10 ms·
Ticketmaster changes policy, no longer offering refunds on postponed shows
- rhombocombus 7y agoThis is completely unsurprising. Ticketmaster's entire business model seems to be monopolizing ticket sales and then gouging the consumer, so one last stick in the eye from them seems in character.
- brianwawok 7y agoTicketmaster going under would be a good thing for users.
- alexfromapex 7y agoI would say it would be a great thing. It’s insane that monopolies like Ticketmaster have been allowed to control entire markets and charge whatever they want and do whatever they want because consumers have no alternative.
- pravda 7y agoYou could not go to concerts. That is the alternative.
- etrabroline 7y agoYea, and if you didn't like Standard Oil, you could just not own a car (or factory).
- pravda 7y agoThat's not the same. The price to get into, for example, a Drake concert is determined not by Drake, but by how much people are willing to pay to see Drake. If the total cost, including all fees and taxes, is more then you want to pay, then don't buy tickets. Don't blame Ticketmaster for the high price to see Drake in concert, blame Drake fans! But if the Drake concert is cancelled, or re-scheduled, then do a chargeback.
- Spivak 7y agoYou won't have an alternative with whatever replaces Ticketmaster because they don't have a monopoly on anything. Any venue putting on a show has no particular reason to use TM outside it providing value to them. There's no lock-in. Hell, there's anti-lock-in. If a venue bucks the trend and doesn't use TM customers will cheer. Well they'll cheer until they realize why everyone chooses TM. Their competition isn't any cheaper and has an even worse customer service. Seriously, I got tickets to a Luke Bryan concert and had to use some no-name ticket service and their "customer service" was a phone number with a full voicemail and was only open Tues-Thurs 8-4 PM. I just checked again and they have since switched to TM. Honestly just call the box-office. It's rare for TM to have an exclusivity contract and most places will just charge you the sticker price and mail/will-call the tickets since it's all the same to them.
- treis 7y ago>There's no lock-in. Hell, there's anti-lock-in. If a venue bucks the trend and doesn't use TM customers will cheer. That's not true. Live Nation runs many big name tours and will (allegedly) avoid venues that don't use Ticketmaster.
- girvo 7y agoIf you as a venue use something other than TM, you can lose future TM run shows if there are comparable venues in your area.
- jariel 7y agoThey are a mafia monopoly in the most classical sense. For starters answer the question 'why everyone uses Ticketmaster'? What's the value again? Because there is no obvious value-creating reason. Live Nation owns 200 venues, and 300 major artists. With enough control over the value chain, you have to pay their tax, or go out of business as the artists they control - or other artists they can bully - avoid your venues entirely. Their power is entirely based on anti-competitive practice - they don't actually do anything of real merit. Plainly 'selling tickets' is not hard.
- etrabroline 7y ago
- HenryBemis 7y agoWell, we (the people) are the ones who keep those thieves in business. They could as well be printing money. Once this covid19 blows over, we (the people) need to remember who was naughty and who was nice, and send the naughty to oblivion. Because if we forget Ticketmaster (what an asshole of a name) will go back to its routine, overcharging etc. I have never purchased a ticket from them and never will. It is a matter of principle. If we all do the same they will either go bust (let's remember to treat similarly the Ticketmaster 2.0 that will spring up under a different name)(same tactics, different front cover).
- TAForObvReasons 7y agoTicketmaster's business model is to take the reputation hit and allow venues and performers to increase fees. This specific move is probably driven by greedy venues. https://stubcrew.com/the-ugly-truth-about-ticketmaster-fees/ https://stubcrew.com/the-ugly-truth-about-ticketmaster-fees/ talks about it more. EDIT: and the downvotes here is probably evidence that they succeeded
- cletus 7y agoNot sure why you're getting downvoted (unfortunately people seem to use this as a proxy for "I disagree with you" or, worse, "you contradict my position"; here have an upvote) but you are 100% correct. All those fees Ticketmaster charges, the artist (and venue?) gets a cut off. Ticketmaster is the lightning rod here but everyone is complicit.
- Someone1234 7y agoAgreed, they're one of several "lightning rod" organizations. They exist to deflect hate, while everyone profits. Same thing with academic textbooks. Book publishers are lightning rods, allowing collages/departments/professors to avoid the reputation hit. If you want to know who is responsible for a bad thing just answer one question: Who has the power to fix it? For example performers/venues could use a non-ticketmaster intermediary, and college professors/schools could assign a non-$300 textbook, but neither do because they gain substantially from the arrangement (either financially or in terms of free labor in the textbook example). So if you "hate" ticketmaster or textbook publishers, you're playing right into their game and the problem will never be fixed. You have to pressure actual decision makers, not lightning rods.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoYou can’t fix people, only incentives.
- Teever 7y ago> For example performers/venues could use a non-ticketmaster intermediary, It's not so easy. Doing so can lock them out of business with ticketmaster.
- chiph 7y agoIt wasn't always this way. My college job in the early 90's was at a record store that had a Ticketmaster machine. This was a CRT terminal with custom impact (not dot-matrix!) ticket printer, talking to their central computer over a leased line. They paid for all of that with a $2.25 charge on each ticket sold. And somehow today, they're charging you even more to print the ticket yourself at home, on your equipment, on your internet connection, on your paper.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- edlebert 7y agoI've heard from some large event organizers that EventBrite is taking similar measures: delaying payouts to event organizers until the event has concluded. I heard from one organizer that they were told by EventBrite that they were not going to see a payout until 2021 for their Labor Day 2020 event.
- jariel 7y agoIf that's true, it could be an excuse to financialise the money. Let it earn 5% while you don't have to pay it out. Or worse, use it for opex in a big ole ponzi scheme style busines!
- bane 7y agoTicketmaster is corporate cancer that could probably be 90% replaced by a couple folks with a webapp.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- no-such-address 7y agoSomething else to know is that Ticketmaster is happy to list and collect commissions from 3rd party ticket sales, but they excuse themselves from "Ticketmaster Fan Support" policies. Caveat emptor.
- techntoke 7y agoFrom what I can tell based on this post, it is up to the event organizers.
- Jedd 7y agoOriginal article this one cites, published four days ago: https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2020/04/10/ticketmaster-quietly-changes-refund-policy/ https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2020/04/10/ticketmaster-qui...
- kraig 7y agoThe Times covered this on the 8th. The policy didn't change https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/08/arts/music/ticketmaster-refunds-coronavirus.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/08/arts/music/ticketmaster-r...
- ipython 7y agoHow can this be legal? They changed the terms and conditions after you agreed to them and provided you no way to opt out of the change?
- Someone1234 7y agoEven if it isn't legal are people really going to assert their rights in court? That's one of the major problems with having weak consumer protections in the US. If this happened in one of several European countries ticketmaster could be fined, but in the US each citizen needs to sue in small claims or will be forced into arbitration that may cost more than the claim is worth (essentially nullifying their rights, or losing money to assert them). Arguing that your rights have been violated with their customer services is a waste of time.
- jacobr1 7y agoWhile less efficient than regulatory action, the US does have a mechanism for this: class-action lawsuits.
- mindslight 7y agoClass action lawsuits are just another method of regulatory capture. The settlement from the last Ticketbastard class action was a $2 discount on expedited shipping and a voucher for a free show of your choice, to be chosen from an empty list.
- wlesieutre 7y ago> YOU AGREE TO WAIVE ANY RIGHT TO A JURY TRIAL OR TO PARTICIPATE IN A CLASS ACTION LAWSUIT OR CLASS-WIDE ARBITRATION. https://help.ticketmaster.com/s/article/Terms-of-Use?language=en_US#section17 https://help.ticketmaster.com/s/article/Terms-of-Use?languag... What we need is a law invalidating contracts with blanket requirements to give up consumer protections and legal recourse against companies
- kevin_thibedeau 7y ago
- lazzlazzlazz 7y agoAlthough Ticketmaster offers a seemingly simple service, thousands of integrations with venues and the people who create events make them extremely difficult to unseat. I don't know of many credible competitors besides Big Neon (https://www.bigneon.com/ https://www.bigneon.com/), founded by a former c-founder of Ticketfly.
- caseysoftware 7y agoYears ago, I was working on an idea and interviewed venue owners to understand what gaps their were. At the time, Ticketmaster gave them the cc processing equipment for free and took a smaller % in exchange for exclusivity for years at a time. After hearing that dozens of times at big and small venues, I moved onto another idea.
- lalaland1125 7y agoIt's not legal for Ticketmaster to retroactively change their policy on old bookings. Unfortunately many other entities are misbehaving in a similar manner. (For example way.com is performing similar shenanigans by changing their policy on March 25th and then claiming that their new policy applies to all reservations after February 25th.) Make sure to keep your rights in mind when companies misbehave: 1. You can submit a negative review online 2. You can file a credit card chargeback 3. You can submit a complaint to your attorney general 4. You can sue them in small claims court Other key note: Do not accept gift cards or credit for future bookings. A refund by definition is cash and that credit will be worthless when those companies declare bankruptcy shortly.
- jrs235 7y ago*3. a) You can submit a complaint to your attorney general. b) You can submit a complaint to the attorney general of __________, the State that Ticketmaster is incorporated in (I'm unable to find which State this is at the moment, anyone?). and c). You can submit a complaint to the attorney general of the State that the venue is in.
- hjkgfdfgh 7y agoGood luck with the chargeback. I tried to open one with Amex online and it was insta-denied with a note to the effect that I needed to work it out with Ticketmaster myself. I'm hoping Amex phone support is willing to work with me, whenever I make it through. Ticketmaster's phone support tells you to open a live chat, then hangs up on you. When you open a live chat you get a canned response that the show is postponed and to go away until it's either canceled or rescheduled... then auto ends chat. If nothing else, I can at least enjoy the minor irony that is getting fucked by the machine over a few Rage Against the Machine tickets.
- RangerScience 7y agoGenerally speaking, I think blockchain is not a good answer for most things, but this is leading me to consider whether it might be an excellent tool for ticket economics. Consider: Each ticket is already nearly a contract; making them into smart contracts seems very straightforward. Tickets do not have the "oracle" / "reality capture" problem many block chain applications have - tickets are essentially pure information to start with. Initial ticket sales combined with an aftermarket very closely resemble ICOs and subsequent coin trading. AFAICT the big stumbling block is the ticket-coin-to-USD conversion; maybe a perfect fit for stable coins? Ah - the other big stumbling block is the UX around ticket redemption; making sure it's convenient, reliable and not exploitable. Hmm. The _interesting_ part IMO is how this could work with spending money from ticket sales prior to the show; you have proof that you'll make X revenue and could borrow against it, at some rate that already includes risk factors. If you have to cancel your show, refunds are "automatic" as per whatever the smart contract specified, and the risk (borne by the lender) is (is the word?) actualized?
- formercoder 7y agoLet’s apply the “do you need blockchain” test: do we need zero trust distributed consensus? No? Then no.
- RangerScience 7y agoFair-ish. Issue is that any entity that has free reign to modify the state of the chain can modify the tickets; such as deciding to no longer give refunds. AFAIK, there are four entities in shows, with varying levels of trust between then: fans, venues, performers, and the ticketing company. (I'm considering ticket redemption are part of "venue"). Some ability to decentrally coordinate without complete trust seems worth exploring at least as a thought experiment. I'm not saying this definitely is a valid application of block chain, just that it looks more like it could be than anything else I've seen.
- formercoder 7y agoThat’s what we have legal systems for. Even if there was some technical barrier for modifying contracts, it still doesn’t work. Not sure if there’s a name for the opposite of the oracle problem but on the output side, but the theaters can still just refuse to honor the tickets. Again we’re back to it being all about the actual contract. Also does every ticket holder run a node? Is that practical? If not, we have the oracle problem at the other end.
- funfunfunction 7y agoShameless Plug: It’s still a WIP, and obviously this covid stuff has been hard for us, but my company sellout.io is trying to build a fair alternative that ultimately gives artists the ability to sell tickets directly to fans. Ticketmaster’s rein will end soon.
- i_am_nomad 7y agoThat’s always going to be a WIP. If artists want to cut out Ticketmaster, they already can, and sometimes do. Ticketmaster exists solely because artists want to charge lots of money but maintain a warm relationship with their fans.
- funfunfunction 7y agoThis is not true for artists. 1/3 of all tickets end up on the secondary market, a few of which Ticketmaster owns. This where fans spend a huge amount of money that artists never see. If Ticketmaster is charging a 10% markup in the primary market and a ticket sells for $100, they make $10. If they charge the same percentage in the secondary market (tip: they don’t) they would make $40. That money the artist never has a chance to see. Even though a fan is willing to pay $400, most of it goes to Ticketmaster’s scalpers and Ticketmaster. Ticketmaster is still around because of anti-competitive practices, not because they’re a lightening rod.
- anonAndOn 7y agoYou have a compelling offer to Ticketmaster's free money? Those giant stadiums are likely getting million dollar annual upfront payments for signing exclusive multi-year ticketing deals. Not even the mighty Pearl Jam (in their prime, no less) could beat the hated Ticketmaster.[0] [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ticketmaster#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ticketmaster#History
- funfunfunction 7y agoYes, make more money over a longer period of time, create a better experience for your customers, and be treated well. Their free money isn’t free, and venues are starting to notice.
- danhak 7y agoThis policy is against California law: California BPC 22507: "The ticket price of any event which is canceled, postponed, or rescheduled shall be fully refunded to the purchaser by the ticket seller upon request. Any local jurisdiction may require a ticket seller to provide a bond of not more than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) to provide for any refunds that may be required by this section." (Added by Stats. 1986, Ch. 378, Sec. 1.) Ticketmaster is based in California. IANAL and don't know how this law might apply to events that are held elsewhere.
- Narkov 7y agoSame for Australia. You need your government to protect you from this kind of terrible behaviour.
- Nerada 7y agoThat isn't clear-cut, at least not in NSW. The department of Fair Trading set up a series of pages which can be summarised by the quote "if the event is cancelled due to government restrictions, this impacts your rights under the consumer guarantees", followed by a plea to businesses to be nice (ha). https://www.fairtrading.nsw.gov.au/resource-library/publications/coronavirus-covid-19/travel-and-event-cancellations https://www.fairtrading.nsw.gov.au/resource-library/publicat...
- sandworm101 7y agoJust as Uber doesn't provide transport, Ticketmaster doesn't sell tickets. They characterize themselves a broker, someone facilitating sales between "Event Providers" and customers. They will pass the responsibility to concert organizers. A lawyer would describe most "Event Providers" as judgment proof, ie too poor to be worth a lawsuit. These aren't the rockstars nor their touring companies. The event provider is the local organization who rents the venue and manages the individual concert. They are all currently shut down, employees laid off, and are likely talking to bankruptcy experts. For example: Vancouver just cancelled its jazz festival. That festival's "event organizer" is the "Coastal Jazz & Blues Society" ... a listed non-profit. There is no blood in that stone.
- meritt 7y agoCredit card chargebacks are going to put that company out of business.
- vernie 7y agoI've always wanted to do a chargeback!
- anonAndOn 7y agoIMHO, this is the ONLY way to get Ticketmaster to revert its policy. Refusing refunds on postponements was likely a stopgap measure as the ticket sales were likely forwarded on to the venues/promoters on a rolling basis and Ticketmaster is holding insufficient funds to immediately issue blanket refunds. I also suspect Ticketmaster does not have the manpower, nor the contractual ability to pass along a tsunami of chargeback losses on to the venues so it will raise the alarm bells very quickly if there are 100k new chargebacks this month. Not only will that freeze millions of dollars in revenues it will also cost a couple million dollars in chargeback fees. Bonus! It also has the potential to mess with their CC processor discounts as they can get in big trouble for high chargeback numbers.
- Marsymars 7y agoMy bank refused, as their policy is to not do chargebacks for postponed events. (PayPal also denied my dispute claim.)
- vernie 7y agoThe only good thing Ticketmaster ever did was employ Terry A. Davis.
- whyhow 7y agoShould I just do a credit card chargeback for an postponed event? Are there any drawbacks? I tried to chat with their customer service and it wouldn't let me because my event wasn't eligible for a refund.
- anonAndOn 7y agoUnless you are a nuisance customer that frequently files chargebacks, there shouldn't be any drawbacks for you. The onus of responsibility lies with the merchant who must provide the processor with sufficient evidence that your claim is fraudulent or unjustified. Which, in this case, almost certainly means you will win the claim and Ticketmaster will lose the funds and be assessed a chargeback fee for the privilege.
- Nextgrid 7y agoA company reneging on their terms seems like a perfect case for a chargeback. They took your money and promised to abide by certain terms and are now changing them retroactively without letting you opt out of the deal and get your money back.
- rapind 7y agoI'm not a Ticketmaster fan from back in the Pearl Jam days, but I think there's a misunderstanding in a lot of these comments. If you are just the platform that venues use, and someone asks for a refund, it's pretty heavy for the platform to be on the hook for the full cost right now (due to a massive amount of refunds). In the short term it can effect your cashflow (covering refunds to consumers while you try to collect from the venue), and in the long terms it could be a huge loss if you're unable to collect from a significant amount of your venues (money already spent). In general you probably wouldn't want to hold excessive amounts in reserve from the venues because it could be a huge negative factor for them (money needed to setup the event), but right now with Coronavirus it's gotta be really messing with them.
- grawprog 7y ago>If you are just the platform that venues use, and someone asks for a refund, it's pretty heavy for the platform to be on the hook for the full cost right now So, Ticketmaster should make profit off of distributing tickets for venues and events, but not be responsible for issuing refunds for the tickets they sold? Seems like that should be part of the risk of operating as a middleman whose sole purpose in existing is to sell something for somebody else, that basically would sell itself however it was being sold while sitting in the middle just sucking up money.
- sciurus 7y agoThis is why Eventbrite has stopped issuing advanced payouts to venues. Given the increased risk, they need to keep the money on hand for potential refunds. I wonder if Ticketmaster has done something similar. https://www.eventbrite.com/blog/advanced-payouts-changes-related-to-covid-19/ https://www.eventbrite.com/blog/advanced-payouts-changes-rel...
- rapind 7y agoNo doubt. Typically they would hold a reserve based on a risk calculation. This epidemic would have completely invalidated the old math on how much to reserve and I suspect has therefore left a lot of platforms in a shitty position or cash strapped.
- zapttt 7y agoI hope all their clients gets lots of non-refunded cancelations. always went out of my way to not pay their abusive service fee (sometimes more expensive than the ticket). until all the suckers would buy exclusively from them, killing all alternatives. hope it plays out realy, realy bad to everyone who is their clients. nothing of value is lost.
- nickthemagicman 7y agoIs Ticketmaster the definition of an anti-competetive monopoly that anti-trust laws exist to break up?
- peterburkimsher 7y agoI wouldn't be particularly upset if Ticketmaster continue to pay the band as if they'd actually played the show. I'd bought 3 concert tickets for shows that got cancelled due to the lockdown, for a total of a few hundred $. I can listen to the music online, but I know that musicians make much more money from touring, so that's my way to support them. As long as the performers get paid, I don't mind, because half the reason I go to concerts is just to pay the bands I like. The other half is bragging rights to tell friends which bands I saw live.
- hnburnsy 7y agoAccording to this, as 'primary', Ticketmaster typically holds the money until after the show which puts them in a better position than Stubhub... "Here’s how the money works in concerts: ... Meanwhile, the “primary” ticketing companies associated with the venues the artist will play sell tickets over several days of presales (artist password, credit card, Facebook or Spotify password, venue or radio station password) during which, hopefully, many of the tickets are sold. Finally, the remaining tickets are released to the general public sale. With luck the show sold out. With a lot of luck, demand was so high that dynamic pricing kicked in, and the ticket prices were moved up continuously over the course of the days tickets were sold. In almost every case, the primary market charges a fee on every ticket sold. Typically primary markets don’t pay the artist until the show is played, the money raised from selling the tickets is held." https://www.ticketnews.com/2020/04/opinion-stubhubs-urgent-peril-and-the-industry-response/ https://www.ticketnews.com/2020/04/opinion-stubhubs-urgent-p...
- hnarn 7y agoSomething tells me this is going to increase the amount of chargebacks from customer using credit cards, and from my limited understanding of them I don't see why credit card companies wouldn't accept them, which would damage the reputation of Ticketmaster. It wouldn't surprise me if this is immediately illegal under EU law, but even if it's not, in my country customers shopping with a credit card are under additional protection since the credit card company is actually the "responsible party", not the merchant, so they would legally have to pay up. Smells like a potential lawsuit in that case between Ticketmaster and any generic credit card company affected by this.
- medina305 7y agoBE SMART AND BECOME RICH IN LESS THAN 3 DAYS....It all depends on how fast you can be to get the new PROGRAMMED blank ATM card that is capable of hacking into any ATM machine,anywhere in the world. I got to know about this BLANK ATM CARD when I was searching for job online about a month ago..It has really changed my life for good and now I can say I'm rich and I can never be poor again. The least money I get in a day with it is about $50,000.(fifty thousand USD) Every now and then I keeping pumping money into my account. Though is illegal,there is no risk of being caught, because it has been programmed in such a way that it is not traceable, it also has a technique that makes it impossible for the CCTVs to detect you..For details on how to get yours today, email the hackers on : (georgbednorzhackers@gmail.com). Tell your loved once too, and start to live large. That's the simple testimony of how my life changed for good...Love you all ...the email address again is ; georgbednorzhackers@gmail.com