10 ms·
Man who stockpiled hand sanitizer donates it all ahead of investigation
- H8crilA 7y agoTotally different scale, but this reminds me of Jesse Livermore, possibly the best speculator of all times. > Following the end of World War I, Livermore secretly cornered the market in cotton. It was only interception by President Woodrow Wilson, prompted by a call from the United States Secretary of Agriculture, who asked him to the White House for a discussion that stopped his move. He agreed to sell back the cotton at break-even, thus preventing a troublesome rise in the price of cotton. When asked why he had cornered the cotton market, Livermore replied, "To see if I could, Mr. President." A true hacker of the markets. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jesse_Lauriston_Livermore https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jesse_Lauriston_Livermore
- toomuchtodo 7y agoIn the same vein, Vince Kosuga cornering the onion market in 1955. https://www.npr.org/2015/10/22/450769853/the-great-onion-corner-and-the-futures-market https://www.npr.org/2015/10/22/450769853/the-great-onion-cor...
- defen 7y agoWhile we're on the topic of weird agricultural laws, from 1949-2015 we had a strategic raisin reserve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Raisin_Reserve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Raisin_Reserve
- H8crilA 7y agoYep, that's a great story too. It's so ridiculous that this is still in force: > The Onion Futures Act is a United States law banning the trading of futures contracts on onions as well as "motion picture box office receipts". > In 1955, two onion traders, Sam Siegel and Vincent Kosuga, cornered the onion futures market on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange. The resulting regulatory actions led to the passing of the act on August 28, 1958. As of January 2020, it remains in effect. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onion_Futures_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onion_Futures_Act > The president of the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, E.B. Harris, lobbied hard against the bill. Harris described it as "Burning down the barn to find a suspected rat". The measure was passed, however, and President Dwight D. Eisenhower signed the bill in August 1958. Thus, onions were excluded from the definition of "commodity" in the Commodity Exchange Act.
- Lazare 7y agoThis is touched on in the Wikipedia article, but it's interesting that the onion market is well known for being significantly more volatile (and thus, bad for farmers) than other normal markets for vegetables. It is a literally textbook example in why banning derivatives is unlikely to be the easy fix some imagine for market failures.
- eru 7y agoAnd gives you a hint for why banning 'price gouging' doesn't help either. (Despite the overall strong sentiment in favour of such silly laws in the discussion on this article. Economics can be a bit counter-intuitive for humans.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Lazare 7y agoAgreed 100%. Also, here's an interesting story: https://www.ft.com/content/6a09e4a6-655a-11ea-b3f3-fe4680ea68b5 https://www.ft.com/content/6a09e4a6-655a-11ea-b3f3-fe4680ea6... > French industrials group Air Liquide is selling its Schülke unit, whose products range from the alcohol-based hand rubs that have become a hot commodity since the outbreak started, to hospital disinfectants and industrial cleaning products. > > It is asking would-be buyers to offer a higher sum than it first envisaged when the sale process began last year, according to people familiar with the situation, reflecting what one person called the “coronavirus effect”. Of course, the reason the business might be worth more is because it's going to make higher profits. In theory Air Liquide could cut prices to ensure its profits stayed the same. In fact, not doing so means they're profiting off Covid-19, right? Which I guess suggests the real problem with what this guy did is scale; he only had a few thousand bottles. If he'd only realised he should have been buying a factory!
- eru 7y agoOr building one!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- MrFoof 7y agoThe classic one often talked about in business schools is Robert Taylor buying up all liquid soap pump capacity in the US when he launched, "Softsoap" to head off other companies muscling him off the shelves through superior marketing and contracts with retailers. http://www.todayifoundout.com/index.php/2019/06/time-guy-cornered-liquid-soap-market-buying-literally-piece-inventory-available-u-s/ http://www.todayifoundout.com/index.php/2019/06/time-guy-cor... Basically had the market to himself for a year.
- pengaru 7y agoWell that was an interesting little rabbit hole with a grim end, thanks for sharing. "His son, Jesse Livermore Jr., committed suicide in 1975. His grandson also killed himself."
- H8crilA 7y agoSurvival > happiness > money. You can argue about the order of the first two. Remember about this and don't leave your home, people!
- myalphabet 7y agoIt isn't all grim! His granddaughter is successful porn star Brandi Love.
- nemo44x 7y agoApple did this with tiny rotating hard drives before they announced the first iPod. The essentially bought the next 1.5 years worth. This helped the iPod from having serious competition while they ramped marketing.
- webninja 7y agoAlso, “In 1955, Onion Futures accounted for 20% of trades in the futures market. In the fall of 1955, Siegel and Kosuga bought enough onions and onion futures so that they controlled 98 percent of the available onions in Chicago.[4] Millions of pounds (thousands of tonnes) of onions were shipped to Chicago to cover their purchases. By late 1955, they had stored 30,000,000 pounds (14,000 t) of onions in Chicago.[5] They soon changed course and convinced onion growers to begin purchasing their inventory by threatening to flood the market with onions if they did not.” ~Onion Futures Act on Wikipedia: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onion_Futures_Act https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onion_Futures_Act
- groby_b 7y agoIf by "true hacker" you mean utter disregard for anybody else's livelihood, sure. He doesn't so much look like somebody worthy of admiration, and more so of pity.
- wolco 7y agoThe system doesn't come with your morality and doesn't operate to provide livelihood to the greatest number of people. Pity the man who was able to show the unequalness the market may bring if you must. But many of the changes in laws can be attributed to holes in the system that were exposed.
- groby_b 7y ago"The system" is what we choose to build. It isn't some unchangeable fundamental part of nature. We choose if it does, or doesn't have morality. It's depressing so few choose morality, and then hide behind "it's the system". It's a choice. I wish people would own that choice, if they chose a system without morality, without consideration for their fellow humans. And yes, I do pity him. His life is sad, and empty, and his final note is heartbreaking. "My dear Nina: Can't help it. Things have been bad with me. I am tired of fighting. Can't carry on any longer. This is the only way out. I am unworthy of your love. I am a failure. I am truly sorry, but this is the only way out for me. Love Laurie"
- cercatrova 7y agoNot necessarily. Systems can become amoral even if actors in the system are moral. Consider corporations. Their fitness function so to speak is to amass capital, as much as possible in fact. Even if everyone inside were moral, they are tended towards actions that increase capital, while not necessarily having all the responsibility of the decision, and so their morality does not come into play, because they don't know the true extent of their decisions. Responsibility throughout the organization therefore diffuses. It is like an ant colony, where each individual performs actions whose combined effects give the entire system some sense of individuality separate from its components.
- 7y ago
- joe_the_user 7y agoProfiteers should face hard prison time.
- H8crilA 7y agoI hope you hold zero stocks and zero bonds.
- grogenaut 7y agoYou don't put a share of stock on your face to go treat a patient. You don't clean up from touching packages or other things with a share of stock. They're not the same thing. I don't even know what point you're trying to make or what you're trying to get out of it. I know we're all bored and stir crazy but maybe now isn't the time.
- H8crilA 7y agoThe use of the word "profiteers". It either assumes wrongdoing, in which case we can talk about ethics or law separate from the profit, or just making profit in general, in which case see my comment on stocks and bonds. Being successful in securities markets largely depends on exploiting other people's mistakes (which create mispricings).
- salawat 7y agoThere's a difference between making a reasonable profit, and an unconscionable one. The latter is what the poster seems to be referring to.
- otterley 7y agoMaking a profit is not the same as profiteering. The relevant statutes define what the latter is.
- ModernMech 7y agoWhat about something like charging $500 per month for insulin?
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoGlad this is getting widespread attention. Buying up all of the Monopoly: Millennial Edition board games in the state to flip on eBay for profit is one thing but buying up goods that you know will cause a panic is something else altogether. Hopefully this dissuades others going forward.
- amiga_500 7y agoHow about buying up housing stock in popular inner city areas only to "provide" housing for people? Housing is an essential good. Profiting off an essential isn't so great suddenly. Yes people need to rent, but many would buy if prices weren't pushed up. Are they or the hand sanitizer guy assisting the market in any way here? Or are they parasitic? People are going to be asking a lot about unfettered capitalism after this. We are going to see many ugly examples in America before this is done.
- egdod 7y agoHousing, food, water, Internet access, cell phones... all more or less essential goods in the modern world. How dare anyone expect to be paid for them?
- TomMckenny 7y agoFood, water distribution, internet, building construction are all things people produce and must be paid for to exist and out of fairness. Land ownership is and always has been an arbitrary claim inevitably traceable to a murdered Indian or the equivalent on other continents.
- kristopolous 7y agoI've been looking for people to make the connection of how this is a great example of the emotional behavioral reality of actually exercising classical economic models and how people aren't just completely atomized rational agents devoid of collective cultural expectation, but you're the first to make the connection. It's a clear narrative for people who are looking for it who are deeply suspicious of how real world humans interact in alignment with the hypothesis of the traditional mathematical models, but to those who don't share the suspicion, you'd have to spell it out. I've had to, it's been painful. People have been penalized for thinking in sociological terms about economic culture all throughout school, because such considerations lead to dramatically conflicting answers. For instance, the more extreme example is private property markets require buy-in from the participants. If a group decides the rules are simply unfair, the game is called off. As a producer of physical assets I've always been keenly aware of theft and sabotage possibilities and prices are kept fair to keep people from doing such things.
- Trias11 7y agoAkin dropping bags of cocaine in ocean when customs ship approaches the drug trafficer's boat. Won't help!
- seemslegit 7y agoOut of pure curiosity, why won't it ?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- guerrilla 7y agobecause they'll prosecute him anyway since he was price gouging?
- seemslegit 7y agoI thought the OP was saying that the cocaine example won't help the trafickers
- NikkiA 7y agoYeah, and it doesn't, except now they have two crimes, trafficking and destruction of evidence.
- seemslegit 7y agoWell if they do drop them before the custom ship arrives, what's the evidence for the destruction of evidence, and the trafficking for that matter ?
- hectorlorenzo 7y agoSome really weird behaving fishes.
- deleted 7y ago
- djsumdog 7y agoThe original article in the Post ended hysterically with him not wanting to be known for this. It's a pretty shitty thing to do and I'm glad the state's Attorney General started investigating him. I was not aware they were price gouging laws in some states for medical supplies during an emergency.
- ceejayoz 7y ago> “But I’m not looking to be in a situation where I make the front page of the news for being that guy who hoarded 20,000 bottles of sanitizer that I’m selling for 20 times what they cost me.” Oops. I'd love a follow-up. "What, exactly, did you think talking to a reporter would result in?
- nate_meurer 7y agoCute. Apparently he caused a bit of upset. He's is justifying himself with a mix of contrition and claims of innocence. > Colvin apologized for purchasing all of the products Sunday, saying that he did not realize the spread of the coronavirus outbreak or the shortage of sanitary products across the country. > ... I had no idea that these stores wouldn’t be able to get replenished. Right. I was wondering what law the Tennessee AG could possibly use to stop these guys. The answer is in the AG's press release (sort of): > On Thursday, Tennessee Governor Bill Lee declared a state of emergency prompted by the spread of COVID-19, or coronavirus. The declaration triggers the state’s anti-price gouging law which prohibits vendors from charging too much during a crisis tied to a state of emergency. > Under the law, the Attorney General’s Office can put a stop to price gouging and seek refunds for consumers. The courts may also impose civil penalties against price gougers for every violation. The law applies to all levels of the supply chain from the manufacturer to the distributor to the retailer. https://www.tn.gov/attorneygeneral/news/2020/3/15/pr20-10.html https://www.tn.gov/attorneygeneral/news/2020/3/15/pr20-10.ht...
- tantalor 7y agoI don't think a random guy hoarding bootleg hand sanitizer qualifies as a "retailer" under the law. If anything, normal penalties for operating without a business license should apply.
- surge 7y agoHe's selling things retail, he's a retailer, the fact he doesn't have a license for the retail business adds to the charges.
- ncallaway 7y agoA) It wasn't bootleg hand sanitizer. It was hand sanitizer purchased from retail outlets. B) He wasn't hoarding it. He was explicitly reselling it. "Colvin sold 300 bottles of the hand sanitizer at a markup on Amazon, The Times reported." So the law 100% applies to this situation.
- brown9-2 7y ago
- freeopinion 7y agoThis article is very low on information. The man is accused of price gouging, and was threatened by the Tennessee AG, but the article says he purchased all his stock before a state of emergency was declared and hasn't sold any since the state of emergency was declared. He's an Amazon seller, but it doesn't say at what price he was selling. Selling hand sanitizer during a crisis doesn't seem like gouging unless the price was exorbitant. It may have been exorbitant as his account was suspended. But the article doesn't mention the actual asking price.
- paulgb 7y agoHere's the original article that started it all, which has more information. It quotes the prices as ranging from $8 to $70 per bottle. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/14/technology/coronavirus-purell-wipes-amazon-sellers.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/14/technology/coronavirus-pu...
- learc83 7y agoHe was selling it for different prices, but the highest was $70 for a single bottle from the NYT article.
- guerrilla 7y agoThere's a previous story which got quite famous which you're missing that went into great detail on this: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/14/technology/coronavirus-purell-wipes-amazon-sellers.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/14/technology/coronavirus-pu...
- surge 7y agoSome of the bottles were going for $70. It wasn't a marginal mark up. He also probably bought the entire supply in a store, so he wasn't correcting inefficiency. And the AG too the supply and donated it, not him.
- ipqk 7y ago> “When we did this trip, I had no idea that these stores wouldn’t be able to get replenished.” > “It was never my intention to keep necessary medical supplies out of the hands of people who needed them,” he continued. “That’s not who I am as a person" This doesn't follow a modicum of scrutiny. If he's buying to sell them at a markup, it MUST be because it's not getting replenished. Otherwise, people would just go to the store and buy it at retail price. It's a BS apology and shouldn't be accepted by anyone.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y ago> it MUST be because it's not getting replenished. I don't think that follows. All that needs to happen in order for the him to sell at a markup is that demand continues to outpace supply, it's not necessary that supply stops. So, from that perspective, his argument holds.
- datashow 7y agoHe thought the stores could easily restock, and he would profit from online sale. Possible?
- garmaine 7y agoBecause people wouldn't want to go out, yeah. Possible.
- inferiorhuman 7y agoBecause there was clearly no sort of distribution infrastructure to get hand sanitizer to people without having to go into the stores. Right. NPR's talked about retail arbitrage before and sure there are all sorts of crazy reasons people buy stuff at inflated prices through Amazon and eBay. What's missing though is that typically the sellers are capitalizing on things that are difficult-to-impossible to find elsewhere (e.g. Trader Joe's products, none of which are otherwise available from other vendors or online from TJs) or to capitalize on sale pricing. Neither of those things are true here with the guy hoarding hand sanitizer. Whether or not he donated his stockpile to charity under duress or not he still deserves to be punished.
- seemslegit 7y agoI hope he kept one bottle for his own use.
- koolba 7y agoThis guy is an idiot for drawing attention to himself.
- bilbo0s 7y agoNot necessarily for drawing attention to himself. But you never try a stunt like that with anything the government might reasonably claim to be medical equipment or supplies. You just don't do it. The best outcome you can hope for in a situation like this is the government comes and confiscates all your supply for redistribution. The worst outcome? Ask Shkreli. You're just begging for them to come down on you when you do stuff like this. When you're wanting to price gouge, do it with something the government will never need. Like Monopoly board games.
- eru 7y agoAnd, if memory serves right, they officially got Shkreli for something completely unrelated to his medical 'price gouging'. The same might happen to you, even if you carefully try to stay within the laws: they'll find something else to pin on you.
- throwGuardian 7y agoAll it took to curb his inner price gouging criminal and bring out the philanthropist was a teeny weeny criminal investigation. What a model citizen!
- ISL 7y agoI have been considering the following business thought-experiment: Price Gougers: a company whose goal is explicit in its name. What you need will always be in stock, but it will always be expensive. It is the kind of company that could ensure that, in situations like this, there might be more N95 masks and hand sanitizer in global inventory. Could such a company get enough social buy-in to survive in the face of anti-price-gouging laws that appear with every crisis? If a person/company had stockpiled N95s a year ago, with intent to sell them at a markup in the event of a pandemic, could that entity ever hope to be repaid for its beneficial risk-taking? (I'll also point out that I'm considering donating most of our few household N95s to our nearby medical center, and am angling to get our research laboratory to do the same. This thought-experiment arises from the fact that investors won't deploy capital to do this kind of thing at scale unless they expect to see a return.)
- myself248 7y agoI sort of love this idea. It'd be the perfect test of some free-market ideals. Similarly, sometimes the government buys product above the lowest market price, because it's produced domestically and it's strategic to prop up the production in case of an event like this. They failed in this case, sadly.
- ISL 7y agoPerhaps pre-designated "price-gouging" companies could be allowed to price-gouge (and might be forbidden to buy up remaining traditional supply once an impending disaster is apparent?), but the person on the street could not? It just seems like there should be some middle ground between, "Price-gouging should be banned!", and "My kingdom for an N95 mask!".
- eru 7y agoWhat's the point? Just allow people to pay the prices they want to pay and sell at. Why add more special licences to exclude the person on the street?
- learn_more 7y ago
- briandear 7y ago> However, Colvin and his brother bought the products before Gov. Bill Lee (R) declared a state of emergency on March 12, which put the price gauging law into place. Colvin also did not sell anything after the state of emergency was declared, the Times reported. Then he didn’t engage in price gouging.
- briandear 7y agoObligatory defense of “gouging”: https://mises.org/wire/3-good-things-about-price-gouging https://mises.org/wire/3-good-things-about-price-gouging
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tuna-piano 7y agoLike any crime or bad ethical activity, let's think about who was hurt and who benefited by his action of buying sanitizer from an area with it and selling it to an area without it. 1. Consumers of sanitizer in his area were harmed (and those people were willing to spend at least $2 per bottle) 2. Consumers of sanitizer in other areas who purchased online benefited (and those people were willing to spend $20+ per bottle) 3. He also benefited financially Why is it a bad thing to take away the option to purchase sanitizer from someone in his area (presumably from people who don't want it as much - as they had the option to purchase but hadn't yet) and sell it to people who want it (and don't have the option to purchase it)? I don't understand why the people in his area deserve the sanitizer more than people in another area - or certainly why that should be a crime. He wasn't dumping the sanitizer into a fire- he was providing the sanitizer to people who really wanted it!
- salawat 7y agoThe goal of the supply chain right now is to get supplies staged in geographical regions so that anyone can have access cheaply. These acts of arbitrage aren't solving market inefficiencies. They're cutting holes in the preventative fabric so to speak. While clearly there are different levels of risk tolerance within the audience of HN and amongst people at large, this was clearly something that struck very few as behavior to be encouraged in any form.
- pensatoio 7y agoIt wasn’t immoral. It just makes people feel bad. I have a huge problem with government controlling prices at any level. Yes, even healthcare.
- krick 7y agoSure there are some important details missed in the story, but I really don't like how fuzzy the line is. It's not like you usually buy the stuff from the manufacturer, the whole world of trading is built on the ability to buy cheap and to sell under the conditions where the price can be (always somewhat artificially) made higher. It's what the resellers do, it's the "free market". Yet when a man manages to predict that the demand (and hence the price) of hand sanitizer will rise during the time of pandemic and to "stockpile" some measly 17 700 bottles of it — he can be prosecuted for that. And I mean, seriously, 17 700 bottles is peanuts, it's not like he was short selling US$10 billion worth of pounds sterling during the time of financial collapse (which he majorly contributed to).
- alexobenauer 7y agoWhole areas were without necessary products directly because of his actions. No, he didn’t mess up an entire industry, but for the areas he hit, we were without sanitizing products much sooner.
- eru 7y ago> [...] the whole world of trading is built on the ability to buy cheap and to sell under the conditions where the price can be (always somewhat artificially) made higher. Not sure what you mean by 'always somewhat artificially'? Eg retail trading of the kind that Amazon or Walmart do doesn't strike me as particularly artificial: of course, there's going to be a price difference between what the factory gets and what customers pay? Same for commodities trading. Or even stocks: if Warren Buffett puts in lots of smarts to find undervalued companies and buys them, the rest of the world catching up some time later seems perfectly sensible. Of course, there might be _some_ instances where the price goes up 'somewhat artificially' perhaps? But I am not sure what that would even mean? My contention here is with the 'always'.
- anigbrowl 7y agoThat's great for elective consumption, but when there's a public health crisis it puts lives at risk. Cornering the market on candy bars or novelty items, make a million bucks, that's great and has my blessing. Trying to do it during a disease outbreak makes someone a PoS.
- aaron695 7y agoStop the lynching, it's boring and pretty evil. That is what Reddit is for. Why not ask the real question, sanitizer is vial, it's soap and a tap you can carry around in your pocket. It's just alcohol and a jell AND a plastic bottle. How can we as a society not be able to produce this, People will even pay for it, they will even pay extra for it. We have failed. Stop blaming individuals. Nothing about C19 was unpredictable.
- mynameishere 7y agoIsopropyl is one of the simplest chemicals in the universe and a big bottle is 1.88 at Walmart. They will never, ever run out of this stuff, even if people start hosing off their cars with it. The whole thing is a joke. This guy was exploiting idiots and the irredeemably lazy. Big deal. But what a fool for him to talk to the media. Maybe he thought he'd get sympathy for losing money because Amazon shut him down...?
- ceejayoz 7y agoWe, as a society, are entirely able to produce this stuff. It's just not instantaneous to do so, nor to ship it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Medicalidiot 7y agoI'm shocked at how this forum has changed its mind on COVID-19 in the past week. This makes me happy that y'all are taking this more seriously.
- H8crilA 7y agoAnd also, that the bottom in stocks may be near.
- petilon 7y agoWhat about price gouging by drug manufacturers? When will the government investigate that? Why is one type of price gouging accepted as capitalism and another type not? "In 2001, Acthar sold for about $40 a vial. Today: more than $40,000. An increase of 100,000 percent." https://www.cbsnews.com/news/the-problem-with-prescription-drug-prices/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/the-problem-with-prescription-d...
- wruza 7y agoNah, that’s only thousands of children a year, pretty much different situation, and also you have one small guy to punch instead of a faceless pharma lobby. /s
- Pfhreak 7y agoWhataboutism doesn't really help. Yes, there are systemic issues with our healthcare system. What this guy did was also wrong. We can choose to address both. We can choose to be upset with both.
- eru 7y ago> Why is one type of price gouging accepted as capitalism and another type not? 'Price gouging' is not an accepted part of capitalism. Those laws (and customs..) that call out some prices as 'gouging' are bad economics and not 'proper capitalism' either way. But you are right, that the drug prices are an even more egregious example. And, of course, we get those weird prices because of heavy and incompetent government interference in the drug markets. So we should probably look into scaling back that interference, instead of adding even more. (And I specifically mention incompetent interference. To give a counter-example, for the most part I am quite happy with the economic policies of my local government. But then, I live in Singapore, where our Prime Minister was the top math graduate of his year in Cambridge, writes C++ sudoku solvers for fun and is looking forward to learning Haskell when he retires.)
- _tulpa 7y ago> 'proper capitalism' Price-gouging is absolutely acceptable capitalism, we only call it 'gouging' because being a greedy asshole doesn't align too well with the moral compasses of most of society. Which is why government 'interference' is a thing in the first place, because otherwise capitalism doesn't give a shit about morals or correctness or acceptableness or anything that isn't capital. It there's any interference it's so much more likely that it's corporate money interfering with the government.
- chairmanwow1 7y agoPeople speak like this is a vital drug that cures people. What is wrong with hand soap and warm water?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoYou can't stick it in your pocket, purse or car for use in situations where a sink isn't available.
- pg_bot 7y agoOne man's gouging is another man's market at work. Would your opinion of this man change if he had stockpiled hand sanitizer a year ago?
- abiogenesis 7y agoIt's not the same thing as stockpiling a year ago wouldn't have caused a shortage.
- pg_bot 7y agoSo why is the crime the same for both people? Also, if he didn't plan on selling the sanitizer then we wouldn't have any (legal) problem with his actions. You can buy all you want with no consequence.
- MperorM 7y agoWell the (in my opinion flawed) idea is to remove the incentive for buying that much in the first place. Say what you want, but someone receiving this enormous an amount of social shaming on top of a painful economic loss, sure is going to disincentivise people from pulling similar stunts in the future.
- salawat 7y agoIf he'd stockpiled a year ago, it wouldn't have been in a state of emergency for one. If he still gouged after the declaration of a state of emergency though, he'd still be liable for breaking the law. It is not that hard to be a responsible member of society and to not jeopardize the well being of widespread geographical areas in the hopes of profiting off a crisis.
- forkexec 7y agoMens rea They should still throw the book at him for trying to profiteer off the misery of others.
- KKKKkkkk1 7y agoLet's say you're desperate for sanitizer because you're caring for an elderly relative. And let's say that sanitizer is available on Amazon for $100/bottle. Would you buy or rather go without?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI'd prefer to live in a world where we don't have to face such moral dilemmas. A lot of people caring for babies are financially stressed as is. Simply having children in the US helps push a lot of people into poverty. We do a lot of things very badly in this country and one of those is we do not have family-friendly policies. For some people, a hundred dollars is quite a lot of money. It can mean not eating and similar hardships.
- gbronner 7y agoWonder what value he can attribute to it. Possible that the tax write off exceeds his cost
- m00x 7y agoTo the commenters here: It's price gouging and not price gauging. The article made a spelling error.
- wruza 7y agoMay I ask what exactly that sanitizer is and how is it different from soap and/or alcohol, which is abundant in any house? Everyone here comments about it as if it was a bottled water or an irreplaceable first aid medicine.
- eru 7y agoApropos: bottled water is also easy to make and replace. Just take a bottle and a water tap. You can refill empty bottles, too.
- objectivetruth 7y agoNo, people stockpile bottled water in emergencies with the assumption that it will NOT be easy to replace, i.e., the tap might stop releasing water. I've seen way too many comments like "Why would you need bottled water in a pandemic?" with the assumption that municipal water systems won't fail. My (US) small town's municipal water system fails a couple of times a year in the best of circumstances, usually just resulting in a "boil order" for a few hours until repairs are made. But imagine half of our six water filtration workers are home sick or caretaking family, or the trucks that bring the spare parts are sitting idle at a depot four states away. Now our town needs 4000 gallons a day just for human survival. To finish the thought experiment, note that there are over 150,000 water distribution systems in the United States.
- eru 7y agoTrue. Though to put this particular crisis into perspective: neither water nor electricity nor online deliveries ever failed even in hard hit Wuhan.
- cesarb 7y agoAFAIK, normal hand sanitizer is 70% alcohol (concentrations much higher or lower than that are not as effective), plus a few extra ingredients to avoid drying the skin of the hands. Washing the hands with soap is better (there are some microorganisms which are not killed by the alcohol), but needs water for rinsing, so there are many situations where alcohol-based hand sanitizer is more convenient.
- marsrover 7y agoThe little guy that scalps hand sanitizer on eBay needs to be investigated while the corporation that scalps cancer drugs is praised.
- salawat 7y agoThe little guy scalping on amazon doesn't have a cabal of lawyers to keep the prosecutor at bay. Frankly, I'd prefer hitting pharma companies hard as well, but you have to make sure the case is bulletproof, or an ineffectual token settlement is the likely result.
- pluc 7y ago> Colvin apologized for purchasing all of the products Sunday, saying that he did not realize the spread of the coronavirus outbreak or the shortage of sanitary products across the country. Heh. Isn't that specifically the reason he did it?
- sneak 7y agoHand sanitizer is not essential, and nobody was forced to buy from him or pay his prices. I think it’s a real shame that Amazon and eBay shut him down and halted the distribution of his stock to where it was most needed, simply on PR grounds. I don’t think he did a single thing wrong, but the mob sure does seem white-hot angry at him.
- robjan 7y agoHand sanitiser is not essential, however it's an important tool which helps reduce the chance of infection in the general population. If someone is carrying a sanitiser they will most likely use it and that benefits everyone.
- kaikai 7y agoThey say “his address was posted online” like it wasn’t displayed on his own website. Pointing that out hardly counts as doxxing.