14 ms·
> There is nothing in the privacy policy that addresses [that data is being sent to Facebook] > The Zoom app notifies Facebook when the user opens the app, det
by godelski 7y ago
> There is nothing in the privacy policy that addresses [that data is being sent to Facebook]
> The Zoom app notifies Facebook when the user opens the app, details on the user's device such as the model, the time zone and city they are connecting from, which phone carrier they are using, and a unique advertiser identifier created by the user's device which companies can use to target a user with advertisements
So Zoom is sending the fingerprints of mobile users to Facebook. Which helps Facebook better track users across the internet. Not only this, but Zoom is not disclosing this information (though it isn't like people read TOS and would be aware of this anyways).
Can we just stop sending data everywhere? If you don't need it, don't gather it.
- robin_reala 7y agoThe good thing is that this is illegal in the EU, so they can just be sued for problematic amounts of money.
- saagarjha 7y agoIs it illegal in California?
- dcroley 7y agounder CCPA, yes.
- sicromoft 7y agoAnyone know the best way to get started with suing them? Or should I assume that's already being done?
- kasey_junk 7y agoThey can’t be sued. They can be reported to a proper privacy authority who can chose to do something about it or not.
- Nextgrid 7y agoAnd as of right now (2 years after the law went into effect) privacy regulators still don't care and nothing suggests things will change. * I've put lots of time into raising complaints with the ICO (the privacy regulator in the UK) and even for the few complaints that were upheld (they try to find every single possible excuse not to), it still didn't have any effect and I have yet to see a proper investigation into the company or a fine. * please don't bring up the 50M Google fine about them forcing the creation of an account while setting up an Android device. Not only is it pocket money to them (aka the cost of doing business) but this ignores the much larger problem like Google Analytics stalking everyone's behaviour across the entire Internet.
- tzs 7y agoGDPR Article 79 [1]: > 1. Without prejudice to any available administrative or non-judicial remedy, including the right to lodge a complaint with a supervisory authority pursuant to Article 77, each data subject shall have the right to an effective judicial remedy where he or she considers that his or her rights under this Regulation have been infringed as a result of the processing of his or her personal data in non-compliance with this Regulation. > 2. Proceedings against a controller or a processor shall be brought before the courts of the Member State where the controller or processor has an establishment. 2Alternatively, such proceedings may be brought before the courts of the Member State where the data subject has his or her habitual residence, unless the controller or processor is a public authority of a Member State acting in the exercise of its public powers. That sounds like a lawsuit to me. [1] https://gdpr-info.eu/art-79-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-79-gdpr/
- kasey_junk 7y agoSee article 78. There is an escalation path.
- leggomylibro 7y agoIt's past time for us to get serious and apply HIPAA-style protection to the storage and transmission of PII, without exemptions. Companies like Facebook will complain loudly that they won't be able to survive, but that is not our problem. If we pass legislation with teeth, they will need to change their business model. That would be the point.
- ilikehurdles 7y agoZoom has allegedly HIPAA-compliant BAAs with users in the health space. If any PHI data is making it over to Facebook without a similar agreement from Facebook, Zoom is in for some trouble.
- spitfire 7y agoIP address, telephone number, city and other identifying information is ALL considered PII. I work with (adjacent industry) HIPAA protected data, which is considered PII by virtue of knowing Bob Smith is in the system. If they're under a BAA and sending that information to Facebook they're in violation. If one of my sub-processors did this my lawyer would be livid. But hey, it's Silicon Valley, don't harsh their buzz man.
- sizzle 7y agoHow do you even report something this technical to non technical folks who oversee HIPAA? Would you have to do a case study style write up?
- SlowRobotAhead 7y agoYou think Zoom is doing it for fun? This is a revenue source right?
- doctor_eval 7y agoWhy do comments suggesting that data collection is paid for by Facebook/google get downvoted? Serious question. This wasn’t my comment but I think it’s true and I’ve said the same previously and was downvoted too. Is it because it’s obvious and well known? Did I miss the memo too? If Facebook is encouraging the capture and transmission of this data and paying for it, does this mean that Facebook has indemnified Zoom?
- SlowRobotAhead 7y agoI’ve long since given up trying to figure out why HN goes and goes against certain things. The vote system here is one of the clearest examples of “let’s build a bubble” that I can think of. There is no way Zoom is just sending secret data to FB out of the evilness (because it’s not goodness!) of their hearts for fun. So someone is trading value somewhere.
- detaro 7y agoObviously someone at Zoom thinks they get value out if it. But that's quite different from "this is a revenue source", which would suggest Facebook paying money for it. Your typical company will happily put a tracking SDK in so some marketers get some more graphs to look at in Facebook Analytics.
- SlowRobotAhead 7y agoHow do you know if it isn’t a revenue stream? I guess I’m thinking that if this information that Zoom (a publicly traded company) was doing this, it would be bad for business, so doing it just optionally for fun, seems like all risk and that an appropriate reward would be a financial incentive.
- somethoughts 7y agoSimilar to how we have organizations which can certify whether produce is organic or not, we need organizations which can certify whether apps and websites are certified ad tracking free.
- skylarchunk 7y agoThis is an interesting point. Either the government would then need businesses to disclose their "rating" (similar to movies) or businesses could opt in to show a seal (like Fairtrade bananas). The problem is, if there aren't enough (popular) sites with the seal, then the value of this declaration is lost.
- dwighttk 7y agoYeah. For many people I interact with Facebook, and to a lesser extent Google, are the internet. So they’d never see the seal unless Google put the sites in their top three results and didn’t scrape the relevant info. Or someone posted a meme with the seal in it on Facebook.
- somethoughts 7y agoFor apps at least, you could add the branding seal to the Appstore metadata that you upload for your app to the Apple/Android App Store. For websites, agreed google would have to display it or it'd have to be after the initial page load which means you'd be tracked the first time you visited the site and you'd know not to visit a second time. Perhaps for websites, a browser add-on that checked a certified ad tracking free database registry could be used.
- somethoughts 7y agoInteresting - the movie ratings is a good analogy - as far as I know the MPAA handles it[1]. Maybe an existing organization in this space such as the eff.org with name recognization could come up with a certification methodology and branding seal for websites and apps. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_Picture_Association_of_America#Film_rating_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_Picture_Association_of_...
- 6nf 7y ago> If you don't need it, don't gather it. What if they need it... to make more money?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tw04 7y agoCan we stop sharing data with facebook and google or literally ANY third party unless absolutely necessary? And if it is absolutely necessary, let users opt out and tell them what feature they lose????? Zoom is quickly gaining a reputation for doing the wrong thing anytime they have a choice between right and wrong.
- HenryBemis 7y agoI have been using Android for the last few years (with NoRoot Firewall installed) and before that I was using iPhone (jailbroken with FirewallIP installed). 95% of the applications installed (on both Android & iPhone), when they open "talk"/send a ping to Facebook. That includes all air-companies, Spotify, anything you can imagine. The only "clean" apps I have found are Amazon, eBay, Dropbox, Signal, Telegram, Skype. Anyone using Android, do yourselves the favor, install (free) NoRoot Firewall. Once you "Start" the firewall check the tabs "Logs" and "Pending" and you will be surprised on what your apps are doing, especially if you leave them running in the background.I also use it to block trackers, ads, FB, etc.
- KennethSRoberts 7y agopi-hole
- adam_fallon_ 7y agoOne thing i'll note here as to a potential reason why they do this I just recently attempted to set up Facebook adverts for an app I developed. When it came time for me to set the metric up I obviously chose "App Installs" as my metric to track. To do this, Facebook told me I needed to install the Facebook SDK in my app to attribute an adverts conversion. I didn't end up running the ad, but I can see why companies potentially have the SDK embedded in their apps to track ad-spend, hence the phoning-home to Facebook. Edit: Just so people don’t have to dig to verify; https://en-gb.facebook.com/business/help/2083260191704068?id=1646770532043319 https://en-gb.facebook.com/business/help/2083260191704068?id...
- conradev 7y agoIt is Zoom’s responsibility to list Facebook here: https://zoom.us/subprocessors https://zoom.us/subprocessors Not sure why Vice called out the omission from the privacy policy – I’ve never seen one that actually lists all companies out by name. The GDPR mandates a list of subprocessors, though!
- conradev 7y agoTheir privacy policy even explicitly calls that out: > Zoom, our third-party service providers, and advertising partners (e.g., Google Ads and Google Analytics) automatically collect some information about you when you use our Products, using methods such as cookies and tracking technologies (further described below).
- sneak 7y agoListing this on their webpage doesn’t solve the spying problem. “Well, at least they told us about it” is absolutely no solution to “so many of our tools are spying on us”.
- HenryBemis 7y agoIt is their right to run their business as they see fit, and it is our right to not use them. It is the deception we do not allow (any more) with GDPR.
- andrepd 7y ago>Can we just stop sending data everywhere? If you don't need it, don't gather it. We're not gonna get there with asking nicely. We need legislation, with teeth (read, fines worth 6 months or 1 year global turnover)
- m463 7y agoThe kindle app contacts facebook too. All KINDS of webpages and apps contact facebook. It's a mess that I only figure legislation can help correct.
- mikorym 7y agoMy opinion about this is that many apps and websites don't have a real product offering. FB, Dropbox, Twitter and others are more of a service offering than a product offering and hence everything is rooted around services and tracking services and, finally, just plain old tracking.
- poutrathor 7y agoI don't see how is selling a service different then selling a product ? If clients want it => pay for it. The real point that privacy advocates REFUSE to talk about is that FREE service wins over 99% market share over PAID service. So people does not want to pay for Facebook (greed) and Facebook does not want to make people pay (market share first in Silicon Valley mindset). Well money for its thousand engineers has to be found ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Now that the actors have collectively chosen the combo free services in exchange for private data, a small minority wants free service in exchange of nothing. How does it work, Freemium, government subsidies ?
- mikorym 7y agoSo just to give you an example of what would be a product. Spotify is half way between service and product. What would make it further closer to a product would be (my suggestion): 1. No free version 2. And while you are at it, don't pool views. If you listen only to "Baby" by Bieber and only that once (or many times) in that month, then Bieber et al. gets your full $10. Edit: minus fees. They still do services, but now they are not "organised around services".
- catacombs 7y ago> Can we just stop sending data everywhere? If you don't need it, don't gather it. But...but... consumer data is a gold mine! We have to sell it! Who will think of the shareholders?
- orasis 7y agoMobile app developers need to gather install/purchase data so they can optimize user acquisition spend. Most are not using PII so I don’t see any problem.