15 ms·
A review of Thomas Piketty’s “Capital and Ideology”
- defterGoose 7y agoWe need only believe in the possibility of a better, different future to act. We need only act to manifest it. Go vote. Go work on things that truly matter. Edit: If you have ideological differences please consider posting a reply rather than just downvoting.
- worik 7y agoGood advice. But in the face of power imbalances ineffective.
- defterGoose 7y agoSadly true. Guess it's war then?
- orthecreedence 7y agoI've been very interested lately in dual power as an alternative to both voting in a system where governments are captured agencies and also bloody revolution. In effect, forming a network that bypasses the current powers until they disappear.
- viklove 7y agoYou don't have to bypass the current powers, you just have to dilute them sufficiently. Currency is just a coupon you spend to redeem on human productive output (goods and services). Since the wealthy have most of the currency, they decide to "spend" human productive output on making them wealthier. Billionaires shouldn't unilaterally decide how society spends its human productive output, that should be a decision society as a whole gets to make. How do you accomplish this? Universal basic income would dilute billionaire's ability to control how human productive output is spent, and instead, society as a whole would get to make that decision. Inflation caused by UBI only hurts one class of people -- billionaires. Everyone else ends up better off, and has more of a say on the direction of human civilization.
- alejohausner 7y agoThe Black Death and the world wars were catastrophes that led to greater equality. Peace and stability tend to favour the wealthy, and lead to greater inequality.
- defterGoose 7y agoIn exact analogy to a pack of hyenas taking down a pride of lions.
- dorchadas 7y agoI'm currently working my way through Capital in the Twenty-First Century. It's been really eye-opening about how bad inequality actually is. I suggest everyone read it, and I'm excited to read his new one soon after.
- hardtke 7y agoThe thing I took away from Capital in the Twenty-First Century was his conjecture that the post-WWII (until about 1990) period was one of the few times in history that prosperity was widely shared with workers. The era that I consider to be normal (since I lived it) is in fact very abnormal.
- _0ffh 7y agoYeah, I realised that too at some point. And I immediately formed a (maybe obvious) hypothesis about the timing.
- bart_spoon 7y agoI'm assuming you don't mean communism? Because even in the book he is fairly down on communism/socialism. It seemed to me the more likely (and unpleasant) hypothesis is that war/nationalism generates growth like nothing else. When the threat of war looms and patriotism is high, government investment in technology and society is also high, and corporations are more likely to be invested in their home country rather than spreading across international boundaries looking for the best ROI. And the rapid succession of WWI/WWII/Cold War basically ensured that environment existed for decades.
- _0ffh 7y agoSomewhat. The hypothesis was that the end of the cold war meant that a big incentive to make the common people in the west feel good about their affiliation suddenly vanished. Competition is good for the customer, after all.
- dv_dt 7y ago
- clairity 7y ago> "[hyper-capitalism] is defined by unlimited international capital mobility to evade regulation and taxation at the national level, alongside definite limits on the ability of labor to act in the same autonomous way." such inequities imbalance the power between labor and capital, which then destabilizes the social structures resting on these economic (and political) foundations. power is a highly dynamic, and as a result, a highly destabilizing force. no (static) socioeconomic idealogy (that we've come up with so far) can dominate it, not even capitalism. and that means we can never truly rest in our vigilence to create and retain the properity, peace and stability that we enjoy only fleetingly. the balance between labor and capital has tipped wildly and we need to enact measures--progressive and dynamic taxes/tariffs, both removing and enacting regulations, de-monopolizing markets, etc.--to bring it back into balance.
- specialist 7y agoI'd like all belligerants to pick a target Gini Coefficient number. Then we manage to that number. Whoever is in power will push the balance towards their number. I'm just so exhausted by all the rhetoric, kabuki, ideology, dogma, propaganda. Arguing about the placement of the deck chairs as the Titanic sinks.
- refurb 7y agoGini coefficient is a very blunt measure of inequality. You could have two countries, one with more equality, but a lower standard of living for the middle class and one country with higher inequality, but a much better standard of living for the middle class. The 2nd (with higher inequality) is obviously preferred.
- geodel 7y ago" “the Democratic Party in the United States transitioned over half a century from the workers’ party to the party of the highly educated.” Elites’ distance from working-class interest, he contends, led the Democratic party and its ideological counterparts abroad to accede to a policy program betraying the values of social democracy: regressive taxation, elite domination of higher education systems, and forms of globalization that enabled the wealthy to hide their assets from tax authorities and trade agreements that facilitated outsourcing. " This is great point. I see this on social media commentary all the time and wonder if educated elites being merely oblivious or totally asshole about working class concerns.
- lainga 7y agoIs it right for Piketty to assert that the Democratic Party was a homogeneous whole in the 60's? What exactly was Daley doing at Chicago in 1968 in the interests of social democracy? You may as well claim that the Democrats transitioned from the party of the South due to unforeseen Goldwater-shaped factors.
- 0x262d 7y agoThe Democratic party has always been an unhappy coalition between capitalists and workers with diametrically opposed material interests. But in the 60s and 70s there was an extremely militant labor movement and the balance of power between those two groups was shifted a lot (although political control was never given up).
- save_ferris 7y agoI always assume most are just oblivious, given the fact that the Democratic Party still tries to identify as a worker-first party. That’s rapidly changing with the rise of the modern progressive movement, DSA and the like. Part of the problem is the two-party system, which essentially ensures that control remains between the Dems and GOP. This is why so many presidential elections wind up being contests of the least-worst option.
- karatestomp 7y ago
- claudiawerner 7y agoAlthough I haven't read Captial and Ideology, Piketty seems to be situated in a weird place, as I gathered by his previous book. He isn't critical of capitalism as such[0] - as economists like Sen, Roemer, Kliman and Veneziani are, but on the other hand he is aware of the transparent ideological forces which shape the way we view the economy and capital. The content of this book, between social, historical and economic axes seems closer to Marx than Samuelson - and it's refreshing in a climate that seems to take the concepts under investigation for granted. I look forward to reading it. [0] There is a debate between Piketty and Marx-leaning philosopher/economist Frederic Lordon in French: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dDY3aczWOd0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dDY3aczWOd0
- bart_spoon 7y ago> Piketty seems to be situated in a weird place, as I gathered by his previous book. He isn't critical of capitalism as such[0] - as economists like Sen, Roemer, Kliman and Veneziani are, but on the other hand he is aware of the transparent ideological forces which shape the way we view the economy and capital. That weird place is simply social democracy. It seems to be unpopular because it is essentially the "centrism" of the capitalism/socialism debate, and everyone hates centrists these days.
- claudiawerner 7y agoI think that's an overly generous characterization of social democracy - it only dodges the critique from right-libertarians concerning property, taxes and the role of government, and it dodges the critique from left-libertarians on capital, alienation and social domination. It's much easier (and more historically accurate) to see social democracy, socialism and capitalism on the same axis, and not to think that social democracy transcends all hitherto established political and economic thought by The Right Choice as if by default.
- 0x262d 7y agoIt's worth noting that Piketty has an astonishingly basic misunderstanding/non-understanding of the marxist analysis of capitalism despite the titles of his books. He hasn't even read Capital. I like his politics relatively well as far as most liberals go but that is still pretty disappointing. “What I mean,” Piketty says, explaining his differences with Marx, “is that your class position is not enough to determine your view of what’s the best system of property, education, taxation. We need ideas and ideologies and we need to take them seriously.” (Guardian in Feb). However, that is a trivially wrong mischaracterization. Marx himself was from a relatively privileged background and he, Engels, Lenin, etc have never argued for a mechanical determination of ideology. In general I think his analysis is that "capitalism should just change some specific things to reduce inequality" without any materialist, political-economic understanding of why inequality is so rampant in the first place - why capital's dominance comes from the structure of the economy. That is why marxism is interesting, marxism makes a very compelling argument for it, and liberals ignore it at their peril.
- 0x262d 7y agoLooking through some of the comments, I want to add that Piketty talks much more clearly about these topics and makes better points than most consensus economists, pundits, etc, so I'm glad people are reading him rather than eg NYT columnists. But I think people who find this sort of thing interesting would find marxism's analysis of the economy much more interesting and convincing. Start with Wage Labour And Capital then try either Value Price And Profit or Capital itself.
- nemo 7y agoAnyone interested in Marx should read Bertrand Russel's critiques of Marxism and his analysis of the Manifesto with an honest mind. The Hegelianism behind Marxism is a tool that can prove both that the Kingdom of Prussia in the 1760s was a reflection of God's will, as well as giving Marx the idea that he had a scientific approach to history that let him predict the future. Any tool of reasoning that can prove anything, in the end proves nothing, and all of Marx's history and analysis is steeped in Hegelian dialectic rendering it nonsense. His many predictions all failed, but his ideology lived on despite Scientific Socialism being a failed science. Also anyone interested in Marx should take the time to understand the Labor Theory of Value. It's a lynchpin of Marx's analysis, and it's an idea long since thoroughly discredited. Marxism is a house built on sand.
- lbj 7y agoI'm surprised he's still writing after that disaster Capital in the 21th Centurary. Rarely have I read such error riddled, manipulative and clearly fantasy based economic writings.
- worik 7y agoMore please....
- lbj 7y agoMore? In terms of explanation I only read the numbers/graphs and not his comments, but most of the important graphs (incl. those mentioned other places in this thread) are extrapolations that go far beyond what his data supports. He is creating a reality that fits his reasoning.
- worik 7y agoWhat is your definition of capitalism?
- throw0101a 7y agoPaul Krugman's review: * https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/08/books/review/capital-and-ideology-thomas-piketty.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/08/books/review/capital-and-... Krugman liked Piketty's previous book (Captail-21C), but concluded this one needed some more editing: > The bottom line: I really wanted to like “Capital and Ideology,” but have to acknowledge that it’s something of a letdown. There are interesting ideas and analyses scattered through the book, but they get lost in the sheer volume of dubiously related material. In the end, I’m not even sure what the book’s message is. That can’t be a good thing.
- pradn 7y agoI once went to a talk by Nassim Nicholas Taleb after the publication of his "Skin in the Game". He said the way to make a book last is to stuff it full of ideas, stories, and wander around. A focused book doesn't last. Take it as you will.
- LargeWu 7y agoWell, that is certainly Taleb's approach. His books do contain some good ideas, but they are wildly unfocused and borderline unreadable.
- kneel 7y agoTaleb is a horrible writer, plain and simple. Attempted to read antifragile and was hit with a wall of incomprehensible jargon. The thesis of the book seemed appealing but he's too abstract, smells like a hack.
- ur-whale 7y agoA renowned quack reviewing the work of one of his peers. Guaranteed enjoyment.
- liamconnell 7y agoKrugman also claimed in the same article that Capital in the 20th century was not fully read by most "Like A Brief History of Time". He is right that Piketty's first book is probably just worth it for the introduction and most non-economists never read the rest, but if he cant get through A Brief History of Time then he's got other problems. Hawking made that book very readable and accessible!
- cwperkins 7y agoIf anyone enjoys reading about income inequality, I also recommend Joseph Stiglitz' book called "The Price of Inequality". He speaks of inequality more from an American perspective and he's one of the thought leaders I personally like to hear from. I am a staunch Capitalist and I'd like to see another great era of America ingenuity and invention. I think the path to solve inequality comes from creating wealth and solving big global issues in energy, health and transportation.
- cbnotfromthere 7y agoIf you're such a "staunch capitalist", then why would you listen to an unrepentant "economic Chomsky"???
- scythe 7y agoI think Piketty makes some good points. But I still think any account of the woeful separation between the Democratic Party and the common people which ignores the rise of the pro-life movement has to be incomplete. Piketty thus misrepresents those who are concerned about the prevalence of destructive beliefs among the working class: >“The problem” with the story of a bottom-up defection “is not just that it depends on the notion that the disadvantaged classes are by their very essence permanently racist...” But racism, while extant, is not the most significant ideological issue that separates the elites from the working class, nor can it reasonably explain their disagreements with Democrat policy -- current anti-racist policy is laughably weak, and elites are not consistently anti-racist. That award must certainly go to religion, not racism. That an elite who bemoans the disconnection between the elites and the working class could write a book about ideology which largely ignores the predominant ideology among the working class in Western countries is painfully ironic. Ignore this correlation at your peril: https://www.pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/FT_18.11.07_howFaithfulVoted_vote-for-House2.png https://www.pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/FT_18... One could argue, of course, that the pro-life movement has been cultivated and manipulated for the benefit of capital. But it would be better to actually write the argument. Such a key step should not be left as an exercise to the reader.
- charlescearl 7y agoIt has always been hard to reconcile the rhetoric that labels the “Democrats” as “elites” who are against the “working class” or “under class”. Especially as the grandson of sharecroppers and “maids” and a relative of many other Black folk who would, in terms of wealth and household income, be in the “underclass”. As an exercise, started reading the French edition — I guess even poor Black folk can be “elites”
- lliamander 7y agoI was watching a documentary[1] about Sweden's shift away from social democracy in the 70's/80's time-frame that Piketty talks about. From the way it sounds, the program of social democracy nearly destroyed the country. I would take Piketty's nostalgia for those times with a grain of salt. [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QcX6BUZlEw4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QcX6BUZlEw4
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- refurb 7y agoI have a theory that lessons learned by humanity are quickly forgotten after a few generations and thus we are condemned to trying the same old ideas (with slight tweaks) again until the current generation figures out they don't work.
- cle 7y agoConversely, sometimes constraints and situations are different enough that "failed" ideas might succeed under the new constraints. The world is not a static place, and the environments in which many lessons were learned may not be relevant anymore.
- lliamander 7y agoTrue, but it seems that Piketty's position is that those ideas succeeded and would have continued to succeed if left in place - and consequently, that if we implement them now we will also have success. If it turns out that Piketty's history is incorrect, then the past failure of such plans should make us cautious about trying them again.
- refurb 7y agoAgree 100%. However, I do believe that any ideas that people want to try because they believe human behavior has changed are guaranteed to fail.
- 7y ago
- bisRepetita 7y agoI am reading Capital & Idelogy currently. I find interesting how Piketty challenges the view of property rights. Many think it is something completely natural, sacred. But he shows it is actually ideology. It is not "the nature of things". As I understand it in the book, property is not, and should not be seen as, a 100% inalienable human right. If it was so, it would be completely fair that slave-owners in Haiti and Santo Domingo were paid to forego slavery, when slavery was abolished. It was seen as a compensation for this new law that reduced the value of their property: slaves. Of course, slaves themselves were not compensated. Since they were the main beneficiaries of this new law, they actually had to pay for it in some cases. This is actually what happened. In the USA, there were discussions about a similar outcome, but the sheer enormity of the needed compensation made it impossible This was one big reason that lead to the civil war. This is the kind of weird, morally unacceptable reasoning about property rights that you will run into if you accept property as a all-powerful, unconstestable principle.
- refurb 7y agoOf course property rights are ideology. Anything to do with society and how it's organized is ideological. I think we ended up with private property because the alternatives have been tried and they are worse (e.g. tragedy of the commons).
- bisRepetita 7y ago>I think we ended up with private property because the alternatives have been tried and they are worse (e.g. tragedy of the commons) I don't thinl it is all or nothing. Private property is overall a very good idea and principle, and Piketty says that too. But when someone sees property it as inalienable right, at any level, is a problem. For example, if one person talks about a tax based on wealth, two people can have a healthy disagreement, and discuss how to implement. But when someone does not event want to consider it... because it would supposedly bring us back to communism dark ages, that is basic ideology in action, not rational thinking.
- mytailorisrich 7y ago
- Proven 7y agoPiketty is full of crap. People are equal in natural rights, not abilities. > The algebraic essence of this argument was symbolized by the inequality r > g, which says that, historically, the rate of return on capital is larger than the rate of economic growth. Why that shouldn't be the case? The capitalist risks his capital. "Economic growth" risks nothing.
- atlih 7y agoSounds like a call for the emperors new monarchy. Robin Hood "stole" back money that the monarchy had excessively taxed and "gave" it to the poor.