5 ms·
Bolsonaro fires health minister, calls to reopen economy
- x3n0ph3n3 7y agoI know we're talking about people's lives, but maybe the world needs to see a country get it devastatingly wrong.
- romwell 7y agoI wish the effects were limited to the politicians making the decisions. Perhaps Boris Johnson's attitude will change a little bit now, for example.
- cosmodisk 7y agoIt will be quite the opposite,I think. The Brazilian president had it as well and here's the article about his actions.
- q92z8oeif 7y agohe did not have it. he claimed he had it, not his doctor. One of the running twitter jokes, started by a famous comedian over there, is asking for the health minister, now that he was fired, to release the real result for the president's covid19 test.
- mikepurvis 7y agoAlready happening in Sweden: https://nationalpost.com/news/world/covid-19-as-swedens-death-toll-mounts-epidemiologists-urge-leaders-to-ignore-their-own-public-health-agency https://nationalpost.com/news/world/covid-19-as-swedens-deat...
- mchusma 7y agoI don't understand the Sweden example. Their daily % increase in deaths is well below California. I don't know if there is a difference in counting deaths but Sweden seems to be doing ok relative to other countries. I have heard that they are effectively shut down voluntarily, so government action was not needed but the effect has been the same. Maybe a Swede can weigh in. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_in_California https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_in_C... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_in_Sweden https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_in...
- andyroid 7y agoSwede here. Like you say our isolation is pretty much volountary, with only larger groups gathering being banned - though I very much doubt that would happen anyway should it be allowed. Our neighboring countries who opted for total lockdown are slowly starting to open up too. I think the death toll in pretty much any country will be primarily depending on how well you’ve protected your elderly. We’ve done OK but could certainly have done better. Though still very far from the “devastatingly wrong” claim above.
- anon84598 7y agoSweden isn't performing a lot of tests for one: https://www.thelocal.se/20200414/understanding-swedens-figures-on-the-coronavirus https://www.thelocal.se/20200414/understanding-swedens-figur...
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoWhy do they need to perform a lot of tests if their strategy isn't dependent on testing?
- ashtonkem 7y agoBecause if there’s a giant spike of currently asymptomatic carriers, you’d want to know.
- icelancer 7y agoFar too early to say this is "devastatingly wrong." The number under the curve matters more than random spikes (that don't oversaturate the health system, BTW).
- JamisonM 7y agoI think Russia is already setting that example, really no need for two. https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/covid-19-russia-spike-cases-1.5533647 https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/covid-19-russia-spike-cases-1....
- vtail 7y agoMoscow and most of the other places in Russia are on a complete lockdown for more than a week now - much stricter that eg. NY or California. I’m not sure what do you mean by your comment.
- JamisonM 7y agoI think if you read the article I linked to you can see what I mean. They were forbidding medical staff from doing tests and treatments! ... In an interview with CBC News on Monday, Dr. Rimma Kamalova, who heads the hospital's rheumatology department and is quarantined in the facility, said when the outbreak started, regional health authorities refused to test patients for coronavirus. "According to our policies ... we could not do testing on coronavirus," she said. "We had orders, at that time, not to give this diagnosis and take the relevant [mitigation] measures." ...
- 2019-nCoV 7y agoRussia is honestly handling the crisis better than most of the western world. They've done >1.6M tests with a positivity rate of 1.7%.
- khuey 7y agoThe number of cases China is reporting in travelers arriving from Russia strongly suggests that Russia is significantly underreporting the scope of its outbreak.
- seppin 7y agoThat positive rate is far too low. If you get < 15% anywhere with a proven widespread outbreak you aren't doing enough testing.
- perl4ever 7y agoDoes it make any difference one way or the other? If the response is vital, then some country will get it "devastatingly wrong", and then won't that produce a new wave after a bit everywhere else? Won't that just be a sequel to the first cycle, where things seemed under control, it was downplayed, and then it got going outside of China. Why should anyone expect other than a fractal replay?
- reinkaos 7y agoIt is already happening in the US.
- romwell 7y agoGood luck to all Brazilians. They'll need it.
- sebastianconcpt 7y agoHeat is providing a lot of natural defense. Things are already going way better than predicted.
- soneca 7y agoOne of worst Brazilian states is one of the hottest (Ceará).
- sebastianconcpt 7y agoYou affirmation does not umake the reality of thermal sensitivity in this virus [1]. There are other factors involved in producing a higher mortality, like comorbidity and demographics. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25855727 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25855727
- sudoaza 7y agoTemperature might or might not help [1] and even if it does it may not be enough. Daily confirmed cases are still rising but effects of the quarantine should be visible soon since i think we are reaching the 3 weeks mark. [1] https://www.scmp.com/news/china/science/article/3079831/coronavirus-can-survive-long-exposure-high-temperature-threat https://www.scmp.com/news/china/science/article/3079831/coro...
- anewvillager 7y agoCOVID-19 isn't caused by this virus (Influenza A), it's caused by SARS-CoV-2.
- EForEndeavour 7y agoYour link is irrelevant to SARS-CoV-2. Did you mean to post a different one? The paper you link to discusses attenuation of influenza A at 39.5 ºC, which is pretty far above useful environmental temperatures (you'd just trade off viral deaths with heatwave-associated deaths), not to mention it's an entirely different virus.
- save_ferris 7y agoThe parallels between the current US and Brazilian administrations are hard to ignore. That said, I really hope Trump and Fauci are able to see this crisis out together. Bolsonaro’s decision today could kill thousands, no doubt.
- redis_mlc 7y agoI wish this b.s. would stop. Corona virus is so contagious and we're so unprepared that it will continue to spread in the US regardless of what we do. Yes, thousands will die regardless of what we do. But there is no way lockdown will continue until people starve. So end this timid lockdown before the total destruction of our economy. Start thinking about public policy instead of "my dear 80 year-old grandpa in the home."
- PacifyFish 7y agoKeep in mind the lockdown is meant to slow spread so the healthcare system doesn't get overloaded, not to stop it. It is successful in this respect, and IMO a healthy balance of economic slowdown and death toll. We'll probably start reopening (hopefully in stages, so we can monitor impact) in the next ~3 weeks.
- skybrian 7y agoWhat's your scenario for people starving? Congress refuses to give out more money? Workers in "essential" businesses (which includes everything food related) stop working? I would be more worried about rent and mortgages.
- rodolphoarruda 7y agoRent in some Brazilian cities has been massively lifted, specially for the elderly. Regarding starvation, I don’t see it happening because people is starting to steal, shoplift, local stores. I saw it in front of me last weekend. And they use minors to steal, so nobody goes to jail. I live in São Paulo.
- spamizbad 7y ago
- aphroz 7y agoHonest question: Did we see any anormal mortality in any country caused by the covid-19? Countrywide there seems to be less death than usual on the period January-March in Europe. Edit: And here goes my karma. I will need to do some PR to catch up with this :)
- cosmodisk 7y agoWe are. comparable death rates in the UK are higher.
- knowaveragejoe 7y agoThe numbers may be similar, if not slightly higher than normal, because the deaths we'd normally have are being offset by reduced activity and increase COVID-19 deaths. So looking at totals without that context doesn't help much. It's the same in the US. Article here: https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2020/04/16/coronavirus-leading-cause-death/?arc404=true https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2020/04/16/coronaviru...
- aphroz 7y agoYes, but what about comorbidity, when people die from cancer but had Covid-19, how do you define what killed them?
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoEurope's seen abnormally high mortality rates starting at the end of March. Someone sent me this graph, although unfortunately I didn't keep track of the source: https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-nq9Tcrho5QQ/XpjnH7DgeRI/AAAAAAAABUg/F0OE1eMwAQI3vZw6-_Ece_Zye4UtjTWbQCK8BGAsYHg/s0/2020-04-16.png https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-nq9Tcrho5QQ/XpjnH7DgeRI/A...
- aphroz 7y agoWe need to compare year to year, mortality is higher in January - March any year.
- virtualritz 7y agoThat reminds me of another headline from last month that was right up the Monty Python alley too: ”Turkmenistan Has Banned Use Of The Word ‘Coronavirus’” As a friend who’s a standup comedian said in response to reading that: “Brilliant, why didn’t our government think of this? We wouldn’t have all these problems.” [1] https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/03/31/824611607/turkmenistan-has-banned-use-of-the-word-coronavirus https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/0...
- wrs 7y agoRecall that the US President wanted to keep a cruise ship from docking because "I don't need to have the numbers double because of one ship that wasn't our fault". If your career is built on the principle that perception trumps reality, it's hard to adjust when reality doesn't cooperate.
- belltaco 7y agoThat's literally the case with 'climate change' being banned from government discussions and reports in the federal govt in the US and in various states. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/aug/08/trump-administration-climate-change-ban-usda https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/aug/08/trump-... https://www.thedailybeast.com/cheats/2015/03/09/florida-bans-saying-climate-change https://www.thedailybeast.com/cheats/2015/03/09/florida-bans...
- htk 7y agoBolsonaro has no negotiation skills, and is (frankly) bad at mostly everything, but he's got a good finance minister who's saying that the country just can't stop creating value, but what is the right balance? Mandetta, the previous health minister, had no flexibility in his views, he wanted to follow the WHO blindly, without weighing anything else. Maybe the new guy has the flexibility and the brains to find a better balance of views, and to create a strategy on top of it.
- ashtonkem 7y agoIt’s not the job of the health minister to consider the economy. If they’re thinking about that, they’re being an awful health minister. It’s the job of the executive to balance between the different paths recommended by different advisors, and chart a path that has the correct balance of trade offs.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoIt's the job of the health minister to give his boss useful policy options to choose from and that requires some level of understanding and accommodating the other variables that the boss has to consider. That means that the health minister has to consider the economy and the economy minister has to consider public health. I don't know much about this guy but if he was as bad at balancing the variables he had to consider as the GP suggests then I can see why he was removed.
- rodolphoarruda 7y agoThis is incredibly in alignment with the first speech of the new minister.
- grolimpio 7y agoThe former health minister was considering the economy and had speaked public a few times about it. He recommendations were based in the fact that the government couldn't simply switch from a horizontal isolation to a non planned vertical isolation. He main responsibility (at least the short term one) was to not overload the hospitals and put the health professionals in risk, and at least that he has achieved. On the other hand, the president wants a "vertical" isolation without a plan, he simply wants to "reopen the economy" (whatever it means). Remembering that he has largely underplayed the issue, calling it "just a little flu" (probably it would be better translated to: "just a cold"). Brazil doesn't have enough tests to make good decisions about which areas should be in a horizontal isolation or to be instead in a vertical one. The former health minister was clear that all the information coming from his office should be backed by science (and this alone was bugging the president a lot for some reason). This also meant that he, as the health minister, couldn't go public and say that a specific medication was effective to treat the covid-19 just because some tests worked in vitro (any doctor or scientist knows that this alone doesn't mean that it'll work efficiently in vivo). The president behaviour was the opposite, many times he went public to say that a drug tested in vitro was enough to have the horizontal isolation lifted out. And as a consequence or his irresponsible pronouncements, many of his followers ran to the drug stores to buy certain medications, leaving people that really need them for other diseases without medication. So the main issue turned out to be the fact that the former health minister was becoming popular because of his common sense, and everyone knows that in the eyes of a populist, "there can be only one".
- kippster 7y agoGood. It's about time the US did the same.
- sergiotapia 7y agoFinally - let people go back to their lives. How's Sweden doing these days?
- ashtonkem 7y agoBolsonaro believes that he’s personally immune because he’s an “athlete”. Wish I was kidding.
- sebastianconcpt 7y agoIsn't that recover of viral diseases which we don't have vaccines for are a function of immune system's response?
- grolimpio 7y agoIt's not that simple in cases where our immune system can also act as the villain [1][2]. We sure can act like irrational animals and play the natural selection card (and leave people to die an excruciating death), but I personally prefer to slow down the almost inevitable [3], so our health system has more time to cope with the situation as well as they can. [1] https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2020/04/07/828091467/why-some-covid-19-patients-crash-the-bodys-immune-system-might-be-to-blame https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2020/04/07/8280914... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/03/11/science/how-coronavirus-hijacks-your-cells.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/03/11/science/how-c... [3] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-02-13/coronavirus-could-infect-two-thirds-of-globe-researcher-says https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-02-13/coronavir...
- ashtonkem 7y agoYes and no. As a sibling pointed out, for some viruses it’s your own immune system that kills you. Also being athletic doesn’t really confer a magic boost to your immune system that overcomes age. It’s better than being obese and out of shape, but it isn’t going to magically restore your immune system to that of a 20 year old. Also, having seen videos of Bolsonaro doing “push-ups”, I’d say that formerly athletic is closer to the mark.
- droithomme 7y agoWhat could possibly go wrong?
- frozenlettuce 7y agoThe Brazilian supreme court already decided that state governors and city mayors can impose regional lockdowns. Most cities are already with restrictive measures and this event is not going to change that.
- aaomidi 7y agoWorkers having to die so their masters can add another zero to their bank accounts.
- soneca 7y agoIt is hard to predict the future, but despite the former Health minister indeed have being fired for clashing with Bolsonaro views, there is not much indication that the policy will in fact change now. It became a ego dispute in the last days, but original rumors that the role would be occupied by someone without health expertise that would follow Bolsonaro orders to the letter were wrong. The new minister is also a doctor who hinted that lockdown is necessary before. I believe Bolsonaro leadership is a disaster and more people will die because of his actions and speeches. I just don't think today's announcement will change much. It will not get worse. The governors here don't have that much autonomy as in the US, but they have enough to define what will indeed happen in the streets. This won't change with the new minister.
- gtirloni 7y agoAfter having undermined most of the efforts of his own health minister, Bolsonaro can't do much worse, I agree.
- sudoaza 7y agoHe's a total madman. Trump is a shithead but he'll read the situation or be advised by someone, jump ships and blame it on the chinese or something. This guy went 100% on this and is not turning back, to the level of taking people to the streets to force business owners to open, walking on the streets to chat with followers (while he's suspected positive covid) and calling for fasting and prayers as a solution. BTW Religious services were defined as "essential" so they can still be carried on. Much of his base is from a fanatic/fringe christian faith so maybe that's were that comes from. What worries me is that now Brazil is in a stand off, the military that surround him, vice-president included, have cutted him off power and congress is starting to look into an impeachment. But even if they do, and do away with Bolsonaro, then the military that ran with him will have the power, will finally declare the lockdown and anything can happen next, they'll be lucky if they have elections after that. Police abuse during lockdown grew a lot in other latin countries, i expect at least the same to happen there, who knows to which level.