14 ms·
As an onlooker I feel like once America awakens to a crisis it is impressive to watch. I mean this kind of should have happened weeks ago, and the executive bra
by Waterluvian 7y ago
As an onlooker I feel like once America awakens to a crisis it is impressive to watch. I mean this kind of should have happened weeks ago, and the executive branch is a bit of a panicked joke. But I mean... You've got this colossal capacity to deploy field hospitals and hospital ships and such and ramp up capacity.
Terrible hurricane? Show up with a massive floating power plant and water treatment facility plus air logistics.
And I think one of the strongest virtues of the United States is being proven by Trump: the incredible power of leadership at all levels of government. In the absence of a leader at the top you've got senators and congresspersons and governors and mayors and CEOs all getting shit done. This is all an incredible (but regrettable) exercise of numerous fail safes inherent in the American system.
- lonelappde 7y ago> Terrible hurricane? Show up with a massive floating power plant and water treatment facility plus air logistics. The US has a disastrous recent history of failing to respond to multipld hurricanes with adequate support, from Katrina to Maria.
- nimbius 7y ago>the incredible power of leadership at all levels of government. anyone remember when Mike Pence actually created an HIV epidemic in his state by ignoring the CDC in favour of prayer? :) or when Trump recommended mixing two tentatively researched drugs to combat COVID-19 that could induce fatal arrhythmia? Or Hurricane Katrina? when Bush basically sat on his hands while nearly 2000 people died? C-level leadership is dog-earing their pockets and preparing to shill the government for bailouts, despite buybacks and record profits. Companies like Apple are completely debt free and doing nothing. As an American i feel like the strongest force in this crisis is the teenager at the gas station and the army of people working swing shift at supermarkets for the same garbage wage theyve always earned and no healthcare.
- Waterluvian 7y agoThe people who continue to work the supermarkets definitely are heroes. How can they not be scared?
- beefield 7y agoWhat makes you think they are not scared? Fear is smart and necessary. Keeps you alive. As long as you control the fear and not the other way round.
- coffeefirst 7y agoTrue, but as an American, it definitely feels like we're bringing our B game to one of the nastiest challenges the world has ever faced. We had the ability to write a blank check and fire up mask, ventilator, and test production the second it was clear this was a global problem. So instead of sending excess equipment around the world, we're playing catch up on our own shortage, and the control measures have to be a lot stricter because of it.
- Ericson2314 7y agoYes we could have tested the fuck out of everything in January and road it out the biggest functioning industrial power like WII. Instead we get effected like everyone else. On the other hand, for the sake of the world it's about time the US faced a real (non Perl Harbor / 9/11 bullshit) domestic crisis. The US needs to be humbled, and cede more power to the EU within the western world. So in that sense I am glad we didn't play the new-world-defense game and instead fucked this up, exposing the rot.
- Waterluvian 7y agoAwful to say but I think there's truth to this. Maybe people will respond more properly when their politicians move to defund important services.
- holler 7y ago> and cede more power to the EU within the western world Why would any nation cede power willingly to another? Would the EU willingly cede power to the US? What about Britain? That's not how sovereignty works. The US response has been massive and unprecedented.
- mantas 7y agoAs a citizen of a EU member, EU is laughing stock these days.
- 1996 7y agoDon't you have each state trying to steal supplies from each other? Like CZ stealing Chinese aid to IT, DE stealing masks made for BG etc?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- primitivesuave 7y agoI don’t see why this was downvoted as it is certainly an interesting discussion- will this crisis prompt the wealthiest nation in the world to enact a suitable response to a viral pandemic? My opinion is a strong no. After hurricanes and floods, we simply rebuild houses where they once stood and forget they ever happened. Our modern hurricane response is nothing to be proud of. Before WW1, Britain was the wealthiest nation in the world. They controlled the seas of the entire world and despite having one of the smaller populations, could bend huge populations to their will (e.g. India). It took only 4 years for an enormous transfer of wealth to take place from the British Empire, which had itself been sucking up the wealth of the world for centuries, to the United States. The financial hub of the world moved from London to New York. I could certainly see it moving again, and right now the most likely candidate is Beijing.
- jacquesm 7y ago> They controlled the seas of the entire world In their heads. But meanwhile, the Dutch, Portuguese and Spanish had more than their fair share as well. This whole re-writing of history is what enables 'MAGA' and other idiotic revisionist trends, please don't contribute to them. It only gives more credence to the kind of exceptionalism and nationalism on display.
- Waterluvian 7y agoIt's romantic to speak in such absolutes.
- toasterlovin 7y agoTo be fair, the British are pretty exceptional. All of the germanic/viking derived nations are.
- roywiggins 7y agoIt depends what era you're talking about, but the period leading up to WWI the UK was pretty dominant. Neither the Spanish or Portuguese challenged them during that period. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pax_Britannica https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pax_Britannica
- thaumaturgy 7y agoCalifornia especially has a lot of really great people in disaster management, from CalOES on down to the various county-level agencies that they coordinate with. That's not to say that things don't sometimes go upside-down; the destruction of the town of Paradise was an event that nobody had trained or planned for and there were a lot of relatively little things that got mishandled in the process, which slowed down some of the bigger things. But then it was all used as a case study over the next year and became a training drill with new operations manuals for all the agencies involved. So yeah, I get what you mean. New York seems to be taking the right steps here in the absence of a functioning federal government. I hope we don't get to see California in action, but if we do, I expect it will be a very fast, competent response.
- nicoburns 7y agoThey should be responding already surely?
- Aloha 7y agoThats one of the things about americanism, we have little reverence for tradition or authorities - we culturally value results more than process to achieve them. It has some downsides yes, but in times of crisis ie means that, we all just pick up and do our part - and frankly the best ideas usually float to the top.
- Waterluvian 7y agoIt looks sloppy as hell too. Which is partly why there's always so many complaints about how the US responds to any event.
- Aloha 7y agoIt does, but it's mostly effective, just slow to get started in the absence of someone priming the pump.
- watwut 7y ago> we culturally value results more than process to achieve them Frankly, that was not my impression from American management or institutions. The most important was rule following, then appearance of effort, results largely unimportant.
- darkerside 7y agoEvery culture has toxic subgroups that veer in this direction. It likely says more about your experience than the culture in aggregate.
- watwut 7y agoI would not necessary say they were all toxic as a persons. More that the whole culture pushes them to be that way and select people like that as leaders.
- nicoburns 7y ago> we culturally value results more than process to achieve them. You do? Seems to me that there are some areas that this very much doesn't apply too. For example: market processes are preferred over functioning healthcare system. The right to bear arms is preferred over limiting mass shootings. Capitalism is the ultimate authority in america. It's just so ingrained it's not seen as such.
- baybal2 7y ago> And I think one of the strongest virtues of the United States is being proven by Trump Strong military logistic? I think it is such a strong side of US military, that if you compare the entire logistic capacity of the rest of world's militaries taken together, it will still not surpass the US.
- mrmonkeyman 7y agoIf you take the budget of all militaries of the world together it too will not surpass that of the US..
- handedness 7y agoRelevant article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22658475 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22658475
- CraigJPerry 7y agoYeah it’s true and when America does wake up to global warming, it’ll be a juggernaut on so many fronts. I genuinely believe that when America decides to act on global warming there will be zero room for negotiation by others. It’s not in America’s short term interest though so this won’t happen any time soon.
- tanilama 7y agoIt is certainly more comforting/assuring to see more actions take right now. Once mobilized, US starts to impress more. But I fear what has been done is not enough, because it only feel necessary, but the virus is an exponential growing crisis, our capacity can not possible catch up with it. Strict lockdown right now. Take the short term pain, but better for long term.
- pyuser583 7y agoI’ve heard the opposite. Locking down only works as long as people lock down. Once the lockdown ends, the virus re-emerges. The repeated lockdowns continue until a vaccine is created. Taking less serious measures - only locking down the elderly - creates heard immunity, albeit with a higher death rate. The absolute lockdown we are doing now means the crisis will go on longer. The short term pain solution would be accepting the higher fatality rate for heard immunity. For the sake of my elderly parents, I’m glad we’re starting with a lockdown.
- Johnny555 7y agoThe short term pain solution would be accepting the higher fatality rate for heard immunity. But it's a much higher mortality rate without the social distancing since the hospitals will be overwhelmed so the mortality rate will approach the hospitalization rate if 15 - 20%
- Animats 7y agoYes, the wheels of production are starting to turn. Right now, there's a virus test shortage, a toilet paper shortage, a mask shortage, and a hand sanitizer shortage. Production of all those small items has already gone way up, and most of those shortages should be solved in a week or two. Bigger items like ventilators, ICU suites, and hospitals take longer. As for levels of government, that's very real. People outside the US often don't realize it, but the states have more power than the Federal government in many areas. I'm in San Mateo County, California, and we're in lockdown because the County Medical Officer and the county supervisors decided it was necessary. They didn't have to ask permission from any higher authority to do that. Action by the state governor came later. Action by the Federal government came even later, and was mostly advisory. California has wildfires, earthquakes, and floods routinely. So the state's Office of Emergency Services is large and well-funded, and their emergency operations center is usually dealing with something. Most large cities have emergency operations centers. It won't be enough at first. But this is going to be a months long problem, if not a year or two. The support facilities will catch up.
- akiselev 7y ago> People outside the US often don't realize it, but the states have more power than the Federal government in many areas. Especially when a local or a statewide emergency is declared. At that point, all bets are off and authorities can do pretty much whatever they want until someone gets a judge to issue an injunction, which they're a lot less likely to do in a state of emergency unless its gross abuse of civil liberties. Even then, if it goes on long enough, executive power at all levels of government becomes even harder to curtail.
- gentleman11 7y agoThere is a retail level toilet paper shortage due to hoarding and swine reselling it at massive markups. The supply continues to flow however
- Der_Einzige 7y agoShow me evidence that the mask shortage and the ventilator shortage will be resolved at any point in this pandemic please.
- gwright 7y ago> I mean this kind of should have happened weeks ago, and the executive branch is a bit of a panicked joke. And I feel like these sorts of virtue-signaling remarks makes it harder to focus on what to do now. It isn't even clear that anyone would have listened to the federal government weeks ago. Look at the criticism that was made when Chinese flights were restricted in January.
- perl4ever 7y ago"It isn't even clear that anyone would have listened to the federal government weeks ago" "Anyone" being disproportionately the half of the country that likes to sneer at "virtue signaling". It's unseemly to blame the other half for that. Parts of the country just will not believe even now, because it must be another fake media thing like the "Russian hoax".
- gwright 7y ago> It's unseemly to blame the other half for that. Who is "blaming" anyone? Suggesting that there was no public consensus for extreme actions 6 or 8 weeks ago isn't blaming anyone for anything it is just stating a fact. And your last comment seems to be repeating the lie that the President called the virus a hoax, which he did not. He called the unfounded accusations of his lack of actions another hoax. It is unrcontionable to be spreading that misinformation at this point.
- perl4ever 7y ago"repeating the lie that the President called the virus a hoax" I did not. But my comment was flagged so you can make up anything you want about it, so have a cookie.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't take HN threads further into political flamewar. We don't need that here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- scollet 7y agoThe CEOs bit got an audible laugh out of me! Wash your hands of all sarcasm too.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoWeeks ago??? Nah. YEARS ago. The idea of a pandemic is so old even Hollywood is done rehashing it. Do you seriously believe the pro-globalization faction had no idea this would happen? Are you that naive? We've had plenty of warnings (e.g., Ebola, SARS, etc.) and there's no stockpile of the basics (e.g., masks, sanitizers, etc.) That's obviously systemic. If you're blamimg the current admin in full you're a fool. This snafu has much greater depth and breadth.
- adventured 7y agoThe US always lags on a major crisis and then surges over time. It happens in every instance. It's because of the scale and nature of Federal -> State -> Local as a system, mixed with human rights and democracy (no authoritarian switch to throw, so to speak). The US has to put a lot of things in motion to mobilize at all levels and it's extraordinarily expensive, so you don't want to do it unless you must. As recently as mid January the WHO was still repeating Chinese propaganda about the virus not being transmitted from person to person (China had known at that point for at least 30-45 days that that was a lie, they were trying to keep the world from isolating them and hammering their economy, hoping they could stop it quickly). Trump's delays cost the US three to four weeks of additional prep time. From the first week of February (closer to when the US should have began to prepare nationally), versus the end of Feb / first week of March. It was also entirely unclear how infectious it was and what the mortality rate was likely to be, until well into February.
- malandrew 7y agoTrump probably burned approximately the amount of time he bought by shutting down flights too and from China before everyone else.
- wrs 7y ago“Men and nations do behave wisely once they have exhausted all other alternatives.” - Abba Eban
- Tade0 7y agoNote though that such things are usually done by some department of the US army - and that's no accident given that it's the most well funded and some of the most well prepared of such organizations in the world.
- kabapadum 7y agothe incredible power of leadership at all levels of government. // LOL The incredible power of stupidy wich one arose like any other viruses. That's whats exactly we can see now, and especially with people like trump in power.
- Rapzid 7y agoI appreciate the state response and governors, but I can't help but feel like they are being lined up in front of the bus.. "Everyone" is calling for centralized logistical planning and a unified, national response strategy. Unfortunately it appears the executive is, by all accounts, trying to distance themselves from ultimate responsibility.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bamboozled 7y agoMurica!