7 ms·
Just reading the headline, what this means to me is that the "world economy" is doing a lot better than most of us are doing as individuals. I'm on a 25% furlou
by analog31 7y ago
Just reading the headline, what this means to me is that the "world economy" is doing a lot better than most of us are doing as individuals. I'm on a 25% furlough. Sales from my side business have dropped to zero. My other side job has dropped to zero. Among working people, I'm one of the lucky. My family actually has a little bit of money in the kitty.
"The economy" refers to a system that's primarily designed to concentrate and protect private wealth, and a 3% loss of private wealth isn't all that bad at all. The people who are really hurting have no wealth to lose.
I hope an outcome of this crisis is that we start to think about "the economy" in more humane terms.
- jdavis703 7y agoThe GDP (i.e. “the economy”) is a measure of all goods & services produced and consumed. Even if someone is paycheck to paycheck or hand to mouth, this means less goods and services they can make and consume. If this response was about crashing financial markets the blasé tone would be OK (ignoring that many retirees rely on pensions or bank accounts tied to financial markets). But this is about the entire economy.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- missedthecue 7y ago"the system" isn't designed to protect wealth so much as encourage productivity. There is a direct correlation between increases in productivity and increases in wealth, but a system designed to protect existing wealth would look much different than ours. For instance, cartels would not be illegal.
- pmiller2 7y agoWhat do you call it when real wages don’t go up in a system designed to “encourage productivity?” Since the gains aren’t going to workers at all, they must be going to those at the top, right? That sounds an awful lot like “protecting wealth” to me.
- altonzheng 7y agoWhile I agree with your sentiment that the system is flawed and not serving much of the population, I think the parent's point still stands. If the system was designed solely for protecting wealth, it wouldn't be encouraging competition -- ie. cartels and monopolies would be permitted. Make no mistake, whatever the goal is, the side-effects are unfortunate.
- thethethethe 7y ago> cartels and monopolies would be permitted Last time I checked both of these still exist and wield massive power globally. Just because something is “illegal” doesn’t mean that it isn’t part of the system. The system was “designed”, it’s behavior is emergent. States institute laws which have side effects and those side effects are part of the system.
- pmiller2 7y agoReally? You’re gonna tell me cartels and monopolies don’t exist when 10 companies control nearly the entire food and beverage industry? [0] What good is it being able to choose among 195 brands of bottled water [1] when there’s not much of a difference among them? Is this what all our productivity is going towards? Or maybe it’s all that advertising they drown us in to convince us to buy this stuff? —- [0]: https://www.businessinsider.com/10-companies-control-the-food-industry-2016-9 https://www.businessinsider.com/10-companies-control-the-foo... [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bottled_water https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bottled_water
- analog31 7y agoThe prohibition of cartels and monopolies is an old law that has been allowed to be gradually weakened.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ls612 7y agoThe difference between the median and the average strikes again! The popular comparison is that median real wages have only risen slightly from the 70s while average productivity (because by definition the labor productivity numbers are averages) has risen substantially. But much of that is due to the increases in productivity from high productivity individuals, say maybe those whose job it is to tell fancy electronic machines how to do low skill repetitive tasks. Some of those people might even browse this forum! There is actually fairly weak data to support the popular theory of a decreasing labor share of income (and thus an increasing capital share) causing more inequality and to the extent such an effect could exist its size is only a few percent of GDP over the past few decades.
- Polylactic_acid 7y ago"the system" is designed by people with wealth and is absolutely biased towards protecting it. Its just that encouraging productivity generates them more wealth.
- bilegeek 7y agoPretty much Rules for Rulers[1]. [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs
- billfruit 7y agoThat don't negate the parent's argument, that many measures and structures for protecting wealth are outlawed/regulated agaisnt in our world including monopolies, rent seeking, cartels, etc. That seems to be an argument against the claim that the system is designed to protect wealth.
- ibeckermayer 7y agoOur culture is riddled with legal cartels, see medical test production for a horrifyingly relevant example.
- nl 7y ago"The economy" refers to a system that's primarily designed to concentrate and protect private wealth, and a 3% loss of private wealth isn't all that bad at all This isn't really true. A 3% contraction in the world's economy is the sum of all countries GDPs. That's a measure of how much "stuff" (goods and services) is produced. It's more closely correlated with unemployment than with the stock market (ie, with private wealth).
- xvedejas 7y agoBut when we're measuring the "world economy" it's not like we're measuring the heights of the stacks of gold behind scrooge mcduck's coffers, right? These numbers represent things like society's ability to make products people want, and peoples' willingness to spend their savings on things that are useful (instead of stuffing it in their mattress). The effects on labor are terrible, and your furlough reflects that. I personally was recently laid off, and likewise many individuals are hit much harder than 3%. But it's not like we should wish that other parts of the economy were hit as badly. None of it is good.
- analog31 7y agoIndeed. I don't want anybody's money to just vanish. And while as others have pointed out, the numbers are a measure of productivity for somebody, the ability of workers to capture their own productivity in wages is not guaranteed.
- covidacct 7y agoThe ability of workers to capture their own productivity gains is a lower than it's been in a century. This crisis will push the second derivative lower.
- cinquemb 7y agoBut we don't like talking about M2V[0] anymore because it didn't jibe with the daily propaganda for years that all is well [0] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2V https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2V
- jibe 7y agoPeople, especially the press, don't talk about M2V because they don't understand it. No one does outside finance or econ classrooms, and most of them don't either. BTW, jibe, not jive.
- deleted 7y ago
- flexie 7y agoGiven that the population growth is around 80,000,000 yearly, or 1 percent, we are looking at a world GDP per capita decline of 4 percent. Since large parts of the world's population barely had enough for food as it were, and that even in the first world, a lot of the production goes to create wealth for the few rich, and most people don't save much or anything to begin with, it's going to be felt. And do we really believe it stops there? Will people actually want to travel and dine out as much as they used to once the lockdowns are over? Or will they be careful for months or maybe years to come? What happens when the virus really spreads in Africa, India, South East Asia and South America? Will they barely care because they are so young it's not dangerous to them? And what about the second and third wave in the first world? What if the vaccine or cure is not that easy to make and distribute so we don't have any before mid or late 2021?
- nerfhammer 7y agoThe 3% drop refers to productivity, not wealth. So it's like the average of 7.8 billion people is creating and consuming 3% less.
- HSO 7y ago> a 3% loss of private wealth GDP is a flow variable.
- anovikov 7y agoExcept there is no concentration of private wealth in the long term, and income from capital plays an exceedingly small role in the overall economy. Even those in the top 0.1% mostly make their money from wages. What you observe is that fact that a great majority of people live on fixed income which doesn't get hit (because these people are useless anyway, like most government employees), and many live off pensions, plus government boosts it's spending. So those who actually make their living, lose a lot more. But same is true about good times, when economy books it's not policemen or school teachers who get biggest raises. Those with capital are even further up the risk curve: when stock market drops, they directly lose money. And dividends on the stock can easily drop to almost zero.
- imtringued 7y agoLosses are only realized when you sell. A temporary drop only causes panic sellers to lose money.