18 ms·
California governor issues statewide 'stay at home' order
- aazaa 7y agoThe order is vague about shopping for groceries. https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/03/19/coronavirus-read-the-gov-newsoms-order-to-stay-at-home/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/03/19/coronavirus-read-the-... Given that at least one employee of a grocery store has tested positive in CA, it seems that grocery stores, where large numbers of people congregate and touch surfaces, could be a loophole to be addressed... somehow.
- therealdrag0 7y agoHow? They are part of critical infrastructure.
- thomk 7y agoCompletely offtopic but how the hell are those beaches in Florida not closed right now? Those idiots are going to fly home soon and insert this virus straight into their communities.
- danso 7y agoA little more info from SFGate: https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Coronavirus-Atria-Burlingame-nursing-home-SF-15142764.php https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Coronavirus-Atria-Bur... > The order is completely identical to the one in the Bay Area, meaning individuals can also leave their houses to take a walk or go for a jog so long as they are practicing the requisite precautions when coming into contact with another individual.
- rolltiide 7y agoOne week longer from what I hear, April 14th/until further notice
- ilyagr 7y agoDo you (or SFGate) have a reference for that? I read what I thought was the most official version of the California order [1], and it's frustratingly short. After reading it, I can't tell whether I can go for a bike ride. Even the fact that I can go to a grocery store isn't stated explicitly. Is there a clearer, more detailed version? By comparison, the SF order [2] impressed me by how clear it is. For instance, it clearly allows recreation with sensible caveats. UPDATE: The video announcement [3] implies that the intent of the CA order is, indeed, to allow all the things the SF order allows. Not sure whether that has legal force, but good enough for me. [1]: https://covid19.ca.gov/img/N-33-20.pdf https://covid19.ca.gov/img/N-33-20.pdf [2]: https://www.sfdph.org/dph/alerts/files/HealthOrderC19-07-%20Shelter-in-Place.pdf https://www.sfdph.org/dph/alerts/files/HealthOrderC19-07-%20... [3]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zsVZ3EZEl60&t=28s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zsVZ3EZEl60&t=28s
- stygiansonic 7y agoThanks for all the references. I also couldn't find any explicit guidance around "outdoor exercise" that was as clear as the SF order. I do also agree that the video you reference implies that the CA-wide order allows the same sorts of things (Newsom references "walking your dog") but hopefully there is more explicit guidance.
- s1artibartfast 7y agoThe order is essentially meaningless without further refinement. "critical workers" includes essentially any commercial retail https://www.cisa.gov/critical-infrastructure-sectors https://www.cisa.gov/critical-infrastructure-sectors >The Commercial Facilities Sector consists of eight subsectors: Entertainment and Media (e.g., motion picture studios, broadcast media). Gaming (e.g., casinos). Lodging (e.g., hotels, motels, conference centers). Outdoor Events (e.g., theme and amusement parks, fairs, campgrounds, parades). Public Assembly (e.g., arenas, stadiums, aquariums, zoos, museums, convention centers). Real Estate (e.g., office and apartment buildings, condominiums, mixed use facilities, self-storage). Retail (e.g., retail centers and districts, shopping malls). Sports Leagues (e.g., professional sports leagues and federations).
- themodelplumber 7y agoThank you... People need to know this part. It's an exemption in our county order here too. I've been walking and hiking every day since reading that. Some funny stuff... - I always wear a floppy sun hat. Been there, had the dermatologist appointment. I can tell people think I'm a weird prepper. But I'm just going hiking, and need good sun coverage... - Sitting on a bench in the city park, holding a tiny shortwave radio, with antenna clipped on... I've been doing this for years now, but these days people slow down their cars and stare... - Having some family fun with our GMRS license, as we do about 1-2x weekly, anyway my son had a walkie talkie in his hand when we visited a nearby store and the cashier said we gave him a "zombie apocalypse vibe" (then handed me a card and asked me to email him about getting a license) - Walking near seniors and the elderly...SO sad. They look terrified and take ~20 foot detours. (Not terrified at me, just in general...I hope) - Seeing groups, like families talking in the street... They're out just enjoying a bit of sun, laughing, but then they completely disperse or go inside when someone walks down the street toward them. - People seem to be putting on a weird act if they see that you are looking at them, like, "see, this is how I get out of my car during a pandemic." lol. - If you go around a corner and run into somebody... Even if no physical contact... Awkward. Lmao - So quiet. It's like most of our city already died off. But there's only one case reported in our county, far to the south It's weird. When I take a ham radio out hiking, I take one with a blue case, so people don't get the wrong idea...
- 01100011 7y agoJudging by my trip to Costco tonight, I don't think people really understand the whole 'social distancing' thing. Typical Costco, with no awareness of personal space. I tried to stay clear of people but it was useless. I had a much better experience at the grocery store a couple nights ago. People kept a wide berth.
- hkmurakami 7y agoGood move by Newsom considering there were photos of people in socal still going to bars. Judging by how long the shelter in place has lasted and affected curves in Asia, we should be prepared for ~2 months as a baseline. From what we're hearing from friends, life is starting to return to normalcy in Hong Kong, with no new domestic cases reported (though now they're contending with new imported cases from overseas travelers returning home). They have a really effective screening/tracking quarantine system in place where they'll give you a location tracking wristband for remote monitoring. Our family has been affected by this since late January, and there's a big mental challenge aspect to this. Being able to walk outside (unlike in Wuhan) is really big. It's truly unfortunate that the the country's health services bungled their initial testing and screening ramp up.
- wy3yebdudu 7y agoCalifornia probably has a month tops, nobody is going to accept completely halting their lives for two months let alone anything longer.
- Danieru 7y agoEven the most short sighted of society will recognize a need when their family starts dieing. Trouble that takes two weeks. Sadly many Americans have trouble planning several days ahead.
- scollet 7y agoSimilar to the airlines?
- scruple 7y agoAnd international hotel chains, and... the list grows so quickly, who can possibly keep up?
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoIf you look at the fear --in the supermarkets, in general lack of presence in public-- there are more people taking this seriously than not, with or without an official order.
- H8crilA 7y agoNow I'm waiting for the same thing from the US president and leaders of other "laggard" countries.
- war1025 7y agoI am confused. Here in the midwest all the states that I know of have cancelled school, shut down bars, and made restaurants convert to delivery, curb side pickup, or drive through. Further, we are supposed to avoid groups of more than ten people. Is that not the case on the coasts?
- everybodyknows 7y agoSan Diego County did most of that, and yet somehow casinos were excepted: https://timesofsandiego.com/business/2020/03/18/tribal-leaders-jointly-announce-5-local-casinos-will-close-at-noon-friday/ https://timesofsandiego.com/business/2020/03/18/tribal-leade... National sovereignty, perhaps.
- dmitrygr 7y agoThe difference is you are merely supposed to do it. Here you can be arrested for not doing it. This is a good move. A lot of people are not taking it as seriously as they should
- WalterBright 7y ago> Here you can be arrested for not doing it. What do they do with the arrested people? Stack them up in overcrowded jails?
- snerbles 7y agoDue process went out the window in this state a long time ago.
- ineedasername 7y agoarrested or fined. I imagine the fines would be more prudent than violating social distancing by tossing people in jail together.
- lettergram 7y agoIt's more of a request for individuals, with the order being directed at businesses. There isn't any hard enforcement (at least none stated), and people can still go outside. I think the LA times article is better: https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-03-19/gavin-newsom-california-1-billion-federal-aid-coronavirus https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-03-19/gavin-ne... > The state projects that 25.5 million people in California will be infected with the coronavirus over an eight-week period, Newsom said in a letter sent to President Trump on Wednesday requesting the deployment of the U.S. Navy’s Mercy hospital ship to the Port of Los Angeles through Sept. 1.
- Volker-E 7y agoA bit late, but still so far best move of any US State. Originated myself in Central Europe and every day counts when I see the development in my home country and its neighbors!
- brrrrr1 7y agoYou are safe. Your family and friends are safe. Just save money in case of anything, but statistically speaking YOU will be fine.
- irrational 7y agoThis is fine for people like me that can work from home, no problem. But most of my neighbors are freaking out because they are not getting paid and have no way to pay bills, rent, etc. I can't see how this will not end up as the most major worldwide depression ever.
- all_blue_chucks 7y agoThis will be the fastest economic decline ever (by fiat!) but not the longest. One way or another it will be over in a couple years max. Perhaps much sooner if we develop an effective vaccination, treatment, or tracking program.
- billions 7y agoIt's likely more people will die from economic hardship than the virus
- wbl 7y agoThere is no reason we can't ensure they have food and a house for the duration.
- irrational 7y agoThere is no reason we can't. But we won't. Rather, politicians will almost surely choose not to do anything until it is far too late.
- hkmurakami 7y agoThey literally passed a stimulus bill in the Senate this week with $500B for individuals. It heads to the House now.
- irrational 7y agoI’ve been avoiding the news. How much will each American get? Will it be per individual, or only adults? Will people with children get more? Will it be more for more children? How many months worth of expenses should it cover?
- rootusrootus 7y agoThis works for a while, but we can't realistically expect to just shut the country down for the next year or so. Surely there is some kind of plan to try to actively suppress the virus rather than just reduce the R0 slightly? While Congress throws around a trillion here, trillion there, why not make testing every last American (multiple times, as necessary) priority #1? Then we can get people back to work much sooner, and let the economy start to recover.
- hkmurakami 7y agoThere's a huge international effort to develop a vaccine or a suppressant, etc. The US doesn't have even close to the necessary number of testing kits or infrastructure to test 300 million people. They're working on ramping up production and availability of tests.
- forkexec 7y agoThere is no working vaccine. Multiple candidates will take a year and a half if everything works perfectly. It's possible that a vaccine will not be found.
- auspex 7y agoThey already have a corona virus vaccine for many live stock animals so at least that is promising
- arkitaip 7y agoHistorically, a reasonably safe vaccine has taken many years to develop. Rushing a vaccine through the system so it only takes months? Yeah, I not going to stand in line to get vaccinated.
- James_Henry 7y agoThere are promising treatments though, and these should show results within weeks or months.
- hedora 7y agoI’m more and more worried this is an overreaction, even ignoring the economic impact. Look at the projections on page 19: https://www.imperial.ac.uk/media/imperial-college/medicine/sph/ide/gida-fellowships/Imperial-College-COVID19-NPI-modelling-16-03-2020.pdf https://www.imperial.ac.uk/media/imperial-college/medicine/s... They seem to have picked the green line and not the orange line. Hopefully they’re planning for intermittent social distancing, or have some other medium term plan.
- glofish 7y agothe 25 million just does not seem realistic.
- cycrutchfield 7y agoIt's pretty realistic in an unconstrained spreading scenario. That's exponential growth for you.
- ajross 7y agoThe H1N1 epidemic in 2009 was objectively less contagious and less dangerous than COVID-19. In comparison, it grew mostly uncontained and eventually infected about a billion people. If COVID-19 was allowed to do exactly that we'd be looking at 10M fatalities, and realistically it would infect more people (being more novel than a mere flu). The 25M number doesn't seem realistic because every country that has had a COVID-19 outbreak has freaked out trying to control it, and either succeeded via very expensive means or (in most cases) hasn't had the outbreak grow far enough to know whether or not they've failed.
- wolco 7y agoUsing the billion figure best case is 40 million not accounting for which countries would be hit the hardest which would increase the rate as the systems get overwhelmed.
- stevenwoo 7y agoDo you reject the SIR mathematical model for all infectious disease or the numbers chosen for the constants for covid-19 or some other reason?
- ethank 7y agoCalifornia has the biggest agriculture, port and manufacturing base in the US basically. The county orders contradict the state. OC is letting factories stay open with conditions and LA is saying the port stays open as well as the trains, airports (especially KSBD which is Amazon's home base). What a mess.
- jefftk 7y agoIf the county says "you need to stay home if X" and the state says "you need to stay home if Y" then the effect is "you need to stay home if X OR Y". There's no contradiction.
- ptero 7y agoMore frequently though the effect is that people think "our politicians do not know what are they doing; I will do what I think is reasonable" and do what they want.
- gpm 7y ago"you need to stay home if X OR Y" is the safe bet, but it's not always required, sometimes one thing preempts (invalidates) another. I'm not sure if that happens in this case or not though. Consult a lawyer via telephone if it matters I guess.
- cortesoft 7y agoBecause agriculture and importing are deemed of vital importance and allowed to stay open.
- gamblor956 7y agoLA has also issued its own stay at home "order." During the initial part of the press conference, it was explicitly described as not a lockdown. The statewide order is similar. Strongly recommended that people stay indoors, but outdoor activities are still allowed. In both cases, the orders do not include any potential punishments (to individuals) for violating the order. (There are punishments outlined for businesses.)
- 0xffff2 7y agoIANAL, but violating the county orders in the bay area was widely cited as a being a misdemeanor offense. There were also platitudes from law enforcement about "compassionate enforcement", but the potential for punishment is there.
- asveikau 7y agoIn SF they said it was a misdemeanor, but that being cited for it would be a last resort, that they would seek voluntary compliance before getting to that point.
- devmunchies 7y agoWhere can I read the details? Are restaurants allowed to stay open if they are doing food delivery?
- cortesoft 7y agohttps://covid19.ca.gov/ https://covid19.ca.gov/
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dabei 7y agoFor people with young kids this means no more nannies.
- scotty79 7y agoNo more nannies required or available?
- usaar333 7y agoYou are not allowed to employ a live out nanny unless you are in an essential occupation. (At least that was in the Bay area orders)
- wuunderbar 7y agoWho's enforcing?
- variaga 7y agoDetails and a link to the actual order here: https://covid19.ca.gov https://covid19.ca.gov
- Leary 7y agoPeople look at the thousands of deaths in China and Italy and may think this is an overreaction. What they don't realize is that those figures are the result of tough lockdowns, without which, the death toll would've been easier an order of magnitude greater. California has shown true leadership in this crisis. I hope New York and Washington will soon follow.
- scotty79 7y agoNot sure how anyone can look at hundreds of additional daily deaths and think it's fine and business as usual.
- flunhat 7y agoThe top comment above, for example. I think people are generally terrible at understanding exponential growth & systemic vs. one-off risk.
- therealdrag0 7y agoLooking at the last few days, NY's cases are going up scarily fast. WA seems to have "almost" flattened the curve.
- grnkj43t 7y agoHow about this for a lockdown - we start shooting all the fucking liberals that want to take our freedom from us? It'll solve the problem no?
- ajdfladf 7y agoFUCK THESE LIBERAL FUCKS! GUNS, GOLD, MOTHER FUCKING FREEDOM!
- usaar333 7y agoThis is a great move, but I'm not sure how this will hold up unless the state seals its border. If the entire country doesn't follow suite, is that the next step?
- ajdfladf 7y agoyou fuck you you freedom stealing piece of shit - go back to the motherfucking gulags asshole!!
- yters 7y agoShouldn't the least vulnerable, ie most of the population, go mingle and become immune to protect the vulnerable?
- all_blue_chucks 7y agoIt kills plenty of young people.
- yters 7y agoAny more than the annual flu that no one freaks out about?
- ajdfladf 7y agoohhhh - these fucking liberal fuck asses don't like that talk
- twblalock 7y agoAt some point we do have to consider that shutting down the majority of the economy will ruin more lives than letting the virus infect everyone. Keeping in mind that most young people who get the virus will survive, this is a massive generational sacrifice by the same people who left college around the time of the 2008 crash to protect older people. Anyone who thinks this is only going to last 3 weeks is just not being realistic. Of course nobody wants to callously stand by while older Americans die of the virus. My own parents are at risk. I myself have asthma and I don't really know what my chances would be. However, the worst-case scenario in 20 years is that the older people we saved by sheltering in place will be gone, but the consequences of shutting down the economy will still haunt everyone living. There are long-term trade-offs to consider here, particularly ruining the lives of the young in order to save the old, and I don't think they are being considered properly. In an ideal world we would not need to make choices like this, but the choice is real and we can't fumble it. I feel like a bit of a dick for posting this, but after reflection I do think it's a valid point and we cannot escape the trade-offs I described.
- tempestn 7y agoThere is an alternative: locking down until testing can be significantly ramped up. This wouldn't need to take more than a month or two. The cost to test even everyone in the population on a weekly basis is much, much lower than the cost of being locked down, and once that infrastructure was in place, other measures could be dropped, because we would know and could isolate only those who are infected (symptomatic or not). Edit: I should add that ramping up testing may take longer than that. I'm not an expert; just going by what I've read. Even so though, we should definitely aim to scale up testing as much as possible; the better our testing, the less restrictive and long-lasting isolation measures will need to be.
- enchiridion 7y agoThis is a great idea. The first thing that has given me hope since this set in.
- 7y ago
- downerending 7y agoAt this point, what sort of narcissistic, psychopathic fool needs to be told to stay home unless you really need to make a minimal trip out in order to survive?
- nickysielicki 7y agoMaybe someone who isn’t a software engineer and doesn’t make as much as you, and maybe has a family that depends on their income? You need to check your privilege. Working from home isn’t realistic for most people. For many, the decision is squarely between a paycheck and staying home. You’re pretty out of touch if you would call someone narcissistic or psychopathic for struggling with that.
- downerending 7y agoWhat part of "really need" did you not understand?
- siquick 7y agoBond Beach in Sydney had several thousand people on it last night, pubs and bars are still operating as normal in my area - the only thing thats changed is most corporate people re working from home yet are still meeting with friends. I've had 4 invites to gatherings over the next few days. We here in Sydney are (as usual) sleep walking into a big mess.
- nickysielicki 7y agoOkay, what’s necessary? I think a paycheck is necessary, therefore, if I lived in California, I’d continue to go to work. Tons of governors are issuing meaningless statements like these. Ping me when someone actually imposes martial law.
- skrowl 7y agoIf you don't have an "essential job" like working at a hospital, grocery store, power company, etc. You're allowed to go outside and walk in your neighborhood, but apparently the police will enforce it (probably just at ticket) if you're out for a non-essential reason. They also forcibly closed all gun stores in the state. It's not martial law to the letter, but it's damned close.
- PopeDotNinja 7y agoHere in Spain they'll fine you 100-ish Euros for walking around while the lockdown is in effect. I'd expect something similar in CA. Besides, in CA if you go to work, everyone and their dog will tell at you to go the eff home.
- ab_testing 7y agoI think that California and very soon the whole of US would need to shift to survival of the fittest mode. The US population cannot survive multiple weeks without a paycheck. Any unemployment that is received is just enough to put food on the table but not pay rent. Some statistics on lower wage workers * 152 Million people worked in US in Feb 2020 * 16 Million of those in retail (A huge majority of them would be unemployed ~50%) * 17 Million people worked in Leisure and Hospitality (If bars/restaurants/movie theaters/theme parks/casinos stay closed around 80% of them are unemployed * 3 Million people work in educational services . With schools and colleges closing a majority of them are unemployed. Source of data https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t17.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t17.htm * You can only keep things shutdown until people are either begging on the streets or rioting
- yibg 7y agoI think about this a lot too. China in general has a much higher savings rate. Where as the US has a large proportion of the population that live pay check to pay check. What happens after a month and things are still not contained?
- simlevesque 7y agoThis is why the US is not a good place to live in.
- adfjl23rnz 7y agoLIBERALS: FUCK YOU!! FUCK YOU! You are fucking over our country! FUCK YOU!
- adfjl23rnz 7y agoliberals
- adfjl23rnz 7y agothanks for fucking over the economy you fucking ass liberal fucks!
- implying 7y agoI haven't seen this reported elsewhere: The executive order at https://covid19.ca.gov/img/N-33-20.pdf https://covid19.ca.gov/img/N-33-20.pdf cites Government Law 8665 to enforce itself, which reads: CA Govt Code § 8665 (2017) Any person who violates any of the provisions of this chapter or who refuses or willfully neglects to obey any lawful order or regulation promulgated or issued as provided in this chapter, shall be guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction thereof, shall be punishable by a fine of not to exceed one thousand dollars ($1,000) or by imprisonment for not to exceed six months or by both such fine and imprisonment. Six months of jail time and $1,000 is what they are threatening us with.
- omar_a1 7y agoIn SF at least it isn't really being enforced unless they absolutely have to. Based on the news Tesla has been the biggest offender so far. Plus people can still legally walk around outside, so the most tangible enforcement would come down to ensuring everyone in public is avoiding people they don't live with.
- s1artibartfast 7y agoHow has Tesla been an offender? They were specifically allowed to remain open by the shelter in place order...
- omar_a1 7y agoThey've been defying the order all week, and were specifically told by the sherrif's office that they are non-essential, but continued to run. I think they've only just started to come around, after a visit from the sherrif's office. > Tesla said it would temporarily suspend electric-car production at its Fremont plant after Monday, after days of apparent resistance to a county health order requiring an immediate shutdown.[0] [0]https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/article/Inside-Tesla-s-Fremont-factory-car-production-15143877.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/article/Inside-Tesla-s-...
- 7y ago
- SllX 7y agoPharmacies, Banks, Grocery stores and takeout restaurants will continue to operate.
- s1artibartfast 7y agoThis order is very vague with respect to what critical infrastructure and workers entials. Based on the linked definition, every worker fits into one of the critical business types.
- x__x 7y agoHow is no one talking about ID2020?
- wdr1 7y agoWill we still be able to get food delivery? The order says only those part of CISA define critical infrastructure should show up to work, which doesn't seem to include pizza delivery or short order cooks. https://www.cisa.gov/critical-infrastructure-sectors https://www.cisa.gov/critical-infrastructure-sectors
- btilly 7y agoI have read a number of public health orders relating to COVID and this is by far the worst written. The Bay area one allows people to get out and walk for exercise. This does not. The article doesn't bother linking to the actual order. https://covid19.ca.gov/img/N-33-20.pdf https://covid19.ca.gov/img/N-33-20.pdf has the text of the order. It just said the critical infrastructure sections. The (non-linked) URL for which is https://www.cisa.gov/critical-infrastructure-sectors https://www.cisa.gov/critical-infrastructure-sectors. Which is extremely vague. For example should my local Best Buy remain open because it is part of the Information Technology sector? Or is providing people with headphone adaptors for work at home not critical infrastructure? I have no clue! I hope that they do.
- firefoxd 7y agoIn my Neighborhood, there is street sweeping on Wednesday and Thursday. A couple days ago, the Mayor of LA announced that they won't be giving parking tickets because of the situation. Well, this morning everyone got tickets. It's not that the residents are too lazy to move their cars. This is LA, there is no parking. We only get space if a good chunk of us are at work. Yeah, let's all stay at Home. But let's also not get punished for it.
- grnkj43t 7y agoQuick thinking politicians? Like motherfucking Hitler? Motherfucking Mussolini? Motherfucking Pinochet? FUCK YOU!!! Fuck you and your liberal fucking friends! Jump in front of a fucking bus!
- httpz 7y agoThis may buy some time but we can't be in lockdown forever. Testing infra really needs to ramp up during this time. S.Korea never actually ordered any stay at home order. People are voluntarily avoiding going outside and aggressive testing is paying off.
- romski 7y agoThe case fatality rate of being 80 years old is 5.77%. Each year this many people age 80 die of various ailments. I don’t remember staying home for months praying this number goes down.
- serf 7y agoA 65+ year old family member works in the defense industry as an engineer. They are being asked to continue a commute into Los Angeles, continue a job that doesn't allow for social distancing, and isn't being provided with any protection items, whatsoever. They are told that they are essential, and that they cannot have time off. Let me make this clear : They are a civilian, entirely. I SURE hope that those who do indeed get sick from the poor decisions of their employers will have some path available to them legally to make the irresponsibility righted in some way.
- shoulderfake 7y agoConsidering what's going on in Spain, anything less than police enforced total shutdown will end up being an insufficient response.
- nojvek 7y agoThis is effectively stopping the economy and creates all sorts of rippling effects. US has awful social support and this will hit the working population really hard. The best case I see is we can ramp up testing kits and masks to 100s of millions. Test everyone repeatedly. Track and quarantine rigorously. At the same time give monthly stipends to everyone while “sit in a hole or die” order is going on. Make sure banks don’t foreclose, people still have insurance and jobs (too late for some parts like hotels and restaurants). I can see why people are panicking and buying guns in poor neighborhoods. We’re putting people on survival mode. We first downplayed this for a long time when we had a 2 month head start (Thanks Trump and team) and still feel unprepared for the worst.