5 ms·
The police have far too much power in this. The police should only have the power to name a suspect and then request a single GPS fix in a window of their choos
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 7y ago
The police have far too much power in this. The police should only have the power to name a suspect and then request a single GPS fix in a window of their choosing. Anything else requires more judges to sign off. This power of dragnet, "give me everyone within 200 feet of this property in the last 48 hours" is just astoundingly one-sided.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoWhy? They use it to compile a witness list, maybe suspect list, rule out many people, as a first approximation. As long as the data is archived and not open for abusive use; where do you feel any harm comes in?
- jacquesm 7y agoBecause such information should only be used to confirm as specific person was present, not to dragnet a bunch of innocents.
- jellicle 7y ago"Somebody walked by the outside of a house where a 97-year-old said something was stolen" wasn't previously sufficient grounds to search every document you had ever written or received, but now it is.
- kspacewalk2 7y agoSure it was, if they walked/biked by the house 3 times in close succession around the time of the burglary. A completely legitimate reason to make him a person of interest and interview him. If he was picked up on a neighbour's door cam, this wouldn't even be on the news.
- TuringNYC 7y agoBecause it costs each innocent victim tens of thousands of dollars to defend themselves. If they are poor, they may have no defense. Next, they are plea bargaining to a crime they didn’t commit because that is the only reasonable option left.
- kspacewalk2 7y agoIt doesn't though. Hiring a lawyer was his choice. Location tracker data alone is not enough for him to be even a suspect, just a person of interest. And it's the tracker data that shows police that his passing the house 3 times around the time of the burglary (which is a completely legitimate reason to question someone) is in keeping with his usual routine and thus exonerates him.
- TuringNYC 7y ago>> "and thus exonerates him" How does this exonerate him if he has no lawyer to go thru the procedural efforts? You are right that hiring a lawyer is a choice, in as much as going to prison is a choice.
- 99052882514569 7y ago>How does this exonerate him if he has no lawyer to go thru the procedural efforts? Because police would likely not even contact him in the first place once they see that there's nothing extraordinary about his movements.
- syshum 7y agoHave you heard the term "General Warrant", in Colonial times general warrant was issued by the Crown granting law-enforcement broad discretion or authority to search and seize unspecified places or persons. This is plainly a type of General Warrant, something that was banned under the US Constitution
- imtringued 7y agoWhen you use a geofence you have a witness list of mostly innocent people. You can't rule out anyone because that information requires a warrant. The end result? Warrants on random people and most of them are innocent. The entire system is broken and was never going to work.
- maram 7y ago>>The police have far too much power in this. Why it's not the case that Google has too much power in this, by collecting data from their users without asking their permission?
- deadmutex 7y ago> by collecting data from their users without asking their permission It is my understanding that Google Location services asks before storing this data. My fear is that by writing blanket untrue statements like this, people that don't know better just read it as fact, and spread it. Disclaimer: Work at Google (in a different space), but everything I write here is my own opinions/views.
- Terretta 7y agoYour understanding may be legally correct but is pragmatically incorrect. “Normals” in no way understand they are consenting to this, and further, your employer continues to tighten the noose on users who did understand and turned it off, that products will no longer work without this data. To be clear, Google has the right to demand location data as payment for services rendered.
- maram 7y ago>>Google has the right to demand location data as payment for services rendered. Sure, just let them be clear about it. By clear, I don't mean they mention it in the last line of the 29th page.
- srtjstjsj 7y agoTurning on Location Services requires tabbing through pages of location-specific text before the OK button is enabled.
- cheschire 7y agoThey could put it in the first line and people wouldn’t read it. Pop up fatigue is getting intense. Generally nobody reads notices anymore. They just want the content or service.
- x86_64Ubuntu 7y agoThey did go to a jduge. >...Gainesville police, looking for leads, went to an Alachua County judge with the warrant for Google.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 7y agoI know they do- that's not the point. It's that you can goto a judge without knowing WHO you are asking for information on. The judge should have to see a suspect's name, information supporting why they are a suspect, etc. Not "gimme everything on everyone in this radius and this timeframe"