11 ms·
Outside of young, childless tech workers, this sudden remote work experiment is not going well for most people I know. This isn’t the controlled trial of remot
by PragmaticPulp 7y ago
Outside of young, childless tech workers, this sudden remote work experiment is not going well for most people I know.
This isn’t the controlled trial of remote work that these think pieces suggest. Instead, everyone is forcefully stuck at home without time to prepare. Parents are juggling childcare with getting work done, while fighting an uphill battle against IT systems that weren’t prepared for everyone going WFH for every job at the exact same time.
Even the remote teams I know are struggling to get work done in the middle of this 24-hour news cycle of virus news and political battles about how to address it.
I don’t think we’re going to look back on this experiment and conclude that it was a net win for productivity or even for worker happiness.
- checker659 7y agoYeah, I think this experiment is going to backfire. People are going to hate WFH/Remote work coming out of this it seems.
- mschuster91 7y ago> People are going to hate WFH/Remote work coming out of this it seems. The question is, what are they going to do? There are two options... demand better tooling (I'm actually surprised about Microsoft Teams!) or go back to office and put up with everything related to a multi-hour commute - infection risk in public transport, gas/insurance costs, endless traffic jams, hours lost each day that can be spent with partner/s and children instead, or simply with sleep...
- checker659 7y ago> or go back to office and put up with everything related to a multi-hour commute - infection risk in public transport, gas/insurance costs, endless traffic jams, hours lost each day that can be spent with partner/s and children instead, or simply with sleep This one unfortunately (because, choice inertia)
- RHSeeger 7y agoIf it results in 1. Workers (that previously hadn't been remote) realizing that it has good parts and bad parts, that paying an extra 10%+ in rent/mortgage in order to get a proper home office can be the cost of working from home (and then the costs of utilities for a now non-empty home). That doesn't mean it's bad, just that it has pluses and minuses. 2. Companies realizing that people working from home _does_ have benefits, and it's _not_ just people sitting around in their PJs being unproductive. Then I think we've gained something. It's not a backfire, so much as a better understanding that everything has tradeoffs.
- MivLives 7y agoYour first point is the part I'd like most to change with this. I live in an apartment with three other people. It's fine when we're all coming in and out and spend all day at work. But now that 3/4 of us are at home, and confined to our rooms it's getting annoying. There's no good public space, and none of us share any interests. I live and work in a single room, and I wish so much I could move to somewhere with more space. If I were full time work from home there's no reason I'd need to live with other people. The only reason my rent is so high is because I live near a city which I have to do to work. I suspect this is true for other people as well, and if we saw a greater amount of full time remote people would spread out a little.
- 0x202020 7y agoI saw this in a company I worked at previously. When I joined they had just moved their headquarters from the West Coast to the Midwest and gave employees the option to WFH or freedom to come into office still at new location. Within a year it was a pretty even split on A) staying where they were and working remote B) moving to be in the suburbs around the new location C) moving further out from the city but staying on the West Coast D) leaving the company
- closeparen 7y ago>paying an extra 10%+ in rent/mortgage Where a one-bedroom is $4000, a two-bedroom is going to be $6500, not $4400. Obviously a cheaper metro will have lower prices, but is the relative premium for an extra room also so dramatically lower?
- imtringued 7y agoThat doesn't matter since WFH isn't popular right now. If 0.01% of people work remotely and then suddenly everyone ends up doing WFH then it is unlikely that more than 99.99% of people are going to hate WFH. So lets be pessimistic and say 99% of people end up hating WFH and only 1% like it. That's still a 100 fold increase in people who will do WFH.
- joegahona 7y agoI've been loving the comfort of working from home (childless), but I suspect you're right that it's not going well for most people. Most of my zoom meetings are disrupted by shrieks of needy children and a shocking number of cellphone ringing/notifications.
- taneq 7y agoNo sane person actually works from home with their young kids present, at least not in any real job. Until schools have their remote classes sorted out with actual teachers giving actual attention to students over video, nobody's going to be getting any quality work done.
- closeparen 7y agoEvery last parent on my team of 100 has at least one child under five, so not even then.
- avip 7y agoIt is not possible to give "actual attention to students over video". There really is no such thing. Remote teaching does not, can not, and should not work for young kids. It's not a university. (source: life)
- heavenlyblue 7y agoIdk - the company I work for was totally prepared for this and the IT systems are absolutely OK. Exceptions: weekly full-house meeting of 400 employees isn’t supported by hangouts so you can only participate in read-only mode The only issue I personally have is my WFH broadband is horrible. Basically what you’re saying is that “the company I work for does a horrible job of having it’s systems available for remote work”. But then it would also be true of other things
- vsareto 7y ago>Exceptions: weekly full-house meeting of 400 employees isn’t supported by hangouts so you can only participate in read-only mode Those have almost always been 'meetings that should have been an email' in my experience. I think some leaders are just used to having an audience to be effective.
- ovulator 7y agoYeah, that's not a meeting, that's a sermon.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoIt probably would've been best handled by a livestream. Let the preacher/CEO talk, and have everyone else use the chat for comments.
- cameronbrown 7y agoIf you have Q&A, these meetings can definitely be effective.
- mc32 7y agoObviously regardless of all the above, there will be permanent changes because of this, even if it wasn’t all voluntary and we can return to normal. I think we can be certain some things will change with respect to how people work as well as other behavior. For example, do we need all those extraneous stimuluses. Surely some people will overdo it in both directions. It all remains to be seen.
- suls 7y agoThe changes during extraordinary times aren’t always permanent. Apparently female workforce participation during WWII was a record high but not in the decades that followed.
- mc32 7y agoI wouldn’t discount that so quickly. While we didn’t see the impact immediately I do think it opened the door years later as the economy adjusted.
- formercoder 7y agoI agree. If anything business travel and in office time will increase - we’re gonna realize how great it is to be in the same room.
- jrumbut 7y agoYeah, I'm two weeks into this and badly miss my office. Edit: no children either, just easier to work with people in the same building sometimes.
- coldpie 7y agoYep, me too. Early 30s and childless. I've never liked working from home, and now I'm forced to do it. It sucks. I like having someone looking over my shoulder (look what I'm spending time on right now!). I like having a bus to catch at 3:00 so my day ends right there. I like having a commute that separates work from home. I like having people to talk to and make jokes with. I like having separate work and home computers. For me, the benefits of WFH are...? I honestly can't think of any.
- mrlala 7y ago>Early 30s and childless. I've never liked working from home I'll chime in here.. perhaps you don't like working from because you are childless? In my opinion it's the the opposite of what people are thinking... I think you would find that the people who like working from home are ones with kids (let's say >5 where they can at least take care of themselves long enough without worry of instant death.. infants/toddlers are obviously an exception here, unless you have a stay-at-home spouse and a separate part of the home). The reason is that when you have kids you have a day-to-day schedule with them that is vital for the family's sanity. Your kids also will start to have schedules like school & activities. Also, you simply want to see and spend time with your kids. Being gone/unavailable from the moment you wake up until 6pm might not be an issue for people when they are a little younger without kids, because they still have the whole night to do whatever. I was like that in my 20s. I worked until 6/7pm and I didn't mind at all. I had plenty of energy afterwards to unwind without basically a care in the world. In my late 30s with young kids, I am supremely lucky to work from home (I have done this full time for like 7 years so this is nothing new to me). I get to spend a LOT more time with my kids, take care of the house (billions of more things to do with kids around), and all that jazz without worrying about being fixed into a schedule where I would never see them. I guess I could go on and on.. but that's my view on all of this.
- buboard 7y agoYou re forgetting that people need time to adapt. Imagine if we did the opposite switch, we went from all being farmers to working in an office downtown overnight. It happened, but over many many decades. Of course it's not going to work for everyone, but many many people will adapt
- api 7y agoI realized after I had kids that a huge amount of "new urbanist" thought is driven by the young and childless and does not incorporate the needs of people with children or of children themselves. This falls under the same category. Without child care or some place for the children to go, it's absolutely impossible to work from home. If only one parent works it can be done, but if both parents have to telework it's a no-go. Non-parents don't get it. It's impossible to get anything done with kids around. The only way I can imagine it to be possible is if you were to abuse and traumatize your kids so they'd leave you alone because they're afraid of you. Maybe that's what some of our ancestors did.
- zxcmx 7y agoOur ancestors got their children working as soon as they were able. Farm work, piece work, factory work, whatever. Kind of frowned upon now.
- api 7y agoIt's not possible now. I'd say a good 80% of the work I do requires at least a year of intensive study and/or hands-on learning to even be capable of attempting and another 5-10 years to master. Nowadays someone needs a minimum of four years of college to be able to do anything. You can't start contributing to society until you're 20. Everything easy has been automated or outsourced.
- randomdata 7y ago> I'd say a good 80% of the work I do requires at least a year of intensive study and/or hands-on learning to even be capable of attempting One year is nothing, really. As a farmer, the work I do required about a decade of study before I could be productive on my own, and I'm still working on mastering it. In the days of yore, farm kids had to start engaging with their teachers as soon as they could as it was the only way they were going to be able to be capable of attempting the practice once they reached adulthood. > Nowadays someone needs a minimum of four years of college to be able to do anything. Well, you need four years of college to get past the gatekeeping. Gatekeeping that is setup because the work has become so much more accessible, necessitating means to cull competition. You don't have to start as a young child nowadays like the farm kids used to have to. You can easily coast into adulthood without even thinking about a career.
- mjevans 7y agoWork / Family + Life is out of balance; I really hope that's what we, collectively, learn. The lack of time for child care is the problem. I've observed a sibling that does have children being severely taxed daily (in occasional video calls across the country). It isn't the working from home aspect that's broken, it's how little time "a normal job" affords parents, or even those of us who've yet to find a life partner.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gdubs 7y agoIt’s also been a week. Like you said, this is anything but a controlled experiment. People are trying to push through a lot of psychological stress right now. Families are suddenly responsible for homeschooling — 2 young kids and a toddler in our case. It’s a lot. If people look back at this period and use it to judge the effective remote work is, that would be pretty ridiculous. (Of course, some people who are fundamentally against remote work will do just that.) If one worked remote during a hurricane, and pretended the hurricane wasn’t the dominant factor, it would also be ridiculous. But it is time to be asking, how could we be better set up at home? What are the strengths and weaknesses of our tools? Does the current schooling model work in the 21st century? Or is it too fragile and dependent on an old societal structure? Should we be paying teachers a lot more than we are? Conversely, we should be talking about the ‘wisdom’ of open offices. Hindsight is 20/20, but wouldn’t regular old offices with doors that close implement a fair amount of physical distancing?
- harikb 7y agoAbout the open-office vs individual- in this particular case though individual offices would have been just as dangerous, since the ventilation system is all connected. although I agree the lower density of workers would have helped.
- ABeeSea 7y agoNot disagreeing that the office setup wouldn’t make a difference. But there is almost no evidence that the virus can spread through ventilation. It can only be aerosoled in very rare instances (like during intubation) and droplets would fall to the ground before reaching the ventilation systems.
- xenonite 7y agoAerosols are created when flushing the toilet, and the virus is detectable in stool, so there is another vector.
- smileysteve 7y agoSquirm; While yes, air systems are shared, modern offices (and homes) have filtered (though likely not HEPA filtered) positive pressure outlets and there is a central (hallway or more typically edge of building) negative pressure return. While this virus does survive in aerosol form, it is not strictly airborne; This means that a non HEPA filter will likely stop it and that, from the return side; it's more likely to settle on the carpet or furniture than particularly infecting a human. The more likely issue would be meetings of more than 1 person in a poorly ventilated room with no airflow; where aerosol virus would linger.
- aivisol 7y agoOne thing that stroke me yesterday looking at my 13-year old is that children actually suffer more than adults. While we are allowed to take occasional walk out of our homes ( groceries, etc), they are totally locked up - no friends, no school socializing, everything is virtual only. If this lockdown lasts for any long period of time, it might backfire badly on them.
- HeyLaughingBoy 7y agoThis is a really good point that I think people will slowly figure out. We live in a rural area with essentially no school age kids nearby, so we're very aware that during summer, Christmas break, etc, we have to arrange ways to keep our 10 year-old in contact with kids his age. In summer we usually sign him up for the in-school daycare a couple days a week so he can see his friends and we also arrange to visit other families with kids he knows frequently, trips to the park, library, etc. However, in the current situation, that's all gone flying out the window. A least, because of where we live, there's lots of space to go outside and play without coming into contact with anyone outside this household. I shudder to think how quickly we'd all go insane trapped in a small apartment!
- dorchadas 7y agoBias warning: I am a public school teacher myself. And this is also exactly what I feel the people who are now pushing for online schooling in general don't get (apart from the fact there's a non-negligible part of the population that doesn't have consistent/good internet access). There's a lot more to school than just going and learning 'stuff that doesn't affect real life', as some seem to believe. It's about social learning as well, and they're completely underestimating how much this happens in schools.
- Kaiyou 7y agoBecause maybe in their experience - it definitely was in mine - it didn't happen at all in school. I always disliked school because of the other students that got in the way of my peaceful life. Never had a single friend throughout school and college, either. Maybe you think social learning just happens by putting kids together, but that's bullshit. People like me who'd needed it the most didn't get any of it during school. There also wasn't much in regards to an education. In hindsight, school was a complete waste of my time, that at times negatively affected me because of bullies nobody did anything about. If only beating was still a thing when I went to school, then the teachers maybe would have beaten the shit out of the bullies, so they'd have to first spend a week in the hospital before getting suspended on top of that. Sorry, thinking of school always makes me angry.
- dominotw 7y agochildcare workers won't be 'working from home' so not sure how this woould be a problem once the scare is over. Unfortunately ppl with children are usually against company wide WFH flexible policies. I am guessing is just jealously. I have a coworker right now that asks ppl working from home in the morning meeting " oh so you are working from home today", so annoying. Ppl with children please don't ruin it for the rest of us. we support you too.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- yodsanklai 7y agoI've been working remotely for a while, but most of my colleagues work in the office by choice. First thing I noticed, our remote meetings are much better now. It works better when everyone is remote. Another thing that surprised me, many of my colleagues don't have a good working environment from home. They live in small appartements, sometimes with young kids, and mostly don't have an office or even a good laptop. > Even the remote teams I know are struggling to get work done in the middle of this 24-hour news cycle of virus news and political battles about how to address it. Agree. It takes self-discipline not to follow this to closely.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> They live in small appartements, sometimes with young kids That's most likely the reason why they "work in the office by choice". Back when I was still working in a physical office, I couldn't understand why someone would want to escape from their home into an office. As a WFH father of an infant, I fully get it now. Working with a small child nearby pretty much precludes any regular focus or deep working sessions. > Agree. It takes self-discipline not to follow this to closely. Indeed it does. I've never wasted so much time obsessively reading the news like over the past month.
- Matrixik 7y agoI'm childless tech worker and I hate working from home. I live in very small flat and I simply don't have space to separate work/home related stuff. I'm really struggling to focus on work task and when I finally do it I have problem to stop working (and end it too late). When in office someone will always ask why I'm still working or I will get hungry and food is waiting at home so I need to leave. Also video conferencing is poor replacement for talking with others.
- orthoxerox 7y agoYou should have an alarm that rings at 5. Or just write a script that disconnects your company VPN at 5.
- p_man 7y ago»8:45 each weekday morning, I drop off my four-year-old at preschool, hug him goodbye, and drive back home». Well, in that case it wouldn’t be a challenge at all for us. Here kindergarten and schools are closed, and it’s quite a challenge to produce full workdays whilst taking care of two little ones at home.
- bbbbgfgim 7y agoA challenge. Lol. Like most parents trying to work and take care of kids, I’m guessing work gets like 15-25% of your time. But you still want the full amount on your paycheck.
- xellisx 7y agoI WFH for 6 years at my last job. I didn't have a child. Now I have one, and with the SO that doesn't have to work at this time, it's still hard.
- bbbbgfgim 7y agoOh yes parents just have it soooooooo hard. They made the choice to have kids, they should love with those choices. Parents already get so many additional benefits at work compared to those without children, plus all the excuses to not do work/leave early. It’s discrimination. I don’t feel sorry for them at all.
- blaser-waffle 7y ago> Even the remote teams I know are struggling to get work done in the middle of this 24-hour news cycle of virus news and political battles about how to address it. +1 for this. I'm 100% remote, as are many members of my org, and we're struggling to deal with the big changes happening. Webex and Zoom occasionally drop audio or just straight up drop people. Also can't underestimate the kids thing. For example, my boss has 8 year olds who LOVE to sing as loudly as possible -- ask me how I know :)