10 ms·
The mask guidance is confusing as well. I get they are trying to preserve masks for medical staff. But, they also say it's mainly spread by coughing, sneezing
by tyingq 7y ago
The mask guidance is confusing as well. I get they are trying to preserve masks for medical staff. But, they also say it's mainly spread by coughing, sneezing, and resulting spray of bodily fluids. Surely even a scarf around your face would have some benefit? Yes, I get that the virus is small enough to pass through, but some deflection is better than none.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sonicggg 7y agoSomething does not add up about the advice. Specially given that Eastern authorities encourage the use of makes by the general public. Which part of the World is better handling this pandemic?
- bilbo0s 7y agoMasks should just be a given. If we consider a place like South Korea, or Singapore, the executive actions contrast wildly with the executive actions that our city, state, and federal governments have taken. If I'm not mistaken, in Singapore they even went so far as to distribute packs of masks to each and every family. I don't ask for that level of efficiency, but it does illustrate an example of effective executive action during times like these.
- jplayer01 7y ago> I don't ask for that level of efficiency, Well, why the crap not? Why is the west so unbelievably bad at handling this epidemic? Why aren't we able to produce our own masks? These things are essential and it was all off-shored to China. Now the west is screwed while life goes on in Asia.
- bilbo0s 7y agoActually, we do produce masks. Right here in the US. We just didn't order up enough in the ramp up to prepare for the surge the way the government did in Singapore. As to the question of competence, well, I guess maybe I should demand the eastern level of competence out of my leaders. But what good does it do to demand something that you know from the outset your leaders are not capable of? We have the leaders we have. I can't change that right now. The only thing we can do collectively is to try to get the best we can out of them, realizing that it's very likely their best ain't gonna be anywhere near asia level efficiency. Maybe one of the good things to come out of this crisis will be a demand for higher quality stewards. Maybe we'll get much higher quality candidates at election time? But in all honesty, I kind of doubt it.
- wbl 7y agoYou should. Don't you deserve good goverment?
- MiguelVieira 7y agoRight now it’s paradoxical: according to the government, masks are useless for civilians, but essential to medical personnel.
- ISL 7y agoThere is a resolution to the paradox. Masks do work (especially when worn correctly), but the net-optimal place to put them to work is keeping medical personnel up and functional. Have spare masks? We are trying to get them to the people who need them most: https://findthemasks.com/ https://findthemasks.com/ We are presently listing hospitals accepting small-scale donations in 28 states, growing fast.
- the8472 7y agoThat's not a resolution because the claim is that they're useless ("not effective"), which is not the same as there existing a better use. They could have communicated the truth, instead they chose to lie, which erodes trust. https://twitter.com/Surgeon_General/status/1233725785283932160?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw https://twitter.com/Surgeon_General/status/12337257852839321...
- jendnfoxke 7y agoYOU are making the claim that they’re useless. “Not effective” does not mean “useless” You are making a dishonest argument to make your misguided point.
- longerthoughts 7y agoIf they’d said something like “they’re effective but it’s better for all of us if these people get them instead of you” would that have been effective?
- the8472 7y agoThey could have avoided making any direct comment on effectiveness and simply stated that access by medical personnel needs to be prioritized since they're the most exposed group.
- en-us 7y agoAgreed. The US surgeon general lied to the population about the efficacy of masks to try to preserve them for healthcare workers. It would have been better to ask people to preserve N95 for healthcare workers and instead improvise their own. Any reduction in droplet transmission is going to drop the R0 of this and help flatten the curve. As an alternative see Hong Kong, where they are encouraging the population to improvise masks: https://www.consumer.org.hk/ws_en/news/specials/2020/mask-diy-tips.html https://www.consumer.org.hk/ws_en/news/specials/2020/mask-di...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- simonh 7y agoImprovised masks commonly provide little protection, but obstruct breathing so people suck in more air with more force, increasing their risk of exposure.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoUnless you have a study that backs this up, this is just baseless speculation. I agree with the other posters, I am incredibly frustrated with the CDC for misleading about the efficacy of surgical masks with statements like "the virus particles are smaller than the holes in the mask" - that may be true, but all the studies I could find show that masks reduce flu transmission by 70-80%.
- en-us 7y agoWhat you say is directly contradicted by the researchers at University of Hong Kong-Shenzhen Hospital, as detailed in my link above. Can you cite a study that supports your claim?
- ardy42 7y ago>> It would have been better to ask people to preserve N95 for healthcare workers and instead improvise their own. Any reduction in droplet transmission is going to drop the R0 of this and help flatten the curve. > Improvised masks commonly provide little protection, but obstruct breathing so people suck in more air with more force, increasing their risk of exposure. The point of an improvised mask should not be to protect the wearer, but to protect the community from the wearer.
- ceejayoz 7y ago"Why Telling People They Don’t Need Masks Backfired: To help manage the shortage, the authorities sent a message that made them untrustworthy." https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/17/opinion/coronavirus-face-masks.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/17/opinion/coronavirus-face-... And some data back from SARS: "Always wearing a mask when going out was associated with a 70% reduction in risk compared with never wearing a mask. Wearing a mask intermittently was associated with a smaller yet significant reduction in risk." https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/10/2/03-0730_article https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/10/2/03-0730_article I saw a lot of people sanctimoniously talking about fit tests in normal healthcare settings as if an imperfect fit dropped effectiveness immediately down to 0% from 100%.
- Symmetry 7y agoI think the thing is that most people will naturally treat things qualitatively. A mask either protects you or it doesn't. A substance is either a poison or it isn't. Etc.
- dzdt 7y agoYes the truth is masks help, but officials decided to lie about this to prevent panic over lack of masks. But this is damaging not only to official credibility but also to the response. A big demand for masks in January could have forced new supply chains to develop in the west. That would have averted some of the current disaster happening where hospitals can't get masks.
- dahart 7y agoAgreed; I believe a scarf around your face will have some benefit. The CDC’s current guidance is about “respirators”, and maybe they’re not saying anything at all about plain masks or scarves, but studies posted here on HN in the last 2 days have shown some positive effectiveness for any kind of mask at all. I’ve heard first hand from a friend in Shenzhen China - where they are now back at work - that they are certain masks are effective, and the main vector is coughing and sneezing. If nothing else at all, wearing a mask can be a very helpful reminder to not touch your face.
- davrosthedalek 7y agoTo your last point, I would worry about that. If you are not used to it, you might want to re-adjust it quite often, and you have to take it off at some point. It is really hard to not touch your face. I probably touched it twice writing this.
- dahart 7y agoOf course you take it off when you get home... so? Yes, it is hard not to touch your face, which is why having a mask on it helps you remember not to... just try it. You have to consciously reach under your mask to achieve skin to skin contact. You can easily scratch your face through your mask without touching your face. Touching your mask is not the same thing as touching your face. I’m rather confused about this push back. Of course wearing a mask doesn’t guarantee you can’t get infected, but it’s better than not wearing one. There’s a bunch of evidence of this, in studies, and in China right now. What is there to worry about? If you’re really worried, then don’t go out.
- erentz 7y agoThe whole blaming people for hoarding masks and then the "masks don't work" things have been incredibly frustrating. It is almost like authorities didn't want anyone to start asking why the public couldn't get masks, as they can in say Taiwan. Most (if not all) distributors and manufacturers of masks has been prioritizing health care systems and governments over retailers since January. Just as they should do. Were there any that weren't? I didn't see any reports of that, but if so of course the proper thing is to report them and talk to them. Not to blame random joe for having a mask. The fact was since January retail supplies were only existing stock, which as we know was quickly sold out with a lot being sent back to family overseas (no judgement there). And I haven't seen any masks being restocked at any hardware stores or pharmacies since. At no time did I hear about authorities going around every pharmacy or home depot to try to collect any masks. Why? Because they knew there were no supplies and what was there was so small it'd make no dent in the problem. So blaming the public is grossly irresponsible and even put people in danger. I have an immune compromised friend that was responsibly using masks but got harassed for wearing masks "that don't work". And there were plenty of similar reports of such behavior from others.
- ceejayoz 7y agoWashington state just seized a restock from a Target in Seattle. https://twitter.com/GovInslee/status/1241505423259099136 https://twitter.com/GovInslee/status/1241505423259099136
- whatshisface 7y agoThe message to commercial entities is clear: don't bother responding.
- ceejayoz 7y agoIf you're gonna respond by selling N95s to consumers right now, instead of to hospitals, then I'd rather you didn't bother responding.
- 7y ago
- MR4D 7y agoThe CDC is letting perfect get in the way of good. If you look at almost all of their actions, they continually clamp down on things that might work because they have not been proven. It seems to me that they are led by academics and theoreticians with very little operational capability at the top decision making channels.
- Reedx 7y agoPretty much. We're seeing the result of institutional decay at every level. "In the middle of the 20th century, a cadre of credentialed experts was created to replace citizens. This was a mistake. The selection mechanism for entry into this cadre selects against bravery and original thinking. Experts should be consulted, but what use is an expert unwilling to consult on a grand vision? The American system of the 2020s through the city, county, state, and up to the federal level has been staffed with people who know how to speak and make themselves appear blameless, but not how to act." https://americanmind.org/features/the-coronacrisis-and-our-future-discontents/annoyance-or-armageddon/ https://americanmind.org/features/the-coronacrisis-and-our-f...
- pm90 7y agoA few counterpoints: - The CDC (and the US Federal Government in particular) has been understaffed and underfunded for the entire duration of the Trump Administration; to expect the agency that's been gutted for 3 years to rise up to responding effectively to a pandemic seems a bit much. The CDC is not the Center for Pandemic Control; 99% of the time their goal is to optimize tests and 99% of diseases they work with are not pandemics. - Understanding that the responses to the pandemic by federal agencies would be suboptimal, the pandemic response team was created for this very scenario to provide an "optimal" response to a pandemic. But that too was disbanded by the current administration. Removing all the ways in which an agency is empowered to tackle a specific problem and then claiming its institutional decay doesn't sound reasonable to me. Federal agencies are hyper-specialized things and deliberately don't have the kind of "leadership" that you're looking for... that power is held by the President, as it should be. Literally any other competent president would have (re-)created the task force and empowered that to lead the response.
- CriticalCathed 7y agoIt's not all that confusing. The science is pretty clear. The best use of masks on people in public is on the sick themselves. You can't use the standards and practices in something like a TB hospital for medical personnel in public spaces. Not only is it an inefficient use of resources, but the efficacy is in question. You cannot expect the general population to adhere to the standards of a TB hospital. It cannot be done, even if it was a good idea. For example, standard practice is that a mask is meant to be worn for only 8 hours and that is under the assumption that you have no reason to believe you were exposed. If the mask becomes wet, damp, or if you have any reason to believe you've been exposed you're supposed to immediately doff it carefully and dispose of it. Typically PPE is used only once per exposure, or is reused for exposure to one patient at a time. There are so many variables at play here. From the efficacy of the masks themselves, the best allocation of resources, the different varieties of masks, the techniques for proper fitting, the decontamination processes, other PPE. Does this mean masks are not useful? No. And you won't find many experts making this claim. It's clear that masks help. Think critically about this. It is not as simple as "masks good" or "surgeon general lied." There are manifold hysterics going around -- please don't contribute to it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- EGreg 7y agoIf the virus is mainly spread by coughing and sneezing, wouldn’t mandating absolutely everyone to wear a regular mask that covers their own cough be enough? Better than all these quarantine measures? If you are caught without a mask you get fined. How else can people get the virus? Perhaps people shed the virus through their skin? Or touch their face and get it on their hands? So people can wash their hands before touching their face. Also people can get it in their private homes. But those groups don’t mix all the time. So I am just wondering... N95 masks are for the person who doesn’t want to get the virus. But what about everyone else? I understand that you could wear the mask crooked and there are problems with application. But mass producing N95 masks and giving them out and MANDATING everyone wearing them like women in Saudi Arabia seems like a better policy.
- Thriptic 7y agoIt's very irritating because people don't understand the concept of defense in depth. Are surgical masks going to give you total protection? Of course not, but as you say they provide SOME benefit. Saying "masks don't work because they don't fully stop the virus and users misuse them" is basically equivalent to saying "code review is a waste of time because it won't catch every bug and because devs don't do it correctly". The solution isn't stop doing code review, it's to teach people how to do it and to understand it's limitations.
- deelowe 7y agoWhat's more frustrating is the exact same logic applies to "social distancing." Social distancing will not completely stop people from getting sick. It'll just slow the spread. So, according to the CDC, an imperfect solution for quarantine is totally fine, but when it comes to masks, only n95 or better are worth pursuing.
- XorNot 7y agoIt's quite likely that in all the scenarios a mask may have a useful effect, N95 or better is the only time it works. For medical professionals in close contact with patients and dealing with airborne-protocol pathogens (which is what a droplet-mediated pathogens like SARS2 becomes classed as once patients are coughing and being intubated) then a bad mask is quite probably worse then no mask (this has precedent: ineffective masks obstruct breathing, which makes you take deeper breaths and draw more particles in deeper in your lungs - it's a big problem when dealing with fine dusts in construction).
- ceejayoz 7y agoIt's highly likely that even basic surgical masks have some impact. A fit-tested N95 is the gold standard, but the widespread use of surgical masks in Asia during the SARS epidemic does seem to have had an impact. https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/10/2/03-0730_article https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/10/2/03-0730_article
- dahart 7y ago
- flipflipper 7y agoI heard, anecdotally, that non-approved masks have the possibility of aerosolizing a cough/sneeze more
- dirtyid 7y agoFor reference, this is the recently released guide on mask usage by Chinese National Health and Medical Commission: https://zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/114129365 https://zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/114129365 Cat meme because it was reposted to Chinese Quora. Obviously consider that Asian countries have no mask shortage due to existing cultural practices. Masks should be prioritized to prevent collapse of medical capacity when there is shortage - the policy suggestion most western countries are seeing. The TL;DR of the guide: the only scenario not to wear (normal surgical) mask is when you're alone. Surgical masks for almost every other situation, N95+ for high risk situations. On efficacy for public health, The microbiologist Yuen Kwok-yung, from HK who was a key figure in SARS and one of the expert teams on Covid response: >Given this novel coronavirus is so "cunning", with probably many infected but asymptomatic people moving around in communities, how should ordinary citizens protect themselves? >We can only rely on telling everyone to wear a mask, wash their hands frequently, use alcoholic sanitiser. I had called for everyone to wear a mask when I was in Beijing, but many people disagreed, saying that the World Health Organisation (WHO) said healthy people don't need to wear masks unless they go to crowded places. Nevertheless, if people wear masks only when they feel sick, then the eight infected people on the Diamond Princess would have transmitted it to others because they were not feeling uncomfortable. Wear a mask to protect not only yourself but also others, because if you are infected but asymptomatic, you could still stop the spread by wearing a mask. >In our experiments previously, we found 100 million virus strands in just one milliliter of a patient's saliva. Therefore, scenarios with the potential for exchanging saliva are generally quite dangerous. The temporary success of virus control in Hong Kong this time is not only due to population controls, but also contributed by the early advocacy for mask-wearing, hand-washing, and social distancing. Otherwise, with such a dense population in Hong Kong, the epidemic would very likely have spread the same way as in Italy or Daegu in South Korea. https://www.straitstimes.com/asia/east-asia/exclusive-qa-with-hong-kong-microbiologist-yuen-kwok-yung-who-helped-confirm https://www.straitstimes.com/asia/east-asia/exclusive-qa-wit... Google translate of guideline: The general public (1) Home and outdoor, no people gathered, well ventilated. It is not recommended to wear a mask. (2) Being in a crowded place, such as office, shopping, restaurant, conference room, workshop, etc .; or taking a box elevator or public transportation. In low- and medium-risk areas, it is recommended that you wear spare masks (disposable medical masks or medical surgical masks) with you, and wear them when in close contact with other people (less than or equal to 1 meter). In high-risk areas, disposable medical masks are recommended. (3) For those with cold symptoms such as coughing or sneezing. It is recommended to wear disposable medical or surgical masks. (4) For those who live together with those who are separated from home and discharged from rehabilitation. It is recommended to wear disposable medical or surgical masks. Personnel in specific places (1) It is located in densely populated hospitals, bus stations, railway stations, subway stations, airports, supermarkets, restaurants, public transportation, and community and unit import and export places. In medium and low risk areas, it is recommended that workers wear disposable medical masks or surgical surgical masks. In high-risk areas, it is recommended that workers wear medical surgical masks or protective masks that comply with KN95 / N95 and above. (2) In prisons, nursing homes, welfare homes, mental health medical institutions, school classrooms, construction site dormitories and other densely populated places. In medium and low-risk areas, it is recommended that you always wear spare masks (disposable medical masks or surgical surgical masks) with you daily, and wear masks when people gather or come into close contact with one another (less than or equal to 1 meter). In high-risk areas, it is recommended that workers wear medical surgical masks or protective masks that comply with KN95 / N95 and above; other personnel wear disposable medical masks. Key personnel Suspected cases, confirmed cases, and asymptomatic infections of new coronavirus pneumonia; close contacts of new coronavirus pneumonia; immigrants (from entry to end of quarantine). It is recommended to wear medical surgical masks or protective masks without exhalation valve that conform to KN95 / N95 and above. Occupational exposure (1) Medical personnel such as general outpatient clinics and wards; emergency medical personnel in medical institutions in low-risk areas; administrative personnel, police, security, cleaning, etc. engaged in epidemic prevention and control. Medical surgical masks are recommended. (2) Personnel working in the ward and ICU of patients diagnosed with a new type of coronavirus pneumonia, suspected case patients; medical staff at designated medical institutions for fever clinics; medical staff in emergency departments of medical institutions in middle and high risk areas; epidemiological investigations and experiments Room testing, environmental disinfection personnel; transfer of confirmed and suspected cases. Medical protective masks are recommended. (3) Operators engaged in the collection of respiratory specimens; staff who perform tracheotomy, tracheal intubation, bronchoscopy, sputum suction, cardiopulmonary resuscitation, or lung transplantation, pathological anatomy in patients with new-type coronavirus pneumonia. Suggestion: hood-type (or full-type) powered air-supply filter respirator, or half-plane power-supply air-filter respirator with goggles or full screen; P100 anti-particulate filter should be used for both types of respiratory protection Elements and filter elements should not be reused. Use protective equipment after disinfection.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- skipwalker 7y agoI found a few links on making "ninja" masks out of t-shirts. They seem as good as any. The best thing is you can just throw them in the washing machine after an outing. https://www.wikihow.com/Make-a-Ninja-Mask https://www.wikihow.com/Make-a-Ninja-Mask http://www.funlol.com/1255/Ninja_Instructions!.html http://www.funlol.com/1255/Ninja_Instructions!.html “Origami” tea cloth mask with rubber bands https://www.instagram.com/p/B96rcR8neYv/ https://www.instagram.com/p/B96rcR8neYv/
- Symmetry 7y agoThere was a paper that went by my Twitter feed yesterday about how dish towels tended to do better on the particulates the researchers were testing on than a t-shirt (or piece of silk, or double layer cotton shirt, or...). I agree about them being better than nothing and it'll be fairly dependent on aerosol size but you should probably prefer thicker clothes.
- skipwalker 7y agoThis website chose cotton t-shirts as the best combo https://smartairfilters.com/en/blog/diy-homemade-mask-protect-virus-coronavirus/?fbclid=IwAR38yOiD_jdcJ9TBrHe83pCtUhUR8nyhegtypQdrgi9hoarBRnwBJmoWs2o https://smartairfilters.com/en/blog/diy-homemade-mask-protec... https://smartairfilters.com/en/blog/best-materials-make-diy-face-mask-virus/?fbclid=IwAR1PNLAAzBkVDcHpMl_lcZ0g-nwOyLVxa06b9HxbEifGo354-a45ZEeoMQ4 https://smartairfilters.com/en/blog/best-materials-make-diy-...
- greedo 7y agoDish towels and vacuum bags do a better job of filtering, but make breathing quite difficult. A simple cotton t-shirt material is fine. And there's no sign that double layers help; and they make it harder to breath as well.
- superzamp 7y agoMy thought as well. The repeated consensus from gov & medical here in France seems to be that they are not effective at protecting you and that's pretty much all that they say. YES, we get it, but what about protecting others from your cough since most people don't even know they're contagious. Even a 20% decrease from a crappy solution is interesting when dealing with exponential curves. Drives me mad.
- amluto 7y agoI haven’t seen any real results on whether bare virions in the air are infectious, but it certainly doesn’t sound like a major mechanism of COVID-19 infection. Certainly, when coughing, a good deal of the expelled material is visible and fairly large. And wet. ISTM a moderately tightly woven or knit hydrophilic mask (e.g. cotton) could be quite effective. Knits could have the added benefit that droplets would need to take a twisty path to get through. And there is plenty of such material around. This shouldn’t be that hard to study in a lab. Find a sick person, have them cough through different masks, and measure viral concentrations on nearby surfaces.
- kriro 7y agoThe standard argument is that a mask may give you a false sense of safety which results in subtle behavioral changes that are a net-negative. Additionally if the mask inhibits breathing you might take deeper breaths which is also a net-negative.
- temac 7y agoThat standard argument is a myth simply used to shape opinion in the context of a shortage of masks, to redirect the existing one to health care workers. In countries where the epidemic is controlled, pretty much everybody wear masks, including handcrafted one in case of shortage. The goal is not to prevent from being infected, but to prevent infecting other, by limiting the amount of saliva you spread everywhere. Especially since tons of carriers are asymptomatic, or starting to be contagious before becoming symptomatic. And even a poor mask in front of your mouth is better than nothing, at least if everybody wears one, and if you don't become careless on other measures (distancing, washing the hands, etc.) So there is an availability and potentially a cultural problem, but that can and should be fixed. Because this will be far less costly than infinite lockdowns.
- susanhi 7y agoChina has ramped their face mask production to 200 million a DAY. And CDC’s continued insistence that face masks don’t work is disingenuous at best. Leading way to a global recession at worst. Had they changed their guidelines to saying that face masks can help inhibit spread at the very least, especially from asymptomatic carriers who are wearing masks, US gov could have contracted mask manufacturers to with millions of dollars worth of mask orders. Spurring then to produce masks, eliminating this shortage of masks. Instead, gov plan has no mask protocol, so the only other option is a global shutdown of “non-essential businesses”. Causing an essential shutdown of the economy. The cost of which they have obviously not calculated.
- namelosw 7y agoI was wondering the same. I'm by no means professional but it seems to be better than nothing, especially for people who sneeze. In China, it's pretty much contained now, and everyone wears masks on the street -- The thing is, there are 1.3 billion people, of course there are a lot of people couldn't buy or afford surgical masks, let alone N95 masks. It turns out people wear regular masks, or even they don't have any mask they sew their own mask. Also, most surgical and N95 masks are disposable, in China, people cover their hand sewed mask outside, covering the disposable masks inside and try to reuse them, and disposes the hand-sews masks. This hack, of course, have potential risks, but it might help for people who are running out of masks.
- ardy42 7y ago> In China ... everyone wears masks on the street ... there are a lot of people couldn't buy or afford surgical masks, let alone N95 masks. Sorry to nitpick, but it's N95 respirators not masks. There's be a lot of terminology confusion on this topic, and I think it's making communication significantly more difficult on this topic. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JR2uLfEVD2w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JR2uLfEVD2w https://multimedia.3m.com/mws/media/956213O/differences-between-respirators-and-masks.pdf https://multimedia.3m.com/mws/media/956213O/differences-betw...
- thoraway1010 7y agoMasks work, masks are low impact on daily living, masks are used successfully overseas by countries that didn't lock down their society (tawain / Singapore etc) - huge empahsis on masks including govt run websites with live maps showing where to get them, masks in all post offices for distribution etc and BIG production increases.
- svara 7y agoI've posted this here before, so sorry about that, but in this case I think it's just so important that I belive it's justified: The messaging around masks has been so aggravating to me that I got together with a couple of colleagues to write a detailed, scientific mini-review / commentary: https://medium.com/@matthiassamwald/promoting-simple-do-it-yourself-masks-an-urgent-intervention-for-covid-19-mitigation-14da4100f429 https://medium.com/@matthiassamwald/promoting-simple-do-it-y... The benefit of widespread mask usage by the general population is source control [0]. This works even if the person wearing the masks makes mistakes such as touching their face more while wearing the mask. Also, it should be obvious that there is no downside to wide-spread mask usage by the general population. The countries that have so far the most control over the virus' spread are the ones where wearing masks is normal and often done to protect others when sick. Importantly, if the goal is source control, then all sorts of makeshift mask designs can work. People in Japan and other countries are already getting really creative [2,3]. Of course, the problem that medical personnel might face even more shortages if everybody starts wearing medical grade masks is real and must be taken seriously. But that's not the only option we have. [0] One reference amongst many, this commentary in the Lancet: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(20)30520-1/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6... [1] Compare growth rates here: https://studylib.net/coronavirus-growth https://studylib.net/coronavirus-growth [2] https://www.cottontimemagazine.com/page/10 https://www.cottontimemagazine.com/page/10 [3] https://mobile.twitter.com/nekohnd/status/1223686733654396928/photo/1 https://mobile.twitter.com/nekohnd/status/122368673365439692...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- darrinm 7y agoAgree. If coughing into my arm helps (CDC recommended) it’s hard to imagine any kind of mask wouldn’t help too. Also recommends mask: https://www.cdc.gov/flu/pdf/protect/cdc_cough.pdf https://www.cdc.gov/flu/pdf/protect/cdc_cough.pdf
- david_w 7y agoViruses are very small: Virions, single virus particles, are very small, about 20–250 nanometers in diameter or 0.25 to 0.025 of a micrometer. https://courses.lumenlearning.com/boundless-microbiology/chapter/overview-of-viruses/ https://courses.lumenlearning.com/boundless-microbiology/cha... The flu virus is typical: ...the flu virus is .17 microns in size. https://www.envirosafetyproducts.com/resources/dust-masks-whats-the-difference.html https://www.envirosafetyproducts.com/resources/dust-masks-wh... Masks work by trapping flu particles. The 95 in an N95 mask is shorthand for "this masks traps 95% of particles of size .3 microns. There are also N99 and N100. N100 trap 99.7%. N100 when it is used in an air filter is called HEPA which I believe stands for High Efficiency Particle Attenuator or Arresting. There is also a level above that found mostly in Europe called ULPA which pushes the decimal out further to 99.9997% . All of these aarea measure of the masks ability to trap particles of 0.3 except ULPA which is a measure of trapping particle 0.17 https://www.globalspec.com/learnmore/manufacturing_process_equipment/filtration_separation_products/hepa_filters_ulpa_filters https://www.globalspec.com/learnmore/manufacturing_process_e... Masks are matted fibers designed to trap particles on their fibers. They do this using 3 mechanisms which all masks share- diffusion, impaction and inertial impaction. Diffusion happens when a particle is so small it is in Brownian (random) motion. These particles are trapped because they constantly change direction randomly as they pass through the mask and eventually run out of luck trying to dodge fibers. Such particles are less than 0.03 microns in size. (I should inject here that even though virus are smaller than this, there's more to the story as detailed below). Inertial impaction happens when a particle is larger than .03 and owing to its size and momentum cannot change its direction of travel fast enough to stop itself running into a fiber. Impaction happens when a particle comes within 1/2 of its radius of a fiber and touches it, becoming trapped. This is the most difficult size of particle to capture (as it happens) and that's why its the reference particle size for safety masks. In the above I acted as though the particles were "trying" to avoid being trapped, but of course that's just a stub for the underlying physics off motion and magnetic attraction/repulsion which underlie these facts. If you want to DIY some sort of mask to reduce your exposure, you have to consider that the weave of most cloth is far far wider than .03 and anyway not in layers (a cloth like yarn is the exception to the second property). Just guessing but rags scarves etc lack the required fiber density to function as safety masks. It is possible that the virions would sail through them even under Brownian motion. But that is not really how virions are transmitted- they are transmitted mixed in with saliva particles which are hugely larger than the virions themselves. The size of a particle of saliva in a sneeze was examined here- tldr: a bimodal distribution of sneeze particle size all over 50 micrometers. https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/full/10.1098/rsif.2013.0560 https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/full/10.1098/rsif.201... Some other studies have put the size as small as .35 micrometer. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4676262/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4676262/ What is really astonishing is how fast the particles travel- 200 MPH. https://www.livescience.com/3686-gross-science-cough-sneeze.html https://www.livescience.com/3686-gross-science-cough-sneeze.... https://www.texairfilters.com/what-happens-to-the-particles-when-you-sneeze/ https://www.texairfilters.com/what-happens-to-the-particles-... So all in all we can say this-any mask covering is better than no mask because it's an odds game with virus particles and saliva. The less able you are to breath through it, the better it functions as a barrier. Ordinary cloth is just not woven tightly enough to substitute for a p95 mask. If you had to choose between multiple layers of x number of fibers and a tighter weave of the same fibers, it might be better to go for a tighter weave because even though individual virions would travel under Brownian motion, that's not how a spray of sneeze which is the transport mechanism of the virus is going to travel. Some sneeze particles containing virions have a particle size of 5 microns and will stay aloft in a still room for a long, long, long time. If someone sneezes and three minutes later you walk through where they were, you could very well become the unknowing, unwilling next host of the virus. That last - horrifying - fact is one of the the reasons why they're telling people to maintain social distancing and just stay home.