 7y agoI highly recommend trying out other flavours of Ubuntu: Xubuntu (XFCE), Lubuntu (LXDE), Kubuntu (KDE), Ubuntu MATE, Ubuntu Budgie. Next week all should get 20.04 LTS release.
- thanatropism 7y agoI don’t understand why you need different distributions for different DEs. The only distro I’ve used past teenage is Ubuntu. I alternate stints of maybe 2 years with Windows, 2 years with Ubuntu. First thing I do after installing the most recent LTS Ubuntu is “apt install spectrwm”. Spectrwm is not even particularly good — everyone tells me to use xmonad instead — but I know how to get it in usable shape in about half an hour. This after many moons of exclusively using Windows.
- RedShift1 7y agoThey are not different distributions but more like a different edition or "spin" of Ubuntu. They just install a different set of packages.
- distances 7y agoFor KDE you're better off with KDE Neon. Still based on Ubuntu, but that's the official KDE distro if you can speak of one.
- olyjohn 7y ago20.04 is due out in a few days. I hope it's good. 18.04 has been total crap for me. The lock screen randomly won't authenticate, and I am forced to reboot. My USB dock suddenly started randomly disconnecting and reconnecting, after it worked fine for months. The "Save/Open" button in the file dialog boxes is in the title bar, which is the dumbest thing I have ever seen. Dialog boxes get tied to windows, so when I try to move the dialog out of the way to see my work, it drags the whole damn window. (Some of this is mentioned in the TFA.) I think a lot of these decisions were Gnome-driven, but still... stick with 16.04.
- tannhaeuser 7y agoI'm on 19.10, and I'm quite disappointed. Exposing all windows as thumbnails is a big regression compared to Unity. It feels heavyweight, and just doesn't work anymore for window navigation. Pressing the app icon on the side bar brings up small, equal-sized window previews on top of each other without spatial information. Consequently I have now tens of open terminal session and browser windows. Global menu is gone, wasting precious vertical space. Or it would, if apps such as Firefox didn't change to use stupid hamburger menus. The place where the global menu used to be is now used for displaying the time, which is absurd. What's not gone is the chopped display of the focussed app's name on the left. I frequently make errors on window decorations (might be me used to Unity, but it's still the case after two months). Search isn't as useful as it used to be, but has a pompous animation. Apps are beginning to use snaps, which I have no use for - all I want is a driver for running the same old programs I used to run the last twenty years. It's not that there's been a boom of new desktop apps for Linux lately. Installation was rock-solid, though. Only had to install synaptics over libinput (libinput causing physical pain for me because I had to press the touchpad hard all the time, and because lack of kinetic scroll). Seriously considering alternatives.
- brabel 7y agoI was on the same boat and decided to install KDE Plasma. Very very happy with the result, the UI dark theme is very beautiful and all shortcuts and UI elements work the way "old" UIs did (unlike freaking Ubuntu 18 and 19 which changed everything for 0 reason). https://kde.org/plasma-desktop https://kde.org/plasma-desktop It was quite easy to install and everything worked out-of-the-box. I just customized some widgets, the dark theme, icon colors and now it looks amazing. Best Linux desktop I've used so far.
- brabel 7y agoJust to make it clear: after I posted this , I did some research and it turns out I am using KDE Cinnamon actually... I installed KDE, and now I have options when in the login page to select which "session" I want: Ubuntu, Unity, Plasma, Cinnamon, Wayland... I have Cinnamon by default, and it is indeed my favourite... Plasma seems very cool, but too different from what I am used to... I might play with it later when I have more time though.
- ryandrake 7y agoI've always considered Debian to be the sane, vanilla Ubuntu :-)
- strken 7y agoOne nice thing about recent Ubuntu is that even though they hide the password box, you can start typing on the unlock screen and your text will be entered into the password box.
- saagarjha 7y agoWhy hide the password box, then, unless you think that users learning to type and have magically it go somewhere invisible is a good UI design… (Interesting aside: I complained to someone on the Mac Safari team that it was difficult to search open tabs, and he told me that apparently this feature already exists! You go into the tab overview, and…just start typing. A little search bar will pop into appearance in the top right corner. Why it couldn't just be there and have keyboard focus from the start, I have no idea…)
- Jtsummers 7y agoWorse, this creates a bad habit. What if the UI changes and now it's the username that pops up first, not a password box? So it's a hard-to-discover feature, and a misfeature unless you elect to keep this behavior forever.
- Spivak 7y agoBecause this only happens on the lock screen when there's no user to be entered/selected. There's no slide-up on the initial login.
- wmf 7y agomacOS hides the password field to encourage people to use Touch ID instead, but Ubuntu probably doesn't even support fingerprint login...
- ajosh 7y agoUbuntu does support fingerprint login if you have supported hardware.
- 7y ago
- Stierlitz 7y ago> Ubuntu got worse at 18.04 .. Give Lubuntu a try. https://lubuntu.net/ https://lubuntu.net/
- buovjaga 7y agoThe official site is https://lubuntu.me/ https://lubuntu.me/ btw.
- Redoubts 7y agoAre they really mixing themes like this? https://lubuntu.me/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/video.png https://lubuntu.me/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/video.png from the front page
- shrimp_emoji 7y agoLOL nOmegalol. LXDE is dead, and jankier than Xfce. Use Xfce (if you like jank) or KDE or Cinnamon.
- tonypace 7y agoLubuntu is no longer on LXDE, having switched to LXQT on version 19.04. LXQT is pretty good from my perspective, minimal but intuitive.
- clarry 7y ago> Ubuntu got worse at 18.04. Logging in on desktop now requires "swiping up" with the mouse to get the password box. Have you tried pressing a key?
- AlexandrB 7y agoIs there any indication that pressing a key is an option? I've been swiping up with the mouse the whole time as well.
- Lammy 7y ago> It’s totally inappropriate to desktops. I don’t agree. It’s important for the user to know a login UI is the real thing. For example, Windows NT used to have you hit Ctrl+Alt+Del to make the credential dialog appear so that any fake lookalike was impossible.
- traderjane 7y agoThat's a bit different. I can fake swipe-up on a GUI but I can't fake Ctrl-Alt-Del.
- Lammy 7y agoThe implementation may be bad but it seems like the same idea to me, “user must interact with UI before entering credentials”.
- olyjohn 7y agoExcept you don't have to. Just start typing your password.
- Lammy 7y agoYes, that’s why it’s a bad implementation of a good idea.
- int_19h 7y agoEven if you had to, it's still a bad idea. Ctrl+Alt+Delete works, because no normal Win32 app can intercept this - so if you do it, and you see a login box, you know that this is the real thing. But any app can go fullscreen and draw a fake login screen that you can swipe up to show a fake login form.
- dfox 7y agoActually the idea behond Ctrl-Alt-Del is the other way around. Application can cause the same effect as user pressing Ctrl-Alt-Del (although doing that is somewhat complex due to interactions with UAC), but there is no way how application can prevent the said effect (essentially switching virtual desktops) from happening when user presses Ctrl-Alt-Del.
- mschulkind 7y agoOne tip for Blender at least... It's very hard to discover, even if you know it exists, but you can drag out from the side of the main icon bar and turn on text labels as well.
- rags2riches 7y agoIcon mania... and pretty much every single icon is only possible to understand after you have learned what it means.
- loopz 7y agoEven worse: You have to try out each icon. Next version replaces many of them and entire design again. Rinse & repeat.
- astrobe_ 7y agoThat's deliberate. The saying "a picture is better than a thousand words" doesn't apply when the picture is 16x16 pixels. Every single icon that makes sense to you now (the floppy disk, the binoculars...) do so because you learned them a long time ago; it's funny how you can now find YT videos that explain where that weird blue icon for the "save" function comes from. The images are just a mnemonic device - in the sense that the sign is partly related to the meaning (the binoculars could very well mean "zoom in" in an alternative world). Certainly a stronger connection works better because it helps to remember, but they are not meant to help with "understanding" what the button does. It is the same deal as with keyboard shortcuts. ctrl+S is Save, but you know that ctrl+V is Paste and it has absolutely nothing to do with spelling.
- a1369209993 7y agoActually the floppy disk made perfect sense when I first saw it: "we're going to do something involving the floppy disk, and there's a put-onto arrow superimposed over it" (the load-file icon had a take-off-of arrow). It makes less sense now, but only because computer storage no longer has a single, iconic (heh) form factor. ZXCV is positional, [C]opy having a nice mnemonic is more of a happy coincidence than a design decision in it's own right.
- CRConrad 7y ago> ZXCV is positional, [C]opy having a nice mnemonic is more of a happy coincidence... ZXCV is actually half positional/mnemonic, half graphical-as-letters, a bit like old-fashioned smileys: X for cut looks like opened scissors, and V for insert looks like the downward-pointing “insert here” arrow-like mark editors and teachers use(d?) to scribble onto others’ texts.
- kristopolous 7y agoGimp is a great example. If you look up screenshots from the late 90s of gimp 1.0 you think "Hey wow, that looks pretty great! I know where the buttons are, I can quickly scan them and it's clear what they do! It isn't a grey on grey tiny soup, they are distinct and clear, this is great. When is this version shipping? It fixes everything!" Apparently almost everyone agrees but somehow we're still going the wrong way, what's going on here? Why aren't we in control of this?
- jimmaswell 7y agoYou can change the UI skin in the options. I've been using GIMP for years and I don't have any major complaints.
- xg15 7y agoThis is about usability, so I don't think referring to a setting buried in the options (that you have to know about first) is a valid point. > I've been using GIMP for years I think usability to users experienced in the software and to new users are two different things. I believe an important part of usability is discoverability which is probably better judged by new users than by experienced users.
- kristopolous 7y agosure, you can make the icon bar more sensible with some effort, but not as sensible as it was in 1998: https://scorpioncity.com/images/linux/shotgimp.png https://scorpioncity.com/images/linux/shotgimp.png
- sbierwagen 7y ago>You can change the UI skin in the options. Holy cow! There's even the "classic" theme right there. Wish I knew this a year ago.
- acidburnNSA 7y agoYup. Edit -> Preferences -> UI -> Icons -> Legacy. Done.
- twic 7y agoThat swiping up thing makes me so angry. What an absolute waste of effort. No way to disable it. If this is what they're doing in the most visible bits of the system, what on earth is happening in the rest?
- freedomben 7y agoJust hit the Escape key. You can also just start typing your password. I often type my password and press enter before the monitor is even awake.
- 101404 7y ago...just to then realize that the computer was still logged in and the focus was on a chat window, and it was only the screen that had been in power saving mode. :-}
- switch007 7y agoYour post needs a trigger warning. My heart is racing.
- apocalypstyx 7y agoAnd this is why I bring my machine out of sleep by tapping the shift key.
- hackmiester 7y agoGood thing no one on HN would ever reuse a password, right?
- koheripbal 7y agoGood news, it is gone in the next version.
- tsjq 7y agothat slide up thing has to be some ultra clownish way. who proposed this, who reviewed & approved this, and on what fundamental ? it there no easy option to get rid of that irritant ?
- wolrah 7y agoPress escape at the "lock screen" and you'll get the login UI. It works the same way on Windows too.
- msla 7y ago> Ubuntu got worse at 18.04. Only if you use the default UI, which I think is an important distinction to make: I use Window Maker and had no regressions. The ability to choose your own UI is an important strength of Unix, and one which distinguishes it from macOS and Windows.
- rvz 7y ago> The ability to choose your own UI is an important strength of Unix, and one which distinguishes it from macOS and Windows. It's a strength as well as a curse for Linux distros not limited to just Ubuntu since the developer of a GUI program must test if their app works on your unique setup, if it doesn't run on one distro or your specific configuration out of the box, then that is already a usability issue. The Linux ecosystem doesn't have any guarantees for the app developer whether if a KDE, GNOME or Xfce built application will consistently work on your setup if the user changes the DE, display manager, etc so it is harder for the app developer to support accessibility features in whatever DE the user uses and its harder for them to track the source of the issue. This could be anywhere in the Linux Desktop stack. The inability to "choose your on UI" on Windows and macOS guarantees that GUI programs will be consistent with the accessibility and look and feel features in the OS which makes it easier for app developers to test on one type of desktop OS, rather than X * Y * Z configurations of one Linux distro.
- CRConrad 7y ago> The inability to "choose your on UI" on Windows and macOS guarantees that GUI programs will be consistent with the accessibility and look and feel features in the OS... Except when it doesn't, which unfortunately is more and more often, to the extent that nowadays it feels it's most of the time. Which is the whole thesis of the web page that this discussion is about to begin with; just go back to it and contemplate that picture of the six window title bars again. Personally, I blame Microsoft. After successfully having introduced and enforced the CUA guidelines, they themselves were the first to violate them on a large scale in a widely-used application (suite): MS Office’s “themed” interface from around the turn of the century. Sure, there were a bunch of MP3 players and stuff, probably inspired by that “kool” (=utterly unnecessarily weird) Kai thing — but AFAICS those were marginal, and Office was what “legitimised” applying non-standard frippery in stead of the simple unadorned standard UI elements.
- josteink 7y ago> Ubuntu got worse at 18.04. Logging in on desktop now requires "swiping up" with the mouse to get the password box. I don’t know about you, but I just start typing on my keyboard.
- olyjohn 7y agoTook a while to figure out I could do that. And I only figured it out by accident.
- walkingolof 7y agoThe "Slide up" is gone in next LTS due in a few days. https://www.omgubuntu.co.uk/2019/10/ubuntu-20-04-release-features https://www.omgubuntu.co.uk/2019/10/ubuntu-20-04-release-fea...
- robocat 7y agoAbout half way through article: “The new lock screen is easier to use, no longer requiting you to ‘slide up’ to reveal the password field (which now sits atop a blurred version of your desktop wallpaper):” Great! That UI was horrific. Hitting a key like spacebar didn’t unlock. Aside: I completely broke the Ubuntu login screen yesterday. I did `apt remove evolution*`. Unfortunately the login screen depends on evolution-data-server, so I couldn’t login from lock screen, and after reboot it dropped me to TTY!! Gnome is just getting crazy - it would be like Windows login depending on MS Outlook! Gnome is a big ball of interdependencies, becoming more like Windows. I get it, but I don’t like it. Edit: FYI: fixed in TTY3 (ctrl-alt-F3) by `apt install --reinstall ubuntu-desktop` from memory.
- ahsima1 7y agoapt automatically removing dependencies by default is such a trap, I much prefer pacman's behaviour of refusing to remove package that breaks dependecies unless explicitly told to do so.
- necovek 7y agoapt will not automatically remove dependencies either. I suspect the OP already had ubuntu-desktop package removed for some other reason, and there was no direct dependency on evolution-data-server for gdm: it will only remove dependencies which no other still-installed package depends on. That might still mean a packaging bug (but at least on 18.04, attempting to remove evolution-data-server prompts me how it's going to remove gdm3 too — sure, it's short and easily missed; attempting to remove evolution does not attempt to remove evolution-data-server since a bunch of other stuff depends on it like gnome-calendar too). In any case, apt will prompt you about all the packages you are about to remove (unless you pass "-y(es)" to it).
- JJMcJ 7y agoBlender icons are also microscopic on a 1920 x 1080 monitor of usual size. We don't all have astronaut vision.
- joe_the_user 7y agoUbuntu shell was a disaster and I can't imagine it's gotten better - Mate on Ubuntu is the answer for that. And Gimp is a mess. Enabling single window mode makes it better.
- zrm 7y ago> Logging in on desktop now requires "swiping up" with the mouse to get the password box. The "swiping" thing is to avoid problems with unwanted activation when the device is in your pocket. It's totally inappropriate to desktops. Anecdote: The first time this happened, I had no idea why it wasn't working and naturally started clicking on things and pressing buttons to try to get it to do the thing. I thereby discovered that you can get the password prompt by pressing Enter. Having used it this way for two years now, your description of this behavior is the first time I'm learning that it is also possible to do it by dragging the mouse upwards. The discoverability of this behavior apparently does not exist -- I assume if pressing Enter hadn't worked I would have had to use a different device to look it up on the internet.
- swiley 7y agoI don't care how "user friendly" you think you are, not being able to log in is an absolute fail. Even getty has a better user interface, imagine that: regression all the way back in to the 70s. This is why I don't touch GUIs from the major binary distros or gnome3 with a 10 foot pole. If I can avoid it I don't ever install anything from those projects.
- philsnow 7y agoI have avoided gnome as much as I can since the gnome2 days. The entire project is rife with UX decisions that leave a bad taste in my mouth. [0] is the example that always comes to mind. I guess this made sense to somebody at the time, but it adds overhead to a process that was simple before, and isn't enabled just for "Enterprise" deployments, it's just dumped on the user to figure out how to configure screensaver hack settings by creating / modifying a theme. [0] https://wiki.gnome.org/Attic/GnomeScreensaver/FrequentlyAskedQuestions#Why_doesn.27t_the_screensaver_preferences_tool_allow_me_to_change_the_settings_for_the_theme.3F https://wiki.gnome.org/Attic/GnomeScreensaver/FrequentlyAske...
- fiddlerwoaroof 7y agoBetween this and https://stopthemingmy.app/ https://stopthemingmy.app/ and the various other systemd/freedesktop “anti-hacker” initiatives, I’ve been finding Linux to be more and more becoming the opposite of the operating system I’ve used for the last 20 years.
- reddotX 7y agoUbuntu got worse because of GNOME
- Florin_Andrei 7y agoUI design lately sounds more and more like a Monty Python sketch.
- BurningFrog 7y agoAs I recall history, using icons was a main way the rest of the industry tried to copy the usability of the MAc UI, as it conquered a lot of mindshare in the 80s and 90s. But the Mac almost never had just icons in the ui. There would usually be an icon and a text. With little space you'd revert to text only. Apple had a team of expert Usability experts. Others... did not. So they just copied something that looked cool and was easy to implement. That it cut down on internationalizion efforts surely didn't hurt either.
- Jtsummers 7y agoThe old interfaces (I guess we can say that now, talking about a quarter century ago) tended to have several modes. The menu bar was always just text. The toolbars offered several options: large/medium/small/no icons, text/no text. (Not all of those options were always available.) This let you progress as a user of a system. When you first experienced it you could use the large icons with text because it made the things you were searching for standout. As you learned the icons you could start shrinking them, and eventually remove the text. This opened up the toolbar to fit many more actions (often less frequently used). And the tool tip from hovering remained throughout, so in the worst case of an ambiguous (or unknown) icon, you could hover over it and learn what it did. Additionally, you'd often get the shortcut for the action when hovering over the button (or viewing it in the menu bar). Many contemporary applications don't provide their users with this notion of progression.
- BostonFern 7y agoOh, the joy of using an application that acknowledges your subtle interactions, such as hovering over an unknown button, like a friendly old-time barber who knows just how to cut your hair. No explanations needed, he knows just what you need.
- int_19h 7y agoIt really depends on the period. On Windows, Microsoft eventually unified menu bars and tool bars - the widget was called "cool bar" or "rebar", and it was basically a generic container for certain specific kinds of children that organized them into floatable and dockable "bands", with automatic layout: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/controls/rebar-controls https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/controls/reba... The widgets that can be placed on that are buttons with icon & text (either of which could be hidden) that can be regular, toggle, or drop-down; and text and combo boxes. Well, and custom widgets, of course, but the point is that they were different from regular widgets in that they were toolbar-aware. IIRC this all first came as part of IE "common controls" library, even before it was shipped as part of the OS. So then a top-level menu is just a band with a bunch of buttons with drop-downs that have hideen icons. A regular Win9x-style toolbar is a band with a bunch of buttons with icons but hidden text, and an occasional text box or combo box. And so on. But the real nifty thing about these is that they could be customized easily, and it was traditional for Win32 apps to expose that to the user. At first it was just about showing/hiding stuff, but Office especially gradually ramped things up to the point where the user could, essentially, construct arbitrary toolbars and menus out of all commands available in the app, assign arbitrary shortcuts to them etc. So if you wanted icons in your main menu, or text-only toolbars, you could have that, too! This wasn't something that regular users would do, but I do recall it not being uncommon for power users of a specific app to really tailor it to themselves. Visual Studio has it to this day, and takes it to 11 by further allowing to customize context menus through the same UI: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/visualstudio/ide/how-to-customize-menus-and-toolbars-in-visual-studio?view=vs-2019 https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/visualstudio/ide/how-to-cus...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- coopsmgoops 7y agoAt the Ubuntu log in screen just start typing your password and it will automatically scroll up.
- dleslie 7y agoYes, let's train users to type their passwords in with no visual indicator of where it's being input, and only faith that it will go well. Great idea. /s
- m463 7y agoubuntu is a hodgepodge. I was always accidentally maximizing windows at the screen edge. wtf. (use dconf to turn off edge-tiling) (also lots of phone home crap you have to hunt to turn off) By comparison arch linux + gnome is relatively unencumbered
- KerrickStaley 7y agoOn the GNOME login screen you can press [Enter] or [Space], or click (on the latest GNOME, 3.34) or swipe up (on the previous versions) to get to the password entry box, or you can just start typing your password. It's extremely easy and discoverable (because there are so many options, nearly anything you do will take you to the password box). I really don't think there's an issue with it. This is with stock GNOME (on Arch); I think Ubuntu may ship a skinned / modified / older version of it (which can create UI problems).
- dleslie 7y agoSo what you're saying is that there's no way to discover it by visual inspection alone; and so my elderly family members could never discover it for fear of breaking something by pressing the wrong button. That's bad UI.
- XorNot 7y agoI remember when I was playing around with building an HTPC for my car in the mid-2000s and I got to trying to put a frontend skin on the touchscreen. And I found all the existing skins completely awful because they were wall to wall arbitrary icons, in a setting where I needed at a glance functionality. Eventually made my own, and the key element? No icons at all. Just text - potentially small text - on the buttons. Turns out, being something you spend your entire life reading, text works great - within a sparse set, you can resolve exactly what a word is from letter shapes even if you can't directly read it, and if you don't know what something is you can just read it. No one ever had any problem using it, even if they'd never seen it before, because every button said exactly what it did.
- m463 7y agoYes, but now you have to write gobs of internationalization code. ;) Actually, that sounds completely sane.
- micmil 7y agoPeople have been whining about Ubuntu's design philosophy since it began. Nothing new there. Blender is only now turning into a useful piece of software for anyone that didn't grow up using Blender exclusively. They've finally pulled their head out and moved towards industry standard UI design rather than the godawful cluster of crap that it had for nearly two decades. It only seems complicated because, I assume, you do not use it terribly often and don't have much experience with 3d graphics programs in general. And yes, you can google where an icon is. You can also use the reams of documentation that exists. GIMP sucks, has always sucked, and will always suck. Can't defend it at all.
- adenverd 7y agoGIMP's UI/UX has been garbage since long before 18.04. Not contradicting anything you're saying, just noting that it might not be the representative example you're looking for.
- p1necone 7y ago"You can't have the same UX for both handheld touchscreen devices and M+K laptops/desktops" seems like an absolutely 101 level no brainer to me. How are big projects/companies still attempting to make stuff like this happen?
- a1369209993 7y ago> How are big projects/companies still attempting to make stuff like this happen? "None of us are as stupid as all of us."
- pferde 7y agoCost saving?
- anewguy9000 7y agowindows 10 is the same, there is lag between when the screen with the input box appears and when it accepts input. so if you start typing too quickly, fail. and don't get me started on their auto update policy (i agree with automatic updates; i do not agree with them forcefully hijacking my computer with no means to stop it. its actually what brought me back to linux as my dd. no regrets!)
- abnry 7y agoIn Ubuntu 19 I can just type my password and hit enter to log in. In windows 10, I have to hit any key before typing my password and hitting enter to log in.
- thawaway1837 7y agoI’m on 19.04 and haven’t experienced the swiping up. Could it have to do with me running i3 instead of Gnome?
- noobermin 7y agoWhenever these discussions come up, I don't know how much of this response is just confusing familiarity with usability. I kid you not, I knew people who bemoaned python because of tab spacing and this wasn't 2003, this was may be a few years ago (2016 or so), which I'd argue is just being unfamiliar with it. C isn't really that intuitive--I still remember learning it at 14 and finding the syntax confusing vs basic--it's just familiar to those who use it. I do feel that some modern changes are annoying and unnecessary though and the instances I see that increase as I get older. I just always try to check myself and analyze how much of that anguish is just from being used to something or not. I will finally say the examples here of inconsistency between evince and MPV is just inexcusable. You can't both break expectations AND be inconsistent, it's like the worst of both worlds.
- StillBored 7y agoThe author completely failed to mention discoverability. Which is a huge part of usability because it allows _new_ people to sit down at your applications and gradually work up their expertise until they are keyboard wizards (or whatever). So, no, just having a bunch of magic unlabeled buttons and saying "use the keyboard" isn't good usability. The part that kills me, is that a lot of these applications don't even really have shortcut key guides. So, you don't even know the magic key sequence for something until you discover it by accident. Worse, are the crappy programs that break global key shortcuts by using them for their own purposes.. AKA firefox seems to manage this on a pretty regular basis. Want to switch tabs? ctrl-tab, oh wait, it doesn't work anymore, cross fingers and hope someone notices and fixes it (which they did).
- WalterBright 7y ago> a lot of these applications don't even really have shortcut key guides Not even Windows itself has, any where that I could find, a list of all the keyboard shortcuts. I find multiple lists, each with a different random subset of whatever the actual set is. Sometimes I'll hit wrong keys, and something interesting happens. I don't know what I did, so it's "oh well".
- greggman3 7y ago
- andreareina 7y ago18.04, <enter> works for me to get the password box up.
- WalterBright 7y ago> You can't Google an icon. I've been complaining about that since 1983, when an Apple evangelist came to my workplace to show off the Mac's icons. Nobody was able to guess what the box of Kleenex icon was, much to the frustration of the evangelist. Of course, there wasn't a Google then, but how do you look up a picture in a dictionary? We've reverted to hieroglyphic languages. (Ironically, hieroglyphs evolved over time into phonetic meanings.)
- macleginn 7y ago> Ironically, hieroglyphs evolved over time into phonetic meanings. No, they didn't. The original creators of hieroglyphs knew how to use them to spell phonetically, but they didn't do it that often, they were satisfied with the old system (just as Chinese are now). It was a job of other people, who actually didn't know how to use hieroglyphs properly, to build a functioning alphabet on top of them. Two systems coexisted for some time, and then hieroglyphs went into decline with the whole culture that supported them.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 7y agoThe Egyptian and Mayan ones did.
- macleginn 7y agoWhat I wrote about was about Egyptian hieroglyphs. I can only repeat that they did not _evolve_ into alphabetic writing. The Semitic alphabet was a fork; alphabetic use by the Egyptians themselves was very marginal. The Mayan system AFAIK was a mixed logo-syllabic one to begin with.
- m463 7y agoBut the heiroglyphs are corporate logos crossed with app icons (that change every so often to stay "fresh")
- StillBored 7y agoI had the hidden window problem the first time i used win7. It was one one of those tiny netbooks with 1024x600. I think I was trying to add a user, and for the life of me couldn't figure it out. Turns out the updated add user control panel at the time put the add button on the lower right of a window with a minimum height > 600px and about 400px of white-space above it, and no resize/scroll bar so there wasn't any visual indication that there was more to the window. But, there is a flip side too. I have ~6kx5k of desktop resolution (portrait mode 5k monitors) and very few applications know how to handle that in any reasonable way. Web pages are frequently the worst, nothing like a column of vertical text consuming 10% of the horizontal resolution of the browser that manages to scroll for a page or two. I guess no one reads newspapers anymore, so the idea of having multiple vertical columns of text is foreign.
- CalRobert 7y agoThe best thing about Ubuntu desktop usability might be mnemomics, where alt+ an underlined letter is your keyboard shortcut, but it seems they're dying :-(.
- asicsp 7y agoI recently came across Glimpse [0] which is a fork of Gimp. They state usability as one of the reasons for the fork. [0] https://glimpse-editor.org/ https://glimpse-editor.org/
- diffeomorphism 7y ago> Logging in on desktop now requires "swiping up" No, it required pressing some button to show the password box. Just like windows. If you don't have a keyboard you can also swipe up instead.
- craftinator 7y agoI've always guessed that the infinite feature creep that is plaguing modern UI's is caused by salaried visual designers who aren't being given new projects to work on. Once the visual templates are fleshed out, the icon sets are put together, the pallettes completed, there's not all that much to do. Unless you start playing around with NEW icon sets, pallettes, mouse aware buttons, etc, etc... I would be so much happier with a consistent, self explanatory UI than anything that is "sleek" or "dynamic". Those properties, excepting very specific situations, really detract from UX. Visuals improve with user familiarity, not with constant changes. Imagine if the Department of Transportation decided to redesign stop signs to be yellow, triangular, with a sleek looking matte finish... Traffic accident deaths would go up 10x in the first week.
- brabel 7y agoUbuntu 19 is terrible. I was forced to use KDE (Plasma) instead because they broke so many basic UI concepts (to give you a tiny taste: changing tabs went from Ctrl+Tab to Meta+Tab, the keyboard layout switcher takes 2 seconds or more because it pops up a stupid little window to show the language selected, and many other things just like this I thankfully erased from my mind and now only the frustration remains).
- necovek 7y agoI use the keyboard layout switcher only with the keyboard which is pretty much instant, so I wonder how was it broken in any of the Ubuntu 19.x releases — that sounds worrying if it carries over to 20.04? (I am on 18.04) "Any Ubuntu 19.x" because non-LTS Ubuntu releases come out every six months, so there was Ubuntu 19.04 and Ubuntu 19.10, but never an "Ubuntu 19": they are never as polished or as stable as LTS releases, and are only supported for 9 months, forcing you to update regularly. If you are looking for a more stable experience and you are not chasing the latest features, you would probably be better served with LTS releases which come out every 2 years (they have hardware updates with newer kernels included every once in a while, so you do not have to worry about using them on latest laptops either). If you want the most stable route, go with LTS point (.1) release. Eg. I only update my servers when 18.04.1 or 20.04.1 is out.
- brabel 7y agoThe language switcher was broken in 18 already : https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gnome-shell/+bug/1754702 https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gnome-shell/+bug/1... People who switch between several languages just can't use Ubuntu because of this, read some testimonials on the bug linked above. This is just one of the pain points though. There were many.
- necovek 7y agoThat's quite interesting — I do not get that behaviour at all, both on newly installed and upgraded systems from older LTSes (3 laptops and a desktop). They are all on 18.04, and I do have at least 2 layouts on all of them (Serbian Cyrillic, Latin and sometimes US English) which I switch between hundreds of times a day. Of the non-standard settings, I've got "make Caps lock an additional Ctrl" and "each window keeps its own layout" on. The rest, including keyboard switching shortcut (Meta+Space) is using the defaults. I simply press the shortcut and start typing and works as expected — if I find the time, I'll debug further and report on the LP bug, but just wanted to report that I do not experience any of the problems mentioned.
- enobrev 7y agoSpace bar (or possibly any key) works. The up-swipe to log in induces ux rage for me. I haven't yet tried to hunt down a way to shut it off because I just hit the space bar and forget it ever happened.
- andrepd 7y ago>Blender fanboys argue for using keyboard shortcuts instead. The keyboard shortcut guide is 13 pages. Well to be fair Blender is a professional tool. It is expected that users read the manual and learn the shortcuts, etc. Discoverability is something that should not be optimised for in a tool for professionals like Blender.
- PunksATawnyFill 7y agoThat is such a lame, played-out excuse. A real favorite of apologists for shitty UI design.
- BubRoss 7y agoYou are absolutely right. It doesn't hold water once you look at other professional programs. They all use the same math underneath and love or die to a huge degree based on their interface. Blender being free and open source opens up possibilities for people with no access to professional tools and researchers, but compared to the commercial tools out there its interface is a mess of inconsistency.
- andrepd 7y agoIt's really not. Take a tool like after effects. The interface is not obvious, the icons are unlabeled (until you mouseover and get a tooltip). You've got to learn it as you would learn to use any other tool.
- gmueckl 7y agoThe UI changes in Blender 2.80 were exactly to get rid of the awful non-standard non-discoverable UI that has plagued the program from the start. It actually fixes a whole ton of issues that the article complains about! For instance, mouse button assignments are now sane (select on left button, not right) and Ctrl+S brings up an actual save file dialog with pretty unsurprising layout and behaviour (instead of that abomination that replaced the application window contents when pressing F12 and required an enter keypress to save - there was no button). There are many, many more of these changes and they were absolutely necessary. The unfortunate side effect of this is that grumpy old users that were trained to accept the previous highly idiosyncratic UI started to complain because they have to relearn stuff. But it's worth it. And it opens up blender for more users.
- stolsvik 7y ago> Ubuntu got worse at 18.04. Logging in on desktop now requires "swiping up" with the mouse to get the password box. You can also just start typing the password if you want to unlock the machine.
- Joeboy 7y ago> Logging in on desktop now requires "swiping up" with the mouse to get the password box. What? I just type my password without swiping anything. I've I think I've upgraded through pretty much every version of Ubuntu for the last few years, I haven't customized it to speak of, and I've always been able to do this on both my desktop and my laptop.
- RandomWorker 7y agoMoreover, specifically I’m running 19.04 and I click anywhere on the screen to open the password. Maybe they changed it over time.
- rbanffy 7y ago> Logging in on desktop now requires "swiping up" That's not how it works here. From boot I am presented with a list of users, I click or press enter and type the password. When it's locked/suspended, all I need to do is to start typing.
- fhars 7y agoI can't find the icons in gimp on a recent ubuntu because they all look the same these days, every icon is just 'light grey geometric shape on dark grey' with no visual distinctiveness at all.
- coribuci 7y ago> (I have no idea what's happening in Windows 10 land. I have one remaining Windows machine, running Windows 7.) I use a laptop with an external monitor. When the monitor is not connected, Adobe Reader windows have the title bar out of the screen. The only way to maximize: Alt + space + x.
- tsjq 7y ago>now requires "swiping up" with the mouse to get the password box. oh, that has to be some ultra clownish way. i would punch through the display within a week. who proposed this, who reviewed & approved this, and on what fundamental ? is there no easy option to get rid of that irritant ? if none, I have to stay with 16.04 for lots more time.