17 ms·
The Longest Record Broken: Gold/Silver Ratio Hits Highest in Over 5,000 Years
- lazyjones 7y agoPeculiar situation. Hoarding Gold purely as an investment strategy is largely a psychological phenomenon now, since it has lost most of its value as a currency in harsh times. Or what exactly are you going to buy with your gold coins when all supply chains are broken and most goods can't be produced even at a higher price? Better hoard canned tuna...
- kareemm 7y agoI always wondered about this. Gold is now valuable only as a shared fiction. In hard times I’d much rather have useful things (food, meds, water, fire) than a pile of stuff that is valuable only because others think it is... which could and does change over time. Clearly I’m missing something...?
- TheAdamAndChe 7y agoIt shouldn't be seen as an investment, but as a hedge against inflation IMO. Silver and gold has fixed supplies, unlike fiat currencies.
- aguyfromnb 7y ago>Silver and gold has fixed supplies, unlike fiat currencies. It can be counterfeited or debased. Will you carry around a scale and testing supplies?
- Symmetry 7y agoAnd historically the amount mined somewhat depended on the price so, as with fiat currency, there was at least some feedback mechanism on the price. Though if you discover a new source it can be bad, see the price revolution[1]. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_revolution
- evbpcapfxy 7y agoYou can transfer ownership of gold without moving your gold. Just as you can transfer ownership of a house without moving the house. Paper money began as a claim on an asset stored in a vault.
- londons_explore 7y agoOnly semi-fixed supplies. If gold gets too valuable relative to labour, more mountains in South America will be pulled down to extract the gold. Think of the way hundreds of millions of dollars have been put into bitcoin mining ASICS just because someone saw a return could be pulled out if thin air... Gold mining is pulling a return out of rock when the economic conditions are right.
- NickBusey 7y agoYup. There are plenty of dormant mines here in Colorado because "there is 100 million dollars worth of gold in that mine but it will cost 200 million dollars to extract it". Once the first number changes enough in relation to the second, those mines will start right back up.
- blevin 7y agoA high profile example is the Donlin project in Alaska. They've been spending decades on de-risking and logistics, and once the gold becomes valuable enough to extract it's likely to be one of the largest mines in the world. https://www.novagold.com/properties/donlin_gold/overview/ https://www.novagold.com/properties/donlin_gold/overview/
- lawn 7y agoYour analogy is slightly wrong, as more ASICs won't increase the Bitcoin supply. (Technically it will a little until the network difficulty adjusts.)
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoI seem to recall that when the Spanish conquered Central and (most of) South America, and found and mined huge amounts of gold and silver, it increased the supply of gold by 20%. Sure, mining may increase the supply of gold... a very small amount compared to the existing supply. It's not going to move the needle in terms of supply vs. demand, though.
- GrumpyNl 7y agoI place my bet on my vegetable garden.
- jonhohle 7y agoGold has utility as well: it’s highly conductive, doesn’t oxidize easily, is hypoallergenic, malleable, etc. Napkin math tells me that over 50 tons of gold have been used just in iPhones over the past 13 years. Just like any commodity - if there is demand, there is probably value.
- vermilingua 7y agoAnd to extract any of that utility, you need an industrial economy. People buy gold when they begin to question the longevity of such an economy.
- Symmetry 7y agoBismuth is priced at $.39 per gram, copper at $.0074. I would bet gold would end up somewhere in that range or so as opposed to the $48 per gram it's at now.
- neuronic 7y agoLooking forward to Bismuth necklaces and Bismuth dental crowns.
- Symmetry 7y agoBismuth has low toxicity for a heavy metal but I think I'd recommend skipping the dental crowns. Bismuth makes very pretty dangly bits handing off earring or necklaces though. https://www.google.com/search?q=bismuth+jewelry https://www.google.com/search?q=bismuth+jewelry
- logfromblammo 7y agoGold is valued because it doesn't tarnish. Bismuth, on the other hand, becomes beautiful only with a patina of oxide.
- DubiousPusher 7y agoNo because it's much more rare. All the gold mined in the history of the world could fit into one moderately sized warehouse. 190,000 tons of gold mined in the history of the world vs. 700,000,000 tons of copper.
- jariel 7y ago"Gold is now valued only as a shared fiction." Every Fiat currency is a 'shared fiction'. Currency is a social contract. Then, if we all agree that Gold is a currency, then it has value in that regard, and since it always has been a currency across pretty much all cultures, across all time, it remains a form of rough currency. If 'civilization fell apart' (and it won't) we would still need currency and if anything it would probably be gold.
- peteradio 7y agoGuaranteed lead.
- tsimionescu 7y agoWouldn't cash dollars be a better bet than gold? Harder to counterfeit, easier to carry around, easier to split.
- sfj 7y agoIf no one was printing more of 'em, they'd disintegrate after awhile if heavily used.
- jariel 7y agoFirst, it's worth remembering that the USD was ostensibly backed by gold up until one generation ago, until the Vietnam War. No kidding. There was some amount of Gold reserve to back dollars, that's why 'Fort Knox' exists. So even the USD was 'just a paper you could trade for gold'! Though really, you couldn't, it was a weird theoretically reality. Now (and really even then) USD is only as good as the integrity of the US Gov and the Fed. If they crash, USD won't be worth the paper it's printed on. In addition, mechanically, physical currency takes a lot of effort to keep going, and with nobody doing that, well it goes kaput. Digital currencies rely on various layers of trust: networking, security, legal, financial, regulatory, institutional. If any of those break, we can't use digital currency. Technically, there might be some kind of super cook block-chain that could work without needing the internet, surely, but it's too complicated for regular use as a currency. Maybe for larger transactions between fiefdoms! But gold and other precious metals would probably be used as s currency until institutional trust could be built back up into institutions so that they could have real fiat currencies. If knowledge and responsibility were very strongly maintained at the local level, it's entirely possible for regional economies to maintain their own fiats. This requires exceptional knowledge and fiscal/monetary discipline. If you have a populist, dirtbag leader who can corrupt the integrity of the monetary system, it will destroy everything. This is the source of most hyperinflation scenarios.
- _red 7y ago>Gold is now valuable only as a shared fiction. While this is true, its important to understand that "all value is subjective" the concept of "inherent value" is a fallacy that distorts ones worldview. A glass of water has a different value at the oasis vs the dessert.
- singularity2001 7y ago"all value is subjective" no, water and tuna have measurable and objective value to your biological system.
- whb07 7y agoNot if you live in a rainforest with ample access to water. It’s got very little value, whereas in a desert it’s got high value.
- js2 7y agoPlease edit your comment to remove the last sentence.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoWhy? What's wrong with the last sentence? (Or has it already been removed?)
- js2 7y agoIt previously had an insult as the last sentence. I'm glad it was edited and I'm sorry it's too late for me to delete my request now.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoEh, no worries. You gave good advice, and it sounds like it was heeded. You left me confused, but no big deal - I've been confused a few times before...
- zeckalpha 7y agoAll value of money is a shared fiction. Smith (1776) talked about this.
- hathym 7y agohow are you going to buy your 9999.99$ can of tuna?
- rabidrat 7y agoYou might be able to bribe the ticket taker or border guard with gold, which you can't do with items like food and meds that have lower value-density and less liquidity. IOW it's more useful when human systems and group behavior are the source of the trouble...which is usually.
- tmn 7y agoIt's not an either or. Someone can easily have 50k of gold and 10k of material goods. 60k of material goods may be excessive in volume and use.
- bagacrap 7y agoVikings lived in hard times and found good very useful/valuable as loot
- chewz 7y agoGood luck keeping $1milion in canned tuna.
- gbear605 7y agoGood luck redeeming $1million in gold
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoJust need to corner the wheelbarrow market.
- bagacrap 7y agoname any society ever where you couldn't have traded gold for a fish
- dangerface 7y ago> since it has lost most of its value as a currency in harsh times? Gold isn't a currency its money. A currency is backed by a store of value, money is a store value. Gold is a great store of value because its rare and doesn't expire this is why humans used it as the first form of money thousands of years ago, and it's why people continued to use it up until very recently. > what exactly are you going to buy with your gold coins when all supply chains are broken and most goods can't be produced even at a higher price? Total global economic collapse seems very unlikely, but let's say the US government collapses in that case the US currency Dollars collapses completely, it has no value its just monopoly money. Today in a war zone where supply chains are broken, local currency or dollars are worthless, but gold will still have the same value world wide no matter what, simply because it is the value. Tuna goes off after a year so while valuable its not a good store of value. Gold doesn't go off, it doesn't rust, it has lots of uses in electronics like phones and computer, only a very small percentage of the worlds supply of gold is used for jewellery / decoration.
- thedance 7y agoThis isn't being caused by high gold prices. Gold price was higher last month and still remains far below its 1980 peak. The thing in this article is caused by falling silver prices. Silver is down 50% this week. It's used in industry, as is gold, but the population of deranged gold hoarders is just a lot bigger, so they are propping up the price of gold somewhat. Goldbugs must be used to losing their shirts by now, since gold has been a terrible investment for more than 40 years.
- TheAdamAndChe 7y agoI bought $300 worth of silver last night, and I plan to buy more while I can. The government is injecting a massively gigantic amount of cash into the economy to counter the decreased velocity of money, but within a year and a half or so, the velocity of money will sharply increase, possibly higher than before. That will cause such a high rate of inflation that I'm afraid of what could happen. I bought physical coins because I don't know if the financial institutions will waver, crumple, or at very least become inaccessible for a while. I've stashed some cash too in case there's a run on the banks, but I don't know if they will be worth as much. Basically I'm preparing for a global depression. This sudden shock to the economy is unprecedented in any modern time, and we have no idea what could happen.
- pferdone 7y agoI feel like I'm reading a video of "All Gas No Brakes" haha
- nl 7y agoThat will cause such a high rate of inflation Hey I remember this prediction in 2008/9. Still waiting for that one to happen...
- aguyfromnb 7y agoExactly. The Fed and government have been trying for over a decade to generate some inflation and decrease the value of the dollar. It's proven nigh impossible, because the American economy is, relatively, too strong, and the demand for USD too great. What is going to change that? The US may be printing money, but so is every other country on the planet.
- ctack 7y agoIt's the highest it's been since the 1940s. Sensationalist headline.
- MR4D 7y agoYou didn’t read the article well enough - it blew through that record, but in 1940 it held the record for a year (we’ve only done it for a short period so far).
- ctack 7y agoHow is breaking the 1940 not more accurate?
- MR4D 7y agoYou said “highest since 1940” and called it sensationalist. But it broke the 1940 record, which means the title is correct and not sensationalist.
- jml7c5 7y agoBy emphasizing a past date, the headline (and article itself) gives the impression that the record was set over 5000 years ago, and that this is the first time the gold/silver ratio has been higher than at that point in time. "Since 1940" would provide better context, and would not prompt such confusion. It seems likely that the reference to 5000 years is specifically to sensationalize the news and draw clicks. As an illustration of the absurdity of such a style, one could equivalently put "in over <x> thousand years" in the headline of pretty much any metric that has been on an upward trend through its history.
- 100-xyz 7y agoLooks like a once in a life time opportunity!
- flyGuyOnTheSly 7y agoTo do what exactly?
- bhandziuk 7y agoTo buy a bunch of precious metals which can be exchanged for goods and services! Much like actual money but less conveniently.
- spaceflunky 7y agoFar far less convenient
- MrLeap 7y agoI buy silver rounds every once in a while when the price seems cheap. They're very handy for a few different kinds of transactions. 1. They're handy for showing your appreciation and getting past a common "I don't _want your money_" barrier in my region. If I pass out a bunch of silver rounds to friends with krakens on them while loudly proclaiming "8 ARMED SEA GODS, TO COMMEMORATE THE FACT THAT MANY HANDS MAKE LIGHT WORK" everyone who helped me smiles broadly, laughs and receives them. An aura of gratuity emanates from the situation from everyone involved. If I were to pass out envelopes with a 20$ bill in each, it would make everyone feel weird. Many would get returned, I probably wouldn't have friends anymore. 2. Garage sales ran by older people. I've found a silver coin has, on average, a higher buying power than equivalent cash. For 1oz of silver, a nice gentleman agreed to trade a circular saw, bench grinder parts, an electric motor, lathe parts, a few hammers, a tool box and an angle grinder last year. 3. Gifts for kids. 1 oz silver rounds are not that expensive, shinier than most objects, larger than most people expect, and tend to be received with wide eyed awe every time I've given them as gifts. Silver is fun.
- numpad0 7y agoThe article has charts, and from it the ratio had been 18 times as much silver for gold in weight up until 1875. The article also mentions it was 2.5x in 3100 BCE, 13.33x in 560 BCE, 10.5x in 300 AD and so on. The real change starts 1875 where it starts to rise and vibrate between 20x to 100x, trendline inclined at maybe 20x per century. And yesterday's peak was at 123.78x. Maybe I could say the human population is 5000 years high as well, except dips in population is much shallower than for this.
- gravitas 7y agoA year ago gold was around $1300/oz and silver around $15, both started inflating when the trade tariff war (US/China) kicked off. https://www.kitco.com/LFgif/au0365nys.gif https://www.kitco.com/LFgif/au0365nys.gif https://www.kitco.com/LFgif/ag0365nys.gif https://www.kitco.com/LFgif/ag0365nys.gif
- samdung 7y agoFor years on and on financial advisors tell me not to invest in Gold. And on every '5 year time block' i have seen Gold outperform every other thing of value. The other thing with Gold, is it gives you peace of mind; not having to monitor your portfolio every often.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoIt's always a case of hindsight; in hindsight I should've bought gold in the mid 2000s and sell around 2012. In hindsight I should've bought Apple, Nintendo, Tesla 15 years ago. But it's always a gamble. If you bought silver in 2011-2012, its value would still be below what you paid for it. If it's peace of mind, just put your money in an index fund and forget about it for a few decades. The economy, broadly speaking, usually goes up over a long enough timescale.
- nl 7y agoBut... it hasn't? If you do rolling 5 year blocks over the past 20 years I think right now (as in the last 3 days) is the only time gold out performs the Dow Jones. And even today - on one of the worst days in stock market history - gold only outperforms it by 12% (26% vs 14%). The gold price now is ~$1500/ounce. In March 2015 it was ~1100/ounce[1]. That's 26% increase. In March 2015 the Dow Jones was 18127, and now it is 21237. That's 14% That's not a great record for gold! Your financial advisors are right. [1] https://www.bullionbypost.co.uk/gold-price/10-year-gold-price-chart-usd/ https://www.bullionbypost.co.uk/gold-price/10-year-gold-pric...
- um_ya 7y agoIf an ancient Roman owned gold and traveled in time to today, he would still be a rich man. Can't say the same about any currency or stock. Gold holds value long term.
- nl 7y agoThis really just shows how precious metals (except for gold) have been abandoned as major financial instruments. There's just no demand for them as a trading instrument anymore, but gold is still used.
- morley 7y agoI'm a little confused. Maybe I'm interpreting this news or other commenter reactions incorrectly? They seem to be saying that the price of gold is on the rise, but the price of the gold ETF has gone DOWN in the last few days: https://spdrgoldshares.com/#home https://spdrgoldshares.com/#home And the futures markets are down too: https://www.investing.com/commodities/gold https://www.investing.com/commodities/gold Are other commenters only speculating that the price is going to go way up, and that the price is a good deal right now? If so, that doesn't seem to be supported by financial indicators, and the speculation around it doesn't seem much better than, say, saying that Bitcoin is going to go up in any given environment. I'm surprised to see this discussion on HN. I hope I'm grokking things wrong.
- chewz 7y agoMore like silver going down. YTD -30%. Also flight to liquidity.
- lordnacho 7y agoThis is a graph of the _ratio_ between gold and silver.
- mulle_nat 7y agoMy impression of the gold market is this: The gold bugs always say, that now is the right time to buy. It rarely is though. That's because issuers and supporters of fiat currency have an interest in the gold price not exploding, because it's basically a counter currency. So you see the current divide of reported gold demand and the price being "artificially" depressed. But the gold bugs can't really win, because the fiat currency owners wield infinite power, unless inflation really kicks in at some point. So gold is usually not that great of an investment. That's my perception, I am not at all an expert on these matters.
- sfj 7y agoIt's more due to the rest of the world having to sell everything to pay their dollar denominated debts, because, during this global economic shutdown, they have no USD coming in.
- lordnacho 7y agoHere's my explanation as an ex fund manager: Gold is the Schelling point flight-to-safety, anti-inflation good. Silver has similar qualities, and might as well be the same thing economically, but it isn't. You're more likely to have heard of gold bugs than silver bugs. When it comes to a massive market panic like this, people think about what other people think about. Well, they always do that, but when there's a panic people have certain safe haven assets that everyone "agrees" are more likely to be safe than others. Bonds are another one, though of course there you have historically had massive government intervention, making it a little less unintuitive why people should buy them.
- appleflaxen 7y ago> little less unintuitive a little more intuitive? or you made a typo? (context suggests a typo, but the double negative makes it difficult to understand)
- lordnacho 7y agoYeah good point. What I'm saying is authorities have bought bonds in the past, so there's kinda a reason to think there's someone who will support the price in the future.
- thedudeabides5 7y agoBond's are a great hedge, until they are not. With the policy stimulation starting with printed money to buy domestic assets, and moving rapidly towards printed money to finance fiscal support, it's not clear that bonds everywhere are a good hedge. https://www.tradingview.com/symbols/TVC-IT10Y/ https://www.tradingview.com/symbols/TVC-IT10Y/ Gold on the other hand, has been a decent hedge universally for a couple thousand years.
- short_sells_poo 7y agoGold is a crap hedge for equity selloffs. It's correlation is highly dubious and as in 2008, in this current case as well it actually sold off sharply with the equities. Bonds are very much like gold in this respect, doubly so if you explicitly pick the bonds of a highly indebted country with a shaky economy, in the middle of a potentially massive pandemic - like Italy. Italian bonds as a hedge have been avoided like the plague by anyone with an ounce of insight.
- anonu 7y agoSilver is an industrial metal. Gold has no real industrial application and is mostly a store of value. So the article is comparing apples and oranges...
- tomp 7y agoI was just wondering this. What industrial applications does silver have? Gold is the most malleable and one of the most ductile metal (can be stretched into a single-atom wire, or flattened into a single-atom sheet), it's a great conductor of electricity and almost non-reactive (therefore non-corrosive and non-toxic).
- gravitas 7y agoIn short: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silver#Applications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silver#Applications
- neuronic 7y agoWhat? Gold is used in a lot of electronics.
- DubiousPusher 7y agoIt is but silver has many more applications overall. Silver is driven about 50% by industrial need whereas gold is about 10%
- op03 7y agoAmerica has lost its hive mind
- talkingtab 7y agoI agree with others: everyone has heard of "flight to gold" and no one has heard of "flight to silver" If many inexperienced people panic it would be natural that they buy gold instead of silver or even copper for that matter. This will possibly change, the ratio go down, as people move from "panic flight" to "considered flight" as the crisis deepens and as people become more knowledgeable. And if the price of gold becomes too high for many people. Perhaps the best thing is to avoid anything that has speculative value or irrational value at this time. Gold has some irrational value because fewer people trading it have a full understanding of alternatives etc.
- littlestymaar 7y ago> The gold market seems split at the moment: while the price is falling, meaning there are more sellers than buyers, everything I read on Twitter is that physical gold is nearly unobtainable – many banks and refiners have run out of inventory. Apparently there has been a surge in retail demand for gold coins and bars at the same time as the price has been falling. Remember: if you “own” gold in some portfolio, you don't really own gold, you own an IOU for gold and you have zero guarantee to get your money back if things go bad. And while fiat money is backed by states, there is nobody to back your fiat gold. (The same reasoning applies if you own bitcoin or any crypto on coinbase or any other exchange).
- biolurker1 7y agoNot true several etfs have the exact same gold equivalent. If you mean apocalyptic scenarios then yeah
- bouncycastle 7y agoWould anyone know if low oil/energy prices impact the gold price? With lower energy prices, it's now less expensive to get it out of the ground and refine it. Could that mean more gold flooding the market in the future?
- DubiousPusher 7y agoYes. But currently that effect is being significantly offset by massive demand for gold as a reserve metal.
- gjabbar 7y agoGold is long term cash. Sovereign funds / private wealth purchase gold as a hedge against inflation. Ie their short term cash (actual cash) being worth less tomorrow. It has this characteristic because gold fundamentally has zero yield. When you enter a crisis period or period of deflation. Which we are seeing now. There is a flight to short term cash (USD). Good bugs who hoard gold or draw parallels to Armageddon and huge price increases in gold do not account for the simple fact that gold is long term cash. During the GFC the same liquidation profile was observed for gold.
- dumbfoundded 7y agoIn some ways, gold is the only real money. Governments have been secretly taxing their citizens by forcing them to use the gov't issued currency while printing more of it. Savers lose value in this process to finance short term needs. You can't print gold. Even when gold prices wildly fluctuate, gold production doesn't b/c it's already so hard. In times like now, we're going to print lots of USD in one way or another. Is there a gov't issued currency that's held its price better than gold?
- gjabbar 7y agoMy first job was at a mining startup that found perhaps the best copper/gold discovery in a decade. We were ultimately acquired. It's a reality. Mines take a minimum of ten years from discovery to bring into production. This is without the typical roadblocks of political/environmental/management/technical showstoppers. Gold has long been thought of a long-term store of value for this exact reason. Governments cannot help themselves, particularly democratic ones, from following a path of unfunded austerity. It becomes the power cycle, at some point there is a financial reckoning, and citizens' wealth is destroyed. Then the cycle begins all over again, usually tied to a metal (like gold) before breaking into fiat when the unfunded liabilities exceed the ability of the country to fund them. US dollars are the best among the worst in fiat. That will change, as it always has historically. Gold will remain as a store of value, as it always has.
- kyuudou 7y ago>Gold is long term cash. The assessment I came to was that gold is a store of wealth, not a currency or investment. It's a way of preserving, not creating wealth. It's what could be passed on to your offspring along with land that holds its value, more or less, over generations. It damn sure isn't the FRN. If you held on to one of those from 1920ish, you'd have about maybe 3-4% of its worth in terms of buying power (of staples like eggs, bread etc) Money and currency are for spending to get things of actual value, whatever those things may be. There are apocryphal stories about Jews in WW2 Germany who had all their wealth in gold (as was common back then) who used the malleability of gold to flatten it out in very thin sheets then make thread from that, then sewed the threads into their clothing so that their wealth wouldn't be confiscated when they were fleeing the Nazis. I don't have any citations, though. Cranky old man perspective: https://grandfather-economic-report.com/inflation.htm https://grandfather-economic-report.com/inflation.htm
- aSplash0fDerp 7y agoPrecious metals and gems will still provide value in areas of the world that are not devastated by war or disease. If the dollar goes tits up, I think the criminal accounting will take down gold with it, leaving the next in line metals to reap the rewards of integrity. You cannot trust any of the accounting with gold.
- ponsin 7y agoWhy is it that there is so much advertising for investing in gold? Many of the podcasts that I listen to advertise it, I see ads for it everywhere. I would think that unlike stocks where you must buy through a broker (for a fee), gold can easily be bought by anyone. So what makes the business of helping people invest in gold so popular?
- bradlys 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pump_and_dump https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pump_and_dump - would be my suspicion.
- bob1029 7y agoI cannot imagine investing in these types of assets. For those who speculate on gold & silver, would you also purchase futures contracts on oil, pigs, and grains? It's pretty much the same idea unless you are having gold bars shipped to your home. If your objective is to make money "quickly", I'd recommend averaging any cash you have sitting around into a market-wide ETF ASAP. The trick is to not get emotional. You have to hold every last share through events just like this one. If you don't use leverage or purchase options contracts you can literally forget the stock market exists when monster events are occurring. Assuming you diversified, there's really nothing to worry about under any circumstance. Just keep buying the same market-wide funds on a regular basis. Never sell. Ever. Selling is how you lose the game. All of this fear has created a generational buying opportunity.
- mortehu 7y agoI think most of the ads are for physical gold, for which you can charge any markup you want. It's more like pitching over-the-counter traded penny stocks.
- thedance 7y agoIt's because there are a lot of gold scams and the scammers have decided that the audience for whatever you are listening to are dupes who will buy gold.
- adaisadais 7y agoGold is such an odd form of value. If money, as Felix Martin puts it, is a social technology then gold is an antisocial technology. (1) Gold and silver look great in a recession because they (unlike the buyer) do not panic. However, in the long run they provide virtually no value to society (unless you make some fancy jewelry or cover your toilet seat) and frankly I find owning large amounts of gold to be a silly proposition. If society were to collapse I don’t think anyone would be hoarding gold or silver... unless your Blackbeard or Scrooge McDuck. Edit: forgot to link :/ (1) https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.nytimes.com/2014/04/13/books/review/money-by-felix-martin.amp.html https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.nytimes.com/2014/04/13/book...
- bosie 7y agoi think you forgot the link to felix martin's article?
- klenwell 7y agoIt's actually a book. I happen to be reading it right now (on recommendation of HN users): https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/18050068-money https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/18050068-money Well written and fascinating.
- drtillberg 7y agoFinance is a mountain of complexity piled on an 'IOU Nothing'. Next time you log into Robinhood and pour your IOUs, stop and think if you've ever-- and I mean EVER-- examined precisely what it is you are buying. What makes gold valuable is exactly what used to make dollars valuable. No BS and you'd be nuts to borrow to buy and hold them (because no yield and storage costs money). That means, in boom times they don't bubble (as much) because ppl aren't buying on credit, and in busts, people see both the intrinsic credibility and price action as a sign of strength. Silver is a thin market more easily classified as a commodity somewhere between oil and gold. The oil market is in a very unusual situation. When that dumpster fire dies down look again at the movement in the gold/silver ratio.
- 7y ago
- Ottolay 7y agoSilver is down because it is largely an industrial metal used heavily in many electronic components. Gold is also used in industry (e.g. Gold plated connectors) but less so compared to its use as a value store by governments[1] and private parties. Since the economy is expected to drop, industrial metals are dropping as well. [1] https://www.fiscal.treasury.gov/reports-statements/gold-report/current.html https://www.fiscal.treasury.gov/reports-statements/gold-repo...
- RosanaAnaDana 7y agoThat headline and they don't have a plot going back 5k years? I am disappoint.
- toohotatopic 7y agoCould it be that people who used to buy bitcoins are now buying gold and that they are preventing the price correcting that every other metal is experiencing?
- thedance 7y agoIt's hard to imagine that the kinds of people who bought bitcoins as an investment have anything leftover with which to influence the gold price.
- mrnobody_67 7y agoThis is the best explanation I've ever seen of how the Fed and US Dollar money printing actually works: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iFDe5kUUyT0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iFDe5kUUyT0 Most people also don't realize that the Fed, which buys Treasury's drawn on a bank account with $0 in it, is privately owned - and distributes dividends to its private shareholders holders (who are not disclosed).
- Hello71 7y agothis seems like a fed conspiracy theory video, a la freemen on the land OPCA arguments.
- hosteur 7y agoDo you have any arguments about what is actually being said in the video?
- IAmGraydon 7y agoThe Fed is not privately owned. Directly from the Federal Reserve’s website: Some observers mistakenly consider the Federal Reserve to be a private entity because the Reserve Banks are organized similarly to private corporations. For instance, each of the 12 Reserve Banks operates within its own particular geographic area, or District, of the United States, and each is separately incorporated and has its own board of directors. Commercial banks that are members of the Federal Reserve System hold stock in their District's Reserve Bank. However, owning Reserve Bank stock is quite different from owning stock in a private company. The Reserve Banks are not operated for profit, and ownership of a certain amount of stock is, by law, a condition of membership in the System. In fact, the Reserve Banks are required by law to transfer net earnings to the U.S. Treasury, after providing for all necessary expenses of the Reserve Banks, legally required dividend payments, and maintaining a limited balance in a surplus fund. https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/about_14986.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/about_14986.htm
- radford-neal 7y ago"not operated for profit" and "dividend payments" seem to be contradictory. The question would seem to be how the amount of dividend payments gets set.
- Animats 7y agoNobody uses silver as a store of value any more. It's more of an industrial metal. With not that many industrial uses.
- Empact 7y agoSilver's scarcity is less than gold but its practical portability and exchangeability is a bit greater than gold, because typical units of exchange align with practical amounts of metal (coin-size, rather than gram-size). However, now that a highly-scarce, highly-portable, and highly-divisible Bitcoin is on scene, silver is less useful as a monetary metal because it loses to gold and/or Bitcoin on each of these qualities.
- freepor 7y agoThe value of these metals is largely driven by the same things that drive any consumer fashion, so the gold/silver ratio hitting a new high isn’t any more weird than “hoop earrings hit a 5,000 year high in popularity.”
- mrfusion 7y agoSo why isn’t Silver keeping up?
- marcrosoft 7y agoIf there is on thing you can count on it’s people over reacting. If you hold uncorrelated assets and rebalance them at mechanical levels as people react you’ll have a much smoother ride to the top. Gold and long term treasures play a big role in this type of portfolio. Edit: lookup volatility harvesting
- brentis 7y agoRead all of this thinking of platinum. More valuable than gold and similar utility to silver. Wonder how that ratio looks.
- woodandsteel 7y agoPeople accumulate gold as a hedge against society collapsing sometime in the future. But if society collapsed, then gangs of young men with guns would hunt down all the people with stores of gold, and take it away, and shoot them while they were at it. Seems like you would be safer if you didn't have a bunch of gold.
- ggm 7y agoBoth gold and silver have industrial applications. They don't inform the price, and I doubt they inform the price ratio. Silver and Gold have interesting properties. I hope pricing and hoarding don't reflect behaviours which make them harder to "use" rather than be treated as rei-ified value for hoarding. That said, the tiny size of the gold mountain amuses me. All that digging, so little outcome.
- raincom 7y agoGoldbugs have been waiting for this kind of panic for a long time, because these bugs think that non-goldbugs will increase the demand for physical gold, paper gold (say, $GLD), miners ($GDX), junior miners ($GDXJ), and penny stock gold miners. Today, $GLD has fallen to $140, a level matching Dec 24, 2019 prices. Last Friday, $GDX and $GDXJ crashed. Then some rebound, now crashed again. Anyone with some semblance of how monetary economics works won't go gold full: maybe, 10 percent. Goldbugs dream that one day every economy will be based on Gold; that train left long time ago. These bugs are busy recruiting new 'fools' on various forums. It is like people hoarding bitcoin, eth, etc, who are waiting for the next btc bull run: imagine all those suckers who hoarded tulips after tulipmania!
- mirimir 7y agoSure, but all that paper gold isn't really gold. From TFA: > The gold market seems split at the moment: while the price is falling, meaning there are more sellers than buyers, everything I read on Twitter is that physical gold is nearly unobtainable – many banks and refiners have run out of inventory. Apparently there has been a surge in retail demand for gold coins and bars at the same time as the price has been falling. It seems that the “paper” market, the futures and ETFs, is determining the price and does not reflect the heightened demand on the street for hard metal during this time of insecurity. So the price of physical gold is much higher, for anyone who wants it, anyway.
- raincom 7y agoPaper gold, like $GLD and $IAU, is safer than hoarding physical gold, since many vaults can't be trusted. They are scams at many levels: coin purchases, physical vaults, fraudulent miners (remember Bre-X). If one wants to buy 2 lbs of gold jewelry, or even wear a 'gold shirt' every day, that's fine. One such gold shirt guy, Datta Phuge, in India got beaten to death. Another gold man in Hyderabad, who wears 2.5 lbs gold all the time, need four buddies around whenever he goes out. Or go the wild west way: buy guns, live in a bunker.
- mirimir 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dnprock 7y agoI have a different theory for the silver drop. The gold value has not gone up significantly. So this ratio drop is caused by a drop in the silver price. People are fleeing to cash now. They still value gold and keep it. But the impact on silver demand this time is Bitcoin. It appears to be even better than gold. Why settle for silver when you can buy Bitcoin? Bitcoin may be replacing silver on its rise to catch up to gold.
- bashwizard 7y agoAh goldbugs and silverbugs. I've heard them talk about the economic meltdown for over 20 years now and how I should hoard physical gold and silver and how it will turn me into a MILLIONAIRE! I bought real estate instead post 2008.