9 ms·
Take EVERYTHING in that article with a giant tub of salt. The specifics of torpedo combat are some of the most closely guarded military secrets. Take the foll
by sandworm101 7y ago
Take EVERYTHING in that article with a giant tub of salt. The specifics of torpedo combat are some of the most closely guarded military secrets.
Take the following: "These high-torque, permanent magnet electric motor torpedoes ramp up to speed in under a second. They go from sitting in a torpedo tube to 50 knots in a near-instant because they don’t have the mechanical lag and inertia thermal torpedoes must overcome during startup. "
So much of that is totally wrong. The torpedo has nothing to do with how it gets out of the tube. Its propulsor (not a propeller) wont work from the back of a torpedo tube. Starting it up in the tube, INSIDE the sub, sounds horribly dangerous. The torp is ejected by force from the sub and then starts its engine. Electric or thermal, it's doing 50+ whether it wants to or not. Once out of the tube, further acceleration potential is limited by depth/pressure. All torps have more than enough torque to start cavitating their propulsor in shallow water. To continue to automotive analogy, it doesn't matter whether your car is electric or turbine powered, acceleration is limited by how much power your tires can handle before spinning.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PjoholiW1ho https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PjoholiW1ho
And this is why you don't want that engine running prior to the torp leaving the tube.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KoElLaLcfOc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KoElLaLcfOc
- smabie 7y ago"Aaron Amick is a retired U.S. Navy submarine sonarman. He served in both Atlantic and Pacific Oceans on 688 Los Angles Class Fast Attack and Ohio class ballistic missile submarines. He has published two audiobooks on Cold War-era submarines, Akula SSN Project 971 Sub Brief and USS Nautilus SSN-571 Sub Brief." I dunno, the author's bio suggests that he knows that he's talking about.
- rudyfink 7y agoApparently, there are things called "swim out" torpedoes? https://www.reddit.com/r/submarines/comments/at5nt4/silent_launch_torpedo/ https://www.reddit.com/r/submarines/comments/at5nt4/silent_l... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YbeQmfXE0ws https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YbeQmfXE0ws - discussed in this video (from in the parent article)
- sandworm101 7y agoThose are sometimes called "stealth" torps. They run quiet, and slow, so they don't want the noisy launch procedure. But they also don't do 50 knots. On the other end of the scale there are the rocket torpedoes, really missiles that fly underwater at speeds over 200 knots. You might hear them coming but won't be able to do much about them. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VA-111_Shkval https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VA-111_Shkval And there are even anti-aircraft torpedoes in development. They are a total gamechanger. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IDAS_(missile) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IDAS_(missile)
- ckozlowski 7y agoActually, latter versions of the Mark 48 will do this, running at variable speed. Slow launch, creep towards the target, and dogleg even, then run up to 50+ knots once it's close enough to be heard. With wire guidance, the sub could essentially drive the torpedo to where they wanted it before violent speed and maneuvering would likely cut the wires. This was depicted somewhat famously in the book Red Storm Rising. By all accounts it was accurate. Shkval is a really special case and not the supertorpedo some made it out to be. It's a countermeasure really, and it's range is far too short to use against other submarines. It's a last resort weapon, when someone's already found you. IDAS seems really fascinating to me though, like the "Stinger SAM mast" concepts I'd sometimes hear about. IDAS seems more practical and safe to me though. Coming up to periscope depth to take a potshot at a helo sounds like a risky maneuver to me. IDAS would give better options.
- willvarfar 7y agoManpad-type missiles like the British Blowpipe have been mounted on submarine masks. A major threat to a submarine is all the helicopters and patrol aircraft with their dipping sonars etc. There are some really great pics taken from periscopes of opposition helicopters during the cold war. Nothing you'd want to see in a hot war neither. It seems good to throw a little missile at the helicopter you've just spotted approaching, to give them something to evade and worry about as you make your escape?
- sandworm101 7y agoMore wrong stuff... "It is best if the weapon detonates within a meter of the hull, but a contact detonation can have devastating effects against even the largest warships." Torpedoes targeting ships definitely do not want to hit anywhere near the hull. They explode well beneath the target, tens of meters below. They don't try to directly damage the target. Their explosives create a large void of gas, a hole, under the ship. The ship then cracks in half as it 'falls' into the hole. Whether this technique is also used against submarines, with much stronger hulls, is likely classified. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S6zQ0wBvh18 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S6zQ0wBvh18
- missedthecue 7y agoThe Russian VA-111 Shkval torpedo explodes on impact, but then again, it's traveling underwater at 370km/h
- dmos62 7y agoTrivia: I'm pretty sure that shkval in Russian means heavy, stormy rain.
- throwaway_pdp09 7y ago"squall"
- jacobush 7y agoshriek
- amelius 7y agoBut this would mean the ship also breaks when hit by two normal sea waves with the right spacing between them.
- nabla9 7y agoTrue. The explanation given is wrong. Proximity detonation breaks the ship from the force the gas bubble directs upwards.
- willvarfar 7y agoYou are over-analyzing. There is nothing in the sentence you quote that says if the torpedo was launched or swam out etc. Nothing in the sentence you quote even qualified how long "near instant" was. Etc. You are also saying you know more about this subject than the sub vet who wrote the article...?
- smilespray 7y agoAuthor is known as Jive Turkey on YouTube, and he knows his stuff. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC9bMgCQyFNaMPsK9GtzM5dQ https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC9bMgCQyFNaMPsK9GtzM5dQ
- jfoutz 7y agoVery tangential question. I can think of only a handful of targets that the US might want to shoot at. (I realize there might be a ton, and this is my lack of imagination). The handful I can think of, almost all of them seem like they're in the supply chain to actually build the torpedos. I'm pretty skeptical of the depth of the US stockpile. To put it another way, if there was a war so bad, the US reinstituted the draft, would these tools still be relevant? The US industrial base is mighty, and could certainly retool to meet whatever need arises, but that'll take years. Really seems neat, but after you've taken your 20 or 50 or whatever shots, how do you resupply? Seems like you'd need special coatings or shelf stable chemicals or a hundred other things to make the super fancy weapon. it sure _seems_ like (although I have no fucking clue, so I'm asking) the super fancy weapons are available for a few weeks if things get real bad. _edit_ realized I didn't actually ask a question. Can the US actually build these things from, like, minerals? It's a big country, we have them. The industrial base doesn't seem tuned for actually doing that though. _further edit_ I'm a very silly person. it seems like the only must have is a plausible second strike capability. It's great to be able to protect the free flow of oil, or defend the Kurds from chemical weapons. Hell, one of the most American things I can think of is protecting yankee clippers for safe trade. It's part of the Marine's Hymn. but clearing pirates from the shores of Tripoli isn't absolutely vital. I'd sort of thought that subs jobs in the modern world was making sure that if the US can't play, no one else can either, with moderately sized nuclear weapons. Again, I'm a very silly person. The question with the further edit is, do subs have an essential job beyond second strike cabability?
- londons_explore 7y ago> To put it another way, if there was a war so bad, the US reinstituted the draft, would these tools still be relevant? The drafted people would all go to factories and boatyards to build thousands of new submarines. Each submarine would likely have no people on board, and be fully remote control. The age old problem of "you can't hide while sending and receiving data, so you can't make a drone sub" has been solved by using below-noise-floor gold codes, so without the coding key, nobody can even tell a transmission is going on.
- 7y ago