9 ms·
I do not consider the largest distributor of proprietary, closed-source spyware (Windows) owning the fastest growing open source package manager to be a good ou
by sneak 7y ago
I do not consider the largest distributor of proprietary, closed-source spyware (Windows) owning the fastest growing open source package manager to be a good outcome, personally.
- Supermancho 7y agoYou aren't the only one. Most users are too young to understand how predatory Microsoft has always been. Can't wait for the "npm won't publish my package because it circumvents something in Windows" or whatever. Give it time.
- bdcravens 7y agoI am old enough (42) to remember those days, but honestly I don't feel that threatened by them. I remember their EEE days, and for a long time I haven't seen much of the same behavior.
- bromuro 7y agoSame here (40). I was with Ballmer singing “developer developer developer”... i think his legacy is not that bad. The company was not ready to grasp the idea of open source at these times, but the principle holds.
- allover 7y agoTbf Microsoft have won back a lot of good faith with developers due to projects like VS Code and TypeScript, even for those of us who remember their past. And we're yet to hear of any negative impact of their Github acquisition (afaik - correct me if wrong).
- judge2020 7y agoBefore someone else comes along and writes a monologue, the biggest downside might be how it handled (didn't break) its contract with ICE[0]. If the acquisition didn't happen, old GitHub might've dropped the contract immediately upon enough employees speaking about it. 0: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21412600 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21412600
- allover 7y agoThat's a fair point - thanks for the reminder :|
- manigandham 7y agoThat's a subjective political opinion of a far-left vocal minority. Not everyone has an issue with ICE (a federal law-enforcement agency that stops criminals and saves lives) nor finds a problem with a company legally providing services to the government.
- Dahoon 7y ago>That's a subjective political opinion of a far-left vocal minority What you are talking about is Right-wing politics, even if they are extremely far to the left of your -and the majority of peoples political view -in the USA. Both parties in the US are on the right. This isn't Reddit where the state of US politics is the default norm when it differs from most of planet earth. Though HN is quickly getting there.
- manigandham 7y agoOpen/loose borders is far left policy everywhere. Most countries are far stricter with borders than the US.
- IAmEveryone 7y agoICE doesn't protect the border, that's United States Customs and Border Protection (CBP). ICE are the goons operating everywhere (i. e. not tied to the border) rounding up "suspected illegal immigrants". Because it isn't exactly hard to find illegal immigrants, and their charter allows them to control people without objective cause, ICE gets to arbitrarily decide whom to harass. It's the real-life version of the perennial fear of civil libertarians that too many criminal laws will just lead to any one of us being arrested whenever it happens to be convenient for whoever is currently in power. It isn't going to end illegal immigration, nor curtail it to any significant degree. It just serves to keep a large segment of the people who see every day in a constant state of fear, unable to (for example) seek protection from crime or exploitation for fear of being deported.
- jbkiv 7y agoAgree, What would you say would have been a better outcome? Google? Facebook? Microsoft has changed quite a lot, and in a good way.
- sneak 7y agoVS Code is also spyware; I am not sure that this argument furthers your intended point. The fact that it is open source and popular is not sufficient on its own. It had to be forked (vscodium) to show basic respect for the user’s privacy and system resources.
- allover 7y agoIt's true insofar as VS Code is widely loved by web developers. So it "furthers my intended point".
- charrondev 7y agoNo fork is required. If you build before from the source in its main repo, there is no tracking included by default. It’s builds released by Microsoft that have all of their specific stuff added in.
- chrisoverzero 7y agoVSCodium say they’re not a fork. > This is not a fork. This is a repository of scripts to automatically build Microsoft's `vscode` repository into freely-licensed binaries with a community-driven default configuration.
- Hawxy 7y ago> VS Code is also spyware This is such an extreme & pretentious viewpoint. Microsoft knowing that I have VS Code installed & getting a report when it crashes is not in mine, or really any normal developer's threat landscape.
- snypox 7y agoDon’t forget you’re on HN.
- mbesto 7y ago> Tbf Microsoft have won back a lot of good faith with developers due to projects like VS Code and TypeScript, even for those of us who remember their past. Those are great until they're not. It's why it's called "bait and switch". > And we're yet to hear of any negative impact of their Github acquisition (afaik - correct me if wrong). ANY?! Heh, do a quick search just on HN and you'll find it pretty quickly.
- michaelmior 7y agoI did search, didn't find it quickly. Could you share some sources of the negative impact? (I'm legitimately curious as my use of GitHub hasn't led me to notice any change.)
- mbesto 7y agoI found two pretty damn quickly. They're 3 of the top 5 most upvoted comments on the announcement thread... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17221640 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17221640 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17221656 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17221656 > I'm legitimately curious as my use of GitHub hasn't led me to notice any change Nor I. That's not that point. For the record, I think Microsoft has done wonderfully for the dev community in the last 10 years. I don't see any reason that they are going to "f it up", but big businesses get desperate when environments change and profits get impacted (look no further than what Oracle is doing). Microsoft is not immune to that.
- ptato 7y agoI believe he was asking for specific evidence of negative impact, not people worried it might have a negative impact.
- IAmEveryone 7y agoThe complaints are "I think it really impacts the neutrality of github" and "I hope they don't discontinue Atom or apply their UX styling to the site/desktop app", respectively. Those don't strike me as particularly specific and/or nightmarish.
- golergka 7y agoAnd pulling a package from a custom url is what, one line of code in this package documentation? And the moment it happens, this package will be on top of HN? I understand the concern about MS business practices, but I don't think it applies to environment where transactions (as in, importing someone's package or submitting a pull request to it) don't involve any contracts or money.
- rafaelvasco 7y agoIt may appear blaming Ms forever for their past actions is a good idea. It's not. Those actions and decisions came from certain people. They're long gone. I look only to the present. MS decisions and actions these past few years have been pretty solid imo. We must always assume the best of everything, not the worst. Not matter what. It may appear naive, but it's the only sane way.
- Aeolun 7y agoMS’s decisions outside of everything to do with windows 10 anyhow.
- yarrel 7y agoThey've created a funnel from a jobs site they control, through an operating system and hardware they control, with development tools they control, and source (etc.) on a web platform they control, onto a cloud they control. Assume the best all you like. Microsoft are spying on you and can lock you out of their ecosystem for any reason. When that ecosystem includes critical public infrastructure, there is a problem. The only "sane" response to this is to smile at the MS employees who tell you how much they love Open Source and to use absolutely any other platform.
- bdcravens 7y agoThen you must not like React or Angular, since the owners of those projects are the largest spyware and aggregators of personal data in the history of humanity.
- sneak 7y agoSoftware and services are not the same thing. For some examples: RMS being a douchebag has nothing to do with the usefulness of gdb, nor can that circumstance affect the utility in any imaginable scenario. Microsoft setting censorship policies (aka ToS) on a website they own and control directly affects the utility of npm/yarn/clients. Their website, their rules.
- filoleg 7y agoWell, this comparison seems to be close enough. What about VSCode and Github itself?
- sneak 7y agoThe time for GitHub is over. I have moved all of my repositories away from there that do not depend on GitHub-only integrated services, and am migrating my DNS and domains/hosting off of those integrated services this week. You should too. If you work there, you should quit. https://sneak.berlin/20200307/the-case-against-microsoft-and-github/ https://sneak.berlin/20200307/the-case-against-microsoft-and... VS Code has had to fork to remove the unethical spyware portions within it placed there by Microsoft: https://github.com/VSCodium/vscodium https://github.com/VSCodium/vscodium
- filoleg 7y agoGood for you. However, the general sentiment doesn't seem to behave the same way. I haven't noticed a mass Github exodus at all, aside from some people on the internet being vocal about it for the first month after the Github acquisition. Same with VSCode. I realize this is just pure anecdata and not a legitimately researched observation, but I don't know a single dev in real life who either switched away from Github or VSCode due to those concerns, despite having a wide variety of dev friends from all kinds of backgrounds, including big tech devs, non-tech company devs, fully remote devs, self-taught devs, small startup devs, outside of the US devs, freelancer devs, etc.
- K0nserv 7y agoIt depends on what the alternative is. When NPM starts running out of money to run the service what would happen? More VC, but only to a point and the firms would be increasingly be influencing NPM to make money by any means(probably not good for anyone but the firms). Alternatively a cash strapped NPM fails to invest in security and availability of the service leading to widespread outages or worse a large scale supply chain attack facilitated via the registry.
- mulmen 7y agoThis is sad to read. Why does every project have to be profitable? If NPM is useful users (companies and people) can invest time or cash to support the operations and continued development. This foundation model has been successful across open source and prevents one company from changing the direction of a project to fit their own needs at the expense of everyone else. I think this was critical to the continued growth of open source software over the last two decades. If this trend of selling out to massive corporations continues it will be a major step backwards.
- K0nserv 7y agoTo be clear that's not what I am arguing here, I agree that package registries should, ideally, be owned and supported by the community. However NPM already had fairly significnat VC investment and as such any transition to a community supported model would be challenging. The acquisition can be a good outcome for the current situation without it being the ideal state of things.
- nine_k 7y agoProfitable of not, they should not run out of money. Would yo prefer npm infrastructure to be maintained and developed by the lowest-paid programmers they could hire?
- teknopaul 7y agoImhi Npm is two things a cli tool, and a central repo that tries to be the one and only js repo: to make money from that position. Their infra costs them money only because that was their angle for selling out. Linux repos take the alternative approach to try to get as many mirrors as possible so it can remain free. Microsoft did not buy npm to help it become free. Believe. They bought it because they rekon they can make buck out of it. That buck comes from somewhere. Nodejs going to the Linux foundation was good news. Microsoft buying Npm is bad news.
- ahupp 7y agoWhat's the specific outcome you're concerned about?
- sneak 7y agoEnriching Microsoft and improving their position in the market as a byproduct of publishing and using open source code that has nothing to do with them.
- ahupp 7y agoHow is open source software harmed by Microsoft being successful promoting open source software? This feels like cutting off your nose to spite your face.
- sneak 7y agoThe danger is not to open source in particular; it is to the world in general, which includes open source developers, as well as all other people. Microsoft and their allies make the world a lot worse for a lot of people. They’re the number one distributor of spyware in the world!
- ajay_sibri04 7y agoMuch better than google owning it